5,122 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. A question and answer session on the eleven virtuous mental factors, the danger that fear of death can turn toward worldly aims, and the five degenerations. The teacher explains that death must be taken seriously as a continuation of mind, that reflecting on death helps counter the eight worldly concerns, and that practice spans the small, middling and great scopes together.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 8ab04f6d-d9d9-4768-b1c3-3f784c2cc096
Words: 5,118
So this is from one of the FPMT handouts, I think. But it gives this list of mental factors. We have some additional notes added as well. So there’s alternate translations to some of these terms so that also can be useful. What we were talking about this morning was this box here.
It’s got virtuous factors in bracket 11. Everyone see that? So they’re the 11 virtuous mental factors. So any virtue will be one of these or a combination of those. They’re natural virtuous states.
Faith, shame, embarrassment, non attachment, non hatred, non ignorance, effort, pliancy, conscientiousness, equanimity, non harmfulness. That last one, non harmfulness, is also ahimsa. Does everyone recognize ahimsa? Yeah. It’s one of Gandhi’s slogans, ahimsa, non violence, also it’s translated as.
Which means compassion. That’s the mental factor of compassion there. And non hatred is love. So there’s love and compassion there. So it’s good to think about this list because whenever they’re present, our mind is virtuous.
Any one of them is present, our mind is mixed to some degree with virtue. Okay, so we’ve got a question and answer session at present. Just if anything has come up from the morning session, or in fact if you’ve got anything on this sheet. Just towards the end of the last part of our conversation, you were talking about the importance of looking after the body Yep. Choosing balance.
And I just wondered what you thought that those practitioners that just ate nettles and completely ignored their bodies were thinking. Did they have access to these teachings? Often practitioners, especially those sort of monks or nuns that traditionally survive on begging and so forth. Often they don’t have much choice. They just hope that their virtuous practice will bring food.
People will come and make offerings of food. This is often how it happened in Tibet. A person might go up into the mountains and find a cave and start meditating in a cave. They might go with a sack full of barley, to begin with roasted barley flour. And they just live on that, making puck, mixing a bit of water, just having that two or three times a day.
And then they might have a sponsor that brings up food, But you know, this might get snowed in, they can’t get up there for a few weeks. Doing a fasting retreat as well as the ordinary retreat. So lay have a bit more choice. Sorry? So lay people have a bit more choice about what they eat.
Because did the Buddha ultimately die of food poisoning? No, you can’t die of food poisoning. With the Vajra body, not really possible. There was one layperson by the name of Chunda who offered a meal to the Buddha and in the meal there was pork And the pork apparently was a bit off. This is a couple of months before he died.
And at that point he did manifest getting a bit sick. But he took the meal anyway for the benefit of the donor. And he then manifested some signs of having a stomach upset. But it was all really because he had the Vajra body, it was all a bit of a show. Because at that stage he’s beyond being affected by physical conditions.
So for the benefit of those around, you know, to eat properly and so forth. But it’s a good question. In the end, a good practitioner is not really concerned about the food. They will practice, they will choose just to focus on virtue, the practice of virtue, with confidence that that alone will sustain them and create the conditions for them to be given food when it’s needed. We’re not at that level ourselves of course.
I’ve got a couple of questions about the 11 virtuous mental factors. If that’s okay to ask too. You used the term that they’re natural virtuous mental factors. So does that mean that they’re always there but just kind of covered up by ignorance? Or what’s the kind of natural aspect of it?
No, they’re not always there. And often it takes a lot of effort on our part to generate them. Such as love and compassion generally takes a lot, a vast amount of effort for us because there’s many people we don’t like. And generally it’s hard for us to generate love for those we don’t like. For instance, so we have to generate them anew all the time.
Also, they’re regarded as natural because their very nature is virtuous. Their very substance, their very essence is virtuous. Why is it virtuous? Because they have the nature of not harming other beings. So as soon as faith arises, the whole idea of harming, in a way, is counted.
Faith doesn’t harm. Same with shame and embarrassment, so on. So they’re naturally virtuous. Virtue itself means, in Tibetan I think it’s stated, that which is white in aspect and produces a pleasant result. A pleasant outcome.
So anything white in aspect White in color, white. White in aspect. And produces a pleasant outcome, pleasant effect is what is meant by virtue. So they’re naturally that. Thank you.
And also you spoke earlier about the faith. Yes. A powerful virtuous factor, faith in the virtuous qualities of a Buddha. Would faith in the virtuous qualities of one’s spiritual teacher be counted as Absolutely, yes, yes. One’s virtuous spiritual friend is like the ambassador of the Buddha.
So it’s dealing exactly with the same thing. Thank you. Jumper. So I was thinking that death is a very strong motivating factor. But that it may not necessarily motivate us towards the dharma.
It might motivate us towards more worldly things if we don’t have another motivation. And I’m just wondering if you could speak a bit about that so that it, yeah, there’s sort of a danger that Death could be a motivating factor for worldly things. To indulge even more in the eight worldly dharmas. Yeah, it could be a condition perhaps to form a bucket list, the thought that one is definitely gonna die at some point, better to get True. But in that case it’s not serving its full potential.
It’s almost It’s, you know, like really not respecting the reality of death. It’s almost trivialising death then. I’m wondering what it is we need in addition to the motivating factor of death to drive us towards the dharma. So I guess in the lamrim they talk about the lower realm, fear of the lower realms and so maybe it’s partly contingent on past and future lives but also, I mean, yeah, I’m just wondering what other factors because definitely people have fear of death and it gets them very motivated to maybe work very hard in their business and be very successful or, you know, it could be, you know yeah. Well, probably in our culture people don’t think very much about death.
It’s sort of hidden and people don’t think about it philosophically. It’s more like taking care of death is making sure you’ve got a good funeral plan. It’s going to cover all the expenses with the funeral director, cover the caskets, know, expenses for the papers. And then the person’s died, okay they’re gone, who knows where they go, doesn’t matter. You know, we get on with our life after that.
That sort of attitude is really not, what can one say really understanding death at all. It’s like dismissing it, trivializing it, dismissing it by trivializing it. It’s a huge question that is the fourth of the four human sufferings the worst of the four in a sense. It’s something that can be dealt with. If we have a problem in our society, we put it into the too hard basket and ignore it.
As if they say: Well, I can’t really deal with it. If there’s a God or something else, well, maybe they will sort it out for me. I can’t deal with it. I’ll ignore it. And maybe anyway, at death, I cease to exist and so everything is taken care of anyway.
So all of this is a very unskillful way of dealing with a central issue. It’s trivializing it. So then death can’t for a person who has that type of attitude, death can’t really help a great deal. If you trivialize it I mean the same with anyone. If we trivialize another person, we’re ignoring them.
You know, we’re sort of trying to justify dismissing their existence and not giving them credit or belittling them. So that’s not the way to approach other people. It’s not the way to approach death itself. Now, unfortunately, in our society this is how death is treated, right? We’re so, you know, used to this that we almost take that as the standard approach to death.
It’s probably the worst way that one can approach death. And it borders it is actually, therefore, wrong view. Now in this list here we have I wonder if it’s here. The root afflictions. Okay, if we look onto the one the group under the if you got the sheet there?
If you look at the root afflictions, you’ll notice that there’s five to begin with: desire, anger, pride, ignorance, doubt, afflicted view. Afflicted view is what we’re looking at here. The view of the transitory collection or the view of the perishable composite. View holding to an extreme. Conception of bad The last one, E perverse view.
Now that one there is what we’re talking about. That perverse view there is lokta in Tibetan or wrong view. So that’s the view that the law of causation doesn’t pervade. Not just the law of causation, the inner law of causation. Right?
Now, what we mean by the internal law of causation is really that the mind itself, and especially the ethical what can one say? Value of the various minds and mental factors we have is extremely important. And they have outcomes. Wrong view asserts that happiness doesn’t come from practicing ethics. Or it asserts that unhappiness doesn’t come about from bad conduct, bad ethics and so forth.
And in fact, the internal law of causation that’s associated with karma can be dismissed. And that is what is done if we underestimate death. If we say: Oh, death is not important. Right? It’s What can one say?
Underestimating the law of causation applied to the mind itself and the fact that our virtue does produce happiness for us in future lives. And our non virtue produces unhappiness for us in future lives. Beyond death, death doesn’t end this process in the least. Right? But if we dismiss death and say Oh well, I don’t need to worry about that.
Everything ends at death. This is the worst possible type of view that we can have. It undermines the entire spiritual and ethical practice of a being. Am I being too hard on that type of view? Do you think?
That’s good. Yeah, I mean to think of others as we approach death is a very good thing, to help others. That’s really dealing with compassion and love for other beings, so it’s generating virtue. It’s going to have a very positive outcome for ourselves. But all of that rests on the understanding that we continue beyond death.
That death is not just something that stops our existence completely. So here, of course, we’re talking a lot about death at present, but we’re talking about it from the perspective that death is certainly not the end. Death is just another doorway. But we talk about death in order to wean ourselves off just thinking about this life alone. Otherwise, the way that death is thought about in our society is often very unskilful.
It’s either ignored or belittled. Right? So that’s not how you deal with an important topic. It’s very bad for the people in our community to think in that way. So jumper, got a couple of questions but I can do one at a time.
So the first one, I was just thinking about the three scopes after yesterday’s teaching. And I I’ve always thought of the three scopes as you go through the small scope then you progress to the second scope and then you progress to the third scope. But having thought about the teaching yesterday, I sort of, I realized that well that it seems that you actually don’t just do one and then you go to the next one. You actually finish one and then you incorporate that into the next one. So really a practitioner of the great scope would be a practitioner of all the scopes.
Yes. That’s why they’re called the shared practice of the small scope. The shared practice. Because a being of great scope is also practicing the small scope mixed with the motivation for practicing the great scope. And they are practised together.
Each incorporated into the other. Because as we practise a small scope we can have the aspiration to become a being of the middling and then the great scope. That’s right. So it works both ways, backwards and forwards. It does and that’s how it often is in our practise.
We practise a bit here and then we come and practise a bit over there and then we realise that we need to focus now on this. It’s a bit like putting up a tent. We lay a bit of ground, we sort of try and flatten it out a bit and we un roll the whole thing and then we try and find the pegs and we lose the poles and we realise that we’ve to put a peg in here first but then we’ll have to put a pole over here. So the small scope, the medium scope and the great scope practises are, in a way, influencing each other. And we ourselves, according to our own karma and predisposition, we need maybe special emphasis over here at one time and over there at another.
We need to focus more on renunciation at present, more on the meditation on death at present and so forth. So this, you know, is something that we need to just, in a way, keep a check on and try as best we can. And you know, get advice from other people, Well this is good to practise and take that on board. But all the practises of the spiritual path are included in the small, medium and great scope practises. Jumper, what are the five degenerations?
Okay, look I’ve got a list of them here. Actually I’ve a list that’s taken from this Vinaya text by Jetsunpa, Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen. And right at the beginning of the Vinaya text he talks about the 12 acts of the Buddha. And when he’s talking about the first act of the Buddha he’s talking about the Buddha in his previous life and his name was Dampa Tokar in Tibetan, but in Sanskrit it’s Svetakutu. Bit of a tongue twister.
Svetaketu, which means white banner. And he was the regent in Tuśita. So anyway, at that time, he observed the five degenerations that existed in places like this earth here. So the five degenerations, the first is the degeneration of time. So that means here the existence of dispute and disagreement on the planet.
It’s quite widespread. Dispute is seen to exist everywhere. Then the second one, the degeneration of lifespan. The lifespan itself has been declining for thousands of years. So from the point of view of Abhidharma, the lifespan at one stage was limitless.
Then it came down to eighty thousand years and then from eighty thousand years it’s been decreasing one year every century until it’s gotten to one hundred years at the time of the Buddha. And normally Buddhas do not appear when the lifespan is less than one hundred years. Śākyamūni Buddha, out of great compassion, came right at this period out of a compassion for being such as ourselves. Even though the conditions are terrible. There’s wars, rumors of wars.
But in order to help beings of this particular time, he manifested. So the degeneration of time is the first, then the degeneration of lifespan, then the third one, the degeneration of view. We’ve just been talking about view. Degeneration of view means the increase of wrong view. Reincarnation doesn’t exist, that the law of cause and effect does not fully pervade the mind, that virtue doesn’t produce happiness.
This is completely wrong view. So at this point, we’re suffering the degeneration of view because in the West, which should be quite enlightened, doesn’t know how to posit ethics. And so forth. So this degeneration of view means that wrong view is very deeply embedded and there is difficulty in transforming wrong view into correct view or valid view. And then we have the degeneration of affliction.
So these degenerations really talk about the increase of. So an enduring strong sense of self is what is meant here by the degeneration of affliction. So the sense of self is really strong amongst people. That also implies pride. People have a lot of pride.
Less humility, more pride. And we see that. This sense of individual, you know, don’t know, strong sense of individual pride. It endures. It is the degeneration of affliction.
And then we have the degeneration of beings themselves. So that means the difficulty of taming the mind stream and the senses. So we live in a period where the mind streams of beings are not tamed. Their senses are not tamed. They are addicted and attached to the objects of the senses.
And their mind streams are coarsened by that unruly, untamed. So that’s a pretty standard presentation of the five degenerations. But on the other hand, it’s a very good time to practice. When the conditions are difficult, very good to practice. To be able to endure bad conditions with a good motivation is excellent.
In a way, it’s the best time to practice. When the conditions are good, it’s too easy. But when the conditions are bad, then we’re really tested. And there’s really plenty of opportunities for patience. We should be rejoicing in this, actually.
In the easy times it’s hard to find anyone that’s unpleasant. So it’s hard to generate patience. No need to generate patience. It’s all too easy. Everyone’s very pleasant to each other.
Don’t call each other names. Keep each other presents all the time. Nice food, pat them on the back, pat them on the head. Look after them. So patience is more difficult.
Now we need patience. So now’s a good time to be on the planet. Yep. I have two questions. The first is a little technical.
The second is practical. I noticed vigilance isn’t on the list anywhere. Would that fall within conscientiousness? Yes, yes. I think so, yes.
The reason I asked that question is because practice seems to begin with the question what is the state of my mind? And seems the purpose of recollecting death and impermanence is to prompt or arouse that question in the mind. Once that question appears to the mind, what is the application of recalling death and impermanence as an antidote to an affliction? Or is its job done once you’ve asked that question? It’s partially done, but we have to keep on maintaining an awareness of death.
Because the attachment and so forth are so persistent. So we need just to check ourselves, when a strong attachment arises. To find any method of just taking the wind out of the sails of attachment, greed and the rest. And one way we can take the wind out of the sails is by just thinking about death. So it’s something we can bring to mind regularly.
I definitely am going to die. And so forth. Those three. So it’s good in the beginning, middle and end. So just to bring our mind back to them.
The work is in the beginning and it also continues as we contemplate or just go about our daily business to keep a mindfulness of death is good for us. It just sobers us up a little bit and cuts our expectations down a little bit. If we’re not careful, our expectations blossom and, you know It’s like with money. We get $100 and we’re happy with that but like a thousand. We get a thousand, that’s not bad but I like 10,000.
And so on. So the eight worldly dharmas start off with just a little feeling there and then the next minute our head is completely turned and suddenly a day later we might realise, What was I doing? What was I thinking? Bringing death to mind regularly just helps to keep us in check. Keep the worldly dharmas in check.
My second question is about the eight worldly concerns. So was thinking about those again as well. And I was thinking about know so gain and loss for example that we have craving for all of those things that we see as positive worldly concerns. But then the negative concerns I thought seems to be like a mixture of both aversion and craving. Because it’s like we crave not to have that thing that we don’t want but we also have aversion to it as well.
Yep. So is there some way of using that as some sort of helpful guide or, not really sure where I’m going with this question jumper but that’s where I’m sort of at with that. Yeah, true. We tend to be attached to what? To gain.
We’re attached to fame. And we’re attached to repute, having a good reputation. We’re attached to those things. And they’re always sort of arising for us. At the same time, we don’t like loss.
We don’t like blame. Anyone criticizing us, we don’t like. And then also with loss of reputation, with ill repute or getting a bad reputation. So in a way it’s a bit like we have examples of being attracted to things and examples of being repulsed by things. So those form six of the eight worldly dharmas.
If we are attracted or are attached to those first three, then we’re being swept away by three of the eight worldly dharmas. And also if we repulsed by the second set of three, then we’re also affected by the eight worldly dharmas. So we just need to check on ourselves. What am I annoyed with? What do I resent?
And probably it’s something to do with, you know, like a loss of something, some sort of blame, some sort of loss of repute. And if I am swept away by attachment, it’s probably something to do with gain of something. You know, the possibility of gaining something and I’m overwhelmed by that And I don’t see it as a bad thing or I don’t see it as a potential danger for me. I see it as an opportunity. Oh yeah, a thousand dollars, $10,000, a new house, whatever.
So being attracted by gain, attracted by praise, attracted by one’s reputation increasing, one’s celebrity increasing or these sorts of things. So, here one of the things we’re trying to do is just check on our mind stream regularly, you know, what issues are there? Am I attached to anything? Is my desire being aroused for anything? And just check, is it one of the eight worldly dharmas that I’m dealing with here?
If so, then I should take a step back and maybe reflect on death. But we need to continuously check. At present, tend to be really very addicted to things and that addiction often has associated corollary or something associated with it, the dislike of losing it. And our attachments really overwhelm us. And because of the attachment we can do all manner of things, we can generate all types of mental state that are really very painful for us.
So this reflection on death here as an antidote to the eight worldly concerns is to protect us from being swept away by the eight worldly concerns. And in fact, in the traditional presentation of the negative emotions, have the four floods, like the flood of attachment. And it’s just, you know, when an attractive object presents itself to our mind, we suddenly lose all, you know, inhibition and, Yes, I want that. That object carries us away. Our attachment to the object carries us away.
We have such hope in that object that’s going to solve my problems, I’m going be so happy, etc. And any thought that Oh no, you can’t have that makes us annoyed, you know, and so on. All of this What can one say? It’s not good for us. They’re just contaminated objects of this life.
They’re not the cause of happiness. And what are the other three floods? Ignorance, view and anger I think. Anger, hatred. Just a minute, think I’ve got a list of them here.
Right, the four floods are: desire, existence. So it’s really attachment to desire realm objects and then attachment to higher realms. Two types of attachment, two floods and then ignorance and view. So I think I mentioned anger. Anger is not included there.
Two types of attachment. Attachment at this level and higher levels, God realms. Ignorance, we can be carried away by ignorance. And views such as wrong view. Jumper, going back to the virtuous factors again.
I understand shame, but embarrassment sometimes can be an attachment to ego. For example, often when we’re in class in the teachings, Talking about the virtuous factors, so shame I understand. But I’m wondering about embarrassment because I think it may be ego at times. The example I’m thinking about is in the teachings when we ask a question and there’s this feeling of terror. And if we ask a question and it’s absolutely ridiculous and the answer comes back and we’re totally embarrassed.
But in fact, isn’t that clinging to ego? It can be, yeah. That’s not quite what’s meant here. This is a very particular type of embarrassment. So really both of these really refer to a sense of shame and a sense of embarrassment about our own actions.
The actions that we commit ourselves, about the negative actions we could potentially commit. So having a sense of shame is a sense of shame that prevents us from committing negative actions for our own sake, for what I would think of myself if I committed it. So if I don’t jump up and hit someone because I would be ashamed of myself if I did that. I’d regret it. So that sense of shame is virtuous.
It’s by its very nature virtuous. It’s by its very nature, while it’s in our mind stream, white karmic seeds that produce happiness for us in future. So it’s virtuous. Sense of embarrassment is not committing myself, not committing non virtuous actions out of the fear or the concern for what other people might think if I did so. That’s the sense of embarrassment that’s meant here.
I don’t commit a negative action because I would offend other people in the room. It would be a bad example for them. I have this sense of maintaining virtue out of a sense of respect in a way for other beings. So that sense of shame and sense of embarrassment are very virtuous. We need to have them present at all times.
In general, we do. We stop ourselves from stealing someone’s pen or doing something we shouldn’t do. And that’s out of a sense of shame and embarrassment. And so we need to have them there at all times. They’re very good for us.
This other one about being embarrassed if we suddenly the spotlight’s on us and we’ve to say something and we don’t like being put in such a situation and we get annoyed and so forth. That’s different than Yep. Yes. Being traumatized by someone. We might get stage fright and just flee.
Yes. Our death probably our lifespan is pretty much determined because the karma that creates this life has already been set, it’s fixed at the time of the death process and it generates the intermediate state as well as the birth arising from the intermediate state. So the lifespan, the type of rebirth and so on is set. The exact type of death there’s probably a little bit of room to play there depending on causes and conditions. But it’s maybe, you know, reasonably firm on just how it will happen because people with clairvoyance are often able to see the circumstances of a person’s death.
No, it’s from a previous life. It’s not this life. It’s either the previous life or could be any life even prior to that. Would that be affected by, like we do things like long life pujas and white Mañjuśrī practices and things like that or is that just for higher level practitioners to influence the karma? Yeah, that’s a good question.
There’s a little bit of room to move there about extending one’s period of life or maybe purifying conditions that may arise that would influence the time of death. Not a huge amount but there’s a bit of room to move. But it depends also on the virtue of the person but not a huge amount of room to move. But still, these practices to extend life or the long life of one’s teacher and so forth can also influence the quality of the life that they have as well. The sickness is less.
There’s a little bit of room there about the lifespan. It depends on actually which point of view you’re looking at it from as well. And also whether you’re talking about the sūtra vehicle or the tantra vehicle. And in the Tantric vehicle it’s possible you know, to extend one’s life according to certain tantric practices. Just quickly, the four floods that you mentioned, is that the same as the four currents in the three principal aspects of the path?
The four currents could be. I’m not sure, that might be a I think they’re called Chuo in Tibetan the four Chuos. Chu means water and Chuo means like a stream or a rivulet or a flood. So it could be the four currents as well. So I’m assuming it’s the same term there.
Okay, look, we’ll just have a break at this point. Have a cup of tea.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- five degenerations
- The degenerations that occur as human beings evolve over the eon of existence; they are: the degeneration of disturbing thoughts, of lifespan, of time, of view and of sentient beings. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
- virtuous mental factors kushala-chaitta (Skt); ge wä sem jung (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, the virtuous mental factors are positive qualities of the mind that counteract the non-virtuous mental factors - the root delusions and secondary delusions. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.