TBI Recordings

1 h 53 min · 4,334 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this nearly two-hour talk, Kyabje Rinpoche teaches the Four Attachments, a classical Tibetan framework distinguishing authentic Dharma practice from worldly religious activity. Drawing on Pabongka Rinpoche’s commentary, he explains how attachment to this life, samsaric existence, self and other, and philosophical views blocks genuine development. The core message, illustrated through multiple historical accounts, is that mental renunciation of this life—not physical withdrawal or ritual performance—marks the boundary between real practice and self-deception. He repeatedly presents cautionary tales of retreat practitioners who abandoned food and clothing yet remained internally obsessed with gaining a good reputation. The eight worldly dharmas collapse into three preoccupations: nourishment, dress, and reputation, with reputation-seeking emphasized as the most insidious obstacle. Intended for serious practitioners with some background in Buddhist practice.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Rinpoche 01-700101_1018.mp3

UUID: 65d74d20-fc19-4989-a281-cdd2c687300f

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Public Talks

Date: 1970-01-01

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,334

So we will meditate for one or two minutes on generating the motivation to listen to this very essence of the Mahāyāna, which is the presentation of the three principles of the path. Generally speaking, to listen and for Dharma teachings to be explained, a worthy motivation is necessary and this worthy motivation arises from the realization that we ourselves are one, all sentient beings are infinite in numbers, moreover we are not unrelated, instead we and all sentient beings are extremely closely related since they have all been our parents in past lives. With this as a motivation, as an understanding, we engage in the practice of Dharma, which is a practice of dispelling the negative factors of the mind and generating positive factors. Wishing to help beings, we in turn give rise to a state of mind which wishes to attain a state of perfection and place them in that state of perfection. So, on page four of the translation of Pabongka Rinpoche’s commentary is an explanation of parting from the Four Attachments, which was imparted by Mañjuśrī.

Mañjuśrī said, If you are attached to this life you are not a dharma practitioner. If you are attached to samsaric existence you have no definite emergence, no renunciation. If you are attached to self and other you have no bodhicitta. If you are attached to the view you do not have an understanding of the view. The meaning of these four verses is as follows.

The term attached, and if you are attached refers to desire. Attachment to this life is an attachment to the body, the garb and the wherewithal of this life. In that case one is not a dharma practitioner, because a dharma practitioner is by definition someone who focuses at least on the well-being of future lives. The second the four, parting from the four attachments, if you’re attached to cyclic existence you have no definite emergence. Here, cyclic existence and being attached to cyclic existence refers to finding samsaric existence comfortable and pleasant, while samsaric existence itself is an ocean of suffering in which we dwell under the power of karma and affliction.

If one is attached to this, one has no definite emergence. This in turn means that one is unable to understand that samsaric existence has no essence and one is unable to give rise to the wish for liberation. Without definite emergence, it is impossible to obtain either liberation or omniscience. Moving onwards in the commentary, the question which is addressed at present is what the distinction is between dharma and non dharma, and between pure dharma and impure dharma. Now dharma, Rinpoche explained last time, in a nutshell, is the means to eliminate suffering and the cause of suffering and to attain all happiness.

This is dharma. And here the cause of suffering refers to the afflictions which give rise to suffering. So dharma is that which leads to the attainment of all happiness. This was last time an introduction or an initiation into dharma. At present, in our text we read the boundary on page four between dharma and non dharma and between faultless or pure dharma and faulty dharma is whether the mind discards this life or not.

What is being said here is that the mind which discards this life is a mind of pure dharma, the mind which does not discard this life is a mind of impure or faulty dharma. And, in turn, what is the difference between dharma and mundane activities? Dharma is exclusively the relinquishment of this life and the body of this life. Mundane activities, on the other hand, crave for this life, put effort in this life and take this life on board. Therefore, there is no middle ground between Dharma and mundane activities, between Dharma and this life.

They are exclusively contradictory. There is no inseparable practice of Dharma and of mundane affairs, because Dharma is the relinquishment of this life and mundane affairs, on the other hand, are the endorsement of this life. Thinking about this, the precious Geshe Dromtönpa said to a monk at the end of the first paragraph of page four, Geshe Dromtönpa was the foremost Tibetan disciple of Atisha. Atisha, as you know, spoke no Tibetan, and Geshe Drom Tönpa interpreted for him and taught the dharma to the Tibetans, an extremely pure form of the dharma. Drom Tönpa himself was an emanation of Avalokiteśvara.

Thinking about this, the precious Dromtönpa said to a noble one, which I just translated as a monk, which he says noble one just means monk in Tibetan, When Atisha made circumambulations, he was happy even when coughing, all the more so should we be if engaging in the dharma. Here Drom Tönpa was addressing a monk who was engaged in a series of virtuous activities, or so he thought he was initially prostrating. Tönpa said to him, instead of prostrating perhaps you should practice Dharma. Then he turned to reciting his commitments, and Tönpa said to him again, perhaps you might want to practice Dharma. Then after that he started studying, Drom Tönpa said to him, you might want to practice Dharma.

Finally the poor monk, in a state of disarray, asked Drom Tönpa, how does one practice Dharma? Drom Tönpa answered forcefully three times, mentally discard this life, mentally discard this life, mentally discard this life. Saying this three times is a means of emphasizing it and it means that practices such as prostration, such as reciting one’s commitments or, for that matter, study are beneficial, but they only become Dharma if they are conjoined with discarding this life. And in turn, a Kadampa Geshe, Geshe Sharawa Yönten Drak, asked from Atisha for instructions on how to practice Sadharma. Atisha told him that his instructions were to abandon this life.

This Geshe seems to have been rather dissatisfied with Atisha’s instructions and was not terribly keen on discarding this life, nor was he very keen on meditating on love, compassion and bodhicitta. And when Geshe Drom Tönpa heard this, he said, he has discarded the essence of Atisha’s teachings. The likes of this Geshe do not understand the import of Atisha’s teachings. As a result, at the bottom of our commentary, later he, in other words Geshe Shang Nachung, also said that to practice the mind which relinquishes this right is important for oneself. He taught this, therefore, to all his students.

Moving onwards in our commentary, to elaborate on that, one must relinquish the eight worldly dharmas. Generally speaking, if one has relinquished this life, one automatically relinquishes the eight worldly dharmas. On the other hand, if one is attached to this life, then the eight worldly dharmas naturally arise within our minds. Here, once we are attached to this life, the eight worldly dharmas naturally arise, and if one were to summarize this, since they are encapsulated or summarized in nourishment, investiture and repute, food, dress and reputation, then this is also to be discarded. Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche indicates that the eight worldly dharmas are subsumed in these three preoccupations for nourishment, investiture and repute.

And of these three, the worst is a wish for repute or a good reputation. Nourishment and the desire for good clothing is less powerful. And in Tibet there were monks and meditators who engage in the most tremendous asceticism and would seal themselves in their retreat hut and have inscribed on the door, here I live someone who has given up on this life, enter not, and would live on little or no food, merely blessing flowers with mantras or for that matter blessing space with mantras and ingesting the energy of the flowers or the space. They would have no clothes worth speaking of, their robes would be aged and falling to pieces. So clearly they had abandoned attachment to nourishment and investiture.

Yet within their minds they were not able to relinquish their preoccupation with their reputation and again and again the wish arose within their minds that others on the outside to think in this area lives a great meditator, in this area lives a great yogi, we are blessed to have one such. So such a person, such a practitioner would have abandoned the two first nourishment and investment but would not have been able to abandon preoccupation for a good repute. At the bottom of page four this is indicated, although most scholars, monks and great meditators upon being despoiled of food will survive merely taking the essence of flowers and pebbles, not space pebbles, and upon being despoiled of clothes will garb themselves in ravishing grasses and nettles. In Tibet at the time of Je Tsongkhapa there were many meditators. Je Tsongkhapa wrote them an open letter asking these meditators of Tibet what their motivation was to meditate, what their main practice was and what their goals were.

Now there is a quote which is similar to this one given on page five by the noble Dorje Gompo, who said, interrupting the retreat and scribbling letters on the lintel, although seen as a great meditator by all whom one meets, I state that you are a worthy and great meditator of this life. This refers to practitioners who would stay in their meditation cell and have inscribed on the door I have given up this life and who would have abandoned the nourishment and the clothes of this life, but who would be unable to abandon their obsession with a good reputation. And in addition, since whatever is done, this bleakest of miseries which we cling to will come to naught will come, whatever cleaving to virtue will go to waste year after year, all are taken by the cavalier of the year of birth, hence spear the fancies of this life. So here there were practitioners who stayed in retreat and physically appeared to be in retreat, but it was only their bodies which was in retreat. Their bodies appeared to meditate, their mind was carried away by fancies, specifically the fancies of the eight worldly dharmas, and all of the virtue they accumulated went simply to waste.

A real meditator, a great meditator, is one who has completely discarded the eight mundane obsessions. Hence, spear the fancies of this life. The fancies of this life refer to the eight mundane dharmas. Should they not be stabbed through at all, all scholars, monks, teachers and meditators, in other words all of these purported great beings, will not have barred the gate to the three lower realms. So these practitioners who were merely dwelling physically within their retreat hut, but whose minds were running after the worldly fancies, not only would not have barred the gate to the three lower realms, they would have opened this gate wide and will be reborn there.

The great one from Ngari, this was a very great scholar from Ngari, said, In all the dharma we engage in, having striven for the self aggrandizement of this life, that became the origin. Here Rinpoche says this refers to the noble truth of the origin, the second of the four noble truths, of the increase in one’s pride, envy, hatred and desire, which in turn became a cause for samsaric existence. When one thinks I practice Dharma in as much as it has led to the lower realms, there is no difference with going to the lower realms out of sin. So these are practitioners who are filled with pride, with competitiveness, with envy through their Dharma practice, they think I am a good person and as a result of this they are filled with worldly preoccupations and will be reborn in the lower realms. Such persons are not different from worldly beings.

In our cases, for instance, when we say we recite our commitments, if we are reciting our commitments we recollect non virtue or worldly affairs, then our recitation of commitments does not begin to be Dharma practice. It is non Dharma practice. And therefore what is the thought when we practice in this way? The main thought is our attachment to this life. Because of our attachment to this life, we are incapable of practicing without fancies of this life and recollections of this life arising.

Otherwise, if we had discarded this life, they would naturally cease to arise. Therefore this is the main fault which prevents us from practicing authentically. As Śāntideva says, we are led astray by the wild elephant of the mind. So Śāntideva here as opposites as an example for the mind, a wild elephant, which lacks a master. This wild elephant races away, carried away by the passions in the same way as our mind is carried away by desire, by anger, by envy, by jealousy, by competitiveness.

It is these negative emotions, these afflictions, which cast us into the lower realms. As Śāntideva said, even if all the gods and the demigods should turn into our enemies and try to cast us in the nether reaches of hell, none will be able to succeed to do so. In other words, all the deities which exist would be unable to cast us in the lower realms. It is only the afflictions within our mind which are an inner enemy which is able to throw us into the lower realms. Buddha Śākyamūni said, I am my own foremost protector and I am my own foremost foe.

The meaning of this verse is that we become our own foremost protector, our own foremost succor, when we practice virtue and in turn through this are able to attain liberation or full enlightenment. However, it is we ourselves and ourselves alone who cast ourselves in the lower realms through our practice of non virtue and thereby we become our own foremost foes. So think well about this. If you love yourself, if you like yourself, then you want to accumulate virtue to go up. Then if you don’t like yourself and you hate yourself, then you will accumulate non virtue and go down.

So today is an auspicious day, and therefore, Rinpoche would first like to wish you good fortune and good luck. So, As you remember, Rinpoche mentioned Tenzin would remain foremost in the dharma center in the future, and this is because ever since Rinpoche came to Australia in 1988 and even before, Tenzin was a constant helper and stalwart presence of Rinpoche. Tenzin and Carol together conceived the project of this center and worked very hard to create it. Tenzin actually renovated the buildings and he erected the Buddhist statues which are behind us. Therefore Tenzin is foremost and can be seen as Rinpoche’s substitute.

Tenzin put tremendous effort for many years at this and really can be seen as Rinpoche’s substitute. Tenzin has put tremendous effort as director of the center and the time has come for him to retire from this position, while retaining his responsibilities otherwise. And therefore Rinpoche would like to appoint one new director and one sub director. The new director will be Chris Ridley, who is a longtime student of Rinpoche, who is a student of great faith with an extremely good heart. He is a devoted and dedicated student of Rinpoche, who never basically misses a single teaching.

He will be the director and next to him or under him will be Aaron as sub director who is a dedicated student and whom we hope will be of benefit to the center. In addition, two new helpers are joining the center. They are Chris Dombraine and Jade, and we hope they will work with these two new directors, Tenzin and Carol. Carol is one of Rinpoche’s longest students and she has been Tenzin’s stalwart helper from day one in the creation of the center, and in particular in the creation of the program to aid the monks of Sera Je monastery. In excess of 1,000 monks have been helped thanks to this program, and many of them have become Geshes in America, in Germany, in Australia, in New Zealand, in Mongolia and so forth.

Carol has undergone tremendous hardship in the process. She has sent emails to India, transferred money, sometimes the money didn’t arrive, she had to send it again. She would come to the center in the morning and leave late in the evening without ever accepting anything for herself. Many times Rinpoche asked her if she wanted a present or some donation. Carol has always refused, and therefore she is an example for the students of selfless dedication and of kindness, and Rinpoche would like to thank her for her kindness and her dedication.

It would be a shame if her experience and her commitment went to waste, and therefore even though she is planning on retiring, but she would like to ask her to impart her experience to the newcomers and progressively we can all proceed together. And in addition, we are now creating a publishing company thanks to the kindness of a Swiss sponsor, Rolf Soerburg. Ilya Demovic, your translator, will be the director of the company and it will be his foremost responsibility. Rinpoche in the past asked Ilya to take additional responsibilities in the center, but now we have a new Geshe coming from India and India will have to translate both for Khensur Rinpoche and for this new geshe. In addition, he teaches Tibetan and he will be the director of the publishing company.

So it seems that with his hours of commitments every day it might be a little bit too much And therefore, that will be it. Rinpoche would like to say also that Ilya has always been there when he asked him for help, and that he sees this as a sign of great faith in his student. I like to translate some part that Ilya didn’t translate. Sorry. And Rinpoche just said, you know, how wonderful that he’s giving all his time.

Not only that, but also he’s looking after himself, you know, financially and everything. You know, at the center, we’re not giving any, you know, for him. So that his tongue is dedicated, you know, completely. In every case, he will have hired a translator from in any other place. They will be very expensive.

So that, know, we just said, you know, thank you so much for his time and effort and, you know, his dedication here for the center. Okay. Take care. Thank you, Upsi. Thank you, Upsi.

Oh, yeah. You have served the Dharma Center with your body, your speech and your mind in an exceptional fashion. Rinpoche would like to thank you again and again for your kindness and your benevolence. And he would like to ask you to please help Jade and Chris with your advice so they can continue in your path. In addition to this Dharma present, at no point in the future will you ever have to pay anything for Dharma teachings or anything at the center.

Okay. So Rinpoche would like to thank Chris for having accepted after some hesitation, Rinpoche’s request to become director of the center and would like to ask all of the students, in particularly Jade and Chris Dombriane, to help Chris. Okay. Thank you. Chris is now, the foremost director of the center.

Okay? Thank Thank you. You. I would like to thank Aaron who has a lot of experience in management and thank him for helping us and point out that between mundane affairs and the dharma, the dharma always has to come first. And Rinpoche

Would like to thank his longtime disciple Tenzin, who is his substitute. The same word is used for regent in Tibetan. Tenzin has been with Rinpoche since the age of And whatever Rinpoche said, Tenzin has done. Tenzin has basically erected the center single handedly, and he has done everything for the benefit of others, including cooking for the students when cooking was required. Look around you.

Is the center not beautiful on the outside and the inside? This is Tenzin’s conception and work. Thank you. Okay. Is placing his mind in a state of joy and of prayer at the thought of the efforts put by the volunteers and the workers of the center.

And our new Geshe has received his visa, and there is good hope he will be with us shortly. In addition, three new monks are coming who will perform activities in the center as well. And then to recite the traditional salutation for auspiciousness for New Year, Tashi Delek. Tashi Delek, may all be good and may all perfections be accomplished. And all of you are here because you wish to study the Dharma in the future when Rinpoche will no longer be at the center. Rinpoche would not like that you say, well, Rinpoche is not there, so we won’t come to the teachings of the new.

You should come to the. So we should attend the teachings of this new Geshe for, who actually was one of Rinpoche’s students. Rinpoche was his Khenpo, so he was some something akin to his tutor. He is an extremely intelligent, brilliant. He is also extraordinarily humble and experienced.

And his pass his permit has been granted. But he would like to ask us to practice as much as we can what he has taught. He himself has no difficulty in teaching. It is his nature, but his sense organs have degenerated, and his body has become old. If he were left to himself, he would just keep on teaching indefinitely.

So thank you very much. And he practice and have gained real experiences, and he feels that his presence among us has been of benefit despite his advanced age. Rinpoche would also like us within the center to live in harmony with each other and to be friends. We are dharma friends, and when dharma friends have animosity or anger towards each other, then this is a very great and very heavy sin, so we should all live in harmony. He would like to recount the tale of the four friends.

Once upon a time in ancient India, there was a monkey which ate a fruit and spat out the seed, and from the seed progressively a tree grew. The tree became larger and larger, and eventually a rabbit, a hare, was able to take refuge under its shade. The tree then continued to grow, and eventually a tree dwelling monkey was able to eat its fruit. As the tree continued to grow, eventually an elephant found refuge under it from the heat. These four animals became friends.

All this from one small cause. And as a result of this, happiness ruled the land. Now, if the friendship of four animals could create happiness in an ancient country, how much more so the friendship of human beings? There is no other way to lead to happiness in this world than for all of us to be friends and to start within Australia by spreading in concentric circles circles from this dharma center outwards. This is the only way.

And Rinpoche says that whether he himself is here or not, we should continue on this mode of functioning and the center itself should be of benefit to us and to others. And in this way, the center and coming to the center can implant karmic imprints for liberation in the minds of the students. Place in your minds the following thought. Worldly affairs, mundane affairs, are of no real benefit apart from getting the necessities of this life. But dharma itself is of benefit.

It leads us from life to life higher up until we attain liberation and eventually full omniscience. Sorry. I think I’ll take a bit of opportunity here for to say a few words. First of all, TBI’s growth is really Rinpoche’s blessing. Without Rinpoche’s guidance and his bless, it’s not going to be this happen.

So that we continue to pray and long life and healthy Rinpoche’s life. So, you know, I would like to that all of us, you know, to pray and to to dedicate our, you know, the daily practice for also benefit for Rinpoche’s long life. And secondly, I’d like to welcome for Chris and Aaron to, know, as what Rinpoche said and our commitment, we can go work together forward and with Rinpoche’s bless and Rinpoche’s dedication for the center, what it’s for. And here I’d like to take to thank to Ilya, how much he puts the effort here at center. Every day there’s a translation and now that the Geshe is going to be here and he’s going to be even more busier.

So not only that, as Rinpoche said financially, he’s helping himself. You know that how we all really grateful and his effort and dedication and we wish Ilya’s health and have a great life. And also we pray for his mother to dedicate for his mother as well. And of course, the Carol, as she will continue to help Centre. She’s not going away anyway.

And as Rinpoche said, she put so much time and effort work on Centre. Not only that, also the sponsorship scheme. And now that we have two new people on a sponsorship scheme, Chris and Jade, so that as Rinpoche just said, continue to work towards the sponsorship, how much this benefit for the over there in India and also in Tibet. As said, Rinpoche, know, there’s many monks who were under this scheme and now today there’s many Geshes who passed from the scheme and there were many Geshes who are around the world. So that these are the indirect benefit what we do here.

And so this is also Rinpoche’s bless and Rinpoche’s kindness So that this is I’m going to, yeah, say tonight. And thank you very much all of you. And there’s a chai afterwards.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
chulen
Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top