TBI Symposium – 2011-03-25 (2)

4 h 58 min · 36,075 words · 25 March 2011

TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium - 2011-03-25 (2)
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Opens with a short mindfulness meditation (noting breath and sensations, the three signs, insight alongside Lam Rim), then a two-day seminar on reincarnation: why belief in rebirth is foundational to Buddhism, Indian non-Buddhist views of rebirth, and Western (Greek, Christian, theosophical) views. Later sections cover Buddhist proofs of past and future lives and the general features of karma, with a question and answer session.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 4h 58m

UUID: 3ff0e289-6024-4c30-81e1-4163f72eb7ca

Date: 2011-03-25

Words: 36,071

So this is a preliminary to our two day workshop. Since I do not know how many of you are Buddhists and how many are not, we’re gonna keep it on a very informal, basis. Those of you who are Buddhist can create the motivation to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, as Rinpoche has taught us. Those of you who are not, just proceed onwards with the meditations we will do at present. And what we’re going to do for a very short period of time, because for us beginners short meditations are better, is we’re going to start training in mindfulness.

Mindfulness is the foundation of Buddhist meditation. It was taught by the Buddha himself in the Satipatthana Sutta. It’s very powerful for westerners because it’s evidence based. I personally feel it combines very well with Lam Rim, which is more analytical. So to engage in this meditation, will adopt the meditation posture.

Legs like this if you can. The left hand on your leg, the right hand on top of the left hand, both thumbs touching. If you’re seated in a chair, can do the same thing in a chair. The back as straight as you can. And we will train in the four mindfulnesses.

Mindfulness of the body, of feelings, of the mind, and what’s called mindfulness of phenomena. So how do we do this? In the Burmese tradition, one simply focuses on the movement of the stomach as one breathes. And one notes, when the stomach expands, inhaling. When the stomach contracts, exhaling.

One does not force the movement of the stomach or of breath. One lets it happen naturally. Whenever feelings, thoughts, sounds, any sensation arises, one does not interfere with it. One just notes it mentally. Thought, pain, fancy, sweat.

And one sits in this way, focusing on the movement of the breath with the abdomen and noting any sensation or feeling which arises. We will practice this for a couple of minutes. Thank you very much. This is a very simple and short meditation. It’s if you practice it regularly, incredibly helpful because it leads over time to the realization of what is known as the three signs.

You’ll find as you remain seated, trying to keep the same posture and just noting what happens. Noting the breath, then if pain arises, noting the pain, if thoughts arise noting the thoughts, that the actual nature of our experience is suffering. It’s quite striking. The longer you sit, the more obvious it becomes. We don’t notice it because the moment the beginning of suffering arises, we move.

When you cannot move, the suffering increases. You just stay. There’s suffering. Let’s say a cramp. Cramp.

Cramp. Greater cramp. You know? And it keeps on increasing. One of the first experiences you will gain through Sattipattana meditation is that of the Noble Truth of Suffering.

So it is said the meditators who practice this experience almost unbearable pain at a certain point before it faints. This pain was always present. It’s just occulted by the mind. It is it passes under the radar screen of our attention. Then the second experience, just through sitting and focusing on your breath and noting.

Mahasi Sayadaw’s tradition, giving a mental label, noting. The second experience is you will see that your mind is impermanent. There’s a constant stream of experiences. It never stops. First, there is a sound, someone coming in, then there is pain, then there is a thought.

Then there is the pressure of one’s buttocks on the cushion, one knee one’s knees, then there is cold. And there is nothing else but this. This constant stream of thoughts, experiences, feelings is all there is, and they are not simultaneous. As you train an attention, you will find that hearing the sound and feeling pain are never simultaneous. There is a small gap between them.

And then finally it is said, after this experience of impermanence, one can gain on this basis alone an experience of selflessness. So I wanted to just give you a very short introduction to these practices. There is a separate handout with references for those of you who want to enter a bit deeper into mindfulness training. It was extraordinarily beneficial for me when I was young because it’s evidence based, and westerners respond really well to this. Then I trained in the system of the Burmese master Mahasi Sayadaw, from whom my teacher Geshela Atan took refuge.

Mahasi Sayadaw was considered an arhat. So that’s what we’ve tried to cover today. You have the references. And tomorrow, we will do a very short ten, fifteen minutes introduction to Lam Rim meditation on impermanence and suffering. I think you will find for your own practice that if you connect the direct experience of insight meditation with Lam Rim analytical meditations, this is a very powerful combination.

Insight alone does not provide a theoretical framework. Lam Rim alone feels sometimes as if you’re forcing the mind in a corner, and the mind doesn’t like that. But if you put the two together, then in insight you see, yes, when I sit, within a matter of seconds suffering arises. There’s itching, there’s pain, there’s cramps, hot, cold. So the truth of suffering is a reality.

Then you see, yes, the body, the mind, the five aggregates are impermanent. They change instant by instant. There’s not a moment when they are not changing. If you tie this in with the Lam Rim meditations and impermanence, this is very powerful. I think one of the big problems we have with presenting, especially the Tibetan Buddhist tradition in the West, is that a lot of things which are self evident to people of a Buddhist culture are not self evident to Westerners.

And specifically, the suffering nature of existence elicits some very strong reactions from Westerners. So with insight, what we can propose is that you go and see for yourself. See how long you can sit. Just sit and focus on your breathing without the pain levels becoming in supportable. And this irrespective of the position, whether you’re in a chair, cross legged, standing, the moment you stop constantly changing to adapt to pain, which is what we do, at that moment the pain levels, the suffering of suffering, skyrockets.

And one of the experiences one gets very quickly with insight meditation is insupportable itching. Now, this itching is not something which arises as a result of meditation. This itching is always present. It is simply below the threshold of attention. When attention increases and one actually focuses, one realizes that the body is in a constant state of discomfort.

The mind is in a constant state of discomfort. So that is what I wanted to cover in these short fifteen minutes. We’ll now have a tea break, and we will have, as a German say, the strong theoretical presentations for the rest of the day. Thank you very much. Good morning, everybody.

And welcome to the first day of the two day seminar by Ilya Durevich on reincarnation. And on behalf of TBI, I just have to apologize for a publicity error. Some of us have been here at half past nine with a introductory meditation and a mindfulness meditation. So tomorrow morning, it will be half past nine for a fifteen minute, also meditation. And, also, I think everybody has been here before, so I don’t need to tell you where the toilets are.

And, also, you will all know Ilya. I don’t think there’s anybody here that doesn’t. So the only thing I want to say is to thank Ilya very much for, in the service and respect of our beloved teacher, Kensur Rinpoche Ilya is offering these seminars to help us so that we on the path so that we can have a greater understanding and reception of Rinpoche’s teachings and Buddhism in general. Without any further ado, I’d just like to hand over to Ilya. Thank you.

Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Guys, could we close the door? Ah, there’s a lady. So I’m absolutely delighted to see so many known faces here again, and I look forwards together with you to exploring over the next two days the issue of reincarnation.

There are several questions which have to be addressed. First, why is it important for us to think about the issue of reincarnation in general and in a Buddhist context in particular. Reincarnation is foundational. If one believes in reincarnation, one can be a Buddhist. If one does not believe in reincarnation, one cannot be a Buddhist.

There is no middle ground in the matter. The totality of the Buddhist teachings rest on the notion of saṃsāra, of the infinite cycle of lives, which is a notion which is shared by many other ancient Indian traditions. If one believes in reincarnation, one can be a practitioner of one of these Indian traditions, and there are differences in their understanding of reincarnation. There are differences also in their understanding of the goals to be trained in. If one is unable to believe in reincarnation, or chooses not to do so, then irrespective of the clothes one’s one wears, irrespective of whether one is officially a Buddhist or not, one is one will never be a Buddhist.

Someone who is a Buddhist and who ceases to believe in reincarnation loses that name at that very instant. Someone who is a Buddhist monk and who ceases to believe in reincarnation has destroyed all the vows he holds at that very instant. Someone who has bodhisattva vows, and who ceases to believe in reincarnation, has destroyed the bodhisattva vows at the root.

Someone who has tantric vows, and who ceases to believe in reincarnation, has destroyed the tantric vows at the moment. Because nothing is possible, from the Buddhist context without this belief in reincarnation. Someone who does not believe in reincarnation from a Buddhist standpoint is the most extreme type of nihilist. We talk talk of nihilists, nihilists are people who do not believe in past or future lives. Therefore, the very foundation for any ethics collapses, And we see the tremendous struggle our western societies are going through, to try to formulate ethics, a foundation for ethics, in what is de facto a soft nihilist society.

And it doesn’t work. Our societies are facing endless problems, because having abandoned the one religious tradition which they had, which is Christianity, which through teaching the existence of one future life, at least provided a foundation for ethics. They have ended up in a situation where at best people are agnostic, and are not really sure what’s going on, and in the worst of possible cases, are totally nihilistic, and believe this life is all there is. Then, as Somerset Maugham, the English short story writer famously said, and he was the archetype of nihilist of all nihilists, you know, human bondage. One should do what one wants to do with no regard for the policeman around the corner.

This is a nihilist’s viewpoint. This is the dominant viewpoint in Australian society. This is a dominant viewpoint in much of the West. Now it is up to ourselves whether we choose to subscribe to that viewpoint or not, but there are far reaching consequences if we do. Today, and over the next two days, what we’re going to address is the issue of reincarnation.

We’re to address it from two different perspectives. Today, we’re going to focus mainly on the theoretical substratum, which is important. We’re going to focus first on the understanding of reincarnation in the Indian philosophical traditions, And this morning as well, we will address the issue of the understanding of reincarnation in Western history. There was a Western understanding of reincarnation, which we have inherited largely through the New Age, and which causes considerable problems when New Age practitioners choose to turn towards Buddhism because the understandings are different. This afternoon, we will address the issue of the Buddhist understanding of reincarnation, as well as the proofs of reincarnation from a Buddhist standpoint.

Then tomorrow we will have a much more empirical perspective, we’re going to address the evidence which western scientists have gathered regarding reincarnation. Tomorrow morning, we’ll address the evidence which comes from children who spontaneously remember past lives. Mainly doctor Stevenson’s research, but also Jim Tucker’s research. Tomorrow afternoon, we’re going to address the more controversial issue of hypnotic regression and memories which are retrieved from patients, generally by psychiatrists, such as doctor Netherton, doctor Woolgar, Brian Weiss, and their forefather, the French colonel, Albert de Rochas. And what we will try to do tomorrow is after presenting this data, we’re going to see first what if it can be accepted and what not.

You will find that in the first section, memories of past lives, which are spontaneous a lot, accepted. In the second section, hypnotic regression, one must be very wary of the data. And we will try to understand this material from a Buddhist standpoint. So that would be basically our framework for these two days. We will now have an hour and a half conference, which will focus as we said on the theoretical underpinnings in the Indian and Western traditions, then half an hour for questions, a one hour lunch break, and, from one to two, perhaps a little bit before two, I will be showing two videos today, interviews of Tom Schroeder, who is a Washington Post journalist, who traveled with doctor Stevenson all over the world documenting Stevenson’s research on children who have spontaneous memories of past lives, and an interview with doctor Jim Tucker, who is Stevenson’s successor, a psychiatrist at the University of Virginia, my alma mater, and who is the foremost researcher in the this issue of spontaneous memories of past lives.

So I would strongly encourage you to attend the afternoon session. I’m very grateful to, Steve Sakellarius for, giving me permission to show these interviews, which he made for a movie which was shown in The States. And now we’re going to address today’s conference, reincarnation East West, non Buddhist traditions of reincarnation in India in western traditions. So why study non Buddhist traditions? First, to understand that there are many different views of reincarnation.

Not all forms of reincarnation are created equal. And then to be able this afternoon to formulate the specificity of the Buddhist presentation. This is important because all of us are trying to understand Buddhism, and we can only become sincere Buddhists if we understand clearly what Buddhism is and what Buddhism is not. There’s absolutely no need for any one of us to become a Buddhist. But you don’t get married with, before getting married, the intention to cheat on your spouse.

You don’t enter a religious tradition with mental reservations. So so as not to have mental reservations, one has to understand. Understand clearly, what is the Buddhist understanding of reincarnation, what are the non Buddhist understandings of reincarnation. Then from one’s own side, one thinks, do I agree or not? That is one’s own freedom.

But what is quite regrettable is a very sizable proportion of Westerners who become Buddhist with a strong element, at best a fantasy, at worst of intellectual dishonesty, where the person basically is not a Buddhist deep inside, and wants to be, for whatever reasons, part of the Buddhist community. This is harmful to the person themselves, because they cannot progress on the spiritual path if they are not sincere and honest, and it is harmful to the transmission of Buddhism in the West. So that is why his holiness the Dalai Lama, in the last ten years when I have heard him teach in the West, has strongly emphasized the differences between Buddhism and the other religious traditions. And this has not gone down very well with Westerners, which is almost always a clear sign that it is necessary. So that is what we’re going to be doing here.

I’m going to be emphasizing differences, so that you can make up your own minds. So we will first start by addressing the non Buddhist Indian traditions. This is the picture of the famous Kailash cave at Ellora, which I took in January. It is one of the most monumental Hindu temples in history, entirely carved of rock over three centuries. This is a magnificent spiritual tradition, Hinduism, which believes in reincarnation, but whose understanding of reincarnation is somewhat different from the Buddhist one.

And it is in this milieu that the Buddha taught. Therefore, it is in this milieu that we have to address some issues. So generally speaking, Hinduism as a whole is a very complex religious phenomenon. If we look at the totality of Indian traditions, Indian religious traditions, they can be subdivided into two groups. It is a very clear subdivision.

You have the religious traditions, Indian religious traditions, which believe in God, and reincarnation. That’s a case of all of the so called Hinduist traditions which are listed here, the so called six views, or the six darshanas. And then you have the Indian religious traditions, which do not believe in the existence of a god, of a creator. And that is the Jain and the Buddhist tradition, which appear almost at the same period. All of the six Indian traditions which believe in the existence of a god, which are theistic, subscribe to reincarnation.

They all teach reincarnation and karma. They differ mainly in their understanding of very minor points, such as the actual nature of reality. All of these six traditions believe that there is a creator called the Bhagavan, the lord, that this creator god revealed himself in texts called the Vedas, which found the Indian Buddhist the Indian Hindu tradition, and that reincarnation and the existence of a god coexist. Then the particular specific sphere responsibility of god and of karma are mixed, mixed, and it’s one of the big problems of Hinduism. Karma is accepted, and a creator who intervenes in creation is accepted.

So philosophically, Hinduism runs into considerable problems because of this. The atheistic traditions, which are Jain and Buddhism, do not accept the existence of a creator of the universe or a god. There is no god. The universe appears exclusively as a result of the karma of beings. Then these traditions have no particular difficulty in conciliating karma with anything else.

They are atheistic. All of the Indian schools of philosophy, both Buddhist and non Buddhist, share a common understanding. This is a groundwork of what I have called in other conferences a Gangetic tradition. They assert the existence of an infinite cycle of lives, which they all call saṃsāra. They all agree that this is suffering, and is dreamlike, is like an illusion.

All, with one exception which we will talk about later, assert that there is a liberation called a Mokśa by the Hindus and Nirvāṇa by the Buddhists from this cycle of lives. All without exception assert that this liberation is private and personal. It is not as in the monotheistic traditions, a community affair. There’s no such thing as in Christianity or in Islam, a church in Christianity, the ummah of the believers in Islam, who together progress towards a state of salvation. There is no such thing in the Indian traditions.

Liberation, moksha, is a private affair. It depends exclusively on one’s personal efforts. So these are paradoxically for Asian traditions, extraordinarily individualistic traditions as far as spirituality is concerned. These are also profoundly pessimistic traditions. There is none of the Judeo Christian and Roman optimism.

Life is pain. This is a consensus of the of Indian thought. For this, I wanted to quote from non Buddhist text to show the degree to which this is shared. This is the Maitri Upanishad. It’s the text from maybe the fifth century BC.

Foul smelling and insubstantial is the body, a mere agglomeration of skin, bones, sinews, marrow, flesh, semen, blood, mucus, tears, rheum, urine, feces, bile and phlegm. What is the good and enjoying desires in such a body? This whole world is decaying like these gnats, these mosquitoes, this grass, and these trees that only arise to perish. There is no difference between the view of the Upanishads, which are the foundational texts of Hindu mysticism, and the Buddhist view as taught by the Buddha in the Fire Sūtra. This is common, this is shared, the shared trunk.

Likewise, in the Mundaka Upanishad, again a Hindu text, a non Buddhist text, frail indeed are those rafts of sacrifice. Deluded men who rejoice in them as the highest good return again and again to old age and death. And here the path of salvation is is taught. But those who are in penance and in faith dwell in the forest, tranquil and wise, living on alms, pass on immaculate through the gateway of the sun to where that deathless person dwells. This again is a shared trunk of all of the Hindu traditions, theistic and non theistic.

Buddhist monasticism originates in the so called forest tradition, which was taught in Hinduism. At present, we have to address the differences between these various Indian schools. We have a common trunk. The branches are extremely different. Fundamental difference is how to attain liberation.

Liberation is a shared goal of all the traditions. The means are very different. Some of the Hindu traditions, such as the Mimamsa, for instance, consider that liberation can only be attained through ritual, sacrifice. Others, only through faith. These are the later Indian tradition, the so called bhakti traditions.

You may have heard of the devotees of Krishna, They are searching for liberation from samsaric existence, but they believe it can only be attained through faith. Man’s wisdom is never sufficient. The third group believe it can only be attained by meditation and wisdom. This is a case of the yoga tradition in Hinduism. It is a case of the Jains.

It is a case of the Buddhists. For a Buddhist, there is no liberation through faith alone. There is no liberation through sacrifice and ritual. Liberation occurs through wisdom. In other words, it occurs as Rinpoche has taught again and again through combining the three activities: hearing, in other words attending teachings thinking, and meditating.

There is no other road. Then the subsidiary differences between the Indian schools are, as we said, the existence or nonexistence of a god, In other words, who created the world, and the existence or nonexistence of a self or a soul. In other words, the very simple question, all the Indian schools accept that there is reincarnation. What reincarnates? The Indian schools say the ātman, the soul reincarnates.

The Buddha taught there is no such thing as a soul. There is no ātman. So the Hindu understanding of the Ātman is identical to the Christian understanding of the soul. There is no difference. You cannot be a Buddhist and accept the existence of a soul.

It is not possible. And this is a depiction of saṃsāra, the wheel of life, which I I took in Cave Number 17 in Ajanta. It’s magnificent. It was painted around May in ancient India. You can still see exactly the wheel of life, much is missing unfortunately, as it is depicted in Tibet.

This is a universal Buddhist belief. It is not a specific Tibetan creation. And the notion of the wheel of life itself is shared with all of the Indian traditions, without exception, or with one nominal exception. And that is the issue we will address now. There is one Indian tradition which does not accept the existence of karma.

It is the so called materialistic tradition, the Loka Yata tradition. Loka means word, so these are Loka Yatas, the worldly ones. They are subdivided into two subgroups according to Tibetan scholars. Some Indian materialists said that there was no past and no future lives at all. So they correspond exactly to Western materialists, for this reason this school is very interesting for us, because it seems as if all the lokaryatas have been reborn in Australia, America, and Europe.

They sort of

Fixed the date 25 centuries ago and gathered here, and now they are in charge. And the second group of of materialists in India taught that there were past and future lives, but there was no karma. And this is a very interesting group, because I think many new age practitioners fall in this category. You find people accepting the existence of past and future lives quite casually, but not accepting the existence of karma in causality. Now it’s important to understand these two schools were attested in India, and there was a very powerful Buddhist reaction against these schools.

We will cover partly this afternoon. But their viewpoints are contemporary. Sanjaya Belatthiputta, who was a contemporary of the Buddha, was a skeptic who denied that it was possible to know anything with certainty. In other words, a modern day agnostic. Steve Batchelor probably would sympathize with Sanjaya Belatthiputta.

And then, Buddha’s, if you’ll forgive me for the term Buddha’s whipping boy, Buddha has only praised for the other teachers of the of his age, except for who taught radical. He acknowledged reincarnation, rejected the notion of karma, and actually taught that everything was strictly determined by astrology, by the stars in other words, and that everything we ever did would repeat in a cycle which seemed to correspond to the Platonic great year. Therefore, Gosala Makkhaliputra taught that man had no freedom at all. He had no freedom to choose to practice good, he had no freedom to choose to abstain from evil. It is said in the Pali Canon, the collection of Buddhist texts that he had the most horrific death.

And as you know, the death is often an indicator of what happens. After. We will now pass onwards to western understandings of reincarnation. So let us try to keep in mind, before we pass over to this topic, the common trunk of the Indian understandings of reincarnation. We have a belief in an infinite number of past and future lives.

We have a belief that all these lives are of the nature of suffering. We have a belief that all of these lives, everything that we can see, is illusory, dreamlike. Then we have disagreement. We have disagreement about how to escape. All the Indian traditions agree we are in jail.

Disagreement starts when one starts to ask the question, how do we get out? Then the prisoners fight with each other. I want to go through the roof, I think it’s better to go underground. A third says we have to make it through the walls. But all agree, we’re in jail, and it’s pretty grim in here.

So there is disagreement regarding liberation, means to attain liberation, and the prisoners also disagree with each other regarding who put them in jail. There’s one batch of prisoners who say, there’s this all powerful guardian, and if we are really good prisoners, he will take care of us and let us out of jail. There’s another group of prisoners who says there’s no such thing. We landed here by accident. First group of prisoners are the Hindus.

The second group of prisoners are the Buddhists and the Jain. You can see that if you believed that there was a guardian of the jail, and you had to please him, your outlook on life would be very different. You would make offerings to the guardian. This is ritual. You’d have faith in the guardian.

When he showed up, you’d smile and bow and hope that you would become one of the favorites of the guardian. If on the other hand, as the Buddhists and the Jains, you did not believe that there was such a being as a guardian, then you would believe that all effort and responsibility fell upon your shoulders. So this is a fundamental split inside the Indian traditions. And for us who are westerners interested in Buddhism, who have chosen some of us have chosen to become Buddhist, it is important to understand this. You can reincarnation without being a Buddhist.

There are many different ways of presenting reincarnation. As we said, you cannot be a Buddhist without accepting reincarnation. If you accept reincarnation, and deep down you believe in in God, in some sort of a permanent self, then you are actually a Hindu. You’re not a Buddhist. Buddhist.

The Buddhist teachings do not have to stretch to accommodate that. We do not have to be infinitely flexible. And perhaps someone who deep down feels that this world is created by an outside creator, and that there is this self inside him, be happier inside Hinduism, and would be more successful in his spiritual practice. Because all of these Indian traditions, with the exception of the Lokāyata tradition, are traditions which provide a foundation for ethics. In other words, every single one of these traditions can lead us to higher rebirths.

If there’s a foundation for ethics, in other words, a belief in past and future lives, in karma, then the person, if he or she chooses the path which is appropriate to his inner sensitivities, is able to progress from life to life. From a Buddhist standpoint, none of the Hindu paths allow escape from psychic existence. Not one. Because they teach existence of a self. But escape from psychic existence is not the goal for most of us.

I doubt in this center there is anyone who wants to escape from psychic existence. We’re lucky if we have a couple students who actually think of future lives. That’s already a lot. Those who want to really escape from psychic existence, are in monasteries. And even there, how many are sincere?

It’s a big thing to escape from psychic existence. As Jetsongkhapa says, to turn away from all the pleasures of this life, in reflecting again and again an impermanence and the suffering of psychic existence, to turn away from psychic existence as a whole. There are few who are able to do this. I knew a very fine old Geshe at Sera Je monastery, very close friend of mine, and like all of the true practitioners, he was very sincere, very honest. He was the chant master of the protector group of the monastery, Lama Lhundrup, former disciplinarian of the monastery.

We were talking once. And he said something which is exactly the opposite to what you hear in dharma centers. Dharma centers, you hear people who have been Buddhists for six months or two years, who speak of bodhicitta, and one is close to attaining shinne, and the other seems to have experienced emptiness, and the third has memory of past lives and whatnot. And this old Geshe, who was a real meditator, he said to me once, I was very shocked when he said it, he said, yes. What extraordinary beings are, in other words, practitioners of the lesser vehicle, the Theravada.

If only I had the strength to be one of them. He had been a monk for sixty years. That is a true practitioner, who knows where he stands. So for us who are not even practitioners, we just would like to become practitioners, and many of us are not even though we call ourselves Buddhists are not true Buddhists, because we don’t have refuge, or we don’t have sincere, authentic refuge then it is important to understand and appreciate these other spiritual which, if sincerely practiced, lead their practitioners at least to higher rebirths. And as Nāgārjuna said in the first one attains higher then on that basis, one aims for liberation and for enlightenment.

So these are the differences between the Indian traditions, and at present we will address the issue of the western understanding of reincarnation. And it is important for us to understand that because we find with a lot of western Buddhists that there is in the background after they have become Buddhist, a non Buddhist understanding of reincarnation, we find long term Western Buddhists, who for instance do not accept animal rebirths. Long term western Buddhists who do not believe in the existence of the lower realms. Long term western Buddhists who do not really believe in karma. Then, such persons really are not Buddhists.

A friend of mine was in Dharamsala once, she’s a very good practitioner, and she came to me, and she said, Papuliya, I met the most extraordinary man. He’s a westerner. He’s living in a monastery. He says he’s a great Yamāntaka practitioner, but he doesn’t really believe in past and future lives. So I had never heard of something like this.

Then when I went back to Sera monastery, I spoke with my friends who were geshes, and when I told them this, they burst into hysterics. They were laughing so hard, they couldn’t speak, because it is such a contradiction in terms. Someone who is practicing one of the most advanced tantras, and the basis aren’t there, the foundation’s aren’t there. So that is our case. That’s something we have to try to correct.

And therefore, regarding the western understanding of reincarnation, we find actually early on in ancient Greece a belief in metempsychosis. Metempsychosis in Greek means reincarnation. In other words, it means that the mind, or in this case the soul passes from body to body. It is this Greek understanding of reincarnation, which actually has passed often in a subterranean fashion throughout western history, and has manifested again nowadays in the new age tradition. This Greek understanding is very different from the Indian one, and I think as we study it, we will see the differences very clearly.

It starts most probably with a mythological figure, Orpheus, who was the creator, they say, of music in ancient Greece. A Thracian who lived perhaps in the sixth century BC, and who seems to have been the founder of the so called Orphic mysteries. These were secret cults in ancient Greece, set apart from the official religion, which had esoteric teachings, of which reincarnation was one, and it is those secret teachings which have influenced much of Greek thought. Then, after Orpheus, we have Pythagoras, the great mathematician, who was also a great mystic, a practitioner. It is said he had memories of his own past lives, very clear memories.

Pythagoras leads us to Heraclitus, one of the earliest Greek philosophers, whose outlook was in many respects profoundly Buddhist. He taught the existence of impermanence, and in some very cryptic verses, he taught the existence of past and future lives. And then Plato, who is perhaps the most important Greek philosopher, and who is critical for much of western history, teaches explicitly reincarnation. So we are going to cover some of Plato’s dialogues in which reincarnation is taught, because it is Plato’s understanding of reincarnation you find in theosophy, you find in the works of Alice Bailey, you find in the New Age, and it is this which is often brought by westerners who wish to become Buddhists with them to Buddhist centers. It is reincarnation as choice.

And then after Plato, a figure I will not cover in detail, Apollonius of Tyana, who was a taumaturge, he was a miracle worker of ancient Greece, who claimed to have clear memories of past and future lives, and the so called neo platonists, who were disciples of Plato and of the Platonic school, and who ushered Plato’s teachings into Christianity. And this will enable us to see that there is an entire strand of early Christianity in which reincarnation was taught, reincarnation was believed in, and eventually these teachings were banned by a council, the Fifth Ecumenical Council. So Opheus represented here with his lira, perhaps the originator of the teachings of reincarnation in ancient Greece. It is said he could charm animals, and the Orphic legend is that Opheus traveled to the realm of the dead to bring back his wife Eurydice, who had been poisoned by vipers, and obviously traveling to the realm of the dead is a classical shamanistical metaphor for experiences perhaps out of the body experiences, and upon bringing his wife back, the condition to bringing his wife back was that Opheus was not allowed by the lord of Herald Hades to look back, and Opheus looked back.

Then his wife was taken from him, never to be given back to him. And looking back in all the myths is a symbol of doubt. He who looks back has doubts, has reservations. He is not full heartedly on the path. Therefore, Orpheus’ sin, which prevented him from resurrecting his wife, was doubt.

Lack of faith. In a very different context, this connects, I think, very powerfully with Kensur Rinpoche’s teachings, that without faith there is no foundation for spiritual practice. Opheus’s teachings were very close to the Buddhist teachings. Opheus taught metempsychosis, he taught reincarnation, and Orpheus had an extremely dark vision of metempsychosis. He saw the cycle of lives as of the nature of suffering.

So in this respect, there is no difference between Orpheus’ presentations and the Indian presentations. He also taught that the path from darkness to light passed through self abnegation, giving oneself up. Literally, in the Tibetan tradition, speak of giving up self cherishing, cherishing others. It passes through purification, and it passes through receiving initiation in the mysteries. Now whether Orpheus was a great bodhisattva, a manifestation of the Buddha, teaching teachings adapted to his age or not, we do not know, but there were great similarities.

And from Orpheus, these teachings passed on to Pythagoras, the founder of modern geometry. He studied Pythagoras’ theorem in high school. Pythagoras also taught explicitly reincarnation, and taught the importance of ethics as the foundation of the spiritual life, specifically, Pythagoras was the earliest apostle of vegetarianism. He was a strict vegetarian, who even abstained from eating beans, and led a life of great purity. According, we have none of the works of Pythagoras, but according to a later author, Pythagoras was accustomed to speak of himself in this manner, and this is where he recollects his past lives.

He had formerly been Aethalides. Then he was reborn as Euphorbus, and was wounded by Menelaus at the siege of Troy, the famous siege of Troy recounted by Homer. In that life, he used to say that he had received as a gift from Mercury. Mercury was the god of wisdom in ancient Greece, very closely to the Buddhist Mañjuśrī. The memory of his soul’s transmigration.

In other words, he recollected his past lives. Also, the gift of recollecting what his own soul and the souls of others had experienced between death and rebirth. In other words, Pythagoras explicitly claimed not only memory of past lives, but memories of the Bardo, of the intermediate state. So these, if this is true, mean that Pythagoras had one, perhaps two of the paranormal powers which are taught in the Buddhist scriptures, the memory, clear memory of past lives, and perhaps also the capacity to read others’ minds. These can be developed through concentration alone.

So Pythagoras was not necessarily

A precursor of Buddhist techniques, but the similarities are very striking. Then a very major doubt arose, and this is of tremendous interest for us. Pythagoras explicitly taught past lives. The question which arose among later Greek philosophers is, did Pythagoras acknowledge animal rebirths or not? It seems he did.

Not only him, seems Plato himself taught that one certain Thiresias was reborn as an ape, as a monkey. But Greek philosophy as a whole recoiled from this, and said it is impossible for a human being to be reborn as an animal or for an animal to be reborn as a human being. And this was a particular bias of all of Greek thought, which we find to this day in western culture. It’s this bias of human specificity, what the Greeks called the dignity of man. And you will see that it was a debate much later.

High Rockley’s commenting says, he who believes that he transmigrates after death into the body of a beast or a plant is grossly mistaken. Now the Buddhists teach reincarnation into animal forms. The Jains, in addition, teach reincarnation into plants. Buddhists do not acknowledge this, but they say spirits can live in plants without having the plant as a body. It seems that this is what Pythagoras taught, but later Greek tradition rejected this.

And a neo Platonist Proclus commenting on Plato’s Republic says, in his Republic, Plato says that the soul of Thrasites assumed an ape, but not the body of an ape, and in Dephedrus, that the soul descends into a savage life, not into a savage body. What Proclus is trying to do is to salvage the letter of Plato’s works, where Plato explicitly speaks of animal reincarnation. Without having animal reincarnation, so somehow the soul is connected with a monkey, but is not in a monkey. It obviously doesn’t work very well. And to show you how far this problem goes, Shakespeare in the Merchant of Venice says, sixteen centuries later, what is the opinion of Pythagoras concerning the wild fowl, in other words, pheasants and birds, that the soul of our grandam might happily inhabit the bird.

What thinkest thou of his opinion? And this is the answer the totality of western thought has given. I think nobody of the soul and in no way approve of his opinion. In other words, Shakespeare considers reincarnation a possibility, but thinks too highly of the soul and of man to accept the possibility of animal reincarnation. We have here a fundamental split in the understanding of reincarnation between east and west.

Between the eastern view of reincarnation as connecting all living beings, and the western view of reincarnation as something which only affects human beings. And what happens precisely to other beings, non human beings is open to question. We will see later, if we have time, that theosophists, and by extension the New Age, believe animals have something called group souls. Somehow, there’s a dog soul, which all dogs share, and this dog soul somehow manifests in individual dogs. This has nothing whatsoever to do with the Indian understanding of reincarnation, let alone the Buddhist understanding of reincarnation.

But this is something which is rooted ultimately in Greek philosophy. Philosophy. Then we pass to the next seminal figure in Greek philosophy, which when I was a very young child had a tremendous influence on me. We had access to no Buddhist texts when I was a boy, and I by accident, when I was I think 10 years old, I read this Greek philosopher Heraclitus, and I was just bowed over by his teachings. It seemed so true, and I have kept affection for him ever since.

He lived in the sixth century BC. All of western philosophy turned against Heraclitus, because what Heraclitus taught is exactly the antithesis of everything western philosophy teaches. Heraclitus taught everything changes, instant by instant. Life is a river, it is a flow. The minds come and go from body to body.

None of this was acceptable. In western philosophy, later on with a philosopher called Parmenides, turned radically away from this. So Heraclitus of Ephesus, Ephesus was the island he came came from, taught, and you will see how beautiful this passage is. The quick and the dead, the wakers and the sleepers, young and old, all are the same. How can they all be the same?

For the last are moved to be the first. The last are the old. The older move to be the first because they become young again. They are reborn. The dead are moved to be the quick, in other words, living, because they become living again.

The last are moved about to be the first, and the first in turn become the last, the young become old. The quick, the living in other words, become dead. They rise again and become watchful guardians of the quick and the dead. So Heraclitus is teaching here in veiled language, reincarnation. Reincarnation in Greek philosophy was a secret teaching, as you said, with the mystery cults, and it is very clear when one reads these aphorisms of Heraclitus, that it was present very early on in the sixth century BC.

This is the time of the Buddha. Then moving onwards to the Greek philosopher, who is the father of western philosophy, Plato. Plato explicitly teaches reincarnation, but Plato’s understanding of reincarnation is the foundation of the western understanding. It is fundamentally different from the Indian understanding, and we will see in this passage precisely why it is this different. This is from Plato’s Republic, one of Plato’s most magnificent works.

This is an account of the myth of Er. This is the myth of reincarnation. Your destiny shall not be allotted to you, but you shall choose it for yourselves. And Plato in a vision describes the souls choosing their next life. It was a truly melancholy sight to watch how each soul selected its life, a sight at once melancholy and ludicrous and strange.

The experience of their former life generally guided the choice. It happened that the soul of Odysseus had drawn the last lot of our own. Odysseus was a great Greek navigator, whose wanderings were immortalized by Homer in the Odysseus. His life was seen by the Greeks as one of great suffering, wandering away from home endlessly, trying to get back to Ithaca, and never succeeding. When Odysseus came up to choose, the memory of his former suffering had so abated his ambition that he went about a long time looking for a quiet retired life.

Now when all souls had chosen their lives, they travelled into the plain of forgetfulness, and took up their quarters by the river of indifference. This is the western understanding of reincarnation. This underlines all of the Platonic schools of Greek philosophy, Neo Platonism, the Christian teachers such as Origen, or Clement of Alexandria, who teach reincarnation, that when reincarnation becomes a forbidden teaching in the sixth century, it is this understanding which goes underground, and which is resurrected in Kabbalah, in Spain, in the twelfth century, which is resurrected in the Freemason and Rosicrucian traditions, which is resurrected in the occult tradition in Elizabethan England, and which eventually makes its way into Theosophy, into the teachings of Alice Bailey, and into present day New Age. When Westerners speak of reincarnation, if you read any book on hypnotic regression, whether it is those written by Carol Bowman, or Brian Weiss, this idea of the soul choosing its next life is central. This is a Western idea.

This has nothing to do with the Buddhist understanding of reincarnation. Not only this, one of the key features of Plato’s thought thought is that Plato teaches the bible. We can see that after choosing their future life, the souls actually forget. They go to the plane of forgetfulness. It’s a metaphor for the forgetting which occurs before the next incarnation.

It seems difficult to me that Plato could have constructed this purely intellectually. It seems to me that Plato probably was an initiate in the mysteries, and probably had direct experience. It seems difficult otherwise, but his understanding of metempsychosis, of reincarnation, all very powerful, is not ours. Socrates as well taught reincarnation. He taught specifically what is known as anamnesis, that means to recollect, to remember in Greek.

Socrates believed that knowledge is merely remembering, because it seemed impossible to Socrates that knowledge could be newly, excuse me, newly acquired. Now this is an understanding which is fundamentally similar to that of all of the Indian traditions. Some of us learn faster than others because we have learned in past lives. And in the Meno, there is this famous dialogue where Socrates discussing with Meno demonstrates to Meno that if one of Socrates’ students learned geometry this easily, it is because he was merely refreshing what he had learned before. Now, I found this personally extraordinarily inspiring when I was a young boy.

I read Plato I was in my teens, and I was very perturbed by the fact that everything I had to study would be lost when I died, and it seemed to be completely meaningless to put all this effort in learning and study, just to lose everything. Then these teachings that learning is carried on by what we know as karmic imprints, from life to life, and that the learning becomes each time easier, each time more powerful, is something which is a shared concept, both by Plato and by all of the Indian tradition. So when Kensur Rinpoche encourages us to put effort in this life, for future lives, I often have the impression looking at the faces of the students, that the look of exasperation fleets across their face, and the thought is here we go again. The truth of the matter is that this is the way forwards. In this room we have many different capacities, intellectually and physically.

They come from somewhere. Some of us have great difficulty with studying, and for instance, when we try to learn a language like Tibetan, cannot succeed. Others seem to just pick it up, you know, casually with great facility. This is a sign of past life familiarity. And if we do not have in this life past life familiarity, it is something we can construct in this life for the next life and for future lives.

So it is quite striking to me that this is very much Socrates’ vision as well as the Buddhist vision. So we can see therefore a powerful stream in Greek thought, which is profoundly sympathetic to metempsychosis, to reincarnation, and actually rooted in reincarnation. And then the fundamental transition at the beginning of our era occurs. This is a picture I took of the Cathedral Of Lausanne. It is the dawn of Christianity.

With Christianity, the strand of Greek thought which teaches reincarnation comes smack on with a Semitic religious tradition, which rejects reincarnation and teaches not rebirth, but bodily resurrection. The resurrection of the body, the physical body at the end of time. It is not possible to conciliate the two. There is no common ground. As Christianity became more powerful in the Roman Empire, especially from 03/2021, when it became the official religion under Constantine of the Roman Empire, Empire, the tension became ever greater.

The early Christian fathers, who lived mainly in Alexandria, were Greek by education. They had trained under platonic teachers. They accepted reincarnation, and they basically tried to fuse Christianity with reincarnation. Later on, this was eventually forbidden. And these early Christian thinkers were strongly connected with the Neo Platonists, and there was a new Platonist school.

These were disciples of Plato who taught in Alexandria in Egypt, at the period Egypt was under Greek rule, and the Neo Platonists taught reincarnation. Ammonius Saccas, who lived at the beginning of our era, who founded Neo Platonism, taught reincarnation to his two foremost disciples, Plotinus, who was not a Christian, and Origen, who was one of the greatest, if not the greatest, early Christian church father, one of the greatest scholars of his age, a great Greek philosopher who converted to Christianity, and seeing the body as a source sin, had himself castrated, so as to sin no more. You see the radicality of the choices Origen took. Now Origen composed one of the most important works of early Christianity, De Principiis, in which he teaches exactly Plato’s teachings: Every soul comes into the world strengthened by the victories, or weakened by the defeats of its previous life. Nor, in other words, Origen, with a Christian church father, an authority, teaches what became known in Christianity as the pre existence of souls.

As opposed to official Christian dogma, which to this day, in the Roman Catholic church, the Orthodox church, and the Protestant churches, teaches that the soul is individually created by God at the instant of conception, and is placed in the egg by the act of God. The soul does not exist before this instant. This was not the viewpoint of the Greek church fathers. And the viewpoint of Origen remained extraordinarily powerful throughout eastern Christianity up to the sixth century. So when you hear that Christianity actually is not at odds with reincarnation, this is something we hears a lot, it has to be qualified.

There were Christian fathers who taught reincarnation, but they did not teach reincarnation because they were Christian. They taught reincarnation because they had trained in Platonic philosophy, because they were Greek philosophers training. As Christianity became dominant, the teachings on reincarnation came to be seen as incompatible with the omnipotency, all power of God. And I think personally the Christians are right. I think it is not possible, as the Indian philosophers do, to at the same time teach that there is an omnipotent creator, and to speak of reincarnation and karma.

Indian philosophy struggles with this. The post sixth century Christian philosophers simply rejected reincarnation. So this is to this day the official Christian position. Then, some Christians are now trying to return to earlier understanding, but as we said, it poses problems. From the sixth century onwards, reincarnation became the forbidden teaching.

If you taught reincarnation, you faced being burnt at the stake, and it happened as late as the early seventeenth century to one of the greatest intellectuals of his age, Giordano Bruno, who was a Dominican monk, one of the greatest Greek scholars of his age, who explicitly taught reincarnation, and who was captured by the popes in Rome and burned at the stake for teaching reincarnation. Because at the Fifth Ecumenical Council in 553, which was held in Constantinople, the teachings of reincarnation were condemned. If anyone asserts the fabulous, in other words, incredible, impossible, pre existence of souls, in other words, reincarnation, and shall assert the monstrous restoration, in other words, souls

Becoming god, which follows from it, let him be anathema. This meant anyone who had this viewpoint was excluded from the Christian church, from communion, and certainly in the West, if somebody held his view he was heretic, if he gave it up and fell back into this view again, He was heretic and relapsing. As heretic and relapsing, he could only face the stake. This is the degree of pressure which was brought to bear in the West against the idea of reincarnation. And therefore, the teachings of reincarnation were transmitted secretly underground.

There was among scholars in the West a transmission of platonic thought, of Plato’s teachings up to the sixteenth century, up to the Renaissance, with the great Irish monk John Scott Ariugena, who lived in the ninth century. Scholars were allowed to get away with this. Scholars were allowed to study Plato, and as long as they themselves did not say that they believed in reincarnation and did not teach it, it was acceptable. Plato was an authority. Teaching reincarnation had, as we said, dire consequences.

Reincarnationistic teachings passed into Kabbalah mysticism, in the thirteenth century in Spain, in the famous work of Jewish mysticism the Zohar, which was partly composed in Spain at the period, and which draws on Plato. Even though the Jewish mystics believe the Kabbalah can be traced back to Moses. And this underground transmission continues until the fourteenth century. Plato’s works had been lost in the West. Aristotle was rediscovered when western scholars came in contact with the Arab scholars in Spain in the twelfth century, and Aristotle became dominant, Aristotle did not teach reincarnation.

Plato was almost unknown. Plato’s works had survived in the East, in Constantinople, in Asia Minor, and even though it was it was forbidden to teach reincarnation, even though the emperor Justinian closed Plato’s academy, Plato’s school, nonetheless, it was allowed to study Plato. And all of Eastern Christianity used Greek as their dominant language. So Plato was read in the text in Greek. These teachings therefore survived in Eastern Christianity, and they survived until the fall of Constantinople in 1453.

Just before this, in 1438, 1439, a council was held in Italy to try to reunite Eastern and Western Christianity. And at this time, and this is a turning point in Western history, for the first time, Western scholars were shown Plato in the text. Who was the greatest Greek scholar of Constantinople of his age, came to this council in Italy, he brought Plato with him. And he showed the great Italian scholars Plato in the text, and they started translating Plato. When they started translating Plato, they came on the dialogues we saw.

The Republic with the account of the soul choosing its rebirth, Meno with the account of remembering or learning through remembrance. Plato was an authority. The teachings on reincarnation became respectable again. It is at this point that it happens. Until then, the teachings on reincarnation were banned.

They were banned, and they were prosecuted to a degree which beggars the imagination. For instance, one of the heresies, these were non orthodox religious movements, which spread progressively from Persia through Armenia, Yugoslavia, eventually France, was a so called Manichean heresy, which eventually became known as the Cathar heresy in France. One of the main teachings of the Manicheans and the was reincarnation. They taught reincarnation, and their teachings were very close to those of Aufius, that by a life of purity, it was possible to escape from this world which was seen as suffering. These teachings were so controversial, and I have traced here their spread.

They start in Persia in 02/2016, and then it’s the teachings spread to Armenia under the name of the Paulician heresy, to my father’s country Yugoslavia as the Bogomile heresy in September, then to the South Of France as the Cathar heresy in the twelfth and the thirteenth century, that a crusade was launched by the popes to exterminate these teachings. This is known as the inner crusade. It is estimated that in the small village of Besier in the South Of France, between ten and twenty thousand people were put to death. A knight, a Christian knight, Simon de Montfort, who launched this crusade, asked Saint Dominic, one of the greatest Christian saints of the period, how to recognize in this inner crusade, the outer crusades were against Turks, but this was an inner crusade in France, where the Christian armies concentrated on eradicating, uprooting this heresy. How to recognize a Cathar, a heretic in other words, from a good Christian.

And Saint Dominic, and you know probably the famous line said, kill them all, God will know his own. And this was done. The massacres in the South Of France beggar the imagination, and these massacres actually have had very far reaching historical consequences, since basically it is in the South Of France in turn that in the sixteenth century, the Protestant Reformation took over very powerfully, perhaps as a memory of the persecutions which had been experienced at the hands of the French royal army, and it is deputies from the South Of France in 1791, who overwhelmingly voted the death of king Louis the sixteenth. So this is how historical patterns unfold. Then moving onwards, after the fall of Constantinople, the teachings of reincarnation, because Plato was received again in the West, attained a respectability, and Gemistus Pletho, the great Greek scholar of whom we spoke, in turn was able to transmit them to the two fathers of the Italian Renaissance, Marcello Ficino and Pico della Mirandola, who taught explicitly reincarnation on Plato’s model.

In other words, they taught the reincarnation of human beings, as human beings, and they taught that the soul chooses its reincarnation. It is these teachings which then penetrated western consciousness progressively. The next turning point is the rediscovery of the Orient. The Orient had been known in Roman times, there were commercial contacts between Rome and India, as you know Alexander the Great conquered part of India. We have Buddhist dialogues, these famous dialogues of King Milinda of Menander, in which a Buddhist philosopher is actually debating with a Greek king in present day Afghanistan.

Present day Afghanistan was a Greek kingdom, the famous kingdom of Bactriana. But then after the fall of the Roman Empire, the connection between the East and the West was cut. Colonialism actually led to a reappropriation of eastern wisdom by the West. It has been one of the great benefits of colonialism if one wants to list one. Because when the British started creating commercial counters in India, it became important for purely imperial reasons for the British to understand what the Indians believed in.

Just to rule them, it was important to understand the mindset of the colonies. And therefore, William Jones creates in 1784 in Calcutta, the Royal Asiatic Society, whose goal was to translate Asian texts. William Jones was the first Sanskrit scholar of his age. A mere forty years later, Henry Thomas Colebrooke publishes five monographs on the Indian schools of philosophy. It is in 1827 that for the first time in the West, it is possible to understand what is Buddhism.

Nobody knew until this point. People had heard of someone called the Buddha, he was thought to be a legendary figure. Nobody exactly knew what he taught. These teachings were made available by Henry Thomas Colebrooke. And it is actually Colbrook’s works which were drawn upon by all the great German philosophers when they tried to present Buddhism, like Hegel’s lessons on the philosophy of history, for instance.

Then in 1844, one of the great beings to whom we owe the introduction of Buddhism to the West, translated huge waves of the Buddhist sutras into French. Taught himself all the language without ever traveling to India. He taught himself Sanskrit, he taught himself Chinese, he taught himself Pali, then he started translating, and his translations are used to the present day. They are magnificent translations. It is nineteenth century French.

It is it is just beautiful. Based on work, a German author, Carl Friedrich Koppen, created a synthesis in 1860, which is the synthesis on which all European thought in the nineteenth century relied, the religion of the Buddha. Schopenhauer, when he declared himself a Buddhist, relied on Koppen. Nietzsche, when he presents Buddhism in Twilight of the Idols, for instance, relied on Koppen. It is through Koppen, who himself relied on Burnouf, who himself relied on Colbrook, who himself relied on the work of William Jones, that the transmission to the West started.

And finally, the Buddhist teachings became known to the wider public in a work which is probably completely unknown to most of you, but which was a best seller in its age. Edwin Arnold’s The Light of Asia. Edwin Arnold was a Victorian poet, who wrote a praise of the Buddha in English, an English verse. It’s beautiful poetry, where he, and it is revolutionary for the period, puts Buddha on the same level as Christ. Buddha is the Christ of the East.

Buddhism has gone from being a tradition which is a threat, which is ominous, it is the nihilism of each, teaching soullessness, to the second revelation. This was a book which had a tremendous impact. You can still get it in India to this day if you are interested. And at this point, we see the appropriation of Buddhism by intellectuals. We have the great figure, one of my favorite philosophers when I was young, Arthur Schopenhauer, one of the greatest German philosophers.

Disciple of Kant, who nicknamed his poodle Ātman, and who has this most extraordinary line. At the age of 17, without a university degree, I was overwhelmed by the suffering of life as the Buddha was in his youth when he discovered the existence of disease, aging, suffering and death. This was written in 1832. Schopenhauer Howard goes on to write one of the most important works of nineteenth century philosophy, the world as will and representation, in which he attempts to present in terms of German philosophy Buddhist thought. He teaches that the entire world as we know it is a creation of will, we would say in Buddhist terms of intention, and that the goal of the philosopher is by putting an end to self will, by putting an end to will, to lead to the disappearance of the world, and his return to the state of pure consciousness.

It is surprisingly close to the Buddhist teachings for someone who had access to almost no material. And this led to a split in European thought between German philosophers, who had extremely powerful affinities with Buddhist thought, and French philosophers who were vitalistic, much later with Bergson especially, and who found this German fascination for India, which was seen by the German philosophers as the birthplace of thought and philosophy, and with Buddhism in particular as very disturbing. And this led the French ambassador to Prussia to say, scratch the German, and you will see reappear an ancient disciple of the Buddha. He is writing to the French government, it’s later published in one of his works. They sincerely believe in the doctrine of transmigration and of past lives, and see in the alliance of Kant, the foremost German philosopher, and the Buddha, the seed for the future progress of the world.

This was written in 1862. Then Indian wisdom, Indian schools of philosophy, and I’m sorry I couldn’t avoid being a little bit sharp here, entered popular culture. That’s why I call Theosophy the poor man’s wisdom of the East. With the colonial venture, the issue which which arose for the first time was Western intellectuals, but the ordinary Western man was face to face with cultures, which disagreed pretty much about everything with western culture. It was something radically new.

The West had lived in a bubble until then. Suddenly, British officers were traveling to India, they were coming back and they were saying the Indians believe in reincarnation. The Buddhists don’t believe in God. All of the certainties the West was built upon started collapsing. There were ancient cultures, which had radically different viewpoints.

It became capital to try to harmonize these, and this was part of the effort of Victor ian England. A very colorful character, Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, who pretty much seems to have done everything in her life, from circus dancer to ballet dancer to perhaps less reputable occupations, discovered herself a mystic, and very conveniently for her at an age where access to Tibet was impossible, found that she was in constant contact with Tibetan masters by telepathy, the so called mahatmas, the great souls, and they started giving her instructions. It became very awkward for the Theosophists when the Tibetans came out of Tibet in nineteen fifty fifty nine, and they said, missus Blavatsky, who? But until then, Theosophy had a very good ride of it. She discovered herself in contact with these these great beings, these mahatmas, and she wrote two major works in which what she basically did was to try to connect what she knew of Indian philosophy and the Victorian worldview.

So she basically taught explicitly reincarnation, but she taught reincarnation in the light of what she knew of Plato. So she taught reincarnation as a necessary good. This is radically at odds with the Indian viewpoint. Reincarnation is a positive phenomenon. We reincarnate, it’s a source of happiness, of rejoicing, we will not disappear.

More disturbingly, she drew on what she knew of Darwin’s thought and taught reincarnation as evolutionary. The goal of reincarnation was to move upwards from the lower levels of incarnation, which oddly enough tend to be very dark in skin color and uneducated, upwards to higher levels of reincarnation, which were the Asian races, upwards yet again to the pinnacle of reincarnation, which was being reborn as a Victorian gentleman, preferably in England. Now this is actually what was taught. It sounds extraordinarily disturbing in this day and age, but the theosophical understanding of reincarnation is this one, and this is what passed into more recent theosophists like Alice Bailey. It is actually a racial hierarchy disguised in the framework of reincarnation.

And what is a constant in all of the western teachings on reincarnation, a lack of emphasis on any liberation. This is completely absent. It is absent from Pythagoras through to Blavatsky and onwards. Reincarnation is a good, the soul chooses its rebirth,

The notion of moksha or liberation is absent. There’s only one Greek philosopher, Proclus, who says that it is possible for the philosopher to gain liberation from the cycle of lives, but he doesn’t really see the point. So this aspect of the Western understanding of reincarnation is something which is totally at odds with the Indian understanding, which sees reincarnation as a tragic state of affairs marked by suffering, and escape from the jail, the prison of reincarnation as the goal. And finally, I wanted to conclude with the transmission of Tibetan Buddhism to the West. The transmission of Buddhism to the West started much earlier, as we saw, and it started formally in England with the transmission of the Pali Canon with Rhys Davids, and the creation of Theravada Buddhist monasteries and centers.

The totality of the Pali Canon was translated into English, and it had a big impact on Anglo Saxon society, largely thanks to Theosophy, one has to give credit where credit is due, Theosophy was extraordinarily helpful in the transmission of the Buddhist teachings to the West, by making them more acceptable in a wide swathe of population, even though its understanding was not very accurate. In 1959, the fourteenth Dalai Lama flees the Chinese occupation to Dharamsala, and in the nineteen sixties, and we are the inheritors of this, great Tibetan masters are sent directly by the Dalai Lama to the West. This is Geshe Sopa to Wisconsin, one of Kensur Rinpoche’s classmates, to Seattle, to Paris, my root teacher, to Switzerland, to Hamburg. Taught at the University of Wisconsin, he became he took a PhD and became full professor of Tibetan language. He trained many of my teachers in The United States, such as Jeffrey Hopkins, but also Betsy Napper, and most of the authors who publish now for wisdom are disciples in terms of my teachers, whether it is John Powers, Bill McGee, Alan Cole, and so forth.

Deshung Rinpoche was a Sakya lama who taught at the University of Washington in Seattle. He in turn trained scholars such as Cyrus Stearns in the Sakya tradition. He trained Melvin Goldstein, those of you who study Tibetan use his dictionary. Dagpo Rinpoche was sent to Paris, he was brought to Paris by Stein actually. He trained many of the contemporary French scholars in Buddhist studies.

My teacher Geshe Rabten in turn trained scholars like Tom Tillemans, like Greg, and so forth. In 1970, the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives was created in Dharamsala to enable westerners to study Tibetan Buddhism with authoritative Tibetan teachers, another one of Kensur Rinpoche’s classmates, Geshe Ngawang Dhargyey, taught them. The first Buddhist teachings I ever received in 1981, received from him at the library. Alex Bersin used to translate. And this spearheaded the transmission of Buddhism to the West through the young westerners who traveled to India and to Nepal, searching for spiritual truth.

And finally, in 1970, Serraje monastery was recreated in India, as well as Drepung and Ganden, allowing the complete transmission of the monastic tradition to India. At present, we have at Sera Je monastery, a compound, which is exclusively dedicated to the training of young western monks, who enter the monastery as monks, study the totality of the Tibetan corpus, exactly on the same level as Tibetan monks, and hopefully become geshes. We have 15 rooms, of which 10 are full. Most of our monks are of a very high caliber. We have people with BA’s or Master’s from Princeton, a Dutch engineer, a biologist, two graduates in philosophy, and I think if there is a transmission, authentic transmission of the totality of the Buddhist tradition to the West in the future, it will be through Sera IMI that it will happen.

Thank you very much. I think I have said what I wanted to say for this conference, and I am at present open to your questions. Yes. There are many. It starts by being very naive, actually.

In the Upanishads, it is said to be a purusha, which is the size of a thumb and which lives in the heart. Then it becomes and this is where it becomes very awkward for Hinduism philosophically. It becomes a soul. So in you remember the six views we presented. The basic problem for Hinduism is how does a soul, which is permanent and has no parts, the Ātman, connect to the mind.

The mind connects to the body. Then, if the soul is permanent, it has to connect somehow to this mind, which itself the the Indian thinkers acknowledge is impermanent, it changes. And what they end up by saying is that the mind arises at the intersection of the ātman in the body, and therefore the mind has a material component. So Chitta, what they call mind, is not at all understood as Chitta in Buddhism. The Ātman, which is the soul, is the individual self.

It is that which reincarnates from life to life. And then some of the Indian traditions say that part of citta incarnates as well from life to life. And the path to liberation, certainly in Vedanta, by no means in all of the Indian schools, but in Vedanta, is this realization that this ātman, this soul, is not different in any respect from the universal soul, Brahman, which created the universe. So it is a viewpoint which is very different from the Buddhist viewpoint. Then the big problem as the Indian philosophers encounter is how can there be any transmission of information from citta to ātman.

Ātman is permanent, citta is impermanent. Certainly, some of the schools like the Nyaya school basically consider that Ātman never learns anything. Ātman according to Nyaya is actually unconscious. Unconscious. Some of the other schools disagree.

But you can see the problem. If you have a permanent soul, there could be no change in this soul. There could be no experience. So the very real question is what is moksha, liberation in this case? Is there self awareness during moksha?

It’s not clear that it is possible for the Indian schools. Does that answer your question? It’s difficult. I I was reading in India Santarakshita’s Tattvasamgraha, where he actually it’s a gigantic work in which he criticizes Indian school, so he presents their viewpoints magnificently, more or less at the seventh century, and they run into major problems. But it’s the same type of problems with the which the non Buddhist Indian schools of philosophy run into, when they postulate a god and karma.

Where’s the middle ground? How do they share responsibilities? Karma works, but then God intervenes sometimes and karma doesn’t work, or it’s all God and no karma. Like, with the bhakti traditions, you have the impression it’s all God and no karma. With the yoga traditions of Patanjali, you have the impression it’s all karma and no god.

Where they draw the middle line is very awkward. I think what is very clear is that the Ātman is not a person. So the Hindu idea of liberation does not mean that the individual is saved at all. And actually, it’s not terribly clear what difference you postulate between the Ātman’s of each one of us. Once they become one with the Brahman, the question doesn’t arise.

So we can say that for all Indian traditions, liberation entails the annihilation of the personality. And what about Christianity? I’m not sure what about what I want to read in the past. Christianity? Yes.

It’s very different. Very different. Well, there’s a lot of disagreement to start with. There’s a lot of disagreement. Typically, Christianity tends to take on board Plato’s idea of the soul pretty uncritically.

And then in Christianity, you have two contradictory viewpoints which coexist. That of the soul being saved, and that of bodily resurrection at the end of time to face judgment. It’s actually the coexistence of the platonic viewpoint and the semitic viewpoint. So this sort of coexist, you know, then Aquinas tries to to bridge the two. What Aquinas says, if my memory serves me well, is that after death, the soul is in something akin to a limbo.

It’s not clear whether he the soul is conscious or not, until the time of the bodily resurrection. At the time of the bodily resurrection, the soul enters the body it had. I think Aquinas says it is the premium age, which mean that in your twenties, you know. And then the body and the soul stand judgment in this state. You can see how these teachings are completely incompatible with reincarnation.

So it’s one of the tensions in Christianity. Christianity is a religion which arises at the junction of Semitic thought and Greek philosophy, and is always trying to bridge the two with mixed results. Does that help? Are there other questions? Yes, Molly.

So Buddhism is anti life. To be very blunt about these things, it’s anti life as we understand life. If you mean by life what we are doing here and now, eating, walking, building skyscrapers, etc, in our present state, all of this is what Buddhism rejects. Now, regarding liberation, there are two presentations. There is a presentation of the Theravada and the presentation of the Mahāyāna.

Theravada presentation is that Nirvāṇa or liberation means the cessation, the end of the continuum of the being concerned. Body and mind cease. It is the end of the process of reincarnation. And in the dharmapada, the Buddha has a magnificent line where he says, I have seen the builder of the house, and no house shall he build anymore. The flame shall no longer be lit in the lamp.

So certainly, in the Theravada tradition, at least in the early Theravada tradition, liberation is seen as what is called in Tibetan, remainderless liberation. There is no remainder. There is an interruption of consciousness and of body. Nothing is ever reborn again. And upon reaching that state, the Theravada understanding of the Buddha’s final Nirvāṇa, parinirvana, is that the Buddha stops to exist.

Therefore, from a pure Theravada standpoint, when Theravadans pray to the Buddha, they pray to someone who does not exist. The Mahāyāna understanding of liberation is different. The Mahāyāna understanding is that liberation is one step, a major step, leading to full enlightenment. It means the end of all suffering. It means the end of all afflictions.

And when one reaches liberation, the mind enters into what is compared to a state of trance, which is open ended. Oneself experiences no suffering, one is no longer reborn, one has no body, and this open ended state can continue indefinitely. However, it is said the Buddhas then intervene to draw the arhat, those who have reached liberation, from this state, and set them on the path of the Bodhisattva. It is also said that it takes much longer for them to reach full enlightenment, because having experienced the ecstasy of non suffering, they find it very difficult to understand the suffering of others, and find it very difficult to create compassion. Does that answer your question?

Yes, please. On what top just born. In terms of reincarnation, you mean? Well, we’ll perhaps leave Japanese history to the side because Japanese thought draws pretty much everything of importance from Chinese thought. And if we take Chinese thought, the issue of personal survival after death is certainly unclear up to the introduction of Buddhism in China.

So up to the beginning of the Christian era. Buddhism is introduced in China maybe sixty five BC. It is not clear in Confucius’ works whether he gets any particular position regarding survival after death. The ancestors survive, they are venerated, one owes offering sacrifices to the ancestors. So this is perhaps the primitive religion of all of mankind.

You find this in Africa, the cult of ancestors. Taoism has no particular position at the period regarding survival after death. The Taoist ideal is one of functioning in harmony with the world, in harmony with the Tao, it is not that different from the stoic ideal of functioning in harmony with the logos. Then with the introduction of Buddhism, and that’s why I think Buddhism was phenomenally successful in China, an answer to these questions was given. So the Buddhists taught past and future lives, and, these teachings were then integrated into Confucianism and Taoism after the introduction of Buddhism.

Unfortunately, Buddhism was contaminated very strongly by Taoism in China. There’s a lot of evidence that what we call the Chan tradition, the Zen tradition, is almost half Buddhist, half Taoist. And it’s quite striking when you read Chan works, There’s very little mention of past and future lives. It’s very interesting. Chan Buddhists are Buddhists, but you don’t find as in the Tibetan or Indian or Theravada tradition, this emphasis on past and future lives in escaping from the cycle of lives, to my knowledge.

So I think that’s what I can say on the topic. Are there other questions? Yes. Yes. That is actually not Buddhist, that is shared by all of the Indian religions.

All of the Indian religions have the same presentation of saṃsāra, psychic existence. There are there’s a human realm, there’s the animal realm, there are the hungry ghosts, the pretas, there are the hells, and the number of the hells differ in Hinduism and in Buddhism, but basically, certainly in Buddhism, the hells are seen as mental creations. Then you have the realm of the asuras, the demigods, the realm of the gods. So that presentation is shared. Where the Buddhists and the Hindus differ is that for the Hindus, it is believed that liberation is becoming bharma.

If you become

Bahama, you are liberated. For the Buddhists, Bahama is just a sentient being. So if you become Bahama, you remain Bahama for a god for an infinitely long period of time, but eventually you fall from that state and it all starts over again. So I would say the Buddhist vision of saṃsāra is perhaps a little bit more all encompassing. Then regarding the hell realms, they are big problem for Westerners.

I think there’s sort of a consensus among the Tibetan masters that it’s better simply not to talk about the topic. We have learned to shy away from a series of very loaded topics which Westerners reject. There’s no point. People get angry. You know?

However, if you look at experience, then There are Tibetan yogis, they are called delo, those who went and came back, who died, and after a week, sometimes two weeks, returned to life. These cases are attested in the twentieth century. They do this by choice, generally, and they report traveling to these realms. Then anyone who can enter into that sort of trance, I think, is worth listening to. Obviously, it’s not something any one of us can do.

Right? And what is very puzzling is that in the cases of hypnotic regression we will cover tomorrow, Alberto Rochard, the French colonel who who was director of the Ecole Polytechnique, I mean, it’s like director of ANU, level 1,000. Right? It’s it was a top French school, top French university. He actually regressed some 19 patients in the early early twentieth century, one of whom, a woman, reported, it was a verified regression, she was able to trace her past lives, reported living in a hell realm in the intermediate state.

And she reported being harassed and tormented by black spirits, as she described them. So there is some evidence from hypnotic regression. I think if we think of the nature of the mind, it is quite easy to understand. We see for ourselves, just as human beings. How we see the world depends on our mind.

If you’re happy, the birds are singing and the flowers, you know, are blooming. If you are unhappy, everything is under a cast of darkness. People who are depressed see everything in the most negative light possible. Now by extension, it can go much deeper than this. Not just depression, but anger and hatred.

People who see all others as hostile automatically, projecting their own hostility on the world. If this goes to an extreme, the person creates mentally a world, which is a world of infinite anger, brutality, and violence, and upon death is reborn into that. Then the historian of Dalai Lama about the hero and said, I hope they’re not true. So I certainly hope they’re not true. I personally am convinced they exist, for theoretical reasons simply because I think the mind can infinitely improve.

Mind is impermanent. If it can infinitely improve, it can infinitely degenerate. And the state of complete degeneration, that is one of the hell realms. Then I I have no desire to go there and check. But, you know, if you take this world of ours and you think, what here, to Australians, your country now is at war in Afghanistan, what sort of experience would it be like to be an Australian digger kidnapped by the Afghan mujahideen and skinned alive, which is what is done, before being, let’s say, roasted on a skewer over a fire?

There are videos of this which circulate in India, you know. Then that is just a human experience of suffering. Can there be worse than that, or not? That we have to think for ourselves, you know. And then we have to think that human experience of suffering, that’s what we will cover this afternoon, is it cause or not?

Is it just random, it happens, wrong place, wrong time as we say nowadays, or is there a cause? Now, if it’s just random, wrong place, wrong time, then there’s no point in putting any effort in any type of spiritual practice in this life. Then, before we are born there is nothing, after we are born, there is nothing. Then we go to the beach and we have fun, because that’s all there is. If on the other hand, these experiences have causes, then it is very important for us to try to find what the causes are.

Because if we can eliminate the causes, we can eliminate the experiences. So that’s up to us. That’s our freedom. All of us in this room are free. Most people in the West are not interested in these things.

I read a recent scientific study. According to some sociologists, it would seem that in 20 countries in the the West, religion is condemned to disappear within the next decades. And the top of these countries include Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and Finland. And they did this basically just doing a meta meta analysis of the data of general religious interest in church attendance. So that’s the way it is.

I think religion as a phenomenon, is probably condemned. Most people nowadays have faith in science. They have the same faith in science they used to have in religion. So that’s quite amusing, you know, because basically the mind hasn’t changed, you know. But whether this faith in science can help or not, that’s an open question.

People find it quite shocking when I say this, but for instance, every one of you in this room considers that, you know for instance, electrons exist, atoms exist. Not one of you has checked. Right? None of us has checked. None of us has taken an electron microscope and tried to check.

So why do you consider atoms exist? Because a scientist says so. Why don’t you believe hell realms exist? Because a lama says so. If a scientist said so, you would believe it.

So your belief or your disbelief depends on authority. There’s been no change. We haven’t become more rational. We have just changed the authorities we believe in. So a true scientist who goes and checks and who says, atoms exist because I went and I looked, past and future lives exist because I went and I checked, or they don’t exist because I went and I checked, that type of scientist is a sort of scientist we are in complete agreement with.

But the prejudiced scientists and people who have faith in science in the same same way they had faith in the church in the Middle Ages without ever checking anything, you know. Those people, they haven’t changed. Have they? Who goes and checks? Now it’s not unimportant.

Let’s take the issue of past and future lives. Our survival after death or not is the most important question in our life. Everything else doesn’t matter, whether we’re rich or poor, hungry or not hungry, have a nice house or not. If we survive death, there is hope. If we don’t survive death, there is nothing.

Now, we have to make a fundamental decision. Either there is nothing, and if there is nothing, we have to behave as suggested. Do what you want with due regard to the policeman around the corner. Or perhaps, even have the courage to be a tyrant, to be a monster, to rule over all and put our pleasure above that everyone else. Why not?

If there is nothing, and you are firmly believed of that, you’re not becoming a tyrant is a sign of cowardice. It’s possible. Just because you have very good karmic imprints. But ask yourself. Yes.

But why would you bother? You won’t be there? No. They won’t know? There is no meaning.

What we are told by the likes of Dawkins is that life is a gigantic joke. It’s a gigantic accident. There was some strange quirk in the big soup at the beginning of biology, and amino acids arose, and there was another strange quirk, and then information was generated in the form of DNA, which somehow structured these amino acids. Nobody tells us how. And then these quirks perpetuated, and eventually complex organisms arose, ever more complex organisms, and consciousness then is like another major accident in the whole schema.

Actually, one of the biggest problems biologists have is giving an evolutionary justification for consciousness, which in terms of the brain structure it uses is an extremely expensive phenomenon to maintain. You know? So if we are just biological accidents, and if you’re going to be if you’re going to get somewhere with your practice, you have to go to the end of things. Otherwise, this sort of wishy washy approach doesn’t work. If you’re to be a nihilist, okay?

Take nihilism, read, can we go to the end end of things? If it is just an accident, if we are just biological accidents, if consciousness is a quirk nobody understands, perhaps it enhances the survival capacities of the organism, but it’s not really clear to explain. Why do anything? The only thing perhaps is to search for pleasure, and try not to get into trouble. But if you can get even greater pleasure without getting into trouble, why not?

Now this is a viewpoint of ninety nine percent of the Australians, as far as I can see. As far as I can see around me, as long as you can get away with it, it’s okay. It’s drugs, it’s alcohol, it’s promiscuity on scales which beggar the imagination. I mean, I read somewhere to my surprise that Australians are the foremost group internationally arrested in Thailand for pedophilia. There’s 20,000,000 Australians, right?

I mean, of all the foreigners going to Australia, to to Thailand, it’s Australians who are the foremost offenders. Now this is what is this? This is something which comes from a profoundly nihilistic society. So when you’re away from the policeman in a country like Thailand, when you can get away with it, you give you do anything you want. So this shows clearly that nihilism prevents ethics.

There’s no possibility to found ethics on nihilism. The only way is what we have nowadays, which is laws. And much of modernity is a process of transference of ethics and morality to the legal level. It doesn’t work. We end up with ultra controlled societies and very unhappy societies.

So this question, is there a life after death? Is there a transmission of the mind after death? Number one. Number two, what is it? Is it one life as a Christian say, the Jews and the Muslims?

Is it many lives as the Hindus, Buddhists, the Jains say? This is a fundamental question. This is not a luxury. It’s not a luxury for westerners with time on their hands. It is the most important question.

Question. And your jobs, your money, your relationships, those are luxuries. Because all that is going to be taken from us. Everything we have will be taken from us. So before that happens, we have to make a decision, and then we have to live our lives in keeping with that.

Now whether we go that route or not, that’s a private choice. Yes? In the context of this talk, yes. But generally speaking, no, there’s a big difference. There’s a gradation.

We go from having doubt regarding reincarnation, which I think is the case of all of us in this room, towards a doubt which airs towards a positive. We think there is such a thing. We are not sure. And it is said the transition from that to conviction is a huge experience. So our goal is that.

Our goal is to pass from a doubt airing towards a factual to a conviction. That experience will change our lives. We will not live the same way after that. And then after that, there is the what is called an inferential cognition. This is a mind which can no longer be reverted, which is sure of reincarnation.

This is the goal of all the Buddhist treatises. Then you walk off, give up everything you you used to do, and live a very different life. Yes. Excuse me. Oh, yes.

But first, you have to believe it happens. Yes. Yes. I think in Buddhist cultures, the issue is addressed completely differently. Those who are raised in Buddhist traditions have direct experience of this.

It’s not a case of believing, it’s generally speaking a case of knowing. In Thailand, instance, in Tibet, people know people who remember past lives. Members of their family are said to be the reincarnation of such and such. The phenomenon of spirit possession is very widespread. Then when you see a spirit entering someone’s body, you know that the mind can exist out of the body.

Then in those cases there is no doubt at all. My girlfriend is Thai for instance. Her grandfather has a very large following in Thailand, and she herself had an aunt whose nephew was a bit of a good for nothing. And, he had a very bad car accident and was killed. Then he possessed her mother in front of his mother to try to speak with his mother.

He was he died as a young boy, you know, and her mother is very sensitive to these things. He entered her mother, and he started telling his mother things only she and he knew. And it became a very big problem, because my friend’s mother is exhausted after each of these experiences. I can see Chris’s body language is the language of complete rejection here. But, you see, she eventually spoke to this boy in her mother’s body and told him never to return, because he was not making peace with his mother, and he was exhausting her own mother.

Now, these are experiences I will not talk about here, because I think for most of you it is impossible to connect with it. We all come from strong materialistic traditions, and this tends to be extremely disturbing for us. But you find in cultures like the Tibetan, the Indian, the Thai cultures, this is part of the family life. And therefore, in this respect, they start at a much higher level than us. There is absolute certainty that the mind is not a product of the brain.

Brain. This is absent in Westerners. And one has to move up to this. This is a source, I think, of the tremendous anguish you see in so many Westerners, and often those who come to centers come to try to find a way out of this fear and anguish. Because there is this fear that at the time of death, it is over.

And I think the only way to address it is through multiple lines of reasoning. So this afternoon we will address the logical reasonings, and then tomorrow we’re going to focus a lot on the empirical data. But ultimately, for all of us, the only way is to use these talks as a springboard to gain our own experiences. Because in this matter there’s only two categories of persons, those who know and those who don’t. Those who know have been there and have seen.

Those who don’t have not yet been there. And the only person who can take that decision is ourselves. If you study the material, if you meditate, if you try to do retreats, you will eventually gain experiences, then you will know. Until you do that, it is just talk. So in Asia, they are very fortunate in the Buddhist societies because in many Buddhist societies, it’s just there, and you’ll see in Stevenson’s cases, the cases in Asia, the families just take it for granted.

Yes, the boy who has returned is the reincarnation of the young girl who was killed in a bus accident, 50 kilometers away, and that’s the way it is. And, you know, there’s nothing there to be surprised by or shocked. But we in the West, have so much interiorized nihilism that it is very difficult for us. So I’m sorry, it’s a very long answer to your question. Yes

No. It’s a very good example. And they say, you see, well, I’ve experienced it, and I know it’s true. So how can how can you explain it? How can So that is the reason for which in the Buddhist tradition we, have strong strictures against ever talking about these experiences.

You know? Because they attract a sensationalistic mindset and they never convince. Unless the person has walked the walk themselves, there’s no point. So in centers we tend to talk the talk. Then it’s up to you whether you walk the walk, all of us.

Not based on a genuine exploration. This is what pointed out in some of his work, cutting through spiritual materialism. There’s a strong element of spiritual voyeurism in the West. We can’t experience things, but we look at others living them. In our case, it’s the Tibetans who live the spirituality we can’t live.

There’s no fundamental difference between this and sexual voyeurism. It’s the same incapacity to experience something and living it vicariously through another person. Is of no benefit whatsoever. The only point of teachings is to check oneself whether they are true or not. And this is what I’d like to end with for today.

I think for all of us, there’s really only one question we have to ask, and there’s a lot of resistance to asking this question. But you owe it to yourselves having taken a weekend off to come to this workshop to ask the question. It’s a question of truth. Is this true or false? Is this true or not true?

At a certain point you have to decide. You cannot be indefinitely in a state of suspension of disbelief, studying what the Buddhists say, studying what the Hindus say, studying what the Taoists say, doing a bit of rigging. At a certain point you have to decide, because it not is a trivial topic, it’s fundamental for our future and these decisions affect the lives we lead. So obviously you have to document yourself at first. That’s clear.

But what we find with Western student centres is an indefinite period of self documentation. It just goes on forever. Then this is of no benefit to the student and ultimately it is harm to the community. The student might be better off doing something else. So have the courage to ask the question of truth.

Is it true? Is there such a thing as reincarnation? If there is, what reincarnation are we talking about? Or is it force? If it’s false, then go to a barbecue.

Why why me here? If it is true, then you have to ask yourself, what does this mean for me in terms of my life? Should I be doing things differently? And how should I be doing things? Then I was going to talk about this this afternoon, but basically we’ll take just one more minute for this.

A clear sign of understanding of karma and causality is that the person becomes very careful, very fearful, Very fearful. Because one doesn’t really know what consequences deeds have. Then one doesn’t casually put something on a book. One doesn’t casually misbehave, because when somebody realizes that that pound of flesh will be taken from us down the line, then one becomes extra cautious. Even when some of the teachings sound strange to us, for instance making prostrations with hands splayed out is a cause of a rebirth as an insect, one on the side of caution thinking, yes, perhaps through habituation.

That’s a sign of integration of common causality in one’s life. That’s a bit the goal of this seminar. Thank you very much. So we’re going to be seeing three videos during the next two days. All our interviews, I’m unfortunately rather limited in which can be shown because of copyright reasons.

But Steve Sakellarius, who made the interviews, gave me permission to show these here. So we are very grateful to him. And today, the first two videos will be interviews of professor Robert Almeder, who is a Professor of Philosophy at Georgia State University, one of the main contemporary philosophers who believes in reincarnation, on the validity of the data, empirical data which Stevenson has collected for reincarnation. And the second interview we will be seeing today, which is very interesting, is an interview with Tom Schroeder, who composed Old Souls. I strongly recommend the book, it’s in the bibliography, one of your bibliographies.

Tom Schroeder is a Washington Post journalist who became fascinated by Stevenson’s research and traveled with him throughout India and The Middle East, documenting the way he’s worked. Now what’s interesting with Schroeder is that Schroeder was a self-described skeptic. He really didn’t believe in this stuff at all, and he traveled with Stevenson just to document his work and has left really a magnificent piece of work in his book Old Souls. So first we’re to listen to Robert Almeida on the topic. I think you’ll find him very articulate.

There are some advantages to a training in philosophy, which is that the mind becomes very clear, and he’s able to formulate the issues quite simply and succinctly. Television one day and I saw the BB special on reincarnation, and it was very accidental and Ian Stevenson was standing there talking quietly about case studies he had conducted over a fifteen or twenty year period and they showed on the television the book 20 cases suggestive of reincarnation. I thought that might be very interesting, so I went out and bought the book and I started reading the book. And one of the things you’ll find that when you read the case studies rather than talk about what they are without reading them closely, there’s a kind of force to the case studies that is really enticing, enthralling. What I did is I read them all the way through, and I put down the book, and I said, now this must be wrong, and here, I started reading, so I began reading it, and the more I read, the more I realized that this is Stevenson’s seminal work.

It’s we’ll be talking of doctor Stevenson’s research tomorrow, but his most important initial work was 20 cases of the reincarnation type, where he documented 20 cases of reincarnation which were verified. In other words, he took the spontaneous memories of the children of a past life, and he went and checked these memories, and in a series of cases, he was able to verify the accuracy of the memories. This was important, and it was good research, empirical research, and that it rendered it a scientific question, and that I couldn’t think of any alternative explanation as plausible for the data as that some people reincarnate. As a matter of fact, some people have said after reading the data in the past ten years, why some people have said, look, maybe it’s not unreasonable to believe that some people reincarnate. And Stevenson says that it’s certainly not unreasonable to believe because this is the best fit on the data.

My reaction is stronger. My claim was that in the book that it’s irrational to disbelieve it, and a lot of people thought that was over the top, that was too strong a claim. I amended in a very simple way that if you have a commanding argument that you can’t refute, not to accept the argument is to act irrationally. That’s what I’m saying, that there’s a very strong argument here that has not been refuted and cannot be refuted by my lights, not cannot, but has not been refuted, and it’s irrational not to accept it. The conclusion is that some people reincarnate, meaning by implication that human beings are more than their bodies, that human personality in the end is not reducible to a statement about biochemical states, brain states, biological functional properties produced by brain states or anything like that.

What follows is that human personality as we know it cannot be adequately understood in terms of classical standard psychology which works on a purely materialistic basis. In other words, to explain human behavior, why people do what they do, on a purely materialistic model, which we typically do, will leave important things out because if human beings are more than their bodies and their minds are causally relevant in producing their behaviors, and the minds are not simply brains, then to explain the behavior you have to appeal to causes that are quite unlike anything people in standard psychology talk about. So one of the implications of this would be that there’s something wrong with psychology as we know it on a purely physicalistic model, that it will not be able to succeed in explaining these kinds of cases and probably not a number of others. In fact, fact, I take the evidence for reincarnation to be relatively important by way of suggesting that there’s something fundamentally wrong about psychology, contemporary psychology, as we know it on a behavioristic model because it’s only assuming that all explanations of behavior will be handled in terms of biochemistry and neural anatomy and things of that sort.

So in other words, if this data is acceptable, it shows that our way of explaining human behavior has to break out of the existing paradigm. It also suggests that there’s some incredible mysteries here about human nature that we can’t begin to fathom. For example, if reincarnation is true, in these case studies, might not know how it occurs, the mechanism it of occurs, or what happens to these particular beings disembodied between lives. We don’t know where they go, what they do, whether they like it or not. There’ll be an awful lot of questions left over and even if we can’t answer them, how does it happen, why does it happen, what’s the point of it, we can conclude that it happens in some cases.

The recent interest in reincarnation in this country is primarily attributable to Ian Stevenson who is a trained physician psychiatrist initially a pediatric psychiatrist holding a chair in abnormal psychology. Stevenson is the prime mover of the data because he’s made it a research project for thirty or forty years of examining children and seeing whether their claims to have relived, to have reincarnated are actually substantial. His work is revolutionary in that he’s the first one to take children seriously, asking what would it take to show that what they’re saying is true. And his work is revolutionary in that without being overly aggressive about it, he takes each alternative explanation of the cases that are strong and shows why they they don’t seem to work very well, the counter room. So my experience is that he’s extremely hard working, very quiet, and he doesn’t really care to share any light, you know, pop.

He’d rather not it’d be very hard to get him on a television program. He did it once and his claim was that it was more for entertainment than for information and he didn’t think he’d rather do that anymore. He doesn’t want to be identified with the New Age because your New Age movements seem to be problematic. They jump on the bandwagon and you know, he doesn’t particularly care to be identified with parapsychologists who jump on it because they don’t seem to do the research. But he’s done the research, he’s got the case studies and so I think his work is very important if not Copernican in nature.

As a person I find him a genuinely likeable, enjoyable person who is articulate, thoughtful, and a good dinner companion, and a gracious a gracious man whom I admire a great deal. He’s only too willing to be very helpful for people who are trying to get to the bottom of it. And when I first did my book, he read it from line to line and made innumerable suggestions that benefited it, even down to the spellings. I tend to be a bad speller. So he’s very free with his time for people who are sincere and earnest in their attempts to understand the material.

As for his integrity, he doesn’t push the view on anybody and as some people have said that, but he doesn’t push the view on anybody and I think he’s incapable of the kind of lie distortion or manipulation of the data that others would submit to because I think he’s more interested in really finding out what it is and he’s careful enough to say that certain cases are bad cases, they’re frauds and so on. So I find him a person of great integrity. Somebody said, Well look, why even get involved in this because 80% of it’s fraud? And I believe that may be true, 80% of it may be fraud. But the important point is that if a 100 people jump off the Empire State Building and 95 of them land just as you expect they would, painfully and disastrously, But five land gently and walk away.

What do you think needs to be explained? The five that landed gently and walked away, they’re statistically deviant. So some people will say in statistics, you don’t have to explain any of this data because it’s so infrequent and it’s statistically deviant and that most cases like this will turn out to be frauds. But when you take the clear cases and the hard cases, you can’t explain those away by saying they’re like the other ones because you take them because they’re very much unlike the other ones that were wrong. So that sort of stuff.

But there will be other objections too. I’ve heard people say reincarnation couldn’t occur because we don’t know how it could occur. We don’t know how. As scientists we don’t know what the mechanism is, we don’t know how it couldn’t have a mechanism that we could examine, so we can’t know that it occurs. As objections go, that certainly leaves a good deal to be desired because you may not know how something occurs, but have plenty of evidence that it occurs.

I don’t know how Sloughfoot won the fifth race at Hialeah, but I can know that he did very easily. I don’t know how you got into this room, but I know that you’re here, that sort of story. So you don’t have to know why things end up the way they are, although in mature science all our explanations will be causal. But there are kinds of explanations of events that are not causal, but they are purely statistical, you know that something’s occurring, but you don’t know why. So I think you can see the advantage of having a well trained philosopher address the issues.

I think one of the strongest points for me, which I made, makes is precisely that even if 80% of the cases are fraud, This is a very, very high number. I think it’s from true. The problem is how do we explain the authentic cases. Now we will see tomorrow, Stevenson studied two thousand five hundred cases of children recollecting past lives. It’s a huge number.

He studied them in person. He averaged 55,000 miles of air travel per year most of his life. Of those two thousand five hundred cases, eight hundred ninety five are verified. Eight hundred ninety five cases were the memories of the child, not one memories, in some cases 40 or 50 different items of memory were checked in reality against the past of the child. Of these eight ninety five verified cases, Stevenson considers there are thirty five cases for which there is absolutely no possible explanation apart from reincarnation.

Using the harshest possible criteria, the families never met,

The families have no incentive. The child, for instance, remembered being a Muslim and was born in a Hindu family or the opposite. The families often had a financial disincentive and worked actively to prevent these accounts from being published. So those 35 cases, there’s a five people who land from the Empire State Building in Walk. We have to explain them.

And then as we’ll see what is very striking with Stevenson’s research is he started his research on these cases in 1961, he passed on in 2007, his work has basically been ignored by the scientific community. And yet he was dean of the faculty of psychiatry at my alma mater, the University of Virginia, head head of the division of personality studies, a highly respected scientist in all other matters. So it begs a lot of questions. I think what it shows is perhaps the degree of prejudice to this day against the idea of reincarnation in, let’s say, socially respectable academia. And then, I’d like to pass on to the second.

Robert Almeder, a l m e d e r. He wrote a a book analyzing the data for reincarnation, which I unfortunately don’t receive in time for this conference, but I thought his his interview was extremely interesting. Then the second interview we’re going to see is an interview with Tom Schroeder, journalist at the Washington Post, if I can load it, who traveled with Stevenson throughout Lebanon, India, and Sri Lanka, while Stevenson was investigating cases of children spontaneously remembering past lives on one of Stevenson’s last trips. Schroeder actually is a Pulitzer Prize winning journalist. It’s a top award in American journalism.

As you probably know, the Washington Post is one of the two top papers in the country with the New York Times. He also holds a master’s in anthropology and was a self avowed skeptic regarding reincarnation. He interviewed doctor Brian Weiss, who wrote his famous book Many Lives, Many Masters, on hypnotic regression of people to past lives, and stated that he was profoundly unconvinced by Brian Weiss and Brian Weiss’s arguments, and that Weiss seemed to be someone who wanted to believe, and who actually moved away from his positions later. So he is by all accounts an impartial observer and a strong skeptic, yet he was very impressed with Stevenson’s work, That makes, I think, his comments extremely interesting for us. The way that it worked was he would talk to the child and the family of the child, then he would talk to whatever witnesses saw the child make statements early on and then he would check with the confirming witnesses of the family in another village who were related to the person the child was said to have been in a previous life.

He would very meticulously interview dozens of people in each case very often and record what they had to say about all the statements. What he was interested in was the statements that the child had made before there was any contact between the child or the child’s family and the previous life personality’s family. Those were the ones that were most interested because once these families met and as they often did, they would find each other because the child would make a pest out of himself very often saying I want to go visit my village and out of curiosity or just to shut the kid up, the family would take the child and they would find, locate the family and they would meet and very often the child would persuade the previous life family that he was indeed their relative reborn. It seems the most dramatic evidence very often is when a child who for the first time upon seeing the previous life family that he or she has been speaking of for a year or two years or sometimes several years will spontaneously identify the people in that family and they’ll call them by name, they’ll ask questions, personal questions about them and that sort of thing.

Very few of those have been witnessed by Stevenson. He’s only witnessed a couple of those situations and the reason that is because these children are talking about this from the time they can speak and they’re talking about it so aggressively that the families will very often take it on themselves to get together, to find this family that their child is talking about, to take their child to visit their family. They’ll do this on their own and when those meetings occur, that is what causes the stir that causes the talk in the town or the village or sometimes a newspaper article and that’s how Stevenson will find out about it. So is not that many cases that he has personally witnessed these meetings and when he has, he always says that the evidence that is derived from the spontaneous recognitions, although they seem very dramatic, is always suspect for the reason that there are all kinds of unconscious cues. There’s one case in India where a little girl was crying for her other family in another town for years and finally some neighbor was impressed with this child’s grief.

Her own family didn’t want to hear about it and in fact they would punish her for talking about this. But a neighbor or person talked to somebody in the village. One day he was coming by the house and she said, Please, these people, meaning her parents, won’t take me to my village. Please take me to my village. And she at the time was maybe three or four years old.

And she said, My parents’ names are and my village name is and he knew somebody from that village so he went and talked to her and said, Do you know any people the family by this name who lost a daughter? And she did. And so she went to the village of her birth, her birth village, and told the family about this and they were sufficiently intrigued having lost a teenage daughter maybe five, six years before, just before this little girl was born, that they came with a group of other people to talk to this little girl and everybody who witnessed this claimed that the little girl spontaneously identified the father and then the father, in fact she clung to him and insisted that he take her with him when he left and her parents permitted this. And then when she went to the village where that family lived, everybody there was waiting for her and they said she identified a whole string of people. Well, you never know, the way they nod or their body language could suggest something.

So that kind of evidence, although it’s very dramatic, can be misleading. There were some things though where we talked to the family of the little girl who died, who had been killed and they said, Oh yes, she recognized her brothers and she even said, Where’s my sister? Why isn’t she here? She must be at her in laws. And she called the sister by name.

Well, if that you know, and people confirm that that’s what she said, well that’s pretty hard to cue. But even so, any one of these things could be wishful thinking, maybe somebody in another conversation when she is identifying people might have mentioned the sister’s name and said, A pity she’s not here, and then the mother didn’t hear that original conversation and then the little girl parroted back to her. So there is always a possible explanation and that’s the thing about all these cases is you can come up with ways that these could be arrived at normally for a lot of these instances. But then, so his main interest is in finding cases that are most difficult to come up with a normal explanation. He has looked at over 2,000 cases and he has many types of cases and many of them are families who had where the child is remembering life in a family that was known to her birth family or his birth family or maybe it was even a family member.

And these cases are, he catalogs them, but those aren’t as compelling because there’s always a way, If the family knew the previous life family, then there is always a way that the child could have gotten information. In Lebanon, was a case of a child who remembered being a mechanic, a 25 year old mechanic I believe who was killed in a car wreck. He told us a story of how the child told us, who is now a 27 year old young man, told us of how he had several years before he had been with a cousin of his previous life personality and they were walking there and he had never met, although he had identified as a child the man who was driving the car that his previous personality was killed in and he had never met him and he said, Well, I saw him and I recognized him. So we went and found the cousin to get his version of it and he confirmed that this guy saw the previous life, the driver of the car that wrecked and knew who he was And the way the cousin told it, they were walking through town and Daniel, who was the name of the child, said, That’s Ibrahim.

That’s the person who was driving the car. And the cousin said, No, that’s not him. And he did that to test him. Well that sort of thing happens over and over again. And you know, you can always say, Well, you know, they’re just trying to make it sound.

What Thomas Schroeder does not mention about this case is that this was one of the Stevens’ strongest verified cases. Daniel remembered being in the car driven by his cousin, Ebrahim, around an area called Military Beach in Beirut. What happened was not talked about in the family. It was quite controversial, but basically, his cousin Ibrahim raced, it seems, according to the memories of Daniel, raced with other drivers and eventually crashed, killing all the occupants of the car except himself. And out of curiosity, Stevenson and Schroeder tried to trace the event in the newspapers in Lebanon.

And despite the destruction which had occurred during the civil war, they were actually able to find a newspaper, L’Orient Le Jour, which carried an account of the accident, placed the accident at the place of military beach in which the young Daniel remembered it happening, and gave the account of the accident which a young child had given. This would have been almost impossible for the child to get access to. They had to go to two separate newspapers before being able to find the data. So this is one of the cases which raises many questions. It is by no means one of Stevenson’s strongest cases.

Better. But what happens with these cases over time, what I found was that you had to go further and further to try to explain them in some normal way. You had to say, first of all, after interviewing these people in dozens of cases, there’s no way that they are all just liars, that they are intentionally lying. It’s just not the case. They don’t have anything to gain from it.

They clearly, you know, in some cases they don’t really want to believe for various reasons either the child was remembering life as like a different religion that was awkward for them or they just felt jealous of the child’s attachment to another family, a stranger’s family. There are many different reasons and many cases why the parents would not want this to be. In fact, the Indian case I mentioned, the parents actually punished the child for speaking of these things and it was a neighbor that finally made the connection between the child and the previous life family. After a while you begin to think, well this is a real phenomenon, whatever is causing this, there really are children who are just learning to speak, who seem obsessed for some reason about the life of a complete stranger with very mundane and some often quite unattractive lives. Why would a toddler be fixated on a 25 year old mechanic who died in an unglamorous car wreck?

There is no obvious reason for that. Even if some of these recognitions that were credited to him like when his sister, when the previous life personality sister came to see him for the first time, he recognized her immediately and said, Bring her bananas. This was a fetish of the previous personality, just loved bananas. The mother of the previous personality said, he asked her, the little boy asked her, Did you ever finish that sweater you were knitting for me? And indeed, she had been knitting a sweater for her grown son and she still had it and she told us that she went and got it, unraveled the material and knit a sweater in his size and gave it to him.

And then we asked to see the sweater just as evidence that that was indeed and his real mother, his birth mother, confirmed that yes, he had given him a sweater, but they had to leave their Beirut house during the war, and when they came back, everything was gone, including the sweater. So you keep layering and you know there’s other stories of him like recognizing on the looking up on a balcony and seeing somebody and that was the dead man’s friend who he went hunting with and the little boy yells up to the balcony, Have you been hunting lately? And it just goes on and on like that. So after a while, you begin to think, well, there’s got to be something besides intentional deceit going on and maybe this is some very elaborate you know, some people who are students of this say, well, this is some kind of extra sensory perception because they find that more acceptable than the idea that it’s just reincarnation flat out. But that’s how compelling some of these cases are, that in order to explain them, very serious people feel they need to resort to something like century perception that some people might think is as fantastic an idea as reincarnation anyway.

So this is a septics account of Stevenson’s work. I think it’s all the more compelling because, basically, it shows the power of the data. I will be addressing Stevenson’s work in detail tomorrow, and tomorrow we will see a video of Stevenson’s successor, professor Jim Jim Tucker at the University of Virginia. But what I’d like to do is I’d very much like in these two days to tie the theory and the empirical data together. So I know the theory is a little bit more tedious, but it helps us a lot to try to make sense of this material, And then the memories which Stevenson recovered seldom extend over more than one lifetime.

There are cases in which he re the child recollects three lifetimes, but it’s very rare. In that sort of very short time span, it is extremely difficult to see the operation of karma, but there are cases where one can glimpse at the phenomena at work. That’s what we’ll talk about tomorrow. Then we’re gonna have a twenty five minute break, and then we will, this afternoon, cover the Buddhist presentation of past lives. Thank you very much.

So for all our scientific method, we are by what we are in this life. The bus just wouldn’t come. I have a long night waited. The bus wasn’t coming, and this friend of mine was getting more and more nervous. And finally, the bus came twenty minutes late, and she turned to me and she said, you see, it’s a ghost of chairman Mao which is holding the bus back because you criticized him.

So here, it’s the ghost of science which is holding the mics back because I was critical of science this morning. So returning to this quote of the Buddha, basically, this is the very core of the Buddhist understanding. Our past lives determine who we are at present. Therefore, if we want to know who we were in our past lives, what was sort of a person we were, we just look at our self now. We do not need actually memories of past lives.

If we have a human rebirth, if our mind is peaceful, if we’re not a choleric person, then we accumulated virtue, we were not angry or choleric in past lives, otherwise we would not experience a result in this life. And as for future lives, we do not need any supernormal means of investigation. Our minds at present determine our lives in the future. Then our deeds and our minds are related, as the Buddha says in this quote, as a chariot and the ox which draws it. The two are not of the same nature, yet wherever the ox goes the chariot goes, the chariot Our deeds and our mind are not of the same nature, but wherever our deeds go our mind follows.

And what I would like to address at present before entering fully in the Buddhist perspective is I would like to cover with you in greater detail precisely the school of Indian philosophy with which we are the most at odds with, the materialist school. I think it is very important because the materialist school, the Lokāyata school of which we talked this morning was an influential school in ancient India and it is a school which resonates very powerfully with much of modernity. So there’s an awful lot which is actually believed or taught nowadays which was formulated by the materialist of ancient India very cogently. And theirs can be said to be a school which leads to a spiritual wasteland. It is a school of radical nihilism, a school of dearth, of parched parchness.

The foremost critiques the locayatas, the materialists address to the existence of past and future lives are summarized by the great Buddhist scholar, Śāntaraksita, in his Tattva Sangaka. Shāntarakshita was perhaps the greatest scholar of his age. He lived at the end of the seventh century to early eighth century. He actually traveled to Tibet from India to start propagating Buddhism in Tibet and resided in Samye, and it is his disciple Kamala Śīla who debated with Heshang Moheyan, the Chinese Zen monk, monk in Tibet. Kamalaśīla composed a commentary on on Shāntarakshita’s work, and as they basically address all of the schools of thought of ancient India, it’s something I find of considerable interest and will draw upon it here.

So the Lokāyata critique of a belief in past and future lives and the Lokāyata presentation is that consciousness proceeds from the body itself. We would say nowadays the mind is just a product of the brain. There is nothing else. This argument was already formulated by Gosala Makkhaliputra twenty five centuries ago. And then the Lokayatas go one step further and assert that for consciousness to reside in the fetus, which is unborn, is sheer audacity.

Nothing can be cognized at that stage as a sense organs are not there. In other words, from the lokaryata perspective, the fetus is not a sentient being and consciousness depends on sensory input. When there is no direct sensory input, there is no consciousness. Now this viewpoint is a viewpoint which I would say is dominant in most western countries. All the legislation regarding abortion for instance rests directly on this.

The fetus is not sentient, therefore the fetus has no rights which can be referred to. The fetus actually is at best a potential human beings with the rights of a potential human beings which are superseded by the rights of the mother, which has actually in many if not all western countries up to a certain point in the fetus’ development, the right of life or death over the fetus. Now this argument that the fetus cannot be sentient because it lacks sense organs goes back to ancient India. From a Buddhist perspective the fetus is sentient. Normally in Abhidharma, the fetus is said to be sentient from the very instant of conception onwards.

Whether that is the case or not, we don’t know, but we presume it is, although obviously the fetus, you know, has levels of sentience which do not compare with ours, it is obvious that the neuron apparatus does not support that. The third point of the Lokāyata which is I think something which haunts much of the West is that at the end when the body dies, the substratum in the shape of the body having ceased to exist, how could the consciousness exist? In other words, for the Lokayatas, for the materialists, consciousness is merely mental activity, the activity of the brain. Once oxygen, sugar cease to arrive to the brain, actually once the brain’s decay starts, consciousness fades in keeping with that decay and disappears within minutes of bodily death. This I think is probably the dominant view in the West.

It’s a view people either acknowledge grudgingly or are aware of. I think it’s a view not a single Westerner is comfortable with, but it’s a view we are encouraged not to think about too much. I mean, the message our society sends is just don’t bother your minds with questions which cannot be solved. Lead useful, preferably economically productive lives, in other words, be good cogs of the great economic machine. And in due course, you will find personal answers.

The best our society can do when people face this fear of extinction at the time of death is to propose palliatives. Palliatives in the form of tranquilizers, antidepressants. It’s an interesting phenomenon that the more developed the society, the greater the consumption of anxiolytics, whereas you would expect it to be exactly the opposite. In India, nobody takes anxiolytics, nobody uses Prozac. In France, I think people pop them like chewing gum from what I understand.

So this raises a very major question how is it that incredibly advanced societies with a very high level of material developments where the causes for suffering, cause suffering and anguish should be greatly reduced, are the most anxiety prone societies perhaps in history. And I think the fundamental root for this can be found in the fact that whether we acknowledge it or not, we have interiorized the Lokāyata view. We have interiorized especially the first and the last point. Consciousness proceeds from the body, and when the body stops, the mind stops. Personality ceases, all is over.

This can only create tremendous sadness and depression, and it is I think an experience of all Buddhist centers I have known that we get a very large proportion of our students from students who are entering the end of their life and who have lived in keeping with the advice of society, they have been productive elements of society, they have married, they have had children, they have had fun, they have traveled the world, which is the main reward I gather, which is offered nowadays to a productive element of society. They have not asked the wrong questions. The wrong questions are the questions of meaning. These are the questions which threaten our society because our society has no answer and when faced with their own imminent demise, when suddenly it may be cancer, it may be Alzheimer’s, may it be Parkinson’s, may be a heart attack. Some of the fortunate young ones it’s a car accident which wakes them up.

Suddenly they are face to face with questions they have been told not to ask and they have no answer. The shock is terrific and the unfortunate side effect is that they go from a state where they can’t be bothered to ask the questions to a state where they need the answers now, preferably yesterday, then this is no way towards any type of spiritual growth. It takes a lot of time. So one of our main functions here is to greet everyone and to slow many of the students down. It is important to take things quietly, to think carefully, to try to understand.

Being in a hurry because one needs canned answers before one’s own demise unfortunately does not work. It would be very nice if it did, but it doesn’t. It provides an artificial sense of solace. It doesn’t provide anything long lasting and nourishing. So the best is early on to try to ask these questions and answer them as best one can.

And we will then move onwards from the Lokāyata critique of reincarnation to the Buddhist presentation, specifically the Buddhist proofs of reincarnation first, and secondly, the Buddhist presentation of karma. This is a magnificent stone representation of the parinirvana of the Buddha from the Ajanta Caves where I was, in January. It was carved around the sixth century of our era. It is six meters in length. The caves were not built.

The caves were carved with hammer and chisel out of stone inside the rock. This this statue was carved inside the rock as the entire temple walls. It’s it is magnificent. So the Buddhist proofs of the existence of past and future lives were very powerful lines of reasoning for generations. They tend to cut much less ice with westerners nowadays.

Westerners are much more sensitive to empirical data even if it is misunderstood. But I do think we owe it to the ancient Buddhist masters to present these lines of reasoning. For myself, I find some of them very powerful. I hope they will be of help to you. So there are basically four teachers who have entered in great detail in the philosophical arguments establishing the existence of past and future lives.

And the reason they did this is because without this, the very foundation of the path is absent. There is nothing on which one can practice. The foremost is the great Dharmakīrti, the founder of Buddhist logic. In his seminal work, the Pramānavārttika, which is so important that at Serraje Monastery, it is studied for fifteen years of the curriculum at an average ratio of one month a year with amongst from all the monasteries, and the best debaters from the other monasteries gathering each year to debate only on Buddhist logic. To debate on Buddhist logic because logic, pure thought, what we would call nowadays mathematics.

Pure thought is the tool of investigation. If the tool is not honed, investigation is not possible. So the most important chapter of Dharmakīrti’s work of is a second chapter in which Dharmakīrti gives the reasons which enable one to conclude to the existence of past and future lives. Then Shāntarakshita of whom we spoke, who was the great Bodhisattva who traveled to Tibet from India, and his disciple Kamala Śīla gave some very interesting and sharp lines of reasoning in the Tattvasangraha, which I will cover with you. These are actually not covered in the monasteries, so I think it’s particularly interesting that we cover them here.

Dharmaottara, who is a late Buddhist philosopher, develops Dharmakīrti’s reasonings and I won’t enter into his presentation in detail here. I’ll mention it just for the record. And these lines of reasoning were basically developed in Tibet by Jetsongkapa’s foremost disciple, Gyaltsab Je. It is Gyaltsab Je’s commentary on Dharmakīrti’s work which is used in conjunction with Dharmakīrti at Sera Je Monastery. The goal of these studies of Buddhist logic is to generate what we call an inferentially valid cognizer. In other words, a valid cognizer, a state of mind which is true and cannot be reversed, which is based on reasoning and understands that past and future lives are a reality. It is considered so important for one’s practice that this amount of effort is put into it. Because independence on this and on this alone, we can become a Buddhist in the full sense of the term.

At present all of us are struggling with these notions, you know, and are trying to accustom our minds to them. The greater our habituation to the idea of past and future lives and the causal relation between them, the more powerful our practice becomes. And it is on this basis and on this basis alone that then we are able to progress up on the paths and first turn our back to this life, it is not possible if one does not believe in past or future lives. Then turn one’s back on all lives, Again, that is not possible if one does not believe in the suffering nature of past and future lives, and believing in their suffering nature entails believing in their existence. And finally, striving for the state of full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.

And you will see in one of the developments of Gyaltsab Je later on that Gyaltsab Je’s main critique of the materialist school is that it prevents the development of compassion. Because if we do not believe in past and future lives according to Gyaltsab Je, how can you have compassion? So I have translated the section of Dharmakīrti’s Pramāṇavārttika which addresses the proofs of the existence of past or future life. This is in verse. It’s very packed.

We will go into it in a rather cursory fashion. Should one say this is a materialist critique, through habituation there is no actualization since mind is based upon the body. This is the old materialist argument which has survived to the present day. This is not so because the base has been refused. The base here is that mind is based upon the body.

Why has it been refuted? And this is Dharmakīrti’s main line of reasoning. Upon taking birth there are no elements, inhalation, organs and mind which do not depend on their own type. No generation from the soul body because of numerous consequences. The crux of Dharmakīrti’s argument is that the infant, the baby at the time of birth engages in automatic behavior such as breathing.

Breathing is untaught. Even though it is untaught, if a child does not engage in breathing within minutes of birth, the child will die. The question dharma Kirti addresses is where does the breathing mechanism come from? It is untaught, it is vital for survival In dharma Kirti’s line of reasoning is that such a mechanism can only come through previous habituation to such a mechanism. In other words, through karmic imprints of having breathe, breathe in in past lives.

Now, geneticists would probably disagree with this and say that it is perfectly possible for the mechanism to be controlled by a cluster of genes. I am not a geneticist, have no ways of ascertaining this. I know that Darmakirti’s argument can be extended to a very large swathe of phenomena for which there is no clear explanation. One of the ones which is most powerful is what is known in linguistics as the poverty of stimuli argument. The poverty of stimuli argument is an argument which is acknowledged by all linguists from Chomsky onwards, and in a nutshell it is the remark that if one assesses the amount of linguistic information which is provided to a child as it is growing up by its parents, it has been established beyond reasonable doubt that this information is insufficient to allow the child to speak with functional grammar.

So the child is receiving insufficient information to construct the grammar of the language it uses. This is before the child goes to school. Little child starts to speak at age two or three and the amount of data provided to the child, let’s say to a child learning English or to the child learning Tibetan, is analyzed and one finds quite clearly that there is not enough there to enable the child on that basis alone to speak coherently. Then the question which arises is how does a child speak? Speaking is a reality.

Linguists are divided on this one. Chomsky’s position which is which seemed like a very attractive position that has become hugely embarrassing is a so called universal language position which is basically that there is some sort of universal language which is shared by all human beings at birth, in other words basically some sort of cortical structure, brain structure which enables language to be acquired quickly. Not all of the linguistic possibilities have to be excluded. The problem in a nutshell is it’s been impossible to formulate the rules of this universal grammar. So it’s a it’s a structure with no structure.

The alternate approach has been basically to deny that there is a problem. Unfortunately, it does seem that there is one. A Buddhist rejoinder to this would be very much that language and frankly this is not that different from Socrates’ argument in Meno this morning. Language occurs not in a void. It arises on the basis of past life predispositions towards learning language.

And therefore when one learns language in this life, one relearns something. This would go a long way towards explaining the varying speeds with which children learn language. So you can see that argument is, if one understands it correctly, a powerful argument. In addition to inhalation, which according to is a mechanism which can only be explained through habituation to through past lives, Dharmakīrti points out, and again this is an argument which unfortunately does not cut a lot of ice with Westerners, that the mind as a cognitive phenomenon can only arise from another cognitive phenomenon. It can only arise from a phenomenon of similar type to it.

Therefore, the very first instant of mind which from a Buddhist perspective would be at the time of conception, let us say from a Western perspective at some point in the sixth or seventh month of pregnancy, that very first instant of mind from Damakirti’s perspective as a cognitive phenomenon cannot arise from matter. It can only arise from another instant of a cognitive phenomenon. So I I did feel these positions had to be presented, and you have here Gyaltsab Je, the Tibetan disciple of Je Tsongkhapa’s critique of the materialist position. But Gyaltsab Je points out that independence on the materialist position, it is impossible to give rise to compassion. A materialist would say it is not possible to actualize compassion over many rebirths since there are not many past and future rebirths.

This is a case and this was a materialist position we explained because since mind awareness and conception depend on the body, when the body is destroyed so are they. And Gyaltsab Je illustrates the materialist position which is I think a dominant position in contemporary research, scientific research. This is akin to light produced from a lamp. In other words, the mind is seen as a byproduct of the brain. The result of the body or beer and the power to intoxicate.

The power to intoxicate, alcohol in other words, is one in the same or is part of the beer which comprises it. So we will skip this because it is a bit difficult and now address the central argument of dharmakirti, which unfortunately is an argument only if you accept a certain nature of the mind. For dharmakirti, the subject, the mind of an ordinary being just before birth, yet Satjji said just before birth, could say just at conception, arose previously as a former mind because of being a mind. So what is being said here is that mind can only give rise to mind. A cognitive phenomenon can only give rise to a cognitive phenomenon and this is sufficient from the standpoint of the Buddhist logicians to demonstrate the infinity of the mental continuum.

So I think some of you will find these arguments very powerful. Many of you will find them unconvincing. It depends very much on one’s own karmic background and unfortunately very much on the culture too. However, I feel that Shāntarakshita and Kamala Śīla developed some very powerful lines of reasoning as well, which I’d like to cover with you, and they are rather difficult to refute. They they expand on the Dharmakirti’s reasoning.

Those of you who are parents have already had this experience. A little child happily suckling its mother’s breast, and Shāntarakshita points out very powerfully. How would you account for the idea in the newborn babe even among animals of a certain thing being a source of pleasure and another a source of pain? An infant seeks its mother’s breasts, which it regards as a source of pleasure, and it cries out when it does not find it, or having found it suddenly stops crying and proceeds to feed itself. Certainly during the present life, the baby has never experienced the fact of the breasts being the means to allay hunger.

It’s a development on the Dama Kertes argument, relying on breathing. The infant at birth is not taught to suck. Then all sorts of mechanisms are now provided to explain why the infant progresses to the mother’s breast, but a mechanism explains nothing. A mechanism just calls for another mechanism which underlies it and we go from mechanism to mechanism in an infinite regress. What is there ultimately which led the first baby who ever suckled to suckle.

There has definitely been a first baby who ever suckled. So that first baby who ever suckled would led him to suckle. Now this argument applies to all automatic unlearned mechanisms. And even if we take a genetic reading, the capacity of information or the amount of information which a human genetic code can contain is not infinite. I mean, a strand of DNA is supposed to code amino acids and proteins.

Just how much data is it supposed to contain? So this is an ongoing debate in Western philosophy, the nature versus nurture argument, but I think insufficient attention has been paid to these automatic mechanisms. And it is actually something of which, and I will bring it up even in front of an Australian audience, it is something to which German philosophers were very attuned. Kant spoke of a priori structures of reasoning. In other words, even for Kant, there were certain structures of the mind in Kant’s case this referred to space in time which were not learned, which were not acquired, which were present from birth onwards.

So what Shāntarakshita and Kamala Silla’s argument from instinct is, is an argument from these a priori structures. And then Shāntarakshita has another argument, the argument from the sexual instinct. Boars, bucks and other animals who have never seen or heard of the doings become perturbed at the touch of females of their own kind. Sexual behavior is automatic. It is unlearned.

Then it is another category of behavior which has to come from somewhere. Mechanisms have to be proposed which can explain it. The Buddhist explanation is that irrespective of the physiological mechanisms which may be involved, there is a habituation from past life behavior of a similar type which enables this behavior to occur. So these are the traditional Buddhist arguments in favor of the existence of past and future lives. I think they were formulated because there was a feeling that the Lokāyata view in India was such an aberrant view.

It was very difficult to make sense of. Then quite frankly, in addition, as I mentioned this morning, in most Buddhist societies, practitioners through their practice gain firsthand experience of parts of their own past life or lives or they know other practitioners who have. They also know or see people whose behavior is impossible to make sense of otherwise. I I saw with my own eyes a series of cases which are very difficult for me to account up for by any other means, And since they basically tie in with Shanta Akshita’s arguments, I will mention them here. One was one of my classmates at Serraje monastery who was a reincarnate Lama, the reincarnation actually of one of Kinsar Rinpoche’s teachers.

He’s a very young boy, he was when I met him he was 16 and he was in the class of students who were going on thirteenth. He was consistently the top student in the class with very, little effort, which is very frustrating for all of us, but that could be accounted for by raw intelligence. What could not with great difficulty was his phenomenal capacity at memorizing texts. As long as it was a Buddhist text and not in Tibetan and not another text, he could basically look at the text and as far as we could see he would scan the text visually and he had total recall of the text. He could not do this with material which was unrelated and so forth.

And I remember we had to struggle greatly to memorize Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, it’s a very difficult text to memorize. I would go at the rate of half a page a day which for that text was considered good. He just read it. He read the whole 30 pages and that was that. Now his former incarnation had been known as a very good scholar and therefore there was a very clear sense at the monastery that it was because of the mind’s habituation over past lives that his learning, as Socrates said this morning in the Meno was just a remembering, a rehabituation.

This is one of the strongest arguments in favor of study in this life which is that however hard it is in this life, it will be easier in our in our future lives. It gets it doesn’t get harder, it gets easier. Whatever we are accustomed to becomes more and more easy. Then the other case, which really cut me to the quick, was these debates on Buddhist logic I told you about once a year. So I was one of the the happy few who were selected to go.

It was one of it was my favorite topic. And the monks of Sera Ganden and Drepung, all of those who were selected and gathered, we would rotate monasteries. So you would debate with monks from all the monasteries, the top debaters, you know. And I had a very sharp debate, which was a little bit unfair because I was using reasonings from another school in the context of the school, and very difficult to answer. Everyone I sprang it upon, basically defeated in debate.

So I was feeling quite, you know, a kind term is uplifted. Then I saw a big crowd that was happening outdoors around a tree, and a tremendous amount of shouting and debating. There were some forty, fifty monks around that tree, so I came up to see what was happening. It’s a big social event, these debates. And over these big adult Tibetan monks, you know, bit like tanks, I saw in the middle a little boy, 12 years old or so, rather plump, a monk, very charming face, you know, and there were some five, six top debaters just going at him hell bent, you know, when

One was not able to pursue a line of reasoning. The other was attacking him. And this little child, all alone, was just answering one after the other like this, smiling. He was just laughing. I looked at this.

I came up close, but it was the debate at Jang Gonchoe. And I listened, and it was just like it’s like was like seeing an Aikido master just throw, you know, everyone who runs at him, you know, all over the place. I said, my goodness. His reasoning was so simple and so powerful. Then I thought, you know, I mean, I’m gonna I’m gonna, you know, show them how you debate.

You know? I stood up, I obviously, I was the westerner, so they let me debate. I started debating one and everything. He smiled at me. It was just looking at his eyes.

I know exactly what you’re trying to do. And then I came to the critical point, and he blocked. Then I took side avenue, came to another critical point. Normally, you you get them at the point. He blocked.

Then he did this three times in a row. And then with his very kind look, which I felt was very patronizing, he said, it’s very good. Very good. Next. This was a 12 year old child.

Then I was very perturbed by this. So I retired with all the dignity I could muster. And when I was in the back, said to one of the monks, who is this? And he said, I don’t know. It’s a great Pramāna scholar from Drepung Geshi so and so.

It’s his reincarnation. Well, was evident. In my mind, there was no doubt because this was not a child I was debating with. It was a child’s body. But there was a self possession, a self control, and an intellect of a caliber I had never met except with one or two of my teachers at in adults.

So these are experiences I think which which are private. I mean, can only share them with you. And as personal experiences, they seldom elicit conviction, but for myself, they were very powerful. When you see this happen dozens of times, then as Robert Almeder said, it’s not believing in reincarnation which is problematical, it’s not believing in reincarnation.

At a certain point this level of capacity raises a lot of questions and it is actually something we will talk about tomorrow when before talking about Stevenson’s cases of children remembering past lives, we will talk of the case of child prodigies, which raise precisely this question and I have I had two cases of child prodigies born both in extremely defavorized families, because one of the classic arguments advanced against child prodigies is when Mozart was born in a musical family, so it could be heredity or environment. The two cases I found, one certainly cannot say they were born in favorized environments, one of the two ranks as one of the greatest mathematical geniuses in history. Srinivasa Ramanujan. So we will now address the general features of karma. Maybe I would prefer if it’s okay with you.

I think we will have a fair bit of time at the end and just so you all know what this is. A boomerang as good Australians. That’s I believe you addressed it with the indigenous communities. I got absolutely nothing to say on the topic. To me, it looks like a work of art.

To you, You. You know? But this is how karma operates. When Rinpoche speaks of the Wheel of Sharp Weapons, we can just speak as well of a boomerang. When you throw a boomerang, however far it goes, it comes back.

And then the Buddhist scholars try to understand precisely what the general features of karma were before entering into their specific features because clearly if karma is a reality, then it is important for us to understand how it functions, to use it to our advantage. Now what you have I’m sure noted is that all the Buddhist logicians feel that they can prove the existence of past and future lives, no attempt is made to prove the existence of karma or its operation because it is not considered provable. It is not considered provable. You can perfectly believe in past and future lives, and this is a case of certain materialists in India, and never believe in karma. It is said that karma’s operations are so subtle and so complex and range over such a huge range of lives that except as if one is able to see the sum total of lives of a given sentient being in the past and the connection between each life, one cannot see how karma operates.

In other words, the operations of karma can only be established by a fully enlightened being who is omniscient. Having said this, this is exactly what we’re going to try to do tomorrow, not because it can be done, but because it’s very helpful to try to get a sense of what might be going on. But from a Buddhist perspective, these are the general features of karma. Karma is definite, karma is increasing, one does not experience unaccumulated karma, and karma does not disappear. All karmic imprints, positive or negative, share these four characteristics.

When we say that karma is definite, we mean that virtuous karma can only give rise to happiness and non virtuous karma can only give rise to suffering. This is not an immediate experience. It’s something which is we have to basically take and again this is a big problem for western students. We have to take on faith. We can understand how if karma is something at the mental level akin to a boomerang, harming others would eventually lead to our being harmed by others.

But this argument is not elicit conviction. At a certain point, it is something we have to tap take on the faith of our teachers and on the faith of the teachings of the enlightened being. The Buddha himself whom some of us claim to be the students of did attain for enlightenment. So he attained something. If he hadn’t attained it, we wouldn’t be here to study what he taught.

Then he saw these things. He himself said that the operation of kamma was almost incomprehensible and he gave examples. The definiteness of karma is one. It’s very difficult for us to understand that doing something virtuous which is unpleasant, virtue is not always pleasant, some would say it’s frequently unpleasant, leads down the line to happiness. And that doing something non virtuous and unfortunately non virtuous quite often rather pleasant, leads down the line to suffering.

I think if we reflect carefully on the reasonings we can see that if the mind for instance becomes steadily accustomed over lives to a very strong altruistic disposition, This mind will be very content and happy mind. Now in this respect there’s a lot of data from cognitive science which in the last five ten years alone has demonstrated the importance of altruism for mental well-being, which is quite revolutionary. So we do have some support for that, but more than that it is hard to get. Karma is definite means that there are only two paths. There is the path of darkness and there is a path of light.

The path of darkness, which can be epitomized by all the dictators, which have marked human history, is a path one sinks ever lower into life after life. It can be a path of great power, a path of great destruction. The path of light is a path a human being can only attain after many lifetimes of practice. And yet, we can see in these two, I feel emblematic figures of Gandhi and Hitler, how in both cases, great power was manifested. In the case of Gandhi, it was a power of conviction, a non violence, which caused India to become independent.

A nation of the period I think of 200,000,000. And he’s remembered in India as a saint. His Holiness the Dalai Lama considers him as his own teacher. In the case of Hitler, it is a power of coercion and violence, which led not only the German nation and all its allies, but Hitler himself to their destruction. So I feel generally speaking, Karma as it has been explained matures over many lives.

However, when the basis is very powerful, for instance, when many many beings are involved, it can mature over one life. So my personal feeling is that these two figures, Gandhi and Hitler, could represent this. In one case, we have a steady process of mental purification. In another case, we have a steady process of mental decay from a young artist who was basically insignificant, this was Hitler’s case in 1918, to a warlord, to a monster frankly, to a man who sunk in the abyss of despair and committed suicide as his country was collapsing around you. So when we speak of the definiteness of karma, this is what we speak about.

And this is what the Buddha epitomized in these two verses from the Dhammapada. A man may find pleasure in evil as long as his evil has not given fruit, but when the fruit of evil comes, then that man finds evil indeed. A man may find pain in doing good as long as his good has not given fruit, but when the fruit of good comes, then that man finds good indeed. So there is hardship in practicing virtue, but eventually, there are very great rewards. The following feature of coma is that coma is increasing.

I think this is a very good image to represent this in the self same way as the roots of a tree spread and spread and spread. Until they reach, we know not where, in the self same way, very, very small karmic imprints have a power of amplification which we do not begin to understand. Jetsongkhapa says in Lam Rim Chenmo that there are two types of causality. There’s ordinary causality which we study.

Science has become past master at studying this. I mean, it’s physical causality, biological causality, and there’s karmic causality. And they differ precisely in this respect in amplification. Karmic causality has an amplifying factor. Now personally I tend to understand karma in terms of theory.

Some of you may have heard of fractal theory, the development of the French mathematician, Benoit Mandelbrot. It’s a study of very complex surfaces in geometry, which are constituted of other complex surfaces. And what Mandelbrot found is that you have a self replicating nature of these surfaces. Now certain physical phenomena lend themselves very well to fractal modeling. The famous case is coastal shorelines, and you find in coastal shorelines that fractal feature of a minor feature of the coastline being reproduced at the macro level.

So my feeling is that karma tends to function in this way. Karma occurs is a mental phenomenon, but it occurs at the interface of the mind and the physical world. And the fractal theory goes a long way towards explaining the definiteness of karma. In other words, there is a self replicating component. And if we understand karma as all extremely complex phenomena in the terms of another field which has become very important nowadays, especially in meteorology, chaos science, then we get a sense of how the amplicating nature of karma might function.

It’s been pointed out famously that a butterfly batting its wings in China may eventually be the cause of a hurricane in The Pacific through the interlocking network of weather patterns. I suspect something like this is at work with karma. This is perhaps what is meant by the amplifying nature of karma. Something very small, a very small deed, such as just giving a grain of rice to a bird in the garden with a happy mind in one life, and grows, grows, grows, grows, grows, and eventually becomes ten, fifty, 100 lives down the line, something huge, which matures, takes over the life of the person. The person becomes a great philanthropy, becomes a Bill Gates or someone like that.

And suddenly, giving takes up a totally different significance. So Jetsongkhapa points out an effect of immense happiness may arise from even a small virtuous karma. An effect of immense suffering may arise from even a tiny non virtuous karma. And this is Jetsongkhapa’s critical point, which I have never seen anywhere else in the Indian tradition. Hence, internal karmic causation seems to involve a magnification that is not found in external causation.

This is an uncommon feature precisely of this psychophysical causation which we call karma. The third feature of karma is that one does not encounter an experience, the karma of which has not been created. Now what is meant by experience here is an experience of happiness or suffering. Neutral experiences do not necessarily have karmic causes. So karma does not introduce a rigid absolute determinism.

But the slightest experience of suffering and the slightest experience of happiness has a karmic cause, which we cannot identify, but which we can say shares certain features with the result it gives rise to. An experience of suffering for oneself entails having inflicted suffering on others. The sort of suffering we experience is connected to the sort of suffering we inflicted. We share this experience of suffering with other beings who were partners in crime with us. And this is therefore the meaning of not experiencing unaccumulated karma.

This is one of the terrible pictures from World War two of a mother and child being shot by a German soldier. These experiences of horrific suffering are experiences which have causes far back in the distant past. These are experiences which will be repeated, because the three persons who are involved in this tragedy, the soldier, the mother and the child will meet again. In the same way as the mother and the child were responsible for inflicting suffering on the previous incarnation of the soldier, at some point in the distant past. In the self same way, the soldier inflicts suffering on them at present.

In turn, they will re inflict suffering on him of the same nature in the future. I have often felt this goes a long way to explaining what some people have called the Stockholm Syndrome, which is this particular kinship and almost recognition between in the Stockholm Syndrome’s case terrorists and their victims, but criminals in general and their victims. Rape victims describe this, that they have the sense of not knowing, but of acquaintance or familiarity with the perpetrator. It is because in that sort of event, none of us are strangers. And then the final feature of comma is that comma does not disappear.

This is very difficult for us to realize, but in the same way as acorns, when planted in the earth, will stay indefinitely.

In the self same way, karma which is accumulated lingers in our mind like a time bomb. And our minds are cluttered with these little time bombs just waiting for the right moment to explode. The moment is the conditions. The conditions arise and suddenly the karmic imprint is triggered. And you see this happening when the person says they are possessed by something they do not understand, and they did deeds they never thought they were able to do.

I remember when I was in Switzerland reading a case in the in the press of a highly respectable man, a German engineer, had been arrested for pedophilia, a rather horrific case. This was some five, six years ago. And it was everyone is very puzzled because he was fundamentally a very nice man. Married, good job, no as far as anyone could ascertain, no particular, you know, proclivities of that nature. And at the trial, it was reported in the press.

The judge specifically asked him, basically, what happened? And he said, he fell by accident on these pictures on the Internet, and he was possessed. It was as if something took over, and he was no longer able to control himself. This is a karmic imprint being awakened by an exterior condition, which triggers something which takes over the personality. Now it can happen in the negative, as in this case, or the positive sense.

We are at the mercy of conditions. All of us in our mind have an infinite number of these karmic imprints, both virtuous and non virtuous. We do not know what they are. They’re lingering there in the background. And then we’re at the mercy of conditions.

We meet a great teacher, we have some sort of connection with the Buddhist tradition, that meeting is a condition which triggers a maturation of a comic imprint. Then the comic imprint lasts for a period of time. So the student is extremely enthusiastic, they come to the center, take refuge, take all the initiations, come to all the teachings, then suddenly they disappear. They stop coming. It is a common occurrence.

It’s something we see all the time. It is because that karmic imprint matured to meeting the teacher, or reading a book, or hearing some words, or music. Then the maturation of that comic imprint had power enough to carry the students up to a certain point. That comic imprint’s efficacy ceased, and then the student lost interest. It’s quite extraordinary to see.

The student is not responsible. The problem is that during that period of grace where the karmic imprint has matured, it is capital to lay powerful karmic imprints for the future. The more, the better. Because if they will mature in due course. And to do that, we have to understand how karma operates.

Otherwise, we don’t know how to do this skillfully. We can put tremendous effort in laying karmic imprints of little power. Or we can put very little effort in laying comic imprints of great power. So this maturation of the comic imprints can occur both in the positive and the negative sense. Therefore, before negative comic imprints mature, we have to purify as much as possible.

This reduces the impact of the maturation of comic imprints. So I have seen with people I know who did the Vajrasattva retreat, I have seen with my own self, the great impact of purification on reducing automatic negative behavior. It’s very striking. The more the better, because we have no control over the circumstances which occur. Then the maturation of these comic imprints can lead us to terrible places, terrible places.

In the civil war in Yugoslavia, as you know, between 1993 and 1996. My family is an old old Montenegrin family. All my ancestors were war warlords, so my father is the first who wanted to hire things. When the war started, I was asked to lead units down there. I was in Paris at the period.

I refused. And I actually cut all connection with my family over that reason. He said, you know, yours is an illustrious family, you know. You have to come and fight for the good cause. You know?

I said, no. No. What you’re doing is is evil. You know? Then I heard accounts of these paramilitary forces going into villages and slaughtering the villages, and I was told some of them were howling like wolves.

I hear the clear maturation of karmic imprints, clear in this very life of rebirth as an animal. So if we if we study these topics and if we have eyes to see, some have eyes to see, some don’t. If we have eyes to see, then we can start to understand what is going on. And therefore Buddha says in the Dhammapada, a wrong action may not bring its reaction at once, even as fresh milk turns not sour at once. Like a smoldering fire concealed under the ashes, It consumes a wrongdoer in the fool.

So karma operates as Kensur Rinpoche magnificently explained, as a noria. You have a wheel, you see them in India, you see them throughout The Middle East. These wheels which irrigate fields. And basically, the water is the comic input. The vase going up and down is our lives, following each other from the higher realms to the lower realms, to the higher realms, to the lower realms, beginninglessly, with no control.

So to use karma skillfully, it is capital to understand what karma is, what is to be abandoned and what is to be practiced. What is to be abandoned is what are known as the 10 non virtuous deeds, but not exclusively them. This is just a very short summary to make things evident for us. The three deeds of the body, four of the speech, and three of the mind. Most of you know them.

These are 10 major ways in which we harm others or we harm ourselves within this very life. However, for these deeds to actually bear fruit, to give a result, they must be complete. And it is important for us to understand what a complete karmic deed is. It’s important because if we’re going to use karma to protect ourselves and not to harm ourselves, then we have to make sure that the non virtuous deeds we do are incomplete, and that the virtuous deeds we do are complete and powerful. It is independence on this that over time, even in this life, but for certain in future lives, we can improve or not.

So these are karmic strategies. Through understanding the karmic strategies, we can then weaken the non virtuous deeds, which unfortunately we do, and strengthen the virtuous deeds. And the actual path of non virtuous karma, in other words, what a complete non virtuous deed is, entails four components. A basis, a thought, a deed, and a completion. If these four components are not present, it is not sure whether the karmic deed will bear fruit or not.

This applies for both non virtuous and virtuous karma. The basis is a recipient of the deed, somebody who is on the receiving end of whatever we do. The thought is just a motivation. It is subdivided into recognition, thought and affliction. Recognition means actually recognizing who is a recipient.

For instance, if we take a saving, one which is deed of killing, the basis would be the victim of the killing. The thought would be recognizing the victim of the killing as someone we want to kill, not killing the wrong person. The thought is actually the intention to kill, and the affliction is killing under the power of anger, or in the case of euthanasia, killing under the power of desire, or in the case of ignorance, as I’d say in ancient India, the thugs, killing believing that it is of benefit. Or with some Islamic radicals nowadays, The idea that, you know, war in the name of God is a good thing, violence is a good thing. The deed has to be performed in addition, and the deed must reach fruition.

In other words, the victim in the case of killing must die. When such a deed is performed, this is a complete deed. So if we take the case of killing, which is the most harmful deed. What is killing? A deed of killing occurs with as a basis a being who is alive.

And then there’s a debate whether it is only killing other beings or whether killing oneself as well, with suicide, qualifies as killing. Suicide of any way is a non virtuous deed, but the question is whether it’s a full deed of killing or not. So according to Asaṇga, suicide is not a full deed of killing. According to Vasubandhu, it is. And then the thought, one must recognize the person, and this refers both to human beings and non human beings, as the person one wants to kill.

So this recognition must be correct. I won’t enter into the subdivisions of recognition here. Then one must have a motivation to kill the person. One must act under an affliction, desire, hatred, or ignorance, and the deed can be done by any which way. We always think of killing by weapons, but in many country, through mantras, through spells, is a deed of killing identical to killing through weapons.

Having another one kill, saying I am a Buddhist, you know, the house has spiders. I don’t want to know about it. You do what you want to one’s partner who’s not a Buddhist and who has the whatever you call it insecticide. There is absolutely no difference as far as the deed of killing is concerned. Karmically, it’s a heavier deed in doing it oneself, because one is dragging another person in the process with one.

And then the completion is the death of the victim, in this case, the unfortunate spider, let us say. So such a deed where these four features are present is a complete deed of killing. This deed will necessarily mature on us. So this complete deed of killing is has a four general features of karma. It’s definite, so it’ll mature upon us as suffering.

It is increasing. One does not encounter the cause one has not created, and it will not disappear. So unless we purify such a deed, such a deed like the boomerang will return upon us. So in this situation, we need karmic strategies. The karmic strategies are to use these features of karma so as to amplify what is good and tone down what is bad.

That is why the Tibetans say, the evil deeds of the wise are light and the trivial deeds of the foolish are heavy. The evil deeds of the wise are light because those who are wise know how to purify. Therefore, if they commit great evil, they purify immediately. They make sure that the motivation to commit evil is weak, that the deed is not complete, and the maturation is greatly reduced. The foolish, however, do not understand how karma operates.

That’s something very small. Like, for instance, placing a rag on a Buddha statue. Becomes very heavy. They do not understand. The deed becomes ever greater over time.

So there are several aspects of karmic amplification we have to understand. We have karmic amplification from the side of the agent, in other words, the person who does the deed. If we take the deed of killing we spoke about earlier, which is killing, let us say, a spider. This deed can become much heavier through intention, performance, absence of antidote, attachment to wrong views, and bases. If in addition to killing the spider, we kill it with great hatred.

This makes deed of killing more powerful. And if we torture the spider for a long time, this amplifies it even more. Then without any antidote, without ever purifying this deed, and in addition attached to wrong views believing that killing spiders is the thing to do. And finally the basis, instead of a spider, let’s say one kills something which is weak in defenses, such as a fetus or an invalid, a human being, one’s parents. Then every single one of these features amplifies the power of the deed of killing.

This karmic amplification extends to all non virtuous deeds, to sexual misconduct likewise. If one intends to commit adultery, then one is ostentatious, shameless in one’s behavior. One never purifies. One thinks this is perfectly okay. And in addition, one seduces, let’s say, the husband or the wife of one’s best friend who trusts us.

The deed becomes incredibly powerful. It is amplified. Then if the deed is complete and it is amplified, if we take the case of sexual misconduct, we ourselves will experience our partner running away. We us ourselves would experience our partner being seduced by another at some point in the future. The more powerful the deed, the greater the suffering we ourselves would experience as a result of this.

So karmic strategies mean that when we are in situations where we commit non virtuous deeds, which unfortunately does happen to all of us, We try to make sure the deed is incomplete, and we weaken the deed. So we do it with regret instead of a happy intention. We do it in hiding, shamefully. We purify at once. We’re not attached to wrong views.

We feel this is a bad thing to do. And we try to avoid doing it with respect to a powerful basis. Then we have karmic amplification from the side of the recipient of the action. We have the agent, now we have the recipient. So there are certain recipients we have to be very very careful of, because even very small deeds with respect to them become very powerful.

The first is the field. Our spiritual teacher, Kensur Rinpoche for us, Bodhisattvas, parents, or monasteries are very powerful fields. They are powerful fields because these are beings or institutions dedicated to a pure life, who not only are not harmful but are helpful. In the case of the spiritual teacher, everything we know, we know from our teacher. Now this extends not only to the spiritual teacher, but to teachers in general.

Your driving instructor is worthy of as much respect as a teacher as any other teacher. As an Asian, a Vietnamese student here, very beautifully said to me, he said, we Asians understand how to respect a teacher because before any teacher came, there was something we didn’t know, and after he came, was something we knew. This is true for all teachers. He who taught us the alphabet. Now in the case of collectivities, the karma is extremely dangerous.

Any community is a powerful recipient for karmic deeds because many persons are involved. The Sangha, the monastic community is an extremely powerful recipient because it is many monks or nuns which are involved, who have vows. And what makes communities very dangerous as karmic recipients is that it is almost impossible to purify because you have to purify with respect to every member of the community which was present at the time when the non virtue was done. And these communities change constantly. So here, for instance, we have a community, a dharma center.

It is very easy to steal from the dharma center. If we use something without permission in a dharma center, it is stealing. If you go to the kitchen without having a blanket permission to take tea, you just serve yourself, and you walk out. You have basically stolen from the dharma center. You have taken without permission from the center, from a community.

Such a deed is hard to purify because you’ve taken from a very large group of people. Who actually contributed to the purchase of the tea? We do not know. Therefore, communities are dangerous objects. Stealing from insurance companies falls in the same category.

People think, oh, I make a false insurance declaration. It doesn’t matter. The insurance company is rich. The insurance company pools the resources of many people. It amounts to stealing a very small amount from a huge number of people.

What if the physics is saying that there’s no coming bee that is not possible I mean, that’s impossible to purify? It can be purified, but it’s very difficult. You can purify, but to point out how dangerous the deed is, the texts say stealing from the Sangha is almost impossible to purify. It’s not impossible, almost impossible. People who live in monasteries learn to be very careful about this.

Very careful. But Dharma centers are the same thing. A Dharma center is a community of practitioners. So we must be very careful. It is best to get blanket permission from the director of the center, because we ourselves ultimately foot the bill.

We foot the bill. Then, as we mentioned, there’s a difference in power between the deeds performed by the wise and the ignorant. Powerful in terms of the object among offerings to sentient beings, offerings to the teachings is supreme, and what is important for us, power in terms of the intention. An intention such as bodhicitta transforms a deed. A deed which might be small, becomes very powerful as the intention increases.

Between giving $1,000,000 to the monastery with a worldly motivation thinking, they will respect me, I will be well known, Then when I go there, can always live there. Such a deed is not even dharma. Such a deed is is basically it amounts to buying the favors of the monastery and giving $10 with bodhicitta. The second deed is farm up off. Farm up off.

The first deed is just the mundane deed of someone carrying favor. Then we have three types of results if we take our example of killing. We have the result of maturation, causally concordant result, and environmental result. So the result of maturation means just rebirth. What rebirth do we take if the deed is complete?

If the deed is complete, it will mature. Then it depends on the weight as we said of the deed. If it was heavy, if we did it with delight, tormenting the being, never purifying, especially towards a d a being towards whom we are very close, a parent perhaps or a child, then it’s a hell realm rebirth we will be facing. If it’s of intermediate strength, it’ll be a preter rebirth. Light killing would be an animal rebirth.

The causally concordant result is a result which is similar to the cause. We shorten the life of another, we ourselves will have a short life span. So we know people. Everything else goes fine. Their health is never good, or they go from accident to accident.

It’s just astonishing. This is a causally concordant result of having caused an accident or killed in a past life, and a natural enjoyment of killing. We see with animals, I house kept two terriers for a couple of weeks. Their minds are predisposed towards killing. When they see another animal which is smaller than them, the only desire is to kill that animal.

This is the karmic maturation of having killed many times in the past, the mind is accustomed. We see this with children. Our little children early on, they delight in stealing. Or the worst cases, early on, they have a proclivity for cruelty. They torture animals.

This is through having been accustomed to killing in the past life, or having stolen. The environmental result is being reborn in an environment in which in the case of killing, there’s a lot of violence. Let’s say being reborn in Afghanistan, or in Iraq, or worse. And therefore, I would like to conclude with these beautiful verses of Just as on a dark night with clouds, the sudden lightning blares and all is clearly shown. Likewise rarely through the Buddhist power, virtuous thoughts arise, brief in transit in the world.

Virtue thus is weak, and always evil is of great and overwhelming strength. Except for perfect bodhicitta, what other virtue is there that can lay it low? I think it is a very beautiful thought. Then we have finished the presentation for today, and I’m at your disposal for any questions you might have. Yes, Christa?

It’s regarding dealing with speech online and wasn’t that’s why it’s a 10 on. When you text a with each bag, there’s no not taking intoxicants. Mhmm. But in the 10 on, that doesn’t appear? No.

In the body, I tell you. But I would call it as a body, no, or the mind, actually. It’s not a natural non virtue. It’s a vowed non virtue. The Buddha distinguishes between deeds which are in and of themselves nonvirtuous, killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, and deeds which are nonvirtuous because we have pledged not to do them, such as consuming intoxicants.

Intoxicants in and of themselves are neither here nor there. The problem with intoxicants is that they reduce our mindfulness. Therefore, independence from intoxicants, all the other thoughts arise. So for this reason, lay vow holders take the vow never to consume any intoxicants. This obviously applies to drugs, but this also applies to alcohol, any type of alcohol.

Generally speaking, the Buddha condemned strongly the use of alcohol precisely because alcohol is a disinhibitor. We don’t take alcohol because we want to be mindful. We take alcohol because want to relax. In other words, we want to be disinhibited. Now from a Buddhist standpoint, inhibition is a very good thing.

Inhibition means restraint. We think before we act. The whole goal of Sattipattana meditation is to cultivate inhibition and restraint. Then the more relaxed we are, Tibetan say behaving in any which way, the more potentially we can engage in very heavy behavior. So that’s the reason.

Yes? It’s a difficult question. I mean, in both cases, there’s a mechanism. The case of a plant, if you’re speaking of what is it called? I mean, a phototropism.

Right? A plant’s turning towards the sun. I think so. There’s a mechanism which explains this. Differential cell growth in one side of the plant as opposed to another.

But plants are not conscious. Well, at least I’ve tried talking to my flowers to no avail. You know? They they don’t respond. Find Find your your idea.

Uh-huh. I’ve I’ll bring you to you’ll take care of my garden because my plants don’t listen to me. But with children, I think the question the question which is being asked by Shāntarakshita is basically, how do we account for unlearned behavior? Complex unlearned behavior, especially when it is systematic. So nowadays, the only possible account a materialist can give is to say that it is genetic.

That there’s no other way to explain it. If you have, take breastfeeding, reaction under fright, whatever, you know, reproductive behavior, what not. It is not something we learn through mimicry, through modeling ourselves on another. Then, if it is genetic, we run at a certain point in the question of the amount of information which is encoded in the genetic material. It also begs the question, what happened as we said rather naively with the first child who suckled on the breast, the first ram at which I produced, and so forth.

So that is the thrust of Shāntarakshita’s argument. And then obviously the argument can be developed greatly in the direction of linguistics for one, where if the poverty of stimuli reasonment is correct, then there is something contemporary linguistics cannot account for. You know? Then in the direction of natural gifts, we know that artists for instance have a natural predisposition which can largely be mechanistically explained. But when we are speaking of extraordinary cases of creativity, such as that of Srinivasa Ramanujan we’ll talk about tomorrow, who was ranked by Hardy first among all in terms of of creativity, among all mathematicians in history.

Was born in a poor peasant family in Tamil Nadu in India, close to Madras, had limited formal education and started basically discovering theorems, at a terrifying rate at the age of 11, mainly in vision. He had visions of the family goddess and of Narasimha unfolding scrolls of theorems in front of his eyes. Then he would transcribe these theorems, and eventually he sent them to Hardy, who was professor of mathematics at Cambridge Cambridge University. This is the nineteen early nineteen tens. And Hardy was floored to find that Ramanujan was basically at the very cutting edge of mathematics at the period.

Hardy says that some of the theorems were known, some he was able to prove himself with considerable difficulty. He was a foremost mathematician of his age. Some he said he suspected were true. They were beyond his capacity to prove them. I have no clear answer.

I mean, if you look at biology, the boundary between plants and animals is actually very tenuous at the cellular level. If you go back far enough, whether a cell is a plant cell or an animal, a cell at a certain point becomes nowhere nearly as clear cut as it as it is with macro organisms. Then the Buddhists teach that minds can exist in coexistence with plants, someone else was asking me this question earlier, but they do not animate plants. I think what is meant by this is that the mind is not able to cause activity in the plant. Now, our minds are able to cause activity in our bodies.

Motion for instance is a classic. A mind which is coexisting with a tree would not be able to cause motion in a tree. It might, however, live in the tree. It’s not accidental, it’s incapacity to cause motion, as would be the mind of someone in a paralyzed body, it’s systemic. So with plants, think what is lacking from a Buddhist standpoint is intention.

We have no evidence of intention. Then the question of the beginning of sentience, how far back in the unicellular structure do you go to get to the foundations of sentience? That is an open question. Our individual cells, let’s say paramecia or amoeba, are they sentient or not? They certainly don’t have the neurological substratum which supports sentience.

If in keeping with his holiness’s discussion with scientists, motion is a criteria for sentience, intentional motion, then it’s an open debate. They do have an they do have motion. How intentional it is is open to question. Those are open debates. We don’t have an answer at that level.

Yes? Everything depends on the state of mind of the child at the time of death, which is perhaps the most powerful factor in propelling a future life. If the state of the mind of the child at the time of death is hatred towards his murderer, then the chances are that child will come back as a violent person. The problem you see is karma does not operate from one life to the next life. So if we look at it actually technically from the standpoint of the 12 links, this is a karmic event.

So you have a murderer and two victims. The murderer has accumulated the non virtuous deed. The two victims have not accumulated anything. So the murderer necessarily would experience suffering as a result of his non virtuous deed, which would be commensurate to the weight of the deed committed. So the deed is a complete deed of killing as far as we could see from the picture if we take that event.

And the weight of the deed, do not know. Was it done with regret, on order? Was it done rejoicing? Was it done with sadness? We don’t know.

From the standpoint of the recipient, the deed is very heavy. It’s a mother and a child, a defenseless being. So that makes a deed heavy for the perpetrator. Then the receiving party has not committed any non virtuous deed at all. What they have experienced is a maturation of past non virtue.

This may be the end of their experience of that maturation. They may never have to experience it again, or it may be a drawn out process. Now if we look at the cases of hypnotic regression, if they are true, if Netherton’s cases are authentic, then one can see that this process of maturation unfortunately is a drawn out process. It happens not over one life, but over many lives. There’s a debate in Buddhist philosophy about this.

Asaṇga’s position, which is a dominant position, is that the maturation happens over many lives. But they have committed no non virtue, that whether they come back as pacifists or not depends on their state of mind. So ideally, a true practitioner in a horrific experience like this would rejoice because this deed is the end of something. Can you give some examples of if introduce something like in the spinal cords from breast cancer? Well, much depends.

There’s so many factors that it would be very difficult to just say there’s one or two factors. But for instance, if you take an object which from its own side is not heavy, like an insect. An ant, we don’t even bother to look in Australia where we walk. We just walk, and there are thousands of ants on the street. We just walk, you know, killing without concern.

I think all of us do. Very few people I have seen look at where they put their feet, you know. If we do this obliviously, then from the standpoint of the recipient, the ant, the deed is a deed of killing, but it’s not a heavy deed. If we are oblivious, then from our standpoint, the deed is not heavy. It’s still a deed of killing.

But if we start thinking, I don’t care, then the deed becomes heavier. If we walk with irritation on the ants,

The deed is heavier again. Instead of just walking with irritation with ants and mosquitoes, if we crush them with delight, the deed is heavier again. So these are amplifications of the deed. Such a minor deed from the standpoint of the object can become a heavier deed of killing than killing a human being. If one kills a human being who is in great pain, overwhelmed by compassion, finding no other way to relieve the suffering of the being, it is a deed of killing, but the motivation weakens the deed greatly.

We will experience from our side the result, But it may turn out to be a less deed lesser deed than a deed of killing an ant or a fish, going fishing. You know, you see this, the beach here, you know, people fish. Fish comes on the beach, and they let it suffocate to death, you know. Some laugh when the fish is dying, you know. Then if they delight in this, and they see the fish as a living being which is suffering, and they are happy that they have fallen so indeed, it’s heavy.

I mean tsunamis occur in coastal regions not just for geological reasons. It is fishing villages which are destroyed. Because the deed of fishing, which is a deed of taking a being from the sea into an environment in which it will choke to death on a daily basis to earn a living, because of the number of times it is done, becomes a very heavy deed. It’s done not once, it’s done thousands of times. The oneself is on the receiving end of an event in which oneself is suffocated.

We breathe air, are put under water. So this is how collective karma operates. Collective karma is just every single person who has accumulated a non deed of a certain type can experience as a community, as a group, this no need maturing on them. And then we analyze to see the similarity of the effect with cause. So if we look at the effect for instance, we take a tsunami, we take an earthquake, same thing.

What is the effect? In the case of a tsunami, it’s destruction by water and drowning. Then we can see that the cause, the karmic cause, however far back it is, must be related to this. Its destruction, as we said, is through taking a being out of its environment and suffocation. Earthquake is destroying the buildings.

It is a destruction which is similar to its cause. What would be the possible cause collectively of accumulating earthquakes? You’ll be shocked, but bulldozing anthills. If you bulldoze an anthill, these are sentient beings, these are persons. Not like us, perhaps, not as intelligent, sophisticated, but these are persons with minds.

We bulldoze an anthill, we destroy a field with living beings inside, we destroy their dwellings, cause them to collapse, we are karmically creating a cause whose result will share similarities with that cause. This is how karma operates. So if you want to know what you did in past lives, look at the tragedies which befell you. All of us have had tragedies in our lives. Look.

What happened to you, you did to another. The good things which happened to you, the good things were things you did to another. There’s a similarity. Then once one understands, this one becomes very careful. Yes.

It’s not difficult to obtain a human rebirth. It’s difficult to obtain a precious human rebirth. Just a human body, there’s no big difference with an animal. Most human beings live like animals. Precious human rebirth, in other words, human rebirth which is focused in a very broad sense beyond this life, that is hard to get.

Then, obviously, Stevenson’s research is research in children who remember memories which can be remembered. My personal suspicion is that animal rebirths are extremely common, spirit and heroin rebirths are even more common, but they are impossible to remember. I think there is nothing in our present experience which enables us to make sense of them. If you have domestic animals, you can get a sense of this. Look at your dog or your cat.

What sort of mental experience do they have? I mean, at the end of that life, if you had to to describe thoughts you had, what would there be? Nothing, basically. That at all? Is that is that there’s no kind of, like, This this is a personal reflection.

It’s my private personal feeling. I mean, I remember I knew a very good Russian practitioner who had the most extraordinary comment. She said, you know, I find out of the blue, I find cows the most extraordinary animals, and the scent of manure is an absolute delight. Now, where does a comment like this come from? So, actually, I think this is perhaps the way we should be moving.

Then in the case of rebirths or rebirths, I think the suffering would be horrific. To be frank with you, I think the chances of a being reborn as a human being are very low. The chances of a preter being reborn as a human being are very low. The chances of an animal being reborn as a human being are very low. Because once you’re an animal, what do you accumulate?

Animal, comma. Yes. Yes. But how many animals do this? Well, not many, but some.

Some do. But if you take an animal in the wild, a carnivorous animal to live has to kill every day. Every day. A dog like we all think dogs are very sweet, cats are very sweet. They’re very sweet because we feed them canned food.

Otherwise, a cat, a dog in the wild lives through killing on a daily basis. Hermovous animals are stratified by ignorance. Then what karma has accumulated? The only chance for human rebirth would be past karma, way back. But then the conditions have to be met.

So being a pet would create those conditions. Being a pet perhaps at the time of death, if there were human karmic imprints, it might happen. Excuse me. Someone else wanted to ask a question, I think. Zero.

So we said what we talked about this morning. This idea of choice in the process of incarnation is something which is completely alien to Buddhist thought. It’s not as if in the bardo we decide what we will reincarnate as. It would be very nice. It would be really, really nice, but I would put it to you that we would see a very different statistical distribution of professions and wealth than the one we have.

So in reality, it is at the instant of death that our freedom of choice stops. Once we enter the death process, there’s a very specific point at which conceptual activity stops. At that point, we are no longer able to influence our next rebirth. We are no longer able to create karma which would change our next rebirth. From that point on, it’s on autopilot.

Away were the deceased and the recipient? So then your your point about being reborn close by is a very strong one, and there’s a good reason for that. The reason is very simple. Who do we accumulate strong karma with respect to? People in our environment.

We don’t accumulate strong karma with respect to people in other continents most of the time, But we do with respect to the local green grocer and our mother, our father, our sister, our daughter. It’s a famous anecdote of Charipotra. Seeing a mother suckling a child and beating a dog which is eating fish bones. And, through his precognition sees that the child mother was suckling was her foremost enemy in a past life. The dog she is kicking was her husband and I think the fish was her father.

Now this is how karma operates. It is often in close relationships because that’s where the powerful deeds are accumulated. We don’t know, but I mean, I think it is clear that there is a mixture of biology and karma. There’s biological causality and karmic causality. They intersect.

Then what is the one and what is the other that’s difficult to say? That’s a very difficult balance to find. Are there yes? I noticed that when in our whole discussion about karma, I noticed that you used the term receiving party and not the term victim. And something about that interests me because I I think part of the notion of not not coming out of a culture that does past lives and future lives, we get caught up in the destructive event because then then for us, there’s nothing after that.

But for for the mother and child, that that’s it. Right? They’re dead. There’s no whereas the whole the whole it’s not just changing the words, changing the language, but it comes out of such a fundamentally different mindset to say that this is a result that will give rise to further causes. And so therefore, it’s not simply on a victim in this situation.

It’s From a good receiving party, and something about that change isn’t just to be groovy. It’s actually about fundamentally changing one’s understanding of misfortune. Yes. Exactly. Yeah.

Yeah. Exactly. From a Buddhist standpoint, there are no victims. Yeah. I mean, if I wanted to shock you, I would say there are only guilty parties.

All of us are guilty of what happens to us. Or should I say, someone else in the past life to whom we had connected through being part of the same continuum is guilty. So at present, we have good human rebirths because of someone else’s hard work, our past life hard work. What happens to us is a result of past life behavior. Then I think it’s a very liberating viewpoint, myself.

Because we escape from this very near the very narrow confines of the culprit and the victim. And we see a relationship. The relationship between that soldier and those, two victims is a tragic relationship which will continue life after life until one of them puts an end to it. Then this is something we see in the cases of hypnotic regression. It’s very powerful.

I think it’s the strongest argument for the fact that quite a few of them are authentic. We see I knew a case at Sera. It’s a western lady who came to visit me. And it is clear there is something going on. She for four subs there had been four generations of sexual abuse in that family.

Mother, four generations where the women were abused by their father. She was abused by her father, and what was extraordinary was her daughter was being primed by her to be abused. She was an aging woman who was using her daughter to attract men to her. It was transparent to all on the outside. And the daughter had the most extraordinary dreams which clearly showed this.

Then you can only wonder what the karmic relationship is. You know? These relationships, these karmic tragedies are situations in which the whole notion of blame should be eliminated. It’s a very Judeo Christian in a Western trait to try to identify one person who is responsible and one person who is a victim. Actually, we have been switching roles for countless lives.

Switching roles. You see it all the time. You see it all the time. So then because we ourselves don’t want to experience this in the future, we have the possibility to cut things now, to put an end to this. That’s that was the goal of this talk.

The goal is to understand these mechanisms. These mechanisms become meaningful only if we believe in past and future lives. If we don’t believe, there’s no point. Then it’s just a curiosity, what the Buddhists think. But if we do, then it is very important to understand how karma and causality function.

And tomorrow, we will try to connect this with spontaneous cases of memory from past lives and cases of hypnotic regression, then I think you will see that there is a real pattern. Hypnotic regression is particularly interesting because you can go back over a large number of lives. Then if you see a pattern through the lives, you get a sense of how karma might operate. I’m not saying these cases are authentic, but there is an internal coherence which is very striking. Once we see that, then it is up to us to become proactive and to start using karma for us instead of having had it operate against us for so long.

So thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top