Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2006-2007 — 2006-10-16

2 h 5 min · 12,649 words · 16 October 2006 · Buddha House Adelaide

Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2006-2007 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2006-2007 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2006-2007 — 2006-10-16
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 125-minute session, Ven Jampa Gendun opens with a vivid desert allegory — a thirsty traveller climbing a sand dune toward the sound of running water — to trace the four progressive stages of Buddhist faith: believing, longing, clear, and irreversible. He stresses that faith must be grounded in reasoning and direct experience, citing the Pāli phrase ehi passiko (“come and see for yourself”). A guided forgiveness meditation follows, moving through self-forgiveness, asking pardon of others, and releasing resentment toward those who have caused harm. The commentary then returns to the Three Principal Aspects text, unpacking the three-pots and three-recognitions metaphors for productive listening, and introducing the four reliances: teaching over personality, meaning over words, definitive over provisional, and direct wisdom over intellectual understanding.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 09 3PA 2006 10 16.mp3

UUID: 3dfac281-63f0-4ae7-b0b2-087c2d7a1ad0

Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun

Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2006-2007 (Ven Jampa Gendun)

Date: 2006-10-16

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 125.4 minutes

Words: ~12,652

Welcome back. Welcome back. Are you warm? Can you hear me? Can you are you warm?

Projector fan on. Okay. I have a rare one going. I think it’ll cool down, but I just kind of ran over here. No, I’m fine.

Okay. Okay. We’ve been talking about the two causes for going for refuge. Overcoming psychological inertia or being stuck out of a sense of anxiety or fear, constructive anxiety, constructive fear. And on the other hand, overcoming our fears around change, about getting unstuck and developing faith and the importance of faith.

And we talked about what are the objects of our faith in terms of the Buddha, Dharma, and the Sangha. And there’s an allegory which describes the we talked about also about the various types of faith. For example, blind faith, misguided faith. But as was mentioned, these faiths are at best are short lived.

They don’t last very long. They don’t exert a very strong influence, so long term over the course of our lives, and therefore the quality of our lives. But other types of faith, the types of faith which are which are valued in in the Buddhist context in terms of our practice, our faiths which are based upon reasoning and a valid inference, valid credible evidence, and also in terms of our direct experience. Ultimately, everything is to come down to our direct experience, but perhaps many of the things, many of these ideals at present aren’t accessible to us directly, so we have to work by way of reasoning and logic. But we can form a very solid and firm, stable, and powerful type of faith based upon these ways of these as a foundation of our faith.

And there’s an allegory which which describes the the the rising and the subsequent development of these various types of faith which are emphasized in Buddhism. And, you know, each of these faiths are are different from one from another, but they all arise. You know, there’s a very there’s a famous fairly famous saying within Buddhism about how we are to just like a a goldsmith would assay their gold, they would examine the gold by cutting, rubbing, and melting the gold to ensure its quality, to ensure its its purity and so forth. Likewise, we all of these various faiths, they arise in the course of checking up, in in the course of a critical analysis, in the course of looking how these compare to our actual experience in our everyday life. You know, the the Buddha himself said, and I think many of the masters, Buddhist Masters down through the ages, a Pāli expression.

Pāli was, you know, the Buddha taught in the language of Magadha. And but quite often the teachings when they were actually written down, was, it wasn’t till perhaps five hundred years after the passing of the Buddha, they were written down as Sanskrit. But the, but the, the philosophical language of the time was Sanskrit. So they developed hybrid language which combined many of the terms from Sanskrit with the colloquial language of Madhya, and this became Pāli. And there’s an expression in Pāli which is ehi passiko, which means come and see for yourself.

You know? Come and see for yourself what what what I have said, whether it’s true or not. Then if if you check it out for yourself, then you don’t need you don’t have to rely upon other people’s word on it. You don’t have to rely upon some kind of dogma. You don’t and the Buddha especially emphasized not to accept my words simply out of devotion to myself, but come and see for yourself if you actually check up.

And this is the this is how we are to base our practice in in terms of, you know, kind of carry on an intelligent practice. We can’t really, you know, I think kind of mention, I probably over I don’t know if I overly emphasize emphasize that most basically the bottom line about Buddhism is about is about changing our minds. And to change our minds is a very subtle process. It can’t be simply a matter of gathering together more information, you know, or more PhDs or or can’t be done mechanically. It has to we have to find we have to think for ourselves.

It puts a heavy responsibility on each of us to bring about this change. And it tries to give us the the skills, tries to present the actual nature of our situation as clearly and as effective as possible, but the burden very much is bringing about the change whether it occurs or not. It’s not whether you are a member of Buddha House, or whether you come to the teachings regularly, or whether you keep your dues paid up, or whether you it’s actually thinking for oneself, you know, going through this process that we talked about last week, listening, reflecting, and meditating, and make and into through finding a key for yourself to make to make them workable for you. You know, the the Buddha was a great pointer in some of the paintings. He’s he’s when they have a wheel of life, he’s pointing.

And he would say, look at this. Look at this. So he made general very general statements, and we have to take those general statements and see how they specifically apply for ourselves. You know, we are in a way, we have to discover everything that Buddha discovered here for him or herself. But luckily, we don’t have to reinvent the wheel.

We’ve got the Buddha’s wheel, his Dharma, as a guide guides as a a guidepost and some useful guidelines that we can make use of. But still, we have to do a lot of thinking for ourselves. There’s no avoiding it, using our minds as best we can. So, you know, once we begin once we validate the teachings for ourselves, then then our our faith is based within our own actual experience. Ultimately, our faith comes down to depends on just this, our own direct coming to see for ourselves.

You know, the the faith is based upon our own inner truth, our own inner wisdom. You know? In a way, it’s like faith is is a way to greater wisdom than we already have. And and that wisdom in turn is is a way to more effective compassion, which is really at the heart of what Buddhism is. So this allegory begins with ourselves.

We’re out on a desert. We’re there without water, and we’re in pain. But we don’t quite know what we we don’t quite know what is the source of our pain, what is the nature of our pain. You know, we aren’t able to identify exactly the cause of our pain nor what what would be the remedy if if one were to abuse at all, not knowing what why we are suffering in the first place. So there’s just this an experience of of pain and some kind of underlying underlying anxiety that may be this pain is part of is intrinsic to the nature of life itself.

There’s a sense that maybe no matter what we might do, it’s always going to be there one way or another. So but from time to time in the course of our even on the barren landscape of our life, we meet with rare and extraordinary individuals, remarkable individuals who have seemed to have solved many of the problems that we ourselves are presently wrestling with. You know, people who seem to be at peace with themselves and who who are who are at ease in the world. They they they have a sense of, you know, the qualities that we sometimes think of our teachers, for example. They have a sense of humility about them, a sense of of simplicity, of cheerfulness, of kindliness.

You know, they people who whose behavior, even their their very presence, it it seems to speak about some kind of, you know, the way they look, the way they speak, the way they the way they do things. It all it kind of makes gives us a sense that they have some kind of remarkable attainment. So through the impact of meeting with these rare individuals, we radically new idea is sown in our mind. Maybe our confusion, our struggle, you know, all that life has been up to the present time, maybe all that is not intrinsic to life itself. Maybe there are other possibilities open to ourselves.

And so maybe, you know, maybe maybe life isn’t a bitch after all. Maybe maybe maybe there is something other than what I’ve experienced. So there’s kind of a a fundamentally different way of being in the world as exemplified, as modeled by our teachers. So a believing faith arises. It’s a faith, you know, a way of that there is a we have some we still begin to have a sense of confidence that there is another way of experiencing life with which is infinitely superior to our own.

And we we develop determination out of this. It dawns within us. That’s what you know, we begin to think that’s what that’s the way I would like to be. That’s what I would want for myself. Some kind of directionality, some kind of purposefulness begins to be introduced into our life through the impact of meeting such individuals.

So we’re empowered by this this this with the strength and this believing faith. So we, you know, we’re we’re we’re out in the desert, and there’s a huge sand dune. So we begin to we’re not we’re not quite sure where we’re going. We’re not quite sure what the what the form of ours these solutions to some of our problems might take or what to say to find them. But we have a sense that maybe in fact they exist because we’ve seen other people model them for us.

So we take up the the the we begin the journey. We begin to to climb this sand dune which is in front of us, you know, struggling up its side. And from the distance we hear, we can’t see the water, but we hear the sounds of some trickling water, some running water. You know? And we can’t we we it sounds like what it is that we’ve been looking for.

So we move a little bit closer. And what we hear begins to describe our experience, you know, the quality what the what we’ve been going through in our life, our various disappointments, our frustrations, our anxieties. At least what is being said seems as if it were being directed especially to us. It it seems how it seems to describe our life exactly as we have been experiencing it. So we we we and what it means to be an ordinary human being.

All our conflicts, all our disappointments, anxieties, and it and it talks about what are the causes of these conflicts, these anxieties. Is it and it begins to talk about some kind of solutions, some methods that we can work with. So what is said sounds right to us. It speaks to our reasoning mind and our feeling hearts. So we it also accords with our own experience.

So some now some kind of longing faith arises within us. There’s there’s a yearning. You know, we we come to understand for ourselves just what it is that we’ve been searching for. What is the nature of our pain? So there there there there that’s what what is being said begins to be something that I want to achieve for myself.

That’s what I want to do. That’s the way I want to be. You know? That’s what I will have it. So some kind of determined an inspired longing to drink from this this river, which is on the other side of the sand dune, begins to rise in us.

So in power with the strength of our longing faith, we make the this arduous trek up the side of the sand dune. Let us say we put into practice these various teachings what what we’ve been hearing. And we come down the other side and we drink of some of we drink of the some of the water, some of we drink of some of the solutions to some of our problems. Our life begins to cheer up a little bit. Our life isn’t quite as problematic as it was was as it once was.

And a clear faith arises in us. It it it we come to experience what it is that we’ve been wanting for in our life. It’s just not an idea. It’s that we begin to experience some of the solutions and some of the outcomes that we want for ourselves. So there’s actual quenching of our thirst to some degree or other.

So we we validated within our own experience the truth of what was said. So we actually have found some of the solutions to some of the problems that we’ve been trying to solve all along. So empowered with the strength of our clear faith, we continue to drink from the water. That is we continue to practice the teachings. And we again and again put the teachings in the practice, and as a result, we experience it still further and further cessation cessation of our pain until an irreversible faith arises.

You know, when when it would be very difficult for somebody to say, that table is not red, because that’s my that’s my direct experience. That’s what I have come to know directly. You it would be definitely it would be extremely difficult to to undermine that that confidence that I have, that conviction that this table is red because it’s it’s it’s part of my actual experience. So, likewise, in terms of having having actually experienced some of the solutions by means of some of these teachings, having solved some of our problems, by means of our practice, then there arises an irreversible faith. You know, there’s no other life, kind of life, which is open to us.

It’s quite we naturally follow this way of life because it is the most workable solutions to what we’ve been experiencing in terms of our problems all along. It actually is working through some kind of payout. We’re experiencing directly the outcome of the teachings themselves. We’ve integrated the teachings and therefore have realized some of the solutions. You know, we we are at one with ourselves.

We are we have a one. We have come home. We have found our place in the world. So each of these faith is rising and giving and giving rise to the other continually throughout the course of our practice. You know, the the believing faith, longing faith, clear faith, and finally, irreversible faith.

And they’re continually arising one and one depends upon the other. So the point is in talking about these various types of faith is that faith is simply not just a religious artifact or something for simply for devotional people or simple minded people. Faith is an indispensable agent for change. And even if in a very mundane sense, we have to have faith in the in the process and the outcomes of what it is the change that we want to bring about. So our faith is in our faith what determines the directions and goals of our life.

And therefore, who we who we become and who we don’t become, what we experience and what we don’t experience in the course of our life. You know, through faith, we will aspire. Through through our aspiration, we will make effort. And by means of our effort, we will achieve our goals. So faith is the forerunner.

It is the foundation of all of the all of the subsequent achievements. So it’s something very necessary. You know, if we had enough faith, you know, like they say in the Christian bible, if you had but the faith the size of a mustard seed, maybe we can say to this mountain of afflictions in our minds and and the the all the various sufferings in our lives be gone, and all our problems would be over because we would put into practice wholeheartedly and with the totality of our resources, and therefore we would realize the result. You know, there there does arise faith for all of us from time to time, you know, moments of spontaneous faith in in someone or something or other. But and these faiths are are tremendously important.

But most of these faiths don’t endure. They don’t last. And therefore, terms of the overall quality of our lives, they have a very short term effect at best. The point is if we we genuinely want to make some kind of change in ourselves, our thinking, and our behaving, and therefore, in the quality of our life because the quality of our life is dependent upon our ways of thinking and behaving. Then it’s necessary that we consciously cultivate a deep and abiding faith in the means and the outcomes of the changes that we want to make.

In in the arising of faith, it’s not sufficient that that we simply wait for for grace or for chance or adventitious causes to to suddenly sweep over us. We can’t simply wait for faith to arise in ourselves. We have to be proactive. It’s necessary that that we actively participate in the process. You know, we need to seek out teachers and teachings.

This this requires that we listen and study carefully with open minds, we we need to reflect upon what we what we hear, critically examine the significance of what we study or read. And we and by means of our reasoning, by means of our intuition, by means of our our own life’s experience, examine all of these teachings. So we have to actually do something for ourselves. We have to we have to experiment with the teachings. We have to immerse ourselves in them and come come to terms with the significance.

What are they trying to convey to us? What is the message of all of these various teachings? You know, how can I adapt them to my own particular needs, my own particular style, my own particular temperament? We have to actively entrust ourselves to these new understandings that we’re gaining and make, you know, to be mindful of them in all seemingly insignificant daily events of our ordinary lives. See how they’re fitting in and remember to to apply them when we can, only in a small way.

We we need to allow them to act upon us, to to bring about some kind of transformation. We have to actually participate consciously in the process. So in other words, if we truly want to change, then we have to systematically cultivate faith in something other than what we have presently have faith in. Because what we have faith in, our particular our particular present refuge isn’t working as it should be for ourselves. In a condition of struggle and of failure, failure, we must be able to say, I must try harder or I must try differently.

Both views are essential. Neither of them must take precedence by principle. They are analogous to a view of a man as free and a view of a man as determined. The two do not contend but reflect the interaction between man and his environment. A change in either makes for a change in outcome.

When we say, I must try harder, we mean that the most relevant variable is something within us: intention, will, meaning it. And that if this changes, the outcome, even if everything else remains unchanged, will be different. When we say I must try differently, we mean that the most relevant variables lie in the situation in which intention is being exerted, and that we should look to the environment, to the way it pushes and pulls us, And in this study, find means to alter the interaction. We try to stop smoking, try and fail, try again and fail again. And when we pause to reflect, we ask how we should understand the recurrent failure.

We must be guarded from both views. If we believe we cannot try harder, then we must examine the field in which the effort is being made, look for ways to diminish the obstacles against which it is pitted. If we conclude there is nothing to be altered in the field, we must go back to the possibility of augmented tension. We cannot know the outcome in advance. If we give up, we can never know, but but that for further trying, either harder or differently, might have succeeded.

So, okay, the the outcome to all of this is in terms of our present discussion, what what we’ve been talking about, is that perhaps our problem in not getting what it is that we want in our life is not so matter so much a matter of trying harder, let us say, more of the same, but of trying differently. Maybe perhaps we have to go to a different refuge in our life. So in terms of possible alternative refuge that we can begin to explore is that of the Buddha Dharma and Sangha. You know? The Buddha has the embodiment of wisdom, love and compassion, personal power, and their skillful and fearless expression in our daily lives.

The resources of the Dharma, the the techniques, the trainings, the teachings, but ultimately the truth of things, the way things are in their actual nature. Now we go refuge to the and the the spiritual community, those who assist us, those who help us to implement the Dharma in our daily life. And we try to raise motivation, you know, the why we do what we do. Again and again, trying to go beyond our narrow self concerns, our limited self needs, and trying to if only for one other person, what I’m going to do, I’m going to do so that I can be a little more patient, a little kinder, a little more understanding, a little wiser, a little more discriminating, whatever. It’s free even if one for one other person, and that becomes a refuge.

That becomes a real means, a practical means, a realistic means to solve our problems. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha through my practice of generosity and the other perfections. May I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings.

I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow.

May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward other. Would you like to stand up for a minute? Stretch your legs, and we’ll meditate together. So there’s important area in terms of, you know, our our well-being in a very mundane way, but also in terms of our spiritual progress. And that’s the practice of forgiveness.

I think this is Lama Zopa emphasized this when he in a retreat he gave in France on the on the teachings of the Kadampa, the Geshe’s. He said that the practice of forgiveness was integral to part of our practice. He also mentioned rejoicing and loving kindness. We’ve been working with those two and I thought we’d work with a practice of forgiveness, also meditate on forgiveness. You know, I guess, put some kind of we have to put forgiveness in some kind of context.

It doesn’t mean that when we say that we forgive, it doesn’t mean that we forgive. It’s, you know, that everything’s okay. It’s business as usual. I forgive you. It’s not some kind of misguided effort to to suppress ignore our pain or what actually what actually happened.

It forgiveness tries to understand what happened. And I think Thich Nhat Hanh, in talking about love, he says, if we really understand another person we we love, we will love the other person. That love that love is another name for understanding. Understanding is another name for love. So, you know, we we we try to understand how the situation evolved.

If someone has then has treated us unfairly, has hurt us in some way. We rather than simply seeing them as a problem, we try to see the problem as the problem. The person is not the problem. The problem is hostility, the aggression, the the confusion, the ignorance, attachment within the person’s mind, and this includes ourselves. So, you know, we we we we even though we forgive or we try to forgive, we still have to make perhaps make set things right in a very practical way.

Though though we we might understand and forgive, still we might say it’s better that the two of us not relate in the same ways that we did in the past, that we we no longer have the same connection that we have in the past. So, you know, forgiving is letting go of the hostility, the the resentment that we feel, the grudge, the thought to retaliate. We may feel hurt. We may feel betrayed. We may feel resentment, but we let go of the desire to retaliate.

We don’t put the person out of our heart. In other words, we as we forgive you know, forgiveness means that we give up the hope of a better past. The past, we we and move on. We can’t undo the past. All we can do is transform our attitudes toward what happened in the past.

Forgiveness is the price that you pay for freedom. If you want to free be free, you have to free yourself of hostility, of grudge, of a sense of wanting to get back, of anger. That’s the price we pay if you ever want to be free. We can’t let go of the past, You know, we can’t change the past. But if we’re ever to be free, we have to move on in terms of our attitude toward the past.

So, you know, forgiveness has many different, you know, like, facets, many different components, you know, parts, like, you know, the the the disappointments and feeling of being misunderstood or treated unfairly or being used. So we have to we have we have to might have to figure from many different points of view. Perhaps, in some ways, we aren’t capable of forgiving at present. But there is some level we can there is some at some level, we can begin to forgive. There’s some facet of the of our attitude that we can begin to work with.

You know, that we can begin you know, there’s there’s this hostility. There’s this this wrongness or this unfairness that was done to you, and it’s it’s it’s it feels like a solid mass of of wrong. But if we can to do if we can begin to break it down and begin to work with it, we can see that there is it has made up a complex of different issues. Some involve ourselves. Some don’t have don’t have anything to do with the other person.

So we can begin to work with some parts of the sense of grudge and this hostility, this this resentment, this wanting to retaliate, resentment, this wanting to retaliate, to hurt back. You know, they said I think it was Henry Wadsworth said that if we could know the biography of our enemy, it would be enough to just disarm all our hostility. Simply understanding that this other person is just as confused as ourselves. And just as we make mistakes, other people make mistakes, and perhaps this person made a mistake. We don’t always act when in terms of our our intelligence.

We don’t always act in terms of ways that we would most prefer to act. We know that for ourselves. And why if we can do that for ourselves, if we can understand that for ourselves, we can apply that to others as well. So, indeed, we have to forgive ourselves as well as well, you know, for the mistakes that we’ve made, for for for not standing up for ourselves, for for acting in ways which we hurt others and either intentionally or unintentionally. You know, for situations that we handled poorly, for example, or letting ourselves down.

So we’re going to work with this with forgiveness. First, we’re going to, you know, call it we have we’re going to work with with specific instances, you know, not just a general diffuse I forgive, but particular actual events that have happened to us in the past. And we begin begin by thinking of an instance where we hurt others, and we’re going to we’re going to forgive ourselves first. You know, we we we they’re thinking about that there are many ways that I’ve hurt and harmed others, that I’ve that I’ve hurt and harmed myself, that I’ve betrayed myself, that I’ve abandoned myself, that I I’ve let myself down in thought and deed unknowingly or unknowingly. And for all the ways that I’ve hurt myself, you know, through the bad choices that that I’ve made by acting out of confusion, by acting out of anger, you know, all your various afflictions.

For acting out of fear or acting out of pain, I forgive myself. Now we can simply very in a very in a trying to we can simply begin with the words, I forgive myself, and simply quietly repeating the phrase, I forgive myself, and trying to develop the feeling of actually letting go of the hostility that is being directed towards yourself with regard to what this specific event. Then we we can also we forgive we ask others for their forgiveness. Again, remember specific specific instances where we’ve hurt others. There are many ways that I’ve hurt and harmed others, that I have betrayed or abandoned them, that I have I have caused them suffering knowingly or unknowingly, That out of my pain, out of my confusion, out of my anger, I hurt, and I ask for your forgiveness.

I ask for you know, the piece of the people there, we ask, we shouldn’t begin with the most difficult. Some something that we can work with. You know, I mean, like, for example, you know, if if someone killed your parents when you were five years old in front of you and you sworn revenge, that someday you were going to you were gonna get back. Maybe that’s a bit too difficult for now. But something that’s something that’s workable, that you can actually have a sense that if the other person stood understood how you felt, that they would, in fact, forgive you.

I ask for your forgiveness. I ask for your forgiveness. And then finally, forgiving others for what they’ve done. You know, there have been many ways that others have hurt and harmed ourselves, have abused abuses or abandoned us, that, you know, through their pain, through their anger, through their confusion, they have harmed me. And for all of that harm that they have caused me, I forgive you.

I offer five I offer my forgiveness to you. I offer my forgiveness to you. And seeing if you can actually begin to let go of some of the hurt, some of the resentment, you know, this this wish to retaliate. Okay. So we’ll begin with mindfulness of breath, taking a comfortable firm posture.

Beginning to react relax the body, starting in the crown of the head, the scalp, the forehead. I’m feeling the the the wrinkles begin to smooth out in the brow. The pressure in around the eyes beginning to dissipate. The muscles in the face beginning to relax. The jaws relax.

Moving down to the neck, perhaps turning your head to the the side a few times gently. Consciously relaxing, softening the muscles in the neck. Your shoulders. Rotating your shoulders a few times, feeling the tension, the burden beginning to move down into the ground, your shoulders beginning to relax, keeping the back straight, but letting your shoulders just hang on your on your spinal cord. Your hands The lower arms.

The upper arms. Chest as it is. Letting go of the tension in your that you hold in your stomach muscles, letting the belly go soft. The pelvic area. My buttocks.

The upper legs. Lower legs. Feet. Bring your awareness to this portion of body where you feel a sense of tightness or tension. Consciously relaxing and softening, feeling the solidity of the tightness begin to dissipate, the tension moving down and out of your body into the ground.

And then bring your mind to the breath. Just the easy, gentle, in love flow of the natural breath. If it’s helpful using techniques of counting and noting the breaths. We’re going to meditate on forgiveness beginning with our self. For all the ways that I’ve caused myself suffering out of fear or out of pain, out of confusion, I extend myself forgiveness.

I forgive myself. So thinking of a particular instance where through action or inaction out of fear or pain or confusion, you caused yourself some harm, some difficulties. Difficulties. And simply direct the sense of forgiveness towards yourself. I forgive myself.

Let go of the hurt, the grudge you might hold against yourself, the anger, the self recrimination that you hold against yourself. I forgive myself. I forgive myself. Now I’m going to ask for the forgiveness of others. So they’re calling into mind a specific time, event, situation.

We hurt or harmed others, another person either intentionally or unintentionally, knowingly or unknowingly, out of pain or out of fear, out of confusion, out of anger. I ask for your forgiveness. I ask for your forgiveness. I ask for your forgiveness. Now we’re going to offer our forgiveness to toward another.

So, again, remembering a specific instance, but this time someone who’s hurt you either intentionally or unintentionally out of their own pain or anger, out of their own confusion, out of their own fear, someone hurt us. And let go of any sense of wishing to retaliate, wishing that they themselves be hurt in return. Offer them your forgiveness. I forgive you. I forgive you.

I forgive you. And then bring your mind back to the breath. And getting in touch with your body, any feelings, It’s slowly becoming aware of what’s going on about you. Just take your time. There’s no hurry.

So we’ve been looking at the Three Principal Aspects of the path. The preliminary praise, the preliminary of the pledge to compose, and the the preliminary of encouragement. And preliminary encouragement was in the third verse where it said, listen with clear minds as fortunate of you, who unattached to the pleasures of conditioned existence and striving that your life of freedoms and richness will find meaning and trust yourselves in paths that please the conqueror. So Tsongkhapa is addressing himself to particular listener, and that is to say, a listener who is interested in developing or training in the three principal aspects of the path, the will to awaken, the awakened heart, and the awakened mind. And those were in the second, third, and fourth lines respectively.

And he said, listen with clear minds. So he was admonished admonishments to listen. And we talked about last week, talked about listening in terms of this three stage process of listening, reflecting, and meditating. You know, at the at the listening stage, gathering all the facts together, seeing how they how the information fits together, getting an idea of the the overall structure of the teaching, understanding the terms that are being used and so forth, some of the major concepts. Then at the reflecting stages, using our reasoning and and our own experience, recreating and clarifying doubts, gaining knowledge and certainty for ourselves.

And then with this sense of confident confidence that comes out of this, embark upon the third stage that of of meditating, you know, with having moved through our sense of hesitation or doubts with with regard to the significance of what’s being said, the meaning of what’s being said, we we we actually experience the true meaning. We we try to actually become that meaning, the significance. And we accustom ourselves to this new found under this new found realization again and again. And, eventually, it becomes our second nature. It becomes our our actual nature, and we we we grow and we finally awaken.

So our our progress along the progress along the the path of the three principal aspects of the path involves implementing these three stages of listening, reflecting, and then and also meditating. And as those fortunate ones who are interested in the in these Three Principal Aspects of the path, developing and training them, should listen and listen in this in this context, those three folds, listening, reflecting, and meditating. But Tsongkhapa advises us in this verse. He says, listen with clear minds. So it’s not just listening, but listen with clear minds.

So this this manner of listening with a clear mind is explained through the metaphors of three pots and three recognitions and also what are called the four reliances. So I think Tibetan Buddhism tries to cover every detail of our practice, how we can be sure that our our practice is going to be effective. So it’s pretty thorough thoroughgoing. Maybe sometimes too or too thoroughgoing.

I don’t know. But anyway, presenting presenting some of these details of how we are to listen in terms of the these metaphors. For firstly, listening in terms by way of the metaphor of three pots and the metaphor of three recognitions and may and also explaining it in terms of the four reliances. So beginning with three pots, I mean, I probably many have heard you’ve heard this metaphor before. These are unproductive ways of listening.

The the first unproductive way of listening is like a pot with a lid on top. You know, nothing can nothing can go in it. Nothing can be put in it. Your your mind is is constantly distracted. It’s it’s allowed to wander, or it’s not open to the it’s not open to the teaching, you know, out of a sense of closed mindedness or out of a sense of or your mind or you’re full of pride that simply won’t listen.

So either way, out of whether you’re distracted or your mind is wandering or your mind is closed for one reason or another, nothing goes in. You know, just just just like a closed pot. The second unproductive way is is likened to a a pot with a hole in the bottom. You know, whatever is poured in immediately immediately runs out the bottom. I don’t if you can identify with that.

I can’t. Nothing’s retained or nothing. You know, after the teaching, you’re not sure what was said. You haven’t, you know, in other words, you haven’t remembered anything that was said. So a pot with hole in the bottom.

And the third unproductive way of listening is a pot that’s dirty. It’s whatever is placed in it becomes is immediately polluted. So this is analogous to involves listening with some kind of wrong motivation. I don’t I doubt if you some I doubt if any of you are listening out of trying to gain fame or fortune, but I don’t know. You know, it might be desire to be highly thought of by others.

I don’t know. Or listening or another other types of pollutants, polluted ways of listening or wrong ways of listening would be simply listening out of our out of our preconceptions, you know, filtering everything through our preconceptions, not really listening to what is being said, but how it fits into your already under your present understanding of the way things should be, you know, or or listening just to find fault with the teacher or the teaching. So one has one you have your own agenda, which isn’t a very profitable or productive agenda at that. So listening filtered through all these possible pre preconceptions. So, anyway, whatever is heard is or automatically becomes polluted by in one way or another by your wrong your wrong motivation, your preconceptions, and so forth.

So the Buddha in in a number of sutras, he talked about he talked about these three parts, but he also talked about how they are to be overcome. Just some small antidote. He said, listen well, carefully, and keep in mind. Listen well, carefully, and keep in mind. So listen well indicates that we should listen without prejudice.

And and most without so without any prejudice. So we aren’t prejudging, kind of allowing the mind to take in the what’s being said without without any ulterior motive or without any prejudgment clouding the issue. But also, hopefully, with some kind of beneficial motivation, even if it’s only, you know, I’m listening to benefit myself, but even more so if it’s possible, I’m listening to benefit not only myself, but others. So listening well indicates you should listening without prejudice and with the benefit and motivation. Listening carefully indicates that you should listen with a an open attentive and be attentive to what’s being said, so paying attention.

Listen to keep in mind. So that’s pretty simple, I guess. Just try to remember what’s being said. So the the the three unproductive ways of listening in terms of this these metaphors of a pot with a lid on it that has a hole in the bottom and it’s polluted. Another metaphor that’s that’s used in terms of unproductive or or ways to listen is the three recognitions.

And I, you know, I think these are useful, but I think they have to be understood a in a, I guess, in a in a healthy manner, in a proper manner, intelligent manner. The first because the first one is that the recognition that we are we ourselves are a patient. You know? So when I say it has to be listened, this has to be applied in a healthy or productive manner. There’s a great difference between being a sick person and being a helpless person.

We we aren’t helpless. Okay? But having said that, we have to acknowledge a high degree of perhaps dissatisfactoriness in our life. You know? Otherwise, there’s no opening to a need to change.

There’s, you know, there’s and therefore, there’s no opening as to possibility for any kind of cure. Seeing oneself as a patient who needs some help and therefore looking for actually trying to look for some kind of cure. You know, that to acknowledge our suffering is to be healthy enough to admit that everything is not quite okay in our life, and thereby giving our sense giving ourselves a chance to get better. We have to have some kind of some degree, I think, of a of humility around this. The I think that the Tibetans have a saying that that the grass, the spring grass grows first in the valley.

That’s at the lowest place. So we are we are a sick person, but but we’re not a helpless person. Okay? A big difference in that sense. The second recognition is recognizing that the the teacher is the doctor.

So if, you know, if you were to listen to a teaching by an actual teacher, an authentic teacher, that, you know, recognizing that this person is is there to benefit you in terms of, you know, by way of this metaphor or this analogy that that you are a sick person and the teacher is a doctor. You know, most many people or most people will will readily put themselves in the hands of a of a medical practitioner who has a certificate on the wall. But they find it difficult to admit that that someone else may be more skilled in the ways of of the mind and be and have more insight into the ways of actually finding happiness in their life than themselves. You know, for we all have our various methods for finding happiness and solving our problems. And though though through our own experience, many of our methods might be invalidated again and again and again.

There’s many of the ways that we try to find happiness simply aren’t working. They they haven’t worked in the past, they probably won’t work in the future. But to a large degree, we we are we obstinately hold on as if we knew better. We find it difficult to admit that someone else’s diagnosis of our life problems might might be and their and their prescription for a cure might be more valid, might be more skillful than our own. So it it requires some kind of humility and openness, thinking that I am a sick person and being willing to listen to this person as as if they were a doctor in this way.

And then finally, the third recognition is that is that the dharma is medicine. So it’s, you know, using this idea of patient doctor and the dharma as the medicine. And the medicine is a cure for what our illness, for our sickness. You know, with and more importantly, seeing the seeing the the Dharma as the cure, as the as the medicine, understanding that without actually taking the medicine, you know, without actually practicing the teachings, the path, there is no way for us to get better. No matter how potent the medicine, if we actually don’t take it, it’s a it’s a no use.

You know, if no matter how effective the method, how effective the Dharma might be, we actually have to put it into practice if if it’s going to help us to solve our problems, if it’s going to help us to get better. There’s a there’s a a verse from by the Buddha from a sūtra called the king of concentration sutras where he says, though I have taught the most excellent Dharma, yet having heard it, you do not practice it properly. You are like a patient holding a bag full of medicine who still cannot cure his disease. So, you know, no matter how potent the medicine, you know, we could have a whole medicine cabinet full of the best medicines. But, actually, we never take them if we never put the Dharma in the practice, if we never implement these these ideas and these teachings in our everyday life, they’re not gonna be of any benefit.

So in order to listen effectively to the teachings, we have to focus on what’s being said. We have to try to remain, to retain, and not distort what’s being said. We have to come to the teachings with some sort of degree of humility, a sense of openness, but also with dignity. I have some problems. I but I have I also have the resources to solve solve those problems.

But maybe I could use some help, some assistance in diagnosing what my problems is are problems are and give me some alternate give me some alternatives, some types of means of cure in order to help myself. So I’m willing to listen. And if I hear something which is useful, which is reasonable, which accords with my own experience, then I’ll then I’ll I’ll make use of it. So this is what Tsongkhapa means when he says to listen with a clear mind. So it’s clear in our minds what it is that why we’re here, what we’re doing, and what we can expect, what we can legitimately expect through our process of listening.

But there’s an there’s an additional way that we can listen, and this is sometimes mentioned. These these previous two ways of listening are quite often mentioned in various teachings. And quite sometimes more of these what are called the four reliances are also mentioned. So these four, in the context of listening with a clear mind, if we have to understand how to listen in order that what is said isn’t allowed to become some kind of dogma or or becomes becomes ineffective in in actually bringing about transformation.

It loses its ability to transform our minds. The so this this way of listening is called the four reliances. So what we are to rely on in the course of listening. So the first of these four reliances rely on the teaching, not on the personality of the one giving the teaching. Rely on the teaching, not on the personality of the one giving the teaching.

So this indicates that that we should not blindly accept what is taught simply out of respect for the teacher. That if the truth it is a truth of the teaching which is all important and never the personality of the teacher. So no matter how famous the teacher might be, how authoritative the teacher might be, we are we have to critically examine their teachings. The teachings should stand on its own cogency. You know, the Buddha said, you know, I I alluded to this verse a little while ago.

He himself said, and this this was near his time of death where he said, obikshus, just as a goldsmith gets his gold, first testing by melting, cutting, and rubbing. Sage is except by teachings after full examination and not out of devotion to me. So, you know, as I mentioned in this this Pāli expression, you know, come and see come and see for yourself if what I say is true or not. Once you get once you have done that, you will have no need for for any test testimony by others, by by dogma, by blind acceptance out of devotions from me. So relying upon the teaching, you know, pain emphasizing the teaching, what the teacher is actually saying as opposed to the fame of the teacher or the supposed authoritative standing of the teacher.

The second reliance is rely on the meaning and not on the words. So, again, this this emphasizes the point that the essence of the teaching is the practice of them. So, with great erudite speech, you in all of this possible, you know, the the poetic quality of it, the complexity of the speech, all the various possible ways that the words can be set up, the exposition. We should look at see how they practically function in gaining experience and realization. You know, what is the meaning of what’s being said?

Not being satisfied with the mere words. However eloquently they’re put, what is this person actually saying? What’s the bottom line? What they mean? But how are we determined what the meaning is and what’s being said?

So this is this comes out in the third reliance. Rely on the definitive meaning and not the provisional one. Rely on the definitive meaning and not on the provisional one. Sometimes this word provisional. Sometimes they use the word interpretable.

But I think here, maybe provisional works better. So in in relying on the definitive meaning, we are orientating the mind in the direction of understanding the ultimate nature of phenomena, their emptiness. And and and, therefore, we’re overcoming ignorance, and this is seen as the most beneficial, as the most liberative. So when we talk about rely upon the definitive rather than provisional meaning, the definitive is that which seeks to set out the ultimate truth, emptiness. And it is by means of this understanding of emptiness, which is you will be liberated.

Nothing else. There’s only one door to liberation, and that is this understanding through wisdom of the ultimate nature of reality. This is what is termed definitive. So Śāntideva, in his Bodhicharyavatara said, all these branches of Dharma, the Buddha expounded for the sake of wisdom. Therefore, they must generate this wisdom who wishes to have an end of suffering.

So what do we mean by definitive teaching? What are some of the definitive words, for example? And there’s so many of you are familiar with the Heart Sūtra or the Heart of Wisdom Sūtra. And here, I just put a a very few few lines just to give you an idea by way of example. So here, Avalokiteśvara is speaking to Śāriputra.

Therefore, Śāriputra, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, consciousness. There is no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no form, no sound, smell, no taste, no tactile object, no phenomena. So this is a this is a definitive teaching. Why? Because it is presenting the ultimate nature of phenomena.

It is saying it says here, there is no form. So, ultimately, there is no form. Ultimately, there is no feeling. Ultimately, is no discrimination. Ultimately, there are no compositional factors.

Ultimately, there is no eye. Ultimately, there is no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind. Ultimately, conventionally, they exist. Ultimately, they do not exist. So it’s a teaching on the ultimate nature of phenomena.

It’s a teaching on emptiness. So such statement such statements, they orientate the mind toward realizing emptiness, overcoming ignorance, and is this which liberates. So according to, you know, the of the four tenet systems, the four philosophic systems in which the Buddhist teachings were organized over time. According to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school, the highest middle way school, definitive this is a definitive teaching. Why?

Because it teaches emptiness. It teaches the ultimate nature of phenomena. This what would be an example of it said to rely on the the definitive meaning and not the provisional one. What what is the provisional teaching? It could be almost anything else.

For example, a sprout arises from a seed. That’s a that is provisional teaching. It’s a correct teaching. It’s true, isn’t it? A sprout or a plant arises from a seed.

But it is a provisional teaching. It does not teach the ultimate. And therefore, because it doesn’t teach the ultimate, there is the possibility that it will reinforce your instinctive habit of conceiving of true existence. Now we’re gonna you know, when we talked about the third principal aspect of the path, the the awakened mind, we’ll go through this ad nauseam. We’ll go through this quite a lot about what this means.

The instinctive habit of conceiving of true existence. You know, one can think, and many of the lower schools do, that from a truly existent seed, a truly existent sprout arises. So this is only a provisional teaching because sprouts do arise from seeds, but not ultimately. So this teaching in its in itself can no teaching on the conventional can liberate your mind. Only the teaching of the ultimate can liberate your mind.

Only a teacher on emptiness. Other teachings, you know, for example, we say, a skillful action produces happiness. Unskillful actions produce suffering. That’s correct. And we should we should try to adjust our conduct in accordance with that.

But such a teaching can only cannot liberate you. It can only bring about certain types of mundane happiness in the future and cause you to avoid certain types of unhappiness in the future. Mundane happiness is unhappiness in the future. Such teachings are provisional since they cannot liberate you. We can think, and many of the lower schools do think, from truly existent positive, skillful actions, truly existent happiness arises.

Though that will, in fact, bring you happiness in the future, it will bind you more and more to cyclic existence. These are like what these are term golden chains. You know? It brings you happiness in the future, but happiness within cyclic existence. They cannot liberate you from cyclic existence.

Therefore, it’s like gold because it brings you happiness, but still it’s a chain. And a chain is a chain, whether it’s made out of gold or iron, it’s still a chain. So these are provisional teachings. So we should or finally, we should rely on definitive teachings as a means to find liberation. The conventional is used as a means of understanding the ultimate.

We have to understanding the ultimate. We have to we have to make use of these provisional teachings such as teachings on karma, and to serve as a platform, as a foundation for developing the the the the merit and for developing the overcoming levels of ignorance until finally we’re able to understand the ultimate and overcome the ignorance which binds us to cyclic existence. It’s only the definitive teaching which can liberate you from cyclic existence. And then the fourth reliance, rely on the non conceptual wisdom and not on mere intellectual understanding. So this indicates that no matter how profound our intellectual understanding might be, how deep our intellectual understanding of the ultimate nature of things might be.

It is the it is the nondual. It is the intuitive direct realization that brings about transformation. It is which brings brings about the experience, liberative experience. So saint Śāntideva also talks about this. He says, the two truths are declared.

There are two truths, conventional truth and ultimate truth. And these are quite a thorough understanding of these can be quite important. The two truths are declared to be the conventional and the ultimate. The ultimate is not within the scope of the intellect. The intellect is said to be conventional.

So the ultimate, what is the ultimate nature of things? It’s emptiness. Things are empty of a fantasized way of existing, which we’re continually projecting upon all phenomena continually. This table, this self, this building, they appear to us to be in to exist independently, independent of causes, conditions, independence of their parts, but also most importantly, independent of the force of mind. You know, we talk about like we see something very beautiful.

It is that beauty appears to exist from its own side independent of my mind. That’s why we develop attachment. Due to the force of ignorance, that beauty is as if it exists from the side of the object, and the mind is simply a passive observer. But in fact, you know, like this as this as we say in, you know, the saying in the West, beauty is in the eyes of beholder. The the the that beauty does not exist independent of one’s own mind.

One one that beauty is being imputed by the mind. You know, the nature of beauty is culturally dependent. It’s a cultural construct. We learn what beauty is. It’s not inherent.

It’s not in the nature of the object. From culture to culture, beauty varies. If if beauty were in the were in the nature of the object, we could take the same object and put it into any culture or situation, and and they would all say, oh, that’s beautiful. That’s beautiful. That’s beautiful.

That’s beautiful. If if beauty abides with the natural nature of the object. The fact that they don’t, you know, like, in I think in the Burmese, you know, they maybe it’s the Amazon. Anyway, I know there’s one tribe where they put these big plates in their lips. You know?

It’s a sign of beauty. You know? I don’t know for you, but that doesn’t look beautiful to me. And or the the Burmese tradition the Burmese tribes people, they put these rings in their neck, and they stretch it in their It’s very beautiful. For them, it’s beautiful.

You know? For so that beauty, for them, that’s that’s culturally conditioned beauty, but the beauty appears to to exist from the side of the object. So there’s a sense if I can bring that object, you know, we have a sense of an eye with a certain boundary line that we’ve drawn around. And if I can if I can incorporate that into my sense of self identity, my ego identity to make it mine, I can I can always partake of the pleasure of that beauty as if it were permanently available to me by making it a permanent part of myself? So we develop attachment, wanting to draw that, incorporate that sense into that object into our sense of ego identity, into be into mind because we see that beauty is residing out there.

We’re independent of our own minds. But that’s a misconception. That’s that’s only arises that appearance arises, and that conception arises due to force of ignorance, which misconceives. And in fact, that object is empty of any inherent existence, any inherent quality characteristic, any inherent beauty. So the ultimate or the emptiness that we we should try to understand it, the the ultimate truth, not not merely by the intellectual understanding.

We have to get at it by through intuitive understanding, a direct understanding. Why? Because the an intellectual understanding cannot completely encompass the meaning of the the meaning of ultimate truth cannot be encompassed completely by words and concepts. And therefore, our our understanding cannot be allowed to rest merely in an intellectual understanding if it’s going to be transformative, if it’s going to be. Liberative.

No amount of words or ideals can for example, no amount of words or concepts can adequately explain the flavor of brown sugar. We have to act to understand thoroughly the flavor of brown sugar. You actually have to taste it for yourself directly, experience it for yourself. Then you know brown sugar. And we can give it we can we can get across the a rough idea to someone else about what if what brown sugar tastes like.

But if they really wanna know what it what if they really want to experience, they actually have to taste it for themselves. So this what this this notion here is getting them, that we shouldn’t be satisfied no matter how, you know, vast our intellectual knowledge of about emptiness or ultimate nature might be. What we want is some kind of direct experience, some intuitive understanding, and that’s what that is what is transformative. So we are to rely upon non conceptual, as a direct wisdom, not on a mere intellectual understanding. So through these through the application of these four reliances in our listening, we will never fall into things will not be allowed to we won’t simply be satisfied by gathering knowledge.

I think this a lot of this was simply ensuring that people simply didn’t mistake information for knowledge and knowledge for wisdom. That it would that would simply knowing the ins and outs is is excellent, but one should not be satisfied with that. Otherwise, it simply becomes dogma. It it it actually doesn’t bring about the transformations that we really want from the teachings. So this is the this completes the first of these three overall divisions of three principal aspects of the path.

There’s a prologue, the body of the text, and the the the epilogue or the conclusion. So we’ve looked at the prologue. We’ve gotten through something. You wanna talk about it? Should we discuss something?

You’d like to any questions? Give me some feedback. Is it too much detail? Not enough? No?

Okay. How what about the what about the meditations? Are they okay? How could things be better? Come on, you guys.

You gotta help me, dude. Can I not answer that question? Can you not answer that question? I I mean, I apologize. Yeah, please.

Yeah. Okay. I’ll try to get in the mic. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. I understand. You could get a straight teaching side and get the words. Yeah. I agree.

Yeah. You get different angles to the. Do do you have any comments, question? Got a question. Yeah, please.

When you sort of mentioned earlier on about belief, faith. Yeah. Does that does that sort of form the basis of renunciation? So believing faith is a type of so this type of faith which is just arises to hearing, you know, or or just kinda you know, you met you meet somebody, you meet a teacher, and then and you’re really impressed with impressed with who they are. And they say, I I this I this I became like I am through these these teachings.

And so you have some kind of that what arises is the idea of believing faith. I would like to be like that. And he got like that through what he what by following these teachings, maybe I should do the same. So the idea of faith has the idea of aspiration. Try and I know in in Buddhism, faith has the notion of trying to becoming or incorporating the object of your faith within you, becoming an object.

Like, you have faith in the Buddha or your faith in your teacher. There’s a there’s a sense of wanting to become like that. So you meet with a teacher, for example, and you’d and he says, you know, I am this I became the way I am. In one way or another, he says, I became the way I am through these teachings. And so one wants to become like him, so one becomes interested in the teachings.

So that’s a believing faith. That plays on the renunciation. You have like, you know, once you sort of realize that. Yeah. Think then then you’d have to then you’d begin begin to listen then you actually begin to develop a longing faith where you actually listen to the teachings.

And he talks about various practices and techniques, and he says, well, I wanna make these practice. I really wanna be able to practice these. I wanna be so the I mean, part of the teachings would be the teaching down renunciation and so forth. So what is the the question is what is the connection between this renunciation and does that say it’s made real life. Yeah.

Think maybe initially you’re more interested in impressed by the person of the teacher, or or you hear about the qualities of a Buddha, qualities of a teacher, for example, the qualities of a Buddha. And this induces a believing faith and longing and wanting and then the that they became understand it, that they became the way they are. One need be wanted to be like them. So you have a faith and what’s called the believing faith in them. And then you develop a longing faith because they you understand that they became the way they are through these various practices.

And then we go on to actually experience some of the practice the fruit of the practice as a result of the practice and develop a what’s the third type of faith? What was that third pot? The holy pot. I feel like a holey pot. That’s the How do we fix the hole?

How do we fix the hole? Oh, that was Convincing faith, longing faith Clear faith. Clear faith. Thank you. Thank you for that.

That’s your clear faith. So it becomes clear through actually gaining some kind of experience. I spent I think maybe sometimes the idea of some of the, you know, we have introductory remarks around going for refuge and development of faith. I think, you know, sometimes I don’t feel adequate in explaining them, to be honest. I but I think they’re I think it’s quite important.

I mean, there’s not a a great deal of of information. I mean, not, you know, like facts. But I think the I I think these ideas are very important somehow to to to to create a context for the teaching. Other otherwise, we you know, I think, otherwise, we become like one of these pots with especially with a lid on it. Yeah.

I think creating some kind of and I think faith is important or or a sense of confidence and and creating kind of the, you know, this is what I call the inner ecology of mind. You know, creating a condition where you don’t feel so defensive, where you feel some kind of you create you have some kind of confidence in these teachings. And thereby, especially, for example, in meditation, where you don’t have to be as watchful over yourself. You don’t have to be self conscious over yourself, where you can there’s a sense that you can trust the process, and therefore, you can you can sort of let go. And I think the mind I have a sense that the mind is more the the more faith, the more, I mean, constructive faith, the healthy faith, the more receptive.

The mind is that much more susceptible to to change. I don’t think the patterns are held as rigidly, and I think it’s more open new for for new ways of thinking to to open up, and a new way you know, new ideas to be introduced. I have a sense that the mind is more pliable or workable. Otherwise, I think the mind is really really very defensive and very it’s I think it becomes very what’s different? What’s the opposite of pliable?

Rigid. Good. Yeah. Mind, I think I think this all has that. That’s that’s that’s kind of my thinking.

If you trust in something, you’re some you can relax. You don’t have to be on you don’t have to you don’t feel endangered. You feel safe. That’s why I think faith this this intelligent faith is important because one has a sense Because, you know, as I’ve tried to emphasize, you know, we can’t we hardly know what’s going to happen when we’re on our, you know, on our way home. I don’t know what’s gonna happen.

We’re five years from now, ten years now. But we can have faith enough to trust that without knowing all the details of the outcome of change, that it’s gonna be a salutary change. That is by salutary, I mean, it’s going to be useful, beneficial, that we’re going you know, we we we’re not quite sure of all the details of the outcome, but we’re gonna be a better person. And our lives are going to be appreciably better. Our relationships are going to be better.

We sort of have it. We trust in that. And then there’s a I think there’s a at a deeper level of our being, there’s willingness to give ourselves over to the process. And I don’t think it can be intellectually controlled. You know?

I think it’s something more at a deeper level of our being than that. So creating that kind of context for practice, I think, is important. That’s my notion. So I think sometimes maybe I belabor the point. I don’t know.

I worry about that sometimes. One way of looking at faith is that it’s it’s a faith at its best is a is a synthesis out of doubt and belief. You know, I could believe a proposition or I I can doubt the proposition. I can believe that there’s a glass on the table or I can doubt there’s a glass on the table. So so out of out of working with doubt and and belief, one arrives at a level of a faith.

And this faith is directed toward things which aren’t directly obvious or access accessible to ourselves at present. But one has a trust, having worked through, you know, like a tradition. One is able to, you know, like, begin to have faith in the tradition or faith in these teachings because one has worked through a lot of doubt and beliefs and synthesized them. You know, going know, I think we’re always going back and forth. And then one comes to a sense of trust with regard to those things that we we can’t quite understand at present, but we’re willing to use as a working hypothesis in how we conduct our lives and, like, things like past and future lives.

You know, there’s lots of things like the Dalai Lama said. There’s a lot of things that things that for emptiness is emptiness is the heart of Buddhism in a way, and emptiness can be arrived at by reasoning. So if the heart of Buddhism can be arrived at reasoning, then these other these other principle teachings we we can have we can use it as a working hypothesis. You know, we can we can say, I’m not I don’t I don’t have I haven’t understood them for myself. But if the if the the the central framework of the teaching, the the idea of emptiness, which can be accessible through reasoning, which can be understood through reasoning, is valid, then I’m going to work on the basis that these others are valid until until I understand otherwise.

So one has a it also kind of an overall faith, you know, having worked having gone beyond some kind of doubts and beliefs and actually trust some trust in the the overall teachings. Yeah. I get yeah. So so I think, yeah, that working through doubts and beliefs. The belief is beliefs isn’t quite enough.

Yeah. Because it’s it’s always open to doubt. So we’ll stop there. We’ll dedicate the the merit, the positive energy that we’ve created. All beings everywhere plagued by suffering of body and mind, attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits.

May no living creatures suffer, commit evil, or fall ill. May one be afraid or belittled with the mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms, the deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored upon finding repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food.

May the thirsty find water and delicious drink. May the poor find wealth. Those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness, and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests.

May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power and may people think of benefiting each other.

Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm. May the supreme jewels of the three principal aspects of the path that have not arisen arise and grow. And may those that have arisen, may they never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land circled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful, so please remain until the end of cyclic existence.

Thank you. Have a good week.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
valid inference jepag tshema (Tib)
A new non-deceptive outer cognition directly generated in dependence on its support, a correct reason. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top