TBI Recordings – 01-120929 1329

6,071 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. The speaker answers student questions on training in śamatha (calm abiding) and the conditions it needs, chiefly ethics and reducing sensory distraction. He contrasts shamatha with mindfulness and with Theravada and Tibetan approaches to breath meditation. He explains choosing an object by one’s dominant affliction and recommends short daily sessions on a Buddha statue.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: 8dc81834-4b0c-4084-86d6-31ef813b383c

Words: 6,067

Then I’m at your disposal whatever questions you may have within the limits of my capacities. And if you don’t have any questions, I have questions for you. Yes. Yes and no. What are the conditions for śamatha?

Do you remember? Six. Not all six, but the key ones. That we have. But for instance, absence of noise, do we have?

No. You have relative absence of noise because you’re not doing you’re not practicing concentration. The moment you start meditating, noise is said to be the thorn in the side of the meditator. You actually need earplugs if you’re gonna do it seriously. You do you do need earplugs.

Then what about absence of desire, contentment, and generally speaking, a pure ethic? Do we have that? Not really. Right? If you’re a Westerner and you’re working, it’s difficult to attain śamatha.

Because to attain śamatha, and this is just a general presentation, you really need to receive oral oral transmissions on śamatha as well. You need to engage in up to 18 sessions a day, which last on average five minutes, five to ten minutes. You stop the session the moment concentration wanes. You’re aiming for very small sessions with perfect concentration. So for a lay person who’s, to be frank, not ordained or who at least doesn’t have lay vows, it’s difficult.

It’s almost impossible to attain śamatha. That’s the downside. However, it is perfectly possible to train in concentration. You won’t attain śamatha. I can I can give you my guarantee?

I mean, my teacher, Geshe Rabten, was the first Tibetan Geshe of his generation to attain śamatha. And he trained, he was asked by His Holiness the Dalai Lama to train two generations of Geshe in śamatha. Only a couple attained. Then his top western students were Alan Wallace, whom you may have heard about, and, George Dreyfus who became a Geshe. Both asked Geshe Rabten to go into six months retreat to attain Shamatha, and Geshe as a Tibetan as a typical Tibetan master will do in these cases, said neither yes nor no.

They went into retreat and they didn’t get it. Then they came back and they asked Geshe Rabten. He said, well, I knew you wouldn’t get it, but what could I say? You know? If it was that easy to get, everyone would get it.

However, what Geshela said this morning is very true. We can hope to reach if we can just progress to the second or the third level, that’s a big thing. That’s within our reach. But we need the preconditions. The first and most important precondition is some type of ethics.

You need at least lay vows. You need some boundary to the mind going out to objects of desire. Then, obviously, if you drink or you smoke, you have to give up drinking and smoking. That’s obvious. Right?

Then if you’re going to practice concentration, we’re talking of a very reduced level here. We’re not talking of śamatha. You have to reduce exterior distraction. Ideally, you wouldn’t work. If you work, then you have to have a time every day, preferably seven times when you practice śamatha or you practice concentration, it’s a better term.

Then you want to eliminate television. You want to eliminate the Internet, radio, nightclubs, going out as much as possible, laughing with friends. In every single case, your mind is going out. You can’t even begin to talk of concentration in that case. Then the best way to proceed, if one is serious for getting śamatha, is either take lay vows or become ordained, receive the complete instructions, not just only Lamrim Chenmo, but the middling Lamrim, and perhaps all instructions for your master who has realized.

And then once one has accumulated the merit, go into retreat until it happens, and it doesn’t necessarily happen. So does that answer your question? It’s a long answer, but It does. And it sounds like to paradise when you say that the. Much better.

So an increase in concentration, every one of us in this room can attain without question. śamatha, let’s not delude ourselves. You know, Alan Wallace and George Dreyfus did not, you know. Then some people have natural predispositions, but even then it’s not easy. Are there other questions?

Who is your teacher for mindfulness of breathing? Which tradition do you rely upon? So you made your own soup, basically. Right. And then you’re asking me why it’s not working very well.

What the what it is when you breathe. K. You’ve got So many you’ve got two different approaches. If we’re speaking of mindfulness of breathing, you’ve got two different approaches. In the Theravada and the Tibetan tradition.

So in the Theravada, it’s part of the vipassana trainings. It’s one of the four mindfulnesses. Then it is really not a practice to develop concentration. vipassana seems to be more about the sensory perception of breathing? No.

vipassana are practices to develop wisdom. Then forget everything you think you know about mindfulness of breathing. It makes things much easier. It’s being misinterpreted massively in the West. Just put it on the side.

In the Theravada tradition I presented first in the in the Mahāyāna tradition. The Theravada tradition, what is called Anapanasati, mindfulness of breathing or Sattipattana, which includes Anapanasati, is a practice which is designed to enable you to understand the three marks of phenomena. Suffering, impermanence, and non self. It’s therefore a practice which is designed to generate wisdom, not to generate concentration. In the Theravada tradition, there are separate meditations which are the śamatha meditations which they perform on what they know as Kasina.

Kasina are spheres of the elements. It’s a practice which is actively discouraged in Theravada because as a result of meditating on the elements, there are a lot of problems, physical problems and mental problems. So in the Theravada tradition, the practice of Shamatha is taught to be dangerous precisely because the object of meditation they choose is problematical. In the Mahāyāna tradition, we do not practice or we do not train śamatha with the elements as a basis because if you do, you get disruption of the balance of the elements in the body. That’s Theravada.

In the Mahāyāna tradition, the type of practice you are engaged in is actually a concentration practice. You concentrate on the flow of breath. And Je Tsongkhapa teaches that one has to concentrate on the inward and outer movement of breath, and it is a practice which is encouraged for those trainees which have very agitated minds, high levels of of mental agitation. Then what would you concentrate upon? If you do it in Je Tsongkhapa’s tradition, it’s the inward and outward movement of breath.

If you do it the way I was taught in the Mahasi Sayadaw tradition, it’s actually the sensation of movement of breath at the nostrils. Not everyone can encounter that here. No. No. No.

You you won’t feel it. You feel it here. It’s this area of the skin which will feel the inward and outward movement of breath. And it’s a very subtle object of meditation. Westerners, especially if they’ve done drugs, which is unfortunately very common, cannot find it.

Therefore, Mahasi Sayadaw taught a different technique of meditation focusing on the outward and inward movement of the stomach. But you have to be very clear what tradition you practice in and what your goal is. If your goal is some type of śamatha practice, then I think Je Tsongkhapa’s tradition is uncommonly powerful because I have never heard in Jitsongkapa’s tradition of problems arising from śamatha if it’s done well. Now if you go to a Thai, a Burmese, or a Sri Lankan temple and you say you’re practicing Kasina meditation, every Achan in the temple is gonna come up to you and warn you against this because they get promised because the object of meditation is not well chosen. You know?

So I hope that answered your question. You’re engaging in your own practice. It’s up to you to give us the answers. Nobody taught you to do this. Right?

I mean, you’re telling me it’s a Hindu practice with Buddhist components. Okay. Then you should start your lineage. What can I say, you know? I mean, either you have received a transmission, you consider somebody your guru in the Geluk or the Tibetan tradition.

You haven’t received a transmission. You do what he says and you ask him. Well, then you do your own thing. But if you do your own thing and I don’t advise you to meditate and do your thing because I’ve known many cases of people who get big problems, then you have to take on board whatever comes. Like, right now you’re telling me that you don’t know what your object of meditation is.

Then if you don’t know what your object of meditation is, you haven’t gone from the first to the second level. Right? Because how how can you practice not forgetting the object of meditation when you’re not not quite sure what it is? There’s a strong reason for taking simple objects of meditation, such as a statue of Buddha Shakyamuni. The strong reason is simply that it’s hard enough without having to struggle to find the object.

Then we are all attracted to these glamorous practices where you meditate on the nature of the mind. But it’s extremely hard. You’ve got to find the object and to find the object, have to know what the object is. It’s very difficult. So I’d suggest to you, if it’s śamatha you want to practice the Tibetan tradition, you cannot do better than relying on Lamrim Chenmo. And then if you read Lamrim Chenmo carefully, you will go as far as it is possible for you to go.

Then breathing meditation is very beneficial. But I think if we understand it in the Theravada tradition as a practice to develop wisdom and the three marks, I think that is much more effective personally. Does answer your question more? Yes. Yes, please.

So as I said, that is normally how it’s taught in Theravada. You are focusing on the sensation at the nose. These are not practices from our standpoints. We put it aside. It’s not taught here.

They’re very beneficial. If you want to practice mindfulness of breathing, please don’t wing it. Right? I mean, I know it’s very popular to make a big soup nowadays, but go to authoritative sources. Mahasi Sayadaw was the greatest Burmese meditator of his age.

He came when I was very young to Geshe Rabten’s centers. His books are available in English. You can order them on the web. It’s not difficult. If that’s what you want to practice, practice that.

It’s not. You It’s. You have other questions about. One thing I’d like to emphasize is you you should practice under the guidance of someone. I’m a little bit surprised by some of the tenor of the questions.

If you don’t have Guru Yoga, if you don’t have some type of reliance on a teacher, take my word for it, you can go off the deep end. I mean, I was in India, we had to catch these people back. And sometimes it’s not possible. They pick one book, they pick another book, they do this, they do that, a bit of chakra meditation, a bit of mindfulness, then they get experiences they can’t handle. It can be long.

It can be hallucinations. Then they come in a state of distress to a teacher whom they never consulted before and the teacher has to try to retrieve them. And Pabongka Rinpoche of Nechung Monastery was quite famous for being able to retrieve some of these cases. And the typical result is having done their own thing under nobody’s guidance and having run into big trouble and having been retrieved, they then say meditation is dangerous. This is nonsense.

Right? So if you don’t have a relation with a spiritual teacher at all and the question seem to indicate it’s not there, then at least rely on authoritative texts and consult a learned monk. No Asian would dream to start meditating by himself. It’s not done. And there are good reasons for that.

In the same way as you wouldn’t open an account trading shares on the ASX with zero previous experience and just start gambling your superannuation, would you? Are there other questions? I have a question for you. Why do you want to practice śamatha? You have all come to a seminar in śamatha.

What do you expect as results? You sacrifice the weekend. Right? Where where do you intend this to lead you? To be able to, you know, practice the meditation.

A Shamatha won’t help you for that. Analytical meditation is one thing. Concentration meditation is another. First, you engage in analytical meditation. Then once you have identified, let’s say for instance, you engage in analytical meditation on death and impermanence.

Right? Generate a strong feeling of the meaninglessness of this life through analysis. Then you concentrate on that. That’s concentration meditation. Shamatha will help you with that.

Only that second part. Somebody else, why why are you here? That’s pretty good. Yes. That’s that’s what shamatha is all about.

That’s good. That’s that’s what is all about. Yes. Somebody else? Yes.

Yes, please. Take an animal rebirth. Take an animal rebirth. A dog my dogs are always in the present. They’re not in the past.

They’re not in the future. Always in the present is not a goal. When you’re meditating, yes, as Geshe-la said this morning, then, obviously, your mind has to be focused on the object. But being always in the present, if you’re always in the present, you would practice no virtue, would you? Because to practice virtue, you have to think of the future.

Alright? You would not learn. We learn through memory. You look back at your behavior. You assess it.

This is a bit of a misunderstanding which comes from Zen. Right? There are all of these misunderstandings of Zen, where Zen is understood as this means of living always in the present. Animals live always in the present. It doesn’t seem to do them any good.

At least I I’ve tried to ask my dogs. They can’t answer. But if they could, I don’t think it would do them any good. What Shamatha practice can do, and I think maybe that’s what you’re addressing, it reduce conceptuality. Yes.

If mind’s very busy, it could become less busy. Yes. Yes. The first thing you notice when you start practicing śamatha is that your mind will seem much more busy than before because you started noticing what was happening all the time, which you weren’t aware of. Anyone else?

Why would you why do you want to practice śamatha? Yes. Yeah. That’s a good reason. Why do you think śamatha will help you to call yourselves?

What’s the problem with your motivation? Problem is you’re practicing the effect to get the cause. Ethics is the cause for attaining śamatha. Shamatha is not the cause for protecting ethics. So if you don’t have ethics, you won’t progress in concentration.

It’s true there’s there’s there’s a feedback loop. Right? But if you say you want to get śamatha to protect your vows, you’re putting the horse in front of the cart. You’ve got to protect your vows to get śamatha. Then with vows, the key idea is you only take as many as you can truly protect.

You have another reason for practicing śamatha. There you will need śamatha. Those are analytical meditations, prayers. Your mind is going from topic to topic. That’s not śamatha.

So I I’m sorry. I’m putting you on the spot by asking you these questions, but I’d like to bring out the misunderstandings. And I think it’s the best way to do it. You know? Then while you are praying, what are you doing?

You’re analyzing. If you do the seven limb prayer, you’re going from topic to topic. You’re trying to generate states of mind. You cannot practice śamatha while you’re doing that. Where Shamatha will help you is not Shamatha, but it’s a practice of vigilance.

Vigilance is that part of the mind. Krishna will talk about it maybe tomorrow or perhaps today, which when you are you start training in concentration, you have your object of concentration. Let us say the Buddha statue, but it could be, for instance, the sensation of the breath here. It’s not a good object for another reason, because it keeps changing. So it’s not a good object, you see.

Little statue of the Buddha is very good. The non Buddhists use a twig or stone. Then you focus ninety, ninety five, 98% of the mind on that. There’s a very small part of the mind. Better your concentration, the smaller the part of the mind involved, which keeps checking what’s happening.

Is the 95% still focused on the image of the Buddha which I visualize or has it gone off to think about my weekend in Bali or whatever? That’s vigilance. That vigilance will help you in, for instance, a seven limb prayer. That has to be present throughout our life. When we walk, when we sit as Buddhists, there should always be a part of the mind which is vigilant.

This is much closer to Theravada mindfulness meditation than to śamatha practice. For your goals, mindfulness is more helpful. Mindfulness leads to better protection of the vows because you are aware of what’s happening in the mind. With śamatha, you are training something else. So somebody asked, what are your reasons for practicing Shamatha?

Concentration. Totally. Well, if you are mindful, you’re aware of everything which is happening. You’ve all this is why there’s so many misunderstandings about Buddhist meditation. You practice, for instance, mindfulness of walking.

I think directed it in the temple once a price. Right? How do you practice this? You are mindful of every single component of the walking process, and you walk as slowly as you can while breaking them down. Lifting, extending, setting.

Then you break down the lifting into parts. If a noise happens, you are aware of the noise. Right? If a thought occurs, are aware of the thought. You are training in awareness of what is happening.

Why are you doing this? From a Buddhist standpoint, you are doing this because in so doing, you will become aware that everything is impermanent. It changes all the time. Everything eventually you see as suffering because you become aware that as you lower the threshold for suffering, your body is just invaded with all sorts of aches and pains. And eventually, it is said in the Theravada tradition through this, you can infer selflessness.

That’s mindfulness. You’re aware. Now śamatha, you are training to become unaware. Right? So a true Shamatha practitioner, when he actually enters in Shamatha, sees nothing, hears nothing, tastes nothing, and feels nothing.

All the sense consciousness is are turned off as if you flick the light off. All that is left is a mental consciousness. They are totally different. There’s no relationship. Then for normal practitioners, I think a bit of both is useful.

But if your goal is to protect your vows, it’s mindfulness you need. If your goal is to increase concentration, then it is śamatha you should be training, even though getting it is another story. So I I was very fortunate. I mentioned last time we had a Shamatha seminar to see, my teacher, Geshe Raptor, who had attained Shamatha, enter into śamatha. And when he entered into śamatha, as far as I could see from the outside, and I get evidence for that because medical tests were performed on him, the totality of his sense consciousnesses were shut down.

His body ceased to function as far as I was concerned. There was no breathing. There was no movement. There seemed to be no sight, no hearing. He was like a stone.

Then the doctor was very frightened, and the doctor thought he had passed on. You know? That is śamatha. You know for yourself, if you look at yourself, the best experience you have of training in śamatha probably is those of you who’ve gone to university. When you focus single pointedly on something preparing an exam, if you have good concentration, you can focus so hard, you don’t hear somebody who comes in the room.

Then that’s a sign you will do well at śamatha. If you’re one of those people who’s studying with music, you will not do well in the śamatha. There’s zero there’s zero concentration. The more exterior stimulus you need, the worse your chances for śamatha. That’s why when we start training in śamatha, in concentration, first, we reduce the level of exterior stimuli.

And that includes the object of desire, obviously. So does that help you better to understand the difference? Okay. Are there other questions? Yes, please.

You can attain śamatha on any object. You don’t need a visual object. As you for you, a musician, you can attain it through a tune. But it is said at least in in our tradition, in Je Tsongkhapa’s tradition, that śamatha is not attained through the sense consciousnesses. In other words, if you want to attain it through a tune, you would have to first listen to the tune, even better, a note, one note, and then enter in meditative posture and imagine hearing that note.

And on that basis, you can attain śamatha. You attain it through rhythm as a sound generality. Nobody does it, but actually in some of the practices of Kālacakra tantra, it is taught. You know? Normally, we attain śamatha on the basis of what we know as a meaning generality, which is visual.

Because eye consciousness is the most important consciousness for us. Right? We rely on the most important consciousness. So we take something we can see, typically a statue of the Buddha. We observe it carefully until we have a very clear sense of what it looks like.

And then we visualize a perfected Buddha in space in front of oneself with our eyes semi closed focused on the tip of our nose. This visualization is generated within the mental consciousness and then we train our mind on this basis. You can do it on the basis of a sound. You could do it on the basis of a bodily sensation. I think it’ll be complicated.

Then animals have often very good concentration. I was walking my dogs yesterday. I was quite surprised. They have concentration on the nose, on the the affective sensations. Surprising concentration.

Surprising. Does that answer your question? For most people, it’s easier with the eye consciousness. Then you don’t do it with the eye consciousness but with the mental consciousness, but the data you get through the eye consciousness. Right?

Then if you wanted to train in concentration in śamatha, you’d have to ask in serenity if it’s appropriate to take a sound as a support and you’d want to take a sound which is meaningful, not just a note. If you could hear, for instance, a sentence being uttered, a sentence of dharma, why not? I never heard of anyone doing that, but why not? Why not? It’s difficult.

That’s why, generally speaking, people practice with objects which are easy to find. That’s what I was telling Lily. You can go for the esoteric objects, but you have to keep the object. Right? Yes.

That’s very good. It’s an excellent motivation. I mean, you know, I think we don’t have access to motivations like bodhichitta, then yours is excellent. You want the teachings to be given. You are thinking of others, which is excellent.

Motivation’s excellent. You know? Not at all. We don’t understand the benefits of śamatha. Like, in India, you wouldn’t have to talk the benefits of śamatha because everyone in India or in Thailand my wife’s grandparents are great Shamatha practitioners.

My wife’s grandmother practices Shamatha on a candlelight, you know, to travel to the different grounds. Then you don’t have to convince them of the benefits of Shamatha. Shamatha is a gateway to paranormal powers, you know. In much of Asia, śamatha is practiced only for this. You know?

Because they know that paranormal powers such as telepathy, teleportation, levitation, and whatnot, forms of precognition exist. Then Atisha says that the gateway to helping others is śamatha for this reason. Because if we have śamatha, we can read people’s minds. Then when we can read people’s minds, we actually know what the problem is. All of modern psychology collapses on the fact that one actually doesn’t know whether what the person is saying to you is what the actual problem is or not.

it’s said it’s like trying to figure out what’s in the bag by feeling it from the outside. Right? Doesn’t work. Right? But if one has access to the person’s mind and someone who has śamatha can do this, then a great practitioner can say, okay.

This person is speaking to me about their money problem, but in reality, let’s say, it’s jealousy which is a problem. Then in that case, one gives the antidotes to jealousy. The person has never talked of this. Right? So that is why Atisha says Shamatha is the gateway to helping others.

And with that as a motivation, that’s a Mahāyāna motivation. It’s very good if you can have it. Are there other questions? Yes, please. So the Dhyanas are a result of training in śamatha.

Once you train in Shamatha, have access to the first Dhyāna. And then in the Theravada tradition, there still is nowadays a tradition of training and obtaining all four Dhyanas, the second, the third, and the fourth. Then these Dhyanas, the second, third, and fourth specifically, allow one to be reborn in the form and the formless realms of the gods, no longer in the desire realm. They are not taught in the Tibetan tradition because the Tibetans don’t see the benefit. With Shamatha, you have enough concentration to attain direct realization of emptiness.

That’s sufficient. You have enough concentration to become an Arhat in the Hīnayāna or to attain the path of seeing in the Mahāyāna. Then the higher concentrations, they only have benefit if you want to be reborn in the god realms. I think this is a little bit the critique of a kasina meditation in Theravada because there is this feeling it’s focused on obtaining paranormal powers. And Theravada monks I’ve heard talk about it, talk mainly about siddhi.

They call it in Pali. And it’s focused upon being reborn in the god realms. In other words, cyclic existence. So śamatha is good enough concentration for any single goal we might have within dharma. Then you have to see for yourselves if you believe in the god realms or not.

How is it possible for an immaterial spirit to exist? If you think carefully of the nature of the mind, I think it becomes pretty evident such such things are possible. It takes some thinking. Do you have other questions? Mhmm.

Sam, please. Why with the second stage, your mind is already more withdrawn. So you have started to withdraw the mind away from the sense objects. That is enough to say that you are basically meditating. You may lose your object of observation over and again, but you basically use recollection to bring the mind back to the object of observation.

That’s not bad. And then you can progress upwards. I just think we have to be very realistic about what we can attain. And that’s why these six conditions are always presented. Someone who wants to attain śamatha first puts all the conditions on his side.

And then it’s always said that it’s not difficult to attain. It takes six months. But in practice, we find that very few people get it. Then obviously it can’t be that easy. Right?

There are a lot more than 65. I mean, even in the Buddhist tradition, Prāsaṇgika says there are 300 per second. Then it’s obvious with the development of modern technology that there’s even there’s a lot more than that. Right? How percentages, I couldn’t tell you.

I mean, you know, I’m sorry that didn’t give his percentages. Try. Try and see where it leads you. I think if you take this text, you know, the third volume of Lamrim Chenmo, you’ve got everything you need in here, really. And you try it out, but do it in keeping with instructions which are given.

And Geshe-la didn’t talk about it this morning, but there is an important point in the selection of the object of observation. And this is well, we have five minutes. Maybe we’ll talk about this, and I’ll take the remaining questions too. Yes? I just finished saying something, and then I will I will take your question.

You should choose the object of observation in function of your dominant affliction. You have to know yourself. If your dominant affliction is desire, you take one type of object of observation, if it’s anger, another. And if you have no dominant affliction and they’re all the same, then you have freedom in choosing the object of observation. Now why is this the case?

Because if you have a dominant affliction, the moment you start you start reducing sensory input, which is what you do in śamatha, the dominant affliction comes to the fore. Let’s say one is choleric by temperament. Let’s say, you start focusing the mind inwards, so you’re moving from the first to the second level, the nine levels, anger is gonna rise. That anger is gonna prevent you from getting anywhere in śamatha. Therefore, if you are the choleric type, if it’s a dominant affliction, you need an object of observation which reduces anger so that you can actually get somewhere with śamatha.

That would be love. You’ve got for reducing desire, you would use as object of observation, foulness of the skeleton, the traditional meditations and foulness of this kind of decaying human body. For anger, you would meditate on love. Then typically they say for pride, you would meditate on a complicated topic tends to create humility. So the 18 subdivision of the constituents is a classic a classic one.

Then for doubt, nothing is given, but doubt is is put in the same category as mental agitation. For that, traditionally, one meditates on the breathing using the breathing as an observer object of observation. And for ignorance, one would typically meditate on the traveling. So this is if you have a dominant affliction. Then if they’re all the same, then you would use whatever you want with preference given to the image of a Buddha.

And then I have time for your question. Question. Very good reason to do it. I mean, that’s why we try to gain śamatha. Shamatha is not a Buddhist practice.

Right? Shamatha is a practice which is basically common to all the Indian religions. It’s present in Buddhism, Hinduism, and Jain. Probably the virtuoso of Shamatha are the practitioners of Patanjali’s Rāja Yoga. That’s the only practice they have.

Right? Now the Buddhists use this, as you said, as a tool for their meditation. You said, it’s a tool to make the mind stronger, literally, more concentrated. You want to reach with śamatha a level where your concentration is like an iron stream. It’s indestructible and it’s focused on whatever object you wanted to be focused upon.

You know? And that tool isn’t used as you say to realize renunciation, bodhichitta, emptiness. But to get that iron, that stream of molten iron focused on an object, you need the conditions. And the first condition is ethics and vows. Because ethics and vows are voluntarily withdrawing the mind out from some sensory object.

That leads, as Geshe-la beautifully explained this morning, to a training in recollection on the one hand and in vigilance on the other hand. Mhmm. Well, I just I just rely on. I think both are the case. Right?

The practice of patience or forbearance is an antidote to anger. Certainly, the practice of love is an antidote to anger. Certainly. It’s a very good way to put it. With mindfulness, your goal is for the spotlight to be as broad as possible.

If possible, infinite. Every single sense input, every mental experience is noted. Now with Shamatha, your goal is for the light beam to be like a laser. Exclusively focused on the single point. You can see that these are different practices.

Right? These are very different. Now when you practice mindfulness, you develop tools which are of use in śamatha. You develop vigilance. Right?

Vigilance is of use in śamatha. And then when you practice śamatha, you develop vigilance as well. So there is crossover. Then we have time for one question if it’s a short one. Yes?

I think the best way to do it is set aside from the rest of your practice five minutes. During those five minutes, you want the best quality meditation you can have. Everyday on the same object without ever changing the object. Like that, you will progress in concentration. That is the beginning of the eighteen five minutes a day of śamatha practice.

Then you want to do it in the morning. So it should be the first thing you do when you wake up. You choose one object of meditation. You never ever change after that. That’s really important.

So typically, a statue of the Buddha is a good way to go. You must first observe it really carefully. Do you have a very, very clear sense of all these qualities? Then if you can, you try to memorize the major and the minor marks of the Buddha, the 30 major, the 80 minor marks. And then when you Geshela will explain how to do this, you adopt the posture, you do the perfectly correct posture, the eight point posture, seven points if you don’t count breathing, and you visualize this statue of the Buddha in front of your eyes, the distance which is comfortable up to one meter, but it’s a bit far, maybe 80 centimeters, as large as you find it comfortable.

Not too large because that would basically, generate sinking, not too small. That generates agitation average. And then you are focusing on two factors, stability and clarity. It must be stable. You see at the beginning, it will want to move by itself or tilt.

And it may decide not to be of the color you had chosen it to be, which is very common. You’re focusing on yellow Buddha and it appears red, you know, and you want clarity. And then every day, five minutes, the moment the session degenerates, you stop. And if you do that, all of us, our concentration will increase. And then when you have time, you can do a retreat.

It’s up to you. Obviously, it’s best to do so. If you don’t have a lot of time, you are training in pure concentration here. You can attain it without a Buddhist motivation. I mean, the Hindus attain it with images of their gods, with stones, with pebbles, you know.

It is the mind which is being trained. And the best is to have a motivation to attain full enlightenment for the sake of others. For this, train in śamatha. You know? But if you start getting to the point where your motivation and all the other practices take up all the time, then where is the time for the Shamatha practice gonna come from?

So if you’re short on time, your motivation you generate before the other practices, you do a very short one here. A couple of seconds. Motivation, couple of seconds. Then five minutes. Five minutes for śamatha is a long time.

Long time. Then I think that’s all for today. Thank you very much. And then if you have other questions, please keep them for tomorrow. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
siddhi ngö drub (Tib)
A realization or attainment, either common or supreme. Common siddhis refer to psychic powers acquired as a by-product of the spiritual path; supreme siddhi refers to great liberation or enlightenment. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top