Study of the Mind – 02 SoM

41 min · 2,556 words · 1988

Study of the Mind (Khensur Rinpoche)
Study of the Mind (Khensur Rinpoche)
Study of the Mind - 02 SoM
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk continues a presentation on the seven types of consciousness, giving a rough outline of each and then beginning a detailed explanation of direct perceiver as a non-mistaken knower free from conceptuality. It contrasts conception, mistaken consciousness and inference by sign, and notes that a Buddha has only direct perceivers. The second half is a question and answer session on whether the prime cognizer is part of the mind and why Buddhists study the mind, with the answer that unskillful states must be subdued to reach enlightenment.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 42 min

UUID: 883e4cb4-376b-425e-b15f-c22e762019d6

Words: 2,552

Which is wavering between thinking it is this way or it is that way. So it’s a mind which is wavering between, for example, thinking, Is it a person? Is it not a person? Is it a pot? Is it not a pot?

Is it permanent? Is it not permanent? Wavering between these positions, it’s a two pointed mind which cannot stabilize on understanding the object. A two pointed mind which wavers between two different positions. For example, you wake up in the morning, just think, well, should I go to work today or shouldn’t I go?

That’s doubt. And in such a position, while you’re staying in that, you’re only in that position, you’re not enjoying yourself in that position nor are you going to actually can you accomplish what would bring your happiness, why this doubt exists. Then the seventh is wrong consciousness. Wrong consciousness is the consciousness which apprehends the object in an opposite way to its actual nature. For example, thinking that even though the actual nature of this table is impermanent, conceiving it to be permanent would be a wrong consciousness.

It’s apprehending in the opposite way it actually exists. So we’ve this is just we’ve just roughly gone through these seven types of consciousness. And in the future, now we’re going to this is just to give you a sense, an idea of what’s coming. And now we’re going to, in the future, go into each of these in detail so that you can understand them each thoroughly. So we’ll begin with an explanation of direct perceiver.

The definition of direct perceiver is a non mistaken knower that is free from conceptuality. A non mistaken knower that is free from conceptuality. A non mistaken knower that is free from conceptuality. So, definition is a composite of three different concepts. First is non what do we mean by non mistaken, knower, and free from conceptuality.

So we to begin by understanding what we mean by conception. Now, thinking mind, which reflects upon what your room might look like, what the path outside looks, what the road looks like outside, to that mind appears that object. Your room appears to that thinking, to that thought consciousness. The path, the road appears to that consciousness. This type of mind, the consciousness to which these objects are appearing, is what we mean by conception.

For example, you know, someone had not who never gone to Bodh Gaya, which is in India, and just in dependence upon my describing Bodh Gaya, I said, you know, there’s a very big stupa or reliquary monument, you know, and I described them, the stupa, and I said, Then the bodhi tree is there, and then behind the bodhi tree is a Buddha sitting there. It just depends upon my speech, my description. Some image begins to form in your mind, some concept about what Bodh Gaya must be like even though you’ve never been there. This mind in which this idea about Bodh Gaya is forming is what we mean by conception. Simply in dependence upon my speaking words, the words enter into your ear, and you hear the words and you begin to think about what, for example, Bodh Gaya is like.

And so, image, the mind which forms in this way, is a conception which follows dependence upon terms or sound. So all these various consciousness which think, thought consciousness, we’re thinking, Oh, this is blue, this is a man, this is a house. All these consciousness we think, This is this. This is that. These are all conceptions, conceptual consciousnesses.

So when we say in the definition of prime cognizer, say free from conceptuality, we mean non conceptual, not conceptual. When we say free, we mean it’s not conceptual, that it’s free from all this type of thought consciousness. So then the second term that we have to understand is non mistaken. If we were to look up in the sky and we were to see two moons, in fact there’s only one moon in the sky, but if were to see two moons, that would be a mistaken consciousness. For example, if we press on the eyeball, we can see two images of the moon, and the consciousness perceiving these two images would be a mistaken consciousness.

Another example is that someone who is suffering from a bile disease. For example, if someone has hepatitis, when they look at a white piece of paper, the white piece of paper appears yellow due to the illness. This perception, this apprehension of a yellow piece of paper would be a mistaken consciousness. So another example of mistaken mistake would be if we got in the car and we were out driving and we were passing some trees. Now, we can become mistaken to what is actually moving.

It can appear to us that the trees are moving, where in fact the trees aren’t moving. It’s the car who is moving. So this appearance of the trees moving is a mistaken appearance. It’s mistaken. So, what we’re talking about here is something which is that which is not mistaken, that which is in accordance with the way the thing actually is, in accordance with its actual nature.

It’s non mistaken. Have we taken another example to our direct perception to our eye consciousness which perceives the flower? The flower, what appears is the flower, and we’re not mistaken with respect to the flower because it actually is a flower. Something which is not a flower is not appearing. We’re not mistaken because what is actually a flower is appearing, and it is in fact that’s the way it actually exists, and therefore the eye consciousness which perceives the flower is not mistaken.

And then this third term was knower, and when we explained the definition of consciousness, that is, that which is clear in knowing, we went into the explanation of knower. And therefore, we’ve explained the three terms within this definition of direct perceiver. So we’re going to spend the remaining part of the teaching of our period answering questions. So if you have any questions that you’d like to answer, Rinpoche will answer them. Definition of knower.

So the term knower itself does not have a definition, but it has a sense. It has a meaning. And the meaning of the term knower is seeing the object The meaning of knower is that to which an object appears. That to which an object appears. That to which an object appears is the meaning of knower.

It also can be that to which an object is reflected. When we talked about the nature of consciousness, it’s as if the consciousness We use the analogy of a mirror, that the object is able to be reflected in the mirror, but unlike a mirror, which is able the mind reflects the object, but unlike a mirror, it’s actually able to move forward toward the object and apprehend the characteristics of the object. So this is the quality of the knower. It is the ability to move toward and actually comprehend the characteristics of the object. So first, the object comes toward the consciousness and is reflected just as in a mirror and then the consciousness actually moves toward the object and is able to comprehend its characteristics.

Okay. Let me just point out that it’s not quite a definite it’s just a rough Yeah. I don’t think I use the word realizes. No, it doesn’t realize. It doesn’t realize.

Okay. Go ahead, I’m sorry. Which examines object value without relying on reason or experience? I didn’t say realize. Yeah, yeah.

But just in my own experience, I can’t think of any situation where I couldn’t I don’t use original experience. Even when I think of a baby, even though it doesn’t label its mother, it’s using reason and experience to start to respond positively to her. You mean when you do examine an object that you always are relying on reason or experience? So when you examine something, it’s not necessary that you have to depend upon either experience or reason. For example, if someone said in this room there was an image of a Buddha and you had never seen an image of a Buddha, and you came in this room and you stand in front of this particular image, and you say, I wonder if that’s a Buddha or not.

You’re examining this image, but your examination is not relying on either reasoning or experience. But it means that I already have an idea in my head what a Buddha who a Buddha is or what a Buddha is. Probably, do you mean just by a sit go at this door some of the label? I’m getting a bit confused because I think that most people would have an idea from their reading and experience who Buddha is or a little bit something about Buddha, but it may not have a a representation. But I still have ideas in my head about a Buddha before I come into this room.

We’re talking about a person who doesn’t Uh-huh. For example. So you’re saying they have nothing. They don’t know anything about Buddha. Yeah.

We’re using that as an example. Right. They’re examining, but they’re not relying on either reasoning or experience in the process of their examination. Right. So it’s just the same as if you gave me the word of Dor in Tibetan, Is it?

Just exactly that same thing. And I would just accept that because I it’s not reliable, my reason or experience, except for my concept of door. As to whether that’s a door or not? No. No.

It’s whether the label you give me in Tibetan is really what it is in Tibetan or not. Just say, for example, what is a door in Tibetan? You gather the Tibetan word. I don’t know from my experience or reason whether that’s correct or not. I just accept it blindly.

Is that the same? Can I when they forget all the day? Right? Yes, that’s right. You’re just depending upon you don’t understand what a door is, what the Tibetan he means when he says word door you’re just using a label and applying it without any reason.

Yeah. Wish I gave two examples for I think this is for indirect cognition. Indirect? Sorry. Inferential cognition.

And one of them, which was smoke for fire, except that the other one, was that having a red face implied anger, I didn’t feel that I that that was a valid thing. Don’t marvel. Don’t marvel. So, just on the basis of the sign of red face by itself is not a correct sign to infer anger. But if this person’s face was not red when you began speaking with him, and as you spoke with him his face became red, that could be a correct sign in dependence upon which you could infer that he’s becoming angry, he’s angry.

Just in general, a red face doesn’t mean a person’s angry. No. But also, one possibility, if he didn’t have a red face to begin with and his face became red, it could be because he was embarrassed. So in dependence upon what you’re saying to this person, then you can infer by his red face that he’s becoming angry. And also by other signs that for example, if he was becoming embarrassed, then there’s a tendency to shrink back.

And his face may become red, but there’s other signs that you would take into consideration his attention to shrink back. When a person becomes angry, he kind of blows up. This kind of becomes bigger. So in dependence upon what you’re saying and all these various signs taken together, but mainly the the red face. I see.

Rinpoche apologizes to anyone who just because they have a red face that they think Rinpoche thinks they’re angry. He doesn’t mean to infer that they’re all angry just because they have red faces. Is the prime cognizer the mind or part of the mind? Is the prime cognizer right? Well, what is it?

I mean, is it the mind — what part of us does it belong to? Is it us? Is it our minds? So, in different individuals at different times within their awareness, a prime cognizer arises. Different individuals at different moments within their awareness, a prime cognizer arises.

What is a prime cognizer? So a prime cognizer is a new incontrovertible knower. A new incontrovertible knower. And how does that relate to, like those of us that come over to Buddha House and we hear lectures about the mind, in what way does that relate to my sort of very basic understanding of mind? I mean, it must be part of the mind, surely, if we’re thinking it.

Yeah, it’s a part of mind. And if we’re looking at things all the time, isn’t it aren’t we doing it all the time? Making sort of those at the levels that you read out, I mean, are we are we constantly doing that all the time, looking and These seven consciousnesses? They’re Those are happening all the time, really, aren’t they? Every time while we’re awake, we’re on those different seven levels, are we?

So, in the case of, for example, of Buddha, he only has direct perceivers. He doesn’t have any of the other six. Whereas, the course of ordinary people, each moment of consciousness would be classed as either one of these seven. Could you ask him why the Buddhists study this then? Is it sort of part of learning to see more clearly?

Why study awareness and knowledge? There isn’t mean, is it to sort of become more clear about what we see, about perception? So just as in a room there are a variety of material objects. Likewise, with respect to the mind there are a variety of various states of mind which arise. Some of these states of mind are skillful, some are unskillful.

So, order to achieve Buddhahood, are seeking to enhance the skillful states and to eliminate the unskillful states. This is the method of achieving enlightenment. Therefore, we have to know which minds are skillful, which states our minds are skillful and which are unskillful, and begin to decrease the power of those unskillful ones and increase the power of the skillful ones. And therefore, it’s necessary to know all the varieties of types of mind. Thank you.

So it’s important that we understand how our mind is operating because we have many types of mind arising. For example, we have skillful states of mind, unskillful states of mind. And dependence upon unskillful states of mind, we engage in negative actions. And dependence upon negative actions, we experience suffering. And therefore, if we finally want to bring an end to our suffering, then we have to bring an end to our negative actions, and therefore we have to subdue our unskillful states of mind, unskillful varieties of consciousness, and therefore we have to be able to recognize, and therefore it’s quite necessary to study them.

So no more questions? Okay. What is the question? Can you make your question a little bit clearer?

Questions answered in this teaching

What is the definition or meaning of the term 'knower' in the study of the mind?

The term knower does not have a formal definition, but it has a meaning: that to which an object appears. It can also be described as that to which an object is reflected. The analogy is a mirror, in which an object is reflected. Unlike a mirror, though, the mind can move toward the object and apprehend its characteristics. So the quality of the knower is the ability to move toward an object and actually comprehend its characteristics. First the object comes toward the consciousness and is reflected, as in a mirror. Then the consciousness moves toward the object and comprehends its characteristics.

Is a red face a valid sign from which to infer that someone is angry?

A red face by itself is not a correct sign for inferring anger, and in general a red face does not mean a person is angry. It can be a correct sign if the person's face was not red when you began speaking and became red as you spoke, so that the change depends on what you are saying. Even then, the redness could come from embarrassment. Other signs help tell the two apart. An embarrassed person tends to shrink back, while an angry person kind of blows up and seems to become bigger. The inference rests on what is being said and these various signs taken together, though mainly the red face.

Why do Buddhists study the mind, and is it part of learning to see more clearly?

Just as a room holds many material objects, the mind has many states that arise, some skillful and some unskillful. To achieve Buddhahood, one seeks to strengthen the skillful states and eliminate the unskillful ones, which is the method of achieving enlightenment. So one must know which states of mind are skillful and which are unskillful, in order to decrease the power of the unskillful and increase the power of the skillful. This requires knowing all the varieties of mind. Unskillful states lead us to engage in negative actions, and negative actions lead to suffering. To end suffering, we must end negative actions, which means subduing unskillful states of mind.

Scroll to Top