6,769 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The teacher explains the nine stages of mental placement toward calm abiding, including the roles of recollection and vigilance, the obstacles of forgetfulness, laziness, sinking and agitation, and the six forces. He contrasts the shared Indian concentration path with the Buddhist aim of liberation through selflessness, and describes how calm abiding combines with insight. The talk then covers the paths of accumulation and preparation and answers questions on Lamrim and past lives.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: b8118833-5b25-4482-9238-504194e5e94f
Words: 6,765
The first thing I’d like to point out is that Rinpoche corrected the material in this chart with one substantial modification. This chart comes from the translation of Kamala Śīla’s Middling Stages of the Path published by the Central Tibetan School in Sarnath and they, in the chart, they consider that the size of the flames refers to recollection. So Rinpoche corrected this. It’s not the intensity of recollection which is indicated by the size of the flames, is the intensity of effort and enthusiasm required for the practice which is quite a substantial difference. Think you’ll agree with me.
Then if we look at the development, each of the nine mental stages is indicated in bold letters starting with mental placement. As Rinpoche explained this morning, when we start out we actually don’t even start at the level of mental placement since as we were saying yesterday if an object doesn’t appear to the mind you haven’t even started running, you aren’t even here. So this begins when something appears to the mind. So once the image of the Buddha appears to the mind and your mind nonetheless is running away under the power of sinking agitation and forgetfulness which severs the visualization, then you are probably at the level of the first mental placement. As long as there is forgetfulness, as long as you lose the object of meditation, you are below the third level, by definition, because it’s at the third level that forgetfulness ceases.
And then as Rinpoche explained, the monk holds two implements, a noose and a hook. So, as you know in ancient India the noose was used to hold the elephant, to tie him down, actually that’s the meaning here, tie him down to what? Tie him down to the object of observation. That’s a function of the noose. The hook was actually used by the Mahut to guide the elephant.
So hence the hook is vigilant. Neither of these is operative. Neither is operative at the first, at the second, and only one is operative at the third placement. What this means is that at the level we are at, neither recollection nor vigilance function. So talking of recollection can begin meaningfully at the level of the third placement, repeated placement.
Until then, the force of recollection isn’t really operative. It’s much more an issue as Rinpoche explained over the last three days, the last four days actually, of eliminating during these first two levels, the first two main obstacles to the generation of calm abiding, which are first, and I put them from the bottom up, laziness, and secondly forgetfulness, forgetting the instruction. So laziness actually occurs specifically at this level, it can occur throughout. It is the refusal to start practicing, of which Rinpoche has talked. Forgetfulness is indicated by the fact that the monk is not connecting to his mind.
You see, the nous of recollection is not holding the mind. When recollection holds the mind at that moment the forgetfulness of the object of meditation ceases. So what do we mean by forgetfulness? As we said yesterday forgetfulness means interrupting the continuum of contemplation. If you have visualized a Buddha’s image, so you are here already at least, and you keep it in your mind but suddenly you think of going to watch this major cultural event, the footy match in Adelaide, then you have at that point suffered from forgetfulness.
So that means you are on one of these three levels. Thank you Carol. Rinpoche explained that generally speaking the elephant symbolizes the mind because it is both powerful and uncontrolled, just as a wild elephant and, the monkey symbolizes agitation. Neither of these is accessible to us at the level we are at. There is during the three first stages, agitation and sinking when we meditate, but it is not the main obstacle we are struggling against.
We start struggling against agitation and sinking from patched placement up upwards. So it’s very helpful to connect this chart which is based on Asaṇga’s Ground of the Hearers and is a Hīnayāna presentation with the Mahāyāna presentation Rinpoche gave during the last three days based on Maitreya’s separation of the middle and the extremes. So if you remember in Maitreya’s presentation you have five faults against which eight antidotes are applied. Now it’s extremely helpful to identify where these five faults are on this nine fold presentation. So at the beginning this is what we struggle against, forgetfulness and laziness, and as Rinpoche explained, this path leading up to calm abiding is generated by training in the six forces.
These are six forces which actually lead the mind upwards. The first of these is the force of hearing. I was not able to put it on the chart. It is here. The force of hearing what?
Of hearing the teachings. If you don’t know how to practice calm abiding, you haven’t even started. So first you receive the teachings, and then you try to cause an object of meditation to appear when it appears you have entered the first level of calm abiding. Until then, you’re not even there. Then, at that first level, the moment you start analyzing your mind, you will have a sense of an explosion of conceptual activity, because you will have become aware of how wild the elephant is.
Until then you don’t realize it. People who don’t meditate will quite frankly say to you my mind is very controlled, It’s an unexamined mind. And after the first placement and before continuous placement, you generate the second force, the force of thinking which is recollecting again and again the object of meditation. This enables continuous placement. So continuous placement does not mean uninterrupted placement.
Continuous placement just means that it is longer. There is longer between the intervals which breaks due to forgetfulness. So it’s an increase in continuity and you are still tormented by the five objects of desire, which all are connected to agitation. Agitation as Rinpoche explained based on Asaṇga’s definition of agitation in the Compendium of Ascertainments is connected with attachment. Then, as Rinpoche explained this morning, you do notice that the mind starts to purify itself, Specifically, there is a progressive increase in the two factors of clarity and abiding of which we spoke about yesterday.
So, if you remember yesterday we said that calm abiding occurs at the intersection of clarity and stability. You need both a clear mind and a stable mind. That middle ground is calm abiding. So a slight increase in the clarity and in the stability occurs after continuous placement. Until you have some sort of continuity on the object, it’s impossible to talk of clarity or stability.
Then we move to repeated paste placement or patched placement. At this point the force of recollection comes into its own. Until then we don’t have recollection, we have fragmentary recollection. Because the force of recollection comes into its own, forgetfulness ceases. So from this point onwards, from the third point onwards, you stop losing the object of meditation.
It may sink, it may become a little bit unstable, but you will stop losing the continuum. That is indicated by the fact that the nous, which symbolizes recollection here, in other words memory, when we say recollection we mean memory. Memory actually connects to the mind. In other words, the mind remembers the object of meditation. And the mind actually acknowledges the meditator.
The mind starts to obey the instructions. So it is at this point that agitation and sinking become the main obstacle. So there as you remember grouped as one by Maitreya, as two by Kamalaśīla, and, you will notice here at the level both of patch placement and of close placement that vigilance is not operating. It is difficult to have vigilance. One has memory and you can see that between the third and the fourth level the mind becomes purer, agitation decreases, subtle sinking is identified for the first time, but vigilance can still not be brought fully to bear.
Now you will also notice that the size of the flames indicating the amount of effort does progressively decrease as one moves upwards. Now here it is important and this is going be a difficult point to distinguish between coarse and subtle sinking. So we’ll talk about it because it is perhaps the main contribution of Jitsongkapa to the presentation of insight and His Holiness emphasizes it greatly as well. You can have more explanations on subtle sinking in the great Lamrim Chenmo or in the talks of the Dalai Lama at Harvard. Both give some very nice explanations on that.
We actually don’t understand what sinking is to start with, so subtle sinking is something which is almost impossible for us to get. Sinking does not mean that we lose the object of meditation as with forgetfulness. The object of meditation is there, it is stable, but it is dull. It is there, we see the Buddha’s form, we don’t see it with limpidity, with clarity, it is dull. That we can identify, that is sinking.
Subtler sinking is however a refined version of this. Not only is the object there, it is clear, but what is missing when we spoke yesterday of the two factors of clarity and intensity, what is missing at the level of subtle sinking is, if you want a full description, what is called intensity and limpidity. That is missing. The object is there, it is clear, but there is a certain radiance, a certain intensity in the visualization which is absent. This is very difficult to identify and this is why many Tibetan meditators basically got stuck on the level of close placement, and they thought close placement was a meditation with great relaxation because they were in a state of subtle sinking.
Then, if one meditates for long, either with sinking or with subtle sinking, it makes the mind very dull, and this creates the causes for an animal rebirth. This is why Śākyapandita said the Mahāmudrā of the ignorant is the cause of an animal rebirth, a famous passage, long before the Geluk tradition, this is not a Geluk specificity. There was a major problem in Tibet at Śākyapandita’s time, which is in the thirteenth century, up to Je Tsongkapa’s time in the late fourteenth, early fifteenth century, with meditators who had no clear understanding of the process of meditation and would just receive some short oral instructions, go in a cave and put great effort in these short oral instructions and then it was a luck of the draw. If the oral instructions were good, they got somewhere. If they weren’t good, and these were these oral instructions were often the notes someone took based on the notes someone took based on the notes took.
If the oral instructions were not good, they got stuck on one of these levels. And His Holiness has said recently, it was a tragedy in Tibet that often so much effort went towards so little. These were extraordinary practitioners in terms of effort but the understanding was limited. So either subtle sinking or sinking creates these difficulties. Now when agitation arises in practice you will find that you can get a lot of Lung, what the Tibetans call Lung, this inner tension, it can become so great it causes a person to stop the practice.
This is very common in long retreats. During the third and the fourth, levels, patch placement and closed placement, the main focus of training is actually trying to control sinking. As a result of this, at the level of close placement, agitation increases a bit. And it is at this point that the force of vigilance is really established for the first time. It was present before the monk was carrying the hook of vigilance but it was not operative.
He was not able to, or we were not able to apply vigilance, in other words the checking process of the mind to bring the back the mind back to the object of meditation. Now this does not occur as with forgetfulness once you have lost the object of meditation. If you lose the object of meditation at this point, at any time, it means you’ve reverted back to the three first levels. Vigilance actually functions in this way. Recollection, which is basically 95% of the mind, is focused on the object of observation.
It is the rope or the noose which ties the elephant, often they say to a stake in the ground. 5% of the mind, from time to time, checks to see whether or not sinking or agitation are present. Now to check you must know what things are. So for vigilance to understand whether sinking or agitation are present or not it has to understand what sinking is which looks and often look like a good meditation session and what agitation is which often looks like very strong clarity. And that is why it is not before the end of the fourth stage, close placement, that vigilance is established.
It’s very difficult to be vigilant against the thief breaking in if you don’t know the difference between the thief and someone who lives in the house. You have to know the difference. That’s the difficult point. Then at that point moving up to the fifth stage of subduing or taming, the situation changes completely. The monk is applying both means of controlling the mind: recollection or memory and vigilance.
And the mind is responding. That is why the elephant is half white and you can see there is even less effort required. And finally on pacification, the monk no longer needs to apply recollection or vigilance. He still holds the tools as you can see, but his mind follows him and vigilance has been disempowered and basically causes almost no problems anymore. Then it is a progressive process of development of the mind until one reaches the full state of meditative equipoise.
The only difference between the ninth level of calm abiding and the actual attainment of śamatha is that for an attainment of śamatha both bodily and mental pliancy must be present. First mental pliancy or mental serviceability, if you want, then bodily or physical pliancy. Rinpoche gave a marvelous and very short introduction today to the difference between Buddhist and non Buddhist paths at this point. All of this is shared with all of the non Buddhist Indian traditions, there’s no difference. This is practiced by the Sankhyas, this is practiced by the followers of Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras, this is practiced by the Jains.
Actually they attach much more importance to concentration than we do, much more. But the main focus of the non Buddhist Hindu practitioners and Jain practitioners is developing the concentrations. Because through the concentration, specifically through attaining calm abiding, and then above calm abiding you have the second, third and fourth dhyanas, you can be reborn as a god in the form of the formless realm. This is the main goal. If you read the Indian text, you read Patanjali, it’s explicit.
The goal is to be reborn as Brahma, to become Brahma. What is not appreciated is that there is a fall from that state, that is not appreciated. So until here the path is the same both for the texts called them worldly practitioners, these are the non Buddhist Hindu practitioners, and Supramundane practitioners, these are the practitioners such as Buddhist practitioners who are looking for liberation. At this point, the paths diverge. The Buddhist practitioners go in this direction, the non Buddhist practitioners go in this direction.
The non Buddhist practitioners then generate even more powerful concentrations to try to be reborn as high as possible in the God realms. The Buddhist practitioners are satisfied with a good enough concentration, which is calm abiding. It is good enough to meditate on selflessness and on this basis to attain liberation. And therefore, as Rinpoche explained this morning, they unite riding on the elephant which symbolizes calm abiding, with wielding the sword which symbolizes vipassana, not in the Theravada sense of the term, but in the Mahāyāna sense of insight into emptiness. And this arises and we won’t go into it too much, through after giving rise to calm abiding, focusing first that mind of calm abiding on emptiness, you initially have to have a calm abiding focused on emptiness, which is not an insight, and then engaging in analyses of selflessness within that calm abiding.
And that is a very difficult process because most of the mind is single pointedly focused on the object and an inner core is analyzing the object. That is said to be akin to a fish swimming in a river which does not trouble the flow of the river. That conjunction of calm abiding and insight, where calm abiding here is the method aspect of the path and insight is the wisdom aspect of the path, is what leads to for the Theravada, the Hīnayāna practitioner, liberation from cyclic existence, for the Mahāyāna practitioner in the vehicle of perfections to full enlightenment. So you have to correct the text throughout when you see this sort of passage, seeking with powerful recollection the view. This is actually, it is wrong in the Tibetan.
It’s seeking with powerful enthusiasm the view. Remember Rinpoche corrected that for us. And then basically we haven’t had the possibility to put them all here, but the five faults in accordance with Maitreya. So as you remember on the three first levels you have laziness and forgetting the instructions, then basically up to the level of thorough pacification you have as main thoughts sinking and agitation, and then all the way up to the attainment of meditative equipoise, the main fault becomes the intemperate application of the remedies. In other words, in a situation like this, where there is no impediment to concentration, the mind is single pointedly concentrated on the object, vigilance can become overactive.
One checks too much and one sees faults where there are no faults. Then one applies antidotes which are unnecessary and one severs the continuum of concentration. So it’s a matter at this point of pulling back a little bit. Are there any questions about this? Yes?
Yes, please. Oh, I’m terribly sorry. We’ve had problems with the printing. It should be here. It’s here on my version.
You can photocopy my copy. This was done on one one word per session, it will pass to another one. Either side of the mirror is where it should be. Yeah. I know.
Can I give you this one and you use it for everyone? You know? Yes. Are there other questions? Yes.
Yes. Let me show you. It is down here. The presence or absence of tongues of fire, etcetera, etcetera, greater or lesser power of enthusiasm. So it’s down here and up on the top as well.
Yes. Physical pliancy achieved with the coarse body. Physical pliancy arises through an uncommonly easy flow of the winds of the major elements in the channels. So it’s quite striking that Asaṇga who is giving a Pāramitāyāna presentation of pliancy, actually a Hīnayāna presentation of pliancy, nonetheless does it in very strong Tantric terms. And it’s all the more striking because Asaṇga lived much before the official dawn of tantra.
Western Buddhist scholars consider that Buddhist Tantras originated maybe in the sixth century, and there are some very strong counters to this. The first is Nagajuna’s Bolichita Vivarana, which conservatively taught, which quotes from the Guhyasamāja, is in Nagajuna’s style, and then if Nāgārjuna composed it in the second century, the second is thank you kindly the second is Asaṇga’s Śrāvakabhūmi, where Asaṇga speaks textually of the flow of the winds of the great elements earth, water, fire and air, and this is certainly not Pāramitāyāna vocabulary. So it’s achieved bodily pliancy achieved with the physical body and then as a result of this the body as Rinpoche said gains uncommon capacities. That would be different. That’s different.
That seems to correspond to a very coarse form of the illusory body, the impure illusory body, it seems, if it’s attested, because there’s a lot of debate about it as you know. In the case of pliancy, what happens is, actually, it is when a yogi gains śamatha and bodily pliancy, it is within this very body that he can, for instance, travel through walls, fly in space, but there is a caveat. He can only do this during his calm abiding session. So he is not conscious when he does this. He enters in calm abiding with the intent of travelling through the wall, travels through the wall and then leaves calm abiding.
He cannot in a state subsequent to calm abiding just walking around decide I will travel through a wall and do so without entering calm abiding. So if you remember we said when a yogi has attained calm abiding the meditation session lasts as long as he wants it to but he cannot decide during the meditation session to interrupt it. It’s not possible. That would call for the appearance of conceptual minds which are not present. So if he does not set a time limit, he just stays in meditation indefinitely.
In such a same way, if a Yogi wanted to travel through a wall or travel into space, he would first generate that intention and then he would enter calm abiding, perhaps having done a visualization to that effect, and fixed a duration for the session, and when he came out he would be on the other side. Or if he decided to fly in space, I suppose he wants to be very sure to have landed before. So it’s a very particular particular type of practice. Are there other questions? I think the one thing I’d like to emphasize is less the development of calm abiding than the fact that it’s a shared trunk of all the Indian traditions.
It’s not something which is Buddhist, not even specifically Buddhist, for that matter in the Buddhist tradition we do not focus as much as some of the Hindu traditions on concentration. The idea is to get a serviceable concentration good enough for liberation and we talked in some of the conferences I gave here of the difference between the Buddhist and the Hindu traditions, this is where it happens. Until here the trunk is the same. So the presentation of cyclic existence is the same, the existence of reincarnation is taken for granted in all the major Indian religious traditions Buddhism, Jain, the majority of the Hindu traditions. The concentration techniques are strictly identical.
There’s a lot of evidence Buddhist Yogis drew on Indian sources for these. All are aiming for a liberation because non Buddhist, Hindu Yogis and Buddhist Yogis agree that this realm of Maya, of illusion, is of the nature of suffering, but the disagreement is on the means to get there. Having attained concentration, what does one meditate upon to be liberated? That’s the only difference. So the difference is very slight, but important.
The Hindus believe and the Jains that there is an Ātman, there is an individual soul which is illusory, and that when the yogi realizes the identity, especially in the Advaita Vedanta tradition, identity of the Ātman with the universal soul of Brahman, in concentration he is liberated from cyclic existence. The Buddhists on the other hand say there is no Ātman, mayaratmya. This non Ātman, non selflessness is what is meditated upon, and when that is realized the Yogi gains liberation. So as far as the trunk is concerned, they are exactly identical, the goal is the same, although it is understood differently. It is the means once having attained concentration which differ.
This is why in ancient India it was very common for Hindu yogis to become Buddhist and it happened also that Buddhist yogis became Hindu because it is just at the level of selflessness that they differ. Are there any other questions? Yes? True vipassana can only occur after calm abiding has been generated. So it is said that the object must initially have been focused upon by śamatha.
Now yours is a very sharp and good question because actually there is a passage in Asaṇga’s Abhidhamma Samuchaya, the compendium of ascertainments, in which Asaṇga says one can generate either calm abiding first and vipassana after or vipassana first and calm abiding after. This passage has to be qualified. What a Sangha is referring to is somebody who has already attained Sine, already attained calm abiding and then before engaging in a meditative session can first focus on calm abiding and then generate vipassana or first train in vipassana and then pass back to the calm abiding he had already generated. It does not apply to someone who is newly training in calm abiding. So it is a basic difference between vipassana and analytical meditation.
I’ll just finish with this: analytical meditation can occur at any level of one’s training but vipassana can only occur on the foundation of śamatha. Of calm abiding. Yes. You have to qualify. You can attain calm abiding based on any object but at the point where you want to generate a vipassana which is analyzing emptiness, whatever the initial object of calm abiding, you must change objects and focus a calm abiding mind on emptiness first.
It is within that continuum that a vipassana can arise. You might have generated your initial calm abiding focusing on a Buddha statue, a rock, whatever. No, not at all, not at all. Generally speaking, even though to give rise to vipassana, once one has attained calm abiding, this mind of calm abiding must first be focused on emptiness, almost nobody newly generates calm abiding on the basis of emptiness, which is too hard. You could, but to do that at the level of the first close placement, you actually would need here to already have a conceptual understanding of emptiness, which is very difficult because you have to have a meaning generality of emptiness appearing to the mind.
So in our case we speak of emptiness, all of us in this room have what’s known as a sound generality of emptiness appearing to the mind. The term emptiness resonates in our mind, we associate it with something we nebulously understand, this has no relation to actual emptiness. We hope. We hope. I don’t know.
Yes Richard. Normally yes, because you’re training in calm abiding to meditate on emptiness. But you train with a simple object, because you have to find the object, right? So you train with a Buddha’s statue as an object or a Buddha’s painting because it’s easy to find. Otherwise, you can see the difficulty.
Now, some practitioners start here, and this is Mahāmudrā in the Paramitrayana tradition, by focusing on the conventional nature of the mind. Minds being clear and cognitive. It’s much more difficult because you have to find the object. Then, you see, up to this point your big problem is forgetfulness. If you’re not terribly sure what the object is, you’re not sure whether you’ve forgotten it or not.
It’s a big problem. Are there other questions? By definition, once you have calm abiding, the image puts it beautifully, the elephant is lying at the feet of the meditator. Your mind goes when we speak of pliancy, bodily and physical pliancy, it means your mind and body are completely serviceable. They do what you tell them to do.
I mean, a yogi who has calm abiding tells to his mind I mean, they say, you know, when you have calm abiding, that your mind is so clear, they say, you can see every atom in the room. That’s the impression you have, that’s the level of clarity. And then obviously if you have bodily pliancy, you say to your body, do 10,000 prostrations, you enter in calm abiding, the body does 10,000 prostrations. You’re not aware of it. You come out of it, there should be no fatigue.
The body is pliant. But the body may be saying that because once it started you are unaware, right? By definition, yes. Well, no. You are working with conception.
No. No. So all the way here, this is a very good point. Thank you for making it. All this is conceptual.
All the way up to calm abiding and beyond. If you close your eyes, or you focus on the tip of your nose, and you visualize the image of a Buddha, that image which appears a conception. And the attainment of calm abiding is an attainment based on a conceptual mind. So in the text when one speaks of eliminating discursiveness or fancies, this actually refers to other ideas, other conceptions. But attaining calm abidement is conceptual.
And then, once one has attained calm abiding, when one practices vipassana, at this level you haven’t entered the path, right? You have the paths of the three beings, hearers, solitary realizers and bodhisattvas. You haven’t even entered the level of the path of accumulation here. You are non path being, you are a worldly being, even though you have calm abiding. However, having attained calm abiding and having studied, you have to bring to mind the meaning of emptiness and then focus the mind of calm abiding on the generic image of emptiness which arises, a conceptual mind.
When you do this, this is conceptual meditation, it’s not non conceptual. Then you analyze within that calm abiding, and that is a process of vipassana, you analyze emptiness, and analyzing, analyzing, analyzing, analyzing, meaning generality, in which the mental image shrinks and at a certain point you experience emptiness nakedly, with a direct realization of emptiness. At that point you have entered the path of seeing. No. No, the path of preparation starts with the union of calm, or the training of the union of calm abiding and insight.
So the path of accumulation, as its name indicates, is a path in which one basically accumulates merit and whatever instructions are needed, having generated that initial mind for entry in the path. So, the three paths: Hearer and Pratyekabuddha paths are paths of the Hīnayāna. The Bodhisattva path is the path of the Mahāyāna. The criterion for entry in the Hearer or Pratyekabuddha path, entry in the path of accumulation, is the natural and spontaneous arising of renunciation. The criterion for entry in the bodhisattva path is the natural and spontaneous arising of bodhichitta.
So while you are meditating on renunciation as a Hīnayāna practitioner and it doesn’t arise naturally without any meditation from your part, you have not even entered the path of any of the hearers or pratyekabuddhas, you are not a path being. When you are meditating on bodhichitta, which is our case, we meditate on the three principles of the path, and we have some sort of taste of bodhichitta during meditation but not a lot out, we have not even entered the path of the Mahāyāna. Are not, none of us in this room is either a Hīnayāna by path or a Mahāyāna by path. We are not there. It’s very far from us.
Now what is meant by the natural and spontaneous arising of renunciation of bodhichitta? What is meant is that if you are a Hīnayāna practitioner, your renunciation in meditation and out of meditation is the same. So whether you are walking, lying or meditating, renunciation is always present with the same high level of intensity, naturally, with no effort. For bodhichitta it’s the same thing. It means that whether you are meditating and generating bodhichitta and have a taste of it, or going to the market, the bodhichitta is there with the same intensity.
At that point you have entered the path of accumulation. Then you move upwards on the five paths, you have the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and what is known as the path of no more learning, which is the final attainment of whichever vehicle you are in. Now, if I’ll try to shut this down. Now you have three categories of being. You have hearers, also known as śrāvakas, solitary realizers, and you have Bodhisattvas.
The entry into the path of accumulation for hearers and solitary realizers is the generation of natural renunciation. The entry into the Bodhisattva path is a generation of natural bodhichitta. Below that you may have, you may have calm abiding, for that matter you may have much higher concentrations, you are not a path being. Then it is during the path of preparation of hearers, solitary realizers, bodhisattvas that calm abiding and special insight, vipassana, are conjoined. And what one does is one focuses the special insight on the meaning generality, the mental image of selflessness.
We’ll keep it very simple and call it selflessness in general. The two types of selfless, but we’ll keep it to that. And as the conceptual image fades, one moves up to the path of seeing, which for all three beings occurs with the non conceptual experience of selflessness, the selflessness of their vehicle. Then, one can move up to the path of no more learning of a hearer, which is the arhathood of a hearer, the enlightenment of a solitary realizer, or the full enlightenment of a bodhisattva. The difference between the three beings is defined basically by their motivation.
So renunciation or bodhichitta. So these are therefore the three principles of the path. Two are connected with motivation, and one is connected with wisdom. Motivation defines the path one enters, the path of a hearer, solitary realizer or bodhisattva. The vehicle should I say, one enters the vehicle of a hearer, solitary, realizer or bodhisattva.
And wisdom defines whether or not one has one is below the path of seeing, in which case one is called still an ordinary being, or whether one is above, in which case one is an ārya, a noble one. This is a path. Now you can generate calm abiding at any point below the path of accumulation, during the path of accumulation, but you must have calm abiding to enter the path of preparation. Without that you cannot enter it. Are there any other questions?
I don’t understand your question. We have a human rebirth. There’s no certainty. It’s possible. There’s no certainty.
If you were to practice calm abiding and you found extraordinary swift development, then you might wonder: meeting the instructions might just have arisen from having wanted to meet them in a past life. If you heard about these teachings and you wanted to receive them, you weren’t able to, that would be sufficient down the line to cause this. Calm abiding is both difficult and easy. I mean, in traditional Asian societies it’s often remarkably easy. There are cases of Burmese lay people who got calm abiding in three months.
I know of one Burmese girl, she went into the temple, was like after a month she had calm abiding. Amazing case. But these are very particular cases. These are very restrained persons, to start with, is very good discipline, obviously very strong karmic imprints, you know. Are there other questions?
Yes? I think the first step is analytical meditation on Lamrim. That is the first step. That is what changes the mind. Then, obviously, in our case, we speak of analytical meditation on Lamrim.
It starts with relying on the spiritual teacher, and eventually moves to the path of being of small scope. I think most westerners are not there. And for us it is extremely helpful to first generate very strong certainty in the existence of past and future lives. So one of the very big problems of the Lamrim for Westerners is it starts too high. It starts, it’s catering to a traditional Buddhist society in which everyone believed naturally in past and future lives.
Then it doesn’t bite the mind of Westerners because we don’t have that natural belief. So before that, I think it is extremely important to put great effort in understanding or becoming convinced that there are past and future lives and this one can do based on Stevenson’s research, there’s a lot of material out there, that these lives are not only human but also animal. There are such things as spirits. Westerners are uncomfortable with this, but it’s a reality. And then it’s not enough to be convinced in the process of reincarnation.
We have to be convinced in karma. There is such a thing as karma because many Western New Age practitioners believe in reincarnation without taking karma on board. Then it’s sort of you just go from life to life a bit at random and they generally throw in the caveat that you’re only reborn as a human being as well. And then there’s absolutely no motivation to practice anything. It’s a random process.
Once that is put down, then the Lamrim becomes very powerful. Then one starts reflecting first on the spiritual teacher. And one thinks as one of you was mentioning, ‘Okay, I have a human rebirth’, there were causes for this human rebirth. Now, what are these causes? If you really believe in past and future lives, in karma, you think, ‘OK, is said these causes are ethics, then in addition generosity, then forbearance, and then strong prayers to be reborn as a human being.
Now, ethics? Somebody had to teach me ethics. It didn’t dawn naturally in my mind. Who taught me ethics in a past life? A teacher.
Therefore, my human rebirth in this life, I owe to the kindness of a teacher in a past life, and to the work of a person in a past life whom I was not. Then generosity, if you’re born in a good situation, a rich country like Australia, it’s a result of generosity in a past life. Somebody taught us. Then forbearance: somebody taught us to practice patience so we have a good appearance, we are not deformed, etc. If all of this is a result of a teacher in our past life, then we think, ‘Ah, everything I have, I owe to that teacher.’ Then is that teacher in the past life different from the teacher in this life?
Then you start entering in the depths of Guru Yoga. Then after that you move up to Lamrim. It becomes very powerful. But if the gap between our materialist society, which believes basically in nothing before this life and nothing after, and a traditional Buddhist society is not bridged, the Lamrim has no impact. And we end up meditating on the Lamrim outlines, it never changes the mind.
So for Westerners, to answer your question, I’m sorry it’s very long, but I think the most important thing is to take the evidence there is for past and future lives until the conviction becomes really powerful, until it becomes a reality. And that has great benefit for the mind, the mind becomes very relaxed. And you think, ‘Okay, there’s trouble in this life,’ well, many lives before, many lives after, you know? Are there other questions? The names are the same.
The way you attain them is different. The speed of progression is different as well, but the actual attainment of a Parmithayana path, in other words, the path of no more learning of the Pāramitāyāna and the path of normal learning of all four tantras is the same. However, it is asserted in the tantras that it is not possible on the basis of the perfection vehicle alone to attain full enlightenment. A bodhisattva practicing the perfection vehicle will progress all the way up through all five paths of the Mahāyāna to the tenth ground. But on the tenth ground, to become fully enlightened, he must practice tantra.
The reason for this is that tantra basically brings in the picture the very subtle minds. So, if there are no more questions, then I think we’re going to call it good for today’s. Thank you very much. That’s very kind of you. That’s very close.
I must tell you I’m very grateful to you for one thing. I have always wanted to translate this text. I’ve never had time. And this has given me the opportunity to do it. So it is a great pleasure.
A great pleasure.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.