TBI Recordings – 07092016Lamrim 2

1 h 38 min · 4,651 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - 07092016Lamrim 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher explains the Lam Rim stages of the path shared with the three scopes of beings and presents the Lam Rim as the condensed essence of the five major treatises. He distinguishes great compassion, supreme resolve and bodhicitta by their objects of observation and aspects, and explains the equalizing and exchanging of self and others. Students are encouraged to meditate analytically and ask topic-related questions.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 38m

UUID: 30edab39-a562-42d3-9b29-3168366d0443

Words: 4,647

As says in his Concise Meaning of the Realizations, the concise person endowed with intellect is not delighted by the stages of the path of the being of the three scopes. And the meaning of these two verses is that all who are endowed with intellectual faculties are delighted by the presentation of the Lam Rim. Then this obviously does not refer to all living beings in general, but certainly within this small temple of ours, we should all be delighted with this presentation of the beings of the three scopes because otherwise, who will be? Then, obviously, to be delighted with the Lam Rim, one must have a teacher of the Lam Rim. One must, in other words, have heard teachings of the Lam Rim.

So I would like to ask you, are you delighted with the Lam Rim? Okay. Good. Thank you. I’m not saying anything.

Then these two verses of Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s Concise Meaning of the Realizations, who endowed with an intellect is not delighted by these stages of the path of the beings of the three scopes. This refers to the stages of the path ranging from the foundation, which is relying on the spiritual teacher, all the way up to the attainment of full enlightenment in accordance with the Sūtrayāna. So what we need initially is this strong sense. If I train in the graduated stages of the path from the beginning all the way up to the end, then definitely I will gain some type of experience. Perhaps realizations are difficult.

Then the training, it is up to us and the experiences, they are contingent on the amount of effort we put in this. So please don’t fall asleep because if you do, I will too. It’s a very big difference for the teacher when he has a sense that the students have an idea of what he’s talking about. Then one has enthusiasm to teach in the Lam Rim. So in your cases, you have received, I suspect, many teachings on the Lam Rim, and so it is more a matter of grounding things.

Then when says who endowed with an intellect would not be delighted by the stages of the path of the beings of the three scopes. Here, this delight arises when we focus on the topics, and initially, we need a an overview meditation, a meditation on the various topics. And this, I suspect, is probably identical to the understanding which is arisen from hearing. So one needs to have an understanding of the stage of the path shared with the being of the small scope. It’s various topics of meditation That shared with the being of the middling scope.

It’s various topics of meditation. And that shared with the being of the great scope and its various topics of meditation in sequence and in an unmistaken fashion. So I therefore suspect that overview meditation and generation of the mind arisen from hearing on a given topic are broadly speaking similar. Then when the mind arisen from hearing has arisen, independence on that, one generates a mind arisen from thinking, and this corresponds to a contrived experience of the topic of the Lam Rim. What we do need, however, is the mind arisen from meditation, which arises in dependence on a mind arisen from thinking.

This mind arisen from meditation gives rise to an uncontrived experience of the topic of meditation. Then this verse is accompanied by a very, very famous verse which refers to the as the condensed essence of all scriptures. And when one states that the Lam Rim is the condensed essence of all scriptures, that implies that it is the condensed essence of five great treatises which are studied in the great monasteries. So you can see how profound the topic of the is. So when we say that the is the summary or the summation of the essence of all of the treatises, in the case of the five treatises studied in the great seat.

As far as Madhyamaka is concerned, Madhyamaka is completely presented in the insight section of Je Tsongkhapa’s Lam Rim Chenmo. As far as the perfections are concerned, they are presented in the presentation of the path of the being of the great scope. As far as Abidharma is concerned, Abidharma is presented in the context of the path shared with the being of the middling scope since this path focuses mainly on the elimination of the afflictions and the focus of Abhidharma is an explanation of these afflictions. As far as is concerned, it is explained. The second chapter specifically is explained in the past shared with the being of the small and the middling scope, which present respectively death and impermanence and the existence of future lives as well as the four noble truths.

Finally, Vinaya is presented within the context of the three trainings, the training in ethics, concentration, and wisdom, specifically the training in ethics, which is not developed too extensively in So for an understanding of the Lam Rim as the concise essence of all scriptures to arise, it is indispensable to study. And it is not sufficient to study. One must study carefully, and independence on this study, doubts or questions will arise. Now at this point, it is indispensable to raise the question and here one is referring to weighty questions, to meaningful questions, to questions which are related to the topic, not to totally unrelated questions. Otherwise, if no questions are asked, then talk is endless.

I’m not saying you can’t ask questions. I am saying you should ask good questions and questions which are related to the topic. So as always said, you must meditate. And here, to meditate just means to think. There are two types of meditation, concentration meditation and analytical meditation.

So how one proceeds is that one takes a topic of the Lam Rim and one reflects on it. And for this one needs time. Now all of you have time. I don’t believe that you don’t have time. It’s more a case of not wasting the time one one has.

And then as you focus on the topic and you meditate on it, at a certain point, doubts will arise. When these doubts arise, then on that basis, you should ask a question, but that would be a good question.

So, therefore, one should meditate incrementally on the stages of the path shared with the being with the small, the middling, and the great scope. And when one reaches an obstacle, something does not work anymore, at that point, one should ask a question. So if we take the path shared as a being of the small scope, one should first definitely enumerate the number of topics of meditation and then proceed through them in sequence. And for the path of the being of the middling of the the middling scope, which should enumerate the number of topics of meditation and meditate on them in sequence. Likewise, for the path of the being of the great scope, which we have not yet completed.

So what are the objects of observation of meditation of the various stages of the path? The stage of the path shared as being of the small scope has seven topics of observation or meditation. Four which are shared and three which are uncommon. The four which are shared are identifying a precious human rebirth, its meaningfulness and its rarity, as well as death and impermanence. Then there are three topics which are specific, if you wish, or unshared for the path shared with the being of the small scope.

As far as the path shared with the being of the medium scope is concerned, the main topics are two, the noble truths of suffering and the origin of suffering. As Khensur Rinpoche said, they are akin to the four noble truths. Even though the last two truths are not explained explicitly, END pass shared the being of the middling scope. And when the two first truths are expanded, one ends up with the 12 limbs of dependent origination. Now as far as the path of the being of the great scope is concerned, we have the sevenfold causal generation of Bodhicitta, the interchange of self and others.

And then in dependence on this, training in the six remaining perfections. Now as I said in the reason for which does not explain in the path shared with the mid being of the middling scope, the last two truths, noble truths of cessation and of the path, is because their core topic is emptiness, and therefore, they are explained at the level of the insight section of the path of the being of the great scope. This is an extremely important point which you should reflect upon. So at present, I would like to ask you, do you have questions on on all the paths which have been presented? The path shared as being of the small, the middling, or the great scope.

For instance, if we take the path shared with the being of the small scope, do you understand what these seven topics of meditation or objects of observation are? And more importantly, does the do these reflections give rise to delight in your minds or not? Then if you don’t have any questions, we’ll move on to the other topics. You said this isn’t right. Yeah.

Yeah. I know. Don’t worry. Yeah. Then we’ll move on and on and on and be finished quickly.

Mhmm. Yeah. My question is about the recent teachings. I don’t really understand what immeasurable love and immeasurable compassion are compared to either ordinary love and compassion or great love and great compassion. So I’ll wait a bit.

I’ll do you have other questions? If you have thought about this, it’s easy. A lot of is something you should meditate upon. And if you meditate upon in sequence, doubts will arise. So the first point I would like to make is that our focus must be on a Mahāyāna path.

And our goal must be to generate within our mind stream realizations of the Mahāyāna to reach a point where we can say, yes, I have a realization of the Mahāyāna within my mind stream. Then here, I’m not saying that the realizations of hearers or Pratyekabuddhas are wrong realizations, but this is not what we are trying to generate within our mind stream at this point. So let’s take an example to clarify things. If we’re going to India, at the end of the day, the only thing which counts is getting to India. However, we get there.

We can get there slowly or quickly, but what counts is arriving. Mhmm. Likewise, when we are studying Mahāyāna Dharma, this is the focus. Then if your goal is to go to India and you get lost on some alternate path, that’s really not the thing. So this is therefore how it should proceed.

And when one meditates and thinks, this is how I should proceed. Then Gill’s question, as usual, is a dangerous question because it’s a topic which is addressed not only in but in in the Palm of Your Hand and numerous treatises. The first point I would like to make is that, as you know, it is taught that once one has generated great compassion within one’s mind stream, one has given rise to the realization of the path of the being of the great scope. But what we have to ask ourselves is if we generate within our mind stream great love, love in other words, then have we generated the realizations of the being of the great scope or not? So if we say that once we have generated great compassion within our mind stream, we have generated a path of the being of the great scope, then it is impossible to assert that great compassion exists within the mind of a arhats who are hearers or Pratyekabuddhas.

There is actually no other good reason to say this. Do you understand the meaning of great compassion? Do you understand the meaning? That’s not great compression. Chris?

So great compassion is the uncontrived wish and aspiration that all sentient beings, whoever they might be, be free from suffering. One has to emphasize the term uncontrived here. So as you know, there’s a threefold subdivision of suffering. The suffering of suffering of change and all pervasive suffering, but we will take a simple subdivision of suffering, the twin subdivision of suffering into physical and mental suffering. Then great compassion is the wish for all beings to be free from these two.

Now if there were to be a being in this world who was beset neither by physical nor mental suffering, then he would not be an appropriate object for great compassion. But I’m joking. So physical suffering does not afflict most of us, but certainly mental suffering does. And great compassion is the uncontrived wish or aspirate

That all sentient beings be free from physical and mental suffering. Then we do not have it within our mind stream, but we understand what it means. It’s easy. So now as far as Jill’s question is concerned, you understand what great compassion is as we explained it. Is that present or not in the mind of hearer and Kritika Buddha, solitary realizer, arhats?

If it is, then we cannot posit it as a gateway to the Mahāyāna. But if it isn’t, what are the reasons for which it isn’t apart from that? So let us take at present the sevenfold causal generation of Bodhicitta. We spoke of hearer and solitary realizer arhat. Then, obviously, the mind training in the sevenfold causal generation of Bodhicitta would be extremely easy for, hearer and solitary realizer, arhat.

Almost all of the seven, sequences would arise very swiftly for them, because they all hinge on an understanding of past and previous lives, and hearer and solitary realizer arhats have paranormal powers which enable them to perceive these directly. Therefore, they would at once understand that all sentient beings are ones mothers of yore, then the recollection for the of the kindness arises spontaneously, and the wish to repay it arises almost spontaneously. On this basis, what ground do we have to say that they would not generate great compassion? So when one has great compassion, there is no certainty that one would have a of emptiness. However, when one has great compassion, one puts a great effort into understanding emptiness.

So therefore, if we assert that great compassion is present within the mind stream of hearer and solitary realizer, Achat, then we would have to say that they have the realizations of the Mahāyāna. On the other hand, it is difficult to say that these are absent within their mind streams. So what is the position of in this matter? States that hearer and solitary realizer have love and compassion within their mind stream. As well as immeasurable love and compassion, they have not generated supreme resolve which follows a generation of great compassion and precedes that of bodhicitta.

Supreme resolve is the resolve to attain oneself enlightenment for the sake of all suffering sentient beings. So this is a difficulty. I brought it up to encourage you to reflect. I hope you will reflect. So I don’t know how you will react to this, but explains this in terms of two different types of compassion.

States that solitary realizer and hearer have a mother or a a matriarchal, a mother like compassion, which is at the end of the day an ineffectual compassion, and lack the paternal compassion which is present in the bodhisattvas, which is a compassion which acts. So at present, we have completed the presentation of the stages of the equalization and interchange of self and others, starting with equanimity reflecting on the faults of self cherishing or egoism, on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism, the thought of the actual interchange of self and others, the practice of giving and taking, and the actual generation of bodhicitta. Within this sequence, there is no specific step dedicated to the supreme resolve. And having generated bodhicitta, one is then ready to take the bodhisattva vows. Then the number of topics or objects of meditation in the path of the being of the great scope would be seven, eight, or 10.

I will check, and we will talk about it later. Mhmm. Do you understand? Can you give these objects of observation? Can any one of you give them?

Chris? Then let us set aside the sevenfold causal generation. Can you give the steps for the generation of bodhicitta in the equalization interchange of self and others? Then after this, we have the Bodhisattva vows taken upon generating engaging bodhicitta. Right?

So when one takes the bodhisattva vows, there are four white dharmas and four black dharmas. The white dharmas are dharmas to be engaged in. The black dharmas are dharmas to be abstained from. The four black dharmas include lying, deprecating or criticizing a bodhisattva, and telling a Bodhisattva not to engage in virtuous deeds. And the four white dharmas are the opposite of the black dharmas.

So when one has taken bodhisattva vows, if these four black dharmas are not present, then the vows may decline but will not be destroyed. Now even though one has taken bodhisattva vows, if one were from the depth of one’s heart to say, I will not accomplish the welfare of this one person. Then at that point, one’s bodhisattva vows have become void and so has one’s generation of bodhicitta. Let us therefore present meditate during a couple minutes on the meaning of great compassion. Mhmm.

Would you like to open the page one and recite one, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandalofy, verse one and three.

Now regarding just question about the relationship between love, immeasurable love, and great love, and compassion, immeasurable compassion, great compassion. I’ll cover this quietly in the weeks to come. It’s a difficult topic, so we don’t get confused. Then please ask your questions at present, one question per person, And please concise questions so when everyone has finished asking questions, if there’s no one else, you can ask a second question. I was just thinking while Geshe la was talking about, like, a summary of all of the Lam Rim.

And I’m not sure, but I’m thinking, like, of all the lum rim, the three principal aspects of the path is a summary of the Lam Rim. And is that summarized by a motivation and the actual practice in terms of developing a motivation and the practice of view? Can that be summarized into two? Motivation and the view, no? It’s not sufficient.

Motivation is that with which we engage into things. Then if you mean motivated by definite emergence and motivated by bodhicitta, yes. Okay. And another. Guess I got a little bit confused, I don’t know if I heard right, about arhats.

And they may have great compassion, but not the resolve to attain bodhichitta. I thought arhats couldn’t have great compassion because they’re locked in the bliss of their own personal liberation, that they’ve eliminated self grasping with it but not self cherishing. So the core of my question is, if you still got self cherishing, how could you have great compassion? There is an important difference in power between the compassion which is generated in the context of the equalization and interchange of self and others and the comp compassion which is generated as a part of the sevenfold cause and procedure. If arhats have great compassion, if, then they would have the compassion which arises within the context of training in the sevenfold causal generation of Bodhicitta, but they would not have the compassion which arises within the context of the equalization of self and others.

So there are two means to generate great compassion. The first in accordance with the sevenfold cause and procedure, the seventh second in accordance with the equalization interchange of self and others. The great compassion which arises in the context of the equalization and interchange of self and others is completely absent within the mind stream of an akhat. This is a much more powerful form of great compassion than that which arises in the context of the sevenfold cause and instruction. When Jetsongkhapa mentions the issue of the existence of great compassion within the mind stream of arhats in the context of Lam Rim Chenmo, it is in the context of the sevenfold causal instruction.

But this is something we must examine carefully. Thank you. You should read the section of the which is dedicated to the topics we are studying. At present, we’re studying generation of Bodhicitta and specifically the equalization interchange of self and others. Then you should study these two topics within Lam Rim Chenmo, the great stages of the path and Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand.

If you try reading the totality of the Lam Rim, you will get lost. My question is about, tonight we covered great compassion and then the supreme resolve. And, Geshe la said that the supreme resolve then precedes Bodhicitta. But my understanding was that great compassion combined with the supreme resolve is Bodhicitta. No.

How could bodhicitta be the mixture of great compassion and the supreme resolve? Great compassion induces the supreme resolve, and then the supreme resolve induces bodhicitta. Therefore, bodhicitta is the result of great compassion and of the supreme resolve. Then this is something we already explained, but I’ll ask you. To understand the distinction between great compassion, love, the supreme resolve, and bodhicitta, you must differentiate between their object of observation and their aspect.

Then if their object of observation and aspects are different, they are different. So what are the objects of observation and aspects? Mhmm. Yeah. What’s the object of observation of conventional bodhicitta?

In a cook, cook, cook. Enlightenment. Mhmm. What’s the object of observation of great compassion? And because the objects of observation of bodhicitta and great compassion are different, bodhicitta and great compassion are completely different.

Yeah. Yeah. I didn’t quite hear the four black dharmas. It’s because I didn’t translate them quite accurately because I didn’t understand. Yeah.

Yeah. Nice. You can check-in the. I was not able to completely translate because I don’t know them, but I will tell you next time. What is the objective observation of love?

So the object of observation of love and great compassion are identical, but the aspects are different. What’s the aspect of love? Then it is happiness Because if you say could all city beings have happiness and the causes of happiness, that’s a verbal formulation. Right? Do you all understand that the aspect of love is happiness?

I don’t know. I mean, So what’s the aspect of compassion? So, therefore, you can differentiate love and compassion in terms of their aspect. The aspect of the one is happiness. The aspect of the other is suffering.

There’s nothing in particular which is said about the mode of apprehension of love and compassion. So this is therefore how we can differentiate compare great compassion, love, and bodhicitta in terms of their objective observation and aspect which are different. Then not a lot is said about the of the mode of apprehension except for. Then ask your question.

What is the aspect of conventional? The aspect is The aspect is full of natural enlightenment. The aspect and the object of observation are the same. Probably. Hello?

This aspect and the components are the different in terms of, you know, components of you know, get you to explain the aspect of love and the aspect of great compassion, but components Of love and great. Aspect are they different? No. Because when we speak of parts, we speak of parts and the whole. Whereas the aspect is an aspect of the mind.

Parts refer to parts, a form of matter, for instance. When we speak of well, in Tibetan, it’s obvious is the components of the whole. Right? First, if you take the body, the body is that which owns the parts. The parts are the head, the limbs, and so forth, the arms, and so forth.

This is just not a, you know, Chinese and Japanese translation. We we say. Ji and he is two components, not in not in the not in the suffering. Mhmm. I mean, the happiness and the suffering.

Mhmm. That’s but that’s meaning is compassion. Compassion. Compassion has the two components in the Chinese and Chinese. I see the character has two parts.

Actually, there is almost no difference between love and great compassion. The only difference is the aspect within the context of the sevenfold causal generation. However, in the later on in the future, we will study quietly the difference between love, compassion, great love, great compassion, immeasurable love, immeasurable compassion. Okay. And the Where did this father arise in the mother like formation of?

We’ve been we’ve been thinking about the great compassion of a mother giving birth, looking after a child, doing everything in her power to make sure the child is well, make sure that it grows up strong, make sure that it learns properly. Where’s this father been all this time? So true. So what you say is very true, whether it is for mammals or for other parents, the one which which takes care of the child is the mother, but the one who protects the child is the father. My question is about, given that we’re all impermanent, can a being of dull acumen become a being of sharp acumen in within a lifetime?

Definitely. Just matter of training. The faculties can be trained. The faculties can be trained. The mind, the intelligence can be trained.

There’s some very nice passages in Abhidharma on beings of sharp faculty. If you want to develop your mind, study Abhidharma. It’s very beautiful. Geshe la recommend a text to explain precisely the aggregates? So you can rely on Vasu Bandhu’s texts which presented from the standpoint of Abhidharma.

Can I get that on the class? Abhidharma Kosha. In order to develop a sharp mind, one can debate for Düdra for three months, and it’s equivalent to doing a retreat a long retreat on white manjushri. I’m just wondering how we could, as a group, perhaps incorporate that here at TBI in terms of developing our reasoning and analytical skills. Not necessarily debate, but, some sort of better analytical method for analyzing the teachings.

Practice your Tibetan. I tried. Tried. Take it. You will need Tibetan.

You know? Exactly. And someone say, I’m just talking. And I can direct experience of this because in Jeffrey Hopkins’ program at the University of Virginia, we tried to introduce debate in English. It was rather catastrophic because we didn’t have a technical terminology.

It didn’t work. You know? In Tibetan, there’s a very, very precise technical terminology. But you have to learn Tibetan. It’s best.

Terminology is not stable in English. Is that? Because we don’t have government sponsorship. Because in Tibet, there were dharma kings. The West, we don’t have dharma kings.

There was a law in Tibet. What you could translate, you had to? You weren’t allowed to translate differently from the law. In English, we don’t have that. Every translator does.

Okay. I stop here to net. Thank you. I’d like to announce that everybody probably know, but just reminding you, the twenty fourth, you know, Geshe-la is giving empowerment on Chenrezig and before that, So if you’re going to come for long weekend, it would be good to if you can

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
four black dharmas nagpö chö zhi (Tib)
Four actions that impede your spiritual progress. They are: 1) deceiving your guru or a holy being; 2) feeling misplaced regret; 3) criticizing or abusing a holy person; and 4) cheating others. LYWA
four white dharmas karpöi chö zhi (Tib)
Four actions that speed your spiritual progress; they are: 1) never lying to your guru even at the cost of your life; 2) inspiring sentient beings to follow the Mahayana path... LYWA
graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Can a person of dull intellectual ability become sharp-minded within one lifetime?

Yes, definitely. It is a matter of training: the faculties can be trained, and the mind and intelligence can be trained. The Abhidharma has some very nice passages on beings of sharp faculty, and anyone who wants to develop their mind is encouraged to study Abhidharma, which is described as very beautiful. For a text that explains the aggregates precisely, one can rely on Vasu Bandhu's works, which present the subject from the standpoint of Abhidharma, namely the Abhidharma Kosha. To develop a sharp mind, one can debate in Düdra for three months, and this is said to be equivalent to doing a long retreat on White Manjushri.

Scroll to Top