1 h 32 min · 4,070 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This session continues a Lam Rim teaching on the path of the being of the great scope and on generating bodhicitta from love and compassion. It contrasts the sevenfold causal instruction with the equalization and exchange of self and others, and explains the faults of self cherishing and the qualities of cherishing others. The talk also argues for past and future lives through the subtle mind, and ends with questions from students.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 32m
UUID: e41d5737-9bac-48d7-8918-acad728c2d49
Words: 4,066
So in brief, the practice of the being of the small scope, which includes the seven topics of meditation within which we do not need to enter in detail at present, can be summarized as engaging in the practice of the 10 virtues and abstaining from the practice of the 10 non virtues. So one must eventually pass from the path of the being of the small scope to the path shared with the being of the middling scope. And here when we refer we refer to passing, we refer to realizations which are generated within the mind stream. Now in our case, this is basically a verbal understanding. But what is important is to try to understand in reality which what such a transition involves.
So the main realization of the path of the small scope is turning away from the vanities of this life. Now at which point does a transition from the path shared with the being of the small scope to that shared with the being of the middling scope occur? And, what are the criteria for such a transition? In our own case, all of us without exception wish for happiness. It is a general characteristic.
However, there are two types of happiness, physical and mental happiness. And, being unaware of the difference, we focus overwhelmingly on physical happiness, which cannot lead us to happiness alone. Mhmm. There is also mental happiness, and this is what we should focus upon. So this understanding that there are both physical and mental forms of happiness is extremely beneficial to us.
So when, we turn away from this course physical happiness, which arises in dependence on the five exterior sense objects. And I am not saying here that we do not need to depend on the five exterior sense objects, but we cannot depend on them totally. So when we turn away from this coarse physical happiness, probably we have gained the attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope. At this point, we ask ourselves where precisely is happiness, and it’s a question we have not asked until now. It is within the mind.
And what prevents us from experiencing profound inner happiness? If we analyze, it is the afflictions. In other words, the three poisons, desire, hatred, and ignorance, and the various other afflictions. Once one focuses on the elimination of these afflictions, are the obstacle to attaining inner happiness, probably one has entered the path shared with the being of the middling scope. In other words, one has generated definite emergence, which is nothing else but in mind turning away from cyclic existence or if you prefer, the noble truth of suffering.
So this is the transition from the path shared with the being of the small scope to that shared with the being of the middling scope. And once one has entered the path shared with the being of the middling scope, there are, in brief, two main topics or objects of observation, psychic existence on the one hand, or if you prefer, the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of cessation. And if these are developed further, we obtain the four noble truths. If they are developed even further, we obtain the 12 limbs of dependent origination in the forward and in the reverse sequence. So you understand, therefore, that there are numerous objects of observation topics within the path shared with the being of the middling scope, both extensive and briefer topics, and you should keep them within your mind.
So within the topics of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, we have the four noble truths. Now at present, one must pass from the path shared with the being of the middling scope to the path of the being of the great scope. How does one proceed? Here, I would like to give a contemporary example to enable us to understand the importance of these preliminary studies. Let us imagine one is flying to India from Australia, and one has to stop over in Singapore.
If one has, never, undertaken such a trip before, then when one arrives at Changi Airport, it’s quite confusing. One isn’t quite sure where to go to catch the corresponding flight to India. It’s rather stressful. On the other hand, someone who has done this frequently just breezes through, Changi Airport and heads on to India. It is the same thing, as far as the preliminary study of the topics of Lam Rim are concerned.
If one has studied these topics carefully before, when one engages in meditation, it’s a very simple and straightforward process. So, therefore, first, we must identify clearly how the transition from the path shared with the being of the middling scope to the path of the being of the great scope occurs. What is the criterion for that transition? And after this, since the specific topic of our study is the path of the being of the great scope, what are the objects of observation or the topics of the path of the being of the great scope? Now, the foremost topic of the path of the being of the great scope is the means to generate Bodhicitta in dependence on love and great compassion.
And for this, there are two main procedures. The first is the sevenfold causal instruction, and the second is the instruction of the equalization and the interchange of self and others. We have focused on the instruction of the equalization of the interchange of self and others, which is subdivided into five. The first is, the equalization of self and others, then reflecting on the force of self cherishing, reflecting on the qualities of cherishing others, the actual interchange of self and others, and engaging in or giving and taking, in dependence on that. So time we have, we should be able to dedicate one hour or perhaps half an hour a day to covering these topics and, thinking to ourselves, yes, how strange it all is.
This would be of great benefit to us. Therefore, one should reflect on these topics for half an hour or an hour in a state of physical and mental ease. Initially, one should be physically at ease and comfortable since if one is physically uncomfortable, it affects one’s mental peace. And in addition to this, one should keep one’s mind at ease. Because if the mind is troubled, then whatever topic one focuses upon, one focuses upon with a troubled mind.
Yes. Then the best time for this is, early in the morning simply because not only is one’s mind clear and is one relaxed, but in addition, there is no one about. There is no one to ask us to do things for them, to talk to us, and therefore, we can concentrate quietly on these topics. In the afternoon and in the evening, it is very different. There are people around this conversation.
It is difficult to to do this. And this is my way of thinking. If it is of help to you, so much the better. If it isn’t, just drop it. So the question of the criteria for having passed from the path shared with the being of the middling scope to that of the being of the great scope is not an easy one.
However, if we analyze a bit the path of the being of the great scope, we can see that within the two aspects of the path, the method and the wisdom aspect of the path, and I assume most of you are familiar with this distinction. The path of the being of the great scope is mainly focused on the method aspect of the path, not on the wisdom aspect of the path. Now why is this the case? Why? It’s because In short.
No. Not not a lot of words briefly. Okay. Been covered in the noble truth of the path. Noble truth of the path..
So the answer is very simple. The main focus of the path of the being of the great scope is the method aspect of the path because its main focus is the welfare of others, of other sentient beings. This being the case, how does one proceed or how is the transition from the path of the middling to that of the great scope effected? This being the case, how is the transition from the path shared with the being of the middling scope to that of the great scope effected? How does it occur?
Pretty similar. Yes. Let’s put it simply. The attainment of the path of the being of the small scope is countering the velocities of this life. The attainment of the path of the being of the middle scope is countering the vanities of all lives.
What is the attainment of the path of the being of the great scope? So when one has entered the path shared with the being of the middling scope, one has generated uncontrived definite emergence. Or if you prefer, one has turned away from the vanities of all lives. To do this, one must see the faults of the vanities of all lives or of psychic existence. Now at the level of the path of the being of the great scope, what corresponds to this?
Same false self cherishing. That’s it. That is what is So once one has understood the faults of self cherishing, then cherishing others, in other words, generating empathy for others arises. Self cherishing and cherishing others are opposite. And, therefore, the realization of the path of the being of the great scope is to counter self cherishing and to give rise to cherishing others.
Now in our own case, this is extremely difficult to do. Our self cherishing is extremely weighty. It is omnipresent. But eventually, over time, it is possible to counter it. And once we have countered it and given rise to cherishing others, in other words, altruism, then in dependence on that indeed, one can give rise to great compassion.
Just to answer to this question, what the realization of the path of the being of the great scope is, by answering great compassion is too brief, we need the stages leading up to it. Do you understand? So what are the thoughts one contemplates when one is training in the past shared with the being of the middling scope? The thoughts of psychic existence. And through this, one is able to turn away from the vanities of all lives.
What are the faults one contemplates when one trains in the path of the being of the great scope? The faults of self cherishing or egoism. And in doing this, one is able to generate altruism. So this is clearly explained in the Lam Rim, and I would encourage you to study it. Explains that there are two means to generate this.
The first is to recollect the kindness of others. The second is to recollect how they have benefited us. If we recollect their kindness, then we are generating bodhicitta by means of the sevenfold cause and effect instruction. If we recollect how they have benefited us, we are generating it through the equalization and the interchange of self with others. So there are two modes of generation of.
The first is the sevenfold causal instruction. The second is the equalization and the interchange of self and others. And here, one must study in detail because if these two modes of generation of bodhicitta are equivalent, then doubts can arise. For instance, is there such a thing as countering, self cherishing, and generating altruism within the sevenfold causal process of generation of bodhicitta? It is not explicitly mentioned.
On the other hand, if it were completely absent, it would be inappropriate. If it were present, these two instructions would be identical. So I have a short question for you. There is a difference in the enumeration of the sevenfold causal instruction and the five points of the equalization interchange of self and others. So in brief, my question is, what is the difference apart from enumeration between these two modes of generation of bodhicitta?
Do you understand? Do you know a sevenfold causal process of generation of bodhicitta? What is it? Bodhicitta is not part of the sevenfold causal instruction. It’s a result.
Who can give me the exact list? Chris, can
That’s it. So the great intent is the last of the sevenfold causing instruction and is the result. So this is quite a beneficial way to do things because in the context of Pāramitāyāna, we tend to focus on the sevenfold causal process of generation of bodhicitta. And we do not cover that much the equalization and the interchange of self and others, which is mainly presented in lojong. This is lo jong training.
This is a case because the sevenfold causal process was transmitted directly from Atisha downwards. So what’s the difference between these two? Why? Why? Why?
Why? Why I get to repeat everything. Why does the sevenfold cause and effect instruction not contain the totality of the equalization and interchange of self and others, whereas the equalization interchange of self and others contains the totality of the sevenfold cause and instruction? Why? All I’m asking you is, are there differences or not?
If there are, show them. If there aren’t, Emma? What do you mean by explicitly implicit? Self a thought of cherishing others and humming one’s own self cherishing. You’re explicitly doing that in the meditation, like, thinking about the faults of self cherishing.
So for ourselves, the mode of generation of bodhicitta by means of the sevenfold causal instruction is more difficult because it presupposes an understanding of past and future lives. So I’d like to ask you to check within your own minds if I explain the rationale for the existence of past and future lives, is it or not of benefit to you? Yes. If it is, listen carefully. Do you understand?
Everyone’s gonna sleep tonight. Right? That after falling asleep tonight, when we wake up tomorrow, will we understand, for how long we slept or not? Now will you actually know precisely what time you fell asleep at or not? No.
They can talk to me about it. No one can because at that point, the sense consciousness has ceased to operate. It’s the same thing with death. And therefore, every single one of us can answer the question, when did you go to bed? But no one can answer the question, at what time precisely did you fall asleep.
So at that point, all our sensory consciousnesses cease. And, obviously, all our conceptual consciousnesses cease. Otherwise, we wouldn’t be falling asleep. But the next morning when we wake up, do we remember what we did the previous day or not? You remember, don’t So at the time of death and there is not a single one of us in this room who will not die, all of the coarse consciousnesses cease.
And the only consciousness which passes into the future life is the most subtle mind. Now the reason for which in our next life we cannot remember the events of our previous life is simply because of the subtlety of this mind which passes from life to life. It’s not the case, with waking up from sleep the next day, but we can remember what we did the previous day precisely because there is a continuum of coarse mind. So the reason for which, upon waking up the next day, we can remember what, we did one or two days before is simply because there is a continuum of coarse minds which has passed from, the previous day to the present one. The reason for which we are unable upon being reborn in a future life of recollecting what happened in the previous life is because it is a continuum of subtle mind which has passed from life to life.
And therefore, the mental consciousness is uninterrupted from life to life. A stream of subtle mind passes from life to life. Such a stream, however, does not bear memories. In the case of waking up after sleep, it is a stream of coarser minds which has passed from the previous day to the present one, and such a stream of coarse minds can bear memories. Once we become able to use these subtle minds, then we will be able to recollect previous lives.
These are as it may, once one meditates on the equalization and the interchange of self and others, one focuses, the second point, on reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the faults of self cherishing or egoism. And having done this, one is able to give rise naturally, to an impartial empathy for others or altruism. Now when we train in the equalization and the interchange of self and others, we reflect on the benefit others have imparted to us. And I’d like to give you a very simple example. All of you are reading and taking notes.
Do you really believe you would be able to read or to write if someone hadn’t taught you? Not one of you could. Therefore, all of this we owe to the kindness of others. It is our egoism, our self cherishing, which makes us say, I did it all by myself. Then, obviously, this is not the case.
If we can read, if we can write, if we can attend teachings, it is due to a large collection of causes and conditions.
Likewise, qualities are most important. Qualities remain with us until the time out, we die. Then let us take some major qualities such as honesty, not stealing from others. Do you really believe that you would be naturally and spontaneously honest if no one had ever taught you to be honest? Let us therefore meditate during a couple of minutes.
First, on the thoughts of self cherishing, which leads us to believe that, whatever qualities we might have, we achieved somehow without the help of anybody instead of depending on the help of numerous other beings. And in dependence on this, let us reflect on the qualities of altruism or cherishing others. Please open the paper page one we recite one b two three four page five, another six manual three. First one, industry. So from the standpoint of Buddhist scriptures, we have beginningless previous lives.
And these beginningless previous lives definitely exist, yet we are completely unable to remember what they are. We are, for instance, in our present life, unable to say whether in our previous life we were a human being, an animal, a god, a demigod, or whatever. However, this in no way puts in question the existence of these previous lives. Now I am not saying here that one must believe in the existence of past and future lives. I am, however, strongly suggesting that you analyze and investigate the issue.
It is similar to the situation when one wakes up from deep sleep. None of us at the time of waking is able to say with certainty precisely at which time we fell asleep, simply because at that point all sensory consciousnesses and conceptual activity ceases, yet we definitely fell asleep. So today, we’re Wednesday. Yesterday was Tuesday. You all remember clearly what you did west yesterday, I hope.
So what lies in the interval between yesterday and today? Sleep. Now whether or not there is, cerebral activity during sleep, during deep sleep, I will set aside. But clearly, today, when we wake up, we can remember what we did yesterday. Yet, we are completely unable to remember what we did or who we were in our previous life.
Why? There’s food for thought there. Kind of why? The body the the the life okay. Swine down.
The body mind of this life has to get on with self cherishing and looking after itself. And if you remember the previous lives, it interferes with your ability to actually do that. That’s what I think. The the mind that passes from this life to the next life is extremely subtle, so it’s very difficult to have any sort of awareness. Awareness.
Mean memory? Mhmm. My view is that I think we’d go mad if we remembered everything from past lives. In fact, there are people who remember every detail of their current life, and they have real mental problems. I don’t think we would be able to cope mentally if we could remember past lives.
Another. Simple. Okay. That’s it. I have a doubt.
A, some people do remember previous lives, and from what we understand, they remember them because they’re pretty traumatic. B, some people like lamas and stuff show clear signs of remembering previous lives that were not traumatic but were the results of being practitioners in the dharma. So some people remember previous lives, both traumatic and not traumatic. So that’s all I wanna say.
This. There are people who remember their past lives, but it is probably not our case. So what I would like to know is why we don’t remember our past lives, whereas when we woke up this morning, Wednesday morning, we, I hope, had a clear memory of what we did on Tuesday and on Monday. Monk. From what I understand, it’s because of the coarseness of our minds now.
Did you what? From what I understand, it’s the coarseness of our minds now that, no longer exist at the time after death. So those memories that we the memories we can hold now, we can hold because of the coarse mind, but then once we die, that mind dissolves or, it no longer exists. So those memories, we can’t retain memories anymore. So that’s okay.
And I’ll at present take only one question from one person. Make it short, and then we will stop. Ishla, what are the faults of self cherishing? So there are numerous faults of self cherishing, starting with the faults of self cherishing of ordinary beings like us who are unable to give up the affairs of this life and moving upwards to the faults of the self-cherishing of hearers and solitary realizers who are unable to give up striving for the bliss of liberation for their own sake alone. What?
Have you caused him? Another question? Maybe. Okay. How would Geshe la explain the memories of past lives of children who have not who have no attainments at all?
Yeah. That obviously, let’s set aside the issue whether the child itself has attainments or not. There’s two possible causes that in the previous life, the being in the previous life had attainments. Another possibility is that these memories arose from very powerful and very stable karmic imprints implanted in the mind in previous lives. And these, when they are carried over into this life, definitely give rise to memories.
Then whether these karmic imprints exist in the brain or not, I would not pronounce myself. So when I’m speaking of karmic imprints, I’m speaking of stable memories. So it may also be linked to the fact that the child has been reborn very rapidly in this world of ours, and therefore, there’s not a great interval of time with, the previous life. Then I mentioned was going to mention to Geshe la, he asked me to tell you that Stevenson’s research on children who have clear memories of previous lives show that in seventy percent of the cases, of the eight hundred verified cases Stevenson has studied, the child died a violent death. Now this violent death from a Buddhist standpoint means that the dissolution either did not occur or occurred in a very, very compact way, and I suspect this is what enables the memories to be carried over to the next life.
Okay. Stop here. Thank you. Thank you. Over the preview page nine, we recite one eight eight b nine ten eleven twelve. Hello.
Okay. There’s a few things coming. Day to day practice. If you look at the fly that’s up and also TBR two thousand sixteen symposium, empathy and altruism, Buddhism and the biology. You know?
It will be fantastic, you know, that you please make sure registered, and
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.