1 h 40 min · 4,116 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 100-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche pursues a rigorous philosophical approach to the Heart Sūtra, using Buddhist logic to understand emptiness. He establishes the four Buddhist schools of tenet and their views on inherent existence, focusing on the Mādhyamika school’s proof that all phenomena lack independent essence because they depend on other factors. The session’s core is an extended explanation of dependent arising—how things exist only by relying on their parts, the mind’s labeling, and conventional designation—illustrated through examples like a hand, a glass, and a newborn child. He shows how this logic refutes the self-grasping that perpetuates cyclic existence, and clarifies that Heart Sūtra’s “no form, no sound” means these lack inherent existence, not that they don’t exist. Pitched at serious practitioners with prior Buddhist philosophical training.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Heart Sūtra 21.11.00.mp3
UUID: 9473c931-6c00-41c8-9a15-16487c9248af
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Heart Sūtra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,142
For that purpose, should first listen to the the essence of teaching of Mahāyāna, the teaching and bring all the parents into contemplation and meditation. And through this I will overcome from disturbing emotions and perfect thoughts and purposes Anyway, I’ll do my best now. Yeah. In the previous class, last week’s class, we have set forth a logic or or logical assigned to prove how the the the phenomenon or the five aggregates and the I which was labeled for the five aggregates are selflessness or are not inherently existent. Here the great masters of Dharma has set forth that there are four schools of tenets in the Buddhist philosophy and the four schools are the Middle Way School, Mādhyamika school.
So among those, the lower schools assert that the phenomena or they assert that there is inherent existence of the phenomena or a person because the reason to prove that is because the I, for example, the I is a dependent arising. Because it is dependent arising, it does exist inherently. And because of that, because they assert that the I or the phenomena are inherent, assert that they are inherently existent, for that, because of that, by stating that they tie the knot of cyclic existence or saṃsāra typing which is called the self-grasping attitude and due to that they circle in cyclic existence or in saṃsāra. Whereas the Mādhyamika school, particularly the Prāsaṇgika or consequentialist school assert there is no inherent existence of the phenomena because all phenomena are interdependent. They prove that because they are interdependent, they don’t exist inherently don’t exist or in their own accord or don’t follow their own characteristics.
So, and because of that, they are served in different ways. So now what it means here is that in the last class we have explained about how the I and which was labeled towards the five aggregates and the aggregates are not inherently existent or free of inherently existent because the logical proof was because they are interdependent. And so this is how whichever whether the both in all the Buddhist schools of tenets, they consider the logic of interdependent or dependent arising is very, very important here. So through the logic of dependent arising, we establish according to the consequentialist school which was set forth to be the utmost schools of the tenets and the dependent arising is the logical proof, logic to prove the R and the aggregate are free of inherent existence. Yeah.
So yeah. And as for the selflessness here, there are two types of selflessness. The selflessness of person and the selflessness of phenomena, which are in terms of selflessness there are numbers of selflessness, but it has they are divided into two main divisions called the selflessness of person and the selflessness of phenomena. So selflessness of person is that the I which was labeled to it, labeled to the five aggregates is the person. And because that I does not exist inherently or are free of inherent existence and and and so the the I the in the free of inherently existence of that I is the is the selflessness of person and the lack of inherent existence of the phenomena of the five aggregates is called the selflessness of phenomena.
So, these are the two main selflessness, and from the beginningless time we are very used to the labeled I which was labeled towards the five aggregates and because of that holding which is called the grasping attitude of the I and thinking that I is important and which exists so and so. And due to this, we cultivate the numbers of attachment, ignorance, and anger because of that I. And due to this, we accumulate numbers of action through attachment, anger, and ignorance, and as a result of those actions or karma, we circle from the cyclic existence and undergoes through numbers of suffering and which also undergoes through numbers of suffering. So through the logic of dependence arising, we can overcome the root of the cyclic existence which is called the grasping attitude of the I or self. And through this logic we can overcome the disturbing emotions and attain, disturbing emotion attachment and so forth and attain the state of liberation of an arhat, enlightenment, Buddhist practice and so forth.
And also through the logic of interdependence we realize, we develop or we realize the selflessness of both the phenomena and the person. So and now in yeah. We have we have been explaining about how the Bodhisattva with the lower faculty trained in the five paths of Mahāyāna. Bodhisattva with the lower faculty during path of accumulation, they developed an understanding of emptiness through hearing the teaching on emptiness. After and through and yeah.
By listening to the teaching of emptiness and through this, they derive or they cultivate the wisdom through hearing or wisdom of hearing. And after this, then they cultivate the wisdom derived from contemplation. And that wisdom is being gained through training or through the understanding of the emptiness or teaching of emptiness through analyzing or through reason, which means by training through the logic or logic or through Pramāna studies and establishing how things are empty or emptiness through logical The the natural emptiness or emptiness itself, exists from the beginningless, from the beginning or from the beginningless, you know, from the beginningless of the time. But but it is because it is very subtle, we are not able or we don’t understand or we are not able to realize that emptiness emptiness. It is because because we are being obscured by by by the delusions or disturbing emotions.
To understand or realize or to realize or understand emptiness by the ordinary being, how one should realize emptiness is one should train realize the emptiness through the logical approach or through analyzing on the subject or through the logical proofs from the statements of logical approach. And whenever whenever one be able to refute the object of negation, and then that is the time or whenever one realizes or refutes the object of negation, one understands or one realize. So how to refute the object of negation through training in the logics is that for example, like the I which we have set forth in the earlier classes which we are labeled to the five aggregates and it does terms of nominal, the I which exists, but because of our ignorance we exaggerate way, the mode of existence of the nominal I in opposite or in mistaken way and due to this we hold that grasping attitude of art or self grasping attitude and as a result, that self grasping attitude undergoes or develops the attachment so forth, and we suffer. So and we exaggerate or overestimate that the the eye, the existence of the eye to which as we said here that the I which labels towards the five aggregates does exist in terms of nominal or nominally it does exist but depending on the five aggregates.
But we exaggerate on that I thinking or perceive that I which exists by its own without depending on others or thought aggregates, And that is the mind which apprehends the existence of the eye without depending on five aggregates is the mistaken one and it’s called the mistaken one. And the I which exists without depending on five aggregates is the one which is called the object of negation and where which is which which we need to refute. So and so which is the which is the object of negation that the the the the the the existing of the arm without depending on the part aggregate is the object of negation. And so so we have to refute that object of negation through logic by saying that I does not exist inherently because it is interdependent, because it is interdependent on others or it’s interdependent if their eye comes by depending on the five aggregates. For example, by depending on the sound of the eye and the mind which labels that eye towards the five aggregates, the eye is produced without depending on those, the I does not exist by its own.
Therefore, because it is arising or the R does not exist inherently, and through this logical approach, whenever one realizes that R does not exist inherently because it is interdependent, and when everyone has the proper understanding of this logic one realizes itself, the inherent existence of the arm. Important because through the basis of the dependent arising, we set forth the entire validity of cause and effect, actions, liberation, previous and the later or rebirth, so forth. And because of that, because of, because everything is interdependent, the low cost effect, everything come. If there is not the logic or there is not interdependent, then the law of cause and effect as well as interactions of previous and later life do not exist as well. And as for the the teaching of dependent arising arising or dependent relationship is set forth to be in It has been set forth in three.
What are the interdependent relation or dependent arising set forth like subtle, gross, subtle and very subtle it is because example like here the Tibetan word here which means meet and is dependent and So the is mean is rely and which means the base. Right? So and some people say that that these three are a thing. For example, like flower and the metok. The metok is a flower in Tibetan language and some people say it is the same.
But if one really analyze within it, are slight differences in those words. So they as we said, they are the four schools of tenets in the Buddhist philosophy or Buddhist in the Buddhist yeah. In Buddhism. The the the particularly two sūtra schools, mind only schools in the Cittamātra and the middle way, the Mādhyamika school. So the first three classes assert or interpret or the definition of interdependent is the first one which we said in Tibetan words as we said just before ten drel.
Interpret the dependent arising as the first one which is called meeting one because how the asserted dependent relation or dependent arising is because all these results or effects, the phenomena are produced by meeting or the gathering of causes conditions because they are the product of meeting mixture by meeting the causes and conditions, Therefore, the dependent arising is the meaning of meeting. This is what the previous class says. Now explain about the way of interdependence. It is because the the the first term, as for phenomena, there are two types of phenomena to call the compounded phenomena and the uncompounded phenomena too. So the first three classes establishes the interdependent only for the compounded phenomena, not for the, they can’t apply the logic of interdependent for the uncompounded phenomena.
So because of that reason, they set forth that the meaning of interdependent is just mere the meeting of cost and condition and Because of the meeting of cause and condition, the result of the product has been produced. And this is the definition of dependent arising. But the dependent arising of the compound phenomena is being support the the cause, the dependent arising accounts. And for the middle way school, Within the Middle Way school there are two classes of the school which are called Autonomy and the Consequence School. The autonomy school of middle way is slightly lower, the consequentialist is set forth to be the utmost school.
And so the meaning of the dependent arising by the autonomy school is the second one which we call the depend or rely, the second meaning which we set forth. That they assert that the meaning of interdependence is because the things exist by depending on the part or other particle or a part. Therefore their way of asserting, proving the dependent arising becomes a bit subtle, more subtle than the previous classes, the first three classes, the dependent arising or giving the meaning of dependent arising by saying that phenomena exist by depending on the parts and the particles and which they captured their interdependent, captured the entire phenomena, both the compounded and the and the uncompounded phenomena. And so what it means by saying the phenomena exists by depending the particle or particle which means that for example on this bell, body of the bell, saying that it exists it exists depending on its part, but saying that because that bell has the direction of the eastern part, say east, west, north and south, and then or we’re saying it has the bottom part and the upper part, and by, yeah, so because of all that part, having all this, by possessing all the parts of parts that bell exists.
If it hasn’t got apart it does not exist. So they logically approach it. They are not inherently existent because they are the product by depending on the parts and which logical proof becomes more subtle than the previous one. So their meaning of interdependent arising is that by depending on the parts and like this finger. And because of the finger have the the four parts like east west north and the finger has been produced.
If there is no east part of the finger, the finger does not exist. The finger does exist by depending on its own by its part and the by the gathering of the part, it exists. Without those, the finger does not. The meaning of dependent arising according to the utmost class, consequentialist school of middle way, the Mādhyamika school. So the meaning of dependent arising is the last one of the previous which we said means the base.
Base which I said. And their way of establishing this the the the the dependent arising is very very subtle. Is because they said that how they describe the meaning of dependent arising instead, for example, aggregates and the eye which was labeled or based on the five aggregates. In order to produce that I it needs to rely or depend on others. For example, first it has to depend on an eye which perceives which helps one to impute the name I towards the five aggregates, and that the conception or thought which grabs that five aggregates of the I.
So by gathering, by yeah, by depending on the the conception or a thought and the the word or a sound of the ah which was of those two and which labeled the I towards the five aggregates and through this the existence or the person, the I has been produced. So without, which means the main source or the I which was based on the conception or thought and the sound of the I which is heard by the ear, through this the I is being produced without depending on those the I does not exist which was labeled on the basis. So it’s, for example, like a hand or a palm. For example like from the very beginning somebody labeled a palm or a hand and which a person labeled the name, the sound hand with the palm or the hand. Then the conception arises afterwards, grasps, but oh, this is the hand.
And by depending on those sound of the hand and the the grasping of the the mind which grasps the hand, the hand has been produced. And how how they produce the hand was the sound hand. That sound was produced by depending on the part, entire part of the hand and by by by, yeah, depending on both fingers and so forth. And and by depending on all by by depending on the basis, the name the hand has been produced. And if there is no hand in the the parts of the hands like say the fingers and so forth and in Tibetan word which means that the person hasn’t got a hand because the basis of labeling is not present there.
By depends, so the person has, we call the person or the hand that exists within the person because the basis of labeling exists within the person. So which proves that everything exists by depending on the basis of imputation? So example, if one wants to cultivate or cultivate the emptiness of hand and how one wants to cultivate the emptiness of the hand is for example, the hand, the existence of the hand without depending on its part is the object of negation which means the which is called the inherent existence. So in order to prove the hand is not inherently existent or it’s the empty of inherent existence you can put the logical proof through this way by saying that the hand is empty of inherent existence because it is dependent arising, it depends on its part, the sound, the thought which labels the hand towards the hand, and the hand without depending on all those conditions like thought, sound and so forth, the hand do not produce, hand is not produced by itself. Because it depends on all this, the thoughts, name, sound of the hand and so forth, the hand has been produced.
Therefore, it is not inherently existent. It is empty of inherent existence. What is the example of hand is because So see how the hand appears in one’s mind. When you look at your hand and we never thought or one never thinks that the eye, the hand is produced by depending on the part of the hand or depending on the fingers and so forth and how it appears to us. Normally, we always perceive the mind sees or the hand appears in our mind the, you know, that the hand exists by its own without depending on others, that is called grasping.
So always appears to us the hand exists by its own side or without depending on other. And we perceive that or hold that the existence of the hand without depending on other and that is called the true grasping attitude, which is ignorant and which leads us to circle in the cyclic existence. For example, like I, how I appears within ourselves, within our mind. The I always appears to us that I exist by its own or without depending on other and we grasp that I exist by its own characteristic. And through this we, and that is called the grasping of our inherent existence of the I is called the self grasping attitude, called the ignorance.
And that self grasping, ignorance of self grasping attitude obscures us from seeing emptiness and that leads us to circle in the cyclic existence. Likewise everything is same like the glass or table or I think we call all examples. The glass table and we all these things appears in us, but it appears to us that those things exist by its own without depending on other. For example like a table, that the table has been labeled by seeing the part of the table, the surface, the length of the table so forth and by having all this, the part of the table, the table has been labeled to that object and through this the table, the name table has been produced without depending on its part the table does not exist. So likewise for example, like a little baby myself and, from the very beginning that I was born as a baby and at that time everyone says that a child or a baby is being born and if the baby exists inherently then for me I have been a baby and been a monk etcetera and become Geshe, ex-abbot and a teacher in Adelaide at Buddha House and so forth.
And if the baby exists existing inherently or without depending on other then that baby should be called by Khensur Rinpoche born rather than instead of saying the baby or child is born. And so all these things, the baby, the I, or everything depends on the basis of labeling the five aggregates. Without depending on those it does not exist. Like Pamela, at the time she was born. At the time nobody says Pamela is born.
It says a baby was born and later on a couple of grandmas get together and say, oh, let’s call this Pamela. And everyone’s whole Pamela is there. And then it comes, this is Pamela. The name Pamela was labeled and everyone grasped that Pamela exists by its own or without depending on other. In fact it does depend on the aggregates.
Yeah, the non existence of all without depending on other, No, no, so existence of the I without depending on other is called the object of negation and whenever one so which means the inherent existence of the I is object of negation which is the one we need to abandon or refuse through the logical proof of applying the dependent arising, saying that I does not exist inherently because it is dependent arising and also in the Heart Sūtra text that once you see all the once you see all the five aggregates, aggregates are also empty of inherent existence, so which means that they do not exist inherently and they are empty of inherent existence. So the inherent existence of the five aggregates is the object of negation and whenever one refuted that object of negation, the inherent existence of the eye, then one realized the empty of inherent existence of the five aggregates which is the emptiness one realized. No. So in Heart Sūtra text, there’s no form, no sound, no smell, no taste, and no tactile sensation or texture. It doesn’t mean there is no form, there is no sound.
Of course, there is sound, there is form, and there is smell and taste, beautiful cakes, sweet and sour, so forth. But what it means is that the inherent existence of the form is not there and inherent existence of sound and so forth is not there. It does not mean they are not there. And during saying that the object of negation, the inherent existence of form is the object of negation, and and so that do not exist because there is emptiness. If the object of negation exists, then there is no emptiness.
So this is how it works. Because there is emptiness, there is no inherent existence of the the form because it is the object of negation. So from and also that from the beginning during the brief explanation of the emptiness, earlier part of the Heart Sūtra the text says that text clearly says that one should see all five aggregates are also empty of inherent existence and that was during the brief explanation. So at that statement it said that one should see all five phenomena are also empty of inherent existence and during the detailed explanation the text set forth no form, no sound, no smell because the inherent empty of inherent existence has been explained in the earlier part of the text. One should apply those empty of inherent existence on the later part.
When it says no form which means that the form is empty of inherent existence or form is not inherently existence. So here the meaning of the existence which means for example like a form, the existence of the form. So what it means is the form is there, for example the form is there, but it exists or it stays there by depending on the part of the form and without depending on other then the form do not exist wherever it is. So this is how it’s called the by depending on others that things do exist or things do stay for example. Without depending on other So here, and also in other ways, the meaning of existence is also example like a glass, the existence of the glass on the table.
And at this stage there is glass which does exist on the table right now, but the name the glass which is on the table has been labeled from one’s mind, we should call that object as a glass. Because we label the glass to that object and at this stage the the name glass and the object is on the table. If the glass exists by its own or without depending on others, then glass should always remain on the table without depending on the labeling of the mind. The glass should be always there without projecting that there is a glass or the named glass from the mind.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- selflessness of person gang zag gi dag me (Tib)
- According to the Prasangika Madhyamaka school, the most subtle view of selflessness of person is the lack of inherent existence of the person or self. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.