Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching continues the Lam Rim sequence, linking refuge, karma and the path shared with the small scope. It explains three modes of abandonment: restraining nonvirtue, the antidotes of definite emergence and bodhicitta, and the wisdom realising emptiness. It then covers the Mahayana paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing and meditation, with student answers throughout.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 34m
UUID: 2b0f1b63-0d0b-4c63-b568-b9b5d99e62c7
Words: 4,501
As teaches in his canticle of realization, the concise concise Lam Rim. Since it is certain that we will be reborn in the lower realms and the triple gem definitely protects from this, takes stable refuge and does do not allow the precepts of refuge to degenerate. Those, my teachers practiced in this way, those desiring liberation should practice likewise. Now this stanza teaches the totality of the path shared with the being of the small scope. And Jetsongkapa concludes his, this stanza by saying, I, the yogi, practiced in this way.
Those striving for liberation should do likewise. In addition, the two verses which read, therefore, train well in what is to be appropriated and what is to be abandoned and practiced purely are to be understood as referring to abandoning non virtuous deeds and training in virtue. So, therefore, one should engage in the appropriation of virtue, and one should abandon nonvirtue. Now how precisely should one engage in relying correctly in this way on, causality? This is not something which can happen at once or instantaneously.
It happens in dependence on causes and conditions. Now what precisely are these causes and conditions? These causes and conditions are refuge. It is in dependence on refuge that this practice in accordance with causality occurs. So, therefore, the practice of the appropriation of virtue and the abandonment of nonvirtue occurs in dependence on the practice of the taking of refuge in the triple gem.
And going for refuge in the triple gem itself, in turn, arises in dependence on a realization of the suffering of the lower realms. So, Gishna, I would like to ask you to explain the relationship between the practice of engaging in virtue and abandoning non virtue and going for refuge. So since the practice of engaging in virtue and abandoning non virtue occurs, in dependence on the practice of going for refuge, Keshele, I would like to ask you to explain this relationship. So can you explain it? Yeah.
It’s an important question. Mayan my understanding is that refuge can become the foundation for the intention to practice. It’s yeah. Okay. Oh, that’s all I can say.
So as you remember, there are five topics of meditation in the past shared with it being of the small scope, and Geshek has presented them in the past in the forward sequence. Then at present, we are looking at them in the reverse sequence. So if we look at the appropriation of virtue or engagement in virtue and abandonment of nonvirtue, which are the culmination of the past shared with the being of the small scope, that arises in dependency on going for refuge. Going for refuge arises in dependence on awareness of the suffering of the lower realms. This in turn arises in dependency on meditation, on death, and impermanent impermanence.
So can you explain the relationship between the two first ones? Can I just just quickly, please? Would of suffering ethics? It taught the way to And so, therefore, independence on one’s refuge in Buddha and Buddha’s word and, his realizations, which are the dharma, one should practice ethics. Yes.
There’s a relationship. That’s it. There is a close relation in this between going for refuge to Buddha Śākyamūni and the practice of engaging in virtue and abandoning nonvirtue Since Buddha said, it is through relying on my teachings that you will be able to engage in virtue and abandon non virtue. Mhmm. We can we can turn it off if you want.
Alright. So what? A little warm I rely on this for the speech, and I don’t need a lamp for my ears. Right? Between the practice of engaging in virtue and abandoning non virtue and going for refuge.
Then moving further back one step, what is the relationship between going for refuge and an awareness of the suffering of the lower realms? Could you please explain? Quick. Quick. Quick.
Quick. Just one. We go for a refuge in the triple gem on the basis of understanding the suffering of the lower realms and asking ourselves a question, what can protect me from the suffering of the lower realms? And the Triple Gem provides a suitable protection from the suffering of the lower realms. Indeed, it is through reflecting on the sufferings of the lower realms and the defects of the sufferings of the lower realms that at present, being aware of the fact that we do not have a protector from these sufferings, we seek for such a protector.
In other words, we seek for refuge. This is the relationship between these two topics. Do you understand? Now the practice of reflecting on the suffering of the lower realms arises out of meditation on death and impermanence. Do you understand?
The relationship between reflecting on the suffering of the lower realms and meditation on death and impermanence arises as follows. Among the many topics of meditation on death and impermanence, the central one is the awareness of the uncertainty of the time of death. Now at the time of our death, after our death specifically, there are only two possible roads, a rebirth in the higher or the lower realms. In our own cases, we have accumulated a large number of for rebirth in the lower realms. So this is how these two topics are related.
And meditation on death and impermanence arises from a meditation on the identification of leisure and endowment. There’s a close relationship. This one.
And what in turn is the foundation of meditation or contemplation on the identification of leisure and endowment, it is none other than reliance on the spiritual teacher. Maitreya’s Mahāyāna Sūtra Alamkara identifies 10 criteria for the Kalyana Mitra, the virtuous friend of the Mahāyāna. But within these 10, Jetsongkapa subsumes these into three. A spiritual teacher must be someone who, between self and others, cherishes others more than self, must be someone who has more qualities than oneself. And between qualities and defects within the spiritual teacher, that spiritual teacher has more qualities than defects.
And therefore, one moves in the forward sequence by reflecting first on the main topic which is the foundation of the path relying on the spiritual teacher. This is followed by the topic identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment, the rarity of that rebirth. Then one moves on to the topic of contemplation of death and impermanence, the suffering of the lower realms, going for refuge, and finally, the general characteristics of karma and causality. Mhmm. Do you understand?
Sure. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay.
And the foundation in turn of the totality of the Lam Rim is none other than a conviction in the existence of past and future lives. And one must, in turn, rely on a spiritual teacher, a virtuous friend, who is able to explain the mode of existence of past and future lives. Do you understand? Good. Thank you.
If you understand, it’s okay. Sure. Yes. Yes. Everyone says yes.
So, therefore, the verses in the canticle of realization will read, relying firmly on the object of refuge do not allow the precepts of refuge to degenerate and reflecting on white and black karma engaged in the appropriation of virtue and the abandonment of non virtue. Now Buddha Śākyamūni did not say that he would save living beings by lifting them out of suffering with his his hand nor by washing them, washing their sins off. Instead, Buddha Śākyamūni encouraged beings to study dharma so as to be able to liberate themselves. And this is the meaning of not allowing the precepts to degenerate. Independence on this, one can then engage in a practice of white and black karma.
So you have all received many teachings. This is the core of these teachings. Even if Buddha Śākyamūni were physically present now, there is nothing additional he could give to this. And this is why Buddha said, it is through teaching suchness that I liberate. In other words, it is, for instance, through teaching and studying the four noble truths.
Now this is, therefore, the path shared with the being of the small scope. One’s focus is on engaging even ethics, which is the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. Excuse me. Engaging in ethics, which is the practice of the 10 virtues and abandoning the 10 non virtues. Now here, the term abandonment, abandoning the 10 non virtues must be understood.
When one speaks of an abandonment at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, one means by this that one puts pressure on the nonvirtues. One does not allow them to increase, to blaze up. So some of you have wondered in the past whether one speaks of abandoning the 10 non virtues at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope. This means that one also abandons, for instance, desire at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope. And then what precisely does one abandon at the level of the past shared with the being of the middling of the great scope?
Here, one must understand that the term abandon in the level at the level of the past shared with the being of the small scope means to put pressure, literally to squeeze the head, if you wish, of the nonvirtuous deeds. And it is to be understood in terms of, for instance, the four opponent forces. As you remember, in the four opponent forces, when, for instance, one has committed a non virtuous deed among others, one generates a resolve never to engage in this deed again, never to be, if you wish, vanquished by this deed again. So let us take an example. The second nonvirtuous physical deed, the deed of stealing.
Let’s imagine, for instance, that we enter into, let’s say, a room such as this one, and there is 1,000,000 lying around unattended. Then at this point, one thinks if I were to take this money, definitely, my life would be very comfortable for the rest of my life. But the moment this desire to steal the money arises, one reflects, indeed, for the rest of my life, I will be comfortable enough. But, in future lives, as a result of having committed the non virtue of stealing, I myself will experience suffering. And then one restrains, one subdues this non virtuous impulse.
So this is the meaning of abandoning the 10 non virtuous deeds at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope. It means that one controls, one restrains, one overcomes these nonvirtuous impulses. It does not mean that one eradicates them from the root. When it is said that one abandons non virtuous deeds and engages in virtue, that is the meaning of the term abandons. Do you understand?
So, that is basically what this means. And as far as the five topics of meditation of the past shared with the being of the small scope are concerned, do you understand them? Do you know them? Some of you are new. Gishela wonders whether you’d know these topics or not.
So the precious human rebirth. And then there’s death and impermanence. Contemplation of the lower realms. Refuge in the three jewels. Yep.
And then cause and causalities in karma. Ah, good. Very good. Thank you. So when Jitsongkapa says at the end of the stanza, I, the yogi, have practiced in this way.
Those striving for liberation should do likewise. Jitsongkapa is saying that he himself has practiced in this way. And then we ourselves, at present, are mainly, functioning on the verbal level with these concepts. But what we must do is analyze carefully the terms and link them. And as we analyze these concepts and link them, the meaning will become clear.
So this is the meaning of the wisdom arisen from, thinking from within the three, the wisdom arisen from hearing, thinking, and meditation. So this is, therefore, the mode of abandonment at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Now on the path shared with the being of the middling and of the great scope, one generates respectively uncontrived definite emergence and fully characterized bodhicitta. Uncontrived definite emergence is said to be
An antidote to desire. Bodhicitta is said to be an antidote to anger. How is this possible? What is meant is that uncontrived definite emergence sees the defects or the thoughts of desire. So once one has generated, therefore, a fully characterized definite emergence, for instance, then it acts as an antidote to desire.
What do we mean by this? We mean that, the object of desire appears as very coarse to fully characterized definite emergence. As a result of this, when we have generated fully characterized definite emergence, desire dwindles within our mind. That does not mean that it is abandoned. It dwindles.
Therefore, we can say that definite emergence acts as an antidote to desire. Do you understand? So this is very clear if we look at two objects, one new and one old. And Yashir was looking for new and objects. He can’t find them here.
So let us take cars. Sticking you in an old car. If we have an old car, then we have no particular attachment to it. It’s just a car. And if it isn’t there, that’s the way it is.
But a new car is a very different affair altogether. And this is why it is said that once one has generated a fully characterized definite emergence, then, there is no attachment for any of the marvels of samsaric existence because they are all seen as transitory and impermanent. And this is why and the Lamian gurus of the past said that definite emergence is the antidote to desire, bodhicitta is the antidote to anger, and emptiness is the antidote to all afflictions. Then here we have to think, how is bodhicitta the antidote to anger? It’s very similar.
It’s a close connection. So can you give an answer? Okay. You can’t be angry if you’re cherishing others. Yes.
Very clear. You are awesome. Very clear answer. Yeah. Thank you.
And the other? Okay. Okay. So how precisely does bodhicitta act as an antidote to anger? Then we all are the same.
We all experience anger, and we experience anger mainly independence on people, on persons. Some people get angry at things, but we will set that aside. And when we experience anger with respect to a person, just how does that person appear to us? That person appears to us as pleasant or unpleasant. Obviously, that person appears as unpleasant.
Then when we have generated bodhicitta, how precisely do others appear to us? They appear to us as pleasant. We see them as relatives or children. Don’t understand. So, therefore, we must, look at this in terms of the object of anger and the object of bodhicitta.
Whether one can say that they’re opposite or not is open to question, but certainly, are not commensurate with each other. So when, therefore, fully characterized definite emergence has been generated, it acts as an antidote to desire. That means that desire is reduced. It does not mean that desire is abandoned nor that desire cannot appear. But even though it appears, it does not operate.
It is not operational. The same thing is true for a bodhicitta. Bodhicitta acts as an antidote to anger. This does not mean that anger does not arise in the mind of a bodhisattva. It certainly can arise in the mind of a bodhisattva on the path of accumulation.
Whether it can arise in the mind of a Bodhisattva on the path of preparation is open to analysis. In either case, however, this angular anger is dissimilar to our anger. They do not fall under the sway or under the control of anger. So, therefore, regarding the mode of abandonment by the antidote, So far, Geshelec has presented two modes of abandonment. The first is at the level of the path shared as a being of the small scope, an abandonment by means of controlling or subduing nonvirtuous deeds.
And the second is at the level of generating, uncontrived definite emergence or bodhicitta, which is an abandonment through understanding the defects. The third mode of, operation of the of an antidote is an antidote which leads to an abandonment without remainder. This is the most powerful antidote, literally the fiercest antidote. This occurs when the object of apprehension by the mind, which is the antidote, and the object of apprehension, which is to be abandoned, are directly contradictory. And this is the mode of abandonment of the ignorance grasping at a self by the wisdom realizing emptiness or selflessness.
And therefore, this third mode of operation of an antidote, an antidote which abandons without remainder is the mode of operation of the wisdom realizing emptiness when it acts as an antidote to the ignorance grasping at an I. This wisdom, realizing emptiness, leads to the abandonment of that ignorance without any trace of any type, without any remainder. And it is precisely for this reason that we have the numerous subdivisions of the grounds and paths in Salam because there are incremental stages during which the remainders of ignorance are abandoned. There are no such stages in the development of bodhicitta precisely for the same reason. So this is why there are five paths and 10 grounds.
It is because through the wisdom realizing emptiness, one abandons incrementally the afflictions and the seeds of the afflictions and grasping at true existence and the seeds of of grasping at true existence. Then it is not through the the development of bodhicitta that any of these are abandoned. Bodhicitta, however, is present in the backdrop or the background. So this is, therefore, why we study emptiness, and all of us have heard a lot about emptiness, but it is very difficult to actually explain, let alone understand it. Then in this respect, your translator is extraordinary because it is thanks to his presence here that we can have teachings on emptiness.
And Geshe la hopes, perhaps not initially, to explain the Prasanika Madhyamaka view, but to start by explaining emptiness in terms of dependent arising. First, causal dependent arising and then moving upwards. So as far as both definite emergence and bodhicitta are concerned, if Geshe-la were to ask you, you could probably explain quite accurately accurately what they are. When it comes to emptiness, it’s a very different matter altogether, and we would all get confused. Therefore, Geshe la has a very sincere hope to be able to explain emptiness here gradually and incrementally, and, you have a translator who can translate these topics.
Do you like emptiness? Yes. Thank you. Sorry? Okay.
Yeah. Yeah.
And, therefore, initially, although gaining a realization of emptiness might be difficult, once we receive teachings on emptiness and think carefully about it, we can see how it should be possible to gain liberation or full enlightenment. Not in this life, maybe that would be difficult, but in the future over lives. And it is at this point that the belief in past and future lives is extremely important. And therefore, even though we might not attain these states in this life, definitely, we can deposit the seeds for their attainment in this life, and that generates a great happiness, which is taught in the Dharma. Then mental unhappiness, as you all understand, arises from the afflictions.
It arises from being unsatisfied, unsatisfied with what one has. In other in other words, it arises from lack of contentment, and lack of contentment arises from desire. So once we are able to subdue the afflictions, we are also able to subdue mental unhappiness. So, therefore, we should endeavor to generate this wisdom realizing emptiness whose object is directly opposite to the object of the ignorance grasping at an I. And as you know, one can generate both a conceptual and a non conceptual realization arisen from meditation of emptiness.
This conceptual realization arisen from meditation of emptiness ushers the path of preparation and the non conceptual, the path of seeing. And Geshe la personally believes that once one has generated a conceptual wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, one has probably stopped the grasping at true existence. So now we talk about the Salam. So could you please give the five paths of the Mahāyāna? Sorry.
Yes. And, Natalie, can you, also of the Lam Rim. Could you give the five paths of the Mahāyāna? Whichever of you can give them, please give them at present. Good.
Thank you. So, therefore, once one has generated an insight focused on emptiness on a Mahāyāna path, in other words, once one has generated a conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness on a Mahāyāna path, one has entered the Mahāyāna path of preparation. Now here, because this is a mind arisen from from meditation, probably that the ignorance grasping at true existence can no longer arise. It is stopped. And the progression from the Mahāyāna path of preparation through the Mahāyāna path of meditation occurs through opposing to the ignorance which apprehends an I or a self, the wisdom realizing emptiness.
This is the direct opposite of that ignorance. So let us at present generate a motivation related to bodhicitta, and then we will have the recitation of the prayers. And and also page five number six manna offering verse one and three So whenever uncontrived conventional bodhicitta is generated within the continuum of a sentient being, that sentient being has entered the path of the Mahāyāna. Uncontrived conventional bodhicitta is the gateway to the Mahāyāna. Mhmm.
So quickly, what is the difference between the Mahāyāna path of accumulation and preparation? So what’s the difference between the Mahāyāna path of accumulation and preparation? The path of accumulation, there is no insight into emptiness. So what’s the difference between the Mahāyāna path of preparation and seeing? At the level of the path of seeing, it is a direct realization into emptiness, which is no longer a conceptual mind.
At the path of preparation, the insight into emptiness is a conceptual mind. In other words, in brief, both the Mahāyāna paths of preparation and accumulation are minds arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. The one is conceptual, the other is nonconceptual. What’s the difference between the Mahāyāna path of seeing and meditation? At the level of the path of seeing, one abandons the acquired grasping at true existence, and at the path of meditation, one abandons the innate grasping at true existence.
So what what do you mean by acquired grasping at true existence? So since you were very good, you brought the topic up. Since you brought it up, please explain it. So
Acquired grasping itself is the belief in a tenet system, any kind of tenant system. And the innate grasping itself is the belief in any kind of true existence. So, obviously and what is your second point? The innate grasping at true existence is what according to you? Any grasping at true existence.
So what is meant by a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness? Directed at everyone. Well, there’s 20 and some students in the class. Right? Okay.
It’s a difficult topic what the mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness is, initially, one must be able to formulate it verbally before gaining some type of experience. So during the meditation session, meditating on emptiness, one sees emptiness nakedly. So and that becomes a mind arisen from meditating on emptiness. So what you’re saying is when you say nakedly nakedly, you mean that this is a non conceptual realization of emptiness. Before yes.
I do. And before that, you would have a conceptual, understanding of emptiness through So during the Mahāyāna path of preparation, you have a mind which is arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. But you don’t have that naked mind arisen from an naked mind, arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. Which path are we talking about? Fabric.
Fabrication. Oh, yes. It’s still conceptual. So it’s not naked. Right?
Correct. Yes. Sorry. So what you should say is that minds arisen from meditation focused on emptiness can either be conceptual or nonconceptual. When they are conceptual, you are on the path of preparation.
When they are nonconceptual, you are on the path of seeing all above. So what is this mind risen from meditation? So Geshe-la would like to know what we mean when we say mind arisen from meditation. What’s the meaning? Lily.
Lily in the back. Yeah. I’m just guessing. I think it might be after you have remembered the term, so the or the idea, So the wisdom from hearing. And then when you actually get at the meaning and you understand the meaning, that’s thinking.
And then when you have the wisdom arisen from meditation, it’s when you’ve applied the mind to that object which has been which the mind has has got at directly, and you then apply some insight. And when you start, to analyze and put the insight in with the calm abiding, then you have the mind arisen from meditation. Okay. Okay. Yeah.
Good. Good. The good idea. The meaning is there. Good idea.
This difficult topic, this one, what the mind arisen from meditation is, for instance, to generate uncontrived bodhicitta, it is said that the uncontrived bodhicitta needs as a base or a support in mind arisen from meditation to become present within the mind stream, likewise, for the realization of emptiness. Oh, I just okay. Just online. Was just thinking, could it be between the two paths as an example? And you can tell me if you think the example’s wrong because I I want to know that.
If you went to Tuesday night class and you studied the Chittamatra School looking at the aggregates and you you conceptually meditated on this subject, pairing them back until you had a view of emptiness that was conceptual by, you know, thinking about the just the different different levels from consciousness to the the layer of vision on it. And you just kept working it back and meditating on it, and then eventually you attained that naked view of emptiness. And by doing that, then you would have moved on to the path of seeing from the path of meditation. As far as Cittamātra is concerned, if you gain an experience of the Yajna Vajnana, you’re definitely at the end of the path of meditation. Okay.
Thank you. So stop here tonight. You know? Thank you. Just a reminder, there is a short teaching in English by Geshe la on Sunday morning and and then a shared lunch.
If anybody’s interested in some potatoes for planting on the
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.