1 h 41 min · 4,333 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher defines meditation as repeatedly protecting the mind’s focus on a virtuous object and advises using recollection and breath counting to settle the mind. He explains substantial causes and cooperative conditions, using them to argue for a beginningless mental continuum, past and future lives, and the practice of seeing all beings as past mothers as a basis for bodhicitta. Questions follow on these topics, including the mental continuum, bodhicitta and the origin of living beings.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 42m
UUID: eb510f70-c112-454a-ab77-3dc0b41bd50b
Words: 4,329
So regarding the definition of meditation, says meditation is protecting the aspect of observation. The mind’s protecting the apps aspect of observation of a virtuous object of observation over and over again. Then I would like to recommend to you to memorize the meaning of this definition and to reflect repeatedly on it. So here, when it is said that the object of observation is virtuous, when the mind itself is virtuous, then, automatically object of observation focused upon is virtuous. And here, the, definition mentions protecting the aspect of a virtuous object of observation over and again.
Here, the aspect of the virtuous object of observation refers to the paths shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope. Then, actually, meditation necessarily presupposes a virtuous mind, a mind which abides within virtue. So just as for instance, abiding in keeping with advice, we attend teachings in this temple. Our body is physically present in the temple, and our minds as well should be present in the temple. Now since the mind is beginningless and nonmaterial, it has a tendency to get scattered to move away.
If that is the case, then, and I will not explain this in detail, you know how to do it, You should focus on the outwards and inwards movement of breath and count it. Then for the mind to be focused in this way for a long period of time is something which we are at present unable to do. But even if 100% is not at present on the horizon, if it can be focused 60%, then that is good enough. And then over time, we will improve. Then this is how one should think about it.
At once, these things will not happen. So this is how one should proceed meditating either on the path shared with the being of the small or of the middling or the great, being’s path. So here, when we speak of meditation, in Tibetan or to meditate, then the meaning is a special state of mind. Now at present, our mind is under the sway of the affliction such as anger. Obviously, if all thinking was meditation, then there would be nothing special about meditation.
So meditation involves an uncommon mode of virtuous thinking. And there are stanzas both in Śāntideva’s Bodhicharyavatara and in Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama, the stages of meditation to the effect that one should stake the wild elephant of the mind with the rope of recollection and thereby accumulate vast swathes of virtue and eliminate all fear. Now here, recollection or memory is used to stake the mind, to tie the mind to the object of observation, the virtuous object of observation. And when it is said that one eliminates all fear, fear refers to the afflictions. At present, we are under the sway of our mind, and our mind is under the sway of the afflictions such as anger.
So what meditation entails is merely withdrawing the mind inwards and controlling it, focusing it on a virtuous object of observation. So since this is so important, let’s let us at present meditate ourselves during a couple minutes. Mhmm.
Previously, I explained a substantial cause and cooperative condition. As some of you were not present when I gave these explanations, I will reexplain this succinctly. Do listen carefully because then we will use this to explain the existence of past and future lives. The assembly in a very easy. So I do this in an easy to understand way, uncomplicated way.
So you remember that when we presented the explanation of bodhicitta, there are two ways to generate bodhicitta. Mhmm. The sevenfold, causal instruction and the equalization and interchange of self and other instruction. Then as you remember, I did not explain in detail the sevenfold causal explanation because it’s a little bit difficult to explain. The reason for which I did not explain in detail the sevenfold cause and instruction to generate bodhicitta is because the first of these seven causes is recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mothers of yore.
Now let us set aside all sentient beings and animals and just focus on humans. We have to recognize all human beings as one’s mothers of yore. Now this does not refer to one’s mother of this life, but it refers to one’s mothers of previous lives, and therefore, brings in the picture the existence of past and future lives. That kind of taking is Chris. Chris, I’m sorry.
You know? So, you are. So let us take the Chris the case of Chris. My apologies to Chris for taking him as an example. Then if I try to understand how Chris may have been my mother of yore, then this immediately links up with substantial causes.
And when we say mother, it is mother or father, but often children do not know their fathers. Then, because it links with previous lives, since otherwise Chris and I have no particular relation. I am Tibetan. Chris is Australian. You know, I was born in Tibet.
He was born here. Clearly, this relation goes back to a previous life. And for that reason, we need the concept of substantial cause. So Ārya Asaṇga composed three treatises on one very short line of two verses, which Buddha Śākyamūni uttered. From the existence of this that arose from the generation of this that was generated.
And independence on this, Ārya Asaṇga introduced the concept of the three conditions, the immutable condition, the impermanent condition, and the condition of potency. So the first of these conditions, the immutable condition, refers according to Assangem to the following. Some assert that all composite phenomena arise from movement within the mind of or god. Now this is not the Buddhist position. Buddhists assert that all composite phenomena arise in dependence on causes and conditions, and for this reason, refer to immutable conditions.
Then the second condition, Asaṇga mentions, is the impermanent condition. Having demonstrated that all phenomena arise from immutable conditions, in other words in other words, from causes and conditions and are not created by God. Then the second doubt which might arise is that these causes and conditions might be permanent, then they are not. As a result, Asaṇga teaches impermanent conditions. Then the third condition as Asaṇga teaches is the condition of potency.
Having established that all composite phenomena and so forth not only do not arise from the mind of God, but arise from causes and conditions, and that these causes and conditions are impermanent, one might think that anything causes anything else. This is not the case. Effects arise from a cause which is similar in type to themselves, and this cause similar in type to themselves is a substantial cause. Whichever composite phenomenon necessarily must have these three conditions, an immutable condition, an impermanent condition, and a condition of potency. Now regarding composite phenomena, one must distinguish between exterior and interior composite phenomena or if you prefer exterior dependent arisings and interior dependent risings.
Now within these three conditions, the important one for our discussion is the condition of potency. All composite phenomena arise from a cause similar in type to themselves, which is the substantial cause. In brief, whichever composite phenomenon or to put things in terms of Buddhist logic, if something is a composite phenomenon, it necessarily has both a substantial cause and a cooperative condition. Or if you prefer, if something is a composite phenomenon, it necessarily arises from both a substantial cause and cooperative conditions. And think about it in this way, and your understanding will be precise.
So this may be a little bit difficult, but I’ll present the definition of a substantial cause. A substantial cause is that which produces later a result which is of similar type with itself. Do I understand definition Do you understand the definition of a substantial cause? Alright. This you have to understand.
So it is through understanding what a substantial cause is and this alone that one is able to demonstrate the existence of previous and future lives, which are none other than the continuum of type or the substantial continuum of the mind. Potato. You know? Potato, for example, potato, tomato, that. Rice.
Sorry. Tomato. Oh. Says tomato because he has a Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. He has a Oh, yeah. Tomato. Tomato. But I like tomato.
Trailing values. Tomato. Tomato. How easy. You know?
When you are is tomato or what? Tomato. For me, easy, you know, tomato. So tomato, you know, for example, tomato, potato, rice. So let us take exterior phenomena such as, excuse me, potatoes, tomatoes and rice.
Then these exterior phenomena require both substantial causes and cooperative conditions. So the substantial cause of a potato or a potato is another potato. The cooperative conditions are the four sunlight, water, manure, and soil. So a potato is a substantial cause. Why?
Because if it gives rise to its result, it will give rise to a latter result similar in type to itself. In other words, a potato. Then stores are full of potatoes, which do not germinate, which, in other words, do not give rise to their substantial effect. Why? Because the cooperative conditions for their germination are absent.
In other words, there is no soil, no light, no manure and no water. So for a substantial cause to give rise to its substantial effect, both the substantial cause and the cooperative conditions are required. When the substantial cause and the cooperative conditions are both present, then a substantial effect, in this case, a future potato arises. And if you have any questions, please ask them from. No.
No. Not now. No future. No. Later.
So let us start by examining two cooperative conditions of potatoes, water and manure. Now are water and manure substantial causes of potatoes or not? No. Because when the potato has arisen, water and manure are still present. If Wow.
If they were if they were substantial causes of potato, when the potato has arisen, they would no longer be there. Do you understand? Then all composite phenomena are similar with respect
To needing substantial causes and cooperative conditions. We gave only gave only three examples, potatoes, tomatoes, and rice, but all composite phenomena are similar. Now let us take this potato and inquire whether it has a substantial cause or not. It does. And how far back can one go in this chain of substantial causes?
This ushers a concept of the substantial continuum or the continuum of type, and it is beginningless. There is no beginning. If the substantial continuum of a potato, if it had a beginning, which it does not happen, if it had a beginning, then before that beginning, it would not exist. It would begin to exist at the junction or at the boundary of that beginning. And since it is created, then we would have to ask what it is created from.
It could either have a cause which is permanent, in which case things would become very odd because itself would probably have to be permanent as well, or it could be causeless. In both case, this would harm logic greatly. Do you understand? Don’t don’t worry. When question and answer time comes, you can clarify things.
So this is for exterior phenomenon. Now we can apply exactly the same lines of reasoning to interior phenomenon. There is no difference in this matter between exterior and interior phenomenon. And in our own case, we apply this to ourselves. This is quite easy.
It is easy because we have time. Then don’t stress out. We’re not gonna rush through this one. You come regularly to the teaching, so it is possible to present things quietly so that you would understand. Mhmm.
No hurry. You know? We have time maybe Wednesday. So And this is important, something I have seen, and I personally don’t rush. And your translator said to me that substantial causes and cooperative conditions were very important, and this is very much in keeping with what his Dalai Lama says when he says that this is critical to understand the teachings.
Then let us take ourselves. We also need two conditions to arise just as exterior phenomena. We also need both substantial causes and cooperative conditions. Now let us start by saying that for all composite phenomena without exception, for a given composite phenomenon, the substantial cause is totally different from the cooperative conditions. There is no meeting point.
This, the developments on causality, which we owe to Aria Asaṇga are presented in his Abhidharma Samuccaya based on this stanza, which Geshe la quoted of Buddha Śākyamūni. So therefore, both substantial causes and cooperative conditions are required. Substantial causes and cooperative conditions are contradictory or incompatible, which means in Buddhist logic that there is no common denominator. So this is how the teachers at the monastery teach Buddhist philosophy. This is exactly how it’s taught, then think about it.
And the teacher either consults the text or has memorized it. Students typically have memorized it and reflect on the meaning of what is being taught. So let us now present the substantial cause and the cooperative condition of our own self, ourselves as predicate. So where precisely does our continuum of type begin? It begins at the moment of the fecundation of the mother’s ovum by the father’s spermatozoa.
The mother’s oversight and the father’s spermatozoa are the cooperative conditions of our own existence. Then what is our substantial cause? If one says that our substantial cause is the spermatozoa of the father and the egg of the mother, then things become very strange because probably we could still define ourselves as spermatozoa and egg. Then a second outlook one encounters at time is a very odd one. When one is asked or when one asks someone, what is your substantial cause?
They answer, my parents are my substantial cause. Now if our parents were our substantial cause, then our parents would turn into ourselves. And at present, our parents could not exist by definition. Just as for a potato, the substantial causes of a potato give rise to a later potato, and at that time, the previous substantial cause cannot exist. Now it is precisely because the spermatozoa of the father and the egg of the mother are the substantial cause of our body or our form aggregate that they become our own cooperative conditions.
So we have established beyond doubt that all composite phenomena have substantial causes. Then what do you give as our own substantial cause? No. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. You continue pass it. Say that again, please. You can pass. You know?
Pass it. I mentioned continue. Pass. Just pass. Buddha nature.
Rick. Oh, re No. The subtle mind continuum. The previous moment of the mental continuum. Shipping Just pass.
You can pass it to Natalie. The last moment of our mental continuum in the previous existence to, the last moment of that mind before the first moment of this the mind of this life. Was what was the question again? What is our substantial cause? I’d say nothing.
Very, very good. Your answers are all similar. So that is our substantial cause. It is our mental continuum. And you can see that if we move backwards through our mental continuum, we go back to the moment of our birth, then that mental continuum is present in the fetus in the womb of the mother, back to the moment of conception and further back.
So if we move backwards from the moment the embryo is still in the mother’s womb, the mental continuum is there, and we move back in time to the instant when the egg is fertilized by the spermatozoa of the father, then at that point, the mental continuum must still exist. Then we obviously do not remember this process. Even though the mental continuum was present at these moments, we lack recollection. Now that first instant of fecundation of the mother’s egg by the spermatozoa of the father is associated with a mental continuum, isn’t it? Mhmm.
Now before that first instant, there is something, a previous instant of the mental continuum, but that is no longer associated with the fecundated egg. That is associated with the previous life.
So, therefore, that which is before the first instant of fecundation of the egg by the spermatozoa ushers us into the previous life. To be more precise, ushers us into the or the intermediate state, but the is actually linked with the previous life. And this, therefore, I would like to think shows you how it is logical to view whoever one’s meet one meets as one’s father of yore, as one’s mother of yore, or as one’s siblings, brothers and sisters of yore. It is extremely important on this base to gain the experience of all sentient beings as one’s father of yore, as one’s mother of yore, and then independence on this, one can generate bodhicitta. Let us therefore think in this way, meditate during a couple minutes.
Please note the page. Page one. We missed site one b, two, three, four. And the page five number six, the offering, last one and a three Then ask your questions. Yeah.
You can question. May I ask a question relating to last night’s teaching? Yes. Yeah. Okay.
So regarding the debate topic that we had from last night on whether Tenzen Dorka has one or two homes, would a correct answer be neither one or many? You mean not more than one or neither one nor many? Neither one or many. Mhmm. So you’re saying not many?
I’m saying neither one or many. It’s a difficult topic. Uh-huh. So we’ll talk think about it together quietly. When we say that a house appears to us, then that house is formed.
But does that necessarily mean that that form is obstructive form in the sense in which we understand it? I don’t think so. Then it is probably not a house. And if you assert that it is formed but not a house is probably the best approach. Okay.
Talking about the the meeting of the the sperm and egg so that our consciousness is present at that moment. But is the prior mental continuum, how can I say that? So the cooperative conditions of the prior mental continuum, have they been exhausted through through the beginning of the of the karmic imprints, I suppose, is what I’m trying to say. Have they been exhausted? Like the example of the potato, once once the new potato has grown, then the cooperative no.
Sorry. The the substantial last potato has has ceased to exist? No. The cooperative conditions are still there. Yes, Yes.
Before the, instant of conception, the cooperative conditions of the previous mental continuum are present. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Of course.
You can give the afflictions as example. So afflictions are a very good example. They accompany us throughout our lives until we attain a cessation. Then previous lives are not taken autonomously. They are taken under the power of the afflictions.
The previous life is exactly identical with this one, and there is no difference between our mind and the afflictions. It is not the same thing as in other schools, for instance, distinction between mind and form. Alrighty. I’m just wondering, given potency, if Given what? Given the potency of, cooperative conditions, if a person’s mental continuum contained much virtue, would they be paired with parents who were of the same likeness and also virtuous, or is that too simple?
There’s no definiteness. Mhmm. It’s not assured that if you practice the six perfections like, there’s no tomorrow that you know, or not so much because then you become like but if, you know, you did it a lot, that you would be paired with parents who also were virtuous. It’s really not that
Obviously, there’s no relation between you and your parents. Right? Not necessarily. But the choice the choice of my parents depends on my mental continuum. But if I fill my mental continuum with virtue, then I’m hoping that the likeness of cooperative conditions will attract such parents.
Right? That you can say, if you accumulate the virtue to get good parents, then you will get good parents. Great. And then you go down. That is okay.
First, I just wanna apologize for interrupting Geshe-la earlier on. With the two subdivisions of becoming, one being improvement and two, degeneration, both requiring conditions, if with great compassion, the condition to degenerate is present, would great compassion eventually degenerate back to being its substantial cause of definite emergence? It’s a very good question. So it’s a very good question. Basically, what you’re asking is once one has generated fully characterized great compassion, if that fully characterized great compassion degenerates, what happens?
Well, first, we have to investigate whether definite emergence is present or not once fully characterized great compassion has been generated. Probably, it is not present because fully characterized great compassion fulfills that function. However, once fully characterized great compassion degenerates, then indeed definite emergence is left. Okay. Next question.
The question is obviously, once you have generated great compassion in your mind stream, is definite emergence present or not? It has no real function at that point. And because definite emergence can give rise to great compassion, once great compassion has been generated, definite emergence has turned into great compassion, then it has no specific function left. Okay. A simple question.
Uh-huh. At the start of the class, you asked us to memorize the definition of meditation, and I just wanted to check that I’ve written it down correctly. What I’ve written down is meditation is protecting the object of virtuous observation over and over again. Is that correct? So I’ll give you a precise translation.
So protecting the aspect of the observation by focusing repeatedly on an object of observation, which is a virtuous mind. That’s as precise as I can be. Maybe I’ll get it from you word for word after the class. I just gave it to you word by word. But I’m not very sorry about that.
And you will ask someone else. So here, the crux is the virtuous object of observation. Okay. And oh, okay. Okay.
Yeah. Mhmm. So science would posit or propose that at the beginning of the universe, there were no living beings. So how does Buddhism reconcile that or respond to it? Or put another way, where were the mental continuums housed?
Long time. You know? Have you tried? Do you have time? This is a big topic.
In brief, to answer your question, the answer of Abhidharma is that at the period of the destruction of the elements, earth, water, fire, and air, in other words, perhaps the solid liquid gases and plasma states of matter, the mental continuums transmigrate into the formless realms. So you know these three realms. I assume the realm of desire, the form realm, and the formless realm. This world or this universe of ours is part of the desire realm. Now when it is created or destroyed in the final conflagration, then the mental continuums transmigrate to the form realm.
Then the form realm itself is also destroyed. And at this point, the mental continuums transmigrate to the formless realm, and the formless realm is not material, then there is no destruction of this mental continuum space. This explanation of this mode of exposition is a very good one. That that that explanation is predicated on those beings having achieved high levels of Samādhi concentration. There’s no definiteness.
Some of the sentient beings who having trained in calm abiding or the various and being aware of the qualities of these states would be reborn in these states after wishing to do so. So there’s a huge amount of explanations on this topic in. I think so. Is there a continuum for enlightened being or they being as like like Of course. Definitely.
If they weren’t, how would this be possible? They definitely have mental continuums. Do they they choose can they choose to because they are enlightened beings, so they can choose to be, you know, reborn or substance of course into the womb of human being? Mhmm. Yes.
Indeed. They can be conceived in the womb of a mother. It is one of the 12 deeds of Buddha Śākyamūni. Okay. Nice.
Because just one yep. You can hear, please. My question is actually related to, firstly, to the prayer for the increase of merit in the prayer book on page 10. Is the word Rinpoche the Tibetan translation for Bodhicitta? It appears to be in that prayer.
If you can give me the prayer book. Prayer book. So you send you a remote. Said, you know? Where where is this?
So on the number 11, the prayer for the increase of Yes. And what do you want to know? So if if the word Rinpoche there is translated is a Tibetan translation for the word bodhicitta, does that mean that those beings who are given the title of Rinpoche have attained a mind of uncontrived bodhicitta? What is the second part of your question? Okay.
The second part is, so does that mean that those beings who were given the title of of Rinpoche have attained a mind of uncontrived bodhicitta? Okay. Bodhicitta is. Oh.
So the term Rinpoche, which means jewel or precious, is applied both to beings and to attainments as well as things. Then when someone is called Rinpoche, there is no certainty, no definiteness that they have generated bodhicitta. Okay. Stop it here tonight. Thank you.
Page nine.
Just a reminder of the green Tārā Puja for Mother’s Day on Sunday at half past ten, followed by shared lunch if you wish.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If someone's mind holds much virtue, will they be born to virtuous parents of similar nature, or is that too simple?
There is no definiteness about this. Even practising the six perfections a great deal does not assure that a person will be paired with parents who are also virtuous. Still, the choice of one's parents depends on one's own mental continuum. So if the mental continuum is filled with virtue, one can hope that the likeness of cooperative conditions will attract such parents. In that sense, if one accumulates the virtue to get good parents, one will get good parents. But this is not a guarantee in every case.