Rinpoche’s Story

1 h 51 min · 4,502 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 111-minute teaching, Khensur Rinpoche provides a systematic, in-depth commentary on the three principles of the path—renunciation, bodhicitta, and correct view—the core framework of Mahāyāna Buddhist practice. He begins with motivational groundwork, emphasizing the importance of practicing ethics as the foundation for all realisation. He then moves through the meaning of human rebirth and its rarity, the practice of generosity and patience, and the cultivation of concentration. The bulk of the talk focuses on the view of emptiness combined with dependent arising, drawing extensively on Nāgārjuna. Rinpoche elaborates on the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka understanding of dependent arising as mere nominal and conceptual imputation, showing how emptiness and interdependence reinforce rather than contradict each other—the key to cutting the root of cyclic existence. He addresses partiality of view and concludes with a student Q&A on whether enlightened minds conceptualise. Intended for serious practitioners with some philosophical training.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Line in 0147.mp3

UUID: 4fd382b2-1e99-434f-8730-7358aa8808dc

Teacher: HH Dalai Lama

Collection: Rinpoche's Story

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,497

So both when listening and when, teaching Dharma, it is important to have a good motivation, a motivation to benefit others. In dependence on such a motivation, we will be able, through listening and through having Dharma taught, to accumulate a large collection of merit. So there will be a great benefit if we meditate for one or two minutes on generating the motivation to listen to the three principles of the path, which are the essence of the Mahāyāna teaching, of the Mahāyāna teachings. Thinking that instead of cherishing oneself, one should cherish others since others are infinite in numbers, then and in addition, they can be said to be only one’s parents. Then we should cherish them.

And based on this cherishing reflect that we would like to place him in a state bereft of suffering and of the causes of suffering and a state endowed with happiness and the causes of happiness, but not just any ordinary happiness, instead, the peerless happiness of full enlightenment. This generate this motivation. Page one one b, refuge and bodhicitta for teachings. And if you’re not familiar with the Tibetan phonetic, you can look in the page two. Page five, Mandala offerings.

Verse six, we will recite the first and the last one. We are very fortunate to have obtained a basis for the establishment of Dharma, the practice of Dharma, a human rebirth, to have encountered the teachings of the Buddha, and to be surrounded by helpers in our practice of Dharma. And then having obtained this body, it is important to make this human life of ours meaningful. We make it meaningful through at the supreme level of practice becoming ordained and entering the Mahāyāna stream of practice, aiming for practices which lead us to the state of a Bodhisattva and to full enlightenment. At the middling level of practice, although we are not able to practice at this higher level of practice, at least being aware of the suffering which arises from the afflictions resolving to eliminate all afflictions from within our mind and to attain liberation.

And if even that is not possible at the lowest level of practice, at least to focus on attaining a higher rebirth in the next life and avoiding the lower rebirths. In this case, Dharma will have been meaningful. Therefore, we should put this body of ours, this human rebirth of ours to a good use. And if we do not put it to good use now where we have the possibility to do so, because it is an impermanent phenomenon and we have no way of being sure of the time when it will be destroyed. We are facing the possibility that we will not have practiced at the time our human rebirth is destroyed.

Then at the time of death, if there has been no practice, we will be in a very sorry state indeed. And from that point onwards, there is unfortunately

No guarantee of getting such a human rebirth again anytime soon in the future. So when we speak of practice, what is meant here? What is meant here is first and foremost to generate faith and conviction in the triple gem, in the Buddha, in the Dharma, his teachings, and in the Sangha. If we do this, we will avoid lower rebirths. There are most definitely past and future lives.

And then if we can avoid lower rebirths and future lives, that is already a plus. And, therefore, it is crucial to practice the 10 virtues and to abstain from the 10 non virtues. So what exactly should we engage in to obtain a human rebirth? As Buddha Śākyamūni said, without ethics, there are no higher rebirths. So the first and foremost practice is the practice of ethics.

The practice of ethics may be compared to the ground on which we rely or the ground in which crops are planted. It is in dependence on the ground that crops, come to fruition, that trees and fruits, eventually come to fruition. It is also in dependence on the ground that we stand. Without the ground, crops cannot come to fruition. Likewise, without the ground, we would ourselves fall.

So it is the support for everything. Likewise, ethics is the foundation for practice. And in dependence on ethics, one will obtain in future lives a human rebirth. However, obtaining a human rebirth is far from sufficient. If we were to be reborn as human beings, as paupers and mendicants struggling to gain our daily living and barely eking out a living, that would be of little or no benefit.

So in addition to the practice of morality or ethics, it is crucial to practice generosity. In dependence on the practice of generosity, as Nāgārjuna said, we will gain prosperity from ethics, happiness and from generosity, prosperity. Finally, we should also engage in the practice of patience or forbearance. The practice of patience would enable us not merely to have a pleasant complexion, but also to be surrounded by a good entourage, good friends, and to meet with the teachings. Finally, we should in dependence on all of this train in wisdom.

Without wisdom, we are only akin to animals, and it is in dependence on these three first perfections that the training and wisdom eventually becomes possible. And therefore, in dependence on the practice of ethics or morality, we can put an end contingently to, lower rebirths. Unfortunately, as long as we have not put an actual end to cyclic existence as a whole, we will not have put an end to lower rebirths in general because they are part of the cycle of lives. And therefore, to put an end to cyclic existence as a whole, we first, on top of ethics, must train in concentration. The, training in concentration is akin to a training in stabilizing the mind, which enables us to walk steadily.

And then in addition to this training in concentration, we must train in wisdom. We must therefore train in the three three trainings of ethics, concentration, and wisdom. And not just any wisdom, but actually the wisdom which realizes the selflessness of phenomena. And as much as the selflessness of phenomena, is the actual nature of phenomena, it is what enables us to cut through the root of cyclic existence, which is that ignorance which apprehends phenomena as inherently existing. And it is only through cutting through the root of cyclic existence that eventually we will be able to put an end to cyclic existence as a whole.

As Ārya Nāgārjuna said, he who does not know emptiness is not the base for liberation. Such an ignorant will cycle endlessly. The meaning of this quote says that one who does not know emptiness is one who has not realized emptiness. Realization of emptiness should be our goal. But for one such who has not realized emptiness, liberation is impossible.

Therefore, one who has not realized emptiness is not a suitable base for liberation. It’s not a suitable basis for liberation. It is therefore important for us to meditate on the wisdom which realizes emptiness because otherwise, as Nāgārjuna says in the second verse of this quote, the ignorant will cycle endlessly. The ignorant he who does not realize the emptiness of phenomena will never be freed from the enclosure of the cycle of lives and will always be captive of it. And cyclic existence is endless, and the minds of beings within cyclic existence is endless.

For instance, when a child is born from a mother, he is born in the mother’s house. He is born in her womb, actually, but his mind actually is beginningless. It comes from beginningless time. And in dependence on the existence of past lives, the existence of future lives can be deduced. Should there be past lives which did not give rise to a future life, these past lives would actually be past lives with no effect and would automatically ipso facto become permanent.

Since they are not permanent, then necessarily past lives give rise to future lives. And therefore, the child in turn grows adult, eventually ages as the karma which impelled him within this life wanes, and the time comes for him to abandon his body to die. And then he is reborn again in another body, grows up, ages, and die again. And this cycle is perpetuated, a cycle which is actually impelled by virtuous and non-virtuous karma. So Khensur Rinpoche says there is most definitely, there are most definitely past and future lives.

Were they’re not past and future lives, then none of our practice would make sense. It would not make sense to be ordained. That would be meaningless. It would not make sense to meditate. It would not make sense to engage in the practices of hearing, thinking, and meditation.

It would probably just be appropriate to fool around and play. These are the preliminaries in particular.

And then returning or moving onwards in our text, the three principles of the path, we are at the stanza appearances are infallible dependent origination. Voidness is free of assertions. As long as these two understandings are seen as separate, one has not yet realized the intent of the Buddha. The first verse of this stanza appearances are infallible dependent origination refers to the fact that phenomena arise from their own uncommon causes and not from other causes. So for instance, if we were to take an agricultural metaphor, wheat crops arise from wheat seeds, rice crops arise from rice seeds, and barley crops arise from barley seeds.

They do not crossover. Likewise, the requisite effect arises from its own uncommon cause. The second verse will be commented by Rinpoche in a different way from the translation in your text. Your text reads voidness is free of assertions. Rinpoche will interpret this verse as follows.

The two understandings which are free from the acceptances, emptiness, and so forth. These two understandings refer here generally speaking to the shared view of Madhyamaka by both schools, the Svatantrikas and the Prasangikas. Both Madhyamaka schools assert an emptiness which is an absence of establishment by its own characteristics and an absence of true establishment. However, the two assertions which must be conjoined and which must not be understood separately are the assertions both of dependent arising and emptiness. One who accepts dependent arising but does not accept empty emptiness.

Or on the other hand, one who accepts emptiness but does not accept dependent arising is not one who accepts these two assertions which must be conjoined. And one who has not realized the intent of the Buddha is one who does not see these two understandings, excuse me, who sees these two understandings as separate and who does not understand everything that appears as it is. One can say that one has understood the thought of the muni when one is a a person or a practitioner who has understood that emptiness on the one hand benefits dependent arising and the dependent arising on the other hand benefits emptiness. And specifically, there were a certain number of ancient Indian practitioners as well as early, Tibetan practitioners who wholly understood the naturelessness of phenomena. In other words, the fact that phenomena lacked inherent existence were not able to posit interdependence or dependent origination, and therefore their understanding was said to be a partial understanding.

Likewise, certain other practitioners endowed with partiality were able to posit naturelessness or the lack of inherent existence of phenomena with respect to one specific base, but we’re not able to extend it to other bases. For instance, they might say that the table Rinpoche, has would lack naturelessness, would lack nature. In other words, would be endowed with naturelessness, but that a flower would not. Now these are examples of what is called partiality with respect to the view. It is the type of misunderstanding which sees appearances and emptiness as contradictory in the same way as heat and cold would be seen as contradictory.

And for instance, among the, three lower schools, the Vaibhāṣikas, the Sautrantikas, and the Cittamātrins, it is possible to posit dependent origination on the basis of things, ngopo, or bhava in Sanskrit. But, even though it is possible to posit dependent origination on the basis of things, these three lower schools do not consider things as lacking existence by their own characteristics or lacking true existence since they assert that effective phenomena or things phenomena which are able to perform a function are established by their own characteristics and are also truly established. This would be a clear instance of partiality. In the case of the mind only the Cittamātra school, for instance, with respect to the imputed nature from within the three natures the school accepts, the imputed nature is actually said to lack true existence. However, although the imputed nature lacks true existence, the Cittamātra school does not consider it as a dependent arising since it asserts that the imputed nature is a permanent phenomenon.

And generally speaking, even within the Madhyamaka school itself, there are instances of practitioners accepting one of the two emptiness or dependent arising and not accepting the other. If this were not the case, then the syllogism, the subject vase for instance, it follows that it lacks true existence because it is a dependent arising would not be a valid syllogism for that person since it could only be a valid syllogism for a person which accepted that vase was a dependent arising, but did not accept that vase lacked true existence. Moreover, one must distinguish clearly within the Madhyamaka school itself between the positions of the Svatantrikas and the Prasangikas. Now it is only the uncommon understanding of the Prāsaṇgika’s understanding of interdependence as well as lack of inherent existence within the Prāsaṇgika school, which is a gateway both to liberation and to full enlightenment. The understandings of the Prasangikas and of lack of true existence of the lower schools cannot act as a gateway to liberation or to full enlightenment.

Fundamentally, what must be realized is the simultaneous realization. In other words, the realization at the same time, on the same basis of that mere understanding of the interdependence of the basis and the lack of true existence of the basis. When this definite ascertainment is generated on the basis of an incontrovertible and uncontaminated understanding of the interdependent existence of that basis, then it is possible within the mental continuum of one who has realized this to block, to put an end to the apprehension of true existence. This process where one generates a definite ascertainment of the non true existence of the basis one actually generates a valid cognizer, which realizes that the basis lacks true existence in turn is the antidote to that apprehension of true existence. And as Rinpoche explained, there are three broad categories of dependent arising in increasing levels of subtlety.

The causes level of dependent arising is causal dependent arising, which is dependent arising on the basis of a cause or a condition. A more subtle form of dependent arising is dependent arising in dependence on composition, in other words, on parts. And the most subtle form of dependent arising is that dependent arising which is due to the mere imputation by name, by sign, or by conception. This is the uncommon presentation of dependent arising. It is capital to understand that if phenomena are not established by mere name or conceptuality, then from the Prāsaṇgika standpoint, they cannot be said to arise or to exist in the same way as if a cause did not exist, its effect in no way could be said to arise.

Rinpoche is commenting now elaborately on the three principles of the path based on written commentary in which, he has been reading the following lines. With respect to the basis of all phenomena, all phenomena can be said to be mere nominal imputations. In as much as they are mere nominal imputations, they can be understood to be, mere dependent arisings in the subtle most sense which the Prāsaṇgika school, adopts. What is meant by this is that phenomena do not arise through their own power or from their own side. They arise merely through the power of the name, which is imputed on them.

And when we say here merely, the term merely has a very precise technical sense. Merely here actually excludes the object of negation, which is phenomena is being established inherently. So when we say that phenomena are mere nominal semantic or conceptual imputations through that term mere and through excluding the fact that phenomena are inherently established, we are also implying that they do not exist in the slightest way inherently even at the level of the particles constituting them. For instance, if we were to give an example, let us take the case of a person. A person is said to be an imputation on the basis of the five aggregates.

Apart from that imputation, that name, sign, and conception imputed on the basis of the person, the actual person is unfindable in ultimate analysis. In the same way, if one were to impute the term snake on the basis of a coiled length of rope, then that imputation snake exists merely at the level of a noun on the basis of that basis of imputation, the rope, whether this imputation is valid or invalid. And this is the case, this mode of existence is a case for all beings, whether they be humans, animals, horses, and whatnot. In every single case, they are mere nominal imputations. And therefore, as Rinpoche explained, this term mere in the expression mere nominal imputation is, a term which excludes true establishment, which excludes establishment by its own characteristics.

Therefore, in as much as it excludes true establishment, it implies and establishes non true establishment. Therefore, when we assert that phenomena are mere nominal imputation and thereby assert the emptiness of true existence of phenomena, we also automatically assert the interdependent origination of phenomena and we also automatically assert causality. From dependent origination and from emptiness, therefore, we can say that all causality arises and the causal deeds, both virtuous and non virtuous deeds are accumulated by beings, by human beings, which themselves are mere nominal imputations.

So so far, we have been covering, dependent origination understood in the light of mere nominal imputation. One who has been able to cut the root of the two extremes, in other words, the extremes of eternalism and nihilism, would understand that phenomena lack any inherent existence and for that matter, the very the very atoms lack inherent existence. It is at this point capital to generate the understanding that emptiness and dependent arising are not only non contradictory, but are actually beneficial, actually help each other. And when this understanding has been generated, one can say that the view has been perfected. So through eliminating partiality within the mind stream and understanding first the causal levels of dependent origination, which is dependent origination in terms of causality.

And then the subtlest uncommon prasangika presentation of dependent origination, which is mere nominal imputation and understanding of dependent origination in turn can be generated within the mind stream. And when eventually this realization of both the coarse and the subtle forms of dependent origination occurs simultaneously with the realization of that emptiness which is a lack of true existence of phenomena, then one can say that the view has indeed been completed. Therefore, the goal here is to generate within one’s mental continuum simultaneously both the realization of the coarse and subtle dependent origination of phenomena and the view of emptiness. This is a presentation of dependent origination understood as mere nominal imputation. The second presentation of dependent origination always from the Prāsaṇgika standpoint is a presentation of imputation from a conceptual standpoint.

In other words, dependent origination understood as mere conceptual imputation. And this is done on the basis of a basis of imputation understood as a collection of phenomena. Any basis of imputation understood as a collection of phenomena must be understood as a basis of imputation on which a designation is merely conceptually imputed. And the classical example for this would, for instance, be a person. On the basis of imputation of the five aggregates and the collection thereof, the imputation, the person is imputed by a mere process of imputation using conceptual consciousness.

The term mere here in mere conceptual imputation excludes as in the context of nominal imputation that, basis of imputation and that imputed phenomenon being established by their own characteristics or being inherently established or being truly established. So the meaning in this context of the term mere is the same as the meaning in the context of imputed by mere nominal imputation. And therefore, once we have on the basis of such a basis of imputation as the five aggregates understood that the imputation, the person is a mere conception imputation, we will also have understood that it lacks inherent existence. That realization of the lack of inherent existence of that basis of imputation and of that imputed phenomena in turn, give rise to an understanding that they lack true existence, and this acts as a direct antidote to that apprehension of the true existence of persons within the minds of beings. And it is said actually that one who understands the key points of dependent arising or interdependence for one such, the meaning of emptiness will dawn instantaneously.

So one can say that the core of the teachings of Ārya Nāgārjuna are the understanding that the meaning of interdependence is actually non true existence and that the meaning of non true existence is actually incontrovertible and, unassailable interdependence. And when we say that the meaning of interdependence is emptiness and that the meaning of emptiness is interdependent interdependence, the term meaning here really is quite akin to the term definition. So we are almost saying that the definition of interdependence is emptiness and that the definition of emptiness is interdependence. If interdependence and emptiness are not said to be one, it is difficult to see what they could be said to be. And therefore, for this reason, Buddha Śākyamūni, because it’s what was such a profound truth said, who can understand the profound and the deep, the clear light, which here refers to emptiness, the uncompounded and that very nectar.

The meaning of this quote is that one who has generated within one’s mental continuum, the simultaneous realization of interdependence and of emptiness on one basis has, at that point in time, reached liberation from the cycle of lives? So the view is, difficult to understand and very profound. So it is not surprising for ourselves that we find this so difficult to realize. But through a progressive process of habituation over the lives, we will implant the karmic imprints to eventually be able to do this. As a famous quote from Sūtra says, those who lack merit do not even doubt.

As for those who doubt, cyclic existence is torn to shreds. The meaning of this quote is that those who lack merit do not even doubt the intrinsic inherent reality of phenomena. They just accept it the way it appears to exist. Those on the other hand who are endowed with merit to merely doubting that phenomena are inherently existent, tear cyclic existence to shreds in the same way as a wicked child would tear a new piece of clothing or a new, raiment to pieces. And therefore, for ourselves, this is what we have to strive for.

Thanks to the kindness of the Buddha, to the kindness of Ārya Mañjuśrī, to the kindness of Lama Tsongkhapa and all the teachers, these transmissions have reached us, and we have to make at present strong prayers to be able in due course to realize the meaning of these teachings. The karmic imprints we have implanted in our minds today through listening to these, teachings are karmic imprints which are worth more than millions and millions of dollars. So reflect to yourselves just how lucky you are.

No. So the question is, does the enlightened mind conceptualize? If not, how does an enlightened mind function when making plans or making decisions? So Khensur Rinpoche says the enlightened mind is completely non conceptual. And actually, he thinks when the enlightened mind makes decisions, it’s actually the wisdom of the enlightened mind which decides and makes plans.

So these plans made by the enlightened non conceptual wisdom are far better than conceptual plans. Conceptual minds are mistaken consciousnesses. And because they’re mistaken consciousnesses, the plans made with conceptual minds are largely mistaken and leads lead to tons of problems. This is this is what happens when you have conceptual plans, the type of manifestations Rinpoche was demonstrating. So the non conceptual planning is far better.

It’s unmistaken. Very, very good. Very, very okay. Page nine. Verse nine.

No. Sorry. Verse eight. Verse nine. Hi.

Thank you very much. I have a few announcement. There is a seminar coming up on Saturday sixth oh, no. Sorry. Wait.

Fourth of July. The it is going to give on Saturday July. The idealist father, and, I welcome everybody. It’s on a Saturday on 02:00 onwards until four. And Geshe la’s teachings on Thursday, Again, tomorrow and, Thursday night.

And, if you are beginner, that would be good to come. Or even if you have been for a long time, it’s also very good. You know, there’s a fantastic you can receive teaching. And, also, tenets is probably, is already done. Those who has gone through quite a bit.

And, July 11, there is, the the Tibetan community in South Australia going to held a a dinner celebration for his holiness Dalai Lama’s birthday. So that, if you like to have a one night fun, I think this is the this is the place. And this is you have a fantastic food and a fantastic entertainment. And I will please don’t miss that, you know. You will enjoy that.

I’ll guarantee for you. Anyway, I have I’m going to pass this to Ilya now. Thank you. Yes. And there’s a small announcement regarding the teachings.

So, I have to leave for Switzerland on the sixteenth. Rinpoche will give his last course on the three principles of the path. He’ll finish the three principles of the path on the fifteenth. That’ll be the last teaching on the topic. And then, from, late August onwards, Rinpoche will resume teaching on Nāgārjuna’s great commentary, the Bodhicaryāvatāra, which His Holiness the Dalai Lama told Rinpoche to be of great benefit to teach in Australia.

This is actually the teaching His Holiness himself will give in Sydney. So it is of great benefit for all. And there’s chai and khabse and fruits. Welcome here. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does an enlightened mind conceptualize, and how does it make plans or decisions if it does not?

The enlightened mind is completely non-conceptual. When it makes decisions and plans, it is the wisdom of the enlightened mind that decides and plans. Plans made by this non-conceptual wisdom are far better than conceptual plans. Conceptual minds are mistaken consciousnesses, so plans made with them are largely mistaken and lead to tons of problems. Non-conceptual planning is far better because it is unmistaken.

Scroll to Top