1 h 34 min · 4,225 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk, which continues an earlier session on the Lam Rim path of the greatest scope, explains that outer enemies are endless while inner afflictions can be permanently ended by the wisdom realising emptiness. It covers Shantideva and Aryadeva’s teachings on overcoming afflictions, the need to understand the self before studying emptiness, and the impermanence of the person as the aggregates change. A question-and-answer discussion follows on whether a nominal self can change itself.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 34m
UUID: c9eeea64-85d4-4c19-a2f3-c89985313ead
Words: 4,221
So as Śāntideva says in his Bodhisattvacharyavatara, paraphrasing the quote, when one feuds with a worldly foe, then, obviously, however much one fights with a worldly foe using swords or whatever weapons one one uses, eventually, one or the other will overcome. There is a potency to overcome the other. Otherwise, the fight is endless. Now ordinary enemies are limitless. There is no end.
On the other hand, the enemy or the foe of the afflictions is completely different from ordinary mundane an enemy. Hence, are called in Tibetan, foe destroyers. What do they destroy? They destroy the enemy within their own minds. And here, there is a fundamental difference between ordinary foes or enemies and the foes or the enemies which are the afflictions.
Ordinary foes are endless in the sense that new ones always come when the old have left. But as far as the foes of the afflictions are concerned, once overcome, they can never rise again. And, therefore, the foe of the afflictions are completely different. This is why the verse which follows says, afflictions are abandoned by the eye of wisdom. In other words, afflictions are destroyed by the wisdom realizing emptiness.
So to abandon instantaneously, the afflictions is unrealistic. One can only abandon them through practice incrementally, but it is very difficult to practice anything if one doesn’t understand what and how to practice. And therefore, one needs here to study. And this is perhaps best understood in terms of hearing within the three wisdoms, the wisdom wisdom generated from hearing, thinking, and meditating. Do you did you write down this verse?
So the stanza reads as follows. Whereas ordinary foes, if overcome, come anew from foreign lands, the foes of the afflictions are dissimilar to that once overcome, they no longer arise. And here to overcome the foes of wisdoms as was explained, to overcome the foe of the afflictions as was explained, one must rely on the eye of wisdom. So here when we refer to the foe of the afflictions or the enemy of the afflictions, this is an enemy which is intimately related to our mental continuum. Once this enemy has been overcome or destroyed, naturally, we cease to have exterior enemies since exterior enemies are actually constructs of our own minds.
As I said in the Bodhisattva, Chariavatara, since sentient beings are limitless as space, overcoming all one’s enemies is an impossibility. Instead, subdue your mind, and all your enemies will have been overcome. Just as instead of covering the surface of the earth with leather to protect one’s feet, it is simpler to cover the surface of one’s feet with leather. This is an example given. Do you understand?
Yes. Okay. Jessica. Yeah. So if you understand, it would nice to see it on your faces.
I have the suspicion you don’t understand. If you don’t understand, you fall asleep. Right? Remember when I was a beginning student of, Khensur Rinpoche, you know, we were ranked beginners that didn’t understand a lot. So during the teachings, during the class of Buddhist philosophy, we would drift off in those.
Then Rinpoche had a very long switch, and he would reach and tap us like that on the head, and we would wake up. And later on, as we started to understand the topic study, enthusiasm arose, and we didn’t fall asleep. We have a strong proclivity for falling asleep at all moments, even when we are angry. So here, it is extremely helpful to bring verses like this to mind from time to time. And when we do to reflect on their meaning, it really refreshes us.
And when we are facing personal difficulties, it helps us tremendously. It is, frankly, of no benefit whatsoever to think that afflictions such as desire, anger, jealousy, envy, and so forth, all come somehow from the outside. We do they are due to other people all the time. They are actually within ourselves, and it is due to our lack of self control that they arise. It’s very helpful to think that we are our own protectors and that if we do not protect ourselves, difficulties will arise.
It’s very helpful when one has memorized these stanzas. And then one doesn’t even have to recite them verbally but softly when one is working and doing things? So ordinary enemies, therefore, are inexhaustible. Even if you overcome them, they will arise again. And the enemy or the foe of the afflictions is different from this.
As Śāntideva says in his Bodhisattvacharyavatara, the foe of the afflictions is different because it can be abandoned by the eye of wisdom. In other words, eliminated by wisdom realizing emptiness. So how precisely does the wisdom realizing emptiness counter the afflictions? It counters the afflictions through countering the root, the foundation of the afflictions, which is the ignorance grasping at a self. Once you have eliminated the root, you have eliminated the origin of the afflictions.
If you eliminate the cause, the effect cannot arise.
So it is therefore important to understand this distinction between outer and inner enemies. Outer enemies are inexhaustible because when some are overcome, others arise. Inner enemies, the afflictions, are not inexhaustible because it is possible to put an end to them permanently. So whereas the ignorance which grasps at itself is the root of all afflictions and is countered by the wisdom realizing selflessness, it is also very helpful to focus on contingent occasional afflictions which arise in function of our own predilections or predispositions. We might be prone to anger, prone to desire.
And then when we are walking, when we are lying down, when we are sleeping, we should examine the effects of these afflictions. And if we do so repeatedly, then I can vouch for the fact that they will reduce and not arise easily within our minds. So wall, if we take, for instance, liberation in the palm of your hand, its presentation is extremely extensive ranging from relying on the spiritual teacher all the way up to full and utter enlightenment. It is also very helpful for us to focus contingently in the short term on the dominant afflictions within our mind stream and to try to reduce these. Let us say, for instance, if we are very prone to envy or jealousy, then we should analyze the thoughts of envy and or jealousy and think, my goodness, you know, this is really problematic.
And as a result of this, over time, envy, jealousy, bitterness are going to decrease within our mind stream. It’s probably beneficial for you. Yes or no? I think this would be very beneficial. For instance, if we take the case of anger, then in general, the antidote of anger is forbearance of patience.
But it is actually very difficult to practice forbearance of patience once anger is present full blown within our mind stream. Therefore, it is much more skillful before anger arises to reflect over and again on the thoughts of anger. And then for instance, in the same way as before, we go downtown, we plan it and resolve for instance, not to allow some affliction like anger to arise within our mind stream, we should proceed in this fashion. Otherwise, if we go about things in any which way, then anger can arise easily. As Āryadeva says in his 400 stanzas, to overcome the afflictions, we need to overcome the root of the afflictions, which is the ignorance grasping at itself.
And therefore, if we have time, we should reflect on emptiness, and I believe we do have time. And the topic of emptiness in the context of Lamrim Chenmo is presented within the insight section, which within the paths of the small being and beings of small, middling, great scope is included within the path of the being of the great scope. So in brief, the outline of the path of the being of the great scope is as follows. The fact that Bodhicitta is the gateway to the Mahāyāna, the means for generating bodhicitta, and the measure of having generated bodhicitta. Now the outline continues with the following sections.
Having generated bodhicitta, how to train the mind, and how to train the mind is subdivided into two. How to train one’s own mind and how to train the mind of others. How to train one’s own mind is a practice of the six perfections. How to train other minds is a practice of the four means of gathering disciples. And how to train one’s own mind is subdivided into two, the first four perfections and the second outline, the latter two perfections which are calm abiding and the perfection of wisdom.
So within the presentation of the six perfection, the presentation of the first four perfections, the perfection of generosity, of ethics, of forbearance and of enthusiasm was completed last year. We won’t cover it again. And the outline continues, specifically how to train in the latter two perfections. These are the perfections of contemplation or dhyana and the perfection of wisdom. The perfection of contemplation refers to training in calm abiding.
I shall not cover that here. We have regularly seminars at TBI on calm abiding. The final perfection is training in insight. Insight here is an insight which is focused on emptiness, and therefore, in this context, one must explain emptiness. There are numerous presentations of emptinesses in Buddhist texts.
Here, it is specifically Ārya Nāgārjuna’s interpretation of the teachings on emptiness by the conquerors. So it is important to understand here that if one asks, in keeping with which tenet system is emptiness presented in the context of, it is presented in terms of. So here, before engaging in the study of emptiness, one must understand the reason for which one ought to study emptiness. And for this, one must understand the benefits of the opposite of the ignorance grasping at a self, which is the wisdom realizing emptiness. So one must understand from the very depths of one’s heart the faults of cyclic existence to generate a wish to be freed from cyclic existence, a wish for liberation.
Now cyclic existence exists within our own continuum. So we must understand the the faults of this before wishing to be freed from it, and then we must understand the mode of transmigrating in cyclic existence. Here, the first step is therefore to identify cyclic existence. Now it is acceptable to present as cyclic existence the totality of the afflictions within our mental continuum. And now one must understand the fault of these afflictions.
Geshe Potowa had a presentation of the path of the beings of the three scopes in terms of the 12 limbs of dependent origination. The path shared with the being of the small scope involved an understanding of the 12 limbs of dependent origination in the forward and in the reverse direction leading to lower rebirth. The path shared with the being of the middling scope
Involved an understanding of the 12 limbs of dependent origination in the forward and in the reverse sequent sequence leading to higher rebirth. And the path of the being of the great scope involved extending this understanding of the 12 limbs of dependent origination to all sentient beings. This is very, very thought provoking since the 12 limbs of dependent origination are presented in terms of the path shared with the small, middling, and great scope. So Here, if we want to understand emptiness, who does this understanding? The I does.
So this abuts immediately on the issue of the I and the relation between I and other, I and you. And in this context, I would like to remind you of Āryadeva’s stanza in the Chatuhshataka, the 400 stanzas, in which he says, at the beginning, accumulate merit in the middle, abandon the self, and at the end, abandon all views. And here, the first verse refers to the path shared with the being of the small scope and the accumulation of merit. The second verse refers to training in the selflessness of persons, and the third verse refers to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view. So at the level at which we are at, it is the first verse which matters.
It is the accumulation of merit. In other words, an appreciation of karma and causality and an understanding of past and future lives. Regarding the second verse, selflessness of persons, the self which is refuted here is a self which is permanent, one, and independent, or if you prefer in brief, a permanent self. So to use the words which refer to this is quite easy, but to understand the meaning is another kettle of fish. Basically here, we must understand that we and others are both impermanent.
Why are we impermanent? What’s the reason for this? So when we say we are impermanent, what is the reason why? So here, when we speak of this mistaken sense of self. And when I look at myself, I see this as a self which is the owner of aggregates and so forth, but this may be difficult for you to understand.
I think it is more accessible to understanding the impermanence of the I. But here, why exactly do we say that we are impermanent? Once we truly understand this, then the gateway to an understanding of the surfaces of persons and emptiness is wide open. So we are impermanent. We are not permanent.
Then if we say something is impermanent, what’s the reason? So when I ask you if something is impermanent, why is it impermanent? If I’m impermanent, why am I impermanent? I think it might fry your brains. And at this point, you could end by drifting off and falling asleep.
So why are we impermanent? Because we depend on the causes. Okay. Alright. Are Yeah.
Permanent phenomena dependent arising is true. And don’t worry. You can say everything. I cut it. Why?
Why? Why? So we’re changing from Because our body is changing, we change. And that’s a very good way of looking at Both yourselves and myself depend on our aggregates. And if our aggregates change, if our body changes, then since we are imputed on the base of the aggregates, we ourselves change also.
So when our bodies become older and our hair, for instance, becomes gray, then one has to say that we ourselves have aged. This gets very un PC. But if someone has a fat body, we say he’s a fatty. And if someone is skinny and tall, we say he’s a tall one. Then distinguishing man from woman is done in terms of the genitalia, the genital organs.
And likewise, it is through this type of analysis that we can understand what is meant by a person who is empty of being permanent, one, and independent. Otherwise, if I speak of permanent, one, and independent like this, it just will not penetrate in your skulls. Likewise, when we say of someone, this is someone who has studied extraordinarily well, who is very learned, we are imputing personhood on the basis of the mental continuum of the qualities of study of the mental continuum. Or when we we say, he’s just a lazy one. He’s just a lazy bum.
He doesn’t understand anything. Then we are imputing personhood on the basis of the thoughts of the mental continuum. So here, it becomes very clear why the person is impermanent. If instead of saying the person is a momentary phenomenon, we say instead the aggregates, the basis of imputation of the person are themselves momentary and change instant by instant. Therefore, the person imputed on this base is necessarily momentary and changes instant by instant.
It should be self evident. And, therefore, there is no person apart from the aggregates. The person is intimately related to the aggregates. And when we say that, this is the meaning of the statement, the person depends or relies on the aggregates. Then this leads one to an understanding of the object of refutation: a person which is permanent, one, and independent.
Yeah. I’d like to ask you, whether for yourselves or for myself, is there a you or a me, a person independent of your aggregates or my aggregates? Who said yes? What do you think? So what you is there apart from the aggregates?
Not apart from the aggregates. It’s an independence from the aggregates. Yeah. I know. Apart from?
Never. Never. If they were to be irrational, illogical. If there were a person which was independent of the aggregates, which was separate of the aggregates, then this person would indeed or could indeed be something which is permanent, one, and independent. And this is what those who propound the existence of a person which is permanent, one, and independent accept.
When you think in this way, the understanding of emptiness should begin to dawn. So the first step here is to understand that the person depends or relies on the aggregates. Then the difficulties arise because we have to ask what is the mode of dependence. And here, there are numerous answers. Here numerous scholars, based on the fact that this sense of I, of personhood arises from deep within the mind, have proposed a variety of answers.
We will see them progressively. Therefore, at present, in the context of generating the motivation, rely upon a special mind, endowed with the two characteristics, the definition of bodhicitta, which you all know at present. Let us reflect as was explained on the fact that the person is impermanent and the reasons for which the person is impermanent, and on this basis, refute the existence of a permanent one and independent person and generate the wish to do this for the sake of others. During a couple minutes. Yeah.
Please open the table, page one. And at page five, manual frame. Last one and the three. So when we say that the person is impermanent because the aggregates are impermanent, that does not mean that the person is the aggregates. I am not my hand.
I am not my head. I am not my foot. That is a ridiculous position. But this distinction between the person which is imputed and the base of imputation is one you need to study for and you will understand after study. Then in your cases, you understand what bodhicitta, great compassion, and love are.
If in addition you were to understand what emptiness is, then your studies would be complete with an extraordinary state of affairs. It’s a lot of talk. Then Have you Doesn’t matter. I’ll take your questions at present. I’d really like to clarify this point.
I feel like I’ve only heard it for the first time really tonight. I feel like I’ve only heard this point for the first time tonight except Yeshua has been teaching and before that Rupeshain, before that other teachers. So the person who is one permanent and independent is independent of their aggregates, and so that would be a person who believes in an Ātman or a soul. And so they are saying those people that believe in an Ātman or a soul are saying that that is the person, the Ātman or the soul, which means that there is not just a different view, it’s a complete chasm between the Buddhist view and the non Buddhist view. Then that is indeed the case.
The difference between the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, the outsiders, and the Buddhists is posited in terms of view, as Candrakīrti says, in his praise of dependent origination. It will be difficult to posit it in terms of conduct. Craig? The distinction between Buddhists and non Buddhists is formulated in terms of the view between those who accept the non Buddhists, a person which is permanent one and independent, and those who never accept a permanent person which is permanent one and independent, the Buddhists. Last week, I asked the question about how a thoroughly afflicted mind could transform itself, and that abuts on what we’re talking about now.
And there’s two prongs to why that question came about. Hard determinists would say that if there’s no agent standing outside of the cycle of karma to intervene in karmic activity, then there’s no agent to control or to create change in the process of the karmic process. The second prong to some arguments that are made about the possibility of self change is that, you know, if the self that is trying to improve itself is itself deluded and self deceiving, then how can it transform itself? It’s like trying to pull yourself up by your own bootstraps. That’s an argument that’s been made by Western philosophy.
Can I summarize your doubt? Your doubt in a nutshell is that if there’s not an eye or a soul, how can there be an agent which purifies karma in non virtuous deeds? If by eye you were referring to a truly established I, then such an I is not accepted by the Buddhists. What is accepted is a nominal eye, a terminological eye. And I follow that.
How would such a normal a nominally existent I affect change if it is itself deluded. So while the terminological I relies on the aggregates, the terminological I is not the afflictions nor is it afflicted. So the views you’re expressing are clearly deeply held views of your own. But, actually, you must distinguish clearly between a coarse self of persons, which is a person being one established and independent, and a subtle self of persons, which is something existing within the aggregates, which is the master or the owner of the aggregates, I think you definitely subscribe to that view. Then in that respect, your understanding is mistaken, and it is something which calls for much study and also much meditation.
Without meditation, one does not gain understanding of these topics. Okay. That would also apply to the feeling or the sense of an infinite regression of an I that is imputing upon itself or the imputing I onto the aggregates in an infinite regression of imputations of an imputator. So the person is the imputed phenomenon, and the aggregates are the base of imputation. Then what is your doubt?
There is an imputer who is imputing. The the person is imputed. Right? For the mind, if you prefer. The mind is imputing of a a concept is imputing a concept.
You speak. I’ll translate. So I think my mind is looking for an essential imputer. So the way to proceed here is to study the numerous texts on the view in English and then to reflect on actual reality and contrast the two, analyze and think, and in so doing, one will progress forwards. Otherwise, if one just sits back and doesn’t think too much, one does not progress.
Last week, Geshe la spoke about subduing the mind. I’ve been just thinking about that over the week and wondering if when we subdue our minds, it is also a way of cherishing others. All depends on the motivation. If you subdue your mind for the sake of others, then indeed it becomes an act of self cherish of of cherishing others. And other other question?
No? Okay. Yeah. You can. Maybe I’ll put my doubt a slightly different way.
So if someone is angry with us, we practice forbearance by thinking of them as the stick wielded by the person who hits us with the stick. They’re not acting under their own power. Yet, when we ourselves are afflicted, we are encouraged to practice the opposing powers and feel regret or shame for our actions. Take responsibility for them. So what I’m trying to get at is where do we account for free will and agency when there’s no agent?
This this is a real western doubt. Then it is perfectly okay to look at the I and the self in this fashion as something which is truly existent and which has absolute freedom if this is of benefit for your mind and it is of benefit for the minds of many people. The Prāsaṇgika view is an extremely difficult view, to integrate. One needs to accumulate a lot of merit, and one needs to study in-depth. So it is not something which happens at once.
Brilliant. I’ll just add, these doubts arise in listening to neuroscientists like Sam Harris or biologists like Daniel Dennett. So these are the types of things that they propound. And so when listening to both views, trying to understand the western views, these things come up. And some of the thought experiments and things they propose are are quite strong.
And I haven’t been able to overcome those. Okay. I think finish it. Thank you. Thank you.
Good question. Thank you. The Tibetan news coming on this Monday. So we have a 10:30 reading a heart sūtra, most welcome, and then sharing a lunch with the Geshe la. And in the evening, we have Guru Pooja, 07:00.
So please make sure come along. Thank you. There’s a chai. Okay? Please.
Oh, yeah. Of course, the Sunday teaching as well in 10:30 after the meditation. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- dhyana samten (Tib)
- An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.