TBI Recordings – 05042017lamrim

1 h 26 min · 3,604 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - 05042017lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Teaching on impermanence from the Lam Rim, defining it as momentariness and explaining the mode of disintegration of the mind. It contrasts the Vaibhashika view with the Sautrantika-to-Madhyamaka view of instant-by-instant disintegration, and covers substantial cause versus cooperative condition and whether mental continuums cease or dwindle. Students ask many questions along the way.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 26m

UUID: d523816a-af64-48bd-8b05-faa3bca9b6a0

Words: 3,600

Then as is said by then later and later even to quote having received numerous instructions, nonetheless, the instructions have not entered their minds. Turn everything you’d hear into an oral instruction. Then has a quote to the same effect. And therefore are teaching the same thing, and this is something which concerns us. We have received numerous teachings.

Yet, oddly enough, we are poor in dharma. Then, here, what is meant by being poor in dharma or poor in the Lam Rim? It is simply that one does not understand intent of the Lam Rim, and one does not understand the intent or the goal of the Lam Rim simply because even though one has heard many teachings, one never ever meditates. Then his foreigner Siddhartha Lama, Kirti Tsenshab and Bachi, have given exactly the same advice, which is we must meditate. And meditation here means nothing else than reflecting on the Lam Rim.

If we do not reflect on the Lam Rim, then we will forget it. We are actually very fortunate. Those of us or those, including Geshe la who are ordained because they have perfect opportunities for practice. Then for the remainder of the students who are laypeople, things are more difficult, especially if they have to work or keep an eye on, their children. But it is nonetheless possible to practice.

And by practice here, one means meditate. And every Wednesday, teachings are given here. You must take this opportunity. It will not represent itself easily in the future. Then before attending the teachings on Wednesdays, you should say to yourselves, tonight, I’m gonna listen to the.

I’m gonna learn something. I’m going there for that. Otherwise, if you show up as if you’re going to a show, then there’s no point. To meditate means to think, to reflect on something. Then has all of us has given all us all of us much advice over the years.

And one of the a piece of advice which he gave over and again was meditate, practice. Moreover, here in his own history, the Dalai Lama attended the numerous rituals which were held at the monastery. He always would interrupt them and say, you must meditate at key points. Otherwise, it is mere recitation. Then when one says meditate, meditate on what?

Meditate on the Lam Rim. In other words, meditate on the topics of the Lam Rim of the path shared with the being of the small scope, shared with the path of the being of the middling scope, and shared with the path of the being of the great scope. Then there are two types of suffering, physical and mental suffering. Mhmm. And while we are beset from time to time by physical suffering, health problems, I believe that in this country, the majority of your problems are mental problems.

Your suffering is mental. And this mental suffering, there are means to counteract it. So we have to seek for the means to counteract mental suffering. And if we do so, then ideally, we will be able to attain states such as a state of full enlightenment or liberation, but at the very least, we will be happy people leading happy lives. Then you should be happy when you get up in the morning.

I would like to believe that if you get up in the morning, you are necessarily happy. But it does occur that one experiences nightmares, then it’s not my place here to talk about how to interpret dreams. Nightmares are just that. They are just dreams. Then the best is to put one’s mind in equanimity, and then whatever happens, just happens, We take it in stride.

Otherwise, if we allow afflictions such as anger to take over, then the more powerful they they get, the greater in turn their power over us, it becomes quickly uncontrollable. Then once our minds are not troubled, then at peace, in turn, we will experience fewer physical ailments, and we will lead a long and happy life. And in as much as the that contains the key instructions to maintain an untroubled mind, this is what we should focus upon. Then at present, we will meditate during a couple of minutes following the advice of both Kirti Tsenshab Rinpoche and of Khen Rinpoche Kangyo. And we can meditate ideally on whatever virtuous topic we choose.

But at the very least, if we are unable to generate a virtuous state of mind, we should generate a state of mind of nonviolence, which does not harm others. And here, we should not be pretentious. We do this for ourselves.

So whereas probably all agree that momentariness is the definition of impermanence is the meaning of impermanence. But what they mean by momentariness, especially what the different schools of tenets means, differs. For instance, if we take the Vaibhāṣika School of Tenets, for the Vaibhāṣika, momentariness seems to refer to the momentariness of the actor whose action leads to something at present. So the Vaibhāṣika understanding of momentariness as in an impermanence is a little bit odd. The Vaibhāṣikas consider that we are impermanent, but they consider that all three times are impermanent and that we engage all three times.

For instance, their stance is a little bit strange. If we take the table in front of Geshe-la, they consider that this table exists in the past, the present, and the future and is engaged in all three times. So they assert that there are four different instance in the process of impermanence, an instance of generation, an instance of abiding, an instance of enhancement or development, and an instance of destruction. And if we were to take the case of a human being, they assert that human beings are impermanent, but they assert, for instance, that destruction, the destruction, the instant of destruction of a human being only occurs at the point of the death of that person. From birth from the womb to that point, there is no destruction.

Strange, isn’t it? So to be precise, the Vaibhashikakas do not say that we existed in the past. They say we existed in past time as well as in the present time and future time. And for instance, in our case, our past time would be the time of our birth from a mother’s womb, and the Vaibhāṣikas would say that we exist in that time. So the example that Vaibhāṣikas give is that of milk and yogurt.

When you boil milk to turn it into yogurt and add certain substances, then over time, that milk will indeed transform in yogurt. However, apart from the taste and the potency of the milk, the color and the shape of milk do not change when it transforms into yogurt. It’s an example. Yeah. So when milk turns into yogurt, the only thing which changes is actually the potency and the taste.

Milk is sweet, yogurt is sour. And the Vaibhāṣikas use this as an example for the impermanence of a human being. From the moment of birth until death, according to Vaibhāṣika, apart from minor changes, the nature of the person is constant. If we look at it from a standpoint of one day, it will become clearer. Whatever the time you get up in the morning, then from the standpoint of Vaibhāṣika, there is no disintegration during that day.

You have the past and the future periods, and that’s it. Then they probably assert that the time of our disintegration is the time of our death. So the Vaibhāṣika view is an extremely coarse view because, frankly, if you assert that we have not changed substantially between this morning and tonight, whatever time it might be, then you are probably asserting that we are permanent. Do you understand? Yes.

It’s very easy. So let us present our own system at present. And after all, since the Vaibhāṣikas are Buddhists, then we can scold them, and we can tell them whatever we want to tell them. So we say to the Vaibhāṣikas, this system of yours just doesn’t work. Because if you are saying that we are the same in the morning as in the evening, you are saying that our nature is permanent.

So all of the system of tenants superior to Vaibashi, in other words, the system of tenants from South Radica up to Prasadika, Madhyamaka assert that the definition of impermanence is momentariness and understand momentariness as momentary disintegration or disintegration instant by instant. Now how exactly can we explain this? Let us take an example. Let us say it is 12:00. Then 11:00 fifty nine minutes and fifty nine seconds is the past.

Mhmm. 12:00 is the present. So a better way to explain this one would be as follows. What we are saying is that the instant of generation is established as the nature of an instant of destruction. And this is clearly understood if you reflect that at the tie time of the second instant of a person, the first instant of the person has been destroyed.

So here, therefore, as we said, at the time of the second instant of a person, the first instant of a person has been destroyed. In other words, has ceased. Now I’m not sure what you understand by the term ceased. It’s a technical term in Buddhist thought. So the question which arises here is, what is the mode of disintegration we are positing?

And there are numerous possible modes of disintegration. There’s a lot of debate about this. If we take the case of electricity, for instance, in a telephone wire or in a cable, then when you cut the power, it’s a very rapid process, but basically, the power decreases 99, 98, 97%, basically down to zero. In other words, the potency decreases. Now in your opinion, what is the mode of disintegration as far as impermanence is concerned?

Mhmm. What is our own mode of disintegration? So this applies to all sorts of things such as, for instance, the wisdom realizing emptiness in the mind stream of an ārya being. This is impermanent. What is its mode of disintegration?

Bodhicitta is impermanent. What is its mode of disintegration? The mind of a Buddha is impermanent. What is its mode of disintegration? A strange little bit party.

No? Right. Right. Right. Do Do know?

And that do you understand? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Gotta come look.

The mode of disintegration. Well The mode of disintegration. Of ourselves. Of ourselves. Not so.

I guess I’m just thinking from a physical perspective that is cells disintegrating and recreating all the time. So and when they recreate, they don’t recreate in the same form as they did previously. So What is the mode of disintegration? This is what we have to think about. So you see, Geshe-la gave you the example of electricity.

Then when electricity is interrupted, the power decreases progressively. It’s a very rapid decrease, but it decreases progressively. So what about us? What’s our mode of disintegration? It’s very interesting way of thinking.

This is gonna hurt you when you go to sleep. Strange to think like this. If you take bodhicitta for instance, bodhicitta is an impermanent phenomenon. So it disintegrates. Right?

It’s impermanent. But then if you say no, it doesn’t disintegrate because it’s consciousness and what? If you have a clear straight mind, you will understand this. Lot of food food of thought was impermanence. The momentariness of a continuum is imperceptible to the senses, perhaps not to, an so that consciousness is momentarily changing, and so there would have to be with bodhicitta, there would have to be if that’s generated, there would have to be some, continuity of of one moment of bodhicitta giving rise to the next, but that would be imperceptible.

Yeah. Could it be interdependent itself? That gives rise to the next moment. Mhmm. You are beyond.

I think the mode would be also progressively and occurring instant by instant on a level that we cannot perceive? So the phenomena which we observe cease instant by instant. But the question now is if we look at our own minds, our own mental continuum, does it dwindle instant by instant, or does it terminate instant by instant? Oh, That’s it. That’s what I’d like you to think about.

You would have to terminate if not just terminate. Necessary. Okay. Yes. So you’re talking of a termination on extinction akin to that of the table instant by instant where the table is smashed and destroyed and we cannot use it anymore.

There’s not? Okay. It’s interesting when you put the half iron in the wound. Where? Where?

Because that in If you can’t use it anymore and it’s your mind, then that would imply you can know your consciousness no longer exists at all. I mean, it does happen among those of you who are old that one’s memory dwindles and one becomes unable to use it. Right? I’m getting a little bit confused. Google geese.

Mode the mode of integration for the electricity, if we cut the cord, it’s instant. You don’t have any more power. Mhmm. And then Mhmm. And then we talk about the mode of disintegration above the body or of the mind.

Because they’re different. No. I mean, if you take the case, for instance, of the telephone, right, when you’re talking in the phone and the power is cut, you hear a fading it. It’s a hundred percent first, and it goes down. Right?

Love it. Just go If if the power is cut, you don’t you don’t hear, and you you can talk. You’re talking. It’s not India. Sorry.

Not India. I think in Dene, you know, and Mumbai. And mother. Love. Right?

You should speak up. Yeah. You can see it. The last change. Right?

Yeah. You can see it. I think the mode of of of how we work is that we motivated by subtle impermanence so that instant by instant, the each instant has generation and destruction within it. With the second point about whether we just dwindle or whether we just destroy it completely, is there an in between place between those? I think extinction and termination are synonymous.

The same thing. So what are we gonna do about that? First thing is think what our mind is. Right? Then if we take bodhicitta, it’s a mind.

What is it? How does it proceed? It is impermanent. It disintegrates instance by instance. But what is the mode of disintegration?

And there was the past becoming the fruit future. Right? Alright. Well, we talk about continuum of mind. So if each instant of mind is completely extinguished, I don’t think we’d talk about a continuum of mind.

So isn’t it that one one moment gives rise to the next moment, and that moment is different. But I think the previous moment must still otherwise, we wouldn’t have memory. We? They’re not perfect. Totally different.

They are not these instance, they’re not totally different. So if you light one candle from another candle, these two candles are different. Right? Yes. It’s a cooperative condition.

It’s a mere cooperative condition. You see, cooperative conditions cannot construct a substantial continuum. The realization of emptiness in the mind of an doesn’t disintegrate or doesn’t deteriorate or dwindle. The continuum may be one moment after the other, but it’s

Yes. It is not permanent. The wisdom realizing emptiness in the It’s not permanent. It disintegrates. It would be strange.

It wouldn’t be impermanent. Didn’t hear the question. I don’t think anyone heard your question. Sorry. Does that mean that does that mean that someone who’s enlightened enlightened is impermanent as well?

Thank you. Maybe I’ll know. So, I’d like to go back to Molly’s, example. I like the idea of the flame but just one candle, so if you have a if you light a candle, if you could see the flame at, a subtle enough level, you would see that it was never still, that it was actually constantly, generating and disintegrating and so I’m thinking that our minds, our bodies, our minds, our every bit is like that at the subtle level, like we’re like a flame that is constantly generating and destroying in itself. So the moment of generation is the the next moment of destruction.

That moment of destruction is the moment of generation for the next moment for the next instant. So the fire of the second candle has as its cooperative condition the fire of the first candle, but it does not have as its substantial cause the fire of that first candle. It is not, therefore, a substantial continuum. You have to understand the distinction between cooperative condition and substantial cause. Sorry.

Can I I thought a sub substantial cause was one that continued in the same substantial entity so that clay gives rise to clay pot? So an example should make this clear. First, I would say that indeed clay is the substantial cause of a a clay vase. But if you take the example of rice grain, when you plant a grain of rice, and that eventually gives rise to a rice seedling. The rice grain is a substantial cause of the rice seedling.

But for the rice seedling to appear, you need cooperative conditions. These are heat, water, manure, and so forth. I understand that. So I don’t see how I don’t see how the flame of one candle, goes to the other, isn’t the suspension. I understand all the other.

How could it be could it be the substantial cause? If I take my porcelain cup and fill it with water and then pour the water from my porcelain cup into my glass, does it become the substantial cause of that second water? No. It’s similar. So I think the brain, I’m thinking flame is the substantial cause of flame.

So man is the cause of man. Right? So today, this discussion went very well. This topic of impermanence is extremely important. While we all understand that the definition of impermanence is momentariness, It is the mode of disintegration which is critical.

And you can see if you take bodhicitta as an example, it is a mind, it is impermanent, it is momentary, it disintegrates instant by instant, but it neither ceases nor is terminated. So we have to understand this process of transformation of mind, and this leads us directly to the existence of past and future lives. Then this is a very, very helpful line of thinking. And if we take consciousness, obviously, there are multiple levels of consciousnesses, coarse and far more subtle consciousnesses. Then things have gone very well today.

And please reflect on your doubts because as our understanding of impermanence deepens, this will benefit greatly understanding of emptiness. And also reflect on the distinction between substantial cause and cooperative condition according to Buddhist treatises. Every composite phenomenon necessarily requires both its substantial cause and cooperative conditions. If both are not present, a composite phenomenon cannot arise. And you have, from your own side, brought up this issue of substantial cause and cooperative condition, and it is excellent.

Later on, Geshe-la will enter in detail into this topic. Do you like? Yes. Really? Good.

And from my own side, it’s a fascinating topic. I was just wondering, are you gonna bring it up or not? That’s excellent. And therefore, later on, it will be explained progressively. Okay.

Yeah. Can you start changing? Page nine. Number six, number three. Last one, eighty three.

So within the four systems of Buddhist tenets, the Vaibhāṣikas, the Sautrantikas, and some of the Chitamatrans assert the existence of three final vehicles. What this means is that once one has become an arhat, upon death, one ceases to exist. As a lot of food for thought with this. So so in brief, once, according to these schools, one has attained the state of an arhat upon death, there is no reincarnation, and the continuum of the mind is severed permanently. Because they say if they don’t accept this.

But if an was reborn, he could only be reborn under the power of the affliction that he would be reborn in cyclic existence, but he has abandoned cyclic existence. And this should become more evident when you reflect on the two first of the four characteristics of the first noble truth, which are impermanence and suffering. The first novel truth, novel truth of suffering is said to be impermanent because it is occasional, mi rtag pa, in Tibetan, and it is said to be suffering because it arises in dependence on karma and affliction. Just welcome. One question, please.

Is that correct? Yeah. Yeah. Fuck you. Okay.

So how do Babashika even posit that one can become a Buddha? Using the milk, becoming yogurt example where you don’t substantially change, how can you even become an arhat? That in a way prevents the Vaibhāṣika presentation of the attainment of arhathood or even enlightenment. The Vaibhāṣikas, when they speak of momentariness, refer to a momentariness which is a subsidiary and which manifests at the time of the end of the continuum even though it has begun a long time ago. So it’s very strange.

You cannot talk of impermanence in somehow. Okay. And we shall stop here for today. There’s still one or two places left for the two and a half day teaching for Easter. So please don’t miss out.

There’s a long queue.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top