TBI Recordings – 10082016Lamrim

1 h 35 min · 4,742 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - 10082016Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains how to practise the Lam Rim through the small, middling and great scope paths, with most of the focus on great-scope training in bodhicitta. It covers great compassion, the equalization and interchange of self and others, and tonglen, and notes that the sevenfold cause and effect method also generates bodhicitta. It ends with a question and answer session.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 36m

UUID: 7bb4f617-c523-4cb9-94de-bcbf4204dacd

Words: 4,738

So to practice the Lam Rim, one must initially know how to practice the Lam Rim. After that, it is up to oneself whether one wishes to practice the Lam Rim or not. And this understanding of how to practice Lam Rim, the mode of practice of the Lam Rim, this is study. And when we refer to study, we are referring to the wisdom arisen from hearing. So here practice means to put the meaning of the Lam Rim within one’s mind.

And to do this, one must, as we said, study how to practice. And once one has studied how to practice, then one covers the totality of the Lam Rim, the paths of the being shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope. I would therefore encourage you to inquire from yourselves, do I know how to practice the path shared with the being of the small scope? Do I know how to practice the path shared with the being of the middling scope? And after that, what do I do?

Now when we inquire regarding the mode of practice of the path shared with the being of the smaller scope, the first point to understand is that there are four shared objects of observation with the path of the small scope, the middling, and the great scope. And these are the identification of the rebirth of a leisure and endowment, its rarity, its great meaningfulness, and the meditations on death and impermanence. These are shared with the practice of the being of the middling and of the great So within the outline of the Lam Rim, there is first a presentation of preliminaries and then the outline which is called how to take the essence of a rebirth of leisure and endowment. The path shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the path of the being of the great scope are all included within that latter outline. Now the way to reflect about this is as follows.

First, if we wish to practice, we should study and we should, analyze the conditions which we have at present. Now the conditions in the country such as this one, such as Australia, are exceptional. There is no physical danger of any type. There are nations and capitals in which we encounter the risk of violence and physical danger. Then in those cases, how precisely can one hope to happen to study?

In addition to this, in a country such as this one, one has perfect conditions for study. In addition to this, we have been reborn as human beings. Then as human beings, we have a rebirth which is characterized by intelligence. We can study whatever we wish to study. As Śāntideva says in his Bodhisattva, Chariavatara, independence on this human base, it is possible to eliminate all suffering.

Do not waste it and dwell in obscurity. This is a very powerful piece of instruction since indeed independence on this human rebirth, it is possible to eliminate all suffering, and Shantideva instructs us not to waste this human life. It is critical to practice, for instance, the path shared with the being of the small scope to see the forts as forts. To see specifically the forts which one focuses upon this path as forts. Gönpawa always said, observe the faults and understand the forts as faults.

Otherwise, there is no practice. Now what are the thoughts we focus upon at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope? We focus upon the suffering of the lower realms. Then the path shared with the being of the small scope can be subdivided into two sets of objects of observation. The four which are shared with the paths of the middling and the great scope, which have already been mentioned, and the three which are uncommon, which are specific to the path shared as the being of the small scope.

These are a contemplation of the suffering of the lower realms, a contemplation of the general laws of causality, the four features of causality, and a contemplation of refuge. It is important to contemplate how we spend our days from the moment we rise in the morning until the moment we go to sleep at night. And, if we are realistic, maybe not 100%, but certainly 90% of all our daily activities and thoughts are focused on the happiness of this life. And by the happiness of this life, we mean physical happiness. Now, is physical happiness all there is?

No. There is mental happiness. The moment we start trying to actualize mental happiness, we have started to try to practice down. So these are very powerful reflections for our minds which we should engage in. And we should reflect in this context on the stanza from Āryadeva’s 400, which says, the high suffer in their minds, the low suffer in their flesh, day and night, all being suffer.

Clearly, the high are affected, in other words, those of high social caste of wealth, like us, are affected mentally, and those who are poor are affected physically. So we shall leave the past shared with the being of the small scope there. At present, regarding the past shared with the being of the middling scope, the outline in Lamrim Chenmo in the great stages of the path by Mr. Kopas states, striving for liberation by understanding the thoughts of the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering. Interestingly enough, liberation, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand states that one should strive for liberation through understanding all four truths.

This is quite awkward and delicate, but at the end of the day, is the root text and Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand is derivative. So the topics of the past shared with the being of the middling scope are when they are presented briefly briefly, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering, and when they are presented in a more elaborate fashion, the 12 limbs of dependent origination. The mind striving for liberation is generated through reflecting either on the two first truths or on the 12 limbs. And here, the goal is to generate a state of mind which understands the faults of cyclic existence as faults. As Jetsongkapa says in his Condensed Points of the Stages, without striving at understanding the thoughts of suffering and of the origin of suffering, how can the mind striving for liberation be generated?

Then, we ourselves have, a transient sense of the faults of cyclic existence we do in conversation as well as Gesheera speak of the problems of saṃsāra, but it is transient. It is not permanent. And I hear you frequently in conversation say to me, ah, cyclic existence, saṃsāra, the problems of cycles. Then what exam

You mean by psychic existence? Can you identify it? I don’t know. So if by psychic existence, you mean the human condition, then that is wrong. It’s just a body.

Mhmm. Then if you understand by psychic existence the afflictions, that is better. That’s acceptable. So as says in his, if you do not counter it, how can you strive for that? It refers to cyclic existence and that refers to liberation.

And as Jetsongkapa says in his Condensed Points of the Stages, without understanding the thoughts of without striving at understanding the thoughts of the noble truths of suffering and of the origin, how could the mind wishing for liberation be generated? And therefore, it is through understanding the faults of one’s present state that one strives for liberation from it. So at the level of the path shared as a being of the small scope, it is through understanding the force, the defects of lower rebirth that one strives for liberation from the lower rebirth. At the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, it is through understanding the faults of cyclic existence that one strives for liberation. So the reasons for which the last two noble truths, the noble truths of cessation and of the path are not explained by Jetsongkapa in the context of the path shared with the being of the middling scope are difficult but interesting.

Jetsongkapa says in Lam Rim Cemo, in the context of the specific path of the being of the middling scope, all three trainings trainings of ethics of concentration and wisdom would be explained here. But at present, I will only explain the training of ethics and will explain the training of concentration and of wisdom at the level of the path shared with the being of the great scope. Now this is quite profound, and I would encourage you to reflect on why Jetsongkapa does this. So as the says, I will only explain at present the training of ethics and will defer the explanation of the trainings of concentration and of wisdom. In other words, calm abiding and insight to later and shall not elaborate.

And the reason for this is because should all three trainings be explained at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope, then one would probably be entering directly into a path of the middling scope and not of the great scope. So later on, when we study the path of the being of the great scope, we will study both the presentations of a calm abiding and of insight. Now in this context, one is referring to the generation of a an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. In other words, one is referring to the noble truth of the path and to the noble truth of cessation at the level of the being of the great scope. So whichever Lam Rim you read, you will notice that the presentation of the view as well as a presentation of calm abiding is deferred until the very end of the treatise.

And the doubt does arise why is this a state? His Holiness brings us up repeatedly. Now at present, keep in mind the reason I have given for this. So at the level of the past shared with the being of the middling scope, once one sees the thoughts of psychic existence as false, at that point, the opposite of those thoughts, which is the mind which is striving for liberation arises in an incontrovertible fashion. Now we shall broach the path of the being of the great scope.

The path of the being of the great scope focuses on the training of the children of the Conquerors. The children of the conquerors are the described as those who are striving for two states, and this is quite an important point. Now Bodhicitta itself is said to have twin wishes or twin aspirations. The foundational wish is great compassion. However, there is in addition a wish, for the object of attainment of Bodhicitta, which is full and utter enlightenment.

And whereas the foundational wish belongs to the category of method, the second wish belongs to the category of wisdom since it entails in a meditation on emptiness. So the, core element of this foundational aspiration is great compassion, which is none other than definite emergence extended to others. Now what is the main impediment to the generation of great compassion? It is self cherishing. At present, we are focusing on the generation of bodhicitta through the equalization and interchange of self and others.

This is the third outline in, the presentation of the path of the being of the great scope. This is subdivided into five. The first is a training in equanimity. The second reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the faults of self cherishing or egoism. The third reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the qualities of altruism.

The fourth, the actual equalization and the change of self and others. And the fifth, the practice of Tonglen or giving and taking. So I would like to ask you at present. We lack the realizations of the being of the great scope and we lack them because we do not understand what impediment there is to the attainment of these realizations. Now as far as the path shared with the being of the small scope is concerned, self evident, the main topic we are trying to be freed from is the suffering of the lower realms.

As far as the path shared with the being of the middling scope is concerned, the main topic we are trying to be freed from is the suffering of psychic existence in general. But as far as the path of the being of the great scope is concerned, what is the impediment to our attainments? So to give rise to the realizations of the path of the being of the great scope, you must see the thoughts of something. The thoughts of what? 100%?

We’re speaking with one voice. That’s it. Precisely. Then precisely because we are beset by egoism or self cherishing, we are unable to generate its opposite great compassion. Then it is helpful to reflect in terms of eliminating or rejecting the vanities of this life, rejecting the vanities of future lives, and why not saying rejecting the vanities of egoism or self cherishing?

So is it the case that having generated great compassion, what is the impediment to the generation of which is egoism or self cherishing, we no longer experience egoism or self cherishing? No. It is not the case. It is perfectly possible to have generated great compassion and to experience egoism or self cherishing after just as frequently egoism or self cherishing are experienced before generating great compassion. Great compassion and egoism are contradictory, mutually contradictory.

Now if one has experienced or generated great compassion, but this generation is not stable, then should egoism arise after that, one will fall into the path of a hearer or a solitary realizer. So after generating a great compassion, one proceeds in one’s training. And here I have a question for you. Is great compassion one and the same as altruism or not? What?

Is great compassion one and the same as altruism or not? As cherishing others or not?

So after putting an end to egoism or self cherishing, as we said, great compassion arises since egoism or self cherishing is the main impediment to the horizon of great compassion. And at this point, the doubt which arises is, is great compassion one and the same as altruism or cherishing others or not? Then you have to examine carefully. If it is one and the same, that would imply that great compassion has elements of love, but great compassion and love are posited as different. So what’s your answer?

So is great compassion the same as cherishing others or not? Marie, no? Yes? No? No?

Kind of. Why? Why? In general, they can coexist, but when fully characterized altruism has been generated, then there is no place for egoism. So I won’t go any further here.

You will get confused, but this is what is meant by study. I would encourage you to study and ask yourself, is great compassion one and the same as altruism or not? In the case of great compassion and love, great compassion and love can be said to be of one nature, but different isolates. So great compassion and love are respectively in the aspect of indication and of an affirmation. The only difference between them is that great compassion is the wish for beings to be free of suffering, and love is the wish for beings to be endowed with happiness.

So after generating great compassion, altruism or cherishing others arises. Now at present, we are focusing on training by means of the equalization of self and others. And here it is important to analyze the terms. We speak of equalization here. Now there are numerous forms of equality, equality in time as with simultaneity and so forth.

What is equalization here? Answer quickly. What is the meaning of interchange? Change Equalization and interchange. So here, the meaning of equalization is that in all lives until now, we have set ourselves first and others last.

Now we wish to equalize this. But in addition, we wish to interchange. To interchange what? To interchange our self cherishing or egoism with cherishing others or altruism. This is a meaning of equalization and interchange of such and others.

Mhmm. So such practice is not easy. But before engaging in practice, one must understand how to practice, the manner of practice. Otherwise, it is absolutely hopeless. And to understand the manner or the mode of practice, one must study.

So these instructions on the equalization of self and others are found both in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva Charyavatara and in Nagajuna’s Ratnavali. In Bodhisattvacharyavatara, Śāntideva says, engage in this equalization and interchange of self and others as a secret pledge to lead others swiftly to happiness. Now here swiftly means rapidly. And this instruction of the equalization and interchange of self and others, was a restricted secret instruction all the way to the time of Geshe Chekhawa. From Geshe Chekawa downwards, it became a public instruction.

The uncommon feature of the equalization interchange of self and others is the great intensification of the training in compassion and love, which leads to a very rapid and powerful generation of bodhicitta. This intensification is absent within the sevenfold cause and effect instruction. It is not the case, however, that countering egoism or self cherishing and training an altruism is absent in the sevenfold cause and instruction even though it may not be explicit. So the reason for which Śāntideva says, keep this pledge secret is because this training of equalization interchange of self and others is involved or connected with the view. It is connected with the view precisely because of the interchange between the mind which cherishes others and the mind which cherishes oneself, which are transformed into a mind which cherishes oneself and a mind which cherishes others.

The reason for this is that when we engage in the practice of the swapping or the interchange of self cherishing and cherishing others, we must analyze the relationship between self and others. Now self appears to us as autonomous, but when we analyze, we can see that self depends on others as others depend on self. This is the understanding which enables us to interchange self cherishing and cherishing others. And this mutual dependence of self and others abuts on the view. So when we analyze the relationship between self and other, this can be expanded to analysis of the relationship between one’s own party or one’s own group and the party or the group of others.

And we can see this very clearly in our lives. We may have, been very close to people for two or three years. They were part of our party. And then after that, this year, suddenly, the relationship becomes strained and they are no longer part of our party. They become other.

They are part of the other party. And at that point, animosity arises. The opposite is also true. During two or three years, someone may have been a member of the other party, the other group. The relation was strained.

But suddenly, this year, they become part of our party, our group, the relation becomes concordant. So this clearly shows the mutual relation between self and other, one, our party, and the other party. So it is precisely, this autonomy of the self, this autonomy of one’s own side, which is the object of refutation, and the interdependence to mutual dependence of self and other of one’s own side and of the side of others, which is what should be trained in. Because this is linked to the view and to an understanding of the selflessness of persons, It is said that this practice must be kept as a secret pledge. So this is why says

That, self and other are mutually dependent and not autonomous. Then, this is akin to the lines of reasoning in, being on this side and being on the other side. At present, I am on this side. But the moment I pass over there, I am on the other side. Then So this is the reason for which self and other are said to be mutually dependent.

It is precisely because it’s difficult to understand this, and this can generate in those of dull acumen, the sense that perhaps there is no self at all, which leads to disbelief in causality that these teachings are, to be kept restricted or secret. So this establishment through mutual dependence of self and others is therefore extremely important. Now we analyze it in a subtle way, but in a coarser way, we can see in our lines lives that really everything depends on others, and almost nothing really comes from our own side. As Ārya Nāgārjuna says in his Bodhicitta Vivarana, he who understands how to meditate on the equalization interchange of self and others will generate stable bodhicitta. In other words, this practice leads to the generation of extremely stable bodhicitta.

And therefore, this practice of interchange of self and others where one cherishes others as one had cherished oneself and one discards oneself as one had discarded others is a specificity of the equalization and interchange of self and others, which probably cannot be found in the sevenfold cause and effect instruction. Therefore, once one has actualized the equalization and the interchange of self and others, one has generated fully characterized love and compassion. There is, however, a very important difference between that actual generation of fully characterized love and compassion and the practice of Tonglen or giving and taking. Since when one actually generates fully characterized love and compassion at the level of the fourth outline, the equalization interchange of self and others, it is love and compassion in the form of a wish or a hope. May all sentient beings have happiness in the causes of happiness.

May all sentient beings be free of suffering and the causes of suffering. At the level of the fifth outline, the practice of Tonglen or giving and taking, one takes the determination that this is insufficient and one will actually physically endeavor to take upon oneself the suffering of others and we will physically endeavor to give others one’s own happiness. This is far more powerful. And therefore, I believe that there is no difference between the equalization and interchange of self and others and the sevenfold causal path apart from the actual stage of equalization of, the fourth stage, and the actual stage of Tonglen in the fifth stage. Let us therefore, generate the motivation by reflecting during the couple minutes on self and other, the interdependence and mutual dependence of self and other, and how in dependence on understanding of this, it is possible to generate bodhicitta.

Mhmm. Please open the prayer book, page one. And we read verse one, three, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, month or three, verse one zero three. Page five. We have a couple of minutes, then I’ll take one or two questions.

Please short questions which are on topic. Just a point of yes? Okay. It’s working. Alright.

Good. Just a point of clarification. Did I understand correctly that with the development of great compassion, one automatically develops great love, fully characterized love? Normally, once great compassion has been developed, love has already been been developed. Should that not be the case, it will be developed easily.

Geshe la, could you explain a little bit the connection or actually explain what it means, the connection of the great scope and striving for the two aims of the children of the Conquerors?

So this is very elegant and beautiful. Bodhicitta is said to be a twin aspiration because it has two components. The first is the base, which is an aspiration for the sake of others. This is none other than great compassion. The second is a focus on the object of attainment of bodhicitta.

The object of attainment is full enlightenment. So these two aspirations are not generated simultaneously. In terms of sequence of generation, first one generates a base, which is a great compassion to wish to benefit others and independence on this one generates the object of attainment. Now in terms of object, initially one attains for enlightenment and then one acts for the benefit of others. Mhmm.

Okay. And other other questions. Nick? Okay. Geshe mentioned, think that implicitly in the sevenfold cause and effect method of developing bodhicitta, self cherishing or the disadvantages of self cherishing are there.

Can just elaborate a little bit more on that, where they are and how? There’s no specific meditation on eliminating the faults of self cherishing and actualizing the qualities of cherishing others in the context of the sevenfold cause and effect generation, but the meaning is completely actualized when one trains specifically in love and compassion in the context of the sevenfold cause and effect generation. On that same note, in the sevenfold cause and effect within Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, self cherishing is not mentioned at all. And yet it’s supposedly the obstruction to the realization of great compassion. It seems to me that within the sevenfold method, the obstruction to great compassion in the light of self cherishing not being mentioned at all is more that we do not cherish others.

Could get you to comment on that, please? So in the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta, the three first steps, recollecting or being aware of all sentient beings as one’s mothers of yore, recollecting their kindness and repaying their kindness, naturally give rise to an extraordinary sense of closeness with all sentient beings who are seen as one’s parents. Who has under who undergoing these meditations would then say to another, well, your travails do not concern me. Now when this happens, one has actually actualized a realization of the faults of self cherishing and the qualities of cherishing others. There’s no need to elaborate on the topic.

It would be a waste of time. Likewise, in the equalization of self and others, generation of bodhicitta, nothing whatsoever is said about becoming mindful of all sentient beings as one’s mothers of yore, recollecting their kindness and repaying their kindness because it’s already included. So to give you an example, all of us go to India from time to time. Then the goal of the process is to get to India. Now you can go to India via Singapore, via Bangkok, via Kuala Lumpur, but at the end of the day, it’s irrelevant what matters is getting to India.

Likewise, here, what matters is generating bodhicitta. Now how you go about it is your own business. You can generate it to the sevenfold cause and effect instruction or you could generate it through the equalization and exchange of self and others. So this is a general statement. There are differences in the quality of the bodhicitta which is generated.

For instance, the bodhicitta generated by the equalization and the interchange of self and others is far more stable and powerful. As Ārya Nāgārjuna says in Bodhicitta Vivarana, having relied on the equalization interchange of self and others, bodhicitta will become stable. Okay. And just one, please. The practice of interchange of self and others has this strong history of being a secret practice even though it later became public.

Is it wise, therefore, to keep this practice within one’s own heart? So the reason for which Śāntideva says that this practice must be kept secret is because it hinges on an understanding of the mutual dependency of self and others. And this understanding of the interdependence of self and others is one which is very difficult to grasp for those of dull acumen. It can lead them to rejecting causality and succumbing to the extreme of nihilism. This is why it is said it should be kept secret.

Otherwise, it is perfectly appropriate to talk about selflessness and teach it to others. Okay. We shall stop here. Sorry. On the last what was it?

On a Saturday night, which is

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What does it mean that bodhicitta is a twin aspiration, aiming at the two aims of the children of the Conquerors?

Bodhicitta is called a twin aspiration because it has two components. The first is the base, an aspiration for the sake of others, which is none other than great compassion. The second is a focus on the object of attainment of bodhicitta, which is full enlightenment. These two aspirations are not generated simultaneously. In the sequence of generation, one first generates the base, the great compassion that wishes to benefit others, and in dependence on this one then generates the aspiration focused on the object of attainment. In terms of the object, one first attains enlightenment and then acts for the benefit of others.

Scroll to Top