Rinpoche’s Story – 1991-04-15 – 47A – ‘s Story – KR

30 min · 2,242 words · 15 April 1991

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story - 1991-04-15 - 47A - 's Story - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A conversation about the monastic study curriculum in a Tibetan monastery, covering the stages of classes, how long each takes, and the structure of debate. The speakers clarify the terms used for debate roles, the winter debate session at Jamyang, and the Pramanavarttika and Pramanasamuccaya. A short story about Dignaga and the founding of Jamyang closes the recording.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 31 min

UUID: a0caf014-ad19-49c3-85c8-eee29b2bce25

Date: 1991-04-15

Words: 2,238

So this this this is what they study in Shung Nyingpa. Oh. Yes. So you wanna mark that down? But but I had Shung Nyingpa up here for No.

This is up here. Oh. This is up here. This This This This This is Parchin? Shamatha?

This is Shumita? Subject of Prajñāpāramitā. This This is is what they’re studying. This is the first chapter. This is the first chapter here.

Oh, sorry. I These are subjects taken out in the first chapter. And this is Yes. This is this is Shung Sarpa? This is Shung Sarpa?

Right. But is can I just clarify where the new starts? Does it start with starts up here with Dün Ji Dün Chu. Seventy topics. Right.

Right. Paths paths and grounds. Right. Form body. Turn turning the wheel of Dharma.

Then then Okay. After this, they can see the old the old text class. Okay. Yeah. And then they they do these subjects.

Right. Then Don’t miss out a subject. Yön Tan Sha. Yön Tan Sha. Yondakta.

Yondakta is included in in the new and yeah. After the turning of the wheel Uh-huh. This is included here. I see. So it’s like a third death.

Yeah. Then So then then with my generation begins the the old textual class. I see. Alright. And then.

So then begins this okay. Now begins what’s called the class Shung Sarpa? What do they have there? Oh, yeah. The form body?

They call it beginning separated topics. Beginning separate topics. Anyway, it’s called it’s Shung Sarpa. Just let me write it down. Class it’d class six, won’t it?

So after that Class six. Could you write it’s Tibetan name. I don’t know how to spell it. What do they call it? Separate?

Oh, they call them advanced separate topics. Yeah. That’s Beginning. I mean, that doesn’t mean anything to me. So If you’ve got a better wording.

Shung Sarpa. Shung. And they study they study at that time, the essence of definitive interpretive sutras. And that’s the beginning of the class called Is that down there? Yeah.

Yeah. Okay. It means to to separate out. It’s a separate topic. So anyway, So then with dependent arising begins.

So that’s right. They study these these subjects. All of these? Uh-huh. That’s the whole class.

Do you want the times while we go through this? Yeah. Well, we’ve gotta get it all, but it seems like this there’s classes and the subjects and and the times of the classes might vary from the times of the subjects, if you know what I mean. Like Translate in the actually, Would it be possible for Rinpoche to make a list of some of these in all of these in Tibetan, and then maybe Tenzin could just roughly go through it with me in relation to this to see if I’ve got it straight, and then I could come to you. I wouldn’t take so much of your time.

I mean, then you’re not satisfied with the way you think? Oh, no. I’m very satisfied. Do you wanna go back through this? No.

Not at this stage. But I just wondered if Rinpoche did and he could put down the the times see, there’s a it’s a confusion between classes and subjects and times taken in classes and subjects. Class the names. Difficult to say because some of the some of the students are some of the classes are going very quick go quicker than others because of the the more intelligent classes will go much quicker. Right.

Right. So it can only be stated roughly. So would be a very some of the students would have to they would be in classes where the class would be kept on a subject for a much longer time because they weren’t as not advanced, they weren’t as intelligent. So they would remain in a class for studying one particular subject for a longer period of time. Whereas another more intelligent class would go much quicker.

So it’s difficult to give an exact time. Jump, but that’s clarified for me because I’m I’m thinking in Western terms, you know, in New York. But maybe we can Do mean the No. So we just say generally. Not it wouldn’t necessarily be called it.

But the the small small, middle intermediate And advance. Would each be one year. Right. Then at the Shung Nyingpa? One year for Shung Nyingpa?

It’s number four. Shung Nyingpa? Shung Nyingpa. So it’s it’s probably okay to there this is when the big difference begins to show up and how fast they go. But it it probably would be okay to say that they would do and would be done in one year.

The older text class would be done in one year. But probably some of the students would be staying longer on these subjects. Then could they? Mean, Maybe should you could write that question down. Okay.

Study up to Shung Sarpa. Right. That’s what I thought. That’s good. So that’s the sort of roughly the cutoff point.

So they could go back up. So it was their choice. But this is many of them would go back return after this time. Then the then Shung Nyingpa then the Suku Sarpa. Okay.

In the the Prajñāpāramitā classes. They would all last one year. Each of those classes would last two years. Perfection classes. After after Shung Nyingpa begins the perfection classes.

I think my mind’s almost got up to saturation point. Should we leave it for today and I try not not just this topic and I’ll type it up? So after from the from the seventh so there’s eight chapters. Sorry. So there’s eight chapters in ornament.

Yeah? The text that they’re studying. Yes, yes. And after from the second on through the eighth, then all of the classes are called the perfection classes. Oh, I see.

So they don’t have these strange names after that. And then is that Prajñāpāramitā or Parchin? That’s right. Parchin is Tibetan. Parachin is Sanskrit.

So, the class name would be Parachin, would it? Mhmm. Anyway, we’ll do that next Anyway, this time when his uncles died, Rinpoche was in All all his fellow monks have gone back to come. Was that at that stage, or was it a bit later? At the same time, Shung Nyingpa?

It would be because that’s because of the money, wasn’t Yeah. That’s right. That I mean, the ones that came with him on his own. Not all of them went back. About I it was he Geshe?

Geshe? Oh, I’ve got it. You were you were you were previously. It. Yeah.

It’s alright. I’ll check it later. Damcha debating. What’s Damja mean? Damcha.

Tamja. Tamja. This is I’ve got it’s like a class where people sit around. I stayed there, then people come in debating Tamja, then debating about a subject and. So the the is the person who answers the questions in debate.

And this person has prepared himself by studying the various texts and then he is, I mean not in fact, but theoretically he is stating that now I’m going to bind myself to the assertions of the meanings as I found in the text. Means to bind. I see. Means to bind. Why?

Or commit. Uh-huh. To hold to. What is, I am going to hold to the assertions of the meanings as presented in the text. So this is the person who’s down.

He says, I have studied the text, and now I have found the meaning of the text, and I’m going to bind myself to whatever assertions that I have found in that text. And then the person standing up is the means to send clear reasons. Means clear, means to send. He is putting the questions. So he is trying to create doubts, trying to whatever the assertions of the damcha, the sitter, the answer, and the debater is trying to create doubts with respect to that.

The chews brought from both of us. So, damja is the means that which is bound to. Is bound to. And the wah, and they say wah. And wah makes a person.

Does T a g? T a g. Yeah. Means reason. Right.

Means the thesis or the consequence. L, is it? What I have to add in there. I have to look up the story. Dak sal means to send.

Send can just makes it a person. The the questioner. Daksal is answering. What’s means makes it a person, like operator. Means to send.

So, he sends the thesis and the reason. He’s sending or asking questions using syllogisms. Doctor. Talking about the damja. Well, I didn’t have very much there.

I mean, I’m gonna have to collate all the bits. They’re debating about a subject. That’s what you’ve got here. Is is that Sungju? I don’t I don’t even understand what I’ve got.

So this is a technical terms. This is the adversary, Ngöl, and Chig Go is the proponent. I’m a I’d have I’d have to I’d have to look up those. Ngöl and Chig Go. Maybe you could just help me look for this book again on debate.

Yeah. That would be very helpful. I did look at it. Damja. Damcha li.

Danjali. Danjali. Danjali. Danjali. And.

And. Same. But you just leave the wa off and say. Wa makes it a person? So they don’t debate in the first class, which would be.

Is that right? No, no. The first class? He wanted to shift this from the the the new from the old class to the new class. Oh, well, dependent arising.

That’s in the new class. Oh, good. Okay. Rinpoche, the next time for when we’ll get together, Rinpoche is gonna have to see whether Friday’s gonna be okay. Oh.

Yeah. So he’ll Then I’m gonna then I’m gonna go away for a week? Week. What at the same time as you? Mhmm.

So this Friday, castles from So this this debate session special debate session is called. Very auspicious to to hear these things. Jam. Jam yang. Jam.

Jam yang. They’re different meanings, but listen. Jamyang is the place is the place where they had the debate session. And Jamyang means means Gonpa, winter. Winter.

Chu is an abbreviation of debate. Oh. Debate. Chu. Chu.

So it’s the winter debate session at this place called Jamyang, Monastery. And what they would they would debate at this time is Pramānavārttika by Dharmakīrti. This is what they would debate. And his teacher was named Dharmakīrti was named — his teacher was named Dignāgā. And Dignāgā wrote a group of texts called Pramānasamuccaya.

Samuccaya. They I have to find out what the got the name of that comment Compendium of Valid Cognition. Compendium of Prime Cognition. He wrote this. And when he was living in India, had a slate.

Dignāgā had a slate, and he was living in a small hut, near a village. And he was composing a text, he was writing the famous homage. There’s a very famous homage that he wrote. Mhmm. And he would write it down.

And then having written it down, he would go off and go for alms to the village. Mhmm. And then he would come back, and it would be erased. And he’d again, he’d compose this homage. He’d go off and go back and come back, and it would be erased.

And he began to wonder who was erasing it. So he he he hid one day to find out who was erasing it, and it turned out to be this one non-Buddhist who was wanted to challenge him in his in debate. So the non-Buddhist they had and this non-Buddhist had a debate. And the one defeated the non-Buddhist, and the the non-Buddhist became very angry and upset, and fire came out of his mouth. And and, Dignāgā became very depressed about this.

He said, you know, there wasn’t any benefit in having defeated him. That’s why he had harmed sentient beings by by causing him to be so upset and creating so much negative karma by becoming angry. And he said, maybe I shouldn’t compose a text. Maybe it’s of no benefit. So he he wrote he had a slate, which was written down as famous homage, and he threw it up in the air.

And he said, if this if this slate falls down, then then this this text I’m trying to write is of no benefit to anybody, and I I won’t I won’t finish it. But if it if it never comes down, if it doesn’t come down, then that will be a sign that there will be some benefit from writing this text. So he threw the text the slate up in the air, and it didn’t come down. And and he looked up, and, Mañjuśrī was holding the slate. And Mañjuśrī said that this text, if I haven’t finished this text, it would be a a very valuable text for people to study in the future.

But the text, when it said that the slate did come down, place called Jamyang. That’s where the slate came down, and therefore it’s considered a very holy place. And said to develop one’s wisdom and there are many prostrations. So that’s kind of the end. Some history.

It’s really interesting.

Key terms in this teaching

prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top