Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2 Audio Track.aiff
UUID: 4fc70b18-03e6-49ff-a116-c5a940692bbc
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Rigpa disk 2
Duration: 26 min
Words: 2,939
Now in the Dzogchen teachings, when they really come to nature mind, the great master see that the ordinary mind, delusion mind, has kept our nature mind as hostage almost. It’s just the way we explain that. No. No. I mean, that just makes open people another way.
Is that imprisoned? Another way. In prison. So it’s like the cloud is is obscuring the sky. Same way.
So we found that what is the root of mind. But then when we examine and we investigate mind, we find that there are three subtle concepts about who we are that are especially hard to break down. These are the belief that self is permanent, it’s singular, and it’s independent. For the idea of self to have a meaning, it must be lasting permanent. Or if it was something that appeared and then vanished again from moment to moment, then we would not be so concerned about what happened to it.
But something so transitory could not really be our self. So our subtle belief in permanence leads to conviction that there is an essential core entity of me or others and so on that remained unchanging throughout the time. So we believe that there is a single unique self. If we have no separate individual identity, why would we worry about what happened to our own self anymore than we worry about anyone else? Singularity is an incredibly subtle delusion.
It is difficult to see until it is pointed to us. Thirdly, we believe that self is independent. Otherwise, it would make no sense or say, I did this or I have this. It if I had no independent existence, then there would be no point to claim the action experience of their own. Now this is a little bit complicated, but a very simple thing is that we always be believe that is a permanent, singular, and independent.
But this is Buddhist philosophy from beginning. When you examine, when you examine, we always think that when you really examine, things are permanent. Are not permanent. Things not singular but multiple. Like, for example, this glass.
This glass. It looks very rare, isn’t it? It exists. It It does. And because something exists, we think it’s permanent.
So we attach permanent to existence. That’s the problem. Moment something exists, we think it’s permanent. It’s called the hidden fold of mind. We don’t even realize it, but it’s almost like subconsciously Because of delusion, we always think this is permanent, singular, We are permanently singular independent.
But then you see, what if I throw this glass? Which I might do. If I throw this glass on a hard surface, in a matter of seconds, it’s broken, there’s no glass. Only pieces of glass. And if you break them into further, the dissolve into atoms.
Atom also is modern physics, do not exist. So it’s not permanent. It’s a touch it matter. It’s touch it. That is permanent.
It’s not permanent. But then you say, okay. If it it it’s a beautiful Tibetan expression. It’s it’s free of permanent and nonexistent, which is also an another way of showing impermanence. Is permanent when you realize it neither permanent, but also nonexistent.
It’s not because then you say, okay. If it’s, like, empty, if if if you say, is is this cup nothing? No. It’s here. Yeah.
It’s not permanent, but also it is not nothing. We proved that before that it’s not permanent. When you prove that it’s not permanent, then it’s not singular, then it’s also not independent. But then it is also not nothing. So if it’s not nothing, then how does it appear?
Because of many cause and conditions. When they come together, they appear. When these cause and condition dissolve, they disappear. Like us, as long as all the different functions of the body remain and be alive. One is a girl, then he died.
Is that is that clear? So because of many cause and conditions, they appear. Even though they are not permanent, but yet it is not nothing. But that’s a very important point. There are two lessons from this.
Practical lessons. Even on emotional level. Most important, we have to learn an emotion. Deep emotion level. When you realize deeply that it’s not permanent, just it does everything in this world is not permanent.
Then you see you realize because you see reason why we suffer, one of the main cause of suffering is grasping. Grasping. You understand? Grasping. But then when you realize all that you grasp on them are actually empty, impermanent, then you realize on the deeper level, it is futile to grasp.
When you realize impermanent, the real message is that it’s futile to grasp. So you let go grasp it, and you realize the wisdom of non attachment. But when you say non attachment, doesn’t mean indifferent. When you have no attachment, in fact, there’s even more purer love. Often we think love is attachment.
But you know, ladies and gentlemen, it is the attachment in your love that create all this problem. Attachment. So I know you, in your relationship, you have to always let go, isn’t it, for the couples to really survive? You have to let go and let go and love fearlessly and trust. Give space, respect.
And when you let go, let go. Love is letting go. You understand? So in fact, greater love comes. In fact, as Milarepa have said, realizing emptiness or realizing impermanence is the source of compassion.
But then you see the other point that it is not nothing. Because if it was empty, then you must have Then you have the nearest to go. Nothing, you know, exists. You eat Mary for tomorrow we die. It’s not that because of the positive condition.
And therefore, there is karma. Therefore, whatever we do or say have consequences. In fact, interesting, the near death research they say, people have done, they say not even a single thought is lost. So whatever we do or say. So therefore, you become ethical.
You become universally and person responsible. And you understand? Is that clear? So that’s really also, that’s why Buddha said form is empty, but that emptiness appears in the form of form. Form does not differ from emptiness.
Emptiness does not differ from. Emptiness. Beauty is to see emptiness form at the center. In fact, in the very famous Sūtra called Heart Sūtra in the Prajñāpāramitā, In the Prajñāpāramitā, says, form is emptiness, emptiness is form. In the Prajñāpāramitā, the Heart Sūtra, in the Tibetan, because there’s a the Japanese and the kind of the Chinese version is slightly different from Tibetan.
In Tibetan, it says at the beginning, it recounted by Ananda, I think. One of the most faithful to start with Buddha. You see, in those, they they didn’t have to record us. They’ve had these people who have and forget memory. Anything they heard, they never forgot.
And I thought that was just a story. I mean, I I knew it was just a story. I thought it happened long time ago. But in that, I met many, many great masters like Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche. Like, for example, like Jamyang Khyentse.
Whatever they read, whatever they’ve heard, they never forget. Usually, can be amazing. So Ananda never forgot anything that Buddha taught. So after Buddha died, all his disciples gathered together, and they relied their dharma recollections upon Ananda’s memory. And then recounted, and the law were written down.
And it all began by saying, thus I have heard. Once blessed one that the Buddha in the heart Sūtra, was dwelling in the Vajraphic Mountain, which is Rajagir, near Bodhgaya, Vajraphic. Together, gathering of monks and Bodhisattvas, at that time, the Blessed One, that’s the Buddha, entered the Samādhi, meaning in the meditation called profound appearance. So, actually, Buddha in the Heart Sūtra didn’t say a single word. He remained in the meditation called profound appearance.
What is profound appearance? Is that the understanding of form is in this in this form. That’s that really that profound appearance, indivisible appearance and emptiness, which are things that, and to remain in that samadhi. It inspired Avalokiteśvara. He became a spokesman.
And Sariputra, who represent the wisdom, the intelligence, was the inquirer. And he inquired, and then there’s begin this the incredible dialogue. And when this that also there is a dialogue. When this finished, Buddha arose from the meditation. He said, well done.
Well done. You see, just as you’ve said. All the Buddhas will rejoice. You see? So that’s the profound appearance.
We did we see profound appearance. You understand? Profound appearance. Buddhas Now there’s a beautiful piece from His Holiness the Dalai Lama. In a naive view of the world, we cling to a feeling that there’s a self that in some sense is the master of a body and mind, an agent that is independent and bears its own distinct identity.
Identity. There’s a notion of somehow an unchanging me that goes through different stages of life from childhood to middle age and so on to old age and death. Clearly, we have a belief that there is something in many lives or in some life that retains continuity over time. I mean, it’s so beautiful, these teachings, really. So beautiful, really.
Like, for example, when you say, we all say, you know, we all say, oh, when I was young. Or yesterday. Oh, this morning, I did this. Actually, really, when you examine, you think that when I was young, that young is same as you now. Like, for example, when I was young by the way, when you look at your photos of when you were youthful and you look at photos of now, do they look the same?
In Buddhist teaching, there’s a very fine analysis which kind of at the end of it, you see, you just kind of because when you really examine because we don’t examine. We just assume. We think it’s the same as when I was young. And I really, really realize this also. You know, like, I have had in my life.
I’ve had so many lives. Sometimes we we think of many lifetimes. I think sometimes many lifetimes happen in one Like, when I was younger in Tibet, then when I when I came as a as a when I was young very young when I came as refugee in in India, in Sikkim, then later in my teenage in a Catholic school where I taught catechism. All these things, when I go back to those places, it’s just memory. And you really realize that you’re not the same you because you’re always changing.
That’s one example. So he’s always been of the great discoveries made by the Buddha was that the experience of suffering is always associated with strong emotional attachment to a weak sense of self. To all gain and loss, pleasure and pain rise because we identify so closely with this vague feeling of me. We are so emotionally involved with the self that we take it for granted. So clearly, in order to end our suffering, there is nothing more important than to realize that our body, speech, mind are simply not solid to existing entities that we see in there.
And so even though we investigate again and again, however much we search for a cell that is permanent, singular, independent, we cannot find it. Eventually, we arrive at the conclusion that the service is simply a vague and a convenient concept that we project onto a stream of ephemeral thoughts and emotions and experiences. In fact, it is nothing in or of itself. There’s a very moving I think this will bring it all together. A very moving account from His Holiness the Dalai Lama.
He says, when I was in my late twenties, in 1963, one day I was reading a Buddhist text by Tsongkhapa. At one point, I came across a line which says, I is merely designated to the self of physical aggregates. That is the mental and physical collection. As soon as I read that, I got a special kind of sensation, a strange experience that lasted few weeks. I mean, one version said that he got almost like an electric shock.
Really kind of an incredible experience which completely transformed the perception. And that feeling lasted for a few weeks. But during which time, whenever I saw people, whenever I saw things, for example carpet, I would still see them as carpet or people as people, but at the same time I noticed that they had no essence. I had the distinct feeling there’s no I. Not in the sense that I didn’t exist, but a certain feeling of no I as we understand it.
The absence of solid reality. Physically, something like a lightning surged through my heart. I experienced something like electric shock. If I thought about no self or no eye, then in that moment when I saw object as being without essence or substance, it was just like a picture. I think it is a bit similar to watching a TV or movie.
It’s
Watching a movie. When you look at a movie in one way, you feel that there’s something real going on, but at the same time, your mind knows that it is just merely a picture, merely it’s just acting. It’s not real. You see the same picture one way without understanding that it’s acting, another way still seeing the movie but realizing that it’s merely acting. That previously, unless I talked seriously and continued at least for a few moments, it was difficult to get the kind of feeling that you see, I am merely a designation, you know, about the emptiness of self, you see.
But now as soon as I remember emptiness, that picture comes clearly, that experience comes back to me again. That I is merely a designation that he explained in 1963. We’re meant to seeing things in a solid, tangible way. Therefore, there’s a tendency to grasp at things, to become attached to things. We cling to the idea of separate self, separate things, and we strive for a new experience, a new acquisition.
But yet as soon as we pass them, the buzz is gone. We look for something new again. This endless cycle of craving brings suffering. But in my case, the grasping attitude doesn’t rise. This is because self or the wishes and desires like, I remember he said he said he had many years of I think when he found his now he’s very busy.
He doesn’t go have no time. But in early days, I think he went a little bit of shopping. I think in New York, and I think in Switzerland, even shopping, he said, oh, first of all, there are a lot of nice things. But then when we examine, do I need them? No.
One by one, I don’t need. I don’t need. I don’t need. You said, I don’t need. I don’t need.
I don’t need. And even more so when you realize that I am merely just nature. None of these things, you know, like, for example, in my case, this grasping attitude doesn’t rise. This is because self or the wishes or desires or Rolex watches are perceived ultimately as impermanent, changing, and illusive, empty, like mirages. They’re not quite real.
There’s no way you can fully hang on to them. Therefore, there’s no point in coveting them. In fact, when you buy something, there is a bit of a buzz at the beginning, but then it’s gone again. Like children with toys, perfume, and the like. If we acquire an understanding of emptiness, then the craving, which is the source of all suffering, is lessened.
Now one very great temple, I found this very helpful, very central, he said, You see, with all this, however, there’s a tremendous emotional resistance to the realization it is not truly existing self. That is why it takes a long time to overcome the belief that we have ourselves. But when we finally do, there’s an immediate release of tension and also suffering. In fact, when you realize that there’s no longer sufferer, as long as there’s no sufferer, there’s no suffering. Because there’s so much this because of the I.
I is like a magnet that attracts all suffering. When you realize the non existence of self, it’s like this. If there is no longer this, there is nothing. So you see, when we finally able to realize that there is immediate release of tension and suffering, this is because the cause of suffering has dissolved, and the cause of suffering was a mental attachment to something that was never there. When you finally do that, then mind can rest peacefully in empty space with perfect confidence and assurance through meditating in this way, all subtle doubts are worn away and mind can rest naturally in the nature of great emptiness.
Now think it’s probably easy today. A little bit loses you. Like, you know, a little bit disorient you. That’s very Now when the little bit disorient you, don’t walk like that. But rather that it doesn’t mean you become groundless, but it means that the solidity of things is that that suddenly you begin to open your eyes, but you realize something deeper.
And this disorientation is dissolving the solidity, not the groundlessness, but solidity of self solidity of grasping.
Key terms in this teaching
- dzogchen
- Literally "Great Perfection", the practice to attain the mind's natural, primordial state. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.