TBI Recordings – 01-120922 1518

11,852 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. The talk covers the meditation on a precious human rebirth: its importance for future lives, the general and specific karmic causes needed to obtain it, and the rarity of such a rebirth. It also explains the three types of karmic result and gives instructions for analytical meditation and concentration on this topic.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: 4586232b-9446-4920-936f-70e9163ff5c3

Words: 11,848

And I’m sorry for the short tea break, but we have a fair bit of material to cover in my apologies. I will be finishing, and it’s becoming a tradition, after the announced time. Obviously, if you have something to do, feel free to leave. Since we do not meet that often, I feel it is really helpful to go into these topics in-depth. And this particular topic may seem a bit dry at first, but if one starts reflecting about it, I think you will find it will change your outlook on life.

So you remember we said that there were three main outlines to meditating on a precious human rebirth. The first was identifying it, and this has been presented. We will go into much greater depth in a couple minutes with the specific karmic causes of each of the 18 features of such a life. The second is to reflect on its great importance. Why specifically is such a rebirth meaningful meaningful among among the the many many other other possible possible types types of of rebirth?

Rebirth? Because such a rebirth basically is the first step in a stairway which can lead us as far up as we choose to go. It can lead us to a higher rebirth, to liberation, to the practice of Anuttara Yoga tantra or to full enlightenment. Once we have put our foot on the first step, it is entirely up to us. So for all a human precious human rebirth is perhaps not as meaningful for this life as winning the lottery, which seems to be a contemporary obsession, it is far more meaningful from the next life onwards.

And how meaningful it is or becomes is entirely up to us. So you can see that a fundamental premise to an appreciation of a precious human rebirth is a conviction in the existence of past and future lives. This has to be laid down. And then I have drawn a series of quotes regarding its importance overwhelmingly from Essence of Nectar, which as we said is the lamrim rooted in experience. Temporarily, in other words, as far as this life is concerned, next life is concerned, whatever I want with this excellent basis, I can attain.

But this human rebirth also, if we engage in the practices of the being of middling scope, enables us to attain liberation as well. And there are cases known of Theravada practitioners in Thailand, in Burma, in Sri Lanka who, in the last century, did in one human life attain liberation. Such beings are known. My teacher received refuge from a very great, Theravada practitioner, Maharishi Sayadaw. He was Burmese, but he had many disciples in Thailand.

And Mahasi Sayadaw was said to have attained, full liberation. The one Geshe rapt and heard this, he was very keen to receive refuge from him again because it is said that receiving refuge from an arhat is extraordinarily rare. That is the result of one life of practice. A precious human rebirth can also lead us to full enlightenment. The state of the three bodies.

Or even as a gateway to full enlightenment, the practice of Anuttara Yoga Tantra. The slides are reversed. There’s only one difference really between ourselves and the great practitioners of the past and it is effort. If we look at our lives, all of us in this room, the difference between our life and the results of this life and the life of Milarepa and the results he obtained is just hard work. There’s no other difference.

As a matter of fact, in terms of what we came with, we came with much more than what Milarepa came with. Milarepa was basically an orphan at a very early age, destitute, little education, lived in poverty, and, practiced black magic to take revenge on his tormentors, killing more than 20 people. None of us in this room has this sort of background. You may have had a messy childhood. You may have been rambunctious as a teenager.

I doubt how anyone in this room has done time as we see in America. You’ve probably not been in jail. I doubt anyone has killed somebody. So we have a far better basis for practice than Jetsün. Jetsün in Tibetan means noble one, noble.

Jetsün practiced in a state of starvation all his life in an ice cave. The difference between his practice and our practice is the fierceness, the intensity of the practice. To put it blunt, we are slack and lazy. This is a defining feature of Western societies, especially prosperous Western societies like this one. You know, people don’t see any reason to practice.

Milarepa had direct experience of what life actually meant. And therefore, there was probably no need to give just Milarepa any teachings on liberation and on the necessity to generate renunciation. It was spontaneously there. Because of our soft lives, we do not have that. Then our tragedy is naturally that our lives are soft until the last days, won’t they?

I mean, some of you here are well above 60. Then at a certain point, you would have to leave this world. Have you made preparations? Do you know what would come or not? It’s up to you.

Nobody can do those preparations for you. But if those preparations are not done, you and you alone will have to to foot the bill to face the night alone. Then it is possible to try to forget about it. And this is, I think, our society’s message. Our society’s message is it is morbid to think in this way.

Try not to dwell on it. Somehow, with the progress of medicine, it would be possible to prolong life evermore. Whether the life we are being offered in this prolongation is a life we want is an open question. Certainly, with great old age, life is not pleasant. And if there has been no spiritual preparation of any type, death is very difficult.

Just yesterday, I got two emails. Two persons I know, one is connected with the center, the other is an old friend. Both experienced a collapse in their life. One is facing divorce, an unexpected divorce. The other lost her mother to a lung cancer, took five months.

With all of the refinements, you might always say refinements in torture, modern medicine has developed because chemotherapy in many forms basically amounts to torture. You know? There’s no or very little chance to lengthen the life of person the person and the suffering from chemotherapy is greater than the suffering from the cancer many times. Now what was very striking was the differences in reaction. One person is a dharma practitioner and the other has no dharma of any type, Christian, Buddhist, whatever.

The first person’s mind was basically fairly smooth. Difficulties can happen. The mind was broadly speaking at peace. The person had the inner resources to address the situation. The second friend from Switzerland whose mother died went to pieces.

Now this comes from lack of preparation, and this preparation only us can do. So the dharma we practice is up to ourselves. It has to be a dharma which is congenial with our minds. Nobody has to become a Buddhist. You may choose to be totally areligious, but do take the consequences on board.

Don’t be areligious and then come to the churches, to the Buddhist centers, to the mosques and the synagogues six months from your passing when the doctor has told you that this is it. In a state of advanced panic, trying to find solutions you had fifty years to find. Because the truth of the matter is you will not find them. And we do see even a TBI, a large or fairly large number of people coming in that situation, and it is broadly speaking, experienced, it’s very difficult to help them. They come in a state of fear or panic.

They really they want quick answers to problems which do not accept quick answers. They want ready made solutions to problems which don’t accept ready made solutions. The work has not been done. So it is much better for the going is good, and I think for most of us in this room, the going is good, To put a little bit of effort on a weekly basis to try to find an answer to the big questions and the biggest question every one of us has to face is, what comes after death? Is there something or is there nothing?

And we have to live in function of the answer we find. If we address this question early on, then we have good hope to find an answer we are comfortable with. In my personal case, I am profoundly convinced it is actually possible to find a true answer. I think it is there there is quite a bit of data in that direction. If we keep evacuating this question, it will not be a question we can solve within six months at the end of our life.

And then the hardship is tremendous. So these are the reasons for which one has to try to engage in these reflections and to do this earnestly and sincerely. So contemplating the rarity of the human rebirth is a third feature of meditating on a precious human rebirth. And one can contemplate its rarity from a Buddhist standpoint. First, from the standpoint of the causes which are needed to obtain such a result.

This is something Khensur Rinpoche in particular has taught several times at TBI, relying largely on Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s Lamrim Chenmo. The general causes of a human rebirth are fourfold. The most important cause is ethics. Without ethics, there is no human rebirth for a very simple reason. Because the defining difference between man and animal is restraint.

A human being has the capacity to restrain instinct, to say no to a person. The greater that capacity for restraint, the more developed the human being. The lower the capacity of restraint, the more the person, the lower the human being. And we all well know that, you know, many such people end up in jail. They end up with drug problems.

They cannot control themselves. Anger arises, the fight. Jealousy arises, the attack. They want to drink, they cannot restrain the urge to drink alcohol. They want to take drugs, they cannot restrain the urge.

So that restraint is the foundation of ethics. And that training and restraint is what is meant by ethics. Abstaining from what is non virtuous and practicing what is virtuous. This is a foundation for human rebirth. If in this life, we are able to train our minds in this way, in future lives, we will be reborn as human beings.

In addition, the practice of generosity which creates down the line down the line prosperity, not just being reborn as a human being, but being reborn with decent material conditions in a wealthy or well developed country. And the practice of patience, which gives rise to congenial conditions in a good physical appearance from a karmic standpoint. And finally, prayers which dedicate these three practices to obtaining this result. If these four elements are present, ethics, generosity, patience, and powerful prayers, it is guaranteed karmically that we will obtain a human rebirth. But the foundational element is ethics.

And this is why Yeshe Tsondru says, to gain the opportune fortunate rebirth in particular, each fact is cause of the 18 must be achieved. So we’re returning to our previous diagram. These are the general causes of a human rebirth, ethics, generosity, patience, prayers. To obtain a precious human rebirth with all 18 features, the causes of each of these 18 features must be accumulated. Now if we look to clarify our ideas of the general structure of cyclic existence with the six realms, the hell realms, the hungry ghosts, animals, humans, demigods and all three god realms subsumed as one, precious human rebirths are a small proportion of the human realm.

It is not enough to be reborn as a human being through these four sets of general causes, ethics, generosity, patience, and prayers dedicated to this end. We need in addition 18 sub causes to give rise to the 18 results of a precious human rebirth. So in terms of the cause, can see that a precious human rebirth is difficult to obtain. And I will have to make a brief excursus on karma before presenting the precious human rebirth in those terms. This is an example which Khensur Rinpoche always uses as an example for karma.

Now in terms of its results, karma can be distinguished into the ripening effects, the causally concordant effects, the environmental effects. The ripening effect of a karmic deed is being reborn in a given realm as a human being, as a god, as a demigod or in one of the lower realms. The causally concordant effect is the effect in a future life which is similar to the cause which created it. For instance, one was angry in life one, then in life number two, one actually will have a strong proclivity towards anger. It will already be part of one’s continuum.

One has predispositions for this. The environmental effect is the effect in a future life of the environmental with the effects in our environment, in our surroundings of deeds we have done in a previous life. So analyzing them one by one, if we take the ripening effect, the ripening effect, in other words, a rebirth can be a rebirth as a human being. Here’s a great Indian physicist Satyendra Nath Bose, one of the great minds in the twentieth century. It can be a rebirth as a dog.

It can be a rebirth as a hell being who is inseparable from fire, it can be a rebirth as a hungry ghost. These are ripening effects. They ripen into a future existence, a total existence. The causally concordant effect is within that given existence the proclivities of the person. Some are reborn as human beings as mother Teresa with a natural inclination towards compassion and goodness from an early age.

This is a result of past lives engaged in deeds of compassion. Some are reborn also as human beings but with a natural proclivity towards sadism and cruelty. This is a case of Lavrenti Beria, the head of the NKVD, the domestic intelligence service of Stalinist Russia. Both human beings. That both have the ripening result of a human rebirth, But the one through karmic habituation of the past lives became a nun, traveled naturally to India to help the destitute and the poor.

The other through habituation in past lives, became the armed hand of a totalitarian regime and committed atrocities. And finally, the environmental effects are the environment we are born in. Or maybe reborn in a beautiful and clean environment such as Australia or in a slum in India. The karmic result of sexual misconduct is being reborn in a dirty environment because the deeds themselves are dirty or filthy. The karmic result of sexual restraint is being reborn in a clean environment.

So if you want to be reborn in Australia, again, behave yourselves. Otherwise, look at the pictures. Now in addition, as we said to the four general causes for human rebirth, which are ethics, generosity, patience and prayer for that rebirth. We need specific causes for a precious human rebirth. And if we analyze them at present, we can see.

These are the 18 factors of a precious human rebirth. The eight freedoms and the 10 endowments. Five endowments from one’s own side, five from the side of the environment in your handout. Now if we analyze the causes and this is my own work, I actually have never seen such an analysis but it is possible. Each of these 18 factors has its own individual cause.

It is necessary. What would be the cause of not upholding wrong views? It would be in a previous life rejecting wrong views. The cause of not being an animal would be engaging in ethics and for Buddhists, especially Western Buddhists, avoiding wrong meditation. If one meditates, for instance, on Shamatha wrongly and actually is training one’s mind in subtle laxity, when it’s creating the karmic causes for rebirth as an animal.

Likewise, the karmic cause for not being a hungry ghost is being generous. The karmic cause for not being mentally retarded or mute is not lying to the spiritual teacher precisely because the spiritual teacher is such a heavy object. A specific karmic cause for being human is not being too close to animals. Generally speaking, it is very good to have pets and to be friendly with one’s pets. But if one is excessively close with one’s pets, then there is a risk of identification.

I’m not saying you’re gonna start barking. It is possible. But what happens is eventually these karmic seeds can be implanted. And I’m not looking at my wife when I say this. I think her love of the dogs is very innocent.

And you can see here that if we want to obtain in a future life these 18 causes of which really only 14 can be obtained, The, four at the bottom of this list could only be obtained during a Buddha’s life. We have to in this life train in their causes. It’s not sufficient to make prayers to obtain them. We have to create the conditions. And if we analyze these 18 features of a human rebirth of leisure and environment from the standpoint of the three karmic causes we spoke about, we can see that five of them are effects of maturation.

You want to avoid an effect of maturation of being reborn as an animal, a hungry ghost, a hell being or a long lived deity and you want the effect of maturation of being human. Then you have a series of concordant effects which are in harmony with past life behavior, not holding wrong views, not lacking a conqueror’s teaching, not being mentally retarded or mute which would arise with training one’s intelligence in a previous life. With complete sense faculties having reversible comma, for instance not being habituated to terrible deeds such as hating one’s parents, trying to harm one’s parents, which eventually could lead to parricide or matricide. Having faith in the source, these probably fall in the category of concordant. Effects.

And finally, there are the environmental effects that a Buddha has visited as an environmental effect. It’s on it’s our environment. He has taught the teachings remain. They are followed. There are benefactors.

We are born in the central land and we are not an ignorant person in the border area. So you can see that if you want to meditate carefully on a precious human rebirth, it is a difficult topic. It’s a difficult but important topic. It is something we have broadly speaking obtained. We have approximate human rebirth in this life.

We want to get one in the next life. The only way to do so is to create the causes. So we must know the general causes for human rebirth, which are the four causes, ethics, generosity, forbearance, and prayers. And then we must know the 18 features of a human rebirth we want to obtain and try to obtain the karma for this and make prayers to obtain it. That this is rare is proved by the small number of students here today.

Adelaide is a city of one and some million. In a city of one and some million, how many attend the teachings at Buddha House at TBI? And there are a couple other Buddhist temples in Adelaide, the Thai Buddhist temple in Vietnamese. All in all, I would say, you certainly don’t have more than one or 2,000 persons out of 1,000,000, which means that one out of 1,000,000 has some type of connection with the teachings. That connection with the teachings comes from a past life.

It’s not an accident. That connection with the teachings must be created anew for future lives. So that in the future, we do not end up all alone. And finally, we should contemplate the rarity of a human rebirth from the standpoint of its effects. So said that, if you consider the totality of beings, the number of human beings is extraordinarily small.

But if you actually consider human beings, the number of precious human rebirths among human beings is even smaller. And this is something which is evident if we look at a pyramid, a biological pyramid of life. If we assume that bacteria are conscious, which is a possibility, you have some five by 10 power 30, notice five with 50 followed by 30 zeros, bacterias on this planet. 10 power 18 insects, in other words 10 followed by 18 zeros insects. You have 230,000 types of marine life species species and around 8,700,000 animal and avian species.

There’s between two and four hundred billion birds. Human beings are only 7,000,000 and Buddhists, a high estimate is 350,000,000. Of these 350,000,000, it will be surprising if 10% practiced, maybe less. So I was very generous. I put the boundary here towards the middle.

I think if you put it up there, you would be closer to the truth. Then among the Buddhists, have one to one and a half million monks. Many monks nowadays are sociological monks. It is a sociological position in Buddhist societies. Yet again, how many of them practice sincerely?

It is hard to say. Finally at the top of the pyramid, you have the holders of the three vows which exist mainly in the Tibetan tradition and in the Japanese Shingon tradition. These are practitioners who hold monastic vows, bodhisattva vows and tantric vows. You can see that if we look at the gigantic massive beings at the bottom of the pyramid, we have, if we are very generous, a 150,000,000 beings on top who have something close to a precious human rebirth, a proximate human rebirth of leisure and endowment. This is very small.

These are the beings who can attain liberation and full enlightenment. Then from human beings up to this point are the beings who can attain a higher rebirth in the next life through their efforts in this life. Below this point, nothing can attain a higher rebirth based on efforts in this life because it is impossible to engage in any type of restraint. A dog cannot engage in restraint when he sees a rabbit or mouse run-in front of him. He is overwhelmed by instinct.

A dog, a cat, however much we like our pets are animals which live to kill. They live if they kill. The saving grace for pets in western countries is that they are saved from the activity of killing because we feed them. So they do not accumulate a heavy karma of killing and then if in a previous life there was some virtuous karma, then hopefully that could mature. That is the only hope they have.

Otherwise, once one has fallen below the human level, the chances of a higher rebirth are almost nonexistent. Almost nonexistent. Finally, we should contemplate the rarity of a human rebirth through examples and here’s a famous example you all know is the example of the sea turtle, which originally was taken from a sūtra in the Pali Canon, the Chiggala Sutta. In the Chiggala sūtra, the example which is given is that of a blind sea turtle which surfaces every century. And Buddha Shakyam when he says, it is likewise a sheer coincidence that one obtains a human state.

The words are very strong, a sheer coincidence. It is likewise a sheer coincidence that a Tathāgata, a Buddha worthy and rightly self awakened arises in the world. If you reflect on what a precious human rebirth means, it is not just being reborn as a human being. And from one’s own side, not having wrong views, being able to understand the teachings, having the sense organs. But one must be reborn at a time when a Buddha actually taught.

One must come in contact with the teachings. One might very well be reborn in Africa when the Buddha was born in India as a human being and never even hear the name of the Buddha. There are many living beings on this earth on this earth who have never hear heard the name of Buddha Śākyamūni. Then the possibility of practicing the teachings is non existent even though they have human rebirths. A different form of this metaphor is given in Nāgārjuna’s letter to a king in which he says, since once an animal it is harder to obtain a human rebirth than for a turtle to meet the aperture of a yoke afloat in the same ocean, powerful among men obtain the result through practicing the holy dharma.

So you can see that once reborn as an animal lacking the capacity to discriminate, it becomes impossible in that life to create the karma for human rebirth. Your only hope is some pre existing karma. And that pre existing karma must meet the circumstances which allow it to mature. This is why, let us say, in the square kilometers surrounding TBI, there are maybe 1,000 human beings and there are probably two to 3,000,000 insects, if not more. Then there are eight specific qualities which may or may not be associated with a human rebirth, a precious human rebirth, the so called eight ripened qualities.

These are the features of a powerful rebirth. It’s these are the features of a human being who is able to impact on society. And these are features which all Buddhists try to cultivate and especially practitioners of the Mahāyāna try to cultivate since the goal of the Mahāyāna is to help others. So I gave two examples of non Buddhist monarchs because it is perfectly possible to be a non Buddhist to have the eight ripened qualities. The great French sun king, Louis the fourteenth, who was the most influential king in Europe at the end of the seventeenth century.

And the Roman emperor Augustus who spread Roman law throughout the totality of Europe. In both cases, they had the eight features or the eight ripened qualities. They had a long life. Augustus lived, I think, almost eighty years. A handsome body.

They were born in a high family. They had great personal wealth. They were trustworthy. They had power. They were male in an age where being male gave one power.

Nowadays, that probably would not apply. And they were strong of mind and body. These eight qualities each have their individual cause which had to be cultivated in a previous life. Long life comes from non violence. A handsome body comes from patients.

Being born in a high family comes from humility. Great wealth comes from generosity. Trustworthiness comes from honesty in speech. Power and great wealth come from generosity towards karmically potent beings, not ordinary beings. Being male comes from preferring manhood.

And being strong of mind and body comes from taking duties upon oneself. Should such a rebirth with the eight privileged features be conjoined with a precious human rebirth, the capacity for tremendous good is possible. And we see this in the lives of the great dharma kings. I included Ashoka despite his short life because in all other respects he had the eight qualities. Ashoka, as you know, spread the Buddhist teachings throughout India.

He renounced the military campaigns he led and is held to the present day as an example of a dharma king. I also included the example of king Bumipal, known frequently as Rama nine the great, who did so much for Thai society and who clearly has a proximate precious human rebirth as close to a human rebirth as is possible when not living in the age of the Buddha and has all of the features of such a great being. Those of you who know who remember history remember that it was the king who actually prevented Thailand’s collapsing into civil war in the early nineteen nineties by calling both parties in front of him during a television interview and asking them to find a solution. These are the deeds which someone who has a precious human rebirth and in addition has the eight ripened qualities of a long life, handsome body, high family, wealth, trustworthy speech, power, manhood, and strength of mind and body can do. So these eight causes must be cultivated especially by Mahāyāna practitioners who wish to work in that direction.

I could have given other examples, but I chose the example of the king of Thailand because he is a contemporary monarch, the longest ruling monarch at present. And the traditional examples of King Songtsen Gampo and King Trisong Detsen who in the case of Trisong Detsen sacrificed his life to allow Buddhism to be brought to Tibet don’t seem to be terribly meaningful to a western audience. They simply don’t seem to resonate. It’s too far removed. So at present, what I’d like to address with you are some case studies to see what are the features of an incomplete human rebirth and what the features of a proximate human rebirth of leisure and endowment are.

And I will rely on Ian Stevenson’s work. Professor Ian Stevenson who is the founder of the division of perceptual studies at the University of Virginia, Chester Carlson Professor of Psychiatry and his assistant Doctor. Jim Tucker. The first rebirth I would like to study with you is a partially deficient human rebirth. This is a rebirth of a young Sri Lankan boy, who actually was born in Sri Lanka in 1947 with a very marked physical deformity of the right breast and arm, which you can actually see on this picture.

He suffered from what is known as hypoplasia of the right arm. In other words, a markedly undeveloped right arm as well as other major deformities. What is striking is that this young boy resembled his father’s deceased brother, Ratna Hami. He was actually much darker than other members of the family. And as a little boy at age two, he said he had been born with a withered right arm because he had murdered his wife in a previous life.

These were the first words he said. Now the features of the case are that in his previous life, he believed his wife to be had become influenced by another man who had persuaded her not to finalize the marriage. He remembered clearly in this life as a little boy pleading with her to come to his home. She refused. He remembered sharpening a dagger to kill her on a plank under an orange tree, and he clearly remembered stabbing her to death.

He was accused and remembered being accused of the murder of his wife, Podi Menika, in 1927 and remembers being sentenced to death. Keep in mind this is a child. Then he remembers that five days before his death, his brother arranged an almsgiving to monks on his behalf in the prison. At that time, he told his brother that he would return. These statements are often extraordinarily potent.

They amount to vows. He remembered his execution by hanging And what is very surprising in a child, he remembered the details of the execution. He remembered that the gallows were tried by hanging a bag of sand. He remembers specifically a Buddhist monk offering last rites. He remembers a black hood being placed on his head.

And he remembers thinking of his brother as his last thought as the trap was sprung. And what is surprising is that he remembers after his death falling into a pit of fire. For those who say that there are no, accounts in Stevenson’s work of lower rebirth or hell rebirth, this is a clear, case, you know, which demonstrates that that is not so. Then Stevenson who investigated the case says that a strong argument in favor of the veracity of the case was that the father of the child, did everything in his power to prevent him from talking about it. It was a very loaded case in the small area of Sri Lanka where they lived.

Out out of fear retaliation by the family of the deceased wife. If we examine more carefully the birth defects which are concordant with events in the previous, life, we have hypoplasia of the entire right arm, absence of the pectoral muscle which is completely absent in the child and the right rib was markedly underdeveloped. And finally, the middle phalanx, in other words, the middle part of each of the digits of the right hand was completely absent which you can see in better detail here. Now this is a rare combination of deformities. It occurs in one out of twenty thousand cases and it had never occurred in either family.

Himself considered the malformation of his hand as caused by his murder of his previous wife. And you can see clearly here the absence of the pectoral muscle and the underdeveloped third rib. Now what is very striking in this case is that the young boy considered that this was a karmic result of stabbing his wife in the right breast. It turns out he didn’t stab her in the right breast. And this leads to some major questions.

It clearly from our standpoint seems to be a karmic result, but it also seems that karmic results can be less specific than is often thought to be. A deformation in the upper thorax when the person was stabbed in the upper thorax is a natural result. Whether the person was stabbed to the left or the right seems less relevant. What is very striking in Vijayaratne’s outlook is that clearly he suffered from a case of extreme wrong views as a young man and therefore this rebirth cannot be said to be a rebirth of leisure and endowment. Vijayaratne believed that it was legitimate to murder to cleanse one’s honor.

He had been spurned by his wife to be. Marriage in Sri Lanka occurs in two stages. There’s first a formal acceptance of marriage, and then the wife actually moves to her husband’s house. She had formally accepted him, but then refused to move to his house and was seeing another man. His honor was stained and he felt it legitimate to take revenge.

This is a clear case of wrong views. However, his outlook changed and by 1969, he had a very clear sense that this was inappropriate and that in keeping with the Buddhist teachings, it would be preferable to admonish one’s wife. And if she chooses to disregard the admonishment, simply separate. Now what is striking in Vijayaratne’s case is that there were clear concordant effects within this life of the effects of the causes in previous lives. The pattern in Vigeratne’s previous life was one of infatuation, rejection and then violence.

In this case, in this life, had two psychotic episodes. The first at age 22, during which he became infatuated with a girl in high school, whom he said reminded him of his wife in a previous life. She rejected him and then surprisingly he became delusional and thought he was a bird and actually adopted all of the mannerisms of a bird. He started hopping, gathering twigs to make a breast, to make a nest and so forth. He was eventually diagnosed with hebephrenic schizophrenia.

Then a second episode of psychotic breakdown occurs a couple of years later in 1973 with the same pattern, infatuation, rejection, psychotic episode. It is clear that Vijayaratne had memories of non human previous lives. He has a clear memory after his execution of dropping into a pit of fire which in Buddhist terms looks like a memory of a hell rebirth and then he has a clear memory of flitting through the air and perching on treetops which seems to be a memory of a rebirth as a bird which then was activated during the psychotic episode. In this matter, it is very interesting that Stevenson should say, I have generally adopted the policy of not including references to lives as subhuman animals that have occasionally come into some cases of the reincarnation type that I have investigated in a footnote. It’s lost in a footnote in one of his early works, 20 cases suggestive of reincarnation.

In other words, there was a systematic bias in Stevenson’s research against non-human rebirths. So if we now try to analyze the unfolding of the recollected lives of Vijayaratne, we have one human rebirth as the brother of his father between 1904 and 1928, during which he was rejected by his second wife. He murdered her, stabbing her with his right arm in the thorax and he was executed by hanging on the gallows. Immediately after this, we have a hell rebirth with only one memory, a memory of fire. It is quite striking.

I have always had the feeling that one of the reasons for which non human rebirths are difficult to remember is simply because there is so little to remember. If you were reborn, let’s say, as a cow for instance, what would you remember? You’d remember grass and grass and more grass. There would not be the sense I am a cow. If you were reborn in the hell realm, what would you remember?

Terrific suffering. That would probably be it. Then after this hell rebirth we have an animal rebirth as a bird flying from tree to tree and then a human rebirth in 1947. So we see broadly speaking that there are some nineteen years of hell rebirth and since the lifespan of an animal or a bird is quite short, a couple months, maybe a year as a bird. And then in 1947, Vijayaratne is reborn.

You can see here, we will analyze it carefully in a couple of minutes. Reborn rejected by two different women, psychotic episodes ensue, right arm and digit atrophied, chest muscle atrophied and third rib atrophied. Now you can see here that the hell rebirth and probably the animal rebirth are results of maturation of the non virtuous deed of murdering his wife. In the immediate life after this non virtuous deed, the rebirth is that of a hell rebirth. Killing committed with great anger towards someone who is karmically potent, one’s wife to be.

In the subsequent life, there are still residual effects and therefore there is an animal rebirth. And finally in the human life which ensues, which is a result of previous virtue which may have been accumulated previously, you find effects which are concordant with the cause. Just as Ratna Hami was rejected by his second wife, so is Vijayaratne rejected by two subsequent women. However, instead of giving in to anger, psychotic episodes ensue. In one of which details of the animal rebirth as a bird arise.

So this is an analysis of the case. And it is an interesting case because it’s one of the few cases in which one can clearly have see that there are some memories between the death of the previous remembered personality and the present rebirth. In many cases, there’s a sizable interval but the subject has no memories. Then the question we have to ask is was Vijayaratne’s birth a rebirth of leisure and endowment? Clearly not at the beginning at least since strong wrong views were present.

Then even though Vijayaratne was physically deformed, he his sense organs were not affected and his mind was not affected. So later on in life when these wrong views eventually abated, one could say he had a proximate human rebirth. Certainly not in the first part of his life. Certainly not. And the second example I would like to cover with you is that of a proximate precious human rebirth.

Another Sri Lankan case studied by Stevenson, the case of Wijeratne Adhikari. Which is quite an extraordinary case. This is a young Sri Lankan boy born in 1957 who at age four started talking about his previous life. He had very clear memories of where he used to live, a neighboring village, some eight kilometers from where he was born. Clear memories of his former mother that she was wealthier than now.

Clear memories of his previous house. Details that the house was blue with a tile roof. He remembered a guava tree grew in front of the house, and he remembered the house was near a culvert. He also remembers a very short rebirth as the basically stillborn son of his present mother. The child died, I think it was one hour after birth.

And he was able to recognize his previous life’s mother. Then he gave some embarrassing detail. He remembered that his previous mother had teeth. His present’ mother didn’t, the sort of thing a mother doesn’t want to hear, especially. He remembered having specific toys.

He remembered his nicknames and the profession of his mother in a previous life. And if we analyze the two lives, the present life of young Wijeratne Adhikari and his remembered life which was identified. It’s a verified case. Steven actually traced the case. The young boy was fascinated by cars.

In his previous life as Ananda Mahipala, he owned and drove a car which is very rare for the period in Sri Lanka. Now it’s common but at the period definitely not. He was very close to his mother in his previous life and remained very close in this life. And then there is a surprising series of gaps and we’re to analyze them. In his previous life he ate meat.

In this life he was a vegetarian. In his previous life, he was not religious. In this life, he shortly after became ordained. In his previous life, he was a dedicated hunter. In this life, he not only abstained from killing any living creature, but he forbade his siblings from doing so.

So what happened? We can see there is a gap between the death of Ananda Mahipala in October 1956 and the conception of Wijeratne Adhikari in November. Not a big gap, but a gap. And some of the memories of Anasiri Adhikari start to give us a hint of what happened during that gap. The first rebirth which is remembered occurs even before that of Ananda Mahipala as a dental mechanic, untraced, son of a low cast potter who died in a boating accident and whose finger was damaged while grinding teeth.

We mentioned Ananda Mahipala’s rebirth. We mentioned he was a meat eater, a hunter. He was a kind person close to his mother. And then Wijeratne Adhikari’s rebirth, vegetarian, deep wish to become a monk and becomes ordained at 16. What is interesting is Vanasiri Adhikari remembers being reborn as a rabbit, as a hare.

He remembers clearly eating grass and he remembers being shot. Those are the two memories he has. He also remembers a stillbirth as an infant son of Wijeratne’s mother who died one hour after death. Now if we analyze the sequence of lives comically, what do we see? We believe the first life to the side.

We can see here from a karmic standpoint, the karma of being a hunter and therefore of killing regularly rabbits and crows which is what he hunted gave rise in the next rebirth to rebirth as a hare. The lifespan of a hare is some three to four months. And then obviously, in the context of this rebirth, he ate grass. Then the karmic habituation of eating grass in the third rebirth led in the fourth rebirth to becoming a vegetarian. It’s quite striking.

And because Wijeratne Adhikari had a very clear mind and remembered all of these rebirths, at a very early age, there was a very powerful wish to become a monk, to escape from what he saw as this repetitious pattern of suffering which had no meaning. And this is what we will talk about at present, religious inclination. This is a little child speaking who says to his father again and again that he is disgusted with the endless cycle of rebirth and that he wishes to become a monk and as he put it to make an end to it all. And this against considerable opposition in the family since he was the only son. He was expected to take over the family’s family farm.

Then the young child had a very uncommon habit which was that of filling the well next to the house with garbage and when asked why he did this, he said he did this because he planned on building a house on this filled well for his parents so that he could go away and become ordained. This is a profound wish for ordination in a very young child, which actually led to his ordination as a Buddhist novice at 15 years of age. He must have badgered his parents so much that eventually they agreed. We badgered our parents to get our first car. He badgered his parents to enter a monastery.

There’s a big difference. And when Stevenson interviewed him, the young Vanasiri Adhikari said that he thought those memories of previous lives and the suffering associated with them were what actually led him to the decision to become ordained. This is clearly as complete a human rebirth of leisure and endowment as one can hope to get nowadays. It’s a complete proximate human rebirth of leisure in endowment. All the features are there.

The age freedoms are there. The five endowments from one’s own side and the one endowment we can still have from the side of others are all there. And it is a precious human rebirth which is used in an extraordinarily powerful way. Ordination at a very young age, then Wijeratne Adhikari disappears from history. I have been unable to trace him.

If he became the sort of monk I think he became, he would disappear from history. He would probably become a very pure practitioner. So what is our present state? Our present state is basically akin to that of a man rolling a boulder up along the side of a cliff. As Pabongka Rinpoche puts it beautifully, we have reached midpoint.

We have somehow managed to become human. Through a combination, an extraordinary combination of karmic factors, we are at a point where we actually can continue to roll the boulder upwards. If we let go at present, and it is particularly easy in the West where we are surrounded by all the material comforts and the general viewpoint is one of soft nihilism, the boulder will roll back down. And our chances of rolling it back of getting a human rebirth again, let alone a human rebirth of leisure endowment, will be very small. So this is a reason for which one has to recognize one’s situation, which is that of this athlete rolling a boulder, recognize what one has, recognize this human rebirth of leisure and endowment, recognize its rarity and its qualities, and then try to use it to the maximum for creating the cause in next lives for obtaining again and again such a human rebirth.

In other words, the general causes for a human rebirth, which are the four causes of ethics, generosity, forbearance, and prayers, and the specific causes of each of the 18 factors. There are only 14 factors which causes we can generate, but it is not impossible for us to generate the causes for being reborn when the next universal teacher, Maitreya, comes. This is, I would say, the goal of many of the very great Tibetan teachers, which is to create the karmic causes to be reborn when Maitreya comes and to be one of Maitreya’s disciples. And as you know, as a bodhisattva, Maitreya took the vow that all of the beings who had maintained purely one ethical precept during the time of Buddha Śākyamūni, he would take on as a disciple when he himself returned. This is a very powerful vow.

Then I have covered what I wanted to cover today. I thank you very much for your patience. I think for some this is material which was well known. For others it may have been a bit tedious. I hope you nonetheless derived some benefit from it.

And I would like to point out that this is really the foundation of Buddhist practice. This appreciation of a human rebirth is critical for us. And not just an appreciation of our present human rebirth, but engaging in karmic strategies to obtain it again and again and again. This is the goal Nāgārjuna sets us. That life after life after life after life, we obtain human precious human rebirth.

This is a realistic way of proceeding towards liberation and full enlightenment. None of us in this room will attain liberation or full enlightenment in this life. It is not possible for us. With lives as lay people, you know, dedicating a couple hours a week to the best to practice, that’s not on the agenda. What is on the agenda, however, is life after life going from higher rebirth to higher rebirth, keeping in contact with the teaching life after life, and keeping in contact with one’s teacher life after life so that life after life, our gurus retrieve us, teach us, and help us to move forward.

This is realistic. Then if you have any questions, I will be delighted to take them at present. Yes. Well, it’s very it’s very simple. What is the most important thing in your life?

Look at yourself honestly in terms of what you dedicate time to, what you dedicate effort to, and ask yourself, what is the most important thing in my life? If the most important thing in your life is relationships, money, health, fun, then you are a worldly being. You haven’t even started on the religious path. If the most important thing in one’s life is one’s future life, then one is a religious being. One can be a Buddhist, a Christian, a Muslim, a Hindu, a Jew, all believe in in at least one future life.

And if you believe in many future lives, and the most important thing in your life is those future lives, then if you’re a Buddhist in addition, you’re being of the small scope. Then nobody in this room is a being of the middling scope. Otherwise, we would be very different from the way we are. And nobody in this room is a being of the great scope. Otherwise, we would be very different from the way we are.

And if you’re hidden bodhisattvas, my apologies. But I I don’t think so. So the first thing is to be very, very hard nosed about who we are. If we look at our own behavior and we see, okay, you know, most important thing is my mortgage and vacations, and I’m worried about my health and my friends, my marriage, then we haven’t started. So how does one start?

One starts by thinking about one’s own death. Think about one one thinks about one’s own death and one says, then what comes after? There’s only two possibilities. This is a something or nothing. If there’s nothing, there was a Nicholas, one stops there.

Then this life is all there is. One tries to lengthen it as long as possible. After that, it’s over. If there’s something, one has to find what there is. And that is where as a worldly being, one is not yet a religious practitioner, one can study the great world religions and the great philosophies.

That doesn’t mean one’s a religious practitioner. One’s just studying. Until there is that mental shift and one turns one’s back on this life, one is not a dharma practitioner. One is not a being of the small scope. Being a being of the small scope is a big thing.

I don’t know many. Being a monk or a nun does not mean one is a being of the small scope. One can become a monk or a nun for purely secular reasons. Being a lay person does not mean one is not a being with a small scope. There’s something which happens inside the mind.

There’s not something which happens with the clothing. Does that start to answer your question? We have no way to know. The level other people are at, we have no access to. It’s in their minds.

Then behavior gives us an idea, but not worries. I do not know a lot about Eisenhower’s life. If he was a very devout Christian, I think he was, then perhaps he would be close to being a being of the small scope. He would not be a full being of the small scope because he would not be a Buddhist, but we could say he would be close, be approximate being of the small scope. Just as mother Teresa was definitely a being of the small scope from a Buddhist standpoint.

Definitely. Someone who was definitely focused on trying to be reborn in heaven, in the Christian heaven. Then obviously someone who is training in compassion and love, but not universal compassion and love. A very limited compassion and love limited to human beings. Well, that depends.

I mean, the multiple ways of presenting it. I think probably what you were mentioning is what Asaṇga intended. But Jitsongkapa actually says that those four of the five endowments regarding others refer to being born between the time when the Buddha attained full enlightenment, in other words, in his early thirties, and the time when Buddha attained Para nirvana in his eighties, which is a period of fifty years. And I think that is what certainly the certainly the ghetto tradition has retained. I think so.

Well, I mentioned it for completeness. I mean, Westerners don’t accept the existence of that category of animals. These are not animals as we know them. Naga is a particular category of serpentine beings which are put traditionally in the animal realm in Buddhist taxonomy. But unlike animals, Nagas have very strong discrimination and can be very erudite and learned.

Their great weakness tends to be the great attachment to to wealth. Then in India, you do see quite a few of them. You can get experience of this if you your eyes open. Then it is said that Nagas can develop bodhichitta. So for that reason, it is said that beings in the animal realm can develop bodhichitta.

Well, I think the moment one becomes very intimate with animals to the point where one starts emulating animal behavior, which you see if people have pets, at that moment, karmically, one is creating possible causes for rebirth as an animal. This is why, for instance, there’s a whole category of yoga postures which are actively discouraged in the Buddhist tradition because these Hatha yoga postures involve imitating animal behavior. The night I’ve never done them for that reason. You know? Likewise, when one makes prostrations, it is very important that one’s hands be set on the ground in this way with the fingers touching each other so that one does not imitate animal behavior.

If one imitates animal behavior by closing one’s hands like as fists and therefore prostrating as if one had hooves or spreads them out like this and then it amounts to prostrating with splayed hands, which is creating the karma for animal rebirths either as an ungulate, as a cow, or perhaps as a spider. Then this is due to habituation. So I think if we study karma carefully and that’s what I would encourage all of you to do. Take Stevenson’s work, study them carefully. Ask yourself, is this true or not?

Is it possible for habituation to lead to a rebirth? Even habituation which is meaningless, like dressing up in a sheep skin, you know, and running around going ba ba for fun, you know. Once from time to time, we’ll probably leave no imprints. If you were to do it in a regular basis, you are actually creating karmic imprints for rebirth of the sheep. And this is one of the reasons for which any type of imitation of animal behavior is discouraged.

Think about it. Look at the cases. I know this sounds very very strange to Western ears. The Western presentation of karma is one of crime and punishment. This is not how karma functions.

It’s not the Judeo Christian vision of the righteous God transposed into the realm of past and future lives. It’s a matter of mental habituation. What the mind is accustomed to in this life, in future lives, it will do and eventually this will happen. Does that answer a little bit your question? Yes.

Are there other questions? Yes, please. Naturally. Naturally for sure. For sure.

For sure. Mean, it is liberation was attained in this life, then it it seems difficult to imagine it was only one lifetime practice. Then the other major problem is based on what viewed they attain liberation. I mean, the view taught in the Theravada schools is the Sautrāntika or the Vaibhāṣika view. It’s not possible to attain liberation on that basis.

So it is only possible to attain liberation on the basis of the Prāsaṇgika view. Clearly, they must have discovered the Prāsaṇgika view by themselves. And I personally am convinced through Satipatthana, it is possible to attain the prasanic view for an extremely intelligent practitioner. Because the Prāsaṇgika view is actually the logical view, if you wish. If you analyze in-depth, it is impossible to stop the analysis at any point.

Does that answer your question a bit? Yes, please. Yes. It’s a quote from the Chiggala Sutta in the sense that it is extraordinarily rare to get such a life. It is just basically luck.

It amounts to luck. The luck that the karma matured in such a way that we got such an existence. That is, I think, the meaning. Then I have not checked the Pali sources. You’d have to see what the term coincidence translates.

That’s how you’d have to go about it. Do you have other questions? Yes please Jasmine. You have the face of conviction, pure face and the face of face. In other words, face.

The most important is the face of conviction. The face of conviction is rooted in reasoning. So this is a sort of faith in past and future lives which we are trying to create through studying Stevenson’s accounts of past and future lives, Dharmakīrti’s reasoning is demonstrating past and future lives. It’s it is not a reasonless faith. Does that answer your question?

When we ghost the preters, preters are it’s a rebirth which occurs through extreme avidity, cupidity, or grasping in which the being is never satisfied. Its hunger can never be satisfied. Its thirst can never be satisfied. This can occur either through exterior or interior impediments. And there are traditional descriptions of these beings.

Broadly speaking, many of them correspond to what we know as ghosts in the West. Most of the ghosts and the spirits, let’s say if you have haunted houses that assuming you believe in haunted houses, ghosts and spirits almost always ranged in the preter category. Know? Even the most powerful spirits tend to be put in the category of preters precisely because of this avidity and cupidity which characterizes them. Then rebirth as a preter is typically due to stinginess, extreme stinginess.

Stinginess, not to you know what stinginess means? Yes. So extreme stinginess, lack of generosity, being extremely tight fisted or theft, especially theft with a very strong desire associated with it. Those, deeds typically lead to rebirth as a preta. Likewise, taking away what was given.

You should never give something and take it back. Especially in a religious context, what is given is given. The door is closed. So if one takes back what what is what is given, then one creates, especially in a dharma context, very strong karma for a preta rebirth. In a center like this one, stealing from the center would cause rebirth as a preta.

And since stealing is taking what is not given, if one does not have explicit permission to use something and one takes it, that is stealing as long as it has value. So a center, since a center is a karmically heavy object, not quite as heavy as a monastery, but almost, all of you who will come to the center, you must be very careful. I mean, I have heard of I don’t know if it is true, but I I have heard to my great surprise of theft of books from the library. Then this is a very, powerful creation of preta karma. But even taking a tea bag or a loaf of bread from the kitchen without the permission of the director or the owner of the center is theft.

So when I came to TBI, I asked Tenzin for blanket permission to use tea bags, etcetera, so as not to be exposed to this. Especially in your practice, if you are sponsoring, you must be very careful. If you start sponsoring and you commit to sponsor for a certain period of time, finish your period of sponsorship. If you sponsor someone, let’s say a monk in the monasteries, which is a powerful object, and you pledge to sponsor, let’s say this young monk until he becomes a geishe, then you must do every effort to continue sponsoring him until he becomes a geshe. If you’re absolutely unable to do so, then you really have to explain carefully what the problems are.

But if you casually withdraw from that type of obligation because the object is heavy, it creates very heavy karma. So dharma centers and monasteries are dangerous places. You see for instance here, I have access to the Internet through my computer. Whenever I turn my computer on, it asks me to upload to, update my software. I never do.

I always ask Tenzin when he’s here for permission. Otherwise, I do not. I don’t have the permission to do this. If I do this, it is stealing from the center. The center is a heavy object.

Are there other questions? Maybe yes. Sam. I think that’s it. I mean, if you if by volition you mean intention, yes, that’s exactly it.

Then if we look at our minds, one of us has tendencies in a different direction. These tendencies are the result of habituation from past lives. Then, obviously, they influence our capacity to develop an intention in this life. So the basis of training is mindfulness. Mindfulness of one’s own mind.

So one gauges a mindfulness of the body naturally, of the breath if one chooses to meditate on Sattipattana, but the mindfulness also of the feelings and of the mental states. When one does this, one sees certain patterns unfold and this is where I personally feel that a combination of the practice of mindfulness to a moderate degree with Lamrim is very beneficial. Because the Lamrim gives a theoretical framework to understand what is happening with one’s mind when one observes it through mindfulness. Otherwise, without the practice of the Lamrim and with no study, one may not be able to fully understand what is happening. If you engage in Sattipattana, most of you may have done some Sattipattana, vipassana is often called in the West.

As you know, you focus on the movement of breath at the nostrils or at this level of the stomach. The outward and in inward movement of the breath, you just notice. And the first thing you will notice is the fleetingness of the mind. Things pass. If you have studied impermanence, this is very powerful.

You notice this fleetingness and after your meditation session, you have strong empirical corroboration of the impermanence of the mind. And then you can analyze that impermanence of the mind in the light of the Lamrim, but also of one studies in Buddhist philosophy. Then as one moves on in one’s practice of Sattipattana, the next very powerful experience one will have is an experience of bodily and mental suffering. One will have particularly an experience of very great pain. Pain in the joints, pain in the back and eventually as one moves on in one practice an incredible feeling of irritation of the skin.

It’s as if the entire skin is crawling and alive. Now if one has done no studies, one just has and this is basically the approach in the Theravada countries. One just forges through. But if one has studied, that’s why I feel the approaches are very complementary. Then when this feeling of suffering arises and especially this incredible feeling of crawling of the skin, one thinks what is this?

And one analyzes in terms of the three categories of suffering. Obviously, it’s a suffering of suffering. But was it preexisting or not? And one actually realizes that what happened in Sattipattana is that the threshold of observation of suffering has been dramatically lowered. And preexisting suffering, which is always there, has suddenly become visible.

Then reflecting on this, one can get a very powerful realization of the noble truth of suffering. Because then it becomes very clear that the only thing which prevents us from realizing the noble truth of suffering is the elevated conceptual level which prevents the constant levels of suffering from passing through. The moment that is reduced, the fact that our five aggregates are the nature of suffering becomes evident. So the two, satipatthana and lamrim at the beginning, I find a very powerful. Then at a certain point, I think you don’t really need satipatthana anymore.

You leave it to the side because you have the realization through it of the three marks. Right? The in the Theravada tradition, one speaks of the mark of impermanence, mark of suffering, and the mark of anata, of selflessness. Those are the three marks which you can easily realize through combination of Sattipattana and Lamrim. Then at that point, you have to enter in Lamrim fully.

Then you do the analytical meditations of Lamrim. What you do is at this point, you conjoin analysis and concentration meditation. First, you attend let’s say let’s say you want to meditate on the precious human rebirth. You would first attend as many teachings as you could on the precious human rebirth. Then you would take the eight Lamrim texts or the six Lamrim texts we mentioned.

Study all of the presentations. Then you would go on the Internet and you would document yourself. It is not sufficient to use arguments from the fifteenth century. You need to convince yourself that this is the way things are. And you can see if you check that a rebirth with those 18 features is actually very rare.

Once you have done that preliminary work which is within the field of study, then you engage in analytical meditation. You go in your meditation room or your altar room and drawing on all of this, analyze topic by topic in sequence carefully. First, do I have a present a precious human rebirth or not? You check each of the 18 features, the answer is no. What sort of a rebirth do I have?

Do I have a rebirth with the 14 features? If the answer is no, what’s missing feature? If it’s yes, you concentrate on each of those features. At that point, you stop analyzing and you focus absence of wrong view, first feature. They’re not reborn as an animal, second feature, the eight, eight freedoms and so forth.

Having done this, you then take the second, topic in meditation on a precious human rebirth. You take the third topic of meditation on a precious human rebirth. You analyze each one and then you concentrate on each one. You concentrate until you get some sort of feeling. You need an experience at this point.

For instance, if you’re meditating on the rarity of the precious human rebirth, first, analyze again and again how rare it is. Then you get a feeling of how rare it is and you stop analyzing. You focus on that feeling of rarity. You stay focused on that feeling of rarity until it abates. When it abates, you start analyzing again.

And once you get that feeling again how rare it is, you focus on that, you stop analyzing, you remain focused until it abates. Eventually, you will have a durable sensation of the rarity of a human rebirth. At that point, you can probably say you have realized it. So one’s practice in meditation in Lamrim is this ordinance of analytical meditation and concentration meditation. They go hand in hand.

Analytical meditation at the beginning is much more important. You can actually live without concentration meditation because our concentration is very poor. Then down the line as once concentration increases, then obviously you use concentration meditation which culminates in Shamatha. Does that start to answer your question? Very good.

Very good. Do you have any other questions? Oh yes. Yes. Even though study actually is analytical meditation, the way you should do it if you have five minutes, I mentioned this and then then, you know, I will let you go.

The way you should do it is you should first memorize the outlines. If you don’t memorize the outlines, you can’t really meditate on them. That doesn’t mean you have to memorize every word, but you have to memorize a structure. Then you study. Then when you memorize when you meditate, you engage in analytical meditation.

This memorized outline is your framework. If you haven’t memorized it and you keep peeking at the text, this this will damage your concentration. So a Tibetan, let’s say, when he tries to meditate on using would meditate it would memorize the totality of the outline. And that’s difficult for us, but memorize the meaning of the outline. Memorize the eight freedoms.

Memorize the 10 endowments. Then memorize within the eight freedoms, four from the human standpoint, four from the nonhuman standpoint. Within the five endowments, five from the standpoint of oneself, five from the standpoint of others. Then the 14 which you actually have at present if you have approximate human, rebirth of leisure and endowment. And then you can meditate.

Then thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
nagas lu (Tib)
A snake-like being of the animal realm that lives in or near bodies of water; commonly associated with fertility of the land, but can also function as a protector of religion. LYWA
ripening result
One of the four ways we can experience the results of an action; the ripening result is the actual realm we are born into when we take rebirth. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top