Rinpoche’s Story – 1988-12-09 – 10B – ‘s Story – KR

31 min · 1,831 words · 9 December 1988

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story - 1988-12-09 - 10B - 's Story - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The speakers describe the daily routine of monks at a monastic debate court, including debate sessions, communal prayers, collecting tsampa, and the discipline that enforced attendance. They also discuss the hardship students faced when their money ran out, and the debate curriculum from basic topics through Middle Way, Vinaya and Abhidharma. Photographs of the teacher’s early years as abbot are discussed for a book.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 31 min

UUID: 1f604b1d-ad93-42f8-8799-3398a6fe9a0b

Date: 1988-12-09

Words: 1,827

So it’s the debate hadn’t finished yet. They they would each pick a debate partner Yeah. According to whatever their choice Yeah. And then they would debate. And during this period, the disciplinary, he would walk around and debate the court three times, you know, inspecting the monks and then debating.

And then upon having circled them three times, he would return to his room. And disciplinary and he would return to his room and drink some tea and and have and then the the the monks were allowed to return to their rooms. So then the monks would all return to their individual rooms and they’d prepare a fire for and they they would make some tea and cook their lunch. So then about 01:30, having eaten lunch, they would go they would go around to the various images around the the monastery and making prayers and such. Then they returned to the Debate Court.

During this period of debate, during a debate session, in a period of time, debating went on all the time. So there was always debate, people So they went to they went to, you know, to pay their respects to the various images around the monastery about 12:30. And then maybe about 01:00, then they had to return to Debate Court, all the monks. So then they then they would debate from perhaps two to 02:30. Then they would about 02:30, someone would ring the bell on the roof of the prayer hall, and the monks would gather, as in this picture again, with the abbot.

They would recite the various prayers, such as the praises of the 21 Taras, Heart Sūtra. This would last up to this session prayer session would last up to about 05:00. That’s a long one. You said two 02:30? 04:30.

02:30. So again, at 05:00, they would begin debate with two individuals debating with one another and the disciplinary would would again sort of circle around three times. Then at 06:00, this debate session would finish, and the monks would go back to their rooms. Rooms at 06:00, then they would go to their teacher to pick up a supply of tsampa. Because the teacher bought he bought their tsampa for them.

And so they now they go and pick up their their their portion, their share of tsampa. So, then, if during the earlier prayer sessions there had been a patron who had given money to the monks, then at this time going to their teacher to receive their allotment, tsampa, they would give him whatever money it was they had received, and he would write it down in a book for them. So without that money, then there’s Without that money, there was no way for the teacher to buy the tsampa for his students. So then then they would go to If you were so all the monks had to go to the teachings of their individual teachers if they were found not having gone to their their teachings when it was time, then they would be beaten. By the disciplinary.

So this would be something like the disciplinarian, but it’s the disciplinarian for the district house, not the not the college. So they aren’t called gegös. They have a different name, but they’re like the disciplinarian. And if you’re not going to teaching, then they would beat them. Did nice monks get many beatings there?

So he had a big he had a big stick, beat with the stick. A wooden. So if you didn’t if you didn’t follow the the rules, then you had you were liable to be beaten. So then about seven to 07:30, again, the there would be an the debate session would be announced by the the loud recitation of dé, the syllable dé. So then 09:00.

So then they would at at that time, they would sit around the various places outside around their district house and begin to memorize their texts. Memorize text until eleven, 12:00. Some some of them memorized all night. So this during the debate session, this was the there was always debate going on? So there’s always a young man, so you weren’t — no one stayed in their in their room?

It’s a very long and rigorous day. And all they had to eat was Sometimes they didn’t they didn’t even have tsampa to eat. So they some of them didn’t have any tea to drink in their in their individual rooms. Some a few of them had were able to have a little bit of tea to drink for themselves. Why was that?

They So you need you need you need to make tea, you need tea, you need wood, you need matches, and things like this, and they didn’t have enough money? Some of the some of them didn’t have any wood to build fires at any time. First three or four years, remember Jay, he always had enough tea. He always had enough tsampa. After that, the money that he had brought with him his ran out, and there were many times when he he didn’t have enough he didn’t have any and he would he would just have tea.

And there were some times when he didn’t even have tea. So at first this made him very depressed. So but after a while, it didn’t make it didn’t bother him. He was you know, he became more interested in than anything else in in his studies. And if studies were going well, he was happy.

Sometimes he would ask his friends to help him out and give him some food to eat. So in the evenings, he would drink water. So this is all the the, like, the like, all the Geshes that you may have heard of, like Geshe Ngawang and Geshe Ngawang Dhargyey. They had to stay with they’ve done in the same conditions. No one there.

That would be Did he have fire for winter? They didn’t have even to make tea, they didn’t have enough wood, let alone just to have a fire. So they had very the clothing was was in very bad shape, very tattered clothing, and then they just had in in the in the summer, it didn’t make that much difference. But in the winter, it it became very cold. So getting up at five in the morning and not going to bed till midnight?

This was during debate session. How long did the debate sessions go for? Yeah. So they have a debate session that would last one month, and then they’d have a fifteen day interval without without debate, and then again, a debate session for another month. So they’re during during the course of a year, there would be two months without debate.

Did they have themes that kept recurring different times of the year for the debates, or they’re just sort of working through sutras? Wow. So they had a a course of study that they were passing through, and this would determine that they what they were debating on. The the lowest class would be collected topics and then awareness and knowledge, and classes of reasoning. And so this was the program was outlined and each they would debate according to where they were in this program.

Oh, see. And that would depend on which class they were in. That’s right. So, like, the first year, they’d just have selected topics or whatever. Collected topics.

Yeah. Wherever they yeah. Wherever that class was moving. Yeah. The class would move through this program.

So they they would take up the studies such as the Ornament for Clear Realization and then having studied they would study middle way philosophy. Then they would study discipline or Vinaya. And then Abhidharma or knowledge. So these are the course of studies that they would pass through. Oh, so they would.

That’s what Ed was asking. I mean, Panya was asking for about Abhidharma. They study all that. Oh, yeah. They would in their debates, in the debate form.

Mhmm. So he studied all of that. He studied Abhidharma? Yeah. Yeah.

That’s last study. That’s the last study. It’s the highest, isn’t it? Well, it’s not. It’s just the last.

Not it’s not necessarily the highest. But that’s the last night. It’s pretty These black and white negatives. I hesitate to ask, but just asking. Rinpoche can say no if I could take these.

I’ve got a friend who’s a photographer, get him a set of prints and myself a set to keep for the book, And if Buddha House wants to pay for their set, but can you ask him? It’s 12 often. The would I I’ll try and get a package. To enjoy this. That’s why he he sent for this, especially for that purpose.

So Yeah. It’s in it’s the yeah. The negative for the black and white is easy. And if I could Yeah. Whatever you need, that’s what you do.

Well, if I could take those for now. And could you tell him, Rinpoche, that I’ll come down to when he’s staying at Victor Harbor? Yes, sir. And I’ll try and bring these back. And if he wouldn’t mind to bring these photos down, perhaps we can go through the photos.

I think Dean should be able to explain, and I can get more documentation on them. These negatives are all about the various activities that were centered around his first becoming the abbot. Good. And this one’s working? This is when he gave the the the transmission of the Kālacakra.

Sutras. Dharmasala. That’s right. This I have to find. I don’t know who can copy those, but these I know I can get copies of them.

If you could tell Rinpoche that some of these photos are a little bit dark to reproduce in a book, but I’ve got a friend that Thubten met an elder lady who’s an artist, and she might be able to do black and white sketch, or she would if I we asked No. Be able to do black and white sketches from it. Kasia did he’s going So Rinpoche is writing out all his the teachers that he studied Prajñāpāramitā from and That’s right. Ngawang Dhargyey and then all the teachings that he’s received from the various teachers. Is he also writing what he’s what he studied at this, or is it not necessary?

All of this in the Geshe? It would be helpful if he could remember. That’s great. In all the subjects, people like Panya were asking. That’s all Mhmm.

Even if it’s just an appendix or something like that. That’s right. Yeah. He’s writing that all out. That’s good.

Where was this one taken? That was taken And this one? That’s when he was giving the transmission. So that’s this one. Okay.

Is it Low low. I think Okay. 73. 22 transmission. 1022.

Key terms in this teaching

Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How long did the debate sessions last, and were there breaks between them?

A debate session lasted one month. After it came an interval of fifteen days without debate, and then another debate session of a month began.

Do debates in the monastic colleges follow recurring themes through the year, or do students simply work through the sutras?

Debate topics follow a set course of study that the students pass through, and each class debates according to where it is in that program. The lowest class begins with collected topics, then awareness and knowledge, and classes of reasoning. The class moves through the program together, so in the first year students take up collected topics. Later they study the Ornament for Clear Realization, then middle way philosophy, then discipline (Vinaya), and then Abhidharma, or knowledge. All of these subjects are studied in the debate form.

Scroll to Top