1 h 38 min · 4,296 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues the teaching on conventional bodhicitta, explaining why both aspirations are needed and how great compassion and definite emergence lead to it. It goes on to the six perfections, covering generosity, ethics and forbearance, and why each is harder than the last. Questions on generosity, gossip and forbearance close the session.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 39m
UUID: 88f643f0-6e10-417b-b587-a28c584eb733
Words: 4,292
So as was mentioned previously, the definition or the meaning of conventional bodhicitta is a special mind endowed with both aspirations. Are you able to explain to me why both aspirations are necessary? Do I understand? Sorry. You have to speak louder.
Without both. The achieving full enlightenment, I think, is the with the wisdom aspect of the path. So if you just achieve that, as Chris said, that would be it wouldn’t it wouldn’t be the Mahāyāna Whereas when you add the psycho the sentient beings, then it becomes a bodhicitta and the method aspect. Is impossible to eradicate completely the self cherished attitude. So, therefore, we, unfortunately, cannot experience the the, you know, the highest state of the achievement.
That’s why. Yes. This is appropriate. Listen. So listen carefully.
The definition of conventional bodhicitta is, as was said, a special mind endowed with both aspirations. The reason for which both aspirations are necessary is as follows. The first aspiration is the aspiration for the sake of others. In other words, this is the wish to enact the welfare of others. If this aspiration alone was present, then this would not qualify as fully characterized bodhicitta since, for instance, great compassion is the wish to enact the welfare of others, but great compassion is not conventional bodhicitta since great compassion is the cause of conventional bodhicitta.
The second aspiration is the aspiration for full and utter enlightenment. If this alone were present, then such a mind would not qualify as conventional bodhicitta simply because such a an aspiration for full and utter enlightenment is present in the mind of solitary realizers, Pratyeka Buddhas, but Bodhicitta is not present within their minds. Therefore, it is necessary for fully characterized bodhicitta that both aspirations be present. So now, please, this has been well explained, from your side, why should these two aspirations be present? Please.
You say you’re repeating. Please repeat. Yeah. I nearly repeat. Two two parts of an evening.
So the first is enacting the wheel of others. I translate simultaneously. You just speak. And then the second part is full enlightenment. So the first part is similar to great compassion.
And that if if that alone is present, it’s similar to is similar to great compassion, which is not because it’s And then for the, the second part, if, full enlightenment alone, were what was needed to characterize bodhichitta, then that would not be suitable because Pratyeka Buddhas have that wish to attain full enlightenment without So that is indeed the answer. Now one must understand that to generate conventional bodhicitta, the totality of the, the path of the being, of the small, middling, and great scope are present a bit as a circle. So from your in your opinion, if the wish to benefit others alone is present, is such a mind bodhicitta or not? Good. Why?
Why? That’s it. Good. Precisely. Good.
Very good. Thank you. Then That’s very good. Then you have all understood. Yeah.
Is the mind striving for full enlightenment the meaning of bodhicitta? Why? So you are very straight or forthright, literally. You have understood everything. Indeed, the wish for full and utter enlightenment is present in the mind of solitary realizers, but Bodhicitta is not.
This is absolutely excellent. You have really understood the meaning of bodhicitta, its definition as a special mind endowed with both aspirations, and you now understand clearly why both aspirations and not either one of them alone is necessary. So I was wondering what how I was gonna present things today. And if I presented the definition of bodhicitta as a special mind endowed with both aspirations, would you understand or not? Then you seem to have understood.
Then maybe it’s over. Nice. Good weather. Now you know. A lot.
We go to the beach. You know? Because now we go to Vida. You know? I So feel.
That’s absolutely excellent. The notion of twin of both aspirations is fundamental. So, therefore, you have understood the importance of both aspirations. The first aspiration, the aspiration, for the sake of others, which refers, among others to great compassion, which is the cause of bodhicitta. Bodhicitta is not causeless nor does bodhicitta arise from a cause which is discordant with it.
Instead, bodhicitta must arise from a concordant cause. This concordant cause is great compassion. And then we can trace great compassion backwards through the paths of the middling and the small scope and its specific cause, which is the mind of definite emergence.
So at present, what precisely is conventional bodhicitta? Conventional bodhicitta within the sevenfold division of mind and awareness of Lorig might perhaps be said to be an inferential valid cognizer. It also might not. It is open to debate. The question is whether it realizes its object, is full and utter enlightenment by means of a valid cognizer or not.
It definitely is a conception, and it has a cause, definite emergence, which is also a conception. Now as to great compassion, great compassion is definitely not a valid cognizer. It is also conceptual. Since great compassion is a mind, a conceptual mind, which thinks if only all sentient beings were free from suffering. Now such a mind does not engage its object or sentient beings nor does it ascertain its object or sentient beings.
Therefore, it cannot be a valid cognizer. So just as a great compassion does not ascertain its object by means of a valid cognizer. Likewise, definite emergence, the cause of a great compassion, which is also a conception mind, cannot ascertain its object by means of a valid cognizer. This is a difficult point, but I think you will understand it if it is explained slowly. The what is after all definite emergence?
It is a mind which is striving for liberation. Then such a mind striving for liberation is generated through reflecting on the thoughts of cyclic existence, specifically on the thoughts on the truth of the origin of suffering and on its root, which is ignorance grasping at a self, as well as on an understanding of the abandonment, which is the abandonment of these thoughts. Should such a mind of definite emergence ascertain its object by means of a valid cognizer, it would have ascertained liberation. And at this point, one would have to say that one has entered the path. Therefore, it is really a particularly particularly happy experience to be able to generate bodhicitta within one’s mind stream, and for this, one must initially create its cause of great compassion.
Great compassion here must initially be trained with with respect to one person. It cannot be trained in the abstract with respect to all, and then it is extended from one person to the others. Therefore, the best way to proceed is to train with respect to other persons in this temple, reflecting on the fact that they all experience within their mind stream the afflictions and the sufferings which arise from the afflictions just as we do, and in dependence on this to generate compassion for them. Then once we have done this, there is probably no suffering within our mind. As is said, in a quote, where the mind of love is present, there is no suffering.
Indeed, we will have become close to others. So once one becomes accustomed to love and compassion, then as I said, there is no enemy. There is no focus for anger since we will have become close to all, and we will see that all without exception suffer from the afflictions just as we do. And the key here is mental suffering. Then we should reflect on the fact that in this temple, each one of us experiences the suffering of mental suffering and generate compassion for each other.
Then, obviously, if we cannot do it in a setting like this one, how can we do it on the outside? And therefore, one should proceed in this fashion, training in love and compassion. First, one should reflect on oneself, and then one should reflect on others. So now to generate the motivation for these teachings, let us meditate on it during a couple minutes reflecting on the fact that, really, if there was no mental suffering, there would be no suffering worth talking of. If we had no mental suffering, we’d probably experience very little physical suffering.
It is mental suffering which causes our face to change expression. It gives rise to physical suffering, and therefore, let us try to generate love and compassion for each other. And let us also meditate on the two aspirations which were explained as essential within the definition of bodhicitta and how they contain the totality of. And please open the page one we shall recite one, three, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, monthly offering, verse one and then three. You.
Therefore, after generating fully characterized bodhicitta within one’s mind stream, At that point, one engages in the practice or the training of the perfection, the six perfections, starting with the perfection of generosity. Here, this training in generosity counters avarice or stinginess within our mind stream. The totality of the paths of the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope have as focus the generation of conventional bodhicitta. Once one has generated fully characterized bodhicitta within one’s mind stream, at that point, one trains in the six perfections starting with generosity with as a goal to lead to an ever greater increase in bodhicitta. Therefore, one could say that the practice of the six perfections is training from one’s own side, and the practice of the accumulation and the means of accumulating disciples is training from the standpoint of others.
This is very beautiful, isn’t it? Ideally, we would generate this within our mind stream. And therefore, the totality of the paths of the small being in great scope have as a focus the generation and increase of bodhicitta. And at this point, one trains in the six perfections. So at present, what is the nature of generosity?
The mind of giving. Do you understand? Of generosity. So the intention of giving is generosity. And generosity is subdivided into three, the generosity of giving material objects, the generosity of giving dharma, and the generosity of giving the protection of fearlessness.
Now generosity is motivated by the wish to help others. Ethics also has a component for our own benefit. All of us have engaged and have the possibility to engage in the perfect or the practice of the perfection of generosity since generosity has three components. Mhmm. The generosity of giving material objects, the generosity of giving dharma, and the generosity of giving the protection of fearlessness.
Then this is the case because we have taken bodhisattva vows. Many of us have received many times bodhisattva vows from Kyabje Rinpoche. We have a commitment to protect these vows. The first of all is to practice generosity. And if we look at our own practice, we can see whether or not we have engaged in the practices of generosity, ethics, and so forth.
And if we have, we should rejoice. The perfection of generosity is followed by the perfection of ethics, and there is a rationale for this sequence because engaging in the perfection of generosity is less difficult than engaging in the perfection of ethics. One engages in the practice of generosity only occasionally. One does not practice generosity when one is sleeping, for instance, but one engages in the practice of ethics continually. One must always restrain, let us say, if one has taken the pledge to abstain from the 10 non virtuous deeds, one must always restrain from the 10 non virtuous deeds.
The nature of ethics is an intention to protect. An intention to protect from what? From inappropriate behavior. The term in Tibetan includes the first syllable which means manner. One must behave in a concordant manner.
And here, for instance, one engages in ethical behavior. And at present, if one divides ethics, ethics has three subdivisions, the ethics of restraint, the ethics of the accumulation of virtuous deeds, and the ethics of benefiting others. Now the meaning of the three subdivisions of the perfection of ethics is as follows. The ethics of restraint refers, for instance, to a restraint, which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtuous deeds. The ethics of the accumulation of virtuous deeds refers specifically to the protection of the bodhisattva vows.
And the ethics, which is an ethics which endeavors to benefit others, refers to the attempt to benefit others by means of one’s body, speech, mind. So the first subdivision of the perfection of ethics, which is the ethics of restraint from wrong behavior refers to restraining from wrong or unsuitable physical or verbal behavior. Now this restraint from exterior physical or verbal behavior, which is wrong, occurs in dependence on an inner mindset. And this inner mindset is one which rejects or abandons the afflictions which are the root of this wrong exterior physical and verbal behavior. This abandonment of the afflictions leads to an accumulation of virtuous deeds, and this is how the first subdivision of ethics, the ethics of the restraint from nonvirtue, is linked to the second subdivision of ethics, the ethics of the accumulation of virtuous deeds.
And now in dependence on the second category of ethics, which is the ethics of the accumulation of virtuous deeds through restraining from the afflictions within our mind stream and understanding that others are beset by the same afflictions, we in turn generate the wish to benefit them physically, verbally, and mentally, and this leads to the third subdivision of ethics, the ethics which tries to enact the welfare or perform the benefit of others. You can see that within these three subdivisions of the perfection of ethics, the first, the ethics of restraining from non virtuous behavior is easier to engage in than the second, which is the ethics of the accumulation of virtuous deeds. And the second is in turn easier to engage in than the third, the ethics of performing the welfare of others.
And therefore, it is explicit in the that one must protect one’s ethics, specifically the ethics of the abstention from the 10 non-virtuous deeds. This is clearly explained in Ārya Nāgārjuna’s letter to a friend in which he says ethics is the foundation of all qualities. In other words, just as ethics is the earth or the ground on which both motion and motionlessness occur, likewise, ethics is the foundation of all qualities. So now regarding the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues, this is mainly a physical and verbal ethics. It’s an abandonment of physical and verbal non virtues since the last, three mental non virtues refer more to the sphere of intention.
None of us is unable to try to abandon physical and verbal non virtues. Do you understand? Yes. Yes, understand, but I could not. So you ask a question during the teachings on the Bodhisattva Vows on lying about one’s attainment.
I think it was Near. Near. Yeah. So there were two questions. One was a question about how one could perform the great lie, lying about one’s attainments, if one was an ordinary being and didn’t have an attainment.
And the other question was Jim’s question about emptiness. So these are force which refer to future events. For instance, in terms of one’s future development, if at a future point one were to pretend to have attainments one didn’t have, then one would break one of the Bodhisattva vows. And if later on when we actually understand what emptiness means, one were to teach emptiness to those to whom it was unsuitable to teach emptiness, then one would break another Bodhisattva. So at present, lying about one’s attainments is probably something which is unrelated to us, but we must be wary because in the future, this issue might arise.
So now regarding the 10 non virtuous deeds, we must specifically be mindful of the faults of these seven non virtuous deeds of body and of speech. Recognize these faults as faults, And then at that point, we are able to abandon what is to be abandoned and practice what is to be practiced. Probably all great religions teach the abandonment of the seven first non virtues, killing, stealing sexual misconduct, lying, divisive speech, harsh words, and idle talk talk or gossip. And therefore, there’s a great benefit for us in abandoning these. Now after the perfection of ethics comes the perfection of forbearance or patience.
The nature of the perfection of forbearance is an untroubled mind or an intention which is untroubled. And indeed, when the mind is untroubled, as I said, there is no suffering. Sometimes people say, I have mental problems. It will be more accurate to say that their mind is troubled. Each of the subsequent perfections is harder than the previous perfection.
So the perfection of ethics is harder to practice than the perfection of generosity. And the perfection of forbearance is harder to practice than the perfection of ethics. Simply because the perfection of forbearance or patience is to remain untroubled when faced with inappropriate behavior from another, and this is difficult. So we shall stop here for today. And at present, you can ask questions.
Please, short questions, one question per person. And after everyone has had their turn, you can ask another question. I just wanted clarity on the generosity, the three generosities of objects, dharma, and protection from fear. I was wondering if there’s a fourth one that sometimes listed it as generosity of giving love and if that’s included in protection from fear or if it’s, just a psychological one. Yes.
The generosity of giving love is included within the generosity of giving dharma in the context of the practice of Tonglen, of giving and taking. In Tonglen, when we reflect on the sufferings of others, we train in the practice of compassion. But when we think of giving our roots of virtue to others, we train in the practice of love. Yeah. Okay.
Mentioned the word concordant when he was talking about sutrim. I’m just wondering if can talk a little bit more about concordant. In which context? Well By the way. Yes.
Did you share used the word in the So when one refers to ethics in Tibetan, or means manner and means law or discipline Mhmm. Then this is said to be or manner concordant with Concordant with the manner. How? Because it is concordant with the exceptional or highest behavior of body and of speech. Then if one’s behavior is at odds with the manner, in other words, ethics, then one goes to the law.
Right? One goes to jail. Yeah. And second, third, Fourth? Yes, Sheila.
About emptiness and teaching, can this be done in a delicate manner, like referring to the lack of permanence and that all things change like emotions and, you know, flowers die and our bodies change? So can it be taught in a very delicate way to beginners without actually referring to the emptiness of all things? So when one wants to explain the view, indeed, one should begin by explaining impermanence, then suffering, and so forth. Uh-huh. Geshe-la’s looking for a quote of Āryadeva.
Yeah. Have you caused you? Yep. Geshe-la, could you talk about gossip a little bit more? And I ask because I’m not really quite sure what it entails in this context.
So if a friend rings me and she’s very upset and she’s saying someone has treated her badly and I listen sympathetically, is she gossiping, and am I taking part in gossip, or would that just not be gossip? And the second part is if if someone is really gossiping, is it better to be a bit blunt and offend them rather than participate in the gossip? Because I I find this one is quite hard sometimes in society. So regarding your first question Mhmm. Know, if a friend of yours whose mind was troubled rang you up to explain her problems and you listened, then this has no particular relation to gossip or idle talk.
This is meaningful talk. It is not a meaningless chatter. Then regarding your second question, if gossip or idle chatter has occurred during the day, the best way to handle it is at night to recollect what happens, to generate regret, and to purify what happened.
And then And then as an opponent force to recite one rosary of, We all receive the transmission of this mantra, and it causes us to think about Bodhicitta. Nothing is better than that. I have a question related to the six perfections. There are two aspects to the question. The first is in terms of its difficulty.
The ease of generosity was linked to its frequency, and forbearance being a practice in a social context would also be occasional. Thus, would this not be easier than the constant practice of ethics? And if not, it seems to intimate a constant forbearance perhaps directed at oneself or one’s own practice. Mhmm. The second aspect of the question in terms of engagement, how can one properly engage in correct generosity without clairvoyance and wisdom?
This would be like an unqualified doctor that unskillfully operates on patients merely based on a good intention. Would it not do more harm than good? I’ll let you say each one of you now has two two questions. One question with multiple aspects. You’re very, very good Jewish traders.
It’s not the case that the perfection of forbearance is harder than the perfection of ethics because it is continuous. It is not continuous since in society, people are not always angry at us. But forbearance as such is much more difficult than ethics. So the practice of forbearance is also a practice one must train in, unlike, let’s say, the practice of generosity. And then it is only after having trained in forbearance that you can actually practice it, and then you wait for someone to get angry at you.
So to practice forbearance correctly, you need someone to get angry at you. And when it’s on the point of happening, you think, golly gee whiz. And this is why it is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, just as there is no greater sin than anger, likewise, there is no greater ascetic practice than forbearance. Therefore, train in the practice and study the practice of forbearance by all means. So regarding the question, Geshe-la remembers the passage of Āryadeva in his Chatuhshataka, the 400, in which Āryadeva says, at the beginning, lacking merit, train in causality.
In the middle, focus on the emptiness of an autonomous person, and at the end, focus on the view. In other words, the Prāsaṇgika view. Mhmm. And therefore, here at the beginning, oneself before teaching these topics, once you proceed in this way. And this is why says that before teaching the view, one must identify the person or the I.
Okay. Wait a minute, please. Because I Andrew. My question’s around, generosity. If Gonna just start.
I’ve lost my thought train of thought. Sorry. Just a thought. Around forbearance. Sorry.
If it is my understanding that forbearance is patience. If to show forbearance patience in the face of someone’s anger is to only make them more angry, how is that wise? How does that imply wisdom? So your question is about forbearance, not generosity. Your questions are very strange.
The issue here is not benefiting others. It’s benefiting one’s own mind. So if somebody else is angry with us, we have no control over their anger. Now we train in patience or forbearance irrespective of whether this is of benefit to them or not. Irrespective of the conditions which contribute to another person’s anger, our calming our own mind is of great benefit to ourselves and can benefit others.
Then if it doesn’t benefit them, what are we supposed to do about it? And Andrea. I, this question is about the generosity of fearlessness. I heard an alternative, or a different, interpretation of it, and I just wanted to check if it has any valid validity. And that is that, that a teacher demonstrates fearlessness having overcome, afflictions.
They have no fear fear in their mind stream, and so, through their actions, they demonstrate fearlessness to the students and, as an example. Is that, an acceptable interpretation of the generosity of fearlessness. The fearlessness of the afflictions. That is the thing. That they they overcome the afflictions.
I no longer have fear in their mind stream, and so they can be an example of fearlessness. That would qualify as the generosity of giving dharma. Right. The generosity of giving fearlessness would, for instance, be to save the lives of animals who are going to die. And by doing this, you give them the protection from fear.
For instance, if you save the lives of beings. Okay. It’s probably over. Mhmm. Okay.
All the members, don’t run away. Okay? I’ve got a very special letter for you from center and, you know, all the members. And please take, you know, one with you. And and the seminar the seminar previously for Ilya on the fifth has been transferred to the November 19th.
That’s three principles of the path. And just an advanced notice for on Sunday, November 20, 06:00 special. Guru Puja. Thank you. That’s the November 20.
06:00. Yeah. Yeah. And thank you for your kind $5 donation to the four day facility for the running of the center.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Some lists include a fourth type of generosity, giving love. Is it included in the generosity of protection from fear, or is it something else?
The generosity of giving love is included within the generosity of giving dharma, in the context of the practice of Tonglen, giving and taking. In Tonglen, when we reflect on the sufferings of others, we train in the practice of compassion. When we think of giving our roots of virtue to others, we train in the practice of love.