Q&A Sessions – 01102016Q&A 2 – KR

43 min · 5,703 words

Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
Q&A Sessions - 01102016Q&A 2 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Answers questions on the eighteen root bodhisattva vows, covering the four binding factors that determine whether a downfall breaks the vows and why the ninth and eighteenth are mental downfalls. Also covers responding to ill will through reflection and confession, teaching emptiness only to suitable students, and the idea of intended trainees behind the graduated path.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 4569383c-e571-40c3-8701-cb0b3f992686

Words: 5,699

Well, basically, the 18 vows here, they come from my translation of the six-session Guru Yoga which is made for Rinpoche in 2011, I think. Then that was checked in terms of Rinpoche’s teaching. And the commentary here on the Bodhisattva Vows is by Ngawang Peldan. He’s probably the most authoritative commentator in the Geluk tradition, a very great Mongolian scholar from Orga. He is the commentator Geoffrey relied upon systematically.

It turns out Geshe-la unbeknownst to me is relying on exactly the same commentary. Khensur Rinpoche recommended this commentary, relied on it. So I think you’re on very safe grounds if you rely on this material. Then there are many different possible interpretations. Zopa Rinpoche is a great benefactor of Sera Jey, but I think he himself would recognize he is not a scholar.

He did not finish the Geshe studies, neither did Thubten Gyatso, so Lama Geshe. So I think when it comes to more technical material, you’re on safer grounds relying on the teachings of a Geshe. Do you have other questions? Please. Yes.

Then you’re gonna have to pass it around otherwise if we throw it it’s gonna be a problem. I want to ask about the non virtuous action of ill will Geshe-la mentioned or defined it as being at odds with somebody this feeling of that person evokes feelings of negativity and maybe anger and it’s much easier he talked about dealing with it the antidote it’s much easier in a personal sense of not having anything to do with that person but of course people have to often rub up against the person who evokes these kinds of feelings in a workplace or in a family situation with relatives or whatever He mentioned that there is an antidote and if the antidote doesn’t work there is constraint something else confession and restraint and I wondered what is confession and restraint? Well what was meant was basically when you are dealing with someone, towards whom you have antipathy or even anger, then the best is to change one’s mind. And the antidotes are numerous. You can reflect on love and compassion.

Typically, it doesn’t work very well when you’re angry with the person. But what helps a lot is something His Holiness has pointed out many times. And it is something he noted after speaking with a western psychologist whose name I can’t pronounce, Ekbald, American psychologist of Scandinavian origin. This psychologist found that approximately 90% of all of the negativity involved in anger towards another person comes typically from our own side. Now this is very much in accordance with the Buddhist viewpoint, but Ekbald is not Buddhist in the slightest.

So if we think about that, when we’re very upset with another person, let’s say maybe there’s a reason for being upset, but that reason is five or 10% of the situation. And 90% is the anger coming from our mind. Normally, it tends to calm the anger a lot. And we reach a point which is really the beginning of Buddhist practice where we get a sense of the three first discriminations. I am sick, the teachings of the medicine, and the Buddha is a teacher.

So that sense, I am sick, I am mentally sick, you know, is the very beginning of Buddhist practice. Until that starts, there’s no Dharma practice. Now, what Geshe-la was saying was if we are unable to do this, so someone says just the wrong thing and we flare up and get very angry, Then after that, we have to purify that anger. Or the deed non virtuous deed of ill will has already happened. Maybe we have also said things or even worse, done things we regret.

Then we confess. We can confess to our teacher in person. It’s perhaps the best way to do it. Otherwise, can confess in front of a statue of the Buddha. And then we practice something to purify this.

It can be offering prostrations, reciting Vajrasattva mantra. That depends on the person who are reciting the confession sūtra of the 35 Buddhas. But the best is obviously not to have to purify in the first place. And that happens through restraining anger. Then, if one is unable to restrain one’s anger, what you suggested is the best approach, avoid the person.

But it is not possible to avoid all the people who are going to irritate us. And when we understand in addition that most of that irritation comes from inside ourselves, then the problems are our own mental problems which we have to address Thank you for that. These negativities do become quite entrenched and it’s good to think of strategies to try and change those views The second question I wanted to ask was about the 18 root downfalls of the Bodhisattva vows Geshe-la mentioned the first two were very serious and the other others not so serious if there are four binding factors present. Yes. What are the four binding factors?

The four binding factors, I think I listed them. Yes. They are on the back of your handout of the root vows. And they are here also listed in Ngawang Peldan’s commentary. Thank you.

I’ll see them now. For footnote number five. Not viewing as a fault, not turning away from the desire to behave in that way, joy and satisfaction, and the absence of shame and embarrassment. Typically, if one is a sincere Buddhist and one attends teachings regularly, normally, it’s not gonna be possible for all four binding factors to be present. You may for instance by mistake, let us say, praise yourself and sharply criticize another person who’s a very good practitioner.

But immediately you will feel embarrassed because you know this is wrong. So it is a fault, but it’s not a breach of the bodhisattva vows. It’s not a complete destruction of the vow. Then if one doesn’t attend teachings or if one doesn’t know the teachings, it’s very easy to have all four binding factors. Do you think this is right and I should be doing this and I will continue doing it?

And I’m happy I did it because this is what I merit? And in addition, why should I experience shame and embarrassment? And then, very quickly, these amplify the deed and one has a complete collapse of the Bodhisattva vows. But the dangerous, the very dangerous downfalls are the ninth and the eighteenth Because those are mental downfalls. The ninth is wrong views.

So if the reason is if we stop believing in past and future lives or karma and causality, all our practice collapses. It’s not just Bodhisattva vows, there’s no refuge. If the person is ordained, at that moment they cease being ordained. I knew a case like that with a Western monk who told me directly that he did not believe in past and future lives of karma. And I said to him, well, in that case, you should deposit your robes in front of me and leave the monastery.

You were no longer ordained or a Buddhist. It’s exactly it. At that point, because the foundation of the vows, of all the vows, in other words, ordination vows, vows, bodhisattva and tantric vows, that foundation has collapsed. And that collapse is a mental event. So you can see how delicate this is.

And then relinquishing bodhicitta arises very easily. All it takes is a very great anger towards somebody. Very great anger in the sense, this person I am not going to include in those I am striving to help pertaining for enlightenment. That’s all it takes. Because the very essence of bodhicitta is precisely to work for all.

So because these two breaches are mental breaches and they happen easily, we have to be very wary about them. Very wary. I know Rinpoche expelled someone from the monastery because of the eighteenth vow. A person said to him during the teaching that he did not see why one should take bodhicitta vows. And said to me, then we don’t need such a person here.

You know? It’s a root breach of the root vows. You know? Do you have other questions? Please.

So I’m wanting to know if there are some exceptions. This is a bit tricky. So if a person thought that these say they doubted perfect enlightenment but they they did it because they did it because they didn’t think it was the truth That that’s the first one and the second one would be if they taught emptiness to an untrained mind but they did it in the context of a society that was basically destroying itself say environmentally and politically and socially. Would there be exceptions? Regarding your first question, if you were to not just doubt, but if you were to disbelieve in the existence of emptiness that would be the ninth vow which would be breached.

Bodhisattva vows would collapse and refuge would collapse. You would cease at that moment to be a Buddhist. Even if you were just putting the truth above like the Buddha, you you decided that you thought you knew, but then you thought maybe actually I don’t know and it’s important for me to check on that. Would that still cause the collapse? There’s a big difference between doubting and disbelieving.

That’s what I mean, like a doubt. So if you doubt, then obviously refute and the Bodhisattva vows are fragile, very fragile, but you would still remain a Buddhist. When you ceased doubt, when you actually disbelieved Yeah. You know, at that point, let’s say you say, I believe in God. At that point you cease being a Buddhist.

All the vows are destroyed. You know. Then regarding your second question, remind me of your second question. It’s been a long With the respect to say that the the context that the Buddhist art for resides within which is whether or not Yes. Teach emptiness to the untrained.

So teaching emptiness to the untrained. The key criterion here is the results for the student. Normally, the risk if one teaches emptiness to the untrained is that they will cease believing in causality. If they cease believing in causality, ethics, which is the foundation of the practice, collapses. So if one does that, then one has broken root bodhisattva vows.

Then in a society where most people are engaged in self destructive behavior, teaching emptiness is of no benefit at all. Emptiness is an advanced teaching which is really not of benefit to beginners. What is of benefit are the teachings on ethics and eventually on compassion. They are easy to understand, easy to practice. Emptiness for that reason is taught with great hesitation by the great teachers.

More often than not, the teacher will refuse teaching emptiness. The students must have well studied. They must be committed. There must be no risk of succumbing to an extreme of nihilism. Then emptiness can be taught safely.

Do you have other questions? At lunchtime, we did discussion about two of the vow. One is the number five, appropriate donation to the Triple Gem. And the 16 is taking donation made to the three supreme. Can you tell us the difference between those two?

Very slight. One of the reasons is that the Bodhisattva vows are collated from a new a a numerous number of sources. They were collated by a great Indian scholar called Chandragomin who studied the various sutras in which bodhisattvas took the vows and collated this. And initially, there were even 19 vows. And one of the vowels was found to be strictly identical to one of the extant vowels, and therefore they were reduced to 18.

Basically, the fifth vow seems to refer to forceful appropriation, such as theft. And the sixteenth vow seems to refer refer to appropriation through deception. But in both cases, one is taking something which is donated to the Triple Gem. Now here, that is already a breach of refuge vows. Right?

So what is the difference with Bodhisattva vows? The Bodhisattva vows will not make a lot of sense to you if you do not understand who Bodhisattvas are and who Bodhisattva trainees are. So we are not yet in that category. Typically, Bodhisattvas are beings who are striving for full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Then, because of the amount of merit they accumulate and the prayers they generate, they will typically be reborn in very powerful situations in society.

It’s not always the case. But if you are looking for Bodhisattvas in history, you are looking at presidents, prime ministers, kings, abbots. You are looking at people who are concerned with society as a whole, which is basically not our case. And that is why you have vows such as not destroying cities, which don’t concern us because we actually don’t have the power to do this. But let’s say for instance, the first Dharma king of Tibet, king Songtsen Gampo, was considered to be a bodhisattva, then he had absolute power over Tibet and invaded much of China for that matter.

Then it is for beings like those whose focus is the long-term welfare of society and all beings inside that these vows are formulated. And then many of such beings let’s say in Chinese history for instance, there were emperors in the Tang dynasty which considered Buddhism to be harmful to society because Buddhists, sincere Buddhists, would become ordained, then they would not marry, they would not have children and the cult of the ancestors would be interrupted. And they banned Buddhist ordination, expelled the monks and the nuns from the monasteries. Now it is typically to those beings, assuming they were Bodhisattvas, that the seventh vow depriving of the saffron robes which is disrobing by force applies. Or the tenth vow destroying cities abide.

Or to beings like King Langdarma of Tibet which banned the practice of Buddhism to reinstate the ancient shamanistic religion burn. So at present those vows don’t really apply to us. We don’t have that power. Likewise, when we speak of not giving Dharma or wealth, not giving dharma obviously applies to most of our students here but not giving wealth applies to the great bodhisattvas who typically will be extremely wealthy because of prayers made in past lives. They make the prayers to be able to benefit others, to make vast donations, and when these donations are requested, if they don’t make them out of avarice or stinginess, then the vow is broken, if all four binding factors are present.

So it’s a very once one enters the Bodhisattva yana, the path of the Bodhisattvas, it’s a very different focus. Like if you were looking in the last century for Bodhisattvas, you’d be looking at figures like Mahatma Gandhi even though he was not a Buddhist. It is possible he was a secret Buddhist. Well, that’s what he said. Right?

What he actually believed in, we don’t know. That we don’t know. Definitely, you’d be looking at his one as the Dalai Lama. Belief in God and Buddhism are not compatible. There’s no middle ground there.

There’s no middle ground. So, do you have other questions? Can I ask just one more question? The Chinese, have the Bodhisattva vows but I heard it’s 42, is it correct? Yes.

You have different enumerations. And here, Geshe-la has only presented the 18 root vows. There are 46 branch vows, which he did 46 branch vows in addition to this. They’re not presented because basically, once again, they really concern kings, prime ministers, in the twenty first century, billionaires, presidents, people who have great power. They concern the destruction of cities, etc.

It’s something which doesn’t affect us. So following on, my question really relates very much to just what you were saying. Since taking those vows quite a long time ago I’ve been making them more personal. So for example with the first one, praising oneself or debasing others, I’ve made that, tried to make that very personal like trying not to praise myself just with other people and to not put other people down or criticise people. So is that the correct way to try because as you said these vows, some of them are for a bodhisattva or they’re meant for bodhisattvas so I’m not a bodhisattva yet and it’s going to, would say going to be a really long time before I get there.

So in the meantime upholding those vows is the way to practice those to try and make them more personal whilst still understanding the very nature of what they’re about. That’s exactly it. That’s exactly what you should do. The vows must be lived within ourselves. And then here obviously we are all trying to generate bodhicitta.

We don’t have bodhicitta. But if we practice the sevenfold causal means of generating bodhicitta or the equalization, the interchange of self and others, we will get a feeling. That’s a very powerful experience. It doesn’t last, but it’s a feeling of what bodhicitta might be like. And then our goal is to stretch, to expand that feeling.

Eventually, is present with us all the time while we are awake and asleep. Then at present we are not there. But we train in the vows. We are not able to perform the perfections of generosity and so forth, but we train in them at present. We train in practicing generosity with small things like money, which is not important, basically, So that eventually we can practice the great deeds of the perfection of generosity, such as giving one’s hand, giving one’s head, giving one’s leg.

But there there are I met or I knew of Tibetans who had reached that level. Not famous or great lamas. I remember we had in the monastery a leprous beggar from India. Quite a surprising man. So he always recited manis to get donations because if you recite manis, the Tibetan grandees, they always give you something extra.

Know? If you don’t recite manis, get a bit. But if you recite mantras, I think you get twice as much. You know? So he always recited mantras.

And there was this young monk from Tibet. He didn’t stay long at the monastery. He was a very, very good monk, in his twenties. And this beggar had lost both eyes. And the monk asked the doctor if it was possible to transplant the cornea from one of his eyes to the beggars and give it to the beggar.

He said he’d be willing to do so. And the doctor said, no. There’s no benefit. He suffers from macular degeneration macular degeneration. Then that monk seemed to be practicing generosity at that level.

That’s quite remarkable. And then, and I saw this with my own eyes, the beggar was leprous. Right? So he had there were no fingers left and there were no toes. You know?

So walking is complicated. You have to need a helper and he was blind. Then he started to see shapes. He was in his late sixties, early seventies. Then colors, and then he saw just fine and he left the monastery.

That happened when I was there. And that’s with the blessing of reciting the mantras. Right? So these things happened. I mean that happened in 2004.

It’s not that long ago. If we have faith, a lot is possible. And without faith nothing happens. More questions? Sorry, this is probably a bit basic but just to check.

So you can be a Bodhisattva and not a Buddhist? No. But, to exterior, we have what are called the Bodhisattvas of the exterior. They are within themselves Buddhist but formally, in public, they practice another religion for the sake of others. That is not their inner practice.

Bodhisattvas the whole function of bodhisattvas is to help others. Then, not all beings are helped by Buddhist teachings. So the bodhisattva teaches what helps that being. For some beings, believing in God is far more helpful. I’d say, if you look at the world population, the majority of religious people in the world are or benefit more from teachings regarding God than teachings regarding Buddhism.

There are approximately 1,000,000,000 Christians and 1,000,000,000 Muslims in the world, that’s 2,000,000,000 people, who share the same core beliefs regarding God. Not in the details but the core. Buddhists are two to 300,000,000 to the maximum. Clearly Buddhism is not of benefit to 2,000,000,000 people. Then a bodhisattva is not going to teach something which is useless to these people.

He will teach something which is useful and the belief in God is very useful. Very useful because in dependence on this belief, one can found the practice of ethics. And then, certainly in Christianity, one can found the practice of compassion and love. And that’s of great benefit. Then it’s always been a lingering doubt, for instance, what the inner beliefs of Jesus, the rabbi, Yeshu HaNatzri, Jesus of Nazareth.

What his inner beliefs were, we don’t know. His outer beliefs, what he taught in public, was belief in a God who was a Father and a Heaven and so forth, that was of tremendous benefit. What he actually thought, we don’t know. And if you look at the great benefit for mankind, then you might wonder what his inner belief saw. But we don’t know for sure.

Gandhi is the same thing. His voice of Dalai Lama has said that Gandhi is his teacher. Then then that implies that Gandhi must have been a very exalted being. So publicly, Gandhi was a Hindu. Gandhi taught belief in the karma and Krishna But what Gandhi’s innermost belief was only Gandhi knows.

We don’t know. So with Bodhisattvas, the focus shifts on helping others by any means suitable. There’s a verse of Nāgārjuna in the Ratnāvali which is very important. In which Nāgārjuna contrasts eternalism and nihilism and says eternalism is a right view and nihilism is a wrong view. It’s a very important verse.

Clearly, from a Buddhist standpoint, there are major philosophical objections to the existence of God. But on the basis of the existence of God or a creator, which is a belief shared by the three monotheistic religions, most of the Hindu schools, it is possible to ground ethics and in some cases a practice of love and compassion. On the basis of nihilism it is not possible to ground anything. If you take the extreme forms of nihilism like communism, you cannot ground anything and you end with monstrosities. Do you have other questions?

I do have one one more. Sorry. Perhaps. Perhaps. Or somebody else should take it.

Does someone else have a question? Yes, Grant. Yes. Just hang on. On.

Yes, Yes. Yes. That’s one of the most helpful instructions I think one can receive. It’s just it’s immediately for practice. When you’re in a group of people, be careful of what you say.

Because it is through speech that in a group of people one will accumulate non virtue. Then when one is alone, pay heed or be careful of what one thinks. Because it’s one’s thoughts at that point through which one will accumulate non virtue. Ilya, I missed 13. If you could give some explanation of that one.

So I would suggest that we take Ngawang Peldan’s commentary because this really should be your reference for understanding the Bodhisattva vows. And on page six, Ngawang Peldan says, this downfall is causing a person who is training correctly in the ethics of individual liberation of Vinaya to relinquish those precepts. So, saying what is the point of Vinaya, in other words ordination, monastic ordination. After generating bodhicitta, you will enter the great vehicle and will purify all faulty behavior of the three doors. So, what is Ngawang Peldan saying?

What is the key? When we speak of the Lamrim, what is the key to the Lamrim? The the the foundation, the very essence. Before Je Tsongkhapa’s time, was this huge collection of sutras. You know, it was very difficult to structure.

And Je Tsongkhapa, relying on Atisha, structured this. What was the key to that structure? There was one point. Yes, yes. But what underlies the idea of a graduated path?

That’s exactly it. Yes, but why? No, no, no. If you have a graduated path, what does that mean? Sequential.

Yes, in other words? One thing leads on to another. Yes. In a nutshell, what’s the goal? In the Mahāyāna, the goal is to help others.

People are different. That’s the core understanding which underlies the Lamrim. People are fundamentally different. As people are fundamentally different, you must teach them differently. What works for A does not work for B.

One digests milk the other cannot stand it. So, teachings are adapted to the individual. There is no best teaching. There is no teaching for everybody. For some it is a pure land.

For some it’ll be the Geluk tradition. For some the Sakya, the Nyingma, the Kagyu tradition. For some the Theravada. So what Je Tsongkhapa did was understanding that the trainees, if you wish, the technical terms, the intended trainees are different. He classified the Buddha’s teachings in terms of the recipient.

Now, in that case, you understand the meaning of the thirteenth bodhisattva vow. For someone who is an intended trainee of the Hīnayāna, who is therefore ordained, is practicing the Vinaya and focusing on meditation the selflessness of persons, if a bodhisattva tries to force that trainee into the Mahāyāna path, it is a breach of root bodhisattva vows. It’s a very profound vow. Well, it wouldn’t be a breach of bodhisattva vows I suppose but it hinges on a very Buddhist concept, the notion of skillful means. To help someone, one must talk to the person.

To talk to the person, one must know the person, if possible, from inside. And the only way to truly know the person from inside is actually telepathy. Through telepathy one knows the inner disposition of the person and then one is able to teach what is truly of benefit to the person themselves. And that is why Atisha said that the beginning or the first skill, if you wish, a teacher has to acquire is calm abiding. Independence or calm abiding, one gains the paranormal powers, the most important of which is telepathy.

Through telepathy, one understands that and others, obviously, but telepathy, one understands the inner disposition of the student. And then the teachings which are given, they impact directly the student’s mind. Otherwise it’s very general. In this room for instance I think most of you are Buddhists. Then how many are beings of the small, the middling and the great scope?

I don’t know. If you give a teaching of the great scope to someone who, by inner sensitivity, is a being of the small scope, there is no benefit. There is perhaps benefit in the future, but right now there is no benefit to that person. So instead one has to target the teachings and that’s why bodhisattvas try to gain these paranormal powers as quickly as possible. Is that why the emphasis on guru devotion and the importance of having that root guru?

That’s exactly it. If one has chosen one’s spiritual teacher well, then that teacher is able, either through having developed calm abiding or through a profound experience of human beings, to target the teachings to the mind of the person. And that’s why at the end of the Avalokiteśvara initiation, if you remember, you know, all those who took the initiation had to recite, I will practice as you said. Because at that point, one becomes the student of the teacher. Now, if one does not practice as a teacher says, then that relationship is meaningless.

The whole point of the relationship is just to practice as this very skilled and experienced master instructs one to do. And that is to practice typically in keeping with one’s disposition and being stretched a little bit above that, but not too much. A little bit, just 10% extra. Does that make sense? There’s a very core notion here which underlies the Lamrim.

That’s the idea of the intended trainee. Because if you look at the Buddha’s teachings from the outside, there’s a large amount of apparent contradictions. To some, Buddha taught that the exterior world exists and is composed of indivisible atoms. To others, he taught that the exterior world is purely mental. To others, again, he taught it was a mental imputation.

For some, he taught the attainment of liberation. For others, he taught the attainment of full enlightenment. Then the question which Atisha and Je Tsongkhapa ask is, what or why is this the case? Why is there this huge variety of teachings? Simply because the trainees are different.

Buddha taught for the benefit of a trainee, for the benefit of a person. And then if it benefited the person to believe that the exterior world was real, Buddha taught that the exterior world was real. If they were a more advanced practitioner and it was of benefit to them to view the exterior world as of the nature of the mind, Buddha taught in the Lankāvatārasūtra that the world is of the nature of the mind. And if they were even more advanced, then Buddha taught in the perfection of wisdom Sutras that all phenomena are mere nominal conceptual imputations. So this is why because there’s this wide range of views, we have four schools of tenets Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra and Madhyamaka.

And three types of beings, beings of the small, middling and great scope. You can choose that aspect of Buddhism which is most compatible with yourself and that is the way to practice. The way is not to practice the best with a capital b because it doesn’t work. This is one of the questions I know which irritates His Holiness the Dalai Lama very much. He gets it from Westerners.

What is the best practice? You tend to get a very, very sharp retort if you ask that question. Instead, if one has a spiritual teacher, your teacher will direct you. But I think many of our students actually now don’t have a teacher. Then, more or less we know who we are.

So we should look inside ourselves honestly. Am I a being of this life? I think probably in this room most of our students are formally Buddhists. Most are beings of this life. As the top priority is this life.

Then there’s one set of practices in that case. These are the practices to counter attachment to this life. Most important of these is meditation on death. Death and impermanence. It is what transforms the mind for someone who’s attached to this life.

Once one sees that everything is transitory, that friends, partners, children all die, if they don’t die, they divorce you, if they don’t divorce you, you divorce them. This is the reality. In this room, I think most of you are probably either divorced or separated or something like that. Right? Then many of you have known people who have died, have parents.

In my case, my mother died this year. Then I myself am coming closer to that point, it’s unavoidable. So once you look at life like that, that all your friends and relatives are going to die, that the money which we all strive for so much, we cannot keep. Right? How many people in this room went bankrupt after 2008?

Retired, had to go back to work, lost 40% on the stock market. Now in the last two years, how many of you have lost your houses? Or actually haven’t lost, but have had couldn’t afford to keep it up, had to sell, move to a unit, and sell another unit, move to something smaller. We’re surrounded with these cases. Right?

And this is a reality. When we speak of the sufferings of cyclic existence, it’s this. So meditation on death and impermanence for someone who’s attached to this life will change the mind. And in that change of the mind, is great peace and happiness. And then, one is if one has already turned away from this life, then the next step upwards is realizing that all lives are the same.

That’s quite easy, actually. Once you’ve turned away from this life, to realize that all the life in the future are going to be exactly the same thing is quite straightforward. And then there’s a sense of revulsion towards the whole process, what we call cyclic existence. Then it’s easy to generate liberation. And then, once that sense of the mind striving for liberation for oneself has arisen, there is a switch when I realizes that one is not alone, but everyone is in the same situation and we are all related.

And at that point, it seems deeply shameful, really, to strive for one’s own liberation. Then one strives for something greater than that to help others. But one must work with the level one is at. So the main reason for which our students disconnect is typically because they are practicing at the level which is completely unrelated to where they are. It’s it’s very standard.

Advanced tantric meditations, meditations which are unrelated to their level and then it never impacts the mind. Then, I’m afraid we have to stop here for today. I hope it was of some help. But keep in mind this notion of the fact, it sounds very trite, that people are different. In other words, intended trainees are different.

And as a result, what benefits each one of us is different. There is no point in asking your friend after they have seen your teacher, so what did he tell you to practice? It’s of no benefit to you. To even it’s of no benefit to know because that person is different from yourself. Excellent.

Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
individual liberation
The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
yana
Literally, vehicle; a spiritual path that leads to an awakened state. The vehicle and spiritual journey depends on the attitude of the practitioner. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top