Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-02-24 – KR.mp3
UUID: 050189f7-9ff2-4753-84b2-d5ee5f6d7041
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-02-24
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 27m
Words: 2,630
So we will generate the motivation to receive these teachings. Change the battery of the clock. Although one can posit numerous topics as the topics of Buddhist tenets, the core topic is the selflessness of persons. All of the schools of Buddhist tenets from the Svatantrika Madhyanika school downwards are similar in asserting a selflessness of persons which is a person’s emptiness of being a substantially existent autonomous entity. This however is not the viewpoint of the Prasanika school which asserts that the subtle selflessness of persons is a person’s being empty of existing from its own side, being empty of being inherently existent and being empty of being established by its own characteristics.
Having thus clarified the topic or the subject of Buddhist tenets, one has to address the question of the purpose of these tenets. The purpose is the purpose of the subject or the topic, in other words, the selflessness of persons. So what is the purpose of the ascertainment of the selflessness of persons? It is not a mere study of the views of the different schools of tenets, the Vaibhashika, Sotradhika, Chitamantra and Madhyamika, which at first sight seem incompatible. As Je Tsongkhapa said in the essence of eloquence, a mere ascertainment of the views of the four schools of tenets leads to a sense of their incompatibility.
So there is nothing here to be astonished at. Whatever deed whomsoever engages in is engaged in to eliminate suffering for that person and to realize happiness. And therefore, one should try to understand what is the goal of a study of Buddhist tenets, what the goal of an ascertainment of the selflessness of persons is. These two should basically connect. Very important.
Then as was mentioned, whatever deed someone engages in is for the sake of eliminating suffering and realizing happiness for that person. Now within the distinctions of or the divisions of happiness, there are two types of happiness. There is physical and mental happiness, just as there is physical and mental suffering. The study of tenets does nothing whatsoever for the elimination of physical suffering which arises in dependence on exterior material objects. It is totally unrelated to this.
In as much as physical suffering arises in dependence on exterior physical objects perceived by material sense organs. There is no relation whatsoever with the study of tenets. And therefore the suffering which is said to be eliminated through study and specifically the study of tenets is mental suffering. This mental suffering is a suffering which arises when our mind is troubled by powerful anger, by envy or by competitiveness. And this we know from our personal experience, when our mind is troubled by powerful anger, it cannot dwell in its natural state.
When we refer to mental suffering, we refer to this troubling of the mind which is no longer at ease. The same is true for envy and for competitiveness. So it is important to be able to identify clearly mental suffering. Physical suffering calls for no particular effort. When it is cold, we shiver.
When it is hot, we sweat. When we have eaten too heavy a meal, we have indigestion. This is self evident. Physical suffering therefore arises in dependence on exterior conditions. In the case of mental suffering, we can clearly see that when anger arises in our mind, our mind is troubled.
This troubledness is mental suffering. And we should analyze and see whether this state is a faulty, a defective state or not. Then, if we do not consider such a state of mind as faulty or defective, we can just drop these studies without further ado. If we consider it defective, we must analyze further. Is anger always present in the mind continuously?
It is not. Therefore, it must arise independent on causes and conditions. These must be ascertained. And therefore, one must with a sharp mind try to understand the purpose of the study of tenets. Just to study tenets because one enjoys studying different perspectives is quite meaningless, the contradictory views of different systems of tenets.
Instead, tenets should be seen as a means to eliminate mental suffering And we should investigate initially whether or not states of mind characterized by mental suffering such as anger and so forth are defective or 40 states of mind or not. If we don’t consider them as faulty or defective states of mind, we can drop the whole process. If we do consider them as defective, then we should see a fault as a fault. Then when one sees a fault as a fault, only a dumb, a stupid person does not try to find means to eradicate it. Through study, when through the maturation of study, one understands the importance of tenets which is the eradication of suffering then this will be an extremely important point.
Therefore realizing that anger and so forth are 40 states of mind and understanding that they are not present continually within our mind stream, we can see that they arise independence on causes and conditions. We therefore must investigate to find what these causes and conditions are. They are first and foremost self cherishing but deeper analysis will lead us to the realization that they arise from self grasping or the apprehension of a self. It is therefore extremely important to understand the root of the states of mind which is the grasping at the self or the ignorance apprehending the self. As Chandrakirti says in his Madhyamakavatara, the afflicted arise from the view of the disintegrating composite.
The afflicted here refers to afflictions such as anger and so forth. As Dharmakirti says in Pramanavarttikam, all of the faults arise from the view of the disintegrating composite. This in turn is ignorance which arises from desire. Understanding clearly the root of the cause afflictions we will easily understand these two quotes from Chandrakirti’s Madhyamakavatara and Dharma Kirti’s Pramana Vahtikam. Then in turn, we will investigate the nature of this ignorance apprehending a self.
It is consciousness. It is a consciousness whose object is mistaken. In as much as its object is mistaken, it itself is a mistaken mind. It is a mind which views itself as autonomous. Autonomous in other words, autonomous from or independent from causes, conditions and components.
Then once one understands that this apprehension of an I is incompatible with the mode of existence of phenomena, one will strive to generate its contrary. Its contrary is the apprehension of the selflessness of persons. This is in keeping with the nature or the mode of abiding of phenomena and as one’s realization of this deepens, one will eventually be said to have realized the view. So as the Buddha said, it is through misunderstanding the nature of phenomena that being cycle in cyclic existence. Out of great compassion, the Buddhas teach through numerous means ways to gain liberation from this.
And therefore, the topic or the subject of tenets is the selflessness of persons. The purpose of the study of tenets is through studying tenets to be able eventually to attain liberation. It is therefore important to understand the distinctions between Vaibhashikas and Sautrandikas as well as the distinctions between Sautrantikas and Chitamatras and Madhyamikas. This is best done through the definitions perhaps better translated in English by the characteristics of these schools of tenets. This is a bit difficult but all of us should try mentally to do this for a couple of seconds.
Then I would appreciate concise answers. What is the difference between Vaibhashikas and Sartrantikas? Our best way to handle this one is to reflect on the definitions of Vaibhashikas, Sautrantikas and Chittamatras. Then if you rely on the definitions, you will be able to provide a concise answer otherwise the answer will be countless. They did assert external objects, they do not assert reflective consciousness.
What is the difference between Vaibhashik and Sauthantika? Bev, what is the difference between Chitamatras and Sauthantikas? Aaron, what is the definition of Kita mantra? Chris? What is the difference with South Africa?
Reflexive consciousness. Lily, what is the definition of Vairashikas? What is the definition of Chitamatra, Natalie? Joe, what is the definition of a Sartratika? Anne, could you give a definition either of Vaibhashika or Sartrandika or Chikamatra?
Whichever you can. Does or does not? Sam. Sam. What is the definition of a Chitamatra?
Then having given the definition of Chitamatra, please give the difference between Chitamatra and Madhyamika. Could you give the definition of the Vaibhashika school? After teacher Judy, after giving the definition of a Sautratika, could you explain what is a lower school pro pounder of tenants? And the definition of a Sautrantika. Could you give the definition of a being who is a propounder of Chitamatra tenets and after that explain what is a being who is a pro pounder of great vehicle tenants.
Could speak louder and slower because I don’t get it. I can’t translate. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Yes.
Molly, what is the difference between a being who is a pro pounder of Hinayana tenets and a being who is a pro pounder of Mahayana tenets? So Ralph first, please give the definitions of all three schools of tenants Vaibhashika, Sautratika and Chitamatra. Could you repeat the beginning of the statement on Chitamatra? Could you give an instance, an example of a Vaibhashika? So actual instances of Baibashikas are quite difficult to give.
Instances of both two and four aspectarian Chitamatras are easy to give. They include the latter Vaasu Bandhu, Asanga and as for the Svatantrikas and Prasangikas, their charges will be given later. And therefore, it is really important to reflect carefully on the differences between these four schools of tenets and not to do so in any which way, saying for instance, the Vaibhashikas are those who do not accept the existence of or accept actually the existence of implicative negations since these differences are numerous but instead to rely specifically on the definitions. So when the Chitamatras refute the uncommon tenets of Vaibhashikas and Sautrantikas regarding the existence of exterior phenomena, they do so through propelling their own uncommon view of the emptiness of duality. On the other hand, when the Madhyamikas refute the Chitamatra view regarding the true establishment of other powered phenomena, they do so albeit not explicitly addressing the Chitamatra view through propounding the non true establishment of phenomena.
And this is clear in your definition of a Madhyamika on page 25 in which it is said, a Madhyamika is a being who is a propounder of great vehicle tenets and who does not assert even semiotically actual true existence. So when the Chittamatra assert that other powered phenomena, in other words, all composite phenomena or effective phenomena are truly established. They assert as well that all other powered phenomena are established by their own characteristics and are established from their own side. They assert that all other powered phenomena are truly established because they assert that they arise independence on causes and conditions. In other words, that theirs is their actual mode of abiding.
If I were to take the instance of the table in front of me, the table in front of me is asserted by Chitamatra to exist in its actual mode of abiding and therefore to be truly established. And therefore the Chitamatra assert that the table in front of me is truly established because it is established independence on its causes and conditions, independence of its parts. Because it is established in this way, it is not a mere imputation. Instead, it exists from its own side. It is something which is actually perceived by the eye consciousness which perceives table.
Madhyamikas on the other hand do not accept that table or objects are truly established. Instead specifically the Svatantrika Madiamicas assert that tables arise at the confluence or at the intersection of imputation from the side of the mind perceiving the table as well as establishment from the standpoint of its own mode of abiding from the standpoint of the table. So the difference between Chitamatra and Madhyamika, if we take the instance of the table is that for Chitamatra, the table is truly established. In other words, it is established independence on its own causes and conditions. It is not merely posited by the mind perceiving it.
Whereas for Madhya Mika, the table does not exist from its own side. It is not established So Madameka’s on the other hand assert that Svatantrika for the Svatantrika Madiamikas, the table is actually established as its own mode of abiding and arises at the intersection of that own mode of abiding and of the mind which imputes it whereas the prasangika do not even accept tables establishment by its own mode of abiding. So if we take the example of your translator to posit the distinction between Chitamatra and Madhyamika, Madhyamika, specifically Prasangika Madhyamika considers all phenomena to be mere nominal and semiotic imputations. In other words, phenomena are posited by the means of sound through the consciousness apprehending them. On the other hand, Chitamatra does not consider that all phenomena are mere nominal and conceptual imputation.
For instance, if your translator were not a mere nominal and conceptual imputation, then when someone entered the room and saw your translator, that person would naturally know that this is ilea. This is not the case. One must actually tell this person, in other words, designate ilia on this basis of imputation. So we will enter in detail later in the mode of nominal positing and conceptual imputation, but if you have some questions on this now, I will take them. Only the Prasangika School of Tenets asserts that phenomena are not established from their own sides.
For both the Svatantrika and the Chitamatra Schools of Tenets, phenomena such as this fan are established from their own side. In the Svatantrika system, whatever exists is established from its own side. I will explain what I think is your doubt if it’s okay with you. You don’t understand how the Hasanic view is not self evident to an intelligent observer who sees an object, does not know its name, its name, is told its name and then knows its name. So your question has to be qualified by adding a Chitamatra of sharp faculties because there are somewhat no Chitamatras.
And Geshela says indeed when a Chitamatra enters the room, for that Chitamatra, ilaya is a truly established phenomenon. As a truly established phenomenon which does not exist from its own side, He is not something or someone which is merely imputed by name and conception. Now this is actually the own view of the Chittamatra system and it is important for us try to understand the specific view of each system of tenets inside the system of tenets and within the system of tenets, these contradictions are not apparent but eventually when it becomes dissatisfied with the system of tenets, one moves upwards. Yes, indeed. The goal of studying tenets is to attain liberation.
However, there are two types of liberation. Liberation. There is the liberation which is a mere abandonment of the afflictive obstructions of Kleshavarana, which is the goal of the practitioners of the lesser vehicle and there is a liberation which is also an abandonment of the obstructions to omniscience. Andy, have you question? I think.
It’s not in, I am not aware of its being in Manjushri Namathangiti. It is probably a problem in the English translation. I can vouch it’s not in. Well, please. So we shall stop here for today and we shall discuss by groups of two later the meaning of mere conceptual imputation and imputation by name and conception since it is extremely important.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.