1 h 41 min · 10,081 words · 3 December 2007 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 101-minute session, Ven Jampa Gendun opens with psychiatrist Scott Peck’s definition of love — “the will to extend oneself for the purpose of nourishing one’s own or another’s well-being” — to draw a clear line between genuine care and attachment. He then guides participants through an “exchanging places” meditation, asking them to imaginatively inhabit the viewpoints of a loved one, a stranger, a beggar, and an adversary, and to look back at themselves through each person’s eyes. The second half develops equanimity as the psychological ground for universal compassion, working through the friend-enemy-stranger framework and showing how the same person’s emotional appearance shifts depending on which memories we selectively recall. The session closes with a Lama Yeshe quote on equanimity as practical mental health, and a preview of the following week’s topic: recognizing all beings as one’s mother.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 32 3PA 2007 12 03.mp3
UUID: e9691505-3126-4ac7-9c69-5e1a45f3aee0
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2006-2007 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 2007-12-03
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 101.3 minutes
Words: ~10,077
Nice. How are you? It’s Tuesday. I’m sorry to disappoint you. Jet lag.
Jet lag. Are you comfortable? Did you want do you want the are you warm? Do you want the air conditioner on? K.
Let me know. Okay? What’s an a good idea. How are you? So we begin as we normally do.
Can you hear me in the back okay, Susan? Pardon? Adjusting our motivation. We have to continually continually get back in touch with what is important to ourselves, what we would like to see our life represented above, is our, you know, what makes us feel good about ourselves and this crazy, exciting thing called life, which we’re trying to find some kind of meaning within, some happiness. It seems as if we have to again and again get back in touch with what is most important to ourselves.
We have to stop speeding and stop acting, stop distracting ourselves from ourselves, and pause and look within ourselves. Mean, essentially, I think we want peace, don’t we? We want to find some kind of meaning for ourselves, some fulfillment in all the various ways that each of us uniquely conceives of that fulfillment to express itself. I think what we’re emphasizing at present is the development of love and compassion, isn’t it? Loving ourselves and having compassion for ourselves.
How are we going to care best for ourselves? How are we going to find what it is that we want and get rid of the suffering that none of us wants? You know, even though we’ve over the course of our life, you know, however many years, you know, how far have we gotten in our journey? Or how far haven’t we gotten in what we have been trying to achieve? Spite of all the blood, sweat, and tears that we’ve expended and the struggles and the planning, all the efforts that we made, are we happy?
Have we come to that place where we found we’re content? You know, we I think one of the great insights of the Mahāyāna Buddhism, the universal vehicle Buddhism, is that it sees us as two aspects to ourselves. There is the private aspect that our own inner lived experience, which is inaccessible to others, this inner world of ourselves, we are seeking to find, bring about some kind of peace, our own inner well-being. But also it sees ourselves as another aspect to ourselves, the public aspect to ourselves, that aspect of ourselves which exists in relationship to others, the social aspect or the public aspect of ourselves. So it’s trying to help us to learn that our Me First, I Am Number One, center of the universe approach to the living of our life and the finding of happiness and getting rid of our suffering struggling to do is best shortsighted.
That if we’re ever to find fulfillment, in ever to live out our highest of values, we have to make not only effort in finding some kind of peace inside of ourselves, but some meaningful way of being in this world with others. And the best way, the most skillful way, the most effective, appropriate way of being successfully in this world with others, we call love. And this is not meant to be a sentimental or a romantic notion. It’s quite a reasonable notion. Sometimes we have the idea that reason is purely of the intellect.
But reason can be as well associated with emotions in the heart. It simply means what is most appropriate, what actually works. It’s quite reasonable. To love. I’d like to read just a sentence.
We think we need to be able to trust just as we think we need to be loved. But we have it backwards. As adults, we don’t need to be loved. The only real emotional need, if we want to call it that, is to love. To love is our essence.
It’s who we are. So, you know, we all want to be special, don’t we, in somebody’s eyes? We always we all We talked about last week how we more or less cultivate attachment, not only to others, but we ask others to cultivate our attachment to ourselves so that we feel safe and secure. We feel we need to be loved. And we go around seeking that love in the best ways that we can, never understanding.
Ourselves. And then our job is the most difficult task of all is to learn how to live love others. And I the I guess the best definition, and I’m kind of paraphrasing a definition of love that I got from Scott Peck. Scott Peck, maybe some of you are familiar with his work. He’s an American psychiatrist.
He was quite popular just not too many years ago. He actually came to Adelaide, I think, nine years ago. He wrote a book called The Road Less Traveled. That’s right. Yeah.
Yeah. And he defined love. This is a little bit of paraphrasing what he said. It’s close. So I give him credit.
The will to extend oneself for the purpose of nourishing one’s own or another’s The will to extend oneself for the purpose of nourishing one’s own or another’s well-being. The will to. So it’s a will is like some kind of decision. You know, you’re not suddenly being carried away, you know, swept away by, you know, the beauty of the moment or the passing loveliness of the of the of the moon or whatever it might be, the romantic notion of the night. It’s something that’s quite reasoned.
It seems quite appropriate. It’s come some kind of decision that’s very deeply felt. And it’s a will, a decision to work. And so, know, to will to extend oneself. To extend oneself is some kind of work, you know, is not particularly all that comfortable.
To extend one, it means you go beyond your normal limits. Like for that other person, you’re willing to walk that extra mile, you know, go to some trouble, put yourself out for that other person. I mean, this is the way love is expressed, isn’t it? We put ourselves out for ourselves, and we put ourselves out for another. Otherwise, perhaps our love isn’t demonstrable.
It really isn’t love after all. It’s just a feel good feeling. So it’s some kind of decision to put ourselves out to do some kind of work in order to bring to nourish ourselves, to bring about our own welfare, but also the welfare of others. So this is what we’re trying to develop. I think it’s a tremendously difficult challenge.
You know, as we talked about last week, we have to begin to distinguish between attachment and love. Quite often, the two are more than not mixed together. We really don’t differentiate between the two. But I think one rule of thumb is simply whose interest is at heart here? Who are we concerned with?
Is it oneself or another? If it’s oneself in terms of our relationship with other, then we’re pretty sure it’s attachment, isn’t it? You know, what’s in it for me? What can you do for me? And on the other hand, if it’s the nature of the relationship, the way in which the way of relating is unfolding is concerned with the other, then maybe it is real love.
You know, to forego our own our own immediate needs, you know, in some reasonable way and be there for the other and putting ourselves out for the other to make them happy, you know, to to help them work with their problems. So, you know, when I talk about beginning with one other, you know, I think we have to learn how to love ourselves, let alone to love others, to sincerely wish ourselves happiness and to work for our own happiness. But also, you know, trying to open our hearts as best we can, if only for one other person. You know, this is the way I think is most most realistic in this process of training our minds. That that one person that maybe you can be there for, you know, you can you know, we’re here tonight on a Monday night.
We’re involved in this training process, aren’t we? It’s very unusual. I think it’s quite rare. It’s not the norm of our society. So I think it requires some kind of special effort, but also some kind of special appreciation on our part in what we’re doing, how special it in fact is.
You know, really trying to learn how to love, as is being described here, developing, making the decision to work for the welfare of ourselves and others, to extend ourselves, to press the envelope, if only just a little bit. And that’s the motivation that we can develop in the why we’re here tonight, the purpose for our coming together, is to help us to train in that process. This is like a gym in a way. We’ve all come to exercise on the various equipment that we’ve got worked out here, to exercise exercise our ability to love, if only a little bit more, you know, for that one other person. So, you know, actually imagining someone there that you would like to be there for, that you would like to be a little more caring, little more understanding, perhaps a little more patient.
In some way, to be there for in a more significant way, to be able to extend yourself, develop and the capacity to nourish them. So I think it would seem I’m always reading this quotation that’s outside the door whenever I come into the room by the Dalai Lama, where he says, The purpose of life is happiness, and the greatest degree of happiness is in developing love and compassion for others. And so I think this is kind of the central theme of the Mahāyāna, this universal vehicle. The more that we concern ourselves in a realistic and healthy fashion with the welfare of others, the more that we will find our own inner peace, our own inner fulfillment. We will find greater and greater contentment in our own life.
So, you know, I think the normality of our society has got it quite turned around in the sense of how we’re going to fulfill our happiness. And being there for others and working for the happiness of others, we can find more happiness than we could ever hope to have found in solely trying to work for our own welfare, as we’ve done up to now. And that, I think, is the central message of the Mahāyāna, the universal vehicle, what our teachers have been trying to communicate to us all along in one fashion or another. So, you know, each of us in our own hearts, this is the work that we do when we come here together, is to try to reverse our usual habitual attitude, our self centered attitude, of our selfishness, of our usual preoccupation, our exaggerated self concern with our own welfare alone, trying to reverse that in a healthy and reasonable fashion. You know, I’m here this evening, Monday, December the third.
What I’m going to do, I want some happiness. I’m a human being. I’m a sentient being. I have a mind that’s struggling to be happy, that doesn’t want to suffer just like everybody else. And just like everybody else, I am worthy of my own love and my own compassion.
But we can go beyond that, and we can think of that one other person. You you can do that now. What I’m saying is not very important. It’s probably very confused and kind of mistaken in many ways, but that’s beside the point. Maybe there can be some worthwhile, some benefit if it can help you to stimulate the idea of this one person that’s imagined before you right now.
I’d like to be there for you in a more significant way. You know, I’m learning some methods. I’m learning some I’m trying to train my mind. And I’d like to think that this is not only for my own welfare, which is important, but is well for you, which is just important to me. You’re just as important to me as myself in this way.
What I’m going to do this evening in learning and discussing and meditating all these various activities, I’m doing it for the both of us, for myself directly at this moment, but for you indirectly. And I said that sometime, somewhere down the line, I can be there for you. What I’m doing is for both of us. I’m extending myself. I’ve made a decision to be there for you because I love you.
And this is the way I’m expressing that love both for myself myself and for you at this present moment. And as we progress, we can begin to widen the scope of who it is that we’re working for. And then we can add more and more individuals in some genuine fashion. The inner focus of our life becomes Buddha and this tremendously happy, loving, sane human being. And we have to work.
We have to do the necessary training in order to be that. Wishing it so is simply not enough. We implement the Dharma, the various teachings, the trainings, the techniques, the meditations, the teachings, essentially the truth of things, the way that things are beyond our own set of fictions that we’re continually projecting on the world. We want to know how things actually are. And this process occurs within the social context of the spiritual community and of ourselves.
We are a spiritual community. We we inspire each other. We act as models for one another. We can advise one another. We can teach one another.
We can share all the wisdom that we’ve gathered through all the various experiences of our life with one another, both formally and informally, you know, helping others in very practical, material ways, but also emotionally supporting one another. You know, helping whatever it takes to assist another on their particular journey, on their particular on their particular path to take another step, you know, whatever we can do for another. And trying to raise the level of motivation, the why behind, and the purpose for. And, again and again, trying to contradict this imploding habitual, this habit of imploding in on ourselves, of being being preoccupied and absorbed within ourselves. Again and again, trying to raise the level of our motivation such that what we’re doing is just not for my own piece of chocolate cake.
That hasn’t that hasn’t worked up to now, and it’s never going to work. But somehow, try and to see that the meaning the greatest meaning and purpose I can make in my life is a working for an ever widening circle of others in some meaningful and practically practically effective manner? And and to do that, I have to train my mind. The more I am, the more I have to give. I have to be something.
I have to be a Buddha. You know? We don’t we don’t I don’t know what a Buddha is, but it’s the best person I hope I can ever hope to become. That’s for now what I’m gonna call become a call a Buddha. That’s what I want to become, not just my own self, my own narrow needs and exaggerated self concern, but for an ever widening circle of others.
So we have to keep, you know, keep lifting up, know, aspiring, Keep opening your hearts and not shut down. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha.
Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others.
Reverently, I prostrate with my body, speech, and mind. I present clouds of every type of offering those actually arranged and imagined. I disclose all my negative actions accumulated from beginningless time and rejoice in all the virtues as superiors and ordinary beings. Remain until the end of cyclic existence and turn the wheel of Dharma for migrating beings. I dedicate all virtue, my own and that of others, to the great awakening.
Would you like to, stretch your legs? Stand up if you like. So we’ll begin as we usually do in terms of just working through the body, relaxing the body. And then doing the six part breathing exercise, simply breathing comfortably normally and extending the exhalation, emptying the lungs of all the stale air that builds up. Breathing in normally comfortably again, extending the exhalation and doing that six times individually, then meditating on mindfulness of the breath.
And then as an analytic meditation, I thought we would meditate on meditation where we exchange places with another. There is a process of working through. We begin with a feeling of sympathy. Sympathy means to feel with. One can, as it were, share someone else’s experience.
I went through a similar type of experience myself, whatever it might be, I have a sense of what they must be feeling like. So one shares or feels with that person. Sympathy develops into empathy where one can feel into. One actually has a feeling of how that person might be feeling, whatever the situation might be, whether it’s an experience or just a life situation and so forth, one can actually set aside to some degree one’s own agenda and one’s own projections, as it were, into that space of that other person and get a sense of what they must be feeling like. And then one can identify what they’re undergoing.
If we develop a multifaceted viewpoint, we begin to be able to see situations out of many people’s different viewpoints. Quite often, we’re very myopic. We have tunnel vision. We see everything from our own point of view. We can’t see how other people might be seeing the same situation or indeed ourselves.
So think this is a process of training ourselves and developing the sensitivity and ability to step outside of our own limited capacity to see the situation from one point of view and begin to have a sense of what it looks like from other people’s eyes. So we’re simply going to train first with somebody that we have a close relationship with, somebody that you like, that you love, a parent or a partner, and so forth. Begin to see as best you can, set aside your own agenda, own projections, how you might feel, as if you were that person. And looking back at your former self out of their eyes, and looking back and asking seeing, asking yourself the question from their point of view. Are you fulfilling their needs?
When you are them, do you feel loved? Do you feel valued? Do you feel respected? Do you feel understood? There’s a difference between empathy and and what they call introjection.
Introjection is when we project how we would feel if we were them, as if they must be feeling this way because that’s how I would feel in a similar situation. In empathy, we actually are able to have a sense of what they are actually feeling aside from what, how ever we might feel. So it’s not an easy ability to develop a capacity, a way of understanding another person. So we’re going to do that with a loved one, somebody that we’re close to. We can also do with a neutral person, just maybe somebody that you work with.
If you stepping put yourself in that person’s shoes. The American Indians have a saying, Don’t judge a person until you’ve walked a mile and they’re moccasins. How would it feel to be them? Looking back at yourself, do you have a sense of indifference? This person doesn’t say a word to me.
It’s as if I don’t exist for them, or they’re always being competitive, or whatever the situation might be. A neutral person, somebody that you don’t have any particular feelings for, but that maybe you come in contact with every so often. We can exchange places with maybe I mean, possibilities are endless, aren’t they? Maybe a beggar on the street. This is something you see all the time when you live in India.
But imagine you’re holding your hand out to your former self. And what do you see in your former self’s eyes? Do you see contempt, fear, compassion, indifference? And you can actually verbalize, express what it is that you’ve seen in your former self when you look at it from this person’s point of view. And then finally, looking at it from the point of view of somebody that you’re having some kind of disagreement with, maybe there’s some hard feelings, some problems, and looking at the situation, at your former self, out of their eyes.
What do you see? Trying to see their situation, does it look out from their eyes? And look at yourself out of their eyes. What do you see? Do you see hostility?
Do you see closed mindedness? Maybe open mindedness? Maybe defensiveness? Hostility? Aggression?
Anyway, it can be a useful exercise, think, give ourselves some insight and developing the ability, the capacity to maybe more and more be able to set aside our own agendas, which are usually running in one way or another when we relate to others. And developing a more of a multifaceted, a more universal perspective, being able to look at situations more readily out of how others might be seeing the same situation or seeing us, maybe gaining some insights into ourselves. Okay. So we’ll try that. So beginning with a process of relaxing the body.
Starting at the crown of the head, the scalp, the forehead. Feeling the wrinkles in your brow, smoothing out the pressure in and around your eyes diminishing. The muscles of the face softening, relaxing. Your jaws relaxed. And coming around to the muscles at the back of the neck, perhaps gently turn your head to each side a few times.
Just very gently loosening, stretching the muscles in the back of the neck, relaxing the muscles of the throat. Moving down to the upper back and shoulders perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times and lifting them and just allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides. Feeling this burden, this weight that we’ve been carrying around on our backs all day. Just moving down through your body into the ground like a burden’s been lifted from your back, from your shoulders. Moving all the way down to your hands, your hands are loose, soft.
Relaxing your lower arms And your upper arm. Your chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area and the lungs, and the central region of the back. Stomach releasing your belly to go soft. Relaxing throughout the abdominal cavity.
And the lower back muscles, the buttocks throughout the upper legs Lower legs. And feet. Bringing your awareness to your body in general and perhaps just beginning at the crown of your head and working your way through your body noticing any tightnesses, any tensions which remain in the body, any areas of discomfort. Focusing upon those areas, gently relaxing, softening, whatever tension is there to diminishing the tightness loosen. If there’s an area of discomfort, don’t resist the discomfort.
Just allow it to be accepting. Breathing into the discomfort accepting allowing it to be. The body become comfortable, at ease. A feeling of physical well-being pervading every part of your body. Just be with your body.
And then bring your mind to the breath. Easy. First we’re going to practice the six part breath exercise. So breathing in normally comfortably extending exhalation and doing this six times individually. When you’ve completed the breath exercise, then bring your mind to the breath.
Just the easy gentle in and out flow of the natural breath if it’s helpful using the techniques of counting and noting the breaths. Bring your mind back to the breath. We’re going to practice the meditation on exchanging. And you can think of someone that you love, someone that’s very close to you, that you have an intimate relationship with, that’s important to you, that this person is there in front of you. If you can’t see them clearly, it’s not so important.
The feeling is what is most important. And imagine putting yourself in their place. How would it be to be them looking at the world from their eyes, looking back at your former self? And when you look back at your former self, do you feel loved, valued, understood? And express to your former self what it is that you’re feeling, what you see.
As best you can, play a role. Put yourself identify completely as best you can with this loved one and look at the world out of their eyes. Look back at your former self. And how do you feel? How is it for you?
And we do the same but this time we will pick stranger, someone that you have no real connection with, that perhaps you see once in a while, you work with or see in a shop and so forth. Finding yourself in their place, looking at the world out of their eyes, looking back at your former self. What is it that you see? What kind of impression do you have of your former self? Express this to your former self.
And again, we’ll do the same. We can imagine a beggar, a home less person perhaps, out living on the streets, alone, having a hard time. When you approach your former self and you reach your hand out, what do you see? What’s your impression? How would it be to be this person living in that way asking for help from your former self?
And then lastly, somebody think of someone that you’re having some problems with. There’s some kind of difficulty between you. And look at the problem, the difficulty out of their eyes. How might they be experiencing the same situation from their point of view? Looking back at your former self, how do they experience you?
What do they see? Defensiveness? And you can express what you see to your former self. And then bring your mind back to the breath. And get in touch with your body, notice perhaps pressure of your buttocks on the seat on the cushion, your feet on the floor, positions of the various parts of your body.
Just get in touch with the feelings and sensations in the body. And then in an easy and relaxed manner, just slowly become aware of your So we’re working through the two meditative traditions for the cultivation of the awakened heart. The altruistic intention to become the best person you can become Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. The seven cause and effect instruction and equalizing self for others. We’re working with the foundation for the seven cause and effect instruction.
The foundation is equanimity. I think it’s a big challenge, but anyway. We must be up for it. And it developed you know, we’re trying to prepare the the psychological ground, creating the space where we can begin relate with others in terms of an unconditional positive regard. Presently, our ways of relating are inevitably conditioned to a lesser or greater degree by aversion, attachment or indifference, in terms of that we categorize everyone in terms of these three labels.
These categories, we put everyone in these boxes, and moreover, we react with attachment for those we label friends, aversion toward those we label enemies, and indifference toward those we label as strangers. Within that reactive patterns, there’s no there’s no space. There’s no possibility for the arising of of a universal caring, an unconditional positive regard. There’s not as long as our mind is continually under the influence of these reactive patterns, there’s no space to be able to cultivate and develop this unconditional positive regard. You know, where we we begin to have a caring for others regardless of whether they treat us well, whether they treat us badly, or they don’t treat us at all.
They’re worthy of simply by being sentient being, are worthy of caring. Just by that qualification alone. By their very nature, they are worthy of our love and compassion. We went through, you know, we talked about the difference between attachment and aversion, and so attachment and love, and trying to gain a sense that an appreciation for the fact that, you know, we you know, I think there’s some resistance to the notion of equanimity. You know, there’s a perhaps it’s associated with a sense of of a kind of a a unfeeling quality or mechanical, robotic quality.
We just but I think, on the contrary, it has nothing to do with a lack of feeling. I think that’s what we call detachment, where an inability to engage, an unfeeling quality. We’re simply trying to create the ground, the psychological space where these qualities of love and compassion can find root and begin to fill up that space, space, unconditioned by attachment and aversion and indifference. I don’t think it will harm our relations. Perhaps we can learn to love for the first time, and we can actually be there for that other person.
Guess to a large extent, we’ve been cultivating attachment in one way or another in our relations. And and it’s not to say that there isn’t love. For sure, there is. But it’s a great deal of our ways of relating are in terms of what’s in it for me. And therefore, we can assume that a great deal of our ways of relating are based on attachment.
So how do we actually cultivate this equanimity, this even mindedness, this unbiased quality? So this is meditative tradition. We we begin by imagining in front of ourselves. We’re gonna work with three classifications of people initially. On our right hand side, we’re going to imagine a friend, somebody we feel close to.
On the left side, an enemy, someone we feel at a distance to ourselves. And in the middle, a stranger, someone we, you know, we could care less. They don’t really matter to ourselves. We feel indifferent toward them. And so these are the three overall categorizations we’re going to work with.
I think the important point is we can make use of these categories, these labels, but we can begin to dissociate them with our habitual reactions of attachment, aversion, and difference. Just, you know, just like, you know, it’s not any of the difference between the other types of labels that we normally use, the categorizations that we use. You know, we have categorizations of Jews and Christians, blacks and whites, and so forth. But we have to understand that these labels, these mental images that we’re making use of, they come with a great deal of they’re complex of ideas, beliefs, feelings, emotions. And is a there is a may a lot of emotional energy associated with these categorizations that we’re using.
You know, it’s becoming more evident, for example, you know, when we talk about, for example, Muslims. Yeah. It’s becoming you know, there’s a lot of there’s a that there’s a lot of hostile emotion becoming associated with that label. When a person becomes stable with as a as a Muslim, then there’s automatically a feeling of maybe a feeling of suspicion, a feeling of, well, you know, I’m not so sure about this person. You know?
We have to be aware of these patterns of thought and ways of reacting to these labels. So in working with friend, enemy, and strangers, it’s not as if we’re, you know, the labels no longer these categorizations no longer exist, but they no longer have the same emotive quality in terms of aversion, in terms of attachment, in terms of indifference. We we are and we don’t have to have the intensity of the same habitual ways reacting to these categories. So I don’t think it’s not it’s not heroic or we’re not trying to make martyrs out of ourselves. Think it’s a it’s a a it’s a technique for mental health, for helping ourselves ourselves in in our relationships with others.
And, you know, as I was talking about and how we’re going to be in this world with other people, you know, we can we don’t we can begin to relate with others in terms of an unconditioned positive regard. We can have that toward everyone. I mean, that’s our goal in a way, isn’t it, rather than the uneven biased attitude which we presently relate with the people about us, which is problematic. But I don’t think I think we can have meaningful relationships with significant others and so forth. I’d I think maybe even more so than we have up to now.
You know? Listen. We’re not talking about love here either way. We’re talking about detachment, and we’re talking about aversion and so forth. So friend, enemy, and stranger.
Okay? These three categories individuals that we’re going to work with. And as we think of each of them, we’re going to arouse our natural habitual ways of emoting or relating to them. You know, first, you’re thinking of this friend over here, and you begin to remember all the good times that you shared together, all the many kindnesses that this person has shown you, all the reasons why they’re such a good friend, why it is that you feel the way that you do feel about them. You know, you you know, you try to arouse all this warmth, caring, connectedness, you know, this person takes on, you know, we’re trying to get a sense of how these individuals are appearing to us.
You know, I mentioned last week that mental event of appearance and projection are the same mental event. And the way a person appears and the way that what we’re projecting are the same event, one from the subject side and the other from the object side, but it’s the same event looked at from two different aspects. So we want to get a sense of how the individual is appearing in order to get a sense of what it is we’re projecting. So we actually we’re we’re arousing these feelings with regard first to the the friend, you know, how kind they’ve been to us, all the all that the all that they’ve done for us. And they will begin to appear they will begin to they’ll they’ll begin to appear very appealing to ourselves, very attractive.
They begin to exude kind of a warmth, a glow. You You wanna you wanna cuddle them. And that’s the kind of scent that’s the kind of appearance, a very attractive, appealing, almost like a, you know, beautiful appearance to ourselves. It seems that all all this all their goodness, all their beauty is coming from their own side. And we’re not aware of the part that our own mind is playing in that appearance, that they have an inherent lovableness, desirability about them.
That seems to be almost their nature, at least from attractiveness, this desirability. Now now okay. So you really try to arouse that. You try to get that sense of appearance with this person. You have this glowing lovability, desirability, attractiveness.
And you just wanna bring them to you. You want to bring them close, share their warmth that they seem to be exuding, and the security that they’re able to offer, and so forth. Okay, now we begin to once develop that appearance for our own mind, we begin to analyze, question: What what is the basis for this appearance? What is the basis for this feeling that this that this person is able to evoke in you? You know, what kind of reasons can you give?
Well, this person has been, you know, very kind to me in the past, or they’ve been kind to someone that I care about. They’ve been affectionate toward me. They’ve given me something, or they’ve protected me from difficulty. They cared about me. They were concerned about me.
They went out of their way for me. They’ve enhanced my life in some way, my well-being in some particular fashion, to some particular degree or other. So all these seems all these seem like very good reasons for feeling the way that you do about them. So but we have to begin to question, and this is the difficult part in in in the cultivation of equanimity, the willingness to willingness to question in this way. Are you, toward this individual, simply arbitrarily remembering?
Is your memory, at that moment, very selective? Our memories are photographic photographs of the past. We’re very selective in what we remember. And we often distort even those things we do remember. There’s not a one to one correspondence between what actually happened and what we’ve come to remember, what we recollect.
So, you know, if you were to look within, you know, your in the history of your relationship with this person, even though they, you know, their appearance so warm and glowing from their own side, you’d probably be able to find moments when they they they were very hurtful to you, when they spoke or acted in ways which brought you unhappiness. When it’s seem to really have the intention that well, they didn’t even like you. They hurt you. They they took something from you. They didn’t give you what you wanted, what you felt you needed in some way or another.
They didn’t act friendly or kindly in some way or another. So we we you know, they they let you down, in some way, they rejected you in one way or another. So as you now what we’re trying to do is as you begin to think of this person from this other perspective, from this other point of view, you know, what happened what begins to happen to that appearance? You know? They don’t they don’t quite they begin the glow kind of dims down a little bit.
They they’re not they don’t quite fit so comfortably into that category of friend, of lover, or mate, or as they as as they did previously. You know, their their their inherent loveliness is isn’t as obvious as it was. The appearance isn’t quite the same as it was before. You know, the person hasn’t changed, but their appearance hasn’t gone to change. Why?
Simply by what it is, the ways in which we’re thinking about that person. You know, through arbitrarily selecting various memories, they can appear very inviting, attractive, beautiful to ourselves. If we consciously begin to select other memories, which might which are probably there if you have a long term relation with this person, they begin the appearance appearance takes on a different aspect. They don’t they don’t quite look as attractive, as lovable, you know, at all as desirable. They don’t exude that same quality of of desirability as they did previously.
Previously. So this demonstrates how arbitrarily and readily changeable our feelings and emotions actually are. Now, what we’re trying to do is, you know, on the basis of appearances, we react emotionally. So, you know, we react with attachment on the basis of that appearance, but we can begin to understand the arbitrariness and the changeability of those appearances. We don’t quite buy into those appearances as readily and as intensely as we did.
We’re developing some perspective around appearances. We’re not as captivated by the appearance. We’re developing some perspective, some some open space between the appearance of a friend and how we’re going to relate with that that appearance in terms of our emotional reaction. And we’re we’re beginning to open some space toward making choices in how we’re going to relate. Otherwise, otherwise, it’s instinctive.
Otherwise, it’s, you know, it’s like a it’s a reflex action. There’s the appearance, and you automatically relate in a particular With a friend, it’s toward, it’s with attachment. So on, on, on, you know, it appears to us that, you know, when we look to this friend, this lover, this mate, you know, maybe it’s a parent, maybe it’s a partner, it appears as if we’ve discovered a mate, a soul mate, you know, as if we discovered a friend rather than that we’ve created or invented that appearance. But the latter is, in fact, the case. You know, people have to say, I want to discover my soulmate, as if there was somebody out there who, by their very nature, was the one that you’ve always been waiting for.
What we’re saying here, that it’s a matter of of creation and invention rather than discovering. I don’t know. Maybe that maybe that’s maybe I’ve disillusioned some people. Maybe people don’t want to hear that in a way, do they? You know, many people are looking for their soulmates, aren’t they?
I hope they find them. So, you know, labeling this person as a friend, we’re constantly trying to label to them in terms of abstraction or abstract and fixed concepts about what it is a friend is for ourselves. You know, all these, you know, this this with this complex, you know, this this this label friend, this complex of emotions and feelings and memories, all that we all the all these beliefs, ideas, opinions, which are associated with friend, we’re we’re we’re projecting upon this this poor individual here, you know, all the emotional baggage which goes with that. Now here, you know, friends exist. We can make use of these social conventions, the part of our language, the social conventions.
And they have meaning for ourselves, and we can make use of these labels. But the map is not the territory. The label friend, the category friend, is not not this flesh and blood real human being with all their unique qualities, their aspirations, their hang ups, everything which makes them who and what they are. A mental image is like a smear. It’s a generalization.
It’s a stereotyping to some degree or other. So we’re not relating with a real flesh and blood living human being and all that that entails, but our idea about what a friend is. And in dependence upon giving that label, then there’s an emotional reaction associated with that. So I think, you know, we can we can we can make use of the labels. We can make use of these categories.
You know, they’re just as useful as Christian, Jew, black and white, and so forth. But but there’s nothing which is not an individual. And so we, you know, the labels have a use, but we never have to we should never forget that they are just that. Categorizations. They are not individuals.
And moreover, if we can begin to, using this technique, you know, we we we with, like, we just went through with this friend, we can be the the appearance of that friend does not necessitate the the the emotional reaction which is normally associated with it. Okay, now, for example, we can we can we can relate with the with the enemy. You know, we go we go through the same process with the enemy over here, you know, this bastard over here. And then remember all the all the hard times that this person’s given you, you know, how they been unkind. They didn’t you know, the what they took from you, what the the problems that they’ve caused you in all the various ways.
You know you know, the out of this, develop, you know, a sense of of coldness, of distance from this person. You know, that that that we there develops a sense of resentment, of hostility. We would like to see them unhappy. That’s what we mean. We think we will.
We wouldn’t. We like to see things not so go so well for them. You know, few few problems here and there, at least that. Maybe maybe not go blind or something heavy duty. You know?
That’s but things not quite go so well. That would be nice in a way. You know? So it seems as if all all the things that we like that we that we don’t like about this person, you know, that that they it’s coming from their own side, that they have that they begin to exude a sense of unattractiveness, a repulsiveness. You know?
It’s kinda oozing out of their skin. You know? They’re you know, get away from me. You know? Feel contaminated or something, just by being around them in some way.
They’re kind of repulsive. That’s what they appear. But now, okay, working with that, try and get a sense of that appearance. And I don’t mean a visual appearance. I mean, the all of this complex of emotions and feelings and opinions and how how the how they’re coming this their objective part of your subjective experience and how you react into them, this this object.
And then you you actually and then you begin to think, well, okay. What’s the basis for that appearance? And then, okay. They’ve hurt me in the past. They caused me problems in the past.
They didn’t give me what I wanted in the past, or they hurt somebody who was very close to me in some way. They, you know, they caused me problems. They troubles in some way or another. But if we if we honestly searched, could could you find could you find that sometime when this same person might have, you know, been kind to you or helped you or given you what you wanted in some way or not? Or, you know, even if, you know, maybe the short term relationship, you don’t have that kind of history to work with.
Can you imagine? And look at this person. Just a simple gesture. They say something kind or they do something. They give you something.
Or they maybe they just smile. Maybe that’s enough. And what happens to that appearance? And how does that appearance change for you? You maybe they don’t quite fit into that that categorization of enemy that you had placed them, that box that you had put them in previously, they don’t they’re not quite as dark.
They don’t quite they’re not quite as repulsive. That’s that, you know, They’ve kind of lightened up in a way, and you don’t quite feel the distancing, the repulsiveness that you felt for them previously. And then you do the same with this person in in the middle, this this stranger. You know, why is it that we’ve why why do I feel the I feel toward you, to this person? You know, you know, allowing all the the the the feelings feelings associated with this person arise, you know, feelings of indifference.
It’s as if you dropped off the face of the person, it wouldn’t matter to me. I wouldn’t even notice, you know. I care. You don’t help me. You don’t hurt me.
You know, we don’t have any history. We don’t have any relation between us. You don’t matter, you know, in having that kind of neutral and different feeling. They they appear they appear neither attractive nor unattractive. They don’t they don’t they don’t appear helpful or harmful.
You know? It’s kinda blah. Kinda boring in a way. You know? So we have to analyze our response to that.
You know? What is the basis for that kind of feeling, that appearance, that the way most people do appear to ourselves? It’s because they don’t affect us. We don’t have any history. They don’t help me.
They don’t harm me. They haven’t been kind to me. They haven’t been un kind to me. They don’t make a difference to my life either way, for better or worse. So on the base of that, I call my stranger and put him in that box.
And by by stranger, I mean, it’s just a category. You know, maybe we don’t use that symbol, that language, but it is a box, nonetheless, that we have. Terms of we and we relate with them in terms of that box that we put them in. Now imagine. Okay.
So getting a sense, a feeling for what for how you’re feeling toward the vast majority of people on this planet. You know? That’s the way they appear to you. What would happen if this individual, this particular stranger, if they if they gave you something, if they acted kindly to you, if they smile and gesture, you know, whatever or they help somebody that you close to in some way. And how do they how does that change their appearance?
Well, they aren’t quite they don’t quite appear appear the same. They’re not I can’t quite put them in that same box of stranger, you know, unrelatedness. They’d no. I no. So there’s something something’s something’s changed around them and how I feel that and they they there’s certain like I didn’t notice it before, but there is something about there’s a likableness about them.
I didn’t I I overlooked it before. I didn’t recognize it before. So what we begin to see is that the potential for a meaningful relationship is always there. But, you know, but as long as they were as a stranger, it went unrecognized. So we we we begin we proceed in this kind of meditating by substituting, you know, friends, you know, other friends, other enemies, other strangers.
You know, friends should be we just begin to what we call friends. Friends are are you know, we divide we divide people into three categories, more or less. On my side, on the other side, and somewhere in between. So friends, we’re calling those are on my side. Somewhere or another, they’re on my side.
And maybe they’re maybe there is maybe they’re on my side in terms of being, like, we call actual friends, but they also might be on my side in terms of, well, they’re the same nationality or they’re the same race as myself or this that we have that we we bark for the same football team. We’re all on the same side. We’re all buddies in some way. Some lesser or greater closeness or other. These are all on my side, same side.
So it begins to substitute all of these various types of people, groups, and races, or whatever, nationalities, all those who are on my side. And the same holds true with regard to those who are on the other side, you know, those who aren’t my same race or those who aren’t my same nationality or those who are barracking for the other side, the other football team, which I can’t stand. You know, I’m a crow, and you’re a port. Is it port? You know?
That’s the other side. You know? You know, when I say enemy, it doesn’t have to be heavy duty enemy. It’s just somebody who’s on the other side. You know?
Somebody who’s not on your side. On the other side. And then then we we begin to use, you know, all this whole great category, the vast majority of people on this on the planet who are strangers. They’re not, you know, they don’t seem to they’re not in position of either being on your side or the other side. They just so they don’t they don’t count.
They don’t they don’t matter. And substituting all and seeing how if they were seeing how they change, how how their appearance changes you just by simply, you know, maybe we would be the port. The port supporters said, well, Crows are actually a pretty good team. You know, how would your attitude toward a port port supporter change in terms of if they were to barrack for the crows or something like that? They wouldn’t quite feel you know?
So you wouldn’t quite think, well, they’re so stupid. Why are they barracking for the for the Port or something like that? You know, that’s that’s insane. So when we begin to to train in this way, beginning to train in equanimity, is that the categories of friend, enemy, stranger are not fixed and unchanging. So we’re developing kind of a more fluid open way of relating to these various categorizations that we’re making use of.
It’s like you have a vegetable stew, you know, like, it’s boiling, you know. And sometimes there’s a carrot comes to the top and you see a carrot, and sometimes a potato comes to the top, and sometimes a bean comes to the top. So, you know, these categorizations are constantly undergoing change like this. You know, we have to ask ourselves, who who are we to have who who are we to draw close to ourselves, and who who are we to slap on the you know, who are we have aversion for, distance ourselves from? You know, somebody who slapped your face yesterday and gave you a present today or somebody who gave you a present yesterday and slapped your face today.
Then who would you be naturally closer to? Who would you feel more attracted to? And who would you push away? Who would you feel more distanced toward? And then there’s this other guy, you know, out here who gave you a present three days ago, but you don’t remember him.
You know? You feel you know, he doesn’t matter. He’s in you have feel indifference to them. So we’re we’re trying to loosen our tightness in which we hold these categories. That when that this friend friend isn’t, you know we’re not you know, when I talked about not about attachment, attachment means to fixate.
You know, it means to to grasp onto as if it this is always going to be the case, as if this friend is always going to be the friend. This enemy is always going to be this enemy, and this stranger is always going to be this stranger, and we fix it we fixate on that. So here, I think we’re developing the ability these categories can be made use of, but we’re not fixating on them. And we understand that they’re arbitrary and changeable. And moreover, we don’t we’re beginning to divorce them from our habitual ways of emotionally reacting to these categorizations.
They don’t have the same emotional baggage that that’s overtones, which are which are normally associated with them in terms of these categorizations. You know, know, you know, like, some people hate Jews. Once they you know, they could they could be your best friend, but you say, oh, I’m Jewish. Once they once that label’s applied to you, then you automatically, their whole attitude towards you has changed. You haven’t changed at all.
Same person they once knew. But now they’ve put you in a different box. And the way and they automatically relate with you in terms of not of it and not as you were, that individual, but in terms of their categorization of you, their classification of you, and all the emotions associated with that. And to to some or lesser or greater degree, that’s the way that we normally relate with almost everyone in terms of our classifications. So we’re trying to develop the ability not to hold so tight to these classifications, and moreover, trying to divorce them from the emotional overtones and associations, the reactive patterns which are usually connected with these classifications, so that we can begin to fill that that space that that that we’re creating, which is unconditioned by habitual aversion, attachment to loved ones, aversion to enemies and indifference to strangers, to begin to fill that with unconditioned, which is unconditioned by those qualities, with a positive regard.
We’re creating the mental space where we can begin to to develop we can begin to relate with all three categories in terms of love, in terms of compassion. Otherwise, it makes no sense when when Christ said, love your enemies. It makes no sense, does it? I mean, it sounds like it almost sounds like it’s a you know, it’s paradoxical in a way. This is what you know, this even minded attitude.
So that’s that that is the that is the that’s like the foundation. Like, the like, we’re we’re we’re creating we have this field. This quite often the image that’s made use of, and we’re preparing this field. You know, we’re moving all the rocks and the the and the logs, buried logs underneath the ground and so forth. And even mind it so that we can begin to plant the seeds of of love and compassion so they can thrive.
They have some space to grow. Lama Yeshe, you know, one of my heroes, I’d like to read a quote by him. Meditating on equilibrium is the best way of producing good mental health. Instead of paying a hundred dollars an hour an hour to a therapist, meditate on equilibrium. Close your eyes and ignore all physical sensations.
Abandon the five sense perceptions and allow yourself to sink deeply into an intensive awareness of your mind’s experience of equilibrium. You will definitely become more balanced, open, and peaceful. After ten minutes of this type of meditation, you will come out into a different world. The more we train ourselves to see the basic equality of everyone, having overcome our habitual tendencies to stick them rigidly into categories of friend, enemy, stranger, the more our heart will open, increasing the increasing immeasurably our capacity for love. By freeing ourselves from prejudicial views, we will be able to appreciate fully that everyone without exception wants and deserves to be happy and wishes to avoid even the slightest suffering.
Therefore, from the basis of equilibrium, we will be able to cultivate universal love and compassion, and eventually the full realization of bodhicitta, the open heart dedicated totally to the ultimate benefit of all beings. So maybe we can go a bit that’s the that’s the foundation. On foundation, now we’re going to we’re going to work through a sequence of six causes. We’re going to recognize all sentient beings as her mother. Another challenge.
This is not an easy practice. Remembering their kindness, developing a wish to repay their kindness, appealing love, great compassion, developing an exceptional resolve, and it just I’ve gotta do something. And then finally, this leads to the seventh, which is the result. I have to become a Buddha. I have to become, you know, the best possible person I can become for the sake for their sake.
Maybe we’ll may so next week, we’ll begin the actual sequence of beginning with recognition of mothers. Mothers. Okay? If you’d like to get a cup of tea, and we’ll have a discussion around this. Sometimes we we go to about nine thirty, sometimes a little bit late, sometimes.
Alright. Yeah. It’s about half hour. Okay. So you stay or leave whenever you have?
Yeah. I’m just conscious of going to my brother’s, and he goes to bed really early. I don’t know how to do that.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.