45 min · 2,567 words · 22 July 1991
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Not a teaching. Participants discuss the study curriculum for monastic classes six to twelve, checking which texts are studied in each class and in what order. They also go over the spelling and English titles of the Tibetan and Sanskrit works on the handouts and settle some dates for a chronology. No doctrine is taught.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 45 min
UUID: cae477bd-c256-4d4b-a4bf-8d156e320fff
Date: 1991-07-22
Words: 2,563
Which is mentioned? Mhmm. Very everything up. You want that light on? A little light?
Yeah. Class six, we stick to the old list for now until I change the numbers. We went through and we got all the I don’t know if we got them all, but we got most of the texts study in the classes up to Sakya Sarpa. So the next couple of pages there, you’ll probably find it on page three. Class six.
Kundu. Does that make any sense to you? Pramānasamuccaya by Dignāgā. Is that the text? Yes.
I think so. Pramānavārttika. Yeah. Pramānavārttika by Dharmakīrti. Dharmakīrti.
Dharmakīrti’s text. Dharmakīrti. He’s taught throughout all classes from class six onwards. True. Yeah.
What about Kundu, this this text, Pramānavārttika, is a commentary to this text. Kundu by Dignāgā. Dignāgā. Namjol is a commentary. The the root text is Kundu.
The person the Kundu. The. Do you know what, Opam, what the English term for kundu is? Think so. Companion.
Companion on On valid cognition. Yeah. Oh. This is a commentary to Oh. This is Dharmakriti’s commentary to this.
Oh. So Commentary. And I run it like this is com this is compendium of valid cognition. Oh. And this is commentary to Oh.
Compendium of prime cognition. Oh, okay. Compendium? Compendium on valid cognition. Oh.
About cognition? I’ve covered. I’m just looking here. I think I’ve got enough on Sakya Sarpa. So if we go to what I’ve got as class seven down here, that’s Sakya Ngimpa.
This class includes topics mentioned under for class six, definition interpretive, is content concentrations in form, meditative concentrations in absorption. 20 spiritual communities and mind basis of all. And then I’ve got check this is so here. I don’t know. I’m not class six.
Have I got those in the right class? Should are they right for Sakya Ngimba? Are there any others that should be in there? I So I don’t you don’t need this. I’ll cross it through again.
But that’s right. It is this this this isn’t the correct name. Which one? And interpretive sūtra. So it got a a bit of a or what?
I don’t know. I guess it’s correctness. Essence of oh, I mean, I mean, excellent essence. Essence. I’m not sure which book it’s in.
That was essence of eloquent exposition on definitive interpretive sutras. Oh, cool. Okay. Mhmm. Okay.
So that’s right. So that’s okay. So I’ve checked have you oh, you’ve got you’ve got a same copy, haven’t you, underneath here? Is the This page. Four.
Can you do page four? No. Oh, my. So this yeah. You have to include this.
But that’s this is this is different than that. Well, this is a more up to date. I’ll write that. Okay. That’s it.
There’s no stretch from. I don’t know I page, and there’s a different So to go through. So what do I have to include? The stem dependent arising. Tendrob.
So include from class six Dependent arising. Yeah. This is class seven. Yeah. But they study in class six in -depth one, and then they do it all in general in class seven.
So do I have to include those holes? It depends on what what they study is dependent upon the the divination. Yeah. That’s right. But that’s in class six.
It’s dependent on that, isn’t it? And then in class seven, don’t they study all things in general? That’s what I understood. So he’s just saying that these texts that were just listed would would these texts. But Sukho Saba would just study the one that the mo suggested in-depth.
Is that right? Could you? The Sakya Sarpa, the. So the the divination was just to see which which text they should study first. Oh, first.
Yeah. I thought Rinpoche said they would study that text for the whole of Sukho Saba. Yeah. The So they would look at many commentaries on that text, many different commentaries on that text, but they would study that that mainly that text for the first year. For that year.
Yeah. Great. Alright. That’s fine. So we’re really up to Pänchen.
And Pänchen’s where I start to get really confused because I clarified it in my own mind. Rinpoche know whether that was destroyed by the Chinese, communist Chinese, in ’61 or ’71? Somewhere between ’61 and ’63. ’61 and ’63. Between between somewhere between ’61 and ’63.
Did anything happen again in the seventies or No. She said no. It was already destroyed. That’s alright. I had two dates when I was doing my chronology, and I couldn’t work on that.
So it’s a ‘6 early sixties. So shall we get on to this? Yeah. Things that did, but I’m a little bit confused as to where they fit in. Part one is a.
So is that where it begins with all this stuff here? Is that the the mains? Yeah. Yeah. So you just want the main text that was studied in Pelden?
Probably. So the main text, the root text, is Ornament for Clear Realization. Abhisamayālamkāra. But that goes and goes for ages and ages, doesn’t it? I always get you wrapped this book.
I think she’s got that. But that goes for mean, that takes the study right from class. That’s the main text, which is study for. Right. Well, I I think I need a little more than that is to get all the chapters a bit straighter.
Yeah. The round I mean, that’s that’s the way the that’s where these chapters are coming from, from that book. Right. Good. Thanks.
Yeah. Right. Okay. The book is set up in eight chapters. In how many?
Chapters. Yeah. Yeah. And then in that handout from we studied Abhisamayālamkāra, it goes it lists those eight chapters. Are you talking about the one we did last year with Yeah.
This photocopied Alright. Okay. Alright. Okay. I’ve forgotten where that comes in.
So if I if I refer to that Yeah. Is that adequate? That has all the information. But but but but but so is is is does the go down to chapter eight? Does everything in the, which is two years, you check with Rinpoche cover down to chapter eight, the truth body in that those two years?
Because that’s an awful lot of chapters. To cover from chapter two to chapter eight. To person person learning. The second chapter to the eighth chapter in two years. K.
So then we’ve got class well, would I’ll just stick to the old numbers till I change them. Class nine So you you want the text? Yeah. That okay. Now this is So the main text is The main text is Ornament for Clear Realization.
I’ll get the breakdown of that from From that the handout. Copies. And then there’s other text that they commentaries that they make use of. Alright. Yeah.
So this is good. Yeah, Donsal? Yeah. Clear Meaning? Commentary called Clear Meaning?
Commentary called Clear Meaning? Clear Meaning? Badra. Yeah. H a r i Yeah.
B a d r a. So you have to check the spelling. Okay. Haribhādra. So that’s important commentary.
Mhmm. And then the the general meaning and what does it say? Exposition of the general. What is meetings. This is Tsongkhapa’s writing. Analysis.
Analysis. For all analysis of Final analysis. Mhmm. Part I know what it says. It looks like he’s crossed out of analysis, but it doesn’t look quite I can’t read the problem.
So sometimes no. It doesn’t look like it. Okay. Okay. Now is class nine, this is that the same as middle way philosophy?
Why is it called advanced Mādhyamika? Does that mean they just do a little bit of it in the early classes or something? Well, you have advanced you have advanced you have advanced there. I know. Is that just a mistake, do you think?
So just be beginning. Mhmm. That’s alright. So the the the 10 chapters of? 10 chapters.
Where would I get, like, a list of those? Do know? Or would I need the list? They don’t have any particular name. They don’t.
No. So just leave that. They’re called mind generations. First, second, third, mind generation. So first to seventh mind generation.
First through 10 mind Simplicity. Mind generation. Oh yeah, they do have names. Anyway, it’s easy. I can give you that.
They just take up to 10 perfections, each one. Okay. Then, Jella? Don’t know. The title, is it?
Yeah. Think. So these all So So this is this is Sorry. Which This is the same text up here. Oh, the one the same one for.
Is it? Is. So, yeah, so this in this here here the hearer it’s here they study the mind only school section. I see. Mind only.
Mind only. Only section. Yeah. School. Yeah.
Here they here they study the same text, but they study the middle way section. Mahasse. Middle way. Middle middle way school. Middle Middleway School.
Section. Section. And that’s this is the title of the text Golden Garland of Eloquence. No. This one.
This Exposition? Golden Garland of Eloquence. No. That’s no. This is not just this is text.
13. No, this is No, that’s here just bring this up. This one up. Yeah. Alright.
So you? Parching the cups at the no. It wasn’t. It wasn’t. It’s up up here.
It mean anything to me and gets very confused. It was in the For what? The the class. That was a circus. This is where circus happened.
Sarpa, where’s Ngimba? Essence of Eloquent Exposition on Definitive and Interpretive Sutras. Is that is that from Tsongkhapa? Yeah. Is it?
Yeah. Ah. And this is the same text here. I see. Yeah.
And they’ve studied the first half there, and they studied the second half here. Ah, right. So that one just instead of putting it there, we’ll just put it up here again. Is that right? Well Circle.
Yeah. Two. Circle. And then So that’s the middle middle one. Mind only section.
Mind only section. Mind Mind only school. School. Mhmm. Okay.
Now is are these all by by or Yeah. Are they different books or different chapters? Different Tung. Tung. Tung. Tung.
Opening the Eye of the Fortunate. One to two. What? Opening the Eye of the Fortunate. Now should we get the Tibetan names of these books of song covers as well?
Suppose I should really. It shouldn’t shouldn’t Okay. Yes. Many of these books are listed in the main by in the like in like in the Yeah. Meditation on emptiness.
The book meditation on emptiness in the in the bibliography. Okay. They The same script that you’ll find out of. This is Hopkins one. Is it?
Yeah. And the and and that’s touch it. It. Okay. Make it.
And then And then this too. General meaning of the middle way and final analysis. Are they two different books? Yes. Two different books.
Two different books. Get to it. That’s enough? Yeah. Okay.
We go on to this. I probably just need to clarify. That would be class So we’ve done Uma Ngimpa as well as Uma Sarpa, have we? So we’ve done what’s the old nine and ten? And so this is Dulwa Vinaya.
Uma Sarpa? Dulwa Sarpa? Mhmm. Or or do what we put to both together. Yeah.
Both together with a face. Yeah. I got a do a do a do a a do do Just going back to. Did we do Vasubandhu? Do we have Vasubandhu in here?
Because I don’t think he he wouldn’t have written a tika. Well, so this is wrong. I just crossed him. No. Yeah.
No. He wouldn’t have been writing a tika. He wouldn’t So we’re looking at what we got here would cover class All of it. Nine and ten, wouldn’t it? Mhmm.
So this this is right. This first one? Class eleven and twelve. No. No.
It can’t be eleven and twelve. There’s no there’s no gonna be 13 classes. No. But I haven’t altered my numbers. If I start to alter my numbers how how we want.
How The the guy is a. So this is What is it? Dulwa. D u l w a.
Okay. What is in Sanskrit? Tibetan. Tibetan. How do you spell that?
Just spell s. S. S. S. S.
S. S. I have to check it. Yeah. Yeah.
I mean So you can look in biographies. Yeah. Yeah. And and then it’ll it’ll probably it’ll have it’ll probably have that. I’ll get on to them.
So you can. Quite follow. Is that correct the way it is there? Annotations on Vinaya. Annotations on Vinaya.
I’ll just do an arrow. Annotations. Past. Do it. That’s correct.
You can That’s correct. Yeah. Can you just tick it or something? I think it’s. Okay.
Precious Garland of Moral Discipline. Pänchen Delek Nyima? Where are you up to, Jasquhar? Oh. So the Pension it I’m getting into the Precious Garland.
That’s okay. Anyway, that’s okay. That’s right. Alright. So this is this is more in the advanced classes at Ngimba?
No, this is Dulo. Oh, we’re back under zoo now. Okay. Does Rinpoche call it? Madhya?
Which one is? That must be where I got it confused before with the. Yeah. C h a. C h h a.
Mhmm. This is one word. Jump. Is it spelled right? Can I just check the root root text is Vasubandhu or something?
Let let me explain this before I forget. No. It’s just another name for this text. Oh. You want you wanna write somewhere?
Yeah. Yeah. This is the commentary on the Ornament for Clear Realization. Commentary? The commentary on the commentary on the Ornament for Clear Realization.
And This is the same text here. This one here. It’s both Changkya Jampal. Changkya Jampal. Okay.
The path down. The path to no. That’s different. Okay. Is this is that the root and the others the commentaries or what?
These are all commentaries. The so the root text is the Treasury of Knowledge and these are all commentaries to that. The commentary to the treasury. That’s right. Chökyi Gyaltsen.
The the the the Yeah. Just just checking up up here with the the Vinaya one. The root text was which one was the Vinaya root text? Oh, Oh, I I see. Root Sūtra.
And then all the others are commentaries again, isn’t it? Yeah. Just I just had So, yeah. Root Sūtra. Okay.
So then you have Yep. That would have been root sūtra Abhidharma, not Vinaya, No. No. No. Sorry.
Oh, What what’s this? What’s what’s it in English? Middle Middle way. Way. Middle Middle way.
Way. Middle Middle way. Way. Is this is this is. Oh, that’s the two door.
Okay. So now we’re on to the door. So there’s two main root texts. One is Dharmakīrti’s as it says here, commentary to Dignāgā’s Compendium of Valid Cognition. Mhmm.
And then the other one is one is Nāgārjuna. Alright. There’s a they list those as a two root texts. I see. Then Can I just go back to this?
I’m sure that’s not correct that Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen was a disciple of was it the fifth? I don’t know. It wouldn’t be the fifth.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.