TBI Recordings – D2am

1 h 52 min · 4,532 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - D2am
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Opens with advice on creating the causes for a precious human rebirth through ethics, generosity and patience, including a one-day daily morality practice. The talk then continues reading from the Secret Life of Je Tsongkhapa, covering his visions and lineage and his realisation of emptiness through Buddhapalita’s commentary. It contrasts the Prasangika view with Sakya interpretations and closes with advice to train in wisdom.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 53m

UUID: 17012115-0982-4c9a-a3aa-6ea785a5df06

Words: 4,528

Morality, we will obtain such a human body. The cause for wealth or a good material situation is the practice of generosity, and this is not a material but a mental practice. If one were to give, for instance, $1 with the mind of Bodhicitta, then one would most definitely in the next life obtain great wealth. So it is not contingent on how much one gives. It’s very much contingent on the motivation.

And the third is a good entourage or a good environment, and this is contingent on a practice of patience, which is a practice which bears all of the difficulties and hardships which are inflicted on us. And then with these three practices, we will obtain precious human rebirth, which is fully endowed. So then how should we practice these three bases for obtaining a precious rebirth? As Rinpoche explained, one has to practice ethics, generosity, and patience. But in addition to these three practices, one must also make strong pure prayers to obtain a precious human rebirth in one’s next life.

Now what is meant here by pure prayers? These are prayers which are totally dedicated to one’s future life. These are prayers which are not contaminated by the wish to be happy in this life. So on top of engaging in these three practices of morality, generosity, and patience, which Buddha has taught other practices for the lay people, then with these strong prayers we will generate the causes for a precious human rebirth. However, the practice of morality is a practice which is very difficult for lay people.

What is meant generally by the practice of morality? It is that practice of abandonment of the 10 non virtues which we all know, the three of the body, killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct, the four of the speech, lying, harsh words, divisive speech, and the gossip, and the three of the mind, covetousness, ill will, and wrong views. For us, it is almost impossible to abandon the three non virtues of the mind, covetousness, ill will, and wrong views. And most of us are not even able to abandon the four non virtues of speech, lying, harsh words, divisive speech, and gossip. But what is left?

What is left are the three known virtues of the body. So we can abandon killing, and we can abandon stealing, that is within our range of capacity. Now with respect to sexual behavior, Buddha Śākyamūni did not forbid lay people from engaging in sexual relations, which literally called in Tibetan filthy behavior. He did not forbid it because it would be very difficult, if not impossible, for lay people to abstain from sexual relations. Instead, Buddha forbade adultery.

He forbade sexual misconduct. Now what is meant here by sexual misconduct, by adultery? Every lay person, every male, normally will have a wife or a girlfriend, and every female will normally have a husband or a boyfriend. What the Buddha forbade was to cheat upon, to betray one’s wife or one’s husband. Now this is something which laypeople can practice, to only have sexual relations within their established relationship.

This is not unrealistic. And then how should we ourselves try to practice? Because we have to accumulate pure morality as a cause for a precious human rebirth. Whereas, Rinpoche explained, in general for us who are laypeople, the practice of pure morality is very difficult. However, what we can do is every morning when we wake up to when we wake up, say, I have a precious human rebirth.

I am very fortunate. And then in dependence on this, try to generate in function of our capacity one of the three motivations. If we have the capacity to think, I will strive for full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. If we don’t have that capacity to think, then I am will practice the path of the being of middling scope. I will generate liberation, renunciation from cyclic existence.

We don’t have that capacity at least to think I will strive for a higher rebirth, and then generate one of these three motivations and take the strong resolution during that day. I will not engage in any of the 10 non virtues of body, speech, and mind for one day. For one day, we can do it. And at the end of the day, then we should check our minds, our speech, and our body. And if we have broken, if we have committed any of the non virtues of body, speech, and mind, confess it.

And if we have not committed any of the non virtues of body, speech, and mind, then rejoice. And in doing this, we will for that one day have accumulated the practice of pure morality. It is even better if we can take the eight precepts, Mahāyāna Sojung, whenever it is given. And then each time we do this, it’s only for one day, we will have accumulated pure morality, and this will act as a cause for a precious human rebirth. So then, Rinpoche, he’d elaborated quite a bit this morning, but we will now return to our text, the, Secret Life of Jetsongkapa, and we are on the following paragraph.

Bodhisattvas, Nāgārjuna, Āryadeva, holy Buddha Palita, magnificent Candrakīrti, and the mighty Yogi Nagabodhi appeared and constantly cared for you, oh illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage. So these are the great Madhyamaka, scholars, Nāgārjuna, Ayadeva, Buddha Palita, in which he was says was an exceptional Mādhyamika scholar, Candrakīrti, and obviously Nagabodhi. So Jetsongkapa had clear visions of them, and they then visited him repeatedly. And then continuing with the following verse. There’s a mistranslation here.

It’s exalted who has attained the third ground, not who delights the three words. So the previous stanza referred to the practitioners of the profound view. The present stanza refers to the practitioners of the method side of the path. So Exalted Asaṇga, who has attained the third ground, and who was mainly a taught a teacher of Paramita. His brother Vasubandhu, a second Buddha who taught mainly, Abhidharma, and Dignāgā, child of Mañjuśrī, who was mainly a scholar of Pramāna, of Buddhist logic, appeared and then constantly cared for you, oh illustrious lama, at your feet.

I pay homage.

And then our following verse reads, Dharmakīrti, among teachers, Dharmakīrti was the foremost scholar in ancient India of Pramāna, of Buddhist logic, as well as Gunaprabha, Shakyaprabha. These were the great scholars, the great pundits of ancient India learned in Vinaya. Śāntideva and the glorious Abhaya appeared and constantly cared for you or illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage. Laos. Continuing, all the Mahasiddas of India and Tibet, such as Indrabhuti and Saraha, it’d be best to stop your stanza there.

So Indra Buddhi was perhaps the great scholar of the Guhya Samaja, and Saraha was one of the very great practitioners of Nālānda monastery. And then we have the practitioners of the lineage of Heruka. Luipa was an extraordinary practitioner practitioner of Heruka, which he says one of the root practitioners of Heruka, and he taught the outer aspect of Heruka’s practice. This should be followed not by Krishnacharini but by Thilbupa. Dhirilbupa was the teacher of the body mandala of Heruka, so he taught the inner aspect of Heruka’s practice.

And Krishnacharini, the black yogi, was the teacher of key aspects of the practice of Heruka. And then Tilopa and Naropa, who are well known, appeared and constantly cared for you or illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage. And then the following stanza recapitulates the presentation of these two groups of teacher teachers. The first from the standpoint of the wisdom side of the path. So starting with the stanzas we’ve covered, Bodhisattva Nāgārjuna, all the way down to I pay homage.

And the second group, from the standpoint of the method aspect of the path, starting with Exalted Asaṇga and reading all the way through Dharmakīrti, Gunaprabha, Shakyaprabha all the way to I pay homage. So these two lineages were the two sūtra lineages and then we have the tantric lineages Jetsongkapa relied upon covered in the stanza All the Mahasidas of India and Tibet. And then as is said in the following stanza, through relying on these, Mañjuśrī predicted or prophesied, will produce colossal spiritual. Great benefit is actually what the Tibetan text says. And then the following stanza, when the samadhi of the yoga combining mental tranquility, in other words, with cognition of emptiness, in other words, Vipassana, increased like the waxing moon.

This is in the first phase of the lunar month when the moon is increasing. Then in other words, as Jetsongkapa’s practice was increasing, you beheld the form of the destroyer, Yamāntaka, opponent of the lord of death, complete with all mudras and expressions. O illustrious lama, at your feet, I pay homage. Actually, it’s complete with all of it’s not all Buddhas and expressions. It’s all the hands and all the faces.

So it’s an exact vision of a Yamāntaka. And then the following stanza, we have to correct the translation as well. Having touched your heart to the wisdom sword of Mañjuśrī’s, actually, it’s Mañjuśrī’s having placed his heart of wisdom, his sword of wisdom on your heart. A stream of undefiled nectar flowed into the depth of your being spontaneously and then here we have to correct the translation, generating that worthwhile samadhi of bliss which arises spontaneously instead of spontaneously arousing the propitious absorption of highest joy. Oh, illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage.

So Hebrewji says here the So, actually, we have to correct your text as well at the beginning because the Tibetan reads, and the precious teacher having touched one’s heart with the sword of wisdom. So precious teacher is not mentioned in your translation. And the precious teacher here, Rinpoche says, is most probably who was the teacher who had these direct visions of Mañjuśrī. Je Tsongkhapa had many teachers because of the context, it’s probably Lama Umapa Pawo Dorje. And as for the worthwhile or the good Samādhi of spontaneously arisen bliss, this actually refers to the samadhi of great bliss, Rinpoche says, which was generated when the sword of Mañjuśrī touched Jetsongkapa’s heart and the nectar flow flowed down the sword into Jetsongkapa’s heart.

And the following stanza reads, prayer for rebirth in the land of bliss, in other words, Sukkavati, and a eulogy of the perfect intent of the dauntless protector Maitreya Buddha, as well as the graduated levels of meaning Mañjuśrī lucidly conveyed to you who recorded and skillfully presented them, O illustrious lama at your feet, pay homage. And, Patrice, generally, the practice, for rebirth in Sukhāvati was an extremely important practice in Tibet because Buddha Amitābha had prophesied to Avalokiteśvara that those who recited 25 times 100,000 manis, which would correspond to 2,500,000 manis, would be reborn in this pure land. And therefore, they engaged in very extensive recitations of millions or sometimes billions actually of these mantras to generate the merit to be reborn in these pure lands. And Maitreya then revealed or actually revealed these two prayers, prayer for rebirth in Sukkavati and the praise of Maitreya to Buddha Śākyamūni. And the relation between Amitābha and Avalokiteśvara is that of a father to a son.

It’s a paternal relation since Avalokiteśvara is seen as an emanation of Amitābha. So Buddha Amitābha has tremendous love and affection for Buddha Avalokiteśvara and entrusted the land of Tibet to Avalokiteśvara and instructed Avalokiteśvara to teach the Tibetans the Mani mantra and that through recitation of the Mani mantra, they could be reborn in Sukhāvati. Sukhāvati in Tibetan is which means the blissful place that with with blissful and dera. And in Sukhāvati, there is only bliss, in which he says. There is no feeling of suffering whatsoever.

For that matter, from within the three divisions of feeling, which is happy, neutral, and suffering or unhappy, in Sukkavati, there is not only no suffering whatsoever, but there are no neutral or indifferent sensations. Or feelings are of the nature of bliss and happiness. So then the following verse also has to be corrected. The first line you have is whenever you consecrated a religious image. It’s actually whenever you consecrated a representation of the body, speech, or mind of the Buddha, the wisdom beings actually entered, in other words, the Buddha’s themselves actually entered into the symbolic beings.

This host of deities that you summon still generates fields of merit within beings. Oh, illustrious lama at your feet and pay homage. A meaning of which he says that whenever Jetsongkapa consecrated these representations of the Buddha, the Buddhism says actually entered the representations of body, speech, of mind, and a function as actual fields of merit for the beings. So what we have to understand by this stanza is that was extraordinarily powerful and that whenever he engaged in activities, they impacted the minds of beings.

But he continues with this magnificent stanza, which refers to the realization of emptiness. One night you dreamed of Nāgārjuna and his five spiritual sons amongst themselves discussing the fabric of dependent origination. From their midst came Buddha Parita who touched you with his scripture. The very next day within within you rose the mind of a high one, an ārya, O illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage. So this refers to, Jetsongkapa’s, direct cognition of emptiness, which he had not manifested before the age of 35 or so in which he believes.

And then, at the age of 35 or so, in the early hours of the morning, around four or 05:00 in the morning, had this extraordinary dream in which he saw in the space in front of him, Ārya Nāgārjuna, the main founder of the wisdom, path with his, heart disciples, his successors, Ayadeva, Buddhapālita, and Chandrakirti, all debating on the view. And while they were debating on the view, Jetsongkapa listened carefully and then from the midst of them, Buddha Palita, who was dark blue in color and with a very large physique approached him and touched his head, his crown repeatedly with the main commentary Buddha Palita had written on Nāgārjuna’s Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, the Mulamadhyamakakarikavrti. He touched Jetsongkapa’s crown repeatedly, and Jetsongkapa upon waking up felt he had received the blessing of the Buddhas to realize emptiness. He had practiced very much in keeping so far with the direct oral instructions he had received from Mañjuśrī with respect to this, which was that to realize the view, one should rely on the teacher in indissociable union with the Yidam, one should accumulate extensive collections of merit, one should purify all faults, and on top of this, one should analyze repeatedly using stainless reasonings the teachings and the scriptures of the great pundits of ancient India.

So after having this dream that Jetsongkapa felt the time had come to read carefully the scripture which had been touched on his crown, Buddha Palita’s commentary, and then he started quietly reading. It’s a commentary on the 26 chapters of Nāgārjuna’s Mūlamadhyamakakārikā. And as he read the chapters one by one carefully, he reflected on the connection with Nagajuna’s root text, is very difficult. And when he reached the eighteenth chapter, he had a direct cognition of emptiness, and at that instant became an ārya being. And this Rinpoche says teaches us really how we should practice.

And then in dependence on this direct recognition of emptiness which he had, Je Tsongkhapa composed the three great treatises on emptiness he has left us. The first was the chapter on emptiness at the end of Lam Rim Cemo, then Drang Nge Legshei Nyingpo, which is a commentary on Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra, Tsashig Tikachen, which is a commentary on Nāgārjuna’s root versus an emptiness, the Madhyamaka Karika, and Legshei Nyingpo, which is a commentary on all of the views of the great vehicle, both Chitamatra and Madhyamaka. Jetsongkapa’s realization was, however, a realization of the Prāsaṇgika view. And, as a result of this, it is said frequently in Tibet that for is the bow of the practitioner, we can say that which details the various views of emptiness is like the arrow. And for this reason, the other traditions in Tibet say you have to be very careful with the because they have the bow and they have the arrow.

So they are very dangerous people.

And I forgot to translate at the end. Said, and this is why says in the first verses of the great pandits of yore have put great effort in understanding the view and yet have not been able to elucidate it clearly. I myself, through the blessing of Mañjuśrī, alluding here to the fact he had direct perception of Mañjuśrī, will explain it. So Jetsongkapa’s explanation of the view was contingent on his direct vision of Mañjuśrī. And then Rinpoche says, Jetsongkapa relied for his understanding of the view on two great lamas, both of whom were great practitioners, Lama Umapa Pawo Dorje and Jetsün Rendawa.

Lama Umapa, as Rinpoche had previously explained, was a kampa, and when he was young, he would wander in the mountains chanting the mantra of Mañjuśrī, which was almost recited spontaneously within his heart. And independence on this, he gained direct vision of Mañjuśrī and a very profound understanding of the prasanghika view. As for Jetsün Rendawa, he was the foremost scholar of the Prāsaṇgika view of his age. And Jetsongkapa relied on both of them to try to obtain direct perception of the Prāsaṇgika view of emptiness. But he, from his own side, felt the strong wish to travel to India to study with the great Mahasiddha Maitripa to try to gain understanding of the view because Marpa Lotsawa himself, several centuries earlier had studied with Maitripa and he had said it was thanks to the kindness of Maitripa, he had gained understanding of the view.

And Jetsungkapa expressed this wish to travel to India to study with Maitripa and both Lama Umapa and the other great teacher of Jetsongkapa who was considered to be a manifestation of Vajrapāni, Choekyab Rinpoche, the Nyingma Lama, both discouraged him from traveling to India saying, if you travel to India to study with Maitrepa, you will indeed become a very great scholar. And for that matter, you will be appointed abbot of the monastery in Bodhgaya proper, but you will be a very little benefit to beings. Therefore, stay on in Tibet. In Tibet, you will be of greater benefit to beings. So says, we have to keep in mind the context of the period.

So Jetsongkapa himself was trained in the Sakya tradition, and all of his, main teachers and most of his disciples who were Geshe’s were also trained in the Sakya tradition. But after Jetsongkapa gained realization of emptiness and started composing his great treatises, the Sakya school fell very much at odds with the teachings that Jetsongkapa was giving on emptiness, as they felt these teachings were not in accordance with the teachings, which were held in the Sakya school. Now as a matter of fact, Rinpoche says, there was a shift in the teachings on emptiness in the Sakya school. And at the beginning, the teachings of emptiness in the Sakya school were concordant with the prasangika view. But later on over time, the teaching of emptiness in the Sakya school became a teaching of the great other emptiness, the great Shentong.

And what is meant here, what is meant or what was meant by the Saka teachers regarding the great other emptiness is that emptiness was a emptiness of other phenomena, such as the emptiness of form, the emptiness of non form, and so on. This was not at all the view which Jetsongkapa taught on the basis of his realizations and his teachings from Mañjuśrī. And very great Sakya scholars such as Gorampa Sonam Sengge and Shakya Chokden, after Jetsongkapa’s passing, counteracted forcefully Jetsongkapa’s teachings on the view in major treaties. These were top Sarkia scholars. And in which he says, it is interesting to note that the author of the Seraje Yigcha’s teachings on emptiness, Umichide Jisungsuki Gilte, debates very, very strongly with the Sakya scholars in his presentation on emptiness and criticizes very powerfully their view.

Be that be this as it may, eventually, the Geluk view did prevail, but once he’s traces of this debate, for instance, in the Yamāntaka Sadhana. As you know, Ralo Lotsawa himself was originally trained in the Sakya school mainly. And if you read the Yamāntaka Sadhana, you have in the passage of the generation or in the passage on taking death on the path, you have one verse bereft from the four views, which is bereft from the view of existence, nonexistence, both, and other. This actually originates in Ralo Lotsawa’s teachings. And Jetsongkapa commented on this passage by saying that there is absolutely no need to say bereft from the four views.

It is perfectly sufficient to say bereft from the two views. The two views being the view of eternalism, in other words, a view of the inherent existence of all phenomena, and the view of nihilism, which is a view of the total nonexistence of phenomena. It’s not necessary to say bereft of all four views. It’s redundant. So which says there were many such debates going on.

So, I forgot to translate, mention that actually the Sakyapa view, which is taught by the likes of Gorampa and Shaka Chomten, is really not a Prasanika view. It’s not a Madhyamaka view for that matter. It’s a Chitamatra view. Now there were many debates in Tibet with respect to the view at the time of Jetsongopa. Rinpoche would like to point out that the early practitioners in Tibet such as Guru Padmasambhava, the founder of the Nyingma tradition or Jetsu Milarepa or for that matter or other of the early great practitioners held a perfectly pure view.

They had a pure prasangika understanding of emptiness. It is after that there were problems regarding the view, and this is one of the reasons Jetsongkapa manifested. As for the method aspect of the path, there is no disagreement at all between the four traditions. And then there were some at the period who held that the final, the definitive view was the Chitamatra view. Many held that the final view was the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka view.

So it was one of the uncommon contributions of Jetsongkapa to have reestablished as the final view the Madhyamaka prasangika view, which is the actual view of Ārya Nāgārjuna. Likewise, with respect to Tantric practice, there was considerable disagreement

In the in Tibet at the period of Jetsongkhapa, there were some who engaged only in practices of the generation stage and thought that the completion stage actually referred to completing the realization of emptiness. There was no actual completion stage. And it is to put an end to this that Jetsongopa relying on the Guhyasamāja tantra composed his Rim Nga Seldrön, the lamp to illuminate the five stages of the path in keeping with the Guhyasamāja tantra. Others actually practiced tantra without practising the generation stage at all. They believed that tantric practise entailed just collecting the coarse winds of the body through various meditative techniques and that this would give rise to realizations.

So Jetsongkapa counteracted these two views in his teachings. And what Jetsongkapa taught was that one should rely on one’s understanding of the great scriptures on the two great founders, those who broached or those who created the path, which are Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, because they’re called forwarders in that they were great teachers who, as it were, created almost freeways, gigantic paths on which others could travel. And it is therefore on and one should rely, and himself has been called also the founder of the land of snow. So what he says, the three other Tibetan traditions, Nyingma, Sakya, and Kagyu, all have Anutara Yoga Tantra. In as much as they have Anutara Yoga Tantra, they have the teachings which enable one to attain full enlightenment in one short life of this degenerate age.

This is undeniable. However, it is specific to the Geluk tradition that there are teachings which enable one to attain full enlightenment not merely in this one life of a degenerate age, but actually in three months and what is said to be three units of time, which would correspond to three times fifteen days perhaps, in other words forty five days, so three years and forty five days. And these uncommon teachings which are only present in the Geluk tradition are the specificity of the Geluk tradition. This is what Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche taught. So Rinpoche says, he’s actually very proud of his tradition And perhaps he is a little bit biased.

So No. Good. His sonnet Dalai Lama says, this is not very good. Rinpoche says he would suggest to you that you check by yourselves. You are intelligent.

You study, and you see through analysis, if what he says is true or not. However, you will need special blessings to gain those realizations. No blessing, no realizations. So says, however, it is said that the wise understand through analyzing. But for analyzing, you do need blessings.

Otherwise, you would not understand anything. Now Himachal himself says when he was younger, he was not very intelligent or very wise, and he trained in that and developed those capacities in this life relying on the advice of his holy master the Dalai Lama, which was to train in wisdom. So he studied extensively in this life. Unfortunately, he didn’t put a lot of effort in his studies, and now he is old and his eyesight has failed, so he feels not terribly useful. But he says to you that you should train in wisdom.

This is the advice of his own Dalai Lama. He himself can speak of experience. He did train in the wisdom side of the path, and he did obtain, results. His holiness has said that training in wisdom is actually what leads us to full enlightenment. As a matter of fact, Rinpoche says, we can say that full enlightenment is merely the perfection of wisdom.

And he remembers his saying, do a one month retreat, reciting mantras, perhaps a mantra of Mañjuśrī, and you will see the result. Has done this, and he has seen the results. So he encourages you to do likewise. Take care. Do a mandala offering, which is on page Oh, yeah.

Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Page five verse six.

First verse. Okay. With this slight change program because today is a talk day, Guru Puja day. We start Rinpoche start 02:30, then 03:00. We start 02:30 on teaching, and discussion maybe move maybe forward.

Yeah. Alright. This is it. After the teaching and the straight after teaching and the Guru Puja. Yeah.

No. 07:00. Yeah. Two teaching start 02:30. That way, I think it will finish 04:30, then start the Guru Puja, and then yeah.

Yeah. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

completion stage dzog rim (Tib)
The second of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which control is gained over the vajra body. LYWA
generation stage kye rim (Tib)
The first of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which one cultivates the clear appearance and divine pride of one’s chosen meditational deity. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
Sukhavati Dewachen (Tib)
The pure realm of the Buddha Amitabha. Literally Land of Bliss, it is located in the western direction. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top