45 min · 2,512 words · 16 February 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the positive mental factors of non-hatred (translated as mercy or sympathy) and non-ignorance, the wisdom that removes unknowing. It compares wisdom to turning on a light in a dark room and describes hearing, contemplation and meditation as the stages for developing it. It also covers meditation on repulsiveness as an antidote to attachment, followed by questions and answers.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-02-16
Duration: 45 min
UUID: c1a2aa3a-85ff-40af-8fd7-53be38b9ec7c
Words: 2,508
So the the fifth positive factor is non hatred. Non hatred is the opposite of hatred. In hatred, there is an intent to bring harm to either sentient beings, suffering, or sources of suffering. And with non hatred, there is the non intention. There’s the lack of intention to bring harm with respect to these three objects of sentient beings, suffering, and sources of suffering.
We can say that anger and hatred are are the same. You know, therefore, hatred or non anger are the same. When we talk about non hatred, we mean the quality. Sometimes it’s translated as mercy or I think maybe sympathy. Empathy.
Mercy. I think sympathy is the most good. The sixth positive mental factor is non ignorant. I think it could be translated as non delusion, but also perhaps non confusion. But the standard translation is non ignorant.
With respect to ignorance or confusion or division, it is an obscuration with respect to the actual nature of an object. This is what we mean by ignorance. So therefore, nonignorance would be the lack of obscuration with respect to the nature of the object. That is to say, the wisdom which understands the object is nonignorant. Just as in the case of if we were in this room, but it was it was dark in this room, we would not be able to, due to the obscuring quality of the darkness, we would not be able to come to know what objects were in the room.
Likewise with respect to the obscuring qualities of delusion or ignorance, we’re unable to actually know the the the reality or the nature of the objects which are which we are trying to observe. Whereas if we were to bring a light in the room, we could easily come to identify the actual objects in the room. Likewise, with the wisdom or non ignorant, we come to actually know the action. We come to know the actual nature of the objects before that we’re observing. So so the turning on the light in a room as a means of coming to understand the objects in a room is is analogous to development of wisdom.
This as when we are obscured due to darkness, by by turning on the light, we can come to know objects. Likewise, through development of wisdom, we can overcome the obscuration of ignorance. We come to know the various objects. And initially in order to bring about this wisdom it’s necessary to engage in much hearing listening and therefore through hearing we are beginning to eliminate obscurations which prevent us from knowing the the objects of understanding. So it is through engaging in the activity of hearing that we come to know what is to be practiced and what is to be cultivated, what is to be rejected, what are the categories of positive phenomena, what are the categories of negative phenomena.
We come to know this through hearing. So therefore it’s said that hearing is is is like the light eliminating the darkness of of ignorance. So initially we didn’t know anything about the dharma. Slowly upon listening to it, we’ve come to develop some wisdom with respect to the dharma. We’ve come to some understanding about what the dharma is about.
This is this is a sign that there’s been a process of eliminating the obscuration of ignorance from our mind. It’s coming to some intermediate understanding of the of the nature of dharma. So, you know, this process that we’ve that we’ve been going through of eliminating various the obstructions, you know, We’ve reached in some kind of intermediate stage. And when we talk about a Buddha, we’re simply talking about someone who has brought this this to final, to some sort of culmination. That they have this quality of unknowing has been completely eliminated and there has come about a state of knowing all objects whatsoever.
You know we talked about the Buddha from many points of view, talked about the various qualities of having head protrusion, a crown knot on its head, all the various symbols and signs and marks and signs on its body. But essentially, you know, these are all secondary to simple fact that when we talk about a Buddha, what we mean when we say a Buddha is someone who has completely eliminated all the unknowing and has come to know all phenomena totally. And this is we’re involved in this this process. So in the case of, for example, Milarepa. Now Milarepa, he didn’t have a a crown top-knot.
He didn’t have the the Dharma wheels on his hand. He just had what appeared to be an ordinary body. So when we talk about a Buddha, we’re talking about some inner quality, not something that would necessarily be seen externally. We’re talking about someone who has completely developed their themselves internally, and that is the way they go about this. What they have actually done is eliminating all the factor of unknowing from their mind and develop the factor of being able to know all phenomena.
Likewise, the development of an awakening heart, the mind of enlightenment is an internal quality that we ourselves can through training practice can develop this. Though we have developed this internal quality, you know, our our our outside appearance can remain quite ordinary at the at the the body, but this inside quality, we can develop within a we develop this internal quality of the awakening mind. Whereas having developed such an internal quality for those who understand that we have developed that quality such as the awakening heart, for example the Buddhas who are able to understand that someone has developed an awakening heart and they press their palms together in great reverence and see them as a real source of refuge for sentient beings then this is something that it’s an internal quality which we can’t ordinarily see from the outside. So in in in our progression towards Buddhahood, what we’re seeking to do is to eliminate the factor of unknowing within our mind. And we can begin to do this through the process of the activity of hearing.
And we develop we’re trying to generate the wisdom which is the which is the which would by which unknowing is eliminated. This this is this is our our work. This is what we we are to be involved in. There’s no other way to do it than this. We can’t simply develop the quality of Buddha by walking around.
So there’s a to the to the grounds of Buddhahood, there’s no way we can walk there or we can drive our car or any of these means. So it’s through the two. You know, if we it’s through walking within our own mind that that with the legs of wisdom and method that we progress to Buddhahood. So we’ll take the rest of remaining period of time to have questions and answer. And answers.
We’ll have some good day. So just to be a competitive aid and differentiate to understand how how well you’re developing how your measure of your your understanding is coming along. Yeah. Yeah. The yeah.
Non hatred. I think it’s usually translated as mercy. I think sympathies are good for it also. Benevolence. Right.
Other words. But, usually, the standard translation is mercy. Non hatred. Yeah. So in in general, the the means for combating attachment is the meditation on repulsiveness.
For example, with if you have attachment to a person, then you could meditate on in a skeleton, meditate on skeleton. So they did did. So we’re talking about attachment to human to human to human form, human body. If one is attached to human body, it med meditates on skeletons, you know, without without any when there’s no flesh on on the bone, on the repulse upon its developing the sense that the human body is is repulsive. If you need to understand that perhaps you have attachment to the to the smoothness, you know, the the texture texture of the body, or you have attachment to the nice color of the body, then you would in that case, you would meditate on a corpse, which is a You mean any other particular type of attachment object?
Object to attachment. Your original question was toward animals. So, yeah, there’s a danger that upon, as you as you mentioned, developing a non hatred toward an object. There’s a sympathy or mercy that you could develop attachment or desire towards an object. If in the case of a person then you make use of it, meditating on the repulsive qualities of it, in the negative qualities of it.
And then with respect to, you know, using the example as you did the world peace, that’s an example. I it’s very something very positive like that. He said, you know, that there we might want to establish world establishing world peace, which would be a very desirable thing, but we shouldn’t become attached to that to that to that to that type of peace even though it’s a good thing because as a means to overcome that attachment to even to such a positive object as that then we’d have to think of it such a type of peace is impermanent, that it’s empty, that it doesn’t have an essence. It’s not inherently existing. It’s under the control of karma and afflictive emotion, considering all the draw back of such even the of such a good thing as peace, still this would act as a way to overcome your attachment.
It’s in the same case that, you know, it’s quite you know, we all like to be happy. But, it would be completely unskillful to become attached to happiness even though we want to be happy, even though we like happiness. We’d be unskillful to become attached to it. So when we if we for for example, if we were to develop attachment towards pleasurable feelings, then within the within the middle way tradition, one would when this when this attachment to pleasurable feelings arose, one would meditate that the feeling, the feeler, and the experience of the feeling are all empty or lack inherent existing as a means for overcoming attachment to pleasurable feeling. So hatred arises independent of these three objects, either thinking being from suffering or a source of suffering.
And dependence on those hatred arises. In developing non hatred, we are preventing So, you know, the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas look upon sentient beings in the same way that the the parents pick up on their children with the same type of affection. The same way their parents look upon their children. Though in fact no matter what the child does they have a love or sympathy or benevolence towards the children, still when the child acts in a manner, studies well, then they are pleased with their child and though they are still loving their children when their child acts in a negative manner, for example if they were to steal or something like that, they would be displeased with their child. Likewise though the Buddha is constantly looking upon all sentient beings with love, with its affectionate qualities, mercy, then even though they still have a or constantly have this possessive attitude towards sentient beings when they act in such a way, for example practicing Dharma, engaging in positive types of action, they can understand that this person will quickly attain Buddhahood and therefore they are very with such an individual.
And, likewise, though, they’re constantly being affect affectionate towards all sentient beings. Still, when sentient beings act in a negative manner, they act in a very distinct way because sentient beings are moving away from attaining Buddhahood. So just as in coming to understand what objects are in a dark room, it’s definitely necessary that we have to have light. Likewise, in coming to an understanding of the nature of all the varieties of objects, we have to have initial the initial initial activity of hearing. Hearing is like the light turning on the light.
Having engaged in the activity of hearing, then we actually come to know the object. We we ascertain the object. This ascertainment is is analogous to the second activity which we have to engage in. That is contemplation. That is hearing and contemplation.
So we turn the light, then we come to know what the objects are, and then we come we familiarize ourselves, accustom ourselves to these various objects, and this is the third activity of meditation. So there’s this hearing, contemplating, and meditation. But it must first off, we have to turn on the light, and this is again, this process has begun with the activity of hearing. So just as in the world, in order to come to come to know what you know, what are what’s going on in the world around us, we can we can, for example, read the newspaper. Without reading the newspaper then we are completely in the dark about what is happening in the world.
We don’t have any idea. So in order get an understanding of what is happening around us, people Likewise, in order to come and understand about the phenomena around us we have to begin with the activity of hearing, just getting to know what the things are around us, getting to know what the events are, the phenomena are. Then we we upon actually ascertaining what those phenomena are, this is the quality of activity of of contemplation. Contemplation, we actually have are eliminating the obscuration. And then we go on to accustom ourselves to familiarize ourselves with these various objects, and this is the process this is the activity of meditation, and meditation involves the the development of positive qualities.
So the the contemplation is elimination of the obscurations to coming to ascertain what the eliminating obscurations as to the unknowing of these objects. And then meditation is kinda accustom myself to these objects, familiarizing myself whereby to develop positive types of qualities through excellent just as when we watch the news on television, if if we had the sound turned off, you just see lots of cars and houses on the screen. You don’t know what this is objects. You don’t know what what they’re about. You don’t know what’s happening.
But as soon as we turn the sound up and we can listen to them, we can understand how what what these houses and people are about the these cars, what they’re doing, what’s happening in this particular house. They come to know something. We can begin to ascertain what is going on on the screen, these pictures, what they need. So this is like the worldly worldly measure of standard, you know, to get to we read the newspapers. We listen to the news on television in order to come to know what’s happening around.
And this is the knowledge of hearing. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.