Thought Transformation – 27 TT 1990 05 22

46 min · 2,700 words · 22 May 1990

Thought Transformation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Thought Transformation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Thought Transformation - 27 TT 1990 05 22
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains why the view of emptiness is paramount: realising emptiness is the only way to destroy ignorance, the root of cyclic existence and suffering. Emptiness is the absence of true existence, not mere nothingness, and each person must realise it through understanding. Using the snake-and-rope analogy, the teaching shows how the mind mistakenly grasps at true existence.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1990-05-22

Duration: 47 min

UUID: 5fe25735-787e-46b4-aab6-5d522649c9e8

Words: 2,696

So we should begin by reflecting, developing the determination that for the sake of myself and all sentient beings, I must eliminate all my various faults and bring to consummation all my excellent qualities. If I am able to do that, to eliminate all my various faults and bring the consummation of my excellent qualities, then I’ll be able to establish all sentient beings in complete happiness. And developing the kind heart that in order to actually bring this about, in fact, I am going to train my mind in the supreme of vehicles, the great vehicle, and within that, the view of emptiness, and therefore developing the awakening heart as a motivation for listening to the present teaching.

We’ll spend five minutes meditating that way. So quoting a verse from Śāntideva in which he is talking about the the great number of teachings that the Buddha taught in the lesser vehicle and the great vehicle. Teachings concerning generosity, ethics, patience, effort, concentration, wisdom, teachings concerning the four noble truths, etcetera. And it is said that why did he teach all of these various teachings? That the sole purpose for presenting all of these teachings was as a method to develop the wisdom understanding emptiness, where it had not been developed previously to newly generate it, where it had been generated previously to maintain it, and where it had been maintained to increase it higher and higher.

So just as in the verse that we recite as dedication where it says, may the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow, may that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Likewise, it is said that the Buddha taught this profound doctrine of emptiness as a means to newly generate this understanding that having newly generated, that we should go on to understand it such that we’re that it will not degenerate, but we’ll be able to maintain it. And not only maintain it, but increase it higher and higher. The view of emptiness is given paramount importance. And why is that?

It is because all sentient beings, whosoever do not want to suffer, they all want complete happiness. And that type of happiness is a happiness which is brought about by means of eliminating the various afflictive emotions and thereby all of the suffering of cyclic existence. That is to say, the bliss of liberation. And without the view of emptiness and its understanding, we cannot achieve in any way the bliss of liberation. It is by means of the meditation on emptiness that we’re able to destroy the roots of our suffering, the foundation of our suffering, and that is ignorance.

It is by the wisdom understanding emptiness which is able to destroy the root of cyclic existence which is the conception of self. And by means of this, we’re able to completely eliminate from its very roots the sources of our suffering. Just as in the case of if we have a seed of a flower, if we were to pour scalding hot water on that seed, it would destroy its potency. It would die. It would never be able to sprout again.

You know, we speak of emptiness as being important. But in general, we can’t say that it’s important. What is important is that we realize it — without that, it’s of no benefit in itself. It’s not important in itself, but it is of great benefit if it’s realized within our mind. Then it becomes important.

It becomes something very precious. That is, to gain the understanding of emptiness is what is important, not just emptiness in itself. If we are seeking to realize emptiness within our own mind, the individual within ourselves, as a means to eliminate the root of cyclic existence, which also exists within our own mind, just like that flower seed and pouring scalding hot water on it to destroy that. The realization of emptiness does not exist out there in the earth somewhere — we have to realize that emptiness within our mind. Why?

Because the root of cyclic existence also exists within our own mind. And by gaining this realization we are able to destroy the root of cyclic existence and thereby our own suffering. And therefore this is the reason that we have to meditate on emptiness ourselves, for ourselves, to gain that realization for ourselves, to eliminate the root of suffering which is in ourselves. So it is necessary for us to realize emptiness individually. And in order to realize it, we must come to an understanding.

And how are we going to come to that understanding? It’s necessary to listen to the teachings on mind training and the various methods. What do we mean by emptiness? Emptiness is not simply nothingness. It is not nothing.

It is not simply a vacuum, an empty, a vacuum. It is not that. If you meditate in that way, you’re not meditating on emptiness. Then what do we mean by emptiness? Emptiness is an absence of a particular factor.

It is an absence of a particular factor. It is the nonexistence of a particular factor. Just as in the case we say, Oh, my stomach is empty. What we mean is that there’s an absence of, say, tea and food and various edibles in our stomach, and we say, My stomach is empty. There’s an absence of a particular factor when we say, My stomach is empty.

Another similar example. When we say when we open our purse and we say, Oh, my purse is empty. What we mean by that is, There’s no money in there. There’s the nonexistence of money in my purse. There’s an absence of money in my purse.

There’s a factor which is not there. There’s an absence of a particular factor. We say, my purse is empty. I don’t have any money. Likewise, when we talk about emptiness, we’re talking about the absence of a particular factor, the negation of a particular factor, its absence.

We use many different terms to talk about this factor, which is absent. We use terms such as true existence, natural existence, inherent existence, objective existence, existence from its own side. These are just different names for the same object, names for the same object, using different terms but with the same meaning. Just as in the case when we say “flower,” we also use the Tibetan word metok — different names for the same object. Likewise, we say water, we use the Tibetan word chew.

The different names for the same object have the same meaning but different words, different terms. When we say the nonexistence of true existence, that’s emptiness. The nonexistence of true existence is emptiness. The nonexistence of natural existence is emptiness. The nonexistence of inherent existence is emptiness.

The nonexistence of objective existence is emptiness. So, we say that the nonexistence of true existence, so that true existence, not the nonexistence of true existence, is what we mean by emptiness. But there should arise in our mind some kind of qualm, some kind of doubt. What is this thing called true existence? Without understanding what we mean by true existence, we can never understand what we mean by the absence of true existence.

Unless we understand what true existence is, unless that appears to our mind, what a thing would be if it was truly existent, we’re not going to understand the non-existence of true existence. Just as in the case that there’s generally one monk here whose name is Tenzin. There’s usually one monk here whose name is Tenzin. If we said, Oh, Tenzin is not here today, and you knew who Tenzin was, it would have some meaning to you.

You would understand what the absence of Tenzin meant. But if you didn’t know who Tenzin was, it would mean nothing to you when I said Tenzin was not here. You didn’t know who Tenzin was, when I said Tenzin is not here, it would mean nothing to you. You would not understand the absence of Tenzin. Just in the way that we have to understand Tenzin to understand that Tenzin is not here.

Likewise, we have to understand what true existence is before we can understand that there is no such thing as true existence, that it doesn’t exist. So another qualm may arise. Now, we said in order to understand emptiness, we must identify or recognize true existence. Since we have to identify and recognize true existence, the qualm may arise: Does true existence exist?

True existence does not exist. If true existence existed, then emptiness would not exist. There would be no emptiness. But because emptiness exists, that means that true existence cannot exist because the things are empty of true existence. And you might go on to think, well, if true existence doesn’t exist, then there’s no identification.

There’s no way of identifying true existence. So we question whether we can identify whether the identification of true existence exists. True existence doesn’t exist. True existence does not exist. But what we want to understand is, if it did exist, what would it be like?

That’s what we want to identify. That’s what we go on to examine. If true existence did exist, what would it be like? Understanding what it would be like, we examine that, and we say, Ah, it doesn’t exist. It doesn’t exist, and then we understand emptiness.

So, in general, we say that — not in general — true existence does not exist. True existence does not exist. But we do not realize that true existence does not exist. That is to say, we do not realize emptiness. Therefore, true existence appears to us.

True existence is always appearing to us, to our various awarenesses, to our various consciousnesses. This object which appears to us is the object of negation. It is to be refuted. But because we don’t realize its emptiness, we accept this appearance as being that the object actually exists the way it appears. That there appears true existence and we say, Ah yes, things really do truly exist.

And we accede to that appearance and we grasp to that appearance as if it in fact existed that way. This awareness which grasps to the existence of true existence is a distorted and mistaken awareness. The true existence appears to our various consciousnesses. It appears, for example, to the eye consciousness. Then the mental consciousness seizes that appearance.

It grasps to that appearance as if, in effect, it exists the way it appears. This grasping toward that consciousness which grasps to the true existence of that object is ignorance. It is a distorted consciousness. The objects appear to the sense consciousnesses to truly exist. The mental consciousness which grasps at that appearance to be the way the to grasp at that object to exist the way it appears is ignorance.

Mental conscious which grasps at the object to exist the way it appears, that is to say, truly existent, is ignorance. So we have to investigate the object which is being grasped at to be truly existent. If the object existed as it appears, what would it be like? How would it have to exist if the object existed just in the way we’re grasping at it? When we perform this analysis, we see by making use and analyzing by using various reasonings that, in fact, the object does not exist the way it’s being grasped at.

The object does not exist the way in which it’s being grasped at. That understanding of its nonexistence is the realization of its emptiness. The object does not exist the way it’s being grasped at. That non existence of that object the way it’s being grasped at, that consciousness which understand that the object does not exist the way it’s being grasped at is the realization of emptiness. We’re using some analogies to understand it readily.

Within the various tenets, the schools of philosophy, Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school makes use of analogy of a striped rope in coming to this understanding. The Autonomy Middle Way School uses an analogy of a magician in coming to this understanding. Beginning with this analogy, according to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school, This was roughly explained previously. There is a coiled striped rope and due to darkness that the object does not appear clearly. And a person sees with their eye consciousness the appearance of a snake.

What is actually a coiled striped rope appears to the eye consciousness as a snake. The mental consciousness then grasps at that appearance to be that there in fact really is a snake and the person generates a great deal of fear. So there is an appearance to the sense consciousness, the eye consciousness, and then the mental consciousness grasps at that appearance to be the way the object really exists. Due to this, in this case, generates fear of that object. So how did that fear arise with respect to that snake?

From where did the fear of a snake arise? From where did the fear of a snake arise? First, there was an eye consciousness to which a snake appeared. That eye consciousness induced a mental consciousness, that is to say, a conception, which as if decided or acceded to that appearance, thinking, Ah, there is really a snake there.

This followed upon appearance to an eye consciousness. There arose a conception, grasping at that appearance as in fact existing. So these are the stages which the stages through which there arose the fear of snake. First, there appeared there was simply the appearance to an eye consciousness of a snake. Then the mental consciousness grasped at that appearance as, in fact, a snake existing in that way, or grasped at that appearance as being a snake.

in dependence upon that, fear arose. There is this gradual stages of the arising of fear of snake. So if you were to say to this person, That’s not really a snake, he wouldn’t believe you at all. He’s grasping at that as if it is a snake, and during that time, his mind is not able to conceive of it as not being a snake. So he has a strong belief accepting that object as actually being a snake.

Is that the way it works? So this consciousness which is grasping at snake. Another word for grasping is conceiving. These words are used interchangeably. Conceiving of snake, or grasping at snake.

Is that a mistaken consciousness, or is that a factual consciousness? Is that a correct consciousness? Is that a mistaken consciousness, or a correct consciousness? The consciousness which is grasping at snake. The consciousness which is grasping at snake, which is conceiving of snake.

Mistaken. It’s a distorted consciousness. It’s mistaken in that it’s grasping at something which does not exist to exist. Likewise, to the eye consciousness which sees the flower, the flower appears to exist objectively from its own side and is not designated by awareness. It appears to exist from its own side and not to be designated by awareness.

Likewise, this induces a mental consciousness which grasps at that appearance that the flower exists as it appears, that the flower exists as it appears. It accedes to this appearance, accepting that the flower exists as it appears. That grasping consciousness is the conception of true existence or the ignorance. So, going back to this analogy, that conception which grasp at a rope to be a snake is the measure of the consciousness which is grasping at true existence. It’s a parallel.

So, there are two consciousnesses which could operate with respect to the appearance of a snake. There is the consciousness which accedes to that appearance thinking that that snake is existing from its own side, that it truly is a snake. Or there could arise a consciousness which understands that that appearance really doesn’t exist from the side of the snake. It’s a projection of one’s own mind. So to the person who has generated fear of snake, which of those two types of consciousness are operating?

The consciousness which is grasping.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top