Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching explains the difference between wisdom arising from thinking and wisdom arising from meditation on emptiness, and why the former can be forgotten without stable familiarization. It covers the path of preparation, with its four subdivisions of warmth, peak, forbearance and supreme dharma, and the role of calm abiding combined with special insight. The second half is a group discussion of these points.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 42m
UUID: 95e4fe1d-acc8-4e1c-88d7-86e3c56afbaa
Words: 3,709
Why are the five powers in this context, the first powers? Because they have the power to give rise to their effect, which is the path of seeing. So within these three paths, the path of preparation, the second path, the path of seeing is the third. The path of meditation is fourth. The path of preparation is the preliminary. The path of seeing is the middle path, and the path of meditation comes after these.
The path of preparation is for preparation or praayoga in Sanskrit because it prepares to the attainment of the path of seeing. And therefore, you can see the difference between the path of preparation and the cooperative condition of the path of seeing. Now at which point is this concentration generated at the level of So it is the case that there are instances of generations of mind, the reason for meditation focused on interest. There’s a word called the violence, focused on emptiness at the level of the path of accumulation. Is this, however, of benefit?
Not really. It is certainly not the case that merely to giving rise, for instance, to a realization of endurance such as in mind, reason for thinking focused on endurance that the mere realization of emptiness is of little benefit. For instance, it is true that one should receive teaching of emptiness that is to listen to the topic of emptiness. And in the presence of this, one can give rise to a wisdom arising from thinking of emptiness. In other words, a valid cognizer ascertaining emptiness.
But this alone is insufficient. If we have this alone without generating a wisdom arising from meditation focused on emptiness, then very probably in the future lives, we will forget this experience of emptiness. Therefore, we must at least attain the path of preparation. So let alone future lives. In this life, for that matter, if we do not gain good stability of familiarization with a wisdom arising from thinking of it, we will forget it.
And the reason for this is that our minds are present are minds of the desire realm. In other words, they are extremely troubled minds, minds that are easily distracted. His memory would probably still be the same. School memories around age seven, maybe eight,, and most of that would be forgotten. Then the projects he makes around age seven or eight may last, age nine, maybe 10, For that matter, for those who live to the right old age of 80 or 90, generally speaking, degeneration becomes imminent again. They understand nothing, and their memory is totally lost.
But this is a clear sign that our minds are minds of the desire realm. Let alone forgetting our parents,. If we ourselves were to reach that age, probably our minds would become totally empty. So if we do not repeatedly become familiarized with topics like the language, what hope do we have to gain the stability of mind of accomplished teachers such as Milarepa or Gampopa. So it’s, therefore, critically important to understand the distinction between the wisdom arising from thinking and the wisdom arising from meditation. Now regarding the defining characteristics of the wisdom arising from meditation, the wisdom from meditation focused on emptiness. So I gave you an example to illustrate the difference between these lines clearly to depend on a mind arisen from thinking focused on emptiness,.
If one does not engage in repeated perpetuation is still not enough because one can familiarize repeatedly with the topic, forget it. So one must generate an experience arisen from meditation focused on emptiness.. That is only a benefit.
Therefore, it’s critically important to gain such a wisdom or vision from meditation focused on emptiness. However, And therefore, initially, one must endeavor to understand and to give rise eventually to a valid cognizer which ascertains emptiness. This is a mind that is from thinking focused on emptiness. But as I said, it is doubtful whether this will be beneficial or not. And as Khensur Rinpoche said repeatedly, one must generate stable karmic imprints regarding emptiness, and this can only be done through a wisdom focused on emptiness.
It has been seen that those who have generated it will forget it either in future lives or even in this life. This is not a case of a wisdom arising from meditation focused on emptiness, and therefore, I’d like to request you to reflect by yourselves on why there is such a difference. If, however, I were to provide direct introduction to emptiness, I think you would find it very difficult to understand. So let us approach the problem differently. Let us address the issue of I and the mind.
So we’re here at present. We all have a natural sensation of eyes, for instance. When the heating unit of the air conditioner functions,, then we all say, I feel warm. This is the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensation, the I, which manifests. Likewise, when the air conditioner shuts off, we all say, I feel cold.
Likewise, the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations is the I. So, therefore, the it is the given that such an eye exists such an eye system is based on our experience. If, for instance, we are warm, we say, I feel warm. Likewise, if someone offers offers us a delicious meal, after eating it, we say, this was delicious. I loved it.
So in this respect, the I exists. The difference between the Buddhist and the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India arises as far as the understanding of the mode of existence of this I is concerned. For the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, this I is in relation to the aggregates as a ruler to a subject. For the and this is independently of the aggregates. So it is very, very pleasant to engage in this line of investigation to see the differences between the various modes of positing the I in the various schools of tenets.
They differ as far as your understanding of its mode of existence. Now I’m turning to the path of preparation. The path of preparation is subdivided into four, and you should note these four subdivisions. The first is warmth, the second is peak, the third is forbearance, and the fourth is supreme phenomena or supreme dharma. Now this whole subdivision of the path of preparation is presented from the standpoint of the way in which the antidote to the object of abandonment, which is self grasping, operates.
So the first of these is an apprehension of the object as thoroughly afflicted. And this apprehension of the object as thoroughly afflicted refers, as far as the object is concerned, to the grasping of the self as inherently existent. This refers to the application of objects such as the noble truth of cessation or the noble truth of cessation or the noble truth of the path as being inherently established.. The third is the apprehension of the object as grasping a substance, and this refers to substances being fully established or established from their own side. What really matters is that you understand that the mind arisen from meditation occurs at the level of the path of preparation. And that the path of preparation is subdivided into four as was mentioned, warmth, peak, the forbearance, and supreme phenomena.
Now the context of generating new motivation, please reflect on the fact that if you give rise to a valid cognizer ascertaining emptiness, in other words, a mind arisen from thinking ascertaining emptiness, it is possible to forget emptiness. Whereas, if one gives rise to a mind that isn’t Please open the page one. We will cite one, eight, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, manual offering. That’s one and three. Thank you.
So, basically, as we die, the various aggregates to stop, the the form aggregates appears in the aggregate of sensation, of discrimination, composition of factors, and consciousness dwindles, but the goal that is left is a subtle consciousness So the wisdom of vision from hearing occurs when one thinks about emptiness, one receives teachings about emptiness, emptiness, one reflects about it Now when to repeated analysis, eventually, one eliminates all doubt regarding emptiness. At this point, one has said we have generated a valid cognizer ascertaining emptiness. This is the wisdom which has ascertained emptiness. One should focus on the object, holding it in mind solidly. Now we’ve once, through repeated familiarization by means of a wisdom from thinking focused on emptiness, So for instance, regarding stable or uncontrived definite emergence, we said that this stable or uncontrived definite emergence is in my a reason for meditation. Since it’s difficult to set in the three principles of the path, once it arises day and night continually, true definite emergence would have been generated.
So at this point, indeed, definite emergence arises without any effort whatsoever. Likewise, once the mind focused on emptiness arises spontaneously and without any effort, then we can say that the wisdom arisen from meditation, focused on emptiness has been generated. Now for ourselves, it is probably that we have no experience whatsoever of wisdoms provision from meditation. However, in our own what we experience, we have certain states of mind which arise spontaneously. For instance, when we think of our father, of our mother, of our children, of our boyfriend, girlfriend, immediately spontaneously, a perfectly clear image arises towards mind’s eye.
Doesn’t it? Now I’m not saying that these are minds arising from meditation, but minds arising from meditation share that spontaneity and that clarity. I am not saying it’s an experience arising from meditation. Example it’s an example. Then when such an experience of emptiness, of emptiness, of the forces of definite emergence arises, one is relying on a wisdom arisen from meditation..
Unforgettable. And a mind from thinking focused on emptiness which can forget emptiness. What is the difference? Why is there such a difference? Why does the mind arisen from thinking degenerate? Precisely because such a mind is a mind of the desire realm.
As a reminder, desire realm is affected by agitation and distraction. Wisdom, a reason for meditation. Okay. Then we will start discussion by pairs.
And at that level You said, Is that the gist? Is that the meaning? Well, I see, I thought no. That’s I thought that this was that has And of course, when he’s talking about meditation, he’s not talking about the path of meditation, he’s talking about the difference between meditation and thinking. So when he’s talking about meditation to me, that implies calm abiding.
So it’s the difference between the contemplation and this house. As opposed to camouflaged. Focused as opposed to thinking as opposed to habituation. And so so there’s and you can achieve calm abiding, but you need to combine it. You have to combine it with a special insight.
Focus on the business. Can have and it’s not mere habituation. Said this calm abiding here, which is a mind permeated with a meditation on emptiness, but not special insight,, I understand. That’s the point where you that’s the prevention from going to the lower realms, that it was unlikely that you would ever return to the lower realms. Yes. Once you’ve reached the path of accumulation.
Well, the middle part, the middle of it. The middle part. Because the small one is the main is We may we may draw consolation. Well, but even before you get into the path, to get onto the path, you’ve got to have a renunciation upheld by calm abiding and special insight.. And here, it talks about having an inferential realization with a sharp faculty as a trainee, before you can get onto the path..
So even if you’ve got an inferential Where get this bit of paper from? From? This was handed out at the at the at the treatment I was back. No. No?
No. No. No. This this piece of paper is not do? I’ve never seen it before.
This comes from an idea. I don’t think I’ve seen this before. Yes. So having an inferential realization trainees. But that’s not that’s that’s quite an achievement.
We’re not even on the path yet. Nobody’s talking about this being easy. Have some existence, which means that if that’s the level of having a calm abiding just before he passed on, you know, appeared in a dream, who is one of the great practitioners of yore. So so that means that this is calm abiding, but not insight because that comes to fear. So if that’s the level at which we can guarantee not to fall into it I don’t think there was a guarantee.
Well, not a guarantee. Was an express Where at which point did you know when the fall of the norm is? Yes. Yes. Do Do you you do do you you remember remember me?
Me? Level of forbearance is a. Oh, yes. That’s right. No more rebirths in the lower realms.
Right. The truth? But that’s what Keshe la just said this evening that it was unlikely. Probably. Yeah.
There’s a big difference between probably definitely. Probably, once you reach this point look on once you’ve entered the past, this normally should not happen. Right? So so it could. So in terms of refuge, obviously, fear and faith are the two causes for refuge.
Fear, recognizing that that’s a pretty dire state fair. So in terms of I hope this one has an uncontrollable of difficulty which is sustained through one’s migrating through the lower realms. Well, that’s a problem. Right? That’s a problem.
Yeah. So you would generate a, an an acquired sort of definite emergence. And, obviously, normally after that, you will not commit any heinous non virtues, but you might have committed before non virtues, which are not pure force. But how do you I I I can understand that. How do you run.
For the hell realm, it’s easy. Halram’s impetus, it’s quite straightforward. You could easily see because harem beings and creatives are intelligent. In the animal realm, it’s a problem. Right.
Then you would assume that this would be very philosophical. I know. My cat is here. I’m not saying my cat has any realizations, but you see, it’s within the limitations of the brain of the animal. Yeah.
I mean But so you are you are you are suffering in the the hell world? And that that suffering would basically probably bolster this. So for the hell realms and the preter realms, there’s no problem. Let’s say, even with the generation of bodhichitta in a previous life, in the movies. Because the animals, because of the limitation of the animal’s mind, they’re not substantial.
So it’ll be a true refuge there. He’s he’s requiring getting to that. So what’s the question we’re supposed to be? Yes. Yes.
Okay. Well, we we we can we can understand that a mind of the desire realm is unstable, and so thinking on emptiness without having a sustained focus based on That issue would explain. The second bit refuge, at the very least at the level of a passive seat, since when you take refuge, you take refuge in dharma. Yes. Yes.
And what is dharma if not, you know, completely the truth of level of the of the forbearance in the path of preparation Mhmm. Is a pretty big if that’s if that’s the if that’s the equivalent of going to heaven. Of preparation. This is a part when the realization of intention. Well, all the that means ordinary cortisol.
I think here, that’s that’s where you’re getting pass upsumi, it’s just weird. That’s the that’s like a yogi realizing direct, realizing impotent of the unit. It’s that’s a a yogi You’ll get this to see for a bit. Can’t understand how that was different from Yeah. Within the part of separation.
From here onwards is the path that you could recognize the the reality in Directly. Directly. Another word, realizing emptiness, isn’t it? Yes. Because that’s the preparation for the path of seeing.
That doesn’t mean you can recognize the reality here at this stage. Well, one this is through calm abiding and thinking. And up to up here is at that point, to move from accumulation to preparation, you’ve got single-minded special insight, calm abiding insight focused on emptiness there. Whereas here, you haven’t got the special insight. And that’s that’s a special understanding of emptiness, which obviously comes from thinking first.
Mister, mean, So the thinking — thinking is from here or from here? Thinking is The thinking is there. And then I think it’s still Think think of becomes Observing emptiness doesn’t mean understanding emptiness. I think you go from a conceptual to a meditative insight — to what do you call it? Yeah.
What’s the word it is? I think this I’m not sure, but I think this is, you know, that your mind realizing, oh, there’s a such different reality. That’s the part, you know, your mind, you know, more focusing towards the the different reality. He said it’s like in a dream Mhmm. Where you are aware in a dream that you’re dreaming.
Mhmm. And the the objects of the dream don’t have any inheritance from their own side because how could they if you’re dreaming it? So he was using that as a that’s like and the same thing that we would look around the room just like we’d be looking around if we were having a dream of being in this room. Yeah. We would would be aware that we’re dreaming so we’d be aware Mhmm.
Of the nature of the things that appear to us as not being separate from our own mind and that there’s nothing inherently from the side of the object. Normally we would see these objects as all separate, you know, as permanent, independent. It’s like a gut feeling in this case. You’re not having to conceptualize. Because that’s the yogic direct yogic perception is that right?
Right. This is up here, non conception. But first of all, you’ve got to you’ve got to actually like he said, when you when you have your mother or something like that. Yes.
Of the analysis, you know, just something that we can focus in on without having to, activate it. So you don’t actually have to go through the process process of analyzing from go to work because go to work has become one. And I think isn’t it something like especially in the analogy of a fish swimming in calm water without disturbing the water. So it’s like so there’s no threat to Okay. Hero, sufficient for me.
I said soffit to me. What is that? So say something inside. A cognizer, calm abiding, focused on emptiness,, and arisen through meditation, why does that mind not degenerate? Whereas the same mind which has arisen from thinking does.
And he said he said she gave us the first part, the answer was, you know, through thinking. It’s because of meditation. Think it’s arisen from thinking and what what’s the other one? Meditation. Yeah.
So what’s the special quality about meditation? Quality close to you. Special quality of meditation is after the reason from thinking, isn’t it? Well, you got thinking first. Thinking first.
Well, you got hearing, thinking, contemplation, and meditation. Hearing and the what? Hearing. Hearing hearing, thinking, and meditation. Thinking and the meditation.
Mhmm. Hearing, thinking, meditation. What’s the special quality of meditation? As opposed to thinking. Why is it that the mind Habituation.
Habituation. Habituation. Habituation. But Can you remember the definition of a valid cognizer? Yeah.
That’s what he says. As after yeah. Yeah. We have to understand. So it can arise spontaneously and without distraction.
With calm abiding Sleeping. With calm abiding, I mean, you’ve got all these different stages of calm abiding, meditative equipoise, and then calm abiding. I would have thought that don’t know. But he he can’t lie. He’s trying to be, you know how how do you say?
He’s trying to be modest, humble, humble. I was thinking, if the I can’t if the impression I can’t hold his mind or object for a minute, then what what he does all day. I don’t think that that’s true. I I I personally can’t accept that. It’s one surprise that the I’m reading a book.
Reading a book. You know, billions and times. From virtues. And that’s what he’s he’s I’m going to the last Lam Rim teaching at 5:10.. And he said, if you turn away from the ten ten nine virtues and close the door to the lower realms..
It’s surprising that the Catholics had to invent purgatory then. I almost get that. At the end. Is that the place that still has a chance to go to the heaven? Yes.
Yes. And that’s because they have that idea Maria, which is different from Protestant doesn’t talk doesn’t talk about it. Mother Mary. Mary. Does it Mary?
Much it’s you know, it’s not a catalyst. It’s not really a requirement state to to experience a union with with God for eternity. There has to be a convergence that occurs in order before you can achieve that. There’s a different result if you have a mother or not mother or not have a mother. Stages, you have not reached a sufficient level.
You have not achieved enlightenment. And, really, this is saying that you can only achieve in life before some sort of a bodhisattva point. An over eon survives life after life after life after life, generally speaking, in order to progress up to level of path of no more learning and and the achievement of enlightenment. Life, mean, yes, it can be achieved in one life, nominally, but generally, it’s gonna take you a very long time in progressing after that. So where where is the where is the middle the middle sky in this?
I guess when you realize an arhat,, you realize an instance. Where would that be? That I guess that. Thank you. Yes.
Have a good night, and see you see you later.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- five powers
- The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
- The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.