1 h 39 min · 4,326 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk summarises the path of the three scopes and explains how to meditate on great love, great compassion and bodhicitta, including the sevenfold cause-and-effect method and equalising self and others. It then covers the six perfections, dividing generosity into material giving, giving dharma and giving fearlessness, and stresses that understanding the perfections is not the same as practising them. Questions on motivation and generosity follow.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 39m
UUID: bd2f74fd-b3c0-4271-b1f6-b263ca4ed11d
Words: 4,322
So although we have covered this material previously, I would like to cover again in brief the essence of the path of the beings of the three scopes and their realizations. The realization of the path shares of being of the small scope is an uncontrived, unfabricated striving for higher rebirth. So in brief, regarding the presentation of the past a very easy presentation of the path shared with the being of the small scope. As was said, it’s a foundation or realization is wishing to attain a higher rebirth. The means for generating such a state of mind, in short, is reflecting over and again on the sufferings of the lower realms.
Now what precisely is the object of observation or if you prefer the meaning of the path shared with the being of the small scope. In a nutshell, it is a human rebirth. A human rebirth is an extra extraordinarily powerful rebirth. And what is the means to obtain such a rebirth? In brief, It is taking refuge in the triple gem and in dependence on this engaging in the practice of an ethics, which is the abandonment of the 10 non virtues.
Now regarding the path shared with being of the middling scope, what is the realization of this path? It is the generation of an uncontrived or unfabricated mind of definite emergence, or if you prefer, an uncontrived or unfabricated mind striving for liberation from cyclic existence. And here, please be mindful of the fact that understanding what uncontrived definite emergence is does not mean that we have the realization of uncontrived definite emergence. It would be very strange otherwise. All of us would have the realization of uncontrived definite emergence.
Instead, it must actually be generated within one’s mind stream. Now just as for the path shared as a being of the small scope, what is the means to generate this uncontrived definite emergence? It is repeated reflections on the sufferings and the faults of cyclic existence. What is the object of observation of the path shared with the being of the middling scope? And you have noticed we use the term object of observation frequently.
It’s a very helpful term to use. Its objective observation is liberation. Now what precisely is the means to attain liberation? It is the three trainings. The trainings in ethics, concentration, and wisdom.
An important point I would like to make here is that to have a realization of definite emergence of great compassion and so forth, it is not sufficient to have understood the meaning of definite emergence or of great compassion. To have a realization of definite emergence or great compassion, one’s mind must become definite emergence or great compassion. One’s mind must be subsumed in definite emergence or great compassion. One must therefore generate definite emergence or great compassion within one’s mind stream. The situation is different for emptiness, impermanence, specifically certain impermanence, or let us say the four noble truths.
In those cases, since the object must be analyzed, once this analysis has severed the nets of doubt regarding the object, I think one can say one has a realization of that object. Now regarding the path of the being of the great scope, the realizations of the path of the being of the great scope is the realization of great compassion or definitely the realization of bodhicitta, conventional bodhicitta. What is or are the means to generate these realizations? Broadly speaking, there are two means to generate them. The first is the sevenfold cause and effect generation of Bodhicitta, and the second is equalization and exchange of self and others.
But in brief, they are the practices of love and compassion. What is the object of observation or if you prefer, the goal of the path shared with the being of the great scope? It is full and utter enlightenment. And what are the means to attain this goal? They are the combination of method and wisdom.
In other words, the practice of the five first perfections associated with method and the last perfection associated with wisdom. The practice of the six perfections leads leads to the attainment of full and utter enlightenment. So it is through listening repeatedly to teachings on the that one can present things in such a summarized fashion. Obviously, if one has time, it is best to engage in an elaborate study of the Lam Rim. But if one lacks time, then such a summarized presentation is very helpful.
So what are therefore the means to generate bodhicitta? The means to generate bodhicitta are meditation on love and great compassion. There is no specific meditation on the supreme resolve. Now when one speaks of meditating on love and on great compassion, what is the mode of meditation on love and on great compassion? Specifically, what’s the mode of meditation on great compassion?
So when you meditate on great compassion, how do you meditate? So when we speak of meditation on compassion, it is not meditating on the word compassion. What exactly does one meditate upon? Then, obviously, one should identify the object of observation and the aspect. But let’s set that aside.
How do you proceed? Really? Just one. Just one. Just one.
Not too much. Just one. So please only one answer per person. Right? Only one call.
One reply. Hero? Yes. And here?
Heaven. Empathy. Empathy. Empathy. So the answer is you have to figure that out for yourselves.
We’re not answering questions. So if I ask the questions and I answer the questions I ask, there’s no point. So what do you think? To me, the word mode relates to the way to you the mode of meditation is the way you go about meditation. And the answer my answer to that would be to engage in the sevenfold cause and effect So all of your answers were appropriate.
Khensur Rinpoche over and again would address us and say, meditate on compassion, meditate on love, meditate on emptiness. Then when you say meditate in this context, it’s a very profound statement. So how precisely does one proceed? Well, the first is to generate this wish for all sentient beings to attain happiness. And happiness, we know the meaning of.
And here when we refer to the love or the compassion which, ought to be generated for sentient beings, obviously, we are talking of unbiased love and compassion, not the bias or partial love and compassion, which we all have in our mind stream for those who are close to us. Then in a country like this one, frankly, one cannot say that there are any meaningful difficulties. There are other parts of the world where the hardship is extreme. And this is directly the result of the lack of empathy and compassion. So when we reflect on this, then even though the goals of liberation and full enlightenment remain very far removed for all of us, nonetheless, through thinking about compassion, then we are at ease and happy in this life.
So here, we must distinguish the object of observation and the aspects of great compassion and not ordinary love, but great love. Then in the case of great compassion and great love, the object of observation is all sentient beings. In the case of great love, the aspect is an affectionate love for all sentient beings, which is akin to the love a parent experiences for his or her child. A parent will give anything to his or her child, his food, whatever, to make their child happy. This is what must be generated.
And then the mode of generation of great compassion and great love, as you mentioned, they can be generated in two different ways. The first is through relying on the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, and the second is through training in the equalization and interchange of self and others. And, therefore, when one speaks of meditating on great love, one refers to meditating on these two objects, the object of observation, which is all sentient beings, and the aspect, which is an affectionate love for all sentient beings. Whereas one refers to the mode of generating great love. Then one refers, for instance, to the sevenfold cause and effect generation or the equalization interchange of self and others.
Likewise, for great compassion great compassion has as object of observation, all sentient beings, and as aspect, the wish may they be free from all suffering. Then regarding the modes of generation, great compassion can be generated either by the sevenfold cause and effect generation or by the equalization and interchange of self and others. However, as the direct cause of great compassion is great love, the more powerful great love is, the more powerful its result of great compassion will be. Now to begin with the training and great compassion, we have to focus on the suffering of one other sentient being, any sentient being, not ourselves. I mean, if we focus on our own suffering, it’s very self centered.
So therefore, when we refer refer to meditating on great compassion or great love, the term meditating in Tibetan has the same root as to become accustomed to. The meaning therefore is to become accustomed to great love or to great compassion. And once you understand this, I think you can understand how to meditate on definite emergence as well. So what is the mode of meditation on Bodhicitta? So in parallel with the meditations on great love and great compassion, what is the mode of meditation on bodhicitta?
Maitreya says in Mahāyāna Sūtra Lankara, I assert its root to be great compassion. And therefore, bodhicitta is induced by great love and great compassion. So without mixing them up, without confusion, what is the mode of meditation on bodhicitta? Express yourself. Speak.
So what is the mode of meditation of? So when you meditate on, what do you do? Not answering questions. You should answer. Mhmm.
Speak for yourselves. Can you a Can you have a pen holder? I a think marvelous period for the police. The two of us, we have it easy today. You’re gonna have a hot time.
Each of us says, you and I, we’re sweating it every day, then their turn to sweat. Hey. You’re gonna suffer. So think. Put effort.
So So broadly speaking, what you said was correct that independence on great compassion and great love, one gives rise to bodhicitta, but that is insufficient. It is not sufficient to have generated great love and great compassion. Having generated great compassion, it is not sufficient to think I will attain enlightenment. One must first understand the capacity of enlightenment to benefit others. And for this, one must understand the characteristics of the fully enlightened body, speech, and mind.
Then independence on this one generates a wish to attain for the enlightenment for the sake of others. So bodhicitta is a consciousness. Therefore, when we want to generate bodhicitta, we must first understand what its object of observation and its aspects are, and the same is true for great love and great compassion. Then when we speak of meditating on bodhichitta, it is similar to having all your stuff in a bag. You’re comfortable because it’s under control.
Meditation is not blissing out and staying in some state of absence of thought. Now when one meditates on bodhicitta, therefore, one must initially identify the object of observation of bodhicitta, which is full and utter enlightenment. It is not, however, sufficient upon generating this wish to attain full and utter enlightenment, in other words, aspiring bodhicitta to just sit back and relax. One must also strive for the goal, put effort, and this striving for the goal, this putting effort is engaging in the practice of these six perfections. So you can see here how elegant the procedure for generating these various states is.
Then whether one chooses to follow this path or not, that’s entirely up to oneself. So if one wishes to attain full and utter enlightenment, then one must find what produces full and utter enlightenment. Now generally speaking, one can probably not say that great love, great compassion, and bodhicitta directly generate full and utter enlightenment. They do generate it, but not directly. They generate it indirectly.
So what generates full and utter enlightenment directly? The six perfections do. And therefore, even though generally speaking, you can say that great love, great compassion, and bodhicitta included within the method aspect of the path, nonetheless, they do not generate directly for enlightenment. This is how the the path meanders and leads to the goal initially to generate conventional bodhicitta. We need both great love and great love and the great compassion.
Then having generated bodhicitta, that alone is not sufficient to attain full and utter enlightenment. We need after this to practice of the six perfections, and this eventually leads to full and utter enlightenment. So I don’t know if you’ve noticed that when there’s difficulties on the road, the road meanders. And when there’s no difficulties, it goes straight. So in this case, this road goes straight to full enlightenment.
So what we have to understand here is the procedure or the mode of traveling on the road. So here, it is not sufficient to have generated aspiring bodhicitta. One must also engage in the practice. And at this point, one takes the bodhisattva vows. It is after having taken the bodhisattva vows that one can be said to have engaged in the practice of the six perfections.
Then before one commits to taking the bodhisattva vows, one is still at the level of someone who has merely aspiring Bodhicitta. So at this point, engaging bodhicitta means to decide I will do it. Whatever Buddha Śākyamūni did to attain full enlightenment, I will do the same. And at this point, one engages in the practice to attain full and utter enlightenment. So at this point, one engages in the practice of all six perfections ranging from the perfection of giving all the way up to the perfection of wisdom.
The first perfection is the perfection of giving and the meaning of the perfection of giving is to engage in giving with a mind of giving or a mind of generosity. So the issue arose during the last teaching about the respective distribution of the six perfections in the method and wisdom aspect of the path. The perfection of wisdom is part of the wisdom aspect of the path, and the first five perfections including the perfection of meditation is part of the method aspect of the path. So what exactly is the nature of the perfection of generosity? The object of observation of the perfection of generosity is all sentient beings.
Its aspect is the, substances, whatever one gives. But it is critical here that this, giving be done without any stinginess or avarice. Otherwise, this practice does not begin to be the perfection of generosity. So the perfection of generosity can be defined as a mind of giving. So when one engages in the practice of the perfection of generosity, one gives to sentient beings whatever they wish to satisfy their wish for objects.
And it is important after engaging in this practice not to regret having given or to think afterwards, I should not have given this or that. It was a mistake. At this point, it ceases to be a practice of the perfection of generosity. Before engaging in the practice of the perfection of giving or generosity, it is very important to reflect carefully on what one is doing. Now does a practice of generosity or giving just by the act of giving become the perfection of generosity?
No. It doesn’t. To become a practice of the perfection of generosity in addition to being a give a deed of giving or generosity, it must be upheld by the motivation of Bodhicitta. And here, ideally, it will be upheld by an uncontrived motivation of Bodhicitta. If that is not possible, it will be obtained by a contrived or fabricated motivation of Bodhicitta.
And if that is not possible, at the very least, it should be obtained by an understanding of Bodhicitta. Then this deed of giving becomes a practice of the perfection of giving. Then the perfection of generosity is subdivided into three. The generosity of giving material objects, of giving dharma, and of bestowing fearlessness. Giving material things is giving any material thing.
For instance, if one were to give a small piece of chocolate, as long as the motivation is a pure one, this becomes a practice of the perfection of generosity. So why is it the case that giving something trivial like a small piece of chocolate can lead one to accrue such a vast amount of merit? It is because if it is upheld by the motivation of bodhicitta, since bodhicitta covers all sentient beings, then such a motivation turns a deed into something huge. We can give something as small as one of the candies of Geshe-la’s table and accumulate a vast amount of merit. Now you might wonder how can I accumulate an infinite amount of merit through offering one such throat lozenges since after all, I’m giving it only to one person?
The key here is the motivation. The motivation is to give it to all sentient beings. Then, obviously, there are enough throat throat lozenges for all sentient beings.
Then, obviously, you would accumulate more merit than if you were to give a throat lozenge to each of these 7,000,000,000 human beings on this earth. The second form of the perfection of generosity is the generosity of giving dharma. And this is, in my opinion, the highest form of generosity. It is said in the text that the measure of giving dharma is one verse. So if one imparts one verse of teachings, one has imparted dharma.
Then one can do this without any particular hardship. Then to practice the perfection of generosity of giving dharma does not mean we have to be in this formal setting like in a temple. It can perfectly be practiced at the restaurant over a meal. If during a meal, one explains the meaning of emptiness or the four noble truths to someone, one has practiced the perfection of generosity of giving down. Then if one has some understanding of emptiness and one engages in the practice of the five first perfections, generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, and concentration, and trains in addition in great compassion of Bodhicitta, perhaps one has fulfilled the training of all six perfections.
So at present, let us meditate during a couple of minutes on the meaning of love, compassion, and bodhicitta, the objects of observation, and their aspects. May you please open the prayer book, We shall recite page 13 and also page five, the mandala offering, number six, plus one and three. So at present, ask your questions. One question per person.
Mhmm. And then we’ll check the time. Are we able to practice six paramitas such as generosity and giving without understanding of emptiness? Without having realized emptiness by means of a valid cognizer, it is possible to train in the six perfections. Mhmm.
Possible. Possible. Is there a way to train in the six perfections that could be done on a daily basis? Like, checked it off the shopping list. How are some practical ways to do that?
So if we take the six perfections regarding the perfection of generosity, we can train every day in the generosity of giving dharma. That is easy. Then regarding the perfection of ethics, we can train every day in an ethics which abandons the 10 non virtues with the appropriate motivation. Then regarding the perfection of forbearance of patience that we can train every day in. Regarding the perfection of enthusiasm, we can generate enthusiasm for studying.
Regarding the perfection of meditation, when we meditate on great love, great compassion, bodhicitta, it was a requisite motivation that becomes the perfection of meditation, and the perfection of wisdom refers to an understanding of emptiness. If I were to give examples, it would be inexhaustible. So when we speak of the six perfections, what’s important is to understand that a mere understanding of the six perfections is not the practice of the six perfections. Then the remaining perfections, I will explain later. The ones which follow generosity.
Yeshua, what are the characteristics of the enlightened body, speech, and mind that one must first understand before developing a mind of enlightenment? So regarding the qualities of the enlightened body, these are the 32 major and 18 minor marks explained in Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra. Regarding the qualities of the enlightened speech, these are the 60 qualities of the enlightened speech. But if this is too difficult, we can just reflect on the qualities of His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s speech. And regarding the qualities of the enlightened mind, these are three main qualities.
Wisdom, empathy, and capacity.
Yes. With the aspect of generosity, I think you said it was the substance that’s given. So with the third division giving fearlessness, would equally it be whatever you’re giving? So if you’re rescuing an ant from drowning, you’re giving it life or you’re giving it safety. Would that be the aspect in that division?
So regarding the sub the aspect of the perfection of fearlessness, The object of observation of the perfection of fearlessness is all sentient beings or this specific sentient being. And the aspect is the protection of fearlessness, and protection has substance. So when this living being, the sentient being experiences hardship and when protected from this hardship, this protection is substantial. It is a substance, not in the sense of a material substance as an object, food, drink, and so forth. So in that context, Geshe la, in giving fearlessness, when we’re seeing people being treated unfairly or bullied, we should be intervening with that motivation, and that would be an example of giving fearlessness.
That is not really connected to the perfection of giving, but more to forbearance, isn’t it? So, Geshe, just to clarify, the direct cause of full enlightenment is the six perfections. Is that is that what you said? So the way to look at it is this. The state of Buddhahood subsumes two states, the dharmakaya or the truth body and the or the form body.
Now the first five perfections are the causes of the form body or the Rūpakāya. The last perfection, the perfection of wisdom, is the cause of the truth body or the Dharmakāya. Mhmm. With the subdivision of the perfection of giving the dharma and even giving a verse of the dharma, Does that apply as a perfection if the recipient of that dharma is hostile to the dharma? One must think carefully before engaging in the perfection of giving.
If the recipient is angry or does not accept the verse one imparts, then how could that become the practice of the perfection of giving? The practice of generosity involves satisfying fully the wishes of another person. If another person does not wish to receive teachings and one presentatizes, then how precisely can that be the practice of the perfection of generosity? Then, obviously, when we can train in the perfection of generosity, we envision with the motivation of bodhicitta giving to all sentient beings, and we have no way of knowing the motivation of all sentient beings either. Mhmm.
And other? On the subject of regretting generosity, Rarely, I’m able to generate an unselfish motive when giving, and I delight in the delight of the recipient of a material gift, for example. But it is also mixed with a certain regret because I also know that that material gift is perpetuating a desire. And so there seems to be, in my mind, a mixed sort of feeling of both delight and regret. And I don’t know how to separate them out, and I don’t know if the latter cancels out the former.
So when one trains in generosity, one’s own motivation is critical, and this motivation must be uncontaminated by greed or stinginess. Then we are responsible for our own motivation. What precisely happens in another person’s mind, we have no control over. Okay. That’s it.
You just mentioned the professional giving. There’s a the key of that is the motivation. There’s a three levels of motivation. One, the highest one is uncontrived bodhicitta. Second one is contrive bodhicitta.
And the last one is at least understand bodhicitta. So without the last level of motivation, can a person with that attitude or without motivation to achieve the perfection given? So in the, it is said merely that for a deed of giving to become a practice of the perfection of generosity, it must be upheld by Bodhicitta. Nothing is said about whether this Bodhicitta should be contrived or uncontrived. However, in Madhyamaka, it is said that, it must be upheld by a motivation of Bodhicitta, and this must be a fully characterized one.
So it must be uncontrived. Even though, however, it is not a practice of the perfection of generosity, you wanna accumulate vast amounts of merit through such giving, and it is a practice of the Mahāyāna. Just one question. If I gave some if I gave something to somebody yesterday without a bodhicitta motivation. And then today and then today, I think I retroactively upgrade that motivation in my in my mind and and really think I would like to have given that with a bodhicitta motivation for the sake of all beings.
Does that count? It doesn’t happen. It was passed yesterday. Then things would get very strange, wouldn’t they? Then they don’t worry.
Okay. Actually, I thought I don’t have any announcement, but I do. Yeah. You’re right.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
- The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is there a way to train in the six perfections that can be done on a daily basis?
Each perfection can be trained in every day. For generosity, give the Dharma, which is easy. For ethics, abandon the ten non-virtues with the appropriate motivation. For forbearance, train in patience. For enthusiasm, generate enthusiasm for studying. For meditation, meditate on great love, great compassion and bodhicitta; with the requisite motivation this becomes the perfection of meditation. The perfection of wisdom refers to an understanding of emptiness. Examples would be inexhaustible. What matters is to understand that a mere understanding of the six perfections is not the practice of the six perfections.
Does giving Dharma count as the perfection of generosity if the person receiving it is hostile to the Dharma?
One must think carefully before engaging in the perfection of giving. If the recipient is angry or does not accept the verse one imparts, it is hard to see how that could become the practice of the perfection of giving, because generosity involves fully satisfying the wishes of another person. If someone does not wish to receive teachings and one presents them anyway, it is unclear how that could be the practice of generosity. At the same time, when training in the perfection of generosity, one envisions giving to all sentient beings with the motivation of bodhicitta, and one has no way of knowing the motivation of all sentient beings either.