TBI Recordings – Salam310516tues 2 2

1 h 31 min · 4,039 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - Salam310516tues 2 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Teaching on calm abiding, whose main obstacles are agitation and desire. It explains uncontrived definite emergence as a route to the path of accumulation, and says transitions between the later paths occur within meditative equipoise. Calm abiding combined with insight into emptiness is presented as the antidote to ignorance grasping at a self. The talk ends with a question and answer session on sleep, consciousness and the degeneration of calm abiding.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 31m

UUID: cccffe55-8a14-4c6b-a8b4-3f1bb32b560a

Words: 4,035

So in our case, the majority of us have not attained calm abiding. And if we were to ask or inquire what precisely prevents us from obtaining calm abiding? Since in this present context, we are covering grounds and paths, and there is a very close connection between grounds and paths on the one hand and calm abiding and insight on the other hand. Therefore, what is required for calm abiding? So since we haven’t obtained calm abiding, what then are the obstacles or the interferences which have prevent or which prevent us from obtaining calm abiding?

Can you answer this one by one? So the obstacle towards the attainment of calm abiding is well known. It is agitation from within agitation and sinking. Both are obstacles to attaining calm abiding, but agitation foremost. And obviously, of the answers you gave, such as desire and so forth, are closely related to agitation.

So the etymology of calm abiding in Tibetan is that the mind is pacified from distraction to the outside Mhmm. And dwells peacefully inside. So what precisely troubles the mind, distracts the mind to the exterior, and prevents it from dwelling within? None other than agitation, literally wildness in Tibet, which is closely related to desire. So all of us understand, therefore, that that which prevents us from obtaining calm abiding is none other than agitation, which is one of the components of desire.

And desire is that mental factor which turns our mind to exterior objects, specifically the exterior five sense objects. So what precisely fosters the development of desire within our mind stream? None other than the five exterior sense objects. These are the object of observation of desire and in dependence on it, desire increases. Now we can therefore counteract desire by trying to counteract the these five exterior exterior sense objects.

Clearly, at present, if we were to eliminate them completely, perhaps we would die. So how precisely, therefore, can we counter these five exterior sense objects, which are what fosters cause desire within our mind stream? What is extraordinarily helpful to counter them is definite emergence. We talked of the thought of definite emergence. And as you remember, there are two types of definite emergence.

There is ordinary definite emergence and special definite emergence. So as I had explained, to generate a stable, in other words, an uncontrived sort of definite emergence, one must rely on calm abiding. The reason for this is that the generation of this sort of definite emergence and calm abiding are remarkably similar. In the case of definite emergence, the object of abandonment is none other than cyclic existence or the afflictions. In the case of calm abiding, the object of abandonment is likewise the afflictions, mainly those linked to desire and agitation.

So it is clear, therefore, that to generate a stable definite emergence, one uncontrived definite emergence, we must find means to turn away from this distraction of the mind to exterior sensory objects. And the mind is distracted to these objects and prevented thereby from turning inwards. The goal is to turn the mind inwards. So let us imagine, for for instance, our situation faced with two objects, an old, basically useless object, and a new one. Now if we observe our reaction to the old fundamentally useless object, we have no partiality to this object.

Since we have no partiality to this object, in turn, the afflictions such as desire are not focused upon this object and our mind, which is carried away by these afflictions, is not either. So if we have two things, one new and one old, then we have strong attachment to the new one, and we disregard the old one. So as this thought of uncontrived definite emergence arises within our mind stream, in turn, our mind sees clearly the faults of exterior sense objects and turns inwards. This turning inwards of the mind is intimately or closely related to the generation of calm abiding. So one of you had mentioned when I asked what was a beneficial factor for generating uncontrived definite emergence, the awareness of all pervasive suffering.

And I thought I would comment on this. It is an interesting point, although it is difficult to to understand all pervasive suffering. Generally speaking, there are two modes of generating definite emergence. The first is through reflecting on the thoughts of all pervasive suffering. The second is through observing the afflictions within our mind such as anger, envy, competitiveness, jealousy, all the afflictions under the sway of anger, seeing their faults since they trouble our mind, these are the two ways to generate definite emergence.

One can train in either one. So I mentioned to you that it is important to identify the afflictions, to identify the afflictions as afflictions. And if we take the case of anger, probably around among the 7,000,000,000 or so human

Beings in this world, 90% or so view anger as a defective state of mind. There may be perhaps 10% who view anger as a quality. So let us take the case of anger at present. All of us are at ease and relaxed. There is no anger within our mind, but we know well through experience how anger arises, its process, its mode of generation.

And when we investigate its source, it is definite that its source is the ignorance which grasps at a self. Now regarding all pervasive suffering in Tibetan, The term pervasive in Tibetan refers to the 12 limbs of dependent origination, and this is not an easy topic to understand. When we refer to being in cyclic existence, we refer to the fact that we in are within cycle upon cycle of the 12 limbs going from ignorance to compositional factors, consciousness, and so forth. So this topic of the 12 limbs of dependent origination is a difficult topic since it abuts immediately on a presentation of past and future lives. If one does not believe in the existence of reincarnation, it is impossible to present present the 12 limbs.

Since one given cycle of the 12 limbs begins with beginningless ignorance, and this beginningless ignorance then gives rise to the remaining limbs up to the maturation of the karmic imprint at the time of connection of conception, excuse me, which leads to the eleventh and the twelfth limb, the next life. So when we refer to the thoughts of all pervasive cyclic existence, what we are referring to are the thoughts of being caught within these cycles of 12 limbs. In my opinion, there is no difference in, whichever mode of generation of definite emergence one chooses either through reflecting on the afflictions within one’s mind stream or the, 12 limbs and all pervasive suffering. It is foundational to understand that the generation of uncontrived or stable definite emergence marks the entry in the path. So once one has generated either uncontrived definite emergence or a stable experience of definite emergence, one will have entered the path one will have entered the path of accumulation.

Now to enter the path of accumulation, one needs what is known as a mental base, And there are two aspects of this mental base. So as I mentioned, to enter the path, one must have generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. One may or may not have generated calm abiding. Both cases are present. Now there are remarkable similarities between the generation of an uncontrived thought of definite emergence and calm abiding since the main object of abandonment when one generates an uncontrived thought of definite emergence are the afflictions.

And the main object of abandonment when one generates calm abiding is agitation, which is intimately linked with desire and the afflictions. So when one strives to generate a stable experience of definite emergence, so an uncontrived experience of definite emergence in keeping with Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path in which he says, once day and night,, the mind is no longer distracted by the marvels of psychic existence at that point, one will have well generated definite emergence. Then indeed, one will have generated definite emergence. Now such a state of mind is very remote for us. Since we are beings of the desire realm, our consciousness is a consciousness of the desire realm, which is totally scattered towards exterior physical phenomena.

For being such as us to generate such a mind is very difficult. And as I mentioned, this mind of uncontrived definite emergence is remarkably similar to calm abiding in that it turns away from the five sensory objects. So therefore, whether we choose to present this in terms of entry in the path of accumulation or initial generation of uncontrived definite emergence is one and the same. It is, however, important to rely on calm abiding. Then if this is the case, what precisely is the meaning of saying that calm abiding is generated at the level of the middle path of accumulation?

This is a calm abiding specifically focused on emptiness. So, therefore, when we speak of the attainment of calm abiding at the level of the middle path of accumulation, this is a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness. In in other words, a subject, calm abiding, focused on an object, emptiness. Calm abiding is normally attained as a preliminary to entering in the path. So at the level of the middle path of accumulation, for the first time, the object of attainment liberation is apprehended as object of attainment, and one endeavors to understand what prevents one from attaining liberation, which is none other than the ignorance grasping at a self.

What then is the antidote to this ignorance grasping at a self, the wisdom realizing emptiness. However, at this point, the mere realization of emptiness alone cannot act or can act only with great difficulty as an antidote to that ignorance. What is required is much more than that. It is first a calm abiding focused on emptiness and then on insight which analyzes emptiness independence on that calm abiding, leading to an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. Therefore, a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer, in other words, an ascertainment of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer alone would be very hard put to counter the ignorance which grasps at a self.

And the reason for this can best be understood if we analyze the process of generation of a calm abiding focused on emptiness. That first instant of calm abiding focused on emptiness will probably be a mind of the desire realm. Then for such a mind of the desire realm, which is not a mind of the higher realms, a coarse mind, in other words, to act as an antidote to the ignorance which grasps at itself is very difficult. A much, much more subtle level of mind is necessary to counter this. So to counter the ignorance which grasps at a self, we need, therefore, a very stable mind.

Here, we need calm abiding. Then in our own case, do such very stable minds exist within our mind stream? Obviously not. We just have to check our own mind stream. We cannot stay focused for one minute, in other words, sixty seconds on an object.

In my own case, I’m certainly unable to do that. I suspect you are unable to. Then what talk is there here of a stable mind? We either wander by distraction outside or fall sound asleep. Those are the two options.

Think about it. So it is therefore settled that we need for such an antidote to the afflictions to generate a stable mind. Now a stable mind here is a mind related to calm abiding, but a mind

Of calm abiding focused on emptiness is insufficient. That in mind of calm abiding is merely the factor of abiding. In addition to this, we need a factor of analysis, which is provided by the insight generated in dependence on a calm abiding focused on emptiness. Now last time, Geshe la, actually in response to Chris’ question, quoted the stanza from Āryadeva through merely doubting psychic existence is torn to shreds. There are two verses before these final verses.

Those of little merit, in other words, those of dull acumen, will be unable to generate such a doubt. Now in Āryadeva’s stanza, will be torn to shreds is a verb in the future tense, and this is indicative of the realizations which will be obtained as a result of the realization of emptiness. This at least is my own understanding. Now, therefore, it is the inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness, which acts as an antidote to this ignorance grasping at a self. And one can give here an example, which is that of felling a tree with an axe.

If one wants to fell a tree with an axe, first, one needs a sharp axe. This is the wisdom component, in other words, insight. But in addition to a sharp axe, one needs a strong and stable arm to be able to strike with the axe exactly at the same point of the tree over and again. This is calm abiding. If one’s arm is not strong and stable, then sometimes it will strike above, sometimes it will strike below, and it’ll take a long time to cut the tree.

If one strikes always at the same spot, cutting the tree is a rapid affair. And therefore, the inseparable union of a calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness is the antidote to the ignorance grasping at the self within our continuum. Now the next issue we have to address is the transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation. These transitions are critical points. The transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, from the path of preparation to the path of seeing, from the path of seeing to the path of meditation, and from the path of meditation to the path of no more learning always occur within meditative equipoise.

Now in the case of the transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, It is a transition from the last instant of the path of accumulation to the path the first instant of the path of accumulation of preparation, which occurs as a transition from a meditative equipoise to a meditative equipoise. Now in Buddhist texts, what are these meditative equipoises? These are meditative equipoises which can be focused either on emptiness or on the coarse or subtle selflessness of persons. Now the wisdom of meditative equipoise is always followed by a wisdom of subsequent attainment. These two are incompatible or contradictory except obviously at the level of full of full enlightenment.

Mhmm. So what precisely is this wisdom of meditative equipoise focused on emptiness? A valid cognizer which has ascertained emptiness alone is not this wisdom of meditative equipoise focused on emptiness nor is for that matter the realization of emptiness. To generate such a wisdom of meditative equipoise focused on emptiness, one must initially have generated a realization of emptiness. And in addition, one’s mind must not be focused or one wander to anything else but emptiness.

Please think on the fact that the transition from a being who does not enter the past to entering the path, in other words, the path of accumulation does not require a meditative equipoise. But every transition after that does. In other words, from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, the path of preparation to the path of seeing, the path of seeing to the path of meditation, the path of meditation to the path of no more learning. So today, two new topics have been introduced. The first is the concept of a wisdom of meditative equipoise.

As was explained, such a meditative meditative equipoise is not necessary to pass from the status of a being who has not entered the path to having entered the path. In other words, the lower level of the path of accumulation. However, all the transitions of the paths from that point on, from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, to path of preparation, to the path of seeing, seeing to meditation, and meditation to normal learning, all occur within a wisdom of meditative equipoise. The second point is the development of the notion of uncontrived definite emergence. As was pointed out, there is a very close similarity between the uncontrived sort of definite emergence and the generation of calm abiding since the obstacle to generating calm abiding is agitation, and agitation is intimately related to the afflictions.

Mhmm. Then let us think about this for five minutes. Page one.

So when we say that in the transition from the various paths to the subsequent path, the transition occurs from meditative equipoise to meditative equipoise. We do not mean that it occurs from one meditative equipoise to a different meditative equipoise. What we mean is that one meditative equipoise turns into another meditative equipoise. Now the process of transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation is actually a transition from the last instant of the path of accumulation, specifically the last instance of the great path of accumulation to the first instant of the path of preparation. At the last instant of the great path of accumulation, one has a calm abiding which is focused upon emptiness.

This provides a factor of abiding. And in dependence on this calm abiding, an insight analyzes emptiness at the point where that insight analyzing emptiness gives rise to a pliancy of bliss, which has arisen from analysis. At that point, the transition to the first instant of the path of preparation has occurred. It is called the path of preparation because at that point, one no longer falls under the sway of the afflictions. There are four subdivisions of the path of preparation, warmth, peak, forbearance, and supreme phenomena or supreme dharma.

So So, one must proceed from meditative equipoise to meditative equipoise in the transition from path to path. Whether one does have to proceed from meditative equipoise to meditative equipoise in, for instance, a transition from the small to the middling path of accumulation and from the middling to the great path of accumulation or within the four subdivisions of the path of preparation is something we should analyze for ourselves. I’ll take a couple of questions, please. Short questions. So agitation is related to desire, but it is not desire.

It could be defined as a mental factor whose function is to distract the mind outwards. And Nada? Questions? Is it possible to generate the uncontrived thought of definite emergence without conviction in reincarnation? Perhaps, one has to, become habituated with this, meditate on it, and then see.

Geshe-la, could you define or elaborate meditative equipoise a little bit more, please? So there is a terminological difference. Generally speaking, a wisdom of meditative equipoise is a mind which is focused either on subtle or the coarse or subtle selflessness of persons or on emptiness. Calm abidings are not necessarily wisdoms of meditative equipoise. Since calm abiding is not necessarily focused on the course of subtle of persons or on emptiness and exists within the continuum of non Buddhist practitioners.

I guess you’ll have said at one stage early on in relation to counteracting desire that if one did so completely, perhaps we would die, suggesting that there is a necessary element of desire to continue living is or what what did Geshe la what was Geshe la pointing to there? So our present consciousness as beings of the desire realm probably follows the desire. Then our consciousness actually arises very much in dependency on the exterior sense objects. If we were to eliminate the exterior sense objects, just what precisely would we have as consciousness left? We might fall unconscious or become oblivious.

We have very little experience of drawing the mind within ourselves. So we have direct experience of this with sleeping. What is necessary for us to fall asleep? We must put an end to sensory consciousnesses if an iota of sense consciousness is less we can’t fall asleep. Now once we have fallen asleep, what precisely is the difference with death?

There is a difference, but it’s not a major one. We have great experience, great habituation with minds of desire. And even though there is a huge variety of other far more subtle levels of consciousness within our mind stream and we have received tons of explanation on them, we are totally unable to use them. So we must try to become more familiar with these subtle minds. And as we become more familiar with them, then coarse desirous consciousnesses will dwindle.

So, Geshe-la, I was wondering what scientists say about the status of consciousness in deep sleep. Then in then I told him, generally, it is debated. There is electrical activity of the brain in deep sleep, delta and theta waves. But whether consciousness is present or not is an open question. Most scientists would probably say no.

That’s not the case in the dream state. Then Asaṇga in Abhidharma Samuccaya says that when one is in the state of deep sleep or when one thinks, consciousness is interrupted. Mhmm. Yeah. And Nada?

And twice. Natalie? I was wondering, just following up from Richard’s question. The time when Buddha Śākyamūni became an ascetic and nearly died because of lack of food and liquid. Is that an example of if we give up all the desire objects or the sense objects that we could die.

So, no, I was speaking of ordinary beings like ourselves. Then in Buddha Śākyamūni’s case, he relied on what is known as the food of concentration or mental food. Then during that state, ordinary food is not necessary. Then why did he nearly starve to death?

No danger. No. Never. In our case, on the other hand, our sensations are completely dependent on the exterior five sensory objects. Geshe la, last week, you spoke about the temporary cessation of the afflictions by calm abiding, and yet Buddhists say that calm abiding can degenerate.

I wonder what prevents the degeneration of calm abiding. Calm abiding will will degenerate under the influence of the afflictions linked with happiness, with bliss. I want to ask a question about sleepwalking. Is the person that have sleepwalking got the agitation because you say it’s a mental factor, is distracted, and if weather can calm abiding eliminate this? So that some walking in one sleep is a sign of incomplete sleep, then generating calm abiding has nothing to do with it.

Basically, it’s a sign of partial sleep. Yeah. But some people, when they sleep off, they they also do, you know, some activity like eating and you know? Probably. Yes.

Probably. How could calm abiding benefit? There’s no relation. So calm abiding is the generation of that stable factor of appearance. It’s unrelated to sleep.

When one fall asleep, calm abiding stops. And I should add, in sleep, there is no agitation. Can I just ask a follow-up question to what I was asking before? What would be the antidote then to the happiness or the bliss that is a cause for the degeneration of calm abiding? What would be the antidote to that?

So one counters the afflictions of the nature of bliss by understanding the thoughts of the exterior sense objects. Then these afflictions do not arise. And Jan, just one question. Are you planning on teaching us the definitions of the paths? Of the what?

Of the the paths. So the definition of each path. Each So I’ve already explained the meaning of the three subdivisions of the path of accumulation, and I will explain the meaning of the four subdivisions of the path of preparation, warmth, peak, forbearance, and supreme phenomena. Yeah. Yeah.

I’m sorry. I didn’t notice. I didn’t pick up on it. I’ll look more closely. So we shall stop here for tonight.

Key terms in this teaching

desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How is meditative equipoise defined, and how does it differ from calm abiding?

There is a terminological difference between the two. Generally speaking, a wisdom of meditative equipoise is a mind focused on the coarse or subtle selflessness of persons, or on emptiness. Calm abidings are not necessarily wisdoms of meditative equipoise. This is because calm abiding is not necessarily focused on the coarse or subtle selflessness of persons, or on emptiness, and it also exists within the continuum of non-Buddhist practitioners.

Is sleepwalking caused by agitation, as a mental factor of distraction, and can generating calm abiding eliminate it?

Sleepwalking is a sign of incomplete or partial sleep, so generating calm abiding has nothing to do with it. Some people also do activities such as eating while they are asleep, and this too is a matter of partial sleep. Calm abiding cannot benefit sleepwalking because there is no relation between them. Calm abiding is the generation of a stable factor of appearance, and it is unrelated to sleep. When a person falls asleep, calm abiding stops. Also, there is no agitation in sleep.

Scroll to Top