45 min · 2,877 words · 21 June 1991
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A question-and-answer conversation about monastic life at Sera Je and the three seats of learning, covering how students were assigned to teachers, the roles of the khangtsen gegen and geko in discipline, the khacha gegen (sponsoring guarantor) system, and the meaning of the term lama. Transcript is partly garbled and it is unclear whether the speaker is a teacher or an interviewer.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 45 min
UUID: ab2f65a6-8d42-4aa1-a4a6-e66995e71575
Date: 1991-06-21
Words: 2,873
So they even went to different monasteries amongst amongst the three seats of learning. For example, in Buxa Duar, they went they might go, J student might go to a teacher at Loseling, and Loseling might go to a teacher from Ganden, Shartse, things of this nature. And that was the student’s choice, was students came. He had students from Ganden, Loseling, Oh. And did they request him to give him teaching So according to their liking for a particular teacher their faith, they would they would make they would request that teacher?
So if we get back I’m always trying to do shuffles in my mind to understand. If we get back to the sort of structure of the 14 class 13 or 14 classes we’ve got with the three dudras and the Shungsapa and the Pänchen and all that sort of thing. If we take the students in, say, the the first dudra class or in the class, would they all go to the same they wouldn’t all go to the same teachers, would they? So Would all the students in dudra classes? Well, in in one year.
In one dudra class, would all the students go to one teacher? Yes. They have many different teachers. Then there’s 13 district houses and each of them had monks who were in the dudra class for example. And each of them might have a different teacher teaching the dudra to to their particular content students.
So one class would have many different teachers. So was it in the debate sessions the only time when that whole dudra class for the whole would ever come together? Would it be just a debate time? Just that debate was the only time they would come together, the entire class. Oh, then there would Sera Mey, Sera Je, and Sera Mey together?
Or That debate? Yes. So they they they have different they have their own separate debate sessions. Right. So they would be separate, but they would be having them at the same time.
So they would have different debate sessions at the same time. Mhmm. Each of these each of the schools each of the colleges has their own separate texts written by different teachers that they make use of. Yeah. So it was just that the time was the same, but the actual programs were different.
They have debate sessions at the same time. I mean, not but it’s not the same place. College has got a huge debate area, and each council must also have its own debate area. Is that right? Smaller.
Each have their individual debate areas. Each college. So the college, what would have to be huge, wouldn’t they? Do I have to hold all of mine? I’m just Big.
Then the Khangtsen would be a bit smaller. The Kamsans. Kamsans, It’s just that it’s so difficult to try and comprehend. So the Khangtsen Gegen was like the moral disciplinarian for the Khangtsen, and the Geko is like the moral disciplinarian for the entire college. Is that right?
Mhmm. Okay. If you’re caught not going to your teacher, would it be the or the for the college that would discipline you? Or would it could it be either? I think that’s going to get you.
So, that would be the district house. That would be the concern of the district house disciplinary. Right. And now I’ve got here when he he when he gives him what a stupid question. He had a big stick, and I’ve got also wooden.
Sometimes I just wonder about myself. Alright. The first three classes might assemble with one teacher who would recite all the various definitions which they are expected to learn. Mhmm. I wonder whether this is in the morning or what.
Well, this must be the evening, I think. I think this must be the evening session. Don’t know she’s talking about the evening that the three dudras would go and have a group group group teaching, you know? I’ve got the Geko was that this is for the whole college, was it? That been for all the Dutra classes in the college, not the council?
Because I’ve got the Geko would look around. He usually uses the term Geko for referring to the college, and Geko comes and Geko referring to the to the council. Then it’s got was this responsibility of each individual teacher to look around and see if his students were attending. So said it’s for the whole college, didn’t he, all the dudra classes? No.
So I kinda wanna clear up the individual teachers, the Khangtsen Gegen and the Geko in in the role at that time with the four or the three dudra classes, and whose whose responsibilities and and who gets the blame if the students aren’t there and they haven’t memorized? So this this this was this didn’t necessarily take place. He’s talking only with respect to Trehor Khangtsen’s district house. It didn’t necessarily take this wasn’t necessarily followed by all the different district houses. Trehor Khangtsen comes in.
Oh, So Trehor Khangtsen comes in. They had regular evening teaching Right. For the three classes. Right. Right.
So that that wouldn’t be the same for the rest of the that wasn’t a part of college role then. Was only the khangtsen that did that. Not all of the college. Not the entire college. Not the entire college.
Okay. Okay. So that then it was it would be the Khangtsen Gegen that would be responsible. But then there was something about individual teachers. If their students weren’t learning well, then they would be they would be embarrassed, and so they would have to do some disciplining too.
Or maybe leave this for nothing. I’ll get it. I’ll try and get the question then coming up on the next page, page 13. When a teacher found out that his students were answering poorly or didn’t know what they should have known, he would tell them to get out and not come back because they were a disgrace to his teaching. So So he wouldn’t throw them out of class.
He would just He just straighten them. They would just, you know, tell them that they had to study, that they had to look at at their texts. Yeah. But if it says here that the teacher wouldn’t pass them if they didn’t do well, and the older older students would tell them to leave, saying that unless they answered well, there was no reason for them to be there. I think maybe the old students just act as sort of pressure to get them to study.
But then if they don’t actually pass their exams, then they might go. Is that so the teacher wouldn’t pass them if they didn’t. At Sera Je they didn’t have this policy whereby if you weren’t succeeding then you would be held back and you wouldn’t advance with your class. That’s Sera Je that you went ahead with your class, you stayed with your class, proceeding along with them. Some of the other other monasteries had a policy where you would be held back.
Right. Well, that’s good. I’m really glad I cleared that up because but did the senior students often try and embarrass the the younger ones if they weren’t studying? So the so the the older students would criticize the the younger students and tell them to to they should study better. They’ve come a long way, and they shouldn’t waste their time.
Page 17 now. I guess we’re just getting back to actually the arrangement of the the. Was there only one courtyard? I often say courtyard or front yard. Is there is there only one place of assembly in the in Lhasa, or was there more than one courtyard where they’d have debates and Khangtsen.
Yes. So, the district council just had one inside gathering place of gathering and one outside place of gathering. They didn’t have many outside. That’s fine. I just wanted to work that out because I seem to use different words, and I confuse myself.
Fine. I don’t know if it’s today or in the past. Maybe it’s presently. They have a big they have a big statue of Maitreya at Sera Je. This may be the statue.
But he’s not sure. Yeah. Yeah. Right. Jampa, can you give me a good definition of what I’m of the term lama?
Can define you it, or should I have to ask permission? The Tibetan Lama. Translation of the that’s Sanskrit word guru. Guru. Lama.
It’s just that it gets used in so many ways, and it seems seems to be used when there’s so someone in one of the advanced classes could also be called a lama, presumably, would he? Or would he have to been through passed Madhyamaka? Have to have great, excellent qualities to be called the lama. Is would you say that that that means you have to be through all those courses, does it? Mhmm.
A very That’s not I mean it’s not a No. It’s not a It’s not an officially bestowed title. No. It’s that’s one’s own wishes of one student. Alright.
Alright. So it’s other people that might start to call you that. That’s right. When you wouldn’t Which, I mean, I I hate to be be so blunt, but it’s sort of like a rag bag term. If you’re not a Geshe and you’re not a Rinpoche or a tulku, then then it’s quite nice.
You might be, you know, referred to as a lama. So I mean, I’m trying to get an explanation for Westerners. No. It’s only too much referred to one you refer to somebody as one’s teacher, your spiritual teacher as a lama. But often we say this is where all the Geshe’s and the lamas and the students see.
Then there’s three ways that you can they sometimes they refer to it. Now I mean, they can refer to one individual spiritual teacher, but also to reincarnated masters. Oh, right. Like Tulkus. Like Tulkus.
Yes. So those is those would be referred to as lamas. Yes. But not an ordinary monk. So, I mean, one can refer to one’s teacher as a Lama?
As your Lama? Sorry? As one’s own Lama? Yes. So that’s one’s individual choice.
But generally, to be renowned as a Lama, to be well known as a Lama, then you have to have some kinds of excellent, of well known, excellent qualities. To have a general reputation amongst But the you could refer to, even if he was an ordinary person, if it was your teacher, you could refer to him as your Lama. Right. It’s just that in the West and in India, every Tibetan’s called Lama, like Indians just call Lama ji, almost every Tibetan that walks past. The Nepalis Yeah.
It’s just that people in the West just call everyone lama or in India that you know, just ordinary Tibetans, they call them lama ji, whether they’re male or female. That’s quite funny. You just said funny. So if I work out some sort of definition based on what you’ve just said, that should clear that up. Mhmm.
I’m Okay. Just 20. I don’t go through it. It’s a long way. Was boy, was.
Is that the term for the material needs teacher? Day drill? Day drill? Is that right? Day No.
Oh, god. Did you say? Yeah. And it’s called khacha gegen. Kacha.
Khacha gegen. How would you spell that? Kacha. K y. I think we K a.
Y. K a? Yeah. C h I don’t know what this is. C Kacha means someone who stands surety.
Walking on money. Yeah. If you want to borrow some money, then someone stands surety. So this in order to become a monk, have to have somebody that will stand surety for you. That you will he takes responsibility for your physical necessities, that you’ll follow the rules and everything.
So he’s your He’s the guarantors. So this is this person who stands surety for you? Is it You have to know him in advance. Yeah. Usually, it’s someone well known who is well known to you, who knows you well.
If you’re not allowed to stay in the monastery if you don’t have the khacha gegen. So would that be sort of the role that Rinpoche had with his nephews when they came? So, you have to have at least gotten to the the Yeah. Before you can become a, before you can stand surety. To the That’s a long way along.
Oh. So you have to you can be a guarantor? Yeah. You have to have at least 15 when when Rinpoche’s nephews came, he hadn’t gotten to the Vinaya class as of yet, he was in Uma class, and so his teacher, because of their relationship, was his nephew’s Oh, I see. He he wasn’t able to.
Alright. And the the opposite question to that was, at what stage did the monk assume his own responsibility? Or did he, you know, did he have a khacha gegen sort of looking after him until the naya class all the way through? So even even an older monk has to have a. Really?
Right up to where? Right up to Geshe? As long as one stayed in the monastery. Oh, really? So it never ended.
If you didn’t have a khacha gegen, then you couldn’t stay in the monastery. Oh, even There’s no student without a teacher. A khacha gegen. Yes. Well, so what’s this deja drill term that I have?
Is that nothing? Each monk had only one Daedrel. Daedrel? Daedrel? Just cross it.
Who was his material needs? Sorry. Not doesn’t seem to ring ring a bell. You use the term pecha gegen. Pecha.
Petty. That’s the scriptural teacher. Ah, right. Right. Like pecha.
Pecha is the same word. It comes from the same word. T means to teach. The teaching of the scripture. Oh, good.
No. Got here no matter how much money a student brought into the monastery, it was distributed equally. The food and the clothing would be shared out equally amongst the khacha gegens, all of the khacha gegen students. Like if one bought 5 rupees and another bought 5,000, it will make no difference. Can you clarify that a bit?
So, if the teacher had, say five students, for example, if the teacher had five students and three of them had lots of money and two of them didn’t have any money, then when the would buy, he would supply them with tsampa, with food, with clothing, and they would be given equal out of all their money, they would be given equal clothing, equal food, that they would all get the same. Mhmm. Wow. But Rinpoche said at one other time, when he came to the monastery, he he didn’t have to do a lot of the chores of the young monk because he had money to pay for someone else to do them. That was why the Nyapa didn’t like him.
So, he was able to to if he could if you could give money, and you weren’t you could be excused from doing work. So, that was his case. So one didn’t have to give all one’s money to this khacha gegen? He would give the money to him, but it wasn’t it didn’t become his money. He was holding it for you.
He offered. So that if you had a project, you could you could go say, and I need some money for this particular reason. Right. And he would give it he would give you back to you. Right.
So is that what happened? So he went through his khacha gegen and said I’d like to be excused from doing this work, and he talked about it with his khacha gegen and they agreed. So they took part of the money and paid for a substitute person. Well that’s really interesting. So then when that’s beautiful.
It’s so lovely, that photo. It’s really beautiful. So in the in the case in the reverse case, where Rinpoche was really starving those years when he had nothing, was that the was it the that just kept him alive by giving him a little bit of and so So if we ask him to, he would buy him a tsampa, for example. The ketchup. Okay.
Mhmm. Uh-huh. Belong to Pauline, and she’s transcribing some some started transcribing a couple of tapes of Rinpoche’s. Mhmm. Tape two.
This is when Rinpoche had that trouble as new monk, and I still need to clarify a little bit about the clapping. Just the clapping rhythms and And so he said, Dukkar, the white umbrella, and it clapped. I was it clapped three times quickly, and then we chant some more and clapped another three times. But I checked that out with Tenzin, and he seemed to be quite confused, so he said I should ask Rinpoche again about the clapping for Dukkar. What?
Mhmm. How can he tell this? Oh. Yeah. One one one chuck.
One clap.
Key terms in this teaching
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Did the senior students often criticize or embarrass the younger students if they were not studying?
Yes, the older students would criticize the younger students when they were not studying well. They told them they should study better, because they had come a long way to be there and should not waste their time.