TBI Recordings – 12102016Lamrim 2

1 h 39 min · 4,227 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - 12102016Lamrim 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains bodhicitta as a mind with two aspirations, enlightenment for the sake of others, and distinguishes it from love and great compassion. It covers how definite emergence becomes great compassion, which in turn supports bodhicitta, and the aspiring and engaging divisions. It then begins the six perfections with generosity, covering giving material things, dharma and protection from fear. The session closes with a question and answer period.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 40m

UUID: 3967b36d-1b6d-4428-8d9c-f438ed37848b

Words: 4,223

So as says in his concise Lam Rim, the Garland of Realizations, generating the mind, in other words, conventional bodhicitta, is the central pillar of the Mahāyāna. The meaning of this verse is that generating the mind of bodhicitta is like the life of an individual. It is what is central to the individual. So, here, there are numerous quotes and, scriptural passages which praise Bodhicitta and its qualities, but it is not, sufficient to, gain conviction in the qualities of Bodhicitta. One must also understand its nature and its aspect.

And here, indeed, one praises greatly, great compassion, love, bodhicitta, but, it is insufficient merely to praise it. One must gain an understanding. And you all do understand that understanding what bodhicitta is does not mean that one has it. So here, it is not sufficient, therefore, to understand the meaning of bodhicitta. One must also wish to generate it within one’s mind stream.

And as Śāntideva says in Bodhisattvacharyavatara, having generated bodhicitta within one’s mind stream, one is counted among the signs of the conquerors. And what suffering is there? So it is insufficient to talk about love, great compassion, the supreme resolve, and bodhicitta. One must understand their nature and then generate them. And here, it is critical to understand the differences.

Otherwise, if one hasn’t studied carefully and when one meditates on bodhicitta, one is actually thinking that one’s meditating on love. If one meditates on love, one is thinking one’s meditating on great compassion, then the results will not arise. So there are differences, precise differences between love, great compassion, the supreme resolve, bodhicitta, and one must know these differences. Then mere prayer, folding one’s hands in veneration is not what we do here. We study.

So, here, what is bodhicitta? Bodhicitta is a mind consciousness. Now it is not sufficient to have understood what bodhicitta is to have generated bodhicitta. What do we mean when we say that we generate bodhicitta? We mean that we turn the mind into bodhicitta.

We transform the mind in bodhicitta. Having understood what bodhicitta means does not mean we have generated bodhicitta within our mind stream. Then regarding the view, in other words, the wisdom which realizes emptiness, the mode of study and the mode of generation is rather different. What does one mean when one says one has generated the view within one’s mind stream? It means that one has understood the meaning of emptiness.

Once one has understood the meaning of emptiness, one has generated the view. So at present, I believe that you understand the meaning precisely of love, great compassion, the supreme resolve, and bodhicitta. So I would like to ask you at present to give me the meaning or the nature of bodhicitta, but please briefly and precisely. Just speak. Yeah.

Those answers are adequate. The point to, be clear about is that Bodhicitta is a mind with twin aspirations. The first aspiration is for the sake of others. The second aspiration is the aspiration wishing for full enlightenment. So as was said, one wishes for full enlightenment for the sake of others.

So some have said that if either of the two wishes is absent, this is not bodhicitta. Both wishes are must be present. Wishing merely for full and utter enlightenment is not bodhicitta. One must wish for it for the sake of others. So his holiness at Dalai Lama, when he explains bodhicitta, always explains it as the mind with twin aspirations.

As Maitreya says in Abhishamaya Lankara, generating the mind is for the sake of others to strive for full and utter enlightenment. The first verse here, generating the mind is for the sake of others refers to the first aspiration for the sake of others striving for full and utter enlightenment. The second verse refers to the second aspiration. And, therefore, conventional bodhicitta is this special mind which is defined in Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra as a mind with two aspirations. The first is referred to by the first verse.

Generating the mind is for the sake of others. That’s the first verse. And the second is striving for full and utter enlightenment. That’s the second aspiration. And therefore, in the light of this stanza of Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, a mind which is striving for full and utter enlightenment alone is not or does not qualify as the special mind of bodhicitta because such a mind is, for instance, present within solitary realizers on the path of accumulation and of preparation.

And solitary realizers in the path of of accumulation and preparation could not have bodhicitta because they are not bodhisattvas. Likewise, merely striving for the sake of others does not qualify such a mind as bodhicitta because, such a mind would, for instance, include great compassion, and great compassion is the substantial cause of bodhicitta. As Maitreya says, I assert that its root is compassion. Do you understand? That, this I would like to suggest is a good definition of bodhicitta, a special mind endowed with the two aspirations.

You know what the two aspirations are, aspiring for full and utter enlightenment for the sake of others. Then check, your own mind whether such a state of mind is present within yourselves or not. And this definition is something I would suggest that you retain or write down if you cannot retain it. It is perhaps unnecessary to write everything down, but the essential should be.

Then, if you were to write everything I said, you would fill, numerous pages and might not have the time to read them when you get back home. Instead, I would suggest that you note the essential points like this definition and then reflect on it, when you are back home. For this reason, conventional bodhicitta is said to be the life of the Mahāyāna, just as, the life force is what sustains a person. Since it is the presence or the absence of, conventional bodhicitta within the mind stream, which determines whether one is a Mahāyāna practitioner or not. Then here, one must examine carefully because war indeed in Buddhist scriptures and monastic textbooks, it is said that hearers and solitary realizers do not have great compassion or great love within their mind stream.

There is actually very few good reasons to assert this. So please answer quickly. What is the difference between conventional bodhicitta and great compassion? Brief answers. Okay.

That is very good. It is a sign that one’s understanding is clear if one is able to formulate things clearly. If one is unable to formulate things clearly, then there are doubts. So here, having understood what bodhicitta is, we must generate it within our mind stream. And as I explained previously, understanding the definition is not the same thing as generating bodhicitta within one’s mind stream.

So here to meditate on bodhicitta, we must meditate on a mind which has two aspects, and it is contingent on how well we understand these two aspects whether we are able to generate bodhicitta or not. So these aspects must be clear. And therefore, Bodhicitta is a mind which has two objects of observation. One is full and utter enlightenment, and the other is for the sake of all sentient beings. So now if we analyze the twin aspirations, which underlie Bodhicitta, the aspiration which is a wishing for the sake of others finds its cause in great compassion.

Great compassion is its substantial cause. And in turn, uncontrived definite emergence is the specific cause of great compassion. Now both uncontrived definite emergence and great compassion are conceptions. So, uncontrived definite emergence is the special, cause of great compassion. Because uncontrived definite emergence reflect arises when one reflects on the fact that one sinks within the mud of psychic existence under the power of afflictions such as anger and so forth, which beset all of us.

Now when, one generates definite emergence and then starts extending it to others, one, two, three at a time, it turns into great compassion. Therefore, definite emergence is the special substantial cause of great compassion. So in your opinion So in your opinion, since definite emergence is the cause of great compassion, once great compassion has been generated within the mind, has definite emergence been evacuated from the mind? Has it disappeared? So it does not prevent great compassion, does it?

All of the definite emergence has become great compassion. Mhmm. Exactly. 100%. You know?

So there are numerous steps, however, between definite emergence and great compassion, and these are not generated easily. The key, however, is to keep in mind that definite emergence is a special substantial cause of great compassion. Then great compassion is the specific cause of conventional bodhicitta. So once conventional bodhicitta has been generated, has great compassion turned, entered into conventional bodhicitta or not? Laurence.

Yes. Who? Yes. Okay. Another?

Yes. Oh, yeah. Yeah. You’re saying that basically once great, bodhicitta has been generated, great compassion has if if you want entered or dissolved into bodhicitta. Right?

Mhmm. Another? So think for yourselves. What’s become the mainstream? What do you mean by it’s become the mind stream?

Okay. So when bodhicitta has been generated, it is not the case that great compassion dissolves into it or enters into it. Instead, both remain and as is said indeed, to increase the power of one’s Bodhicitta, one trains in great compassion over and over again. So in this respect, the relation between great compassion and Bodhicitta is different from that between definite emergence and great compassion. Definite emergence transforms into great compassion.

Great compassion, however, and bodhicitta remain separately. Take an example, let us take the case of the sprouting of a grain of rice. For a grain of rice to sprout into a rice seedling, numerous causes and conditions are necessary. The grain of rice is a substantial cause of the rice seedling. But in addition, one requires cooperative conditions such as water, manure and so forth, which will cause this to occur.

Likewise, for the arrival of great compassion, numerous causes and conditions are necessary. The rise of Bodhicitta. Excuse me.

So, bodhicitta and great compassion depend on each other. The more powerful the bodhicitta, the more powerful the great compassion which underlies it. The more powerful the great compassion, the more powerful the bodhicitta which arises from it. So this covers the explanation of the nature of bodhicitta. Now regarding the subdivisions of bodhicitta, they have already been explained.

There is a twofold subdivision of bodhicitta into aspiring and engaging bodhicitta. Aspiring is bodhicitta is that, uncontrived bodhicitta which is present before one has taken bodhisattva vows. When having generated uncontrived bodhicitta, on top of that one takes bodhisattva vows, One will have generated engaging bodhicitta. So probably everyone in this room at present has bodhisattva vows, then it is doubtful that anyone has uncontrived bodhicitta. When uncontrived bodhicitta will eventually have been generated, then since we have bodhisattva vows, we will also gain engaging bodhicitta.

So once one has generated uncontrived, in other words, stable bodhicitta within one’s mind stream, then probably one qualifies as having generated aspiring bodhicitta. This, however, is insufficient to qualify for having generated engaging bodhicitta. Engaging bodhicitta means that, for instance, if we refer to the 7,000,000,000 or 8,000,000,000 human beings in the world, one takes the resolve to work for them. One starts or engages working for them, helping them. Then to take an example, it’s like traveling to India.

First one generates a wish to go to India, but one actually has to go to India. Once one starts going, then that is engaging bodhicitta. So at this point, once one has generated engaging bodhicitta, one’s goal is the attainment of the two bodies of a fully enlightened being, the form and the truth body. And, to attain these, one needs respectively the two collections, a collection of, method and wisdom, which must be accumulated inseparably. Then with the wish to accumulate the causes for these two bodies, one starts engaging in practice.

What is this practice? That of the six perfections. But when, you have time, it is very helpful to, become habituated to by reflection to the progression of the path from the path shared as being of the small scope to that of the middling scope and eventually to that of the being of the great scope. And when one generates this aspiring bodhicitta, then at that point, one says to oneself, it’s just not appropriate to remain like that. You’ve got to get to work.

You’ve got to start working for others. That is engaging bodhicitta. So then it is very helpful to think in this way. And when one studies, one understands really this progression, and one thinks, my goodness, how nice it would be, how marvelous it would be to be a Bodhisattva. This is how it must feel and so forth.

Now there is a reason and important differences in the sequence of the six perfections starting with generosity and ending with wisdom. When one studies, one one should ask oneself, well, why do the six perfections start with generosity? Why don’t they start with wisdom? Or why don’t they start with forbearance? There are important reasons for which the presentation starts with generosity and follows a specific sequence.

So at present, once one has understood the definition of bodhicitta, the nature of bodhicitta, one reflects on its causes, its special causes, such as great love and great compassion. And when one reflects in this way, a certain feeling will arise, an inner sensation. Then this is not bodhicitta, but eventually, although it is not easy, one will be able to generate it. It is not the case that there is someone who does who studies who is unable to generate Bodhicitta eventually. Then, study is something, which is imparted from the outside, but practice is entirely up to ourselves.

We have the strength to practice or we don’t. We do or we don’t. Then regarding bodhicitta, bodhicitta is a state of mind where others are close to us. And as a result of this, we feel very close to them. When we generate a state of mind where others are far away from us, then we become very small and narrow minded.

And, therefore, this is how one should proceed. Initially, one has the sense that others are far removed from oneself. But then through reflecting, one can see that the difficulties I have, others have. The problems I have, others have. The afflictions I have, others others have.

And then in our own case, basically, once the, suffering of food and clothing has been eliminated, the main suffering is mental. Then probably in this temple, no one experiences suffering, due to hunger or poor clothing. So the main suffering is mental. And the root of this suffering is the afflictions within our mind rooted in ignorance, but this is something others experience as well. Then this closeness towards others, this is something which we must experience when we meet others, not when we are all by ourselves thinking about others at a distance.

Then you can imagine if the world was filled with people who felt close to to us to each other, just how nice such a world would be. Otherwise, we’re in a world which is gonna blow up. Then what is important is to have a vast mind, a broad mind, not a small narrow mind. At present, therefore, let us think on the fact that once we generate Bodhicitta, we will have generated a mind which wishes to benefit others and just how pleasant this would be. We should open up the prayer book, page one.

We shall play pray make a prayer. One, b, two, three, four, also page five, number six, Mandala offering, first one, and three.

Page five. So now within the presentation of the six perfections, the first perfection is the perfection of generosity. Now what is the nature or the definition of generosity? Generosity is a mind of giving, which when something is given to another party is not stained in any way by avarice. Therefore, the nature of giving is as follows.

It is a mind of generosity, which whenever material object is given to another is not stained by avarice or by desire. Then generosity subdivided the perfection of generosity subdivided into three, giving things, giving dharma, and giving fearlessness. Now within the nature of, generosity, which is, we said was a mind of giving, which is unstained by avarice, or desire, probably being stained by avarice or desire play applies principally to the first subdivision of generosity, the giving of material things, and, probably not to the second two categories. Then when one engages in such activities of giving, such as giving material things, and, one’s mind is unstained by, desire or avarice, one accumulates, vast waves of merit. Then, the recipient of such deeds of generosity, can be a human being or for that matter, an animal.

It is, however, important when one performs deeds of generosity that these be done in a respectful and suitable fashion, not motivated by anger, but giving nobly to another. Then this is for the generosity of giving material things. Regarding the second subdivision of the perfection of generosity, giving dharma, this does not necessarily have to occur formally. For instance, when one teaches philosophy, in other words, Buddhist philosophy or gives Buddhist teachings, it can also occur during conversation when one imparts dharma to another person. It definitely occurs in this context.

It can also occur when one gives an introduction to dharma. And here, probably avarice is not an issue, but more the, arrogance or the pride which thinks, I am teaching others. Then in my own case, when I teach you, I endeavor not to allow such states of mind to arise within myself. Likewise, whenever you, are able to impart dharma or, instructions to another, do not allow arrogance or pride to arise within your mind. If it does, what you are doing no longer qualifies as the generosity of giving dharma.

Then, it is said that the generosity of giving dharma is the supreme act of generosity. And, here, it is important to teach in the same way. There are many or few students. Sometimes, someone gives an introduction to dharma. There is only one or two students.

Then, Khensur Rinpoche always, said that one should teach them as if one was dealing with a large class, and one should not suddenly see one’s voice fade into extinction. Then, one’s reward, irrespective of the number of students who attend, is that oneself has gained experience. And as for studying, that is entirely up to them. It is out of our control. Then when you meet to study, it is important that you focus on the Lam Rim and do not allow idle talk or gossip to arise.

And unavoidably, comes, but you should try to avoid it. That’s how it is. Then the third subdivision of generosity is the generosity of giving protection from fear. And this arises, for instance, when one protects people who have been imprisoned from harsh punishment. It also arises when, for instance, one is driving and one sees someone by the side of the road who needs help and one stops to help them, this is definitely the practice of the generosity of giving protection from fear.

Also, when one tries to protect the insects which are hitting the car or which are on a corpse. Then when one engages in deeds of generosity, if avarice or stinginess is present, these deeds do not become, the perfection of generosity. If, however, after engaging in these deeds, one dedicates them with the thought, may these roots of virtue become the cause of my attaining full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Then as they are upheld by bodhicitta, they become the perfection, the practice of the perfection of generosity. Okay.

Then I will take a couple of questions at present, and we will stop for the evening. So said that bodhichitta is a special mind endowed with the twin aspirations. Mhmm. Mhmm. I was wondering whether bodhichitta is a mind or is a mental factor.

Mainwind. Mainwind. But I

Thought in Lurig, you said it was a mental factor. Lori Where in Lurig? So based on the stanza of Maitreya in Abhisamayālamkāra, generating the mind is for the sake of others to wish for full and utter enlightenment. Since wish is a mental factor, some scholars have asserted that bodhicitta must be a mental factor. Now bodhicitta has a connection with mental factors, but a majority of scholars assert that it is a main mind.

There are, however, scholars which say it is a mental factor. So, I checked whether the composers of monastic textbooks asserted it was a mental factor or not. And Geshe la said that in, Golden Rosary of Eloquence, it is asserted that some Indian scholars asserted that it was a mental factor, specifically in Maitreya’s Mahayānasūtrālamkara. So the mind of definite emergence becomes great compassion. So at the stage of conventional bodhicitta, when that arises, the mind has not yet become bodhicitta because it is great compassion.

So at what point does the mind actually become bodhicitta? Which mind? The mind. The mind that goes from definite emergence then it transforms into great compassion. And Geshe la was saying that the mind of great compassion does not become transform into bodhichitta at the stage of conventional bodhichitta, but at some stage the mind then would become bodhichitta?

So as is said, the mind Bodhicitta is the mind striving for the liberation of full and utter enlightenment for the sake of others. Now when this mind doesn’t arise in an occasional factor, but arises stably in an unfabricated fashion within our mind stream. At that point, our mind has become one with bodhicitta, if you wish. Can I just follow-up then? What’s happened to great compassion at of that?

It’s behind. Questions which arise from thinking that’s very good. So it’s very good not to just think about these topics here, but when one has returned home to one’s room to think about this carefully. So you have to reflect on the nature, the object of observation, and the aspect of great compassion and the nature, the object of observation, and the aspect of bodhicitta. Are they similar, or are they different?

Is the aspect and object of observation similar or different? Keshuna, is there a difference between the mind of bodhicitta and then the Dharmakāya mind. Can Geshe la is there a next progression or is that just is there a difference between those two minds? There’s a very big difference. A conventional bodhicitta is a mind, a consciousness.

Then the dharmakaya is a person. The dharmakaya is Object. The object of observation of bodhicitta. Just want to come back to the generosity of the Bodhicitta, you know, the first perfection, the generosity. Mhmm.

If if one is, you know, there’s a vow say in the You have to speak up. I can’t hear. I’m sorry. There is a vow say in the body. It say that giving dharma or wealth Mhmm.

As a generosity. Mhmm. But if if you are forced or against your will to be giving, is this breaking of vow? Breaking of bodhisattva vow? Yes.

So who has a bodhisattva vow? If you you are holding a bodhisattva valve Uh-huh. And a person is doing this to you, they they sort of impending on you, you know, to give your wealth. So they are forcing you to give your wealth away. That’s what you’re asking.

Uh-huh. And and is it breaking of vows if you don’t give? If you. Yeah. Yeah.

So one has to analyze the situation. The person who is asking for wealth, what is their situation? What are their needs? Apart from myself, is there someone else who can help them or not? One must analyze the totality of the situation.

So to break a root vow, a root bodhisattva vow, all four binding factors must be present. Okay. So as uncontrived definite emergence is a cause for great compassion and that is a cause for Bodhicitta, do we need to enter the Hiniana path before we develop Bodhicitta because No. Through merely generating uncontrived definite emergence, you will not have entered the Hīnayāna. Upon generating uncontrived definite emergence, check-in the Lam Rim.

You will see that one should ask oneself, what are the benefits of attaining full enlightenment? What are the benefits of Bodhicitta? And at this point, strive not for one’s own liberation, but for full enlightenment. Now ask yourself where your doubt arises from. You are saying that if one does not enter the Mahāyāna, one must necessarily have entered the Hīnayāna.

What I’m saying is if you have developed an emergent, which is the aspiration for liberation for oneself, then that is a Hīnayāna path. I’m I seems to me that would be a Hīnayāna path. Actually, definite emergence is the root or the foundation of all three paths, the path of hearers, Pratyekabuddhas, and Bodhisattvas. Mhmm. Okay.

Thank you. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is bodhicitta a main mind or a mental factor?

Most scholars assert that bodhicitta is a main mind. Some scholars say it is a mental factor. Their reasoning is based on Maitreya's stanza in the Abhisamayālamkāra, which describes generating the mind for the sake of others as wishing for full and utter enlightenment. Since wish is a mental factor, they conclude that bodhicitta must be a mental factor. Bodhicitta does have a connection with mental factors. In checking whether the composers of the monastic textbooks held it to be a mental factor, it was noted that the Golden Rosary of Eloquence says some Indian scholars asserted this, specifically in Maitreya's Mahayānasūtrālamkara.

Scroll to Top