1 h 40 min · 10,540 words · 10 December 2007
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher continues a session on developing an awakened heart, first encouraging daily choices toward becoming a better person and motivation to benefit others. He then guides a meditation on equanimity, examining friend, enemy and stranger, and moves on to recognising all sentient beings as one’s mother, with reflections on rebirth and a mother’s kindness.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2007-12-10
Duration: 1h 40m
UUID: 84276e01-b58c-4afa-b61e-f1097076eb04
Words: 10,536
I am late. How is everybody? So we begin by adjusting our motivation. It seems important part of our practice is to continually coming back to thinking about or just considering for a moment stop speeding around and stop distracting ourselves from ourselves and pause and think about where our life is taking us. Is it in fact where you want to go?
And there’s a Chinese expression unless you change the direction you’re headed. Unless you change the direction you you likely end up where you’re headed. And is where you’re headed at the moment where you want to go? So into this process of continually checking up in terms of our priorities. What do where do I want to go?
What do I What kind of person do I want to be down the track? You know, five years, ten years from now. What would I like to be? What would I like to be doing? Quite often we just simply allow, we drift into those ways of being and doing which come to define us.
Circumstances push and we yield. And we end up, perhaps somebody we have never decided to be. You know, perhaps our greatest gift as human beings is our ability to make free and conscious choices. We’re only aware of, you know, freedom is not something which is given to us. It’s not something like you can keep in the bank and, you know, you can go to sleep comfortably at night thinking about how secure you feel.
Freedom, I think, is in exercising of freedom. It only exists when it’s used. And in this context, I think our freedom is to consistently choose the person that we want to be in all the various, you know, in the within little short term strategies, but also in terms of long long range strategies. You know, how what we would like to see ourselves represent to our values, which kind of resonate, which give give meaning to our life and purpose to ourselves and what we’re doing with this one crazy precious life of ours. You know, what can I do, even if only something insignificant, to take that little step today and tomorrow toward that person I want to be?
You know, we can make lots of long range plans, and they’re important. But, you know, life is very much lived in in the little incidental, almost seemingly insignificant events which are occurring every day. And that’s the way I think the place that we have to build a life, not in the dramatic moments as, you know, those don’t come very often, and perhaps we don’t always make the best choices. But, you know, the overall quality of, you know, we can make a habit of becoming the person that we want to be, just as we have formed the habit in the past of who we are now, you know, what you do now is what you’ll become. So it’s always the choice is always now and always coming back to that.
You know, I made these little choices that seem almost insignificant. It seems so minor. It seems so trivial. Like drops of water, maybe. After a while.
They can become a tremendous force. They can bring about radical changes. So in this process, the purpose of our life, you know, this orientation is we call it Buddha. It’s a good word. It’s can stand us in good stead in the sense that it’s the you know, just simply is a it’s a metaphor.
It represents. It stands in for all that we could hope to make of ourselves. What do we really aspire in in our finest, most noble moments? What we would like to see our life stand for, be a reflection of, when we could feel good about ourselves and respect ourselves and go beyond ourselves and be there for others in some real significant ways. We call that a Buddha.
And that we have to do some work. It’s, you know, it’s it’s fine, and it’s it’s inspiring to think in these ways. But then there’s the practical necessity of actually doing the work to bring about these these changes to be to actually make us the person that we want to be. And, you know, we use these various techniques, this educational process that we’re involved in, you know, these these teachings, our meditations and reflections, our discussions, you know, all the things. You know, it doesn’t have to be in a formal way, just the the the books that we read and the way thinking on the bus or driving home from work or whatever, the way that we talk to people and the things that we talk to people about.
Most perhaps most most succinctly, the truth of things, you know, the way things actually are, always trying to come to that. That’s a difficult that’s a life’s task, isn’t it? And it’s the truth which makes us free, which transforms us. And I’ve been going trying to go and go beyond, and it’s a it’s a it’s a tremendous undertaking, I think. I in that way, I think Buddhism demands a great deal of us.
It demands that we become a Buddha, the best of ourselves, that to go beyond this this set of fiction that we’re continually projecting upon other people and the situations and the things about us, the fantasy that we that we take for reality and the substitute life that we that that we we live. And, you know, working together, the Sangha, the spiritual community, you know, that’s us coming together in the ways that we do and supporting each other, supporting the circumstances by means of which we come together, Buddha House, acting as inspirations for one another and as good examples, I think that’s terribly important, isn’t it? Seeing someone over time you change for the better is inspiring, isn’t Seeing someone who isn’t isn’t as troubled as they once were, who who is beginning to not only working through their own problem, but you can see that they’re beginning to develop a new ability, you know, using their own material to be that they work through. And that wisdom that they developed along the line and and the ways that they cared for themselves being now being expressed and doing the same for others helping them to work through their material helping and caring for them and trying to you know trying to raise the level of motivation.
You know, if if we can develop the motivation just for that one person, you know, within your own, you know, right now within your mind’s eye, if you can just bring to mind one person that you’d like to be there for in some more significant way, a little more understanding, a little more caring, a little more patient, then everything that flows out of that motivation is going to act as an antidote to our general tendency towards self centeredness, exaggerated self concern, to thinking only of ourselves, which is the root of our problems. So that motivation and the directionality that you’re giving your mind through that into your intention, the why behind and the purpose for coming and listening to these teachings and discussing them and so forth is actually all of what we do acts as a as a a way to help ourselves, as an antidote to this tendency towards self centeredness. So, you know, I ask you, you know, just to pause, take the time to get in touch. It’s for you there’s some it’s for your your own good. It’s it’s just some kind of payoff in it.
You know, it’s not there’s no moral obligation or imperative. We’re not trying to be good boys and girls. We’re trying to help ourselves. And this is one way that we can, even at this immediate moment, you know, rather than thinking about, well, maybe tomorrow or the next day, At this very moment, we can help ourselves in a real substantial way by thinking of one other person. I’d like to be there for you.
And beyond all my own crazy mind and my own selfishness, in my better moments, I like to be there for you. I like to learn to be able to be better, to be able to be there more and more for you. That’s more of and more of the type of person I like to be, and I I like to develop some skills and some wisdom, some abilities to be able to to be a benefit for you. You know, something very immediate and personal, something very genuine. So though at this moment, I’m only, you know, sitting here listening to this silly fool talking on and on, and perhaps we’re going to have a discussion and do some meditation.
But nonetheless nonetheless, I’m doing it for you. Somewhere down the line, I hope what I’m doing now is going to be a benefit for you. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha through my practice of generosity and the other perfections.
May I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering.
May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Reverently, I prostrate with my body, speech, and mind, represent clouds of every type of offering, those actually arranged and imagined. I disclose all my negative actions accumulated during beginningless time and rejoice in all the virtues of superiors and ordinary beings. Please remain till the end of cyclic existence and turn the wheel of Dharma for migrating beings.
I dedicate all virtue, my own and that of others, to the great awakening. Awakening. So we’re going to meditate together. Going to meditate on equanimity. So we’ve discussed equanimity.
Equanimity is the foundation of this first meditative tradition for the development of an awakening heart, the seven cause and effect instruction. And we’re trying to develop an unconditioned regard for others as as as, you know, like, the psychologically even ground, creating the the open space where we our minds aren’t continually being buffeted by, you know, these emotions of attachment, aversion, and indifference. And a mind which is unconditioned with those reactive patterns of mind, and we’re going to within that space, that even mindedness, we’re then going to relate on the basis of a positive regard, of love. But as long as our mind is continually caught up, you know, in these reactive patterns of category categories, and then automatically emotionally reacting with attachment to friend to those we categorize as friends, aversion to those who we categorize as disagreeable people, enemies, and with indifference to the vast majority of others, those we consider strangers. There’s no there’s no way that we can really create the conditions whereby we can develop this unconditional positive regard.
There is no space in the mind. The and it is the mind is completely caught up in these appearances and all the emotional baggage which is attached to these appearances. So we’re going to work with this and, you know, some people, I try to talk about the fact of the difference between attachment and love. Quite some people see it as the same. Some people see attachment as something valuable, as a useful emotion, and so forth.
And here, attachment is the quality of fixating. You know, it’s clinging to an object, exaggerating its positive qualities, filtering out its imbalanced mind. It’s it’s it’s murky. It’s where it’s seeing not the individual, but our idea about the individual, and it’s relating in terms of that. And moreover, it’s relating in terms of what’s in it for me, and it’s not concerned with the other, which is, you know, has normal has nothing to do with love, does it?
Love is concerned with the other and the welfare of other, you know, bringing happiness to the other. So there’s a tremendous difference between the two emotions, though they might be they probably are mixed. We we generally have both toward the same person from time to time. And the, you know, the opposite is true of aversion. So we’re to develop, trying to see through these appearances.
You know, you know, if we if we look at the reasons that we give for why we are attached, why we call this person friend, why we this person is an enemy, and this person is stranger, you know, on the what do we keep seeing because of how they related to me. This person helped me. This person hurt me. This person hasn’t done anything to me. It’s always in terms of this me, of our self centered opinions, our neediness, our wants.
It’s always in terms of ourselves. In be on those basis, we we we label, we categorize, we make these judgments, friend, enemy, stranger. And then we we we habitually, automatically react with attachment, hostility, and indifference. So is it realistic to is it realistic to judge others on how they are relating to me? Are others really good or bad from their own side or from our side?
What are they in and of themselves? In and of themselves, all beings want to be happy. They don’t want to suffer. You know? That’s the nature of of sentient life.
Any any an emotional reaction based upon that reason is in keeping with the reality of the person from their side. That person wants to be happy. Therefore, the emotional reaction of love is justified. It’s it’s it’s it’s a reasoned reaction. It’s based in the reality of the person.
From their side, they want to be happy. Therefore, to wish them happiness is in accord with their state of being. And it’s a it’s, you know, it’s a way that we can relate with them in a realistically reasoned fashion. You know, how would how would these how would friend, enemy, and stranger, how would they appear to us if we stop discriminating them on how they relate to me? If you know, on terms of our own self centered opinions or our our needs and our wants?
If we if we stop relating, you know, how would these three categories appear if we if we cease discriminating, judging them, classifying them in terms of what’s in it for me, in terms of my self centeredness. We then we could really see them for what they are. Maybe for the first time, we could really look at our partner or our friend. What you know, maybe also the enemy and the stranger. So it allows a very you know, all everyone is an individual.
They aren’t categories. Categories are useful, but they overlook the uniqueness of the individual. Your partner or your friend or your your mother or your parent, they’re all individuals. And then Thich Nhat Hanh talks about sitting there and holding the hand of your of your mother or whoever and looking at them, looking into their eyes. It’s that it’s that it’s as if for the first time, trying to see them as if for the first time, not our idea about them.
And then trying to see the person, this person who wants to be happy and doesn’t want to suffer there in front of yourself. This real flesh and blood, imperfect, sometimes pain in the ass person that we have to learn how to love, to relate with in some kind of positive fashion. Not our ideals about them, not what it’s in it for me, but try to be see them for what they are. And, you know, who are who are we to you know, these appearances that we get caught up in. You know, who who who are we to be attached to?
Who are we to hate? One person gives us a gift yesterday and slaps her face today. Another person slapped her face yesterday and gives us a gift today. And who are you going to be attached to? Who are you going to feel aversion toward?
And they’re both exactly equal in the in the long term. They’ve done treated you. They related you in the exact same way. So I was trying to see that on the basis of a few reasonings, and these reasonings are are susceptible to change. The reasons we we make these classifications can change in the snap of just the snap of a of a finger, the the shape of the mood, you know, a smile or a frown, and causes these appearances to change, these friend, enemy, and stranger.
So not clinging so tightly to these labels, these appearances, and beginning to create some perspective on these appearances so that we don’t automatically relate in terms of these appearances with the emotional baggage that we we usually carried on carry it with us in how we relate whenever we use these categorizations. You know, trying to develop an an an even mindedness and unbiased attitude toward these three. You know, if you could see these three in terms of from their own side, they simply want to be happy. They don’t want to suffer. You know?
And not in terms of our own self centered opinions and judgments about them, our neediness about them, what they can do for us, but seeing their reality. That’s the reality. There’s a there’s a in in the Pali language, there’s a term called there’s a word called ata. I don’t know much about Pali, but I was reading about this word the other day. And ata means it has two meanings.
It’s a very it’s used it’s a very useful word. This was the word that Buddha used when he talked about the goal of the spiritual life. He said it was Ata, and it it is like good. It means good, but it also means the goal. The goal is good.
He said my my by my teachings bring about what is good for you. He didn’t at first, didn’t say Buddhahood or enlightenment or nirvana. He just said it makes it is what brings about good for you. Our goal is to be is good, what is good for us. So talking about these people the way that we do, you know, rather than seeing them in terms of what’s in it for us, perhaps we can see them in terms of what is good.
What is good for them and what is good for ourselves. It’s good for us to love. It’s part of our goal. You know, as I said last week, I think it was. Yeah.
You know, that it’s not so much that as adults that we we need to be loved, but more that we need to love. That’s good. That’s a goal. So okay. I’m carrying on.
Would you like to stand up and stretch for a moment, then we’ll meditate? So I’ll explain the meditation equanimity, and then we’ll we’ll do it. In the meditation equanimity, we’re going to imagine on your right side, we’ve gone through this last week, I believe. On your right side is someone, you know, that you naturally care about, that you like a great deal, that you love a great deal, you feel close to. On your left side in front of yourself is someone, a disagreeable person, you know, someone you have some problems with, you don’t like.
And then the middle is a stranger. Okay? Someone you feel indifferent toward, don’t have much feelings for in any particular way, as if they don’t matter. And we begin to question, well, why do I why do I why does this why do I label that person as my friend, as my as the person who I care so much about? You know?
What what kind of reasons? And we we begin to supply the various reasons. You know? Maybe maybe they helped me or they said they gave me something. So you begin to develop going through these reasons and develop this sense of closeness, you know, like, you really begin it’s almost you want to, you know, bring them close to you, like, almost hug cuddle them, hug them, hold them close to you, and try to get a sense of that appearance of how they’re appearing so positive, exuding a a sense of desirability from their side, a sense of loveliness from their side, and a sense of goodness from their side.
And that that’s where it appears, and you want to bring that close to you. And then then but then we’re going to introduce some contrary reasons, you know, thinking about some time when this person hurt you, when they said something that harmed you or you didn’t like or they treated you in a way intentionally or unintentionally, which which made you feel bad or they they didn’t do what they said for some reason. And then they’re gonna try to get a sense of how that appearance begins to change. We want to develop the ability to not to cling to these appearances automatically as we now it’s almost like a knee jerk reaction. With the appearance, we react with the specific emotion.
If you begin to develop develop the skill around not in which you create some space and not automatically reacting to these appearances with these, you know, these these most these emotions which are normally associated with them, You begin to have a sense, you know, this person, appearance, their lovability, their desirability, their likability, all their goodness can can begin to radically change. Your mind just supplies a few reasons. On the basis of the reason, the appearance changes. So you you you begin you you don’t fixate like you did before. In a way, that’s what that was a characteristic of attachment, fixating and clinging to an appearance.
It’s but it moreover, it’s an appearance that you’re actually projecting. We begin to see how these appearances are susceptible to rapid change, and we don’t quite there’s not the quite the the the the enemy. You know? What are the reasons I hold this person to be such a I don’t like this person. I I hold them in this way.
I put them in this classification. I judge them in this way. You know, maybe they we we we supply it. Maybe they did something, said something to me, and so forth. And then then we do the contrary, having having a sense of that, how they’re appearing to you, and supply some other reasons, the contrary reasons, how this person harmed you, how they hurt you.
I know. Whether if you can’t think of it in terms of your of your present history with this person, you know, you can imagine what they might do, what they could say, and gain a sense of how that appearance changes. And, you know, and then what could they do to to make you feel good about them, to maybe they could help you, give you a gift, say something kind, and try to get a sense of how that appearance changes. You know, you begin you don’t you don’t get so caught up, so fixated upon appearances. You begin to develop this you begin to see how these appearances can fluctuate just on the basis of a few arbitrary reasons.
I can almost play with appearances. And so we don’t we don’t take them as as imbue them with a reality as we once did, as as as coming from their own side, as so concrete, independent of my mind as we normally do. And so we don’t automatically react to them with the same emotion intensity as we do. We’re giving them to create some kind of space, some we get some kind of perspective. In that perspective, we’re going to allow we’re going to we’re going to try to create love, and that space that we’re creating between our habitual emotional reactions to appearances and those appearances.
In that space, we can begin to cultivate love and compassion on the basis. People can still appear as enemies, but we can learn how to love them. We can we can create that way of relating even if the appearance remains the same. And with this indifferent person, you know, why is it you they don’t matter to you? You know, they haven’t helped you.
You know, it’s always in terms of me, isn’t it? They haven’t helped me. They haven’t hurt me. They haven’t done anything to me. But what if they did?
And what happens when you begin to supply some other reasons? Positive first or negative. You begin to play with these eye these you know, they they smile. They give me a gift. All at once, they appear very lovable, desirable, friendly.
I I no longer emotionally relate with them the same way. So we we developed a skill around these appearances. The appearances aren’t going to aren’t will be there, but we don’t automatically relate to them in the same way. We’re creating some kind of space. We don’t fix it fixate upon either any of these three categorizations.
And on that foundation, we we can develop a more even minded attitude. And in that space of unconditionedness, a way of looking at these three categories without being conditioned with aversion, attachment, and indifference, we can begin to foster some new, more positive way of relating to all three equally with an even minded, unbiased attitude. Okay. So take a firm, comfortable posture. We’ll begin by relaxing the body, beginning at the crown of the head, the scalp, the forehead, feeling the wrinkles in your brow beginning to smooth out.
The pressure in and around your eyes diminishing. The muscles of the of face softening, relaxing. Your jaws relaxed. Moving to the muscles at the back of the neck, perhaps gently turning your head to each side. So gently loose loosening, stretching the muscles at the back of the neck.
And moving down, relaxing the muscles of the throat. The upper back and shoulders perhaps, rotating your shoulders a few times, lifting them, allowing it to drop comfortably to the sides, and just feeling this this weight, this burden moving down and through your body into the ground. You’ve been carrying quite a burden over the course of the day. Now you can let it go. You can drop it.
Moving all the way down to your hands, your hands are loose and soft. Relaxing your lower arms. Your upper arms. Your chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area and the lungs, the central region of the back.
Stomach. Releasing the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, allowing your belly to go soft. Relaxing throughout the abdominal cavity. Your lower back muscles, buttocks, throughout your upper legs, your lower legs. And your feet.
Now bring your awareness to your body in general, perhaps roughly moving through your body from the crown to your toes. If you come across any tightnesses, any tension relaxing those areas consciously, feeling the tightness loosen, tightness diminish, tension diminish. If you come across some area of discomfort accepting it, not resisting or struggling against it, just allow it to be there and breathe into it with a sense of acceptance and kindness, a gentleness with where you’re hurting. Feeling sense of physical well-being pervading every part of your body. Just be with your body.
And we’ll practice the six part breath exercise. Just breathe breathing in normally comfortably breathing out extending the exhalation forcing all the air out of the lungs again breathing in normally comfortably again extending the exhalation doing this six times Having completed that, bring your mind to the breath. Easy, gentle, in and out flow of the natural breath. If it’s helpful, use the techniques of counting and noting the breaths. So now we’re going to meditate on equanimity.
So imagining on your right side in front of yourself is someone that you like, someone who you might is a friend or but someone you care a great deal about. If you can’t see them, it’s not so important, but just feel that this person is there. The feeling is most important. On your left side is someone you a disagreeable person, someone you don’t like, someone you we might call an enemy, but just a disagreeable person, a problematic person. And in the middle, we’re going to have a sense or just a feeling that there’s a stranger.
And first, we’re going to look at the person on your right. And why is this person so attractive to you? Why why do you like them so much? Why why do you see them as a friend? Come up with some various reasons thinking, which justifies this way of looking at them.
Some of the reasons for holding this person as a friend. Do they usually involve how they’re relating to me? What they’ve done for me? How they’ve helped me? Is it always in accordance in relationship to yourself?
What is the nature of the reasons? Is it always in terms of yourself? Self? And we’re going to think in the opposite. We’re going to think sometimes when they related, when we felt them to be an enemy, the same very same person, when they hurt you, when they didn’t get do what you wanted them to do for all the various reasons.
So supply yourself looking back in your history or imagining ways that they might hurt you or they have hurt you. How does their appearance change? They don’t feel so comfortable putting in the box of friend. They can’t quite put them back in that classification. To the same person.
And just look on your left side, look at the enemy, the person you find troublesome, you have some problems with. And one of the reasons so problematic that you see them as an enemy, you put them in that box. How do they appear to you? Unlikable? Something about them is just not very attractive.
So what were some of the reasons? What was the basis of the aversion? Was it always in terms of me? They hurt me. They didn’t give me what I wanted.
They didn’t do what I wanted. Now, I’ve now supply some contradictory reasons, some opposite reasons. If you can’t if you don’t have the history, then just imagine that this person helped you, said something kind, gave you a gift. Notice how their appearance changes. They kind of brighten up a little bit, a little more attractive.
Same person, but they appear differently. They don’t quite fit into that box of enemy as comfortably as they did before. Let’s take a look at this person in the middle. This stranger, the one who doesn’t matter. Why don’t they matter to you?
Why do you feel indifferent? What are the reasons? They haven’t given me anything. They haven’t done anything for me. They haven’t hurt me.
They haven’t helped me. It’s always me. Supplies some contradictory reasons. Imagine the same person helping you, doing something nice to you, giving you a gift, smiling, making you happy. How does their appearance and your reaction to that appearance change?
So just just get a sense of these three people together. You know, this magic let’s have a sense that they’re there, these three types of people. And from their side, they equally want to be happy. They equally don’t want to suffer. No difference whatsoever among those three people there in front of you.
Whether they appear as friend, they appear as enemy, whether they appear as stranger, From their side, their reality is they want to be happy. They don’t want to suffer equally. No difference. Exactly the same. All three.
We lose sight of their reality and we relate with them in terms of our self centeredness, what they do for me. And we classify them and we habitually and automatically react to those appearances with attachment, hatred, and indifference, which has nothing to do do with them. It has everything to do with us. And then bring your mind back to the breath. And get in touch with your body and perhaps the pressure of your buttocks on the chair, the cushion, feet on the floor, positions of the various parts of your body.
Just get in touch with the sensations and feelings within your body. And then in an easy and relaxed manner, slowly become aware of your surroundings, connecting up with the room, taking your time. Okay. So we’re with this, the first of these two traditions to develop an awakened heart. I think, you know, the you know, Buddhism is quite vast and profound result, various types of exotic practices.
But I think there’s there’s lots we can do, but I think there’s nothing more beneficial than simply to try to develop a kinder heart. You know, what is the Dalai Lama say? My religion is kindness. So this is very much what we’re talking about. We’re going to develop in dependence upon six causes.
Result, which is the awakened heart. So beginning with sequence of six causes, we’re going to try to recognize all sentient beings as our mother, remember their kindness, develop a gratitude which wishes to repay their kindness, appealing love, great compassion, exceptional resolve, and then which leads to the result of the awakened heart. So beginning with the first of these, recognizing all sentient beings as our mothers. This is a difficult tradition, think, it’s a challenge. Phabongkhapa Rinpoche, one of the greatest of twentieth century, early twentieth century Tibetan masters said, this graduated path, the sequence of the stages of realizations working all the way up to awakening that we’ve been working through.
The two most difficult are one, to see your teacher as a Buddha, and two, to recognize all sentient beings as your mother. The two most difficult it’s more difficult than emptiness. So if you feel that’s a challenge, you’re you’re quite right. We’re trying to come to a recognition that every living being has literally, not figuratively, but literally been our mother in the past. You know, we we we we talked about rebirth.
I think when we we discussed when we were talking about the wheel of conditioned existence. We said in this that we said that all products, this table is a product, this building is a product. I’m a product. My body is a product. That all products are dependent upon two types of causes.
One was a substantial cause, and the other was a cooperative cause. There is always a similarity of type between the substantial cause and its result. And this is one of the one of the most one of the basic reasonings behind the proof of rebirth. That the within nature, there is always a similarity of type between cause and effect. That there is, you know, fire, let’s see, water ice comes from water, and smoke comes from fire.
An apple tree comes from an apple seed. There’s always a similarity in time between its principal cause and the result, and the same holds to mind. If we trace back our mind at the present moment and as we sit here now, it’s it it is in cause and effect relationship with the mind that walked into this door at seven fifteen approximately. That mind, we could trace back moment by moment, cause and effect relationship, a continuum of replicating moments of mind back to, you know, this morning when you woke up. We could trace that mind back to when you went to sleep last night.
We could trace that mind in an uninterrupted continuum continuum of cause and effect moments back to last year, ten years ago, twenty years ago, when you were a child, at the moment of birth, the mind within the mind within the fetus in the womb, all the way back to the moment of conception, the first moment of mind in this life, that mind too had a similar cause, had a cause which is similar type to itself. It the cause of that mind at the present at the moment of conception was the last moment of the mind of the previous life. An unbreakable continuum, just like from the present mind to that mind in the fetus. Yeah. There’s not a break in that continuum.
One mind rising in dependence upon the previous mind. And that mind that mind at the moment of conception, it also rose in dependence upon a previous mind. And that was the last moment of mind of the previous life. And that mind rose in dependence upon a previous mind, tracing back with infinite regression from life to previous life to previous life to previous life without beginning. Mind only arises from mind.
It doesn’t arise from nothing, nor does it arise from a cause which is dissimilar in type to itself. The same holds true for matter. Matter does not arise from nothing. It only arises from a cause similar in types for itself. We can never posit our first moment of an atom, of matter in the universe.
It is beginningless. And likewise, with regard to our mind, it too is beginningless. Each of our mental continuums is without beginning. Over the over the course of this infinitely beginningless mind, we’ve taken infinitely beginningless rebirths. Just as we took rebirth as a human being in this life, we’ve taken infinite rebirths in the past.
And just as we had a mother in this life, we’ve had infinite mothers in these previous past rebirths. At the moment of our death, when we talked about the wheel of life, the wheel of conditioned existence, we have these karmic seeds within our mind, which give directionality to our mind, which these seeds are activated at the moment of a death by craving. Craving is the cooperative cause, activating, giving our mind some kind of impulse, impetus to reassociate itself with the new gross embodiment. So, you know, what what we what we want to this this we want to develop a sense. We don’t we can’t the the basis that all sentient beings have been our mother can’t be developed on the basis of thinking of the eye of Jampa, this person sitting in front of you or the person sitting where you are.
On that eye, we that that doesn’t make sense to try to develop it on the basis of this eye, this particular eye. We have to develop a sense of what is called a mere I. There is a con an unbroken continuity of subtle most energy in combination with subtlest mind. We’ve talked about this in the past. Okay?
This this this subtlest mind is us. Why is it us? Because it has our whole karmic history encoded in it. You know, our our these karmic seeds that we’re continually creating by our various by what we think, by what we say, by what we do. It leaves an impression upon this mind.
So it’s thus, is your mind is not my mind. It’s a very distinct mind. It has its own predispositions, its own tendencies, its own capacities, its own karmic history. So it’s a distinct mind. So we have this subtle most energy and subtlest mind in a in a in a continuum of replicating moments.
On this on on on on on this basis of subtlest mind, subtle body, we label I, person. This is the the simplest basis for labeling a life. What what constitutes life? Mind. On that basis, we can label I person, not person, I in sentient being, living being.
On that basis, we can that’s that’s the continuum. That’s that is the thread through it all. Due to craving, this subtlest mind and energy will reassociate with a gross embodiment, you know, like that of a human. It reassociate it enters it enters into the fertilized ovum of a of a human being, of a of a female. It it it connects with that engrossed embodiment and develops.
But eventually, that the karmic bond, which is sustaining that connection between the subtlest mind and energy and its gross embodiment will weaken. The body dies. The body simply perishes. It decays. But the subtle most energy, this what we’re labeling I, continues on.
And due to the force of craving, it will again reassociate with new embodiment, maybe of a dog. Then then we can label I on the dog. When the karmic bond between the dog gross embodiment and the subtlest energy weakens, finally breaks, the dog dies. The body decays. But this continuum of subtle most energy and subtlest mind, which leaving eye continues on, there is this continuity of I.
It will go on to, again, re embody. But then grows the body of a human, perhaps. Jampa, a particular I. I am this particular I. Jampa, you know, I was born in where was that born?
Bell, Ohio, United States. You know, I have this particular eye. But that particular I, Champa, which I’m labeling on this gross body and mind, eventually will will cease. It will it will decay. But but the but the subtle and most mind energy, which is associated with that particular I, what we’re calling the mere I, will continue on.
So there’s this continuum, this endless thread from beginningless time backwards and forwards, which we’re calling the mere I. And it’s we’re gonna get a sense of this mere I. I’m I am a particular moment, a particular embodiment of this mere I. I I I this is why I can say I took rebirth as a as a dog or I took rebirth as a human. This because of this continuity which which we can label I is being reassociated again and again.
So it’s on dependence upon this, getting a sense of this I, at which I am a particular instant of, you know, like a wave on this ocean, an expression of. All sentient beings have had a relationship to that mere I of that of a mother. And over the beginning of this time that this mere I has been going through this process of association, disassociation, reassociation, connecting up, disconnecting, reconnecting, infinitely again and again over in during beginningless time. Every sentient being in the web of, you know, interrelatedness of all sentient life life has been as acted as a mother, has existed in relation as a mother to this mere I. Every sentient being has related to this mere I as as our own mother at some time in the infinite past.
Literally, we have been born to every sentient being. There’s no person we can point to and say, this person has not been my mother, literally, at some time in the past. You know, all the various people, you know, whoever you might see, you know, you each person in this room has been has been my mother, has been each of our mothers, has been our brothers, our sisters, you know, all the various types of ways we’re relating over infinite time, infinite numbers of time. You know, in in spite we we have a sense of unrelatedness with vast majority of beings in spite of that sense. In fact, everyone has been our own mother.
Relationships, even in the course of this life, aren’t static, you know, continually changing, even in course of a single lifetime. So every birth is a rebirth, you know. We’ve been dying. We died in a previous life and we died in a previous life to death, died in the previous life, we were born into life after life after life. So when a meditator tries, is trying to meditate on recognizing all sentient beings, it’s important that you have it that you try to have a sense that you’re not developing on the basis of this I, this particular ego, Jampa, but on this this sense of relatedness to this mere I, which constitutes me.
You know, one of the great master Atisha once said, he saw a saw a horse that was injured, and he screamed out, my mother’s hurt. My mother’s hurt. And that that was said to be his expressed his realization that all sentient beings were his mother. Okay. Recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mother.
Takes a lot lot of work. Okay? Now we’re going to begin to remember their kindness. You know, this has you know, it’s not sufficient that we simply relate even if we were to have a sense of relatedness to others as being our mothers. We want to develop even as profound as a relatedness as that of a mother and child.
You know, we have we have to nourish this connectedness, this this profound relationship of mother and child. You know, we have to reestablish the meaning and profound psychological associations that this sense of relatedness once held for us. You know, over time, we lose that sense of what our mother meant to us at one time. Each of us is a human being and thus possesses human life, and human care is literally vital to that life. Mere mechanical or hygienic care is not enough to sustain either physically or psychologically.
When human attention, warmth, care is deficient or absent, we perish. The more quickly and surely the more vulnerable we are. And that death in such a context is first and foremost an existential death, a dying away of the will to live, and that paves the way for physical death. You know, it’s it’s difficult for us to imagine ourselves as we once were, you know, you know, that what it must have been like to be completely vulnerable, completely defenseless. You know, we but, actually, we were at one time.
You know, we’ve you know, when you see a baby and and without its mother’s constant care, that baby would perish, would die. It’s completely vulnerable. It cannot take care of its you know, now we feel like we can take care of ourselves. We feel invulnerable. We feel, you know, we don’t need anybody.
We feel tough. But there was a time when when we were our our our our life life was literally dependent upon somebody taking care of us almost hourly, every day of our life, every day of that child’s life, that baby’s life. When we first come into the world, we are utterly dependent. Without food, physical care, emotional sustenance, we cannot grow. Emotional connection is such an important feature of our survival that babies taken in care but given no love and personal attention cannot sustain life.
They give up and die. Whoever cares for us first is most consistent and most consistently, usually our mother, becomes our psychological umbilical cord. We depend upon her for our very existence. We are merged with her and have no sense of where we begin or where she ends. What she gives us emotionally forms a very essence of our personality.
Her love and attention is an essential food that builds our personality. It is as important as the physical nurture we receive to develop our bodies. She fills our upper world and our first experiences pleasurable and painful take place in an emotional context in which she has created. We are enraptured by her, fascinated by, and very much need her. You know, when when our mother tenderly took us into our arms and, you know, lovingly held us to her breast, And we felt her warmth, and we felt her very life essence flowing into her body when we nursed at her breast.
And that there’s probably no greater bliss that we as ordinary human beings ever experience in the course of our life in that moment of merger. You know, you know, when when it it’s said that when a yogi has direct realization of emptiness, their their their mind merges with a greater reality. The the the the emptiness of all phenomena in the universe. But and their their their their heart is filled with a a joy or bliss beyond ineffable, indescribable joy and bliss. But if they had never meditated, if they had never cultivated cultivated the sense of bliss of the merger with their mother, they would have never been have been able to open up to that greater bliss of the merger with infinite reality.
Their mind would never have been prepared for such a state. You know, how many of us how many of us have ever felt thoroughly loved? You know, not for what not for what we, you know, what we give or for what we withhold or what we do or don’t do. But how many of us have ever felt a love a love which can never be earned, you know, which for which we can never make ourselves worthy or or deserving for because it is it is we are worthy of that love simply for the fact that we are, that we exist, that and it’s just our very existence makes us intrinsically lovable, worthy of love being loved. Intrinsically lovable, worthy of love being loved, unconditional love.
Not baby can’t do anything. It can’t it can’t repay. It can’t ask. It can’t say, please. It can’t entertain us in the way that we try to attract the good things that we want from others for ourselves.
It’s you know, it is but it’s simply despite its very existence. We it is shown love. It doesn’t have to it cannot earn a mother’s love. It there’s no way it can, but it’s given love nonetheless. You know, a baby is is completely vulnerable, helpless.
It’s it’s only in need, and it has no way of earning its mother’s love. It’s remarkable, isn’t it? It can’t there’s nothing that it can knowingly do to to to to return that love, to return that attention that it’s given to. You know, it’s constantly in need of attention, protection. It it, you know, it it can’t earn that protection.
It can’t earn that attention. It’s totally oblivious to the physical and mental hardships and difficulties that it places upon it, its mother, who sustains it in life. You know, we we in this we we come to take for granted what all that our mother had once gave us at one time, you know, a time that we cannot remember at present. And and somehow somehow we we we feel deserving of all that we get, you know, all the pain and difficulties that we that we brought to our mother from from the very first moment subsequent. You know, just thinking about from the very first moment subsequent to her awareness that she’s been pregnant, and that that there’s conception in her womb.
From that very moment, her mind more and more turns her attention to us. You know, we’re just we’re just a clump massive cells, nothing more than that. But, you know, we we we amazingly, still, we we become the object of our concern. You know, we’re just these bunch of cells, but still her attention is again and again paid to ourselves. This is who we are.
You know, how can a mere mass of cells, you know, command the right that we we become the central object of her concern? How can a mere mass of cells command the right that we that we bring that we threaten our mother’s health? The all the discomforts of pregnancy and labor and birth, you know, all the morning sickness, and there’s a possibility of death in in the birth itself, you know, completely helpless. And indeed, we come naked into this world. You know, how could we rationally think that anyone after hours of labor, the pain involved, could take us lovingly into their arms and forgetting all that went just before and hold us to her.
And we as if we were the most precious thing in all the world. And then forgetting all the pain and the discomfort, everything that’s gone before, that only only just seen as as the most lovable. You know, this this is like she’s like this treasure holding ourselves to her. You know, how can you deserve that? How can you earn that that kind of attention, that kind of caring?
And then then no way you can, but it’s freely given. Each of us experienced that. And all the years that follow out of that, you know, after that, you know, all the the the selfless giving that mothers do for their children, you know, the constant concern for us, you know, years of feeding us and cleaning us and clothing us and and educating us and years of you know, hundreds of times a day, our our mother turned her attention to us. Her concern was on us. Her worry was for us.
Our needs, you know, our wants, a hundred times a day, protecting us from from many types of a hundred times a day, you know, putting our welfare before her own. And then she she fed us. She cleaned us. She washed us. She played with us.
She held us. She sang to us. You know? She she provided us what what she could. She, you know, a complete environment of safety and protection for our well-being.
She, you know, she worried over us. She she she went to sleep without sleep sometimes for us. You know, she gave up she gave up a significant part of her life, you know, for this person you are now. There’s a there’s a Japanese haiku, which says, wild persimmons, the mother eats the bitter part. You know, they you know, like eating the burnt shop.
That’s the Australian version. You know? That’s the part that the mother usually eats and gives the gives the best to the to the child. You know, out of our infant you know, we have the idea is to try to get come to to reconnect with some of these primordial feelings, this this bond that was once there between you and your mother. You know, out of our infant out of our infant eyes, our mother was was our world.
And that we we you know, to to I think, you know, to to nurse at her breast was bliss. To to hear her nearby was all the security that we needed to feel safe in the world, to be cuddled by her, you know, with all the comfort that we needed in order to, you know, to go back out there and face all the dragons of our life, you know, that we were going to have to face in beginning to explore our world. We’d always run back to our mother when the dragons got too dangerous for us. Motherly love is the most frequent and most readily understood instance of productive love. During the birth of the child, the mother’s body labors for the child and after birth her love consists in her effort to make the child grow.
Motherly love does not depend upon conditions which the child has to fulfill in order to be loved. It is unconditional based only upon the child’s requests and the mother’s response. No wonder that motherly love has been the symbol of the highest form of love in art and religion. The Hebrew term indicating God’s love for man and man’s love for his neighbor is, the root of which is, warm. So, you know, is the complete faith in utter dependency of the child and it’s absolute trust that enabled Christ to, when he was on the cross to say, father, into my into thy hands, I commend myself.
I commend my spirit. And to be able to to be able to let go into a greater reality and having that trust. And then this is what we learned as a child, as a baby, and we once learned it. You know, it’s that it’s this is the womb from which a bodhisattva is born, which empowers a bodhisattva to be able to dedicate their life toward others, toward all mother sentient beings. This this womb of unconditioned love that we all experience, this this profound primordial connection that we all experience at some time with all of every sentient being.
Yeah. There’s there’s a story about you know, this is a Tibetan story, you know, with with bandits and swords and everything. And this and this one, during the course of there’s a robbery that took place. A mare who was in foal was she was cut along her side, and she fell. And her unborn foal issued from her womb.
And even in the mares as the the mare was dying, even in her death throes, she was licking the embryonic fluids from her dying foal from the fetus. And it said that the, you know, that this gesture, this this that even in such the last moments of her life, her attention to turned toward her young, so captivated. And so the the bandit was so impressed that it became a life changing experience even for him, even some for someone whose heart was so hardened to see motherly love expressed in that way. But, you know, over the course of our life, you know, the our our our our feelings begin to gradually dry up in one way or another. You know, the, know, the feelings of this primordial bond beyond our thinking, beyond our they begin to become eventually displaced with demands and expectations, kind of ultimatums.
And as slowly, our hearts begin to close, and they begin to form a kind of a hard shell around ourselves, around our own heart, a hard shell of self centeredness around our own hearts. You know, we begin to play the the the game of calculated love. You know? Our relations become transactions. Like, you know, the the mentality of debits and credits.
If I do for something of you, get some credit. If you if you do something about me, well, I have a debit. I have to pay you back. And this is, you know, this is the business of getting along in life, the practicalities of life. So we’ve forgotten what it felt like to to be to be loved for no other reason than that we exist, that we can’t earn that love.
There’s no way that we can manipulate the other to love us in that way. You know, we’ve forgotten how it felt to be intrinsically lovable and to be loved unconditionally. At some time, we all were. You know, all the love and all the all the kindness that was showered upon us constantly. And now having lost that feeling of our own existential worth, you know, we we we are we are unable unable to feel the same for others.
How they are simply worthy of our love simply because they are life for no other reason. And therefore, we cannot love ourselves. We are unable to love even ourselves. We have to earn our own love. We have to meet some kind of standards.
We have to fulfill some kind of criteria even to like ourselves. And then we can we just can’t love ourselves simply because we are. So remembering the kindness of our mothers is is like meant is to be like opening a wellspring of emotions and feelings associated with it. It’s meant to it’s it’s like a trying to a vivid reexperiencing of a long forgotten event and all the long displaced and repressed feelings that surrounded that event. I’ve been a baby completely unconditionally loved at some time in the past.
So getting in touch with these primal feelings, all these mental all these images and memories, you know, and reconnecting to this this fundamental bonding instinct of a mother and child. We’re going to continue to talk a little bit more about remembering the kindness of our mother, our mother’s love. Okay? I think we’ll there’s quite a Thich Nhat Hanh goes into this. He talks a lot about his love for his mother and what what it’s meant to him in terms of his practice and his spirituality.
Maybe I’ll read just a little bit. Okay? This is Thich Nhat Hanh. The thought the thought mother cannot be separated from that of love. Love is sweet, tender, and delicious.
Without love, a child cannot flower. An adult cannot mature. Without love, we weaken wither. The day my mother died, I made this entry into my journal. The greatest misfortune of my life has come.
When was a child, I heard a simple poem about losing your mother, and it is still very important for me. So this is the poem we heard. That year, although I was still very young, my mother left me, and I realized that I was an orphan. Everyone around me was crying. I suffered in silence.
Allowing their tears to flow, I felt my pain soften. Evening enveloped mother’s tomb. The pagoda bell rang sweetly. I realized that to lose your mother is to lose the whole universe. We swim in a world of tender love for many years, and without even knowing it, we are quite happy there.
Only after it is too late do we become aware of it. People in the countryside did not understand the complicated language of the city people. When people from the city say that mother is a treasure of love, that is already too complicated complicated for them. Country people in Vietnam compare their mother to the finest variety of bananas or to honey, sweet rice, or sugarcane. They express their love in these simple and direct ways.
For me, a mother is like banana of the highest quality, like the best nep mot, sweet rice, like the most delicious mía, sugarcane. Okay. We’ll continue next week. Okay? So if you would like to get a cup of tea.
We can talk about this. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.