2 h 17 min · 11,657 words · 26 February 2007 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Picturing the Buddha as a radical who staked his status on finding an alternative to suffering, Ven Jampa Gendun opens this two-hour session by revisiting the Four Noble Truths before turning to the philosophical case for rebirth underlying correct view — the third principal aspect of the path. A short guided meditation first asks listeners to locate the I: are you your toe when it hurts, your body if offered a healthier one, your mind if offered a wiser one? The rebirth argument then unfolds through two logical tools — substantial cause versus cooperative cause (illustrated with clay pots and seeds) and the principle of similarity of type — before a television-set analogy challenges neuroscience’s claim that the brain generates mind. A lively Q&A closes on whether the will to live at death constitutes harmful grasping.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 02 3PA 2007 02 26.mp3
UUID: af334470-5375-4c39-ae13-8adebfe27f68
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2006-2007 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 2007-02-26
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 137.6 minutes
Words: ~11,657
Are you cold? Are you cold? Okay. If you get cold, let let us know. Sam, sorry.
Can’t quite get it right. Is it it’s either too high or too low. How is everybody? Okay. I’m not suffering too much because I’m talking about our motivation, and sometimes I think you must get tired of talking about suffering.
You know, the Buddha, he was a dropout in many ways. He was kind of a radical, a revolutionary. He left his home and family, and he wanted to investigate alternative possible ways of approaching life, What he had experienced after that and what he had seen in terms of death and sickness and old age, it didn’t paint a very pretty picture for him. So he was willing enough to try to make an experiment and to invest his a lot of time and energy and a great deal of his status in that experiment. So he came to a discovery for himself that there was an alternative to his perpetual cycles of dissatisfaction and disappointment and frustration.
I guess what we take as a normal life. We have been normalized and we take that as the given. And so within that, we try to manipulate the people and the things and the situations about us and so forth, and kind of create a nice, comfortable niche for ourselves, find some kind of haven out of the storm. Were all kind of refugees in a way, seeking asylum from the vicissitudes of life. But it never works for long.
And even if we find a nice comfortable home, it goes into contraction eventually and we get expelled in one way or another. And we have to start our search all over again in one way or another. So, you know, in his I find it inspiring that he was willing to take a risk and give up all that most people would hold as valuable in his society, also within our times, in our society, in his status and power and money and all the goodies of life, to search for other possibilities. And he actually saw that or he experienced the cessation of his problems. And so he wondered, Well, you know, should I Is anybody going to listen to me?
Finally he was convinced by others that there were some who had only a slight covering of dust over their eyes. So at the age of thirty five he began his teaching career in Sarnath. He began his teaching career in Sarnath, Deer Park, in modern day Uttar Pradesh. And the very first teaching that he taught was the teaching on the Four Noble Truths. This summarizes the entire doctrine that he was going to set out for the next forty five years of his life.
He lived to about eighty years old. And the very first teaching that he gave was of the Four Noble Truths, the truth of suffering. That life, as we now experience it, is dissatisfactory. We use the word dissatisfactory or suffering. In Sanskrit, the word was dukkha.
And originally, dukkha meant a wheel that grinds on its axle. You know? Like there’s a misfit. Life kind of wears us down. It hurts.
It wounds us. And he saw that it was, you know, this was in the very nature of life. And I think this is important to emphasize. We’re not talking about life life in general. We’re talking about a particular way of living our life.
And this comes to the second noble truth, an ignorance driven life, a life which is lived under the control of karma and afflictive emotions attachment, hatred, pride, jealousy but at its root, ignorance. And so is it possible to remove this cause of suffering, the origins of suffering, that is ignorance. And from the Buddha’s own experience, it was. We can develop wisdom. It’s possible to develop the exact opposite or the antidote to ignorance, ignorance which misconceives the nature of I, for example.
You know, at the root of all our afflictive emotions is a sense of a solid concrete self, I. On the basis of this, we make a distinction between self and other, and we, from that, develop attachment for that which we see as enhancing the self and aversion for that which we see as threatening to the self and all the various karmic actions which flow out of that. So there is a path leading to the end of the cause of suffering. And this path is variously outlined in terms of the Eightfold Noble Path or the Three Higher trainings. But here we’re looking at the path of the Mahāyāna and the universal vehicle.
And it’s universal because we, in our evolution, and our awareness of the nature of life as experience it, we can readily understand that we’re not alone in our experiences. You know, there’s all variations amongst us here, all the different shapes and genders and colors and maybe anyway, these are all very much superficial. Beneath it all, we’re all very much alike. We all want to be happy. None of us want to suffer.
That’s universal. And what is more is that within saṃsāra, at least, within these perpetual cycles of dissatisfaction. Though we want to be happy, most of us aren’t happy. And I’m not saying we’re basket cases, okay? But things could be better if we’re honest with ourselves, maybe if we don’t even have to be overly honest.
And though we want not to suffer, still we suffer. That’s kind of a truth about our lives, which many people spend a great deal of their time and energy denying, avoiding, distracting themselves in one way or another, to acknowledge this basic truth of their lives. So, you know, I have great admiration for all of you to be willing enough to acknowledge that things could be better. But more than that, that you’re willing to to do something about it. You’re willing to take that you have an insight perhaps into the nature of your problems and beginning to see that simply working with the outer world in terms of the people situations and material things has not and probably will not solve this basic problem of dissatisfaction which we all experience in one way or another.
And then maybe we’ve all had some kind of insight that it is our own minds in terms of our attitudes, opinions, our beliefs, our worldview, which are the basis of our present dissatisfaction. But through their transformation, bringing about inner change, through changing our ideas attitudes and opinions and so forth, we can find an end to this dissatisfaction. We can find some kind of contentment. But moreover, by going through this process ourselves, by developing our own insights and understandings and skills, we can help others to do the same. As I leave that back room, a I should bring it out with me there’s that there’s a framed quotation from the Dalai Lama, which he says the degree of happiness that we inner happiness that we experience is very much dependent upon the degree of compassion and love that we all have.
And that, you know, out of our understandings and the ability to help ourselves, combining with the wish to help others, then we will something good will come out of all that we do. I think we can feel very assured. I get some kind of confidence in that. Otherwise, no. We can’t be sure.
All the blood, sweat, and tears that we’ve expended over the course of our lives. What hasn’t gotten us? It probably hasn’t gotten us very far. We always come back to the same point in one way or another. So I have great admiration for what it is that you’re trying to do.
I don’t know if I can help, but I do what I can. So the inner focus of our life is Buddha. This what represents this solution to our basic problems, not only our own basic problems, but being position to be of greatest benefit to others as well. And we take that as our guiding star, and we keep orientating. And then we keep reading the dark night sky, and we see that star.
And that’s the direction that we try to continually orientate ourselves back to so we aren’t lost in saṃsāra, lost in the world. But we have to do something. We actually, you know, we’re all on this journey. We have to take some steps to get to where it is that we want to go, to that state of Buddhahood. And these are the practices of Dharma in one way or another.
And what is Dharma? Most basically, I think it’s useful to keep coming back to this in one way or another because it simplifies. Sometimes the Dharma can seem terribly complicated, you know, all of these various all these stacks of texts and teachings and so forth, and all the volumes and philosophy and so forth. But essentially, it is actively opposing our negative states of mind. That’s pretty simple.
And on the other hand, maybe cultivating positive states in mind. If you’re doing that, if you’re practicing Dharma, you can you can feel assured of that. And we do this you know, we we need each other’s help. We’re human beings are social beings. Mental health is a social phenomena.
The world is our hospital. It’s a place where we go to to recover, to get better. So this is like our hospital in a way. And we are all nurses in one way or another, assisting one another to get better. So I think this is a fortunate position that we’re all in.
I think we can rejoice and not take it for granted. And we try to raise the level of motivation, the why behind and the purpose for all that we do. Our being here together and sharing these teachings, these three principal aspects of the path, discussing, meditating, and so forth. If we can help one person, you know, maybe it’s some your partner or maybe it’s your child or your parent, a friend. If I can be just a little more understanding, a little more patient, if I can have some kind of insight into what would be a benefit, then it’s also very worthwhile.
I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha.
Through my practice generosity and the other perfections may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness in the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others.
Reverently I prostrate with my body, speech, and mind, present clouds of every type of offering, those actually arranged and imagined. I disclose all my negative actions accumulated during big endless time and rejoice in all the virtues of superiors and ordinary beings. Remain to the end of cyclic existence and turn the wheel of Dharma for migrating beings. I dedicate all virtue, my own and others’ to the Great Awakening. Meditate.
And I thought you might find it to stimulate some interest around the nature of the I and nature of the self. You know, eventually, on the three principal aspects of the path, we’re going to come to the third principal aspect, and that is the correct view. And we talked, you know, in my just previously in talking working through our motivation, talking about the necessity for overcoming ignorance, and that is, say, developing the antidote, that of wisdom. And the wisdom to ignorance, the ignorance with respect to the nature of the I, is the wisdom which understands selflessness or emptiness. So from time to time it’s good to, even before we come to it as a third principal aspect of the path, to investigate.
Just take a look and stimulate some interest around that. So I’m just going to set forth a few questions that you can ask yourself to reflect upon in your meditation. So taking a comfortable firm posture. So I begin by relaxing, starting at the scalp, the forehead, the wrinkles in the brow, smoothing. The pressure in and around the eyes diminishing lessening.
Your facial muscles softening, relaxing, your jaws relaxed. Relaxing the muscles in the back of the neck, gently turning your head to each side of it. Just softening, loosening, relaxing. Relaxing the muscles of the throat. Moving down to the upper back and the shoulders, perhaps just rotating your shoulders a few times and letting them drop comfortably to the sides.
Feeling the burden that we carry on our back, on our shoulders beginning to move down through your body out into the ground. Your hands are relaxed. The lower The upper arms. Your chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area, the lungs.
Releasing the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, allow your belly to go soft. Relaxing throughout the stomach cavity, all the various organs. Holding your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles. Relaxing throughout the pelvic area. Buttocks.
The upper legs, thighs. Lower legs. Feet. And bring your mind to the body in general, becoming aware of any tensions, any tightnesses in your body. Focus on those particular areas, consciously soften, relax, feeling the tightness loosen, the tension diminish.
Your body becoming comfortable, at ease, a sense of physical well-being pervading your body. It feels good to be in your body. And then bring your mind to the breath, just the easy gentle in that flow of the natural breath. If it’s helpful use the techniques of counting and noting the breaths. Now we’re to meditate on the self and beginning by asking yourself, what do I mean when I say or I think I’m sitting on the cushion or I say or I think I’m sitting on the chair?
What reason can you give to establish that you are sitting on the cushion or that you’re sitting on the chair? I’m sitting on the cushion. What reason can I give to establish that fact? When you stub your toe, you say, I’m hurt. If you kick a stone or a rock and you stub your toe, you say I’m hurt.
Are you your toe? Are you your body? I’m hurt. Is that I the body, the toe? When something good happens to you and you have a happy feeling in your mind, you say, I’m happy.
Are you the happy feeling in your mind? Is the I the mind? When something good happens to you, you have a happy feeling in your mind. You say, I’m happy. Is the I the happy feeling in the mind?
Is the I the mind? If someone were to offer you the opportunity to exchange your present body for a healthy, beautiful, youthful body, would you accept? Doesn’t that suggest that there’s some non bodily self, some non physical self that would be benefited from the exchange? Someone says, I’m going to give you a beautiful, lovely, healthy body. Say, oh, I’ll take that.
Does that suggest that there’s a nonphysical self that would be benefited from that exchange, receiving that body? And then lastly, if someone were to offer you you the opportunity to exchange your present mind, they would give you a compassionate, joyful, wise mind. Would you accept? Doesn’t that suggest that there’s a nonmental self that would be benefited? I’m going to give you a beautiful mind, compassionate, wise.
I’ll take that. Is that I that would accept that? Is that not mental? The I that would be benefited is a nonmental self. And then bring your mind back to the breath.
Then get in touch with your body, becoming aware of the feelings, sensations within the body. And then slowly in a easy gentle relaxed manner, just become become aware of your surroundings. Okay. So we’re going to go through the reasoning which supports rebirth, the logic behind rebirth. At least one of the ways in which it’s traditionally established.
So initially, have to introduce two concepts, and these are tools that we’re going to be working with in order to establish the existence of rebirth. So the first tool, the first concept that we have to come to understand and make clear is to distinguish between two types of basic causes. We have to distinguish two types of basic causes: substantial cause and cooperative cause. Sometimes cooperative cause is called cooperative condition, but I’ll just easy on ourselves. So that’s the first concept that we have to get our mind around.
And the second is the concept of similarity of type. The concept of similarity of type. So these are the two tools that we’re going to be making use of, two concepts which we’re going to base this reasoning establishing rebirth. Okay. Let’s take a look at the first one.
And if you don’t understand something as I go along, if I’m not clear, let’s clear it up as we go. Okay? Otherwise, it maybe it won’t make much sense. Okay. At no time will my hands leave my wrists in this trick.
Okay. The first concept: distinguishing between a substantial cause and a co cooperative cause. Now, we can begin by we can most really understand on the basis of some examples. Okay. We take the example of clay pot.
Tibetans are really into clay pots. Okay. The steps the substantial cause of the clay pot is a wet lump of clay. Maybe you go to the the art supply shop or you go to the river. Like, you couldn’t go to the river, could you?
There aren’t any rivers anymore. Anyway, say there was a river. You go down. You dig up some wet lump of clay. You know?
That wet lump of clay is the substantial cause of the pot. So it is it’s the pot the the clay pot is going to be formed from that wet lump of clay. The substance of the clay is itself shaped into the pot. The substance of the clay is in itself incorporated into the pot itself. Okay?
The substantial cause of the pot is a cause. Why? Because it is assists in the production of the pot. It determines the substantial identity of the result. Yeah, the subset the substantial identity of the result.
The pot is a result. The cause, the substantial cause, is the wet lump of clay. That wet lump of clay determines the substantial identity of the pot. What do I mean by that? I mean the fact that it’s a clay pot and not an iron pot or not a plastic pot or not a wooden pot.
It’s a clay pot. Why? Because it was made from a wet lump of clay. So that wet lump of clay, we say, is a substantial cause of the pot. It itself is incorporated into the pot.
It’s included in the final result, and it establishes this substantial identity that the fact that it’s a clay pot and not an iron pot or a wood pot or a plastic pot, but a clay pot. So that’s one side or one of these two types of causes. The other cause is a cooperative cause. Now, the cooperative cause of the of the clay pot is the potter, you know, the the person who shapes the pot, the wheel, you know, that they throw the pot on, the various tools that they use in forming the pot. Those are all cooperative causes.
They contribute to the production of the pot, but they are not included into the result. The potter, you know, at the end of the day takes off his apron and goes home. And there’s the pot sitting on the shelf or in the kiln or somewhere. You know, he’s not he doesn’t become a part of the result. He stands apart.
So does his wheel. His wheel remains there, all the tools. I could complicate this a great deal. We when we used to when I lived in Dharmasala, India, I went to a school called the Buddhist School of Dialectics, and we we used to debate a lot. Sometimes it’s called the Buddhist School of Dialectics, actually.
And, anyway, you think of all kinds of crazy possibilities. You know, what happened if they if they they if they cremated the the potter and made made some nice mud out of him and put him in made him and formed the pot out of him. Wouldn’t the potter be included in the pot? Anyway, we won’t go we won’t we won’t go there. That’s the kind of things they think of.
Anyway so so the the the the the the potter and the wheel and so forth, they all are they all are causes of the pot. They assist in their production of the pot. And they they they shape the pot. You know, they could have out of that wet wet lump of clay, the potter could have made a clay plate or a clay cup. You know?
But but no. He the potter made a clay bowl. So the the the potter chose, I’m gonna make a clay bowl. He he actually is a cause of of creating that pot, but he doesn’t he’s not included in the final result. He doesn’t become part of that pot, but he is a cause of the pot just as is the wheel is a cause of that pot.
So we know we have two types of causes, substantial cause and a cooperative cause. Okay. And and the necessarily have both a substantial cause and a cooperative cause. If one of them is missing, they do not arise. Okay.
So let’s take another example. Example of a flower. The the a flower grows from a seed. It grows from soil, moisture, sunlight, and so forth. These are all causes of the pot.
Not the pot, the flower, because they assist in its growth. If we don’t have seed, if we don’t have soil and so forth, normally, you know, maybe hydroponics or something, but anyway, we we don’t get the we don’t get the result. We don’t grow the flower. Okay? So they’re all causes of the pot.
The seed is the substantial cause of the pot. It is the chief material necessary for its growth, and it will determine the substantial identity of the result. You know, the fact that that it’s a flower and not a carrot or that it’s a sunflower and not a rose or a morning glory. Okay. Morning glory flower.
Okay. So the the the the the seed is of substantial cause, whereas the the water, the soil, moisture, sunlight are the cooperative causes of the flower. You know, they contribute to conditions necessary for the potential of the seed to be actualized. You know, if we had poor soil or if we had a lack of moisture, then you’re going to get a shriveled up flower or a stunted flower. You know?
So it depends so the the quality of the result very much depends upon that that that cooperative cause, the soil and water and everything and so forth. Okay. Everything in the universe is exactly the same. The production requires both a substantial cause and a cooperative cause. Okay.
That’s one concept. That’s one of our tools that we’re going to make use of, kind of establishing rebirth. Okay. The second concept. Everybody go along with me on all this?
You’re doing very very well. Do better than me. Second concept is similarity of type. If we state this simil simply, there is a consistent similarity of type between a substantial cause and its result. Okay, there’s a similarity of type.
For example, an apple tree grows from an apple seed. Okay. The apple seed is the substantial cause, and its result is an apple tree. And there’s a similarity of type. They’re both from from an apple seed, apple trees grow.
Avocado trees don’t grow. From from wheat seed, a wheat plant grows. An oat seed doesn’t grow. Not even something very closely similar, doesn’t grow. There’s a there’s a consistent similarity of type between the cause and the result.
From from ice arises from water. You don’t get ice from wood. People might produce bombs. They might produce works of art, but they give birth to other people. They give birth to children who are human beings.
They don’t give birth to sheep, lions, and so forth. Okay. All of these products involve transformations of a substantial cause within a continuum of a similar type. There’s a continuity between, for example, my parents and myself. There was a transformation.
Transformation. There was something which which was transformed coming from them, which determined my identity, and that is to say the sperm and of of my parents, and that came and determined myself. There’s a similarity of type, the fact that my parents were human beings, and I’m human beings. So this is consistent throughout nature. We depend upon this.
And otherwise, the world would be chaos, more chaotic than it appears to us most of the time anyway. So the continual production of all the various physical phenomena in the universe are simply recombinations or recyclings or transformations of previously physical, previously existent physical phenomena. Here, we’re talking about something really big, just physical phenomena in the universe. And where do physical phenomena come from in the universe? Material phenomena come from the universe?
They come from previous material phenomena, previous physical phenomena in the universe. There’s a similarity of type. All the all the, you know, all the various energies and the various elements and the energies would bind them together. So material entities are produced only from previous existent material entities. They neither arise from nothing.
Nowhere in all of nature does does a result arise from nothing, nor do they arise from a substantial cause which is dissimilar in type to itself, such as space. Space exists, but it’s not the cause of physical phenomena because it’s it isn’t this dissimilar type from physical phenomena. Okay. So these are the these are the two basic concepts that that we need to work with. Distinguishing distinguishing between a substantial cause and a cooperative cause and the concept of similarity of type.
And we’re going now we’re going to apply this to the ideal of rebirth to establish it. Now, the view of mechanistic science says that the body, that the mind arises from the body, or, or we can be more specific that the mind arises from the nervous system of the brain. That’s pretty, pretty much the assertion of, of modern day neurology or neuroscience and so forth. The mind is like what is called an emergent property. Like, water is said to be an emergent property from hydrogen and oxygen.
An emergent property is is interesting because you can’t it if you have oxygen, you know, if you combine oxygen and hydrogen in proper proportions, you get water. Given the the brain or the nervous system, you get mind. When the body dies, the causes for the mind cease. The body decomposes and returns to its natural elements, and the mind just kind of fades away like a rainbow. So essentially, this is the view the mind is viewed as matter and as physical phenomena.
They’re not quite sure what it is, but, essentially, what they’re saying is there is there only exist physical matter. The mind is essentially physical matter. It is a physical phenomena. Okay. I’d like to read a quote.
Okay. Some people would think of themselves as scientifically minded, believe that the mind is the brain or a function of the brain, and that for this reason, there is no essential mind matter dichotomy. And the mind this has been always this has been a problem in Western philosophy for since Descartes who who said there was mind and there was matter and never the twain shall meet. They’re they’re they’re distinct phenomena. And so he created an absolute dichotomy.
According to mechanistic science, there is no dichotomy. It’s simply the mind is simply material or a function of the brain or the nervous system. According to their view, everything can be explained in terms of the material world. They choose to overlook the qualities of the mind that have no relation to matter, such as such as subjective experience, thoughts, and emotions. Although they would not take seriously this the story of Pinocchio am I familiar with the story of Pinocchio?
Okay. Where a simple piece of a matter, a stick, inexplicably develops a mind experiencing hopes and fears, pleasures and pains, and so on. They would not find it strange if sub subatomic particles, atoms, or molecules started to produce thoughts and feelings. However, not only is there no scientific evidence whatsoever that such phenomena is possible, but it represents a semantic confusion of categories. Linguistically, there is the category of mind, and what is not mind, that is matter.
Matter or the world is that which exists out there beyond the senses. If it does not exist independent of the senses, how can it be categorized as material? How can a material world that exists outside the senses also be the senses that sense and experience it? Such a theory does not answer anything. It does not even begin to address itself to the question of what conscious experience is, let alone to the question of what might or might not exist external to it.
I know it just occurred to me when was reading that. I think somewhere, I think, Bertrand Russell, you know, one of the one of the great philosophers of the twentieth century said, all the the proofs which establish that the mind is material likewise established that all material are of the mind. You know, this idea of with monism, that there is only one. The the those of modern day science generally try to explain phenomena in terms that everything is material. And they and they, using all the reasons that you use establishing this can be likewise established that there is only one, but it’s all mind.
You know, it’s all the idea of idealism that there is no material world. It’s all in the mind. Buddhist cosmo Oh, okay. As we’ve talked about Buddhist cosmology, you know, studying the nature and makeup of the universe posits six types of elements. And we’ve talked about these.
We’ve talked about four of these types of elements, earth, water, fire, wind energy element, but they also posit space element or space, which is the absence of obstructive contact, and consciousness element, which is that which is clear and knowing. So all the, you know, all the multiplicity of phenomena, which constitute, which make up our universe are simply variations of these six elements, these six principles of forces in various proportions, in various in various designs or constructions. All of these elements each have their their separate continuum. And it is the association of the of the continuum of each of these, earth, water, and so forth, that in various proportions, various arrangements, which account for all the multiplicity of things in the world, whether, you know, people, whether it’s immaterial or material material things. So the nature you know, we talked about clear mind or clear light.
We said we said we said the the nature of mind is clear knowing. Clear means it has a separate meanings, but one of those meanings is nonphysical or nonmaterial. Thoughts, feelings, and emotions are nonmaterial. There there is they they all our various feel you know, cognitive states, our consciousnesses, eye consciousness, nose consciousness are all nonphysical, like space. They’re nonobstructed like space.
But they’re not space because space is not knowing. And sometimes the mind is compared to space because space is nonobstructive. But it’s distinct from space because space is not doesn’t have the characteristic of knowing. So now the the crux of rebirth, it comes down to one small little point. The question, from where does mind arise?
Are material phenomena the substantial cause of mind? In other words, is matter and energy the stuff out of which mind is made, or does mind come from a cause which is substantially similar in type to itself, such as a previous moment of mind? You know? Where does the first moment of mind come from in this life? That’s what the that’s what the crux of rebirth comes down to.
All phenomena in the universe, all products in the necessarily have cause. So, you know, the the let’s let’s look let’s look let’s look at let’s take the hypotheses. This is this is okay. The mind does not arise from nothing. Nowhere in all of nature does a phenomena, a product, rise from nothing.
Nowhere being a product, it must have a cause. Moreover, it must have both a substantial cause and a cooperative cause. Now that substantial cause must be of a similar type to that result. Physical phenomena are a dissimilar type to mind. Physical phenomena, the brain, the nervous system, the body is of a dissimilar type to mind.
The only phenomenon that is a similar type to mind and that therefore can act as its substantial cause is a previous moment of mind. The same holds true for physical phenomena, for physical entities. You know, the the they too necessarily have a substantial cause, and that substantial cause substantial cause must be similar in type to that result. The only thing which can act as a similar as a cause which is similar in type to a physical result result is a physical cause, a physical another physical phenomenon, a previous moment of another physical phenomenon. We cannot logically posit our first moment of mind, and we our first moment of physical phenomena.
Each must have a preceding cause similar type to itself, an infinite regression. So each each necessarily has a respective preceding moment of mind, in the case of mind, or a physical phenomenon in case of physical phenomena. There is no first cause. There is no first atom. And and also and likewise, there is no first moment of mind.
And moreover, these two are not convertible. You know, physical phenomena cannot convert into mind, and mind cannot convert into physical phenomena. You know, in Buddhism, we do we do assert the coming and going into and out of existence of universes. You know, the we’d Buddhism would would, you know, would very much go along with the present scientific notion of the big bang and eventually the big crunch when it all comes back together. But this is this is only a small segment of a process that has been created since beginning this time.
You know, this this creation and destruction of universes upon universes. Destruction of universes universes upon universes, you know, this recycling of universes as it were. So the we said that the crux of rebirth comes down to the question, from from where does mind arise? In answer, Buddhism would assert that the mind present at the moment of conception, you know, there is there is there is an ovum, there is a sperm cell which fertilizes that ovum. Now there is the presence from the point of view of Buddhism.
They would assert that at that moment, there is also mind. This constant where does that mind come from? It necessarily has a substantial cause. That substantial cause is a preceding moment of mind. That moment of mind was the last moment of mind of the previous life in the continuum of that individual.
Yeah? So you have the first moment of mind of this life. You have a combination of sperm, fertilized you have fertilized ovum in combination with consciousness. You have a body and mind essentially. What is what is what is where did that mind come from?
It didn’t come from from the brain. It didn’t come from any material substance. It didn’t come from nothing. It didn’t come from space. It must have a cause.
It must have a substantial cause. And moreover, that substantial cause has to be similar in type to itself, the only thing which can act as a substantial cause similar in type to that first moment of mind is a is the mind of a previous is a previous moment of mind. That previous moment of mind was the last moment of mind of the previous life of the continuum of that individual. So each, you know, this this is, you know, each each moment of mind, of an individual’s mind, arises in dependence upon a previous moment of mind. You’re present like, we we we all have a present mind, I suppose.
Okay. We that that moment has arisen in in a a stream of of a continuity of cause of arising, ceasing, giving rise to another moment of mind, giving rise to another moment of mind, giving rise to another moment of mind. If we if we if we we we investigate back, then your present moment of mind as as you as you’re listening to me with all its various attitudes, with all its various opinions and ideas and various potentials of the of your present mind as as we sit here, arose in dependence upon the mind that that, you know, tracing that back further and further on the mind you walked with walked in this room with. The present moment of mind is in direct continuity, a cause and effect relationship with that mind that you walked into this room with. That mind was in a if we trace back, was in a direct continuity, cause and effect relationship with the mind that you woke up with this morning, that you went to bed with last night, of of a week ago, of a month ago, of a year ago, you know, tracing back further and moment by moment by moment, replicating itself as a similarity of type, you know, with with with various subtle changes in the course of this continuity over this continuum of time, all the way back to last year, five years ago, ten years ago, when you were young, if you’re not young now, when you were a child, when you were a baby, when you were just when you were just born in the in in the womb, in gestation in gestation at the all the way back, back, back, back, at the moment of conception.
That mind also arose. And just like the present mind, in dependence upon a similar type acting as its cause of a previous moment of mind, the pre of the last moment of mind, of the previous life. That moment of mind arose in dependence upon a previous moment of mind. That that be of your previous life’s the being of your previous life in in their in their over the course of their life and back and back and back without beginning. The mind is there is a comp just as there is a con conservation of mass and energy in the universe, that the sum total of mass and energy in the universe is neither increasing nor decreasing, simply a transformation of what already exists.
Likewise, there is a conservation of mind. Mind is never newly created nor can it be destroyed. It changes the form. Just like, you know, there is a beginning to this table, and there will be an end to this table. This particular specific form which a material takes has beginning and end, but just with the notion of but that physical form, this continuum of that physical form is without beginning or end.
Likewise, our our the continuum of our mentality, of our mind takes, you know, various due to various conditions, through the various circumstances and so forth, various states arise. They cease. But do but the continuum of that mind is has no beginning nor has an end. We can trace back an infinite regression toward the beginning, and we can we can assert that it will continue without end. So okay.
Let’s let’s look at okay so far? A little bit? This is not to say so we have two continuums. We have a physical continuum constituted of our of our body and nervous system and brain. We have a mental continuum.
And these these are these are these are so the the physical continuum acts as a cooperative condition to the mind, but it is not the substantial cause of mind. Likewise, the mind acts as a cooperative condition of the physical continuum of the body, but it’s not the substantial cause of the body. That is to say, they’re interdependent just like the just like, you know, the potter and his clay pot. The the the the the the potter does not become does not enter into the continuum of the clay pot, but it does shape it. It causes it to be what it is.
Likewise, our mind is dependent upon the body. If, you know, if if we’re physically ill, we can’t think clearly. If we if our nervous system is damaged, the function of the mind is impaired. And the body does affect the mind, just like the potter does affect the clay in a specific form, in a specific manner. So the body and the nervous system are the cooperative causes of the mind.
They condition the mind, contribute to all the various states of the mind. You know, we looked at this in detail when we talked, we went through the dissolution of the body. You know, when the body is losing its ability to support consciousness, that it’s a it’s losing its ability to act as a cooperative cause for body, for the mind, and the various how this affected the mind. It does affect the mind. Likewise, the the the mind is a cooperative cause of the body.
The body depends and it’s affected by the upon the mind. You know, it’s like when we have psychosomatic illnesses, you know, when people have ulcers, when they worry a lot, it affects the body. Stress affects the body. Mental stress affects the body. The mind is a cooperative cause of the body, but it’s not the substantial cause.
The substantial cause of the body is the sperm and ovum from our parents. That’s the continuum, the physical continuum from from whence our body has arisen. Mind and body exist in mutual interdependence. They are they are one another’s cooperative causes, but they are not one another’s substantial causes. You know, be generally, in in you know, if if if you think that the the person is the body, you know, never perhaps actually I mean, we investigated, didn’t we?
I think, you know, maybe. Anyway, we’re supposed to. You know, when I say I, so what do I really mean? If one has never really investigated, one simply identifies the body with as the person. With the demise of the body, the person ceases.
And, you know, we never really have looked have looked into it, but we had never been our body. We have never been our mind either. So it’s not a matter of the you know, we could we we we let’s see. You know, just as the as the as the patterns of mind can change, You know, we can be happy. We can be unhappy.
And we the mind can change as we looked in in terms of just in the eight stages of dissolution from a coarse mind to a subtle mind to extremely subtle mind. And on that continuum of continually changing minds, you know, happy mind, unhappy mind, whether it’s dream mind, waking mind, sleeping mind, we we label I. We continually label labeling I. The I continues throughout throughout these all of these variations of states of mind. Likewise, with regard to the body.
You know? Some sometimes the body is strong. Sometimes it’s weak. Sometimes it’s healthy. Sometimes it’s sick.
And then even radical cases when it dies on so though the the this, the basis, the basis of designation, the physical designation is undergoing tremendous changes over the course of our life. Still, it still is the basis of designation of the I, continuum of the I continues on uninterruptedly. Does mind and body continually undergoing tremendous changes, radical changes at time of death, but even over the course of our life and on that basis, on this basis of mind and body, we’re labeling I, continuing. So, you know, we but we the mind the mind does the I does not come into it and go out of existence. It is a continuity which is being based which is being designated to this this continually changing base of mind and body.
Just, you know, it’s like a like a a like a, you know, like a a wave going moving across the water. You know? It’s the the the the the water the molecules of water are constantly undergoing change, but the form has some kind of persistence over time of the wave or like a candle flame. You know, it looks like a steady, thick, solid mass, but it’s from moment to moment, it’s changing, but it appears like a single form to ourselves. So there’s an example I wanna give.
Let’s see. Okay. I think I think we can do it. Okay. It’s it’s a pretty good example, I think.
It’s an analogy. Analogy. So, you know, in neuroscience, neuroscience would say that the brain is a substantial cause of the mind. That is to say that the mind, the mind is an emergent property of the brain. It is a function, a state of the brain.
And they would, they would, they would, they would support this assertion or this observation on, on using clinical and experimental neurological findings, you know, like, like, for example, this connection between various conscious processes and physiological processes in the brain. You know, if if we if we damage the brain, if we have concussion or contusions of the brain or or if we if the blood supply to the brain is restricted or if we lose consciousness, if we have a tumor in one part of the brain, it affects us. It is it’s it’s associated with particular changes of consciousness as compared with the tumor in another part of brain. That it affects our consciousness in totally perhaps in a totally different manner. So they, you know, they’re they’re quite specific, you know, by you by the quality by your actions, by interviews, by they can diagnose, and they can pinpoint where there might be a a tumor within the brain, for example.
You know, it’s affecting your your state of consciousness, the way you act, and so forth. And dependent upon that that that physiological change in the brain, it brings about changes in the state of consciousness and therefore in how you act and so forth. So this this, they can, and then, then they can go in there and they can actually correct a lot of neurological damage, you know, which caused physical, physiological problems, psychological problems. By removing the tumor, they can use chemotherapy, various drug therapies and so forth. So this represents the the main thrust of the argument of neuroscience that the brain is the substantial cause of the mind.
Why? Because by manipulating the brain, they can manipulate the mind, essentially. That’s what they’re saying, predictably. And if I probe here, particular consciousness will arise. You know?
They cut out this out, and there goes your your piano lessons. Poke this, and you feel happy. They can do that. So this say, oh, then then the brain is the consciousness. The brain is the substantial cause of mind.
So the we’re gonna look at this, the logical inconsistency of this position. You know, this is essentially maybe, you know, maybe what a neuroscientist would would assert in a way. And we’re going to use a simple analogy in that of a television set. So, you know, if we look at okay. So let me just re re go over that again, retrace that again.
The main assertion of neuroscience is that by manipulating the brain, by through drug therapy, by surgery, they can cause specific variations in the states of consciousness. Essentially, that’s what they’re saying. If I poke here, I get a particular consciousness. If I poke there, I get a specific get a different reaction, different type of mentality or a state of mind, different consciousness. Right.
Okay? If we if we take the we take as analogy in a television set, the the quality of the picture and sound is dependent upon the structure of the hardware of the television set. Now I’m not sure what’s in the television set, you know, these days especially. I have no idea. You know, you got these flat screens.
Anyway, usually, there used to be these big tubes, and there are, you know, all these, like, transistors. I don’t know if they use the transistors anymore. Transistors and lots of gadgets inside of parts. So depending upon whether all the are the all the hardware is there, all the parts are there, and they were in working order will will determine what kind of picture and sound you’re going to get from the television set. Okay?
If some of the parts are missing, if some of the parts aren’t working, parts are missing, if some of the parts aren’t working, then there’s good then this is going to lead to specific distortions of the picture and the sound. Now a good repair good repairman, television repairman, could diagnose the problem by the nature of the distortions. You know, he would he would, you know, okay. What’s happening to the picture? Oh, it’s it’s going like this all the time.
Or maybe there’s no picture, or maybe it’s the sound. There’s no sound, or it’s it’s just static. So he’s looking at all the distortions, and he knows that there’s some kind of correlation between those distortions and and what’s going on, you know, with the hardware of the television set, you know, that he can diagnose that, oh, you’re you got a bad transistor there. It’s gonna cost you a lot of money. Anyway, I don’t know what components that are.
Television. So he anyway, he he can diagnose it from just by observing the distortions of the television set. You know? And he can replace the hardware, and and it can repair it. You know?
And what okay. And would you agree with that? Now what but he would not conclude on the basis on the basis of being able to repair these distortions by replacing the hardware or, you know, middling the hardware, repairing the hardware in some way, putting new transistor in or or make it fixing a wire that broke or something like that, that that he would not conclude on the basis that that that the program is being created by that hardware. You know? You know?
That he would he would correctly understand that the integrity or the working order of that hardware is necessary for the integrity, a good sound and picture. Yeah. If the if the the hardware isn’t in good order, you’re not gonna get a good sound and picture. But he would not say that the television set is the originating source of those sounds and pictures. You know?
Like, you know, he would understand that the the television set is the basis of transmission of the sound and pictures. Not it is the sub it is the cooperative cause of the sound and pictures. It is not the substantial cause, which is a television signal from a studio, you know, many miles away. It’s not as if, you know, neuroscience in interpreting the their neurological findings, they would be forced to conclude conclude that the television set is the originating source of those sounds and pictures. You know, just like, like, like a computer can actually generate animated humans and it can generate a a human like voice.
You know? It that to say the source of that sound, the source of that picture is in the computer. That’s that the the the substantial cause the computer is a substantial cause of that animated human that you see on the screen or that that human like voice that you hear. But this is what this is what or the images that you see, the sounds that you hear. This is what neuroscience would would have to conclude since they are saying that the mind, that the brain is is the is the originating source.
What we’re saying is that just like, you know, that the the television set is the basis of transmitting, if that basis of transmitting is not in operating well, then obviously you’re going to get distortions of the sound and picture. But the writ but the source of the sound and picture is not is not the television set itself. It’s simply a supporting condition necessary to manifest actualize this potential of a signal which is coming from a television station, where there are actual people, actual speaking, and so forth, which is being transmitted. And on the end, this acts as a as a supporting condition, as a cooperative cause for the manifestation of this potential of the signal coming from from a television station. So the error is mistaking the cooperative cause, the television, for for a substantial cause, the television signal, you know, coming in the voices and images coming from his television studio.
Likewise, the error of neuroscience is in mistaking the cooperative cause, the brain, which is the basis necessary for the mind to actualize its potential for the substantial cause, which is the preceding moment of mind in determining what is the origin of mind. The neuro science is saying the origin of mind is the brain itself. Buddhism is saying that the brain is not the origin. It is simply the cooperative cause. The origin is a preceding moment of mind, the substantial cause.
Okay. So Does that all make sense? A little bit. Anyway, so that’s that’s some of that’s that’s like the the most one of the major tools of of use in the establishment, you know, of rebirth coming from you know, this is from Dignāgā, Vasubandhu, some of the great Indian masters use this use these notions to try to try to to establish rebirth. I don’t know.
It anyway, I think it’s it’s something to that we can think about. There is there is some reasoning there, some logic involved, and there is you know, there there is there is more scientific evidence in terms of for example, we talked about the conservation of matter and that. Anyway, let’s leave it at that. Okay. I’m gonna sit down there, and maybe we can have a we can discuss some of these ideas.
Okay? Or whatever you feel like bringing up. Are you hot? Would you like to turn on the air conditioner? We have a couple of yeses.
Would you Sandy, would you like to the next on the outside. So on the on your as you on your left hand side, if you press the white button and then you press you have to press two buttons. One button. I think it’s kick it. Does anybody have any comments or anything you’d like to share?
Yeah. The logic you were using, were with that logic, you were arguing that mind is, you know, beginning this and all the rest of it. Yeah. The The analogy is an an the terms you were using to my mind prove that the mind can’t be beginnings because you say or the logic you were using says that the everything must come from a like basis. A cosmic Yeah.
Therefore, for the mind to the universe will come and then you see it’s all gonna crunch down again. And scientists say that this happened a few times, many times other than that because they know how old the universe or the one before or the one before that. But so I’d like to say the the only reason I’m raising it is because the Buddha says that you must find a teacher, and you must test that teacher. You must test that teacher’s theories or statements with your own mind. Good.
Your own mind. What do you gotta say here? So what what what is your objection? Well, beginner’s mind has no beginning. K.
But your logic that you’re using contradicts that to one. Maybe I I was unclear when I said Buddhism accepts the big big bang, big crunch because But I’m just You can’t accept what I say. I’m just asking. How do you I hope I had a good date. No.
Don’t know you can just Okay. What do want to object? I’m not quite sure. What what I’m objecting to is the only way the clay pot could arise is it’s substantial and the whatever of the clay. Okay.
The right right right right Yeah. Therefore, it has to have a beginning. Even though the clay has disintegrated, gone back into the earth, reformed or whatever, and then the next part comes along Yeah. Takes it out and uses it again. So I said different states of mind can have a beginning and an end.
There’s no There’s no There’s no first moment in mind. There’s different states of mind, different begins and Okay? If mine’s never continued. Okay? Because we have different We have sets.
We have individual continue. Yes. Your continue was not mine. Absolutely. Absolutely.
Lucky for you. Yeah. However, because of all the karma, etcetera, our mind has has to write and all the rest of it that arise. Couldn’t it be said then that my mind, my continuum, okay, my mind is the same mind right away from the beginning, although there is no. My mind doesn’t change.
The only way it changes is because of the way karma acts on. Continuum of clear clarity and knowing. Right. Without the game, the way that’s manifesting, know, various states of of mind. Happy, sad, wise, ignorance, That does change over time.
Can we you’ve introduced tonight two new types of elements through Buddhist cosmology. Do you mind just describing those two again? So there’s one, the space element and the the clear Oh, yeah. The clear knowing. The space.
Okay. Space. Yeah. Which is the absence of destructive contact. The absence of the destructive contact.
The the absence of obstructive contact. Absence of what? Obstructive contact. It it allows for movement. If there wasn’t space in this room, it couldn’t move.
So yeah. So and then the so the the four elements we talked about before. I have noticed. And then the space and then consciousness which is defined as clear and known. That which is clear and known.
So that word clear is has different means. One of the means is non means it’s nonphysical and nonmaterial. That which is nonphysical and nonmaterial. The reason they add that is So, like, unconditioned space, nirvana, any negations negations negations are permanent. By permanent, I mean, they don’t arise in the depths of the causes and conditions.
So What’s a negation? Negation is like the nonexistence of elephants in this But that would be a result of causes and conditions because if no one’s let an elephant into his room, no one’s opened the zoo, and they climb down on a. And that’s the cause of no illness in his room. Isn’t it? Yes.
It’s independence. Thought two thousand years ago, we never come to the tree. They could be, couldn’t they? So the the the notion I maybe I’m I’m becoming I’m confusing you. The notion of what in in Buddhism Buddhist logic, permanence does not mean it doesn’t have an end or a beginning.
There are permanent phenomena which have beginnings and ends. Permanent phenomena which have no beginning and no end. Permanent permanent phenomena simply means it doesn’t arise in dependence upon causes and conditions. The nonexistence of elephant in this room does not arise in dependence upon causes and conditions. If we know if I came in this room, that that nonexistence would would no longer exist.
It would be nonexistence. It would be nonexistence. It doesn’t rise in the same way. Another time. And the only reason this is important is because nirvana is a a is a negation.
Cessation is a negation. Stopping. That’s the the afflictive emotions is permanent. It We don’t have to continually be creating it. It’s unconditioned.
It’s peace. Yeah. Basically, I’m just curious as to if at the moment of death, if we’re not wanting to give rise to grasping Yeah. Does that mean that I mean, you hear a lot of people who’ve been hit by a car, and then they just had that will to live and they knew they could die or they decided to hang on and they really wanted to live. Does that mean if we’re at a moment that we should let go of our will to live?
Is hanging on to that last little bit of will to live grasping or should we actually go? Know? Wow. Is it negative to try and want to live if you’ve been hindered? Is car accident a hindrance?
But I’ll be able to decide. The desire desire craving and grasping. Sorry? Craving and grasping. We have a desire not to not go out of existence.
Mhmm. I mean, we we can’t go out of existence. Yeah. But in fact, we have a desire. But craving and grasping will arise at the time of death.
Now whether you whether that craving and grasping is trying to get back to this life or not or not never embodied. So is it okay to let it be or should we be shutting it out and going and going? Not to come back to this life? No. I mean, if you’re in a moment, I mean, where you’ve got a choice.
You can either lie on your right hand side and put your yeah. Or you can go, I’ve I’ve got a strong will to live, and I’m gonna and I’m gonna beat this this time. What do you is it is it negative to be mustering that last little bit of will to live, or should we be gracefully like, would it be seen as craving or brass, and would it be a negative karma to be going out on him? Motivation. Yeah.
I always think just to survive in that side. Having said that, and it’s worried me for a long while, a friend of mine sorry. No. You. I mean, are gonna are you gonna address because she’s Yeah.
I’m in the same vein. Okay. It’s concerned me for a long while, many years, probably fifteen. A friend of mine was dying, and he had a daughter coming over from America, and I was trying to motivate him to stay around. So the daughters couldn’t when she got there, it was within, like, twenty four hours.
When the daughter got there, she would at least be able to say goodbye to her father while he was alive even though he wasn’t, you know, all there type of thing. Life And he did. He hum on, and I was talking to him. I said, you did really well, Fred. You, you know, you hum on.
These words have stayed with me ever since. It’s only since I’m going to put it, that it sort of made some sense. And he said, yeah. But what cost? And he wasn’t a Yeah.
Religious or sort of a bloke. I mean, believed in God, but, you know, he wasn’t just a yes at what cost. Where would he what are you supposed to have that? Well, what’s worried me is that he But is it and then comes to where you say, like, do you fight on, or do you let go? You know, I suppose the motivation would would be I mean, just talking about the will to live is the will to actually make the most of this life and birth as a human being.
You know? Whether it be to help others because we can do this, whether it be to further our mind. If if if if if if you had a good body, you know, this was a this was a this was an accident or something. So you had you had a long you know, you found some really rare conditions in this, you know, really unfortunate situation. You might not be you might not find this kind of situation again.
Who knows? So and and and it was just something that it wasn’t like you, you know, dying of cancer. You’re dying of. So if we talk to what what they call untimely death. It’s like there are certain classes.
We’re gonna we’re gonna go through that. And this this center painting is a depiction of the Buddhist universe. And within the desire realm we live in the desire realm. Just around the corner. They’re the same.
Because there there’s six levels. And then these six six levels, I mean, you get these people with near death experiences, and, like, the ones I’ve read about, they, you know, see the light. They’re going towards the light, and then they hear a loved one saying, don’t go. Come back. And their motivation they they know that they’re for a better time near the light.
This is, you know, simply find what they’re saying. They’re going for a better time there, but because of the love of their children and mother and father, whoever, they decide to come back, that would be belonging to your motivation. Like, you’re coming back not solely for yourself because you know your better life is in in front of you. You’re gonna come back to the old one because motivation is not to leave your loved ones or whoever’s calling you back to, you know, that might a negative comment to be grasping for that life as long as it wasn’t for something in in that life. As long as it was an attachment to something other than other than life.
I I mean, it’s what about if you grasp for her? My my family needs I’ve feeling that thinking that way might might leave us very quickly. I’ve just got I’ve got a feeling that there might be something if if death is that imminent, that there might be a way of thinking that might actually did you see that or something? Do both. Yeah.
So that yeah. You might just go beyond beyond that sort of way of thinking in words. It might be something about seeing the possibilities of death that might enable you to go with it, and you may or may not live. Right? Not live.
Right? Yeah. You might get to that straight away because I don’t know. I mean, I don’t know. I’ve just seen some people go.
They aren’t, you know, only family. And I’m still thinking they’re going to live here. Please have this aspirin or please have this operation. That by that. The fact that there is a process.
We’ve lived all our lives by a process to get to school, to get an education, get to work, get get a job, get a better job, etcetera. It’s all a process moving you along on the the road to life, and death is also a process. And there is a goal worth having at the end of that process even if you end up as in the hell realms. I mean, the Buddha was in the hell realms many times. You know, it’s something you can learn.
You you can carry on your education. And to me, I was very comforted by that. I don’t know. I but I was with my father-in-law when he died, and and he just said, you know, everybody’s fussing around with that. Said, just leave me be.
You know, just leave me be. And he’d spent many years in India as a boy with the Indian Army. You know? And, you know, so I suppose you might mix up a few things there, but, you know, just let me be. I just get weary.
Yeah. So the other thing I’ve you know, the best time to talk about death is why you’re alive and well, and that’s with everybody. You know? Like, us here and, you know, the singer.
Key terms in this teaching
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
- The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.