Rinpoche’s Story — 1991-03-25

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story — 1991-03-25
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1991-03-25 – 42A – ‘s Story – KR.mp3

UUID: a2bd3ed2-f51c-4854-a9e4-2dae65a02363

Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche

Collection: Rinpoche’s Story (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 1991-03-25

Duration: 46 min

Words: 3,852

This is Monday, 03/25/1991, and I’m about to interview Rinpoche on monastic life at Sera Monastery in Lhasa. Sera Je and Sera Me. So it would only be that first morning prayer. So they have after the morning prayer session, they have colleges have their individual debate sessions. Right.

And then So in general, they wouldn’t have a prayer session after the debate session, but on special occasions, they might. Just but only on special occasions. Ah, and then it goes to talk about they having tea and they have black tea after this session. Maybe there’s only special occasions and they bring their own tsampa after debating. Yes.

After debate? Yeah. So there you know, in general, they’re they’re they have a period of debate and then they’ll have a period when there’s no debate during the course of this study. Break period. So, if they’re during a debate period, then the colleges would they would have a regular meet because They would have they would they, yeah, they would have they would be so would give them tea after debate at each of the colleges.

So that’s Sera Je or Sarah May, Not Dre Hor. It’s the same same. But they both would do it after the debate? Right. Then during the debate session?

Whether they had debate session period or not, then at this time, they would gather together and have tea, black tea, both Sera Me and Sera Je independently. So there’s also Dre Hor. Yes. Well yeah. And then we just had here but the the tulkus and geshes would get butter with theirs.

And then the the Geshe and tulku tea. So oh, so they’d be given butter tea. Tea Oh, And then mix yeah. Special. But all the monks would have to provide their own tsampa.

Yeah. So the troubled source of the tsampa. So at a time when Rinpoche was very poor and he didn’t have any tsampa or other monks like him, then they would just have to have tea and nothing. So Can they would they would borrow they would borrow tsampa from other people. This particular ceremony only happens sometimes.

The drinking of tea? Well, yeah, and I’ve got something about they have two cups and they have fifteen minutes and then they have another fifteen minutes sitting. So in normally, they would recite it wasn’t there’s no special ceremony at this time unless the except on special occasions and when there there was some a donor came and and made an offering. But in generally, they would recite one of their two texts that they were studying, either the Ornament for Clear Realization or the Entering into the Middle Way. They would recite the text.

Oh, after they had their tea? The Yeah. So they would recite it at this time. They for mem for memorization, they’d recite one of their two texts. And then they would they they then sign it after Yeah.

So first so first, they would sit down and recite the going for refuge, the recitation of the mind generation and development of the awakening heart and motivation. Then they would drink their tea. Uh-huh. Then they would recite from memory one of the texts. Not the whole text, but segments of the text.

Together in unison. The topics of So, yeah, they would first, they would recite they would recite together. So they would just like we recite Lama Chöpa together, they would recite they didn’t have a text in front of them. They did it from memory. First, they recite ornament Yeah.

For Clear Realization, then they recite entering into the middle way. So they’d go through different sections each time and then pick up the next section the next session. Yeah. The entire text. Not not not the entire text.

Eventually day they wouldn’t recite the entire text. They’d recite maybe one chapter or two chapters short text. Yeah. And then but they eventually, they would recite So the following day they’d continue from where they left That’s off right. Oh, that’s quite interesting.

But that’s is that every day during debate or every day during break time? Or This is only during debate session. Only during the debate period. So they just sort of sharpen up their minds for arguing perhaps to get the, yeah, the text refreshed or something. The the reason for Yeah.

So they were this is the tech this is the This is generally texts that they’re studying and so it’s important that they be able to have these in their mind and sort of aid their memory in their study. Yeah. And help for the debate then. They should have they Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Just wanted to check something about, like, they debate until 10:00, and then they drink their tea quickly, and then they do this recitation. The Is that correct? Yeah. Then then they would have their tea.

Good. I wondered if Rinpoche could just explain a little bit more about donors because we keep on getting reference to it in all sorts of different areas, and I I don’t fully understand it’d be good to put in a bit more explanation. The the the Yes. Just in general. Reasons for for acting as donors or making donations.

Sometimes it would be if someone had died, they would make offerings or if someone were sick or if they had some plan that they wanted to go well, they would to make offerings in order to create a positive merit. This is the reason that people generally acted as donors or patrons, and they might give money. Some generally, give money, but sometimes they would give food off a meal. So money for all of the monks? The No.

Individually or for the college? The possibly sometimes they would give to just monastery as a whole or the college as a whole. Sometimes they would just give to the college or just to the monks. Both possibilities. And with the individual donors, was there some special connection between families such that some would give to Sera Me and some to Sera Je or some to Dre Hor?

Jindak Jindak different reasons for giving to one particular college or district house. It was usually according to if they had relationships, monks who were monk relations. Relatives. Relatives. So they would probably give to that particular district house or that particular college.

Sometimes they had relatives in both colleges, so they would give to both colleges. That’s so interesting. Wearing their cloaks when they were drinking tea. Oh, right. They just take them off for debate.

Right. That’s alright. So I just had that a bit confused there. Take them then they go and take off their clothes and continue on. Sitting in the same positions and just as they were in your mornings?

Okay. So Jacob had it. So at at about 11:30, then the the bell would ring, and then they they they finished their debate, and then they gather again. And sometimes the abbot would come and give teachings on Uh-huh. Or sometimes if he didn’t come, they would just do prayers of Tārā.

And at the Heart Sūtra, they would recite that. Just themselves? Yeah. Not necessarily with the abbot? He would only come on occasions.

Oh. And at those times, he would usually teach Lamrim or something like that. Oh, see. Right. Other times, they would just recite these prayers, and this would last for about half an hour.

Right. And we’ve got something about a chanting master. So was the chanting master there when the abbot wasn’t? What’s his name in Tibetan chanting master? It’s not Tārā. It’s Dükar. And I I I to find out the name of that in English. Dukkar. Dukkar.

Yeah. This is the Dükar. Oh. Yeah. So they they wouldn’t recite Tārā.

They would recite dukkar. Wait. So you check? The Dükar always comes. Is the chanting master.

Oh, right. Always comes. Right. Just mhmm. Does he sit on a a throne also, just a bit lower than the other?

Yeah. Yeah. Alright. They don’t they didn’t they did Tārā in the evening. They don’t they did Ah.

Not not here. Ah, right. Just check if that’s right. After this, then they’d go to individual rooms and have tea and have lunch, have meal. Oh, right.

I didn’t think that. So they would have individual debate for about five minutes. Oh, only five minutes Mhmm. After these prayers. So after that after that five minutes, most most of them would go to the rooms, but maybe it’s some of them a few of them might continue to debate, but it wasn’t mandatory.

Just but most would go away into their individual rooms. That was lunchtime, wasn’t The kalak. Mhmm. Kalak. Tea and food.

And they they provide their own tea, and they cook themselves. And the yeah. The district houses would have a an assembly at this time, at which time they would be served a meal and food. But if there wasn’t, then they would have to make their own meal and food. During this five minute debate period, the disciplinary would walk around five times three times to make sure that everybody was attending and that they were debating.

But it was literally only a five minute period. Very, very short. Yeah, it’s just five So might stay ten minutes, and I might stay fifteen. Yeah. Yeah.

So five to fifteen minutes. Maybe maybe you say ten minutes. It might be difficult for the the disciplinary to walk around three times in five minutes. Oh, we’d give you 15. Made a.

So it’s difficult So it’s difficult to say how many times in any period that that they would have these district house meals. That would be according to the to the donors. And but in particular particularly, Dre Hor Khamtsen. They they had more than most district houses because there were many traders in Lhasa who came from that area. So they had many patrons or donors who cared.

Mhmm. Maybe maybe, roughly speaking, for Dre Hor Khamtsen, maybe ten, fifteen times a month. Oh, that’s quite awesome, isn’t it? Yeah. 10 to to 15 times maybe in a month.

Maybe maybe at most at most 15 times, something like that. I’ve forgotten now. Is it is it about eight eight hundred monks? Previous to the the the coming of the Chinese, there there might have been four or 500. And then after the Chinese come came because there was there was so much trouble that it it increased to maybe a thousand.

It increased? Mhmm. More monks came. Yes. So when they have to because of the the the the troubles that the Chinese were making in his native area, and more monks came to to Lhasa, to the monastery.

So the numbers increased. I see. Is that because they could no longer go to Dargyé? Or Because it didn’t Dargyé moved away. So, yeah, that’s why it was difficult for them to remain there.

The the Chinese were making trouble for them. So would the monks almost immediately go to Lhasa once they became monks rather than go to a local monastery? When was that? During this period? Yeah.

Yeah. During when the when the Chinese were there? Yeah. We talked about before that the beginning, they would stay in the monastery for six or seven years until they were about 16 or 17. They wouldn’t come to Lhasa before that.

No. I was I was just curious about the big jump in the number of monks then. That was all. So was does that mean more laypeople actually became monks? The the increase in monks wasn’t because they they weren’t new monks.

They were monks that had been previously been staying, for example, And the reason that the only reason they came because of the Chinese repression. So these were old monks who were normally would would have stayed back in in, but because of the Chinese difficulty with the Chinese, they came to Right. To to Lhasa. Oh, thank you. Good.

Thank you. For the the district houses? Yeah. Clock, they would again assemble for debate. And then the the then this would last maybe until 05:00.

And during this period also, they would they would have recitation of, for example, the 21 Taras Mhmm. The Heart of Wisdom Sūtra. The upper classes would they they might have a teaching at any time during the course of the day. It could be in the morning. It could be in the afternoon.

And the the students of that particular teacher would ask the the the permission of the of the the disciplinarian to be excused from debate, for example, and to attend because they had they had to attend their teaching. Uh-huh. And after this but the the students of the the new students who were studying the three the three basic logic texts Yeah. At this time, then they would go to their their their teachers and be taught. And it’s at this time that, you know, that the the district house would if they if they found them outside that they hadn’t gone to their teachers, then there was then there it was possible that they might receive a beating for that.

So the the three beginning classes would they might assemble together with with one teacher, and he would ask they would all recite the various definitions that they were to learn have learned for that day. And and then one class would recite the definitions that they they were to have learned for that day, and the next class and the next class go through these three classes. They would they they weren’t and they didn’t have very they weren’t very advanced at this point. Some of these new students, they would have they had very little discipline. So many of quite often they would try to skip out of going to the the the teaching at this time.

And this is when the the Gegö would look around to see if they had were attending their teaching if they were outside. So it was mainly the new students that got beaten? The the the So the individual teacher would take a you know, he would look around to make sure all the students were attending. And if one of the you know, just like in school, that’s the responsibility of the teacher to make to make sure that all the students have are attending. And if they didn’t, then the teacher would find them and and Rinpoche doesn’t think maybe it’s a good idea to talk about that maybe the the westerners, they don’t like to hear about students being beaten.

But if he were to he would hunt them out and find them, why didn’t he come to teaching and beat them? So it’s the individual teachers who who actually beat them. The at during the debate session, if these if these new students weren’t able didn’t answer well or they didn’t know what they were what they were to had should have known the various definitions, then the older students would say, well, you know, who who’s who’s student is who’s who’s the who’s the teacher of this student? This teacher is obviously not teaching these students well, and that this would be highly embarrassing for the the teacher if the students would act like this to the teacher. Just if they when the teacher found out that the students were answering poorly or didn’t know what they should have known, then he’d tell them to get out and don’t come back and things like this because it was terribly embarrassing for the teacher when the students didn’t didn’t do well.

So get out of the monastery or just get out of his side? Teacher wouldn’t pass them if they didn’t do well. And and there was like, they would say, you know, the the older students would say, you you aren’t you don’t they would tell them to get away, to leave. Yeah. Unless they unless they could answer well, then then there’s no reason for them to be staying here.

And they would embarrass the students, these new students. Oh. So they would tell you that they they don’t belong here. And so then the students would out of this, they would be motivated to study better. So it was sort of older peers putting pressure on them?

They would embarrass them. They said, you know, if you can’t if you can’t study well, if you can’t answer like this, then you should you know, you’re gonna have to go back home. And then if if they were to go back home having been returned from the monastery, then they would have they would have been very shameful for them. Yeah. So, you know, why did you waste your time?

Why did you go to Yeah. All the way there? And so they were shamed into working well. Alright. This is very interesting.

To stay, you know, at the monastery and then have to go back because they didn’t study well. They just would they’re these things would be very difficult for them if they went back home. Mhmm. K. [unclear]

What is that? So the the district house district house disciplinarian Mhmm. Would have would have a stick about two two and a half feet long. Is it? It was wood.

And everything. Two and a half feet, and it was quite quite solid, about two and a half inch, three inches thick. Shing was pine or some heavy wood, and they beat with it. They’re doing Dre Dre Dre. This I mean, there’s many of the children were quite unruly.

Yeah. They were they were they were hard to control. They just like to play all the time. Yeah. Think I think many The Or just more in the monastery.

The. So they I mean, this was done out of compassion since if they will continue in the way they were doing, then things would go very badly for them. So in order to help them to develop more better ways of conduct, then they would they would beat them. Necessary to explain this to a westerner because we, and I include myself, are horrified by that because we see beating as violence and intimidation of the the strong against the weak. So this is this is mistaken.

So the parents in the West are are powerless. They’re they’re like their children’s servants. Where as in the the children were always looking to the parents to see what what and what they shouldn’t be doing. They that they would see that what they did was pleasing would be pleasing to their parents, and they would do it. If they see it wouldn’t be pleasing, then they wouldn’t do it.

Mhmm. Often, though, with a parent, and I I wouldn’t know in a monastery, but beating or physical discipline comes from anger, not from compassion, and that’s not necessarily good motivation. So then the the reason for the beating should be that in order to for the to help the child cease on negative kinds of negative types of conduct in order to benefit the child, you know, with with this type of motivation to to help them to help the child. Mhmm. You know?

So if you can help the child to cease negative types of conduct, then you actually the child will turn out well. The only trouble is beating in itself is a negative type of conduct. It’s a physical violence of one being against another. This is how Westerners see. So so out of this and out of this view, then the parents are free to do what is best for their child.

They’re they’re they’re not they’re not actually free to help their child. Well, in the understanding of the Montessori philosophy, which is used by the Tibetan children’s village. He’s telling me to shut up, is he? I think his holiness. I feel his holiness.

Dalai Lama and his sister have chosen this other way, this Montessori way, particularly with young children that you you you you lead them in a prepared way, but you don’t use violence against them. So you never beat them? No. The have the So maybe that’s because the that is the dilemma is seen that the Westerners don’t like to see the children beaten, so he’s imposed that way of running things. I think it comes from a more fundamentally profound understanding of of violence from one person to another, that maybe there’s a very small percentage of people that can use violence for compassion, but that maybe about 90% of those people could Rinpoche truly say that all those teachers would only be doing it for compassion, or would they be doing it because they’d be ashamed by their their students?

That’s not compassion. That’s that’s self motivation. So we we can’t say. I mean, even in the monastic in that monastery situation, there were some who beat out of anger, some who beat out of compassion. So in the in the West, they give they give the the children all the freedom that they want, and and the and the so the the children don’t respect in general, the children don’t respect their parents and and and their wants.

And there is a seems to be in the West a great emphasis on individualism and and doing what you want. And this individualism is what it causes so many divorces these days that everybody’s they two people are the men and one, they come together, but they’re in there very much for themselves. And if they don’t get what they want, then they just split up. They get divorced. And this is one of the difficulties in relationships relationships that he sees in the West, that because their children have been brought up to have all the freedom and all the they don’t they’re not they’re not have subs they don’t have to be subservient or respectful to another person to forego their wants, that they’re gonna be brought up with thinking that they can that they should do exactly what they want and get what they want.

So they they grow up with a sense of individualism, makes it difficult to have harmonious relationships. Rinpoche, I think he’s completely right, but there’s another point that I have to really make on this this violent discipline, which I think is quite different to that, and I would like to try and express it a little bit more. [unclear exchange], but I want to go back to the original argument, which wasn’t what we Why I think his holiness and his holiness’ sisters have adopted this philosophy of of nonphysical violence is because when you impose a solution on a weaker and a smaller person using physical violence

Key terms in this teaching

Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top