Rinpoche’s Story

1 h 58 min · 3,904 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this nearly two-hour discourse delivered on His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s birthday, the speaker explores how to extract genuine meaning from human life by turning the mind toward dharma rather than endless worldly pursuits. After establishing motivation through bodhicitta, the teaching unfolds through several classical Buddhist frameworks: first, the precious human rebirth and the inevitability of death, which condition our choices about virtue and non-virtue and shape our future rebirths; second, the doctrine of karma and the lower and higher realms, illustrated concretely through examples of animal suffering; third, a sustained philosophical exposition of the Middle Way view of emptiness and dependent origination, particularly the relationship between the absence of inherent existence and the conventional reality of cause and effect. The speaker emphasizes that emptiness is not nonexistence but rather the absence of independent, self-sufficient nature—a view that permits karma, virtue, and the path to enlightenment to function, unlike both eternalism and nihilism. The talk closes with a birthday celebration announcement.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Line in 0156.mp3

UUID: 4fabab1c-9034-4ffd-9083-cd71a04b698d

Teacher: HH Dalai Lama

Collection: Rinpoche's Story

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,899

# Line in 0156

**Collection:** Audio Recordings — Rinpoche’s Story
**Duration:** 118.4 minutes
**Words:** 3,906
**Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
**Corrections applied:** 9
**Transcribed:** 2026-03-09 05:14

—

Generally speaking, we should engage in any activity with we’re impelled by a good motivation, specifically those activities of listening to teachings and engaging in teachings, giving teachings should be engaged in with a good motivation. And, in addition to this good motivation, one should try to generate both empathy and love as Rinpoche explained last time. And in dependence on empathy and love when we attend teachings, we will then accumulate a huge amount of merit. So we will now meditate for a couple of minutes on generating the motivation of bodhicitta, which is a wish to free all beings from suffering and place them in a state of ultimate happiness and therefore, to strive ourselves for attaining such a state by listening to the essence of the Mahāyāna, the three principal aspects of the path. And if we listen ourselves to the teaching with this motivation and if the teaching is explained in this motivation, not merely will others benefit, but our own practice will proceed very well indeed.

Page one and one b, refuge and bodhicitta for teaching. We’re going to recite this in Tibetan. And if you’re not familiar with the Tibetan phonetic, then you can look on page two. Page five. Verse six, Mandala offering.

We recite the first and the last verse. As Atisha said, child, this life is short. The objects of knowledge are infinite. Waste not your time with calculations and astrology, but like the swan, drink the very milk from the mixture of milk and water. Extract the essence of this life.

The meaning of this quote is that this life is short. There are many interferences to a human life, interferences which come from disease, from car accidents, from murder, from being beaten. These interferences are countless. At the time of Buddha Śākyamūni, the typical span or the measure for human life was one hundred years. Buddha taught more than two thousand years ago.

In those two thousand years, things have changed considerably. It is said that the lifespan of human beings will shrink in the future. We are trapped between the infinite lifespans of the higher realms and the infinite lifespans of the lower realms. And our human realm is one in which the time dedicated for this life is very short. Therefore, this time is short.

And as Atisha said, the objects of knowledge are infinite. Infinite are indeed the things which one can know, which one can try to understand, but time is of the essence. Therefore, even if one were to focus on dharma, the aspects of dharma and the aspects of the profound and vast dharma are almost innumerable. Therefore, like the swan of whom it is said that it can extract the milk from a mixture of milk and water, we should extract that which we are trying to actualize, our main goal.

And when Atisha says, should you even obtain all your wishes, he is not referring to worldly wishes or wishes from the worldly standpoint. If we reflect on worldly wishes, in this very life, none of us will be able to obtain what we want. But we have been striving like this for endless, limitless past lives and never once have had anything to show for it in the slightest inkling. And yet, in striving for our wishes, in striving to actualize our desires, we have committed a tremendous amount of nonvirtue. And from the worldly standpoint, we will neither be able to actualize our temporary, our contingent, or our ultimate happiness.

Therefore, we should put this aside. From the standpoint of dharma on the other hand, if we strive for the ultimate meaning, for our ultimate goal, then all of the contingent goals will be established and we will go from happiness to happiness as we progress upwards on the paths of the practitioners reaching the level of the arhats and the bodhisattvas and so forth. And then from the Dharma standpoint, there are three types of happiness, supreme happiness, middling happiness, and the lowest level of happiness. So these are the happinesses we should strive for. The supreme happiness, the best happiness is a state in which we have completely actualized our own benefit and also actualized completely the benefit to all others.

And this state of infinite happiness is called full enlightenment or buddhahood. If one is not able to attain or to strive for this goal, then one strives for the middling goal, the middling level of happiness. This is a happiness which is free of any suffering whatsoever because it is a happiness which has freed itself from cyclic existence, the sufferings of which are evident to us when we observe the endless cycle of lives. And when we attain this happiness, we have attained pure happiness, only happiness unmixed with any suffering. And as for the lowest level of happiness and the lowest motivation, we should reflect that there is not a single person in this room at present who will not die.

For that matter, in this world, there has never been a being which has not died. The number of beings who have died in the past is well nigh infinite. And at present, many are dying and many more will die. Not one being in this world will not die. And it is not the case that after death, there is nothing.

After death, consciousness continues its flow. The same way as a river continues its flow. The direction the river goes depends on the orientation given to it. Likewise, the direction consciousness goes depends on two things, karma and afflictions. If negative karma and afflictions are accumulated, then consciousness will move downwards to the lower realms.

We cannot see at present the realm of the pretas, the hungry ghosts, or the hell realms, but we can most definitely see the animal realms. Being reborn as an animal is a result of nonvirtuous karma, and their sufferings are horrible indeed. Think of the fact that the steak you eat, the meat you eat, is the meat of one who is reborn in the lower realms through nonvirtuous karma. And to be reborn as an animal is a result of the smallest nonvirtuous karma. If the nonvirtuous karma is greater than that, middling nonvirtuous karma, one is reborn as a preta.

And if it’s even greater than that, one is reborn as a hell being whose sufferings are inconceivable. Now with respect to virtuous karma, the human rebirth we have at present is a result of the smallest level of virtuous karma. Since above this, there is a rebirth of the demigods who have accumulated more virtuous karma and above them, the rebirth of the gods who have accumulated even more virtuous karma. However, these are only the rebirths which are activated by contaminated karma within the cycle of lives. The karma which is noncontaminated leads actually to rebirth or leads actually upwards on the path to Buddhahood all the way up to full enlightenment.

And if you want the latter, a higher rebirth, especially the type of human rebirth we have now, then one must practice an abandonment of the ten nonvirtues, the three of body, the four of speech, and the three of mind. In other words, we must practice ethics. And in addition to ethics, one must practice generosity or giving. It is not the case that we are unable to practice giving. One can practice even giving a little bit of food to ants.

They are other beings. Therefore, giving food to ants is the practice of giving. And in addition to this, one must practice the practice of patience. Through the practice of generosity, the seeds for a human rebirth are sown. With the practice of giving or charity, we will not have material difficulties and will have some prosperity, enough to eat.

And through the practice of patience, we will have a beautiful complexion, attract many friends, and actually meet with a spiritual teacher.

So it is up to us to think about this, to analyze. If we analyze and if we value ourselves and have some self love, then we will understand that it is for our own happiness that we have to create now the causes so that in the future we be happy. If we do not create the causes, the effect will not arise. There is no such thing as a causeless effect. On the other hand, if we do create the causes, the effect will definitely arise in the future.

So it is up to ourselves and to ourselves alone to either create these causes or not to create them. In the same way as when a mother prepares a meal and puts it out for the child, it’s out of her control whether the child eats the meal or not. It’s the child’s decision. If the child eats the meal, he will be happy. He will not be hungry.

If he doesn’t eat the meal, he will be hungry. It is his responsibility. So please listen carefully. And if you want to gain some benefit from this, it is up to you to do it. And therefore, in the syllogism, the subject is a sprout.

It follows that it is not truly established because of being a dependent arising. The reason dependent arising is the royal reason which is given to establish the non true establishment or the non inherent establishment of the sprout. And when you have in Tibetan the use of the dative case here, it means that the sprout is not established as true or is not established as truly established. This is as in English. Generally speaking, the non Buddhists in ancient India, which refers mainly to the Sankhya school, but also to other sub schools such as the Lokayatas and so forth, did not accept the were non-Buddhist because they did not accept the triple gem.

This was the main criteria for their being non-Buddhist and did not accept the reason of dependent arising within the context of the syllogism which was given. For instance, in the case of the Sankhyas, they did not accept dependent arising but considered that all phenomena arose from a fundamental phenomena. This fundamental phenomena which might be Prakriti is actually said to be permanent and is nonetheless the cause of all phenomena. How could a permanent phenomenon act as cause and produce effects? This is obviously at odds with reason.

Then, after the outsiders, many of the former Tibetans also did not accept dependent arising. The term former Tibetans here does not refer to the non Geluk schools like Nyingma, Kagyu, and Sakya, which all at the beginning were peerless in their understanding and defense of the authentic view. It refers to a majority of the former Tibetan practitioners who did not accept dependent arising and were influenced, for instance, by the wrong views of the Chinese monk, Huashang Mahāyāna. These were people who actually subscribed to an extreme of nihilism. Even within the Buddhist tradition, the three lower schools of tenets, which are the Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, and Cittamātra schools, do not consider that it is possible for phenomena which are not inherently established to be dependent arisings.

They consider that everything which is inherently established is necessarily a dependent arising. Everything which is not inherently established cannot be a dependent arising. The first of the two subschools of Madhyamaka, the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school, even though it does accept the existence of dependent arising, considers that all phenomena which are dependent arisings are necessarily established by their own characteristics. And therefore, like the three lower schools we mentioned, has succumbed to an extreme of permanence. They consider that if phenomena are established by their own characteristics, they are necessarily dependent arisings.

Now from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika, there is no such thing as a phenomenon which exists by its own characteristics. Therefore, this school too has succumbed to an extreme of permanence. And within the Buddhist schools, the non-Prāsaṇgika schools, in other words, all the schools beneath Prāsaṇgika, consider that something which lacks nature eo ipso necessarily becomes nonexistent and are not able to posit a difference between lacking nature and being nonexistent. The Prāsaṇgika school, on the other hand, asserts clearly that if something is lacking nature, it does not necessarily follow that it is nonexistent. Likewise, the non-Prāsaṇgika schools, the lower schools, assert that if phenomena exist nominally or by designation, they are necessarily established inherently.

This is not accepted by the Prāsaṇgika, which says for that matter that if phenomena exist nominally or by designation, they are necessarily not established by their own nature. So fundamentally, the lower Buddhist schools beneath Prāsaṇgika consider that the nonexistence of one’s own characteristics, that phenomena being defined by their own characteristics entails their nonexistence and that if phenomena exist, they necessarily truly exist.

Both the Svatāntrika and the Prāsaṇgika accept the reason. The subject, the sprout, lacks true existence because it is a dependent arising. They consider that both the view of eternalism and the view of nihilism are eliminated by this reason and thereby abide in the middle way between the two extremes of these two views. Whereas the other lower schools through their reasonings are either able to dispel the view of nihilism, the extreme of nihilism, or to dispel the extreme of eternalism. So in this syllogism, the subject, the sprout, it follows that it is empty of true existence because it is a dependent arising. The predicate, it is empty, actually acts as an antidote or eliminates the view of permanence because the view of permanence in this context refers to true establishment.

And emptiness is the direct, the contradictory phenomenon to the true establishment of phenomena. Likewise, the reason, because it is a dependent arising, eliminates the view of nihilism. This is the case because when we say it is a dependent arising, we are asserting that in dependence on causes, effects arise. And this is a clear assertion of the conventional designated existence of phenomena. Phenomena in this context are not nonexistent.

They become necessarily existent if they are dependent arisings. The great Amdo Lama, Chone Lama, says that actually within this syllogism, the subject, the sprout, it follows that it lacks true existence because it is a dependent arising or because it is interdependent. Both the predicate and the reason negate individually both extremes. The predicate, it lacks true existence, negates both the extreme of eternalism and the extreme of nihilism. It negates the extreme of eternalism because the lack of true existence negates clearly the true existence of phenomena.

It also negates the extreme of nihilism because when we assert that phenomena lack true existence, implicitly or indirectly, we are asserting that they are not nonexistent. Otherwise, we would not be qualifying the statement of nonexistence. And therefore, even though they lack true existence, it cannot be said that they are nonexistent. With respect to the reason, the reason of dependent arising, it also negates the two extremes of nihilism and eternalism. The way it negates the extreme of nihilism is self evident.

If phenomena are dependent arisings, they cannot be nonexistent. And the way it negates the extreme of eternalism is that if phenomena are dependent arisings, then they are said to arise or to rest upon causes. And this implies indirectly or implicitly, or this negates indirectly or implicitly that they are non dependent on others and affirms clearly that they are dependent on causes. So this also negates clearly the extreme of eternalism. It’s very unfortunate in English that the term shunyata is translated as emptiness.

This leads many people to the idea that shunyata is nonexistence. This is not the case at all. Śūnyatā or emptiness is an existent phenomenon. It is not a nonexistent phenomenon. So as the glorious Candrakīrti says, the reasoning of dependent arising is a supreme antidote to all wrong views and eliminates both the extreme of nihilism and the extreme of eternalism.

As the glorious Nāgārjuna says, that of which emptiness is suitable, everything is suitable. And for that for which emptiness is not suitable, nothing is suitable. The meaning of this quote, which Rinpoche has mentioned many times, is that for that for which emptiness is suitable, everything is suitable refers to the fact that in dependence on emptiness, in dependent arising, one can say that virtuous and nonvirtuous karma and all of the aspects of the path leading to full Buddhahood are possible. Whereas the meaning of the second verse, for that for which emptiness is not suitable, nothing is suitable, refers to the fact that should phenomena be considered to be truly established, then neither virtuous karma, nor nonvirtuous karma, past nor future lives would be possible nor would full enlightenment be possible for that matter. So one can say that one can see phenomena in two lights.

One can see phenomena in the light of selflessness or in the light of self or in the light of non-trueness or in the light of true existence. In the light of non-true, non-inherent establishment, everything is possible. In the light of true existence, inherent existence, nothing is possible. And this can be understood to be the meaning of the famous quote in the Heart Sūtra, form is emptiness and emptiness is form. This quote has to be analyzed at two levels.

The first part of the quote, form is emptiness, should be analyzed in terms of the two levels of dependent origination or interdependence, the coarse and the subtle. From the standpoint of the coarse level of interdependence, when we say that form is emptiness, we’re referring to the fact that in the light of the definition of form that which is suitable to be formed, form can be understood to arise in dependence on the four elements and the various elementals or the derivatives of the elements and arises therefore in dependence on this. On the other hand, from the standpoint of subtle interdependence, form is a phenomenon which exists as a mere nominal and conceptual imputation. And this is the meaning of the quote, form is emptiness from the standpoint of subtle interdependence. So the very fact that form is emptiness entails the existence of form and the very fact that form arises in dependence on a name, that name form which by its very description gives rise to form, that fact alone is sufficient to establish form.

To put things in terms which are easier to understand, we might paraphrase this quote and say, I am emptiness and emptiness is I. And this quote could then be understood once again in light of the two levels of dependent arising. In terms of coarse interdependence, the I which arises in dependence on the basis of imputation of the five aggregates is asserted. And at the level of the subtle interdependent origination, that I which is a mere nominal imputation and a mere conceptual imputation is asserted. So what is clearly said here is that that I which is a nominal imputation exists. That I, which is not a nominal imputation, does not exist.

And, therefore, this very I can be said to arise through the power of the process of imputation.

And therefore, the emptiness of nature, the emptiness of establishment by nature, in other words, of inherent establishment, and the emptiness of establishment from one’s own side, all enable karma, virtue, nonvirtue, and so forth to proceed. And in dependence on understanding of this emptiness, the wrong views, which are the wrong views of eternalism and nihilism, will not arise. So because this view is a view which is between the two extremes, it is said to be the view of the middle way or Madhyamaka.

So the view which we must try to understand, therefore, is a middle way view, the view between the two extremes of eternalism and nihilism. And if we can gain understanding of this view and meditate on it, we can eliminate all suffering. The reason for this is that the cause of suffering is ignorance. And if we cut ignorance at the root and we have eliminated the cause of suffering, then the result suffering cannot arise. Now in addition to this understanding of emptiness, it’s also necessary to understand the method aspect of the path and this refers to bodhicitta.

Generally speaking, even in worldly matters, both method and wisdom are required for any activity. But as far as Dharma is concerned, the supreme practice of method is bodhicitta and the supreme practice of wisdom is that wisdom realizing emptiness. In dependence on these, everything can be accomplished and one can attain full enlightenment and perform both one’s own welfare and that of others. So, today is a very special day. It’s the birthday of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. And as the teachings are over, to celebrate this, we’re going to have a celebration and try to have a lot of fun.

I would like to say happy birthday in Tibetan. I would like to apologize for the lighting here tonight. But anyway, there will be chai. Cake will be served and then chai will be served. And after that, then we’ll dedicate. So we have only one stanza left.

A small announcement, please. We have only one stanza left in the three principles of the path. Rinpoche will finish that next Wednesday. And if you have any questions, that’ll be the point to bring them with you and ask them to Rinpoche. I will be leaving the next day. Thank you very much.

Page nine. Verse 13, dedication. I have a couple things to announce. Usually, every fifth week will be a discussion, which is the slot for next Wednesday. So Rinpoche is going to finish three principal aspects of the path and there’s only one verse left. So Rinpoche is going to give that next week instead of discussion. So if you have questions, you can afterward after the teaching, you can pass your questions forward, please. And the Thursday night teaching will continue until, it will continue. But after next week, Wednesday onwards, there’s no teachings on Wednesday and Sunday morning.

And so if you like to if you’re not on the email list, if you like to be on the email list in our center, please make sure ask Carol in our office or ring up in our office or send the email to us to put in the email. That’d be great. Thank you very much. Page nine on dedication, verse eight. Verse nine, long life prayer to His Holiness. Can you please make sure your cups are safe?

I have another announcement. The Tibetan community asked me to have a public announcement in Tibetan communities in South Australia. They’re going to hold the Dalai Lama’s birthday night.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top