TBI Symposium – 110730-001

1 h 4 min · 7,262 words

TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium - 110730-001
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The speaker surveys Western neuroscience of mind and consciousness, covering the limbic system, brain imaging, neuroplasticity, and research with the Mind and Life Institute on meditators’ loving kindness and compassion. He contrasts this with Buddhist views of consciousness as beginningless and continuous, and of emptiness and dependent arising, and suggests that dialogue between the two could benefit both.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 5m

UUID: 1a6a45fb-6af0-477d-831d-c2fc143fc290

Words: 7,258

Can you hear me now? Okay, so as I said, I’d like to thank all the organisers for asking me to speak, and particularly Khen Rinpoche, who I think suggested that maybe I might have a useful contribution to make. So I’m very happy to be here. I would also like to say that I apologise in advance for things that I’ve left out because I feel I’m, kind of a bit of a reporter, and so, or a journalist in this way, and so the reporter is the person who chooses bits and pieces to present a bit of a buffet, might say, to tweak your scientific and dharma appetite about this topic. So this is not meant to be comprehensive in any way.

It is highly selective, and that’s what I’m saying, please forgive me for obvious things that I will have left out because I have pointedly picked a few things that I think will be helpful, and that the other presenters will probably highlight other things that I haven’t touched on, and things might come up in the question time. So while I’ve said it’s mind and consciousness, it’s also the dialogue between East and West, and it’s an epic dialogue, I have to say. Now, I just have to get used to this. Just a few words about happiness, because all this comes about because we’re living in a world where we seem to be more unhappy than happy. And so what is it?

According to Rousseau, every man wants to be happy, but in order to do so, he needs first to understand what happiness is. So we need to have an idea of what happiness is. Is it just the absence of pain and suffering? Or what is it? And how can happiness be sustained?

Now, is a question for a Buddhist and a non Buddhist. So, these are very important, things to consider. Leaving back two and a half thousand years, four, three thousand years ago, Epicurus, one must practice things which produce happiness, since if that is present, we have everything. If it is absent, we do not have everything in order to have it. So that seems fairly logical, and I think Buddhists would agree with that, and you can see from your Buddhist practice and where things are going to lead.

Mahatma Gandhi said, we must be the change we wish to see in the world. So if we want to live in a happy, peaceful, harmonious world, we have to do something about it. I’ve just come back from Washington DC where His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, was giving the Kālacakra for world peace. And of course, in that, as he does every time he gives any talk or any initiate, but particularly the Kālacakra, he emphasizes, this aspect, and that it’s beholden to each and every one of us to try and examine what can we do to make a happier, peaceful world. Now, I put these two together.

It’s the East and West. We have, Buddhist perspective, if you like, to remind us, and we have a human brain, with some of the designated areas. I have two models here of the human brain, one is not labeled, the other one is, so you get an idea of, the anatomy of the human brain. I have to say that before I became a psychiatrist and a psychotherapist, I was a haematologist and a pathologist, and in my training we had to do post mortems, and I’ve cut up a few hundred brains, human and a couple of neonatal brains, which was pretty shocking. But of course, nowhere did I find any locus that said mind or consciousness or anything like that.

It’s simply not there. So here we have just some of the basic outlines of the brain, the cortical. This is the area of the frontal cortex which is actually pretty important, which you’ll come to know about soon. And deep within that area, the sulcus, there is a part called the insula which is very important for emotions. So, here we go as mind and consciousness.

I mentioned about looking at happiness and altruism. In fact, the experiments I’m going to show you a few results of later relate to this and relate to compassion training. And we have to ask ourselves, is it beneficial to think about happiness and altruism? And I think the answer has to be yes, definitely. And how can we become altruistic in our intention?

Now, this is just an overall brief summary of some of the areas I’m going to talk about. Consciousness, I’ll talk about the Mind and Life Institute, which I think is, might say, key to the explosion of research into the area of cognitive neuroscience and the dialogue with Buddhism. The human brain, bit of the anatomy, but particularly the limbic system. The limbic system is said to be the emotional brain that neurons that fire together wire together. I don’t know, are any of you psychologists or involved with the study of the brain here at all?

Yes, Pamela is. So, you would know all about this and also about the insular. I actually left the insular out in detail there, so I apologise for that. But it’s been the limbic system has and the idea about it’s been around for a number of years, but now it’s become quite controversial as more knowledge is known that that’s just not the only answer, there are other things. And some of the research into neuroimaging and meditative states, I haven’t detailed all the possible research that is available.

As I said, the explosion of research in this area has occurred in the last ten to fifteen years. Last year, last decade has been the decade of the human brain, and so a lot of research has occurred in that time. In the early 90s, it was not any researcher who wanted to do this kind of collaborative research was frowned upon as being more or less a bit of a hippie. So, basically, one has to realise that it is a new area, things are occurring pretty rapidly, and hopefully things will continue. But from the science point of view, it is fraught with great difficulties because trying to find, as you might know, in scientific experimentation, you have to have a hypothesis, you have to have set up the experiment so that it could be, your results could be reproducible, and the kind of experiment you’re going to use has to be fairly clear and valid and so that it can be peer reviewed, and said yes, this could make a contribution to science.

And so most scientists are quite terrified that what they’re going to set up in this area will not be acceptable. And why is that? It’s because the kind of research they’re doing using adept meditators and novices, trying to determine out is this valid, is this something that can be hold up to scrutiny? And because in Buddhism, as you know, what are you going to choose? Are you going to choose one particular school of Tibetan Buddhism?

Are you going to choose Theravada or the basic vehicle of Buddhism, and amongst the different schools, what type of Buddhism are you, what kind of practices are you going to choose? The other thing to remember, and I’m not going to discuss it in any great detail, is I’m going to do that in my second talk, about mindfulness. Now, there is mindfulness and there is mindfulness, and there is mindfulness. And what mindfulness means to one group is not the same as it means to others. And the research of Jon Kabat-Zinn focused on a particular kind of mindfulness and did some experiments, said it was reproducible, but across the spectrum there are so many different types.

You can pick up any Buddhist book in any tradition and you’ll find different things, the same word means different things, the same as the Samatha meditation or special insight means different things and practiced in different ways. So that’s just a caveat, just saying, you know, it’s like, beware, you have to be very careful about what it is you’re looking into. Then I’m going to talk a bit about the Buddhist view of mind, and again I apologize, this is highly selective and it’s only like a pinch of salt and basically a lot of you know more than I do about it. And then just a note on the appreciation of benefits of the interchange between the two disciplines. So, we’re going to look at the Western view of mind and consciousness and a bit about the Buddhist view.

And putting it in context with the Western view, again, there’s no clear definition of mind, but it’s more like a stream of consciousness knowing, having an idea of who we are, myself, a sense of self and who I am. But that’s very different from the Buddhist view of self and I and me, that sort of thing, it’s quite different. And the Buddhist view of mind is something about continuity from beginningless time, and consciousness again depends on several factors which I’ll come to. Well, what does the West say? It’s postulate well, I should point out too, consciousness there’s no actual site of consciousness.

Western scientists and medical scientists are very coy about it. You ask them, well, where is the seat of consciousness? And they can’t tell you. They say, All we can say is that when the person is you attach electrodes to the brain, you check the brain waves, and where there’s no way, wave activity, I. E.

A flat line, the person has become deceased, and there’s no consciousness. But as Buddhists will tell you, there is something outside that and there is something that can’t be explained by Western scientists. Now, Western medicine says it’s a state of being conscious awareness of one’s own existence, sensation, thoughts, surroundings, like who I am at the moment. It represents the full activity of the mind and senses. Of course, scientists believe you have to have a structure, some kind of, in the Buddhist term, aggregate, upon which consciousness can rest.

So, the scientists are tracking it down to chemicals and activated neurons and probably will go further to atoms, to the atoms. And so, when you start getting, if you start getting down to that level, you’re going to look at maybe the space within molecules. Now, what does that say? I mean, that’s an area for dialogue between Buddhists and scientists, and what’s that going to mean when they finally get there? I mentioned about the unconscious state.

Now, the different states of consciousness exist according to Western belief, that’s the coma or the state induced when someone has an injury, head injury, the person is alive, but the brain is not fully functioning due to the accident or the injury. There are drugs that alter the state of consciousness, such as anaesthetics. Who’s had an operation amongst you? Put your hands up. Okay, so have a think about that and think about what happened to your level of consciousness when you went under the anaesthetic.

So you can have any anaesthetic agent, whether it’s a drug injected or a gas that alters your state of consciousness to the point where you’re still alive, you’re breathing but you’re not aware of things fortunately when you’re going under the knife. But some people have woken up during surgery. And of course there’s a sleeping state and there are various levels of sleep, but I’m not going into that, but you’ll be aware perhaps from your own experience different things have occurred to you when you’re sleeping. There’s your dreaming state, the non dreaming state, there’s an in between state, and there’s a type of state where you are going off to sleep and you may experience unusual feelings or sensations, even what we call delusions. Not everyone experiences that and not everyone who it’s not restricted to someone who has a mental illness.

Similarly, when a person wakes up, they may notice some of these similar things. So, in other words, with the West, and you notice yourself, there’s a stream of consciousness, your thoughts do appear continuous, there’s no actual gap, but the thing is, when did that consciousness arise? If you go back to gestation and the fetus, science is not able to say exactly when the consciousness begins, but we do know that a fetus, some fetuses, can experience pain in utero, they can cry, they can hear sounds, respond to music, various other things, so there’s a lot we do not know about the embryonic state, and the development of the brain, and probably they initially said, oh, consciousness arises. First of all, they said, oh, at birth. Then they went back and said, oh no, it’s probably around six months when the baby, the foetus is viable, but we do know that there have been some neonates have been born for various reasons, much earlier periods of gestation before the forty weeks, so some have come out at 22.

You know, it’s a wonder that they can survive, it’s a wonder that their brain can function. So it’s a miracle, you might say, of medical neonatology that these little infants, babies can survive and you have to wonder though what does happen to their brain. Buddhists would say it occurs at the time of fertilization, the consciousness enters the human organism at that very moment of fertilization. Now, if science was able to refine what they do to pick that up, it would be really fascinating, then that would be the beginning of another kind of dialogue there. Now, I’ve just put in to remind myself the visual primary hierarchy of the brain and the fact that the visual cortex in humans has been the most studied because it’s been very well documented.

We go back to the posterior aspect of the brain here is the visual cortex at the back, cortex and basically that has been very clearly mapped and so studies have been done where they’ve focused a certain colour light on the retina and the individual and again this is first person it’s very important can tell you what color they’re receiving. Now, there have been some experiments which I haven’t designated here, but where some Buddhist adepts have changed the nature of the light that they perceive and that’s by due force, like they’re being told, okay, this color is being focused on your retina, but I want you to change the color to blue. For example, say they focus a red light and they say I want you to manifest a blue light, so these adepts can actually do that, but I don’t have any studies to show you that, but that can happen. But this is a direct perception, it’s not going through second or third parties. So this is an area where Buddhists and Western science could communicate on this area because it’s so well documented.

Now, this quote, That which arises dependently we explain as emptiness. This emptiness is dependent designation. This is the middle way. Because there is no phenomenon that is not dependent arising, there is no phenomenon that is not empty. I put this up as an introduction, I guess, into a Buddhist way of thinking, because it’s so diametrically opposite to anything that Western science could possibly comprehend, but hopefully they are starting to look at this.

Now, in Buddhism, the mind is thought to be primary awareness. So, mind plus body plus awareness is consciousness. This is my understanding. So the awareness exists since beginningless time. How many of you have tried the meditation of the continuity of mind?

Okay, it’s a good meditation to try, and that can show you that you could go back and back and back as far as you can, and those of you that have a positive predisposition could possibly go back to former life or lives. But certainly, the continuity of consciousness, I think, is a demonstration that there is no break in the mind or consciousness, although everything changes. That is another area for dialogue between Buddhism and the West, but they have not quite tapped into that. So, mind is defined as a phenomena which perceives, thinks, recognises, experiences and reacts to the environment. The body is all that is prone to physical phenomena, including physical expression and emotional pain.

So here, Buddhists cannot really separate mind and body, they’re all the same. Whereas scientists say, oh, it’s very different, it’s completely different. Physical, mental and spiritual states constantly interact in the realm of consciousness. Through meditation, the Buddhist believes an intrinsic awareness can develop beyond brain and sensory perception. Now, there was something interesting about consciousness outside the human body that I alluded to at the start, and you may not be aware there have been some reports of people who have had transplants, transplants of kidney, heart, mostly those two organs where the person receiving the transplant has felt something strange going on and may have had dreams about the organ that’s been transplanted and it’s been reported and documented.

There was a woman who received a renal transplant and she had a dream and this voice kept coming up and a name called Timmy. She said, I don’t know anybody called Timmy, Timmy. Anyway, so she, it was constant, and Timmy kept asking for beer and McDonald’s, and this woman had never had any of those things. So, in the end, she went back to where she had the transplant and asked to get some information about the organ, and eventually found out that the organ came from someone called Timmy, who was in his 20s, and she did see the family. They agreed to talk to her, and he was completely addicted to McDonald’s and beer.

So, this is a very interesting case. There have been a couple of others like that as well. I think there was an even movie made about someone who had a transplanted heart and the story relating to that, I think it was in the last couple of years, but this is true. Now, I put this slide up as an introduction to the Mind and Life Sciences Institute. This is Professor, it’s Ritchie, as His Holiness calls him Ritchie, Professor Davidson, and that’s Thupten Jinpa, who’s Holiness’s main translator.

But, and he’s usually present at these, but Ritchie Shee is the one who’s done these special experiments. Now, I’m going to talk about the Mind and Life Institute because it was the initiator of most of these experiments, and particularly through Richard Davidson. And he was one of them who, from the early 70s in 1974, when he was an early young post grad, went to Dharamsala to learn about meditation. Now, as I said, it began with the Mind and Life Institute in His Holiness’s sitting room in Dharamsala and expanded then over the years to full on presentations in erudite institutions. And so, basically we thought, let’s try and look into what is mind and how best can we look into that.

On their website, they’ve got a lot of details about recent fellows, the awards that they’ve made and their research in peer reviewed journals. Now people involved in the Mind and Life Institute were Adam Engle, Francisco Varela, who’s deceased, Richard Davidson. Francisco and Richard were contemporaries, Jon Kabat-Zinn, Daniel Goleman. Okay, it’s a spectrum of collaborative bodies and organisations are involved in the research, and they’re partnering with other organisations and sponsors. Now, these are only a selection of some of the ones involved, the list is too long, but you can see it’s now in the mainstream, it’s now accepted.

So, any of you that are involved in research in these areas, you might like to consider some collaborative work with the Mind and Life Institute or whatever you can do, since you’re coming from a Buddhist background, it would be very important. So you can see University of Zurich, so it’s international, I mean Europe, also some through the university in Amsterdam and I think South America now, so it’s sort of expanding. Nothing in Australia yet, so I’m suggesting you might like to put Australia on the map. The mission: building a scientific understanding of the mind to reduce suffering and promote well-being, I. E, happiness, seeks to understand the human mind and the benefits of contemplative practices through an integrated mode of knowing that combines first person knowledge from the world’s contemplative traditions with methods and findings from contemporary scientific inquiry.

So, I keep mentioning first person knowledge, so, that is what scientists would want. So, things are not diluted or contaminated. What are the core values? Love, mindfulness and compassion, trust and integrity, teamwork and collaboration, impeccability and continuous improvement, open communication and transparency. The vision to reduce individual and societal suffering, promote individual and planetary peace, health, well-being and cooperation.

Mission and strategy is to promote and support rigorous multidisciplinary scientific investigation of the mind, which will lead to the development and dissemination of practices and cultivate the mental qualities of attention, emotional balance, kindness, compassion, confidence and happiness. And you might say, well, that’s terrific. We need more of it. It’d be great if there were more institutions and bodies that were doing work in this area to promote this instead of, you know, promoting research into weapons that can destroy people’s lives. It is multidisciplinary, research in the traditional mind sciences, social sciences, contemplative scholarship and practice, philosophy and humanities.

So, it’s spreading over a lot of areas. This strategy includes dialogues with His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. He is a key factor because every year or every second year he’s directly involved in these conferences with the Mind and Life Institute, which are held at different places in America. And to get into it, have to pass certain criteria because they want people who are involved in these areas in research to have the dialogue in a meaningful way, so you’re not just talking off the top of your head, but you’ve got something to back it up. So, the Summer Research Institute, they have to train scientists and scholars in the emerging fields of contemplative science and studies.

So, contemplative science now is a real entity, and I’ll show you shortly that there’s the first symposium, the International Meeting next year, and I hope some of you might be able to go. The Mind and Life Institute research grant program, so there are grants. Mind and Life Institute collaborator initiative organizes organizes international symposia on contemplative studies and best practices in contemplative research. There’s the Mind and Life Institute developmental science research network, explores human development issues and helps create education related programs that can help children cultivate mental qualities of attention, emotional balance, kindness, confidence, happiness in early life. Okay, so the funding is independent non profit.

His Holiness, the Dalai Lama has contributed. He’s made donations. I know his last donation was over 50,000 US dollars. The Hershey Foundation’s made large donations. His donation’s coming from everywhere now, so that’s very positive.

Now, this is what I was talking about. It’s the first International Symposia for Contemplative Studies. It’s going to be in Denver, Colorado next April and there, if you go to the website, you can see all the prominent speakers and the tentative program. Now, I mentioned about the, awards. They were established in honor of Francisco Varela, who was instrumental in, setting up and promoting Mind and Life Institute with His Holiness.

So far, there have been at least 44 articles in peer reviewed journals, which is very important, more than 80 presentations and more than 40 poster sessions. So you can say now it’s mainstream and it’s accepted. As I said, the awardees, you can look on the website and find out who they have been and what they’ve written, which is very interesting and diverse. You can also buy DVDs and CDs of some of these talks at the Mind and Life Institute. Now, we’re turning more specifically to the neuroscience.

We’re looking at cognition, how things are perceived, but more I’m going to do a bit about the structure of the limbic system. It might seem a little bit boring, but try and keep with me on it. Then I’ll do a bit about the neuroimaging studies, which include the MRIs and the functional magnetic resonance imaging, the F MRIs. MRIs. We’ll talk a little bit about neuroplasticity.

I acknowledge some of the neuroimaging slides I got directly from Matthieu Ricard. He was recently in Australia and he gave me a few pictures. I hope I interpret them correctly. It is a bit dry, but see if you can stick with it. Now, the emotional brain or the limbic system was discovered some years ago, and if you can look at the limbic system here, it’s like a question mark really, a bit of a question mark and it should go down here a bit, down to the brain stem, and some of the key areas we’ll come to now, but mostly it involves things like this part of the brain is a cingulate gyrus.

The pineal gland really isn’t involved, but it’s on the old structures. The mammillary bodies are two little bodies down there that look like two little breasts, hence the name mammillary. The thalamus, which is this structure here, which is divided up into various, what they call, nuclei. The hypothalamus is just there below the thalamus, and the amygdala, which is a little acorn part deep in the brain, and the hippocampus, which is just near there. And what happens, some of those structures are altered, particularly the amygdala and the hippocampus and the thalamus in cases of trauma, emotional trauma.

And of course, part of the cortex, this posterior cortex, anterior cortex here, there’s the prefrontal cortex which we’ll talk about in a moment. So again, it’s said that when people feel emotions, limbic system lights up in various areas and that reestablishes the connections and makes it stronger. So the limbic system is said to be the emotional brain, inverted commas. The structures interconnect quite intensively, some more strongly than others. The humans display the largest web of connections and therefore have the greatest variety of feelings and emotions.

In mammals, of course, they have some of this, and strangely enough, it’s not my area, I’ll leave that to Pamela, but birds are thought to feel pain and they can communicate it to each other and some other animals or organisms in lower realms, but it’s early days about that. But the limbic system, currently it is still designated the limbic system, but because of research that’s going on, this may change a bit, it could freeze it up a bit. The strong human emotions that are expressed can be identified going through the limbic system, and there is some involvement of the autonomic nervous system. Now, the amygdala, we’ll go into the structures now, and perhaps I won’t go through each of them in great detail, but simply to say this is deep inside the temporal lobe. It is connected with the other areas, particularly the hippocampus.

Now, in trauma, the hippocampus shrinks, like a person who has emotional trauma, people with borderline personality disorder, people who have suffered complex PTSD for example, the hippocampi tend to shrink. But the interesting thing is with treatment and with psychotherapy, particularly in borderline patients, the hippocampi can be restored to normal, as can the thalamus. So that’s another evidence for neuroplasticity and remodeling of the brain. So the idea that the brain is a static organ and can’t change is not true. Like when I studied as an undergraduate medical student, I was told the brain is an end organ, that that’s it, when it’s damaged there can be no more neurons.

It was very sad depressing. And then in recent years, we know that this is not true. We know that the pathways can change, there’s remodelling. We know now from studies which is very controversial at first, but using human brain stem cells, you can inject them into the brain, and it’s hoped that this will help remodel the brain, and that there may be hope for diseases such as Parkinson’s disease. Does anyone know the actor Michael J. Fox?

Do you know his illness? It’s very severe Parkinson’s onset in his early or late 20s. Now, he’s had all the treatments and he’s even had the stem cells, so that has helped him and that’s what’s keeping him going, but we don’t know how long that’s going to last. But the fact is there’s hope, and maybe it will also be used in Alzheimer’s disease, but that’s a bit complicated due to the nature of Alzheimer’s, but I don’t want to get sidetracked into that. So, the amygdala has important role that should be, yes, meditation, control of major affective activities.

So these are the major emotions and expressions. It also, interestingly, identifies danger, and important is self preservation, preservation, triggered by fear, anxiety, flight and fight. The hippocampus is involved with memory, long-term memory. If they’re destroyed, your memory becomes eliminated. So, that’s pretty sad.

The thalamus, the stimulation of its nuclei associated with changes in emotional reactivity. It is mostly connected to other limbic system structures and cortical zones of the prefrontal cortex in the hypothalamus give it its importance. I just wanted to mention about the prefrontal cortex, which I hadn’t put as a separate section, but the prefrontal cortex is now emerged as, it’s not designated as part of the limbic system, but it’s designated as something, part of the brain with very major connections to all parts of the limbic system, and we can look at the two different sides. We’ve got the right prefrontal cortex, sorry, right and left prefrontal cortex, and it’s thought that the right prefrontal cortex is much more concerned with negative emotions and that the left prefrontal cortex is more associated with positive emotions, happiness, mean joy, those sorts of things, and it has been shown with EEG studies that there’s much more activity in, as I said, in the left prefrontal cortex with all the positive emotions, the feeling of well-being, and interestingly feeling of self awareness, so the more firing of that area. And the left and the right one is more of the negative parts.

Now the insular part of the cortex, which is deep within the brain, that’s near the lateral sulcus of the brain, as I mentioned before, is connected with two other important parts of the brain, the temporal lobe of the brain and also with the frontal lobe of the brain. And it also has connections and things that can be identified with self awareness and the interpretation of experience. And the insular is something in which more research is being done currently. So I think I’ll have to move along because I’m going to run out of time. So again, this is just to show you that the connections of these different parts of the limbic system, they’re all interconnected, they all have some aspect with emotion.

Now the cingulate gyrus again coordinates sight and strangely smell with pleasant memories of previous or past emotions. It’s also involved in reaction to pain and the regulation of aggressive behavior. If the bundle was cut in this fibres, pre existing anxiety levels and depression seem to disappear. The brain stem, which is that long part going down the neck, is responsible for emotional reflex reaction, has various structures, it has alerting behavior in sleep, affects the sleep wake cycle. The ventral tegmental area is that part going down and that’s mostly responsible again for joy, anger and sadness.

So, we’ll just, the prefrontal area which I have just explained, this is very important, but if this was damaged, then people are not able to solve problems. Cognitive processes become quite impaired. Now overall, as a summary, the emotions are characterised by sudden disruption of the affective balance, usually short episodes with slight or intense concomitant or subsequent repercussions upon several organs can set up a block or partial block of logical reasoning. So we can end up with loss of control. Now, looking at the neuroimaging, which I’ll have to do in very brief time, these are the MRI and what it means.

Uses magnetic fields and radio waves to produce high quality two or three dimensional images of the brain, and the important news that it can be used to image the brain in real time. That’s why the brain is functioning, that’s why it’s so important. The functional MRI relies on magnetic properties of the blood to enable measurement of blood flow in the brain in real time, and you can see the changes in brain activity as various tasks occur are being done and various stimuli are applied. We can see whether the brain activity occurs simultaneously or sequentially in different parts of the brain as the participant thinks, feels or reacts to external stimuli. PET, positron emission tomography, is slower to reveal images, but retains the advantages of being able to pinpoint which neurochemicals are involved.

Now, there’s some examples of researches done in Davidson and Lutz’s laboratory, this goes back to 2004, where they were using functional imaging in novices and long-term practitioners or adepts to look at what happens when loving kindness meditation is being done, and it was set up in a certain way with the boundaries I was trying to designate earlier. These were done in adepts from the two schools of Buddhist, Tibetan Buddhist teaching, Nyingma and the Kagyus, and they had between ten thousand and fifty thousand hours of experience. So, they looked at activation in the anterior insular and the somatosensory cortex, the anterior cingulate cortex, left prefrontal cortex, and deactivation of the parietal cortex. The adip showed more enhanced activation in novices and data, they believe, supported that the the altruistic state invoked a specific matrix of brain signal regions linked to feeling states, planning of movement and positive emotions. So, I found interesting the bit of planning of movement, which I wasn’t aware of before.

So, the positive and negative emotions are expected to differentiate left and right prefrontal cortices respectively, as I mentioned before. Now, basically, we’ll move on. So, love and compassion require an understanding of the feelings of others, suggesting that the very regions subserving one’s own feeling states also mirror one’s empathic experience of others’ feelings. Experienced in empathic pain commonly activate the anterior insula and the rostral anterior cingulate cortex. So, the data suggests these are flexible skills, can be learnt, and indicates the mechanisms of neuroplasticity, and mind body interaction suggests that training may have a Lojong impact on the brain and body, physical health, well-being, etcetera.

So future research using adepts who may be able to induce a state of bare consciousness, now that hasn’t been clearly defined, but beyond the usual state of meditation, would be looking, examining a particular type of consciousness. These, meditative traditions provide a compelling example of strategies and techniques that evolved over time to optimize human well-being, we can now say that the capacity for happiness and compassion is a trainable skill, but not everyone wants to do it because it requires some kind of effort. So the studies, neuroscientific studies, still in their infancy, it’s very early days, but we can see that the suggestion is that neuroplasticity is underlying this. Neuroplasticity is found in many other areas in the human brain where the human brain has been damaged, like stroke or something else, and that there is recovery. Years ago it was thought that those brains could not recover, that people who have a major stroke, there is hope, because if the damage is not too gross, there can be recovery, and that’s where there is hope.

Further examinations in 2007, using FMRIs and using again expert meditators and loving kindness meditation showed again the results showed up the limbic system as being involved. One of the most interesting things was that the a larger cortical thickness was found in these regions amongst long time meditators and in controls, again partly showing neuroplasticity, but the fact that something is pretty unbelievable, you can get more grey matter in your brain. How extraordinary is that? You know, you want to rush out immediately and start meditating here while I’m giving the talk, during the talk, so you can increase your grey matter. Don’t miss a second.

I mean, it’s really important because you never know when you’re going to need that last neuron. I mean, they keep telling you that the brain has got so many neurons and we don’t use, but look, you know, the way we live our lifestyle, we’re using them up all the time. Now, as I said, it was once thought to be a static organ, but it’s not anymore. Now, does anyone recognize who this gentleman is? He’s one of the adepts that were involved in the experiments.

He’s all wired up for the EEG. Here, what we have tried to do for the sake of the experiment is to generate a state in which love and compassion permeate the whole mind with no other consideration, reasoning or discursive thoughts. So the meditators, adepts are really into it, right? This is sometimes called pure compassion or non referential compassion. So it’s all pervading compassion.

So those of you that are into your meditation on compassion will understand what this means. Now, here’s Mathieu Ricard before he himself gets wired. These particular slides are courtesy of Mathieu before he goes into the scanner. This is another Rinpoche, I’m not sure if anyone knows him, I think he’s Nyingma, I think he could be Mingyue, Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche, I’m not quite sure. And these were some of the studies showing the peak activation in the meditative state in the adepts, and this was the baseline.

Again, this is showing the left prefrontal activation here in one of the adepts. So, it’s pretty clear. And these are showing some of the structures in the prefrontal cortex and deep in the insula and the thalamus. Again, this is compassion meditation and it’s showing again highlights in the middle insula, but also there are other areas that light up when there’s loving kindness meditation, so it’s not, it’s more global, and in pain compassion. What does this mean?

It means that meditators, when they were told to look at something or told of something, someone experiencing pain, they themselves experience the pain in empathy, and this is what it shows. Interestingly enough, those that had the highest compassion index also had an increased heart rate, so something was going on in chemical reactions. Again, this is imaging in pain and there were more centres in the bilateral areas of the brain. This is showing a number of adepts doing particular meditative exercises that are thought to be impossible, and this Matthew Ricard took this photograph, he took it in to be developed, and the developer said, another one of these trick photographs. But Matthew said, hey, can’t you see?

It’s just one single slide. So this is true. Now just briefly about some of the Buddhist view, again of the primary aggregate of consciousness, and the background of the Four Noble Truths is really important in understanding this because we want to get to the point we all understand there’s suffering, etcetera, how do we get out of it? So we need to find the path of extinction. And why are we here in terms of Buddhist connotations?

It’s because the aggregates cause us to develop negative karma. We’re constantly developing negative karma through the sensations we experience through the physical aggregates, and also the mental formations and consciousness or discernment. And if you study the Abhidharma, there is a series of rapidly changing, discrete, interconnecting acts of cognizance that are described, and in the Mahāyāna texts, it’s the base that supports all experiences, is basically consciousness. So, to understand that, we’d have to have a lecture or discussion on tenets, which I’m not capable of doing. But the basis of the five sense organs, the eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, are derivatives of form, the sixth sense organ, which is mind, is part of consciousness.

Again, if we try to examine it and cut the brain up, or even by mental analysis, we couldn’t find it. The first five sense objects: visible form, sound, smell, taste, touch, are derivatives of form. The six are form, sensation, perception, and mental formations. The six are the basis for consciousness. Now, we really have to look into emptiness.

This from Nāgārjuna, For whomever emptiness makes sense, everything makes sense. For whomever emptiness makes no sense, nothing makes any sense. I bow down to the Buddha, the unequal supreme teacher, who taught emptiness, dependent arising, and the middle way hold a similar meaning. Buddhists say you can have cognition of true existence, but it is not valid. I mean, can have conventional truth and ultimate truth, and we need to have an understanding of those.

We need to have a way of exiting cyclic existence, meaning we need to overcome our ignorance. And how do we do that? We need to have a realization of emptiness and to attain true cessation. His Holiness teaches emptiness, and from Śāntideva’s text, the eighth chapter, he constantly reminds us of that, and understanding of the I, and how does the I exist. Exist.

We have to really look at higher trainings, because just having an intellectual understanding is not enough, and we really need to know how do we get out of cyclic existence more rapidly. So we need to engage in practices that give an understanding of higher states of consciousness, using the winds and drops, the most subtle states, and the mind, this most subtle wind energy that can take rebirth, either again as a human or in a higher state of liberation. So, this is just a representation of what we need. We need the union of method and wisdom to achieve this. What can neuroscience learn from Buddhist presentation of perception?

Buddhist understanding of perception found within the Dharma presents a detailed catalogue of many types of perceptual awareness not found in the West. So I’m sorry I have not been able to have time to go into exact Buddhist examples perception, or in more detail the scientific, neuroscientific ideas of perception. But Buddhist understanding seems to predate the progress of neuroscience in granting an equal causal status in perception to the previous moment of consciousness, the observed object in a sense power of perception. Buddhism offers the centrality of consciousness and the power of the knower from the experience itself. Addressing the neural substrate of experience is a big challenge for neuroscience.

We’re nearly there. So that’s it. Thank you very much. I’m sorry I haven’t left time for questions, but we could probably do that this afternoon.

Key terms in this teaching

conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top