1 h 32 min · 4,431 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim discussion of the paths of the middling and great scopes, contrasting the sevenfold cause and effect method for generating bodhicitta with equalizing and exchanging self and others. It covers self-cherishing as the obstacle to great compassion, the four noble truths in Pabongka Rinpoche’s text, and a closing question session on which method suits each student.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 33m
UUID: e5748b8c-6683-4af6-8c33-92cdcef9a4de
Words: 4,427
It’s come with the monkey. As Tsongkhapa says in his Canticle of Realizations, who among the wise is not entranced, literally ravished by the stages of the paths of the beings of the three scopes. This refers to the stages of the paths of the being of the small, of the middling, and the great scope, which are presented in an unmistaken sequential fashion. And therefore, who among the wise is not entranced by this? And this therefore refers to generating incrementally within our mind stream the realizations of the path shared with the small, with the middling, and eventually with the being of the great scope.
Now, what precisely are the realizations shared with the path of the being of the middling scope? It is the generation of uncontrived definite emergence. And what is the incompatible condition which prevents the generation of such uncontrived definite emergence? It is a predilection for cyclic existence. The realization of the path of the being of the great scope is great compassion.
And what precisely in this context would be the incompatible condition? In other words, the discordant factor which prevents one from realizing great compassion. Now this is a delicate question. There’s food for thought. What is the answer in your opinion?
What, in other words, prevents the generation of great compassion? What blocks it? So if this is the case, then as you remember, there are two means of generating bodhicitta. The first is the sevenfold cause and instruction. The second is the equalization and the interchange of self and others.
Now if we take a person, a being who is training in the seven fold cause of instruction, then such a being will have generated great compassion. Will self cherishing be an obstacle to the generation of great compassion for such a being or not? Are you sure? Yes. 100%?
Yes. Okay. Then you are unable to posit a difference between the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta and the generation of bodhicitta through the equalization and the interchange of self and others. And there is a difference. You have to be able to positive.
So what’s the difference? Last Vishal week, I think that with the seven fold cause and effect method, it relies on seeing all beings as your mother and and a belief in past lives. And that’s the difference between the individual, self, and others What’s the difference? So what you said is when you train in the sevenfold cause and instruction and you generate great compassion, the obstacle to that is self cherishing and you have to counter it. That’s what you said.
Then there are differences between the sevenfold cause and instruction to generate bodhicitta and the equalization interchange of self and others. What are they? Is one the best and the other the theory? The theory. So this is a topic which calls for study.
If we refer to the path shared with the being of the middling scope, according to Lam Rim Chenmo, the means for generating uncontrived definite emergence, in other words, a mind striving for liberation, is either to reflect on the first two noble truths, the noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering, or more elaborately to reflect on the 12 limbs of dependent origination. On the other hand, Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand states that the means to generate such definite emergence is to reflect on the four noble truths. So now why precisely does say that only the two first noble truths, noble truths of suffering and the origin of suffering are necessary to generate uncontrived or spontaneous definite emergence, whereas Pabongka Rinpoche in, liberation in the palm of your hand, asserts it is the four noble truths. Je Tsongkhapa does not mention the last two noble truths, the noble truth of cessation and the noble truth of the path. Perhaps the reason this is done is because these are only attained independence on an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight.
And therefore, they are explained in the section on insight. Without interrogating you too much, which will make you dizzy, I would point out that a majority of the Lamrim texts, the graduated stages of the path, present the view in the context of the path of the being of the great scope. And they present the view, therefore, after presenting bodhicitta great compassion and so forth. Now the view is what? It is emptiness.
What is emptiness? It is a noble truth of cessation. And therefore, the presentation of the noble truth of cessation of the past occurs at the level of the insight section of Lamrim. Alternatively, one could say that whereas there are not major differences from the standpoint of method in the various schools of tenets. There are important differences from the standpoint of the view with numerous presentations of differences in the view.
And for this reason, the view is presented later. As was mentioned previously, it is not the case that it is indispensable to generate first definite emergence and bodhicitta before generating a realization of the view. Texts refer to numerous cases of beings who have generated a realization of the view without definite emergence or bodhicitta. Then there is another interesting point to be made in the monastic textbooks. They’re using other words that Sera, Ganden, and Drepung.
When the generation of love, compassion, and bodhicitta is presented, it is overwhelmingly presented from the standpoint of the seven fold causal procedure to generate it. And, little, if anything, is said about the obstacles to the generation of great compassion simply because if anything was mentioned, it would have to be self cherishing, and this would then usher the topic of the equalization interchange of self and others. On the other hand, when the path shared with the being of the middling scope is presented, then the main interfering condition to the generation of definite emergence is precisely cyclic existence and the afflictions. The main topic on this path is the four noble truths. Now Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand indicates that there is a difference in power or in strength in the generation of bodhicitta by means of the sevenfold cause of instruction and by means of the equalization and interchange of self and others, specifically a difference in the generation of love and a great compassion.
It would be worth your while to study this text. What is pointed out is that in the context of the equalization and the interchange of self and others, in as much as one generates great compassion and love and trains in Tonglen, in other words, giving and taking, these increase dramatically. And this uncommon instruction is not present in the seven fold causal instruction to generate bodhicitta. During the practice of the equalization and the interchange of self and others, there definitely is an awareness of all sentient beings apart from oneself as one’s mother of yore. But the focus is on sentient beings who are not our mothers within this life.
And in that respect, this practice is supreme in generating both love and compassion. Very clear that in the seven fold cause and instruction, one recollect the kindness of sentient beings due to their having been one’s mothers of yore, but there is no focus on the kindness of sentient beings to one in this life. This is a specific focus of the equalization and interchange of self and others. This is the main difference between the sevenfold cause and instruction and the equalization and interchange of self and others as taught in which is liberation in the palm of your hand. The 7th Floor calls and instruction focuses on the kindness of sentient beings due to their past kindnesses as mother sentient beings, but there is no specific focus on their kindness to us in this life.
There’s only one focus on the kindness of sentient beings. Whereas the equalization and interchange of self and others has two focuses on the kindness of sentient beings, their past focus and their present kindness to us in this life. And therefore, the two central points of the equalization and interchange of self and others are world. Of world. We good And one engages in a series of reflections which act as a cause for the attainment of full enlightenment.
Therefore, whereas on the path shared with the being of middling capacity, it is through reflecting on psychic existence, its faults, the faults of the afflictions that one generates an awareness of the qualities of the state of liberation and strives for the state. On the other hand, at the level of the path of the being of the great scope, it is through reflecting on the faults of self cherishing or egoism and on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism that one generates a striving for the state of full enlightenment. So you asserted that the main, interfering condition to the generation of great compassion, in the context of the interchange of self and others was self cherishing. And, I pointed out then that in that case, one should, counter self cherishing in the context of the seven fold causal, generation of bodhicitta since great compassion must be generated in that context. Now there is another question I would like to address, and that is the following.
If it is the case that to gain the realizations of the path of the being of the great scope, one must have generated the previous realizations, then what is the way of generating the realizations of the path of shared as being of the middling scope, and how does one pass to the path of the being of the great scope? Should this be the case? Are you saying that when one generates great compassion in the context of the equalization and interchange of self and others, one must have generated renunciation first? I don’t I don’t So you are saying that it is not necessary to generate renunciation as a preliminary to the generation of great compassion in the context of equalization of self and others. Therefore, you are saying that when one trains in equalization of self and others, one does not need the preliminary realizations of the path of the middling scope.
Nasus? So, okay, you are saying indeed that one needs as a preliminary to the generation of great compassion with the con within the context of the equalization interchange of self and others to generate definite emergence. But what then is the interfering condition to the generation of great compassion? Then if you are saying that it is self grasping, that also is the interfering condition to the generation of great compassion within the sevenfold cause of instruction. Then what exactly is the difference between the sevenfold cause of instruction and the equalization interchange of self and others?
That’s a lot of. You have to think of it. Yeah. So from the method aspect of the path, this transition from the path shared with the being of the middling scope to that of the path of the being of the great scope is a delicate one. I am not saying that you should not doubt that one can gain the realizations of the path of the being of the great scope without relying on the realizations of the path of the middling scope.
You are entitled to doubt. Then a little bit here, we said you have to generate doubts. Now, ideally, for us, we would gain the realizations of these topics. And if we’re unable to gain realizations or practice, then at least we generate some doubts. So whether it is the case or not that to relying on the equalization and interchange of self and others alone, one can progress to full enlightenment is something we should examine.
If, to train in the equalization and interchange of self and others, one must rely on the path shared with the being of the medium scope, then one must also give a mode of reliance. It’s not sufficient to just assert this. So do you understand this mode of thinking? Now in the context of the presentation of the Pāramitāyāna, one focuses a lot on self cherishing. Whereas in the context of the treatises on, Buddhist philosophy of definitions, one focuses mainly on self grasping.
So if you have one or two free hours and I am convinced that there’s not one of you who can find one or two free hours, I would suggest that you work through the various topics of meditation of the three stages of the path in sequence. Now if you do this regularly, the doubts will arise. If you don’t do do this, I don’t see how the doubts could arise.
And therefore, we have to focus on these topics of meditation of the various paths, for instance, the common and the uncommon topics of meditation. There are three uncommon topics of meditation for the path of the being of the small scope, and one should focus on them as well as on the succeeding ones. If one does this, then these doubts will arise. Otherwise, without study, they will not arise. So in the context of the generation of bodhicitta by means of the equalization and the interchange of self and others, what is critical is to reflect very carefully on both the faults of self cherishing or egoism and the qualities of cherishing others or altruism.
It’s independence on this that one engages in the equalization and interchange of self and others. And therefore, one So, therefore, to generate great compassion, we must eliminate the interfering factor or the opposite, if you wish, of great compassion, which is self cherishing or egoism. And there is a verse in which refers precisely to self cherishing as the opposite of great compassion. And therefore, to generate fully characterized great compassion within one’s mind stream, one must counter egoism or self cherishing. This is something we should think about.
And this is therefore how one proceeds to generate a great compassion and love within the context of the equalization and interchange of self and others. Now within the context of the practice of giving and taking of Tonglen, there is merely an intensification of, great compassion and of love to respectively taking the sufferings of others upon oneself and giving one’s happiness to others. Apart from this difference, great compassion and love are synonymous. There is a nearly a difference in terms of object. It is difficult to say that there is no equalization and interchange of self and others within the context of the sevenfold cause and instruction for the generation of bodhicitta.
What is, however, absent within the sevenfold cause and instruction is the actual practice of or giving and taking, which causes an extreme intensification of both love and great compassion through specific visualizations. I don’t have much more to add on the topic except that within the context of the equalization of the interchange of self and others, it is important to understand the varieties of self cherishing or egoism. There are numerous varieties of self cherishing. Let us therefore, in the context of generating the motivation, reflect, meditate during a couple of minutes. First, on the faults of self cherishing and then on the qualities of cherishing others.
If we do this correctly, then this will naturally amount to a meditation on bodhicitta. Mhmm. K. Please open the page one. We recite one b, two, three, four, And also page five, number six bundle offering, verse one, and three.
So in our cases, I suspect none of us have the realizations of the being of the small and of the middling scope. So, obviously, when we reflect on the faults of self cherishing, we reflect on them with that very limited out outlook. On the other hand, wonder whether someone who has the realizations of the being of the middling scope would be fully aware of the numerous faults of self cherishing. So there is a lot of food for thought here.
Then, clearly, someone who is on the point of entering the Mahāyāna and who therefore has all the realizations of the path shared with a being of the small and the middling scope has no particular predilection or attachment to the vanities of this life or the vanities of all lives. The only particular attachment they have is to liberation. Apart from that, they have discarded everything else. Then in our own cases, when we try to reflect on the numerous faults of self cherishing, this reflection does not lead very far because of the level we are at. We are not at the level of where we understand the numerous faults of self cherishing and the force of striving for liberation for one’s own sake.
Then in our own case, we don’t have an inferential valid cognizer, which realizes this, and that is not sufficient. What we really need is a direct valid cognizer. So we must therefore train our minds over and again in this practice of the interchange of the self and of self and others until we reach a point where it is spontaneous as Nāgārjuna says in his Bodhicitta Vivarana. And once we have reached such a point, once we have trained repeatedly in the equalization and interchange of self and others, then we will be able, for instance, to dwell in the hell Avici, which is referred to in Buddhist scriptures for the sake of other sentient beings without any difficulty whatsoever. Then we will be able to give our bodies and speech to other sentient beings.
And it is at this point that we are able to take the engaging vows of bodhicitta of bodhisattvas, excuse me, and at that point, to engage in the practices of the six perfections fully, the perfection of giving, of ethics, of forbearance, of concentration, and of wisdom. And at present, I will take your questions. As consultant, please ask good questions, pure questions. In other words, questions on topic. Otherwise, I’m gonna fall asleep.
Okay. Yes. I’m waiting. In the three principal aspects of the path, Tsongkhapa mentions we’re carried along by the intense force of the stream of In Tsongkhapa’s three principal aspects of the path, there’s a passage on Bodhicitta that says, we are carried along by the intense force of the stream of the the four four floods tied by the strong bonds of karma, difficult to break, standing the ice our net of self grasping and completely enveloped by the great gloom of the darkness of ignorance. We’re born into existence where it end and suffer, basically, because of that.
So his holiness says that you can use that thought of developing bodhichitta for others, focus on yourself to develop renunciation. Right? So what what I’m wondering is with the sevenfold cause and effect method and the exchanging of self and others, is it necessarily the case that you need to have renunciation in order to develop compassion in great compassion as in the sevenfold cause and effect method. And is is it required that there has to be some understanding of emptiness in order to develop the exchanging of self and others method of. So if one wishes to generate fully characterized compassion in the context of the equalization of self and others, it is indispensable to have generated definite emergence previously.
On the other hand, there is no definiteness regarding the realization of emptiness. There are those who have realized emptiness before, but there were those who will realize emptiness after. Both of us. So you may be reflect you may be thinking of a quote His Holiness has made from my prayers. Okay.
So what is So what is honest is saying is in this verse, which I can give in English, having fallen in the four rivers and tormented by great suffering, this verse actually refers to the reflecting on one’s own suffering and it depends on that generating an awareness of the suffering of others. You said this many times. Mhmm. Well, Susie, second. The practice of great compassion, there is you say there are two method.
One is the seven cause and effect instruction, and the other one is Tonglen. Mhmm. Which method is easier inclined for people or is it equally everyone is different? Can can practice? So the practice of the equalization of interchange of self and others was a practice of the ancient Kadampas in Tibet, which was kept secret from the time of Atisha all the way down to Geshe Chekawa.
And it is Geshe Chekawa who thought that it would be a great pity if this practice was kept secret as it would be very beneficial during the time of the five degenerations, and therefore, he decided to make it public, in Tibet. Mhmm. Now the age of degeneration of the five degenerations is still with us. So this practice will still be extremely beneficial, and it can be linked with the practice of the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta. Just following on from that, Pabongka Rinpoche introduces the equalization and exchange of self and others by saying this is preceded by the same early sections we have done that is from equanimity up to love that comes from the force of attraction.
So it seems that he’s assuming that we would practice the sevenfold cause and effect method as a preliminary or leading into the equalization of itself rather so that that seems to be a bonus advice with you know, rather than have the two separate. Yeah. You’re trying. Yeah. Oh.
Yeah. I did that. In liberation in the palm of your hand, of the sevenfold cause and effect, it says there are eight subsections. The first is immeasurable equanimity, then six causes, and then the effect. So my question it stresses how you have to do everything sequentially.
So my question is, why isn’t immeasurable equanimity, which to me, it seems you need that first. Why isn’t that the first cause? Probably because the practice of equanimity is not indispensable here. There are those who train the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta relying on equanimity, and there are those who train without relying on equanimity. So regarding Chris’ question, I’d like to point out that we are not saying that there is one practice for generating bodhicitta which is good and one practice for generating bodhicitta which is bad.
What we are saying is that you should practice whatever benefits your own mind the most. We are all different. Then for some, it might be the equalization and the interchange of self and others. For others, it might be the sevenfold causal generation. For some, it might be both together.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. The generation of love and compassion, Geshe taught that the interchange of self and other method is supreme because you’re generating kindness for sentient beings of this life rather than in the sevenfold cause and effect the kindness of mothers of previous lives. Is it supreme because the objects of sentient beings in this life is closer to our own experience and therefore, it’s easier to generate a more powerful feeling of love and compassion?
You can already explain why the practice of the equalization interchange of self and others is supreme in your question. You answered your own question, I think. So in the case of the equalization and interchange of self and others, it is quite straightforward for us to reflect on the kindness of others in this life since everything we have, we have thanks to others. And therefore, it is easy to generate an awareness of the faults of egoism and the qualities of altruism. On the other hand, when we come to the sevenfold causal instruction, we must understand that all sentient beings are are mothers of yore.
To do this, we must actually generate a valid cognizer which has ascertained the existence of past lives, probably an inferential valid cognizer. Now this is very difficult to do. I would encourage you to think about these two means of training in Bodhicitta as follows. They are like one great river, which is present in the in the long run. Both are presented and one is encouraged to train in both since they come from different lineages.
The instruction of the equalization in the of the interchange in self and of self and others comes from Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva Charyavatara, where it is explained and where the sevenfold causal instruction is not explained in the slightest. It is not even alluded to. On the other hand, the sevenfold cause of instruction for the generation of bodhicitta comes mainly from the works of Asaṇga, his bodhisattva Bhumi, and from, Maitreya’s works, in which they explain and in which there is no allusion whatsoever to the equalization and the interchange of self and others, and they form one great river which you find in the Lamrim. So you can use either technique to generate bodhicitta. What matters is that you generate bodhicitta, not how you got there.
You understand that once you have generated bodhicitta, whether it is by means of the equalization and interchange of self and others or by means of the sevenfold causal process, they have completed their purpose. You leave them behind. Look at it this way. I mean, have to go to India from time to time. Then there are three ways to go to India.
You can go via Singapore, via Bangkok, or via Malaysia. What matters is that you arrive in India, not what road you travel. Then if you insist on traveling all three roads, you won’t have the money. Right? So if you travel to Singapore and then you come back and you travel to Bangkok and you come back and you travel to KL, you’ll have no money left.
What matters is to get to India. Likewise, what matters is to actually generate bodhicitta, not which technique you used. So whatever is in keeping with your mind is what you should practice. What is in harmony with yourself? So what works best for you?
Yes. What works best for you? Okay. Another? Equalization.
Mhmm. Equalization. Another? Christopher, I think. Is it?
Yeah. Time. Yeah. Yeah. Very long time for.
Yeah. So we should stop here for tonight. Please open the page now. Eight three.
Key terms in this teaching
- Avici narme (Tib)
- The lowest level of hell. LYWA
- bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
- Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
- five degenerations
- The degenerations that occur as human beings evolve over the eon of existence; they are: the degeneration of disturbing thoughts, of lifespan, of time, of view and of sentient beings. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.