Puja

1 h 40 min · 4,353 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Puja (Khensur Rinpoche)
Puja (Khensur Rinpoche)
Puja
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 100-minute teaching, HH Dalai Lama leads an interactive Q&A session on emptiness, the central antidote to ignorance in Buddhist practice. Rather than presenting material, he interrogates experienced practitioners on their understanding of how the lack of inherent existence of the self directly opposes the grasping mind. The session moves from foundational definitions—empty of inherent existence, dependent designation as the middle way—through the crucial distinction between eliminating ignorance about tables versus the self. Dalai Lama emphasizes that emptiness of the self is what counters afflictions; introduces the relationship between selflessness of persons and emptiness of mind as one nature but different isolates; and explains why inferential realization alone cannot serve as a stable antidote—only an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight can eliminate ignorance. Concrete examples (Australian dollars, real versus counterfeit bills) illustrate the principle that valid bases must perform their function. A closing exchange covers samadhi versus śamatha, Buddha nature, Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view versus lower schools, and a preview of His Holiness’s upcoming visit to Adelaide after twenty-five years. Aimed at committed Dharma students.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 09082016Salam 2 – KR.mp3

UUID: 2c5d9587-f410-42b6-a324-95f20a9fc493

Teacher: HH Dalai Lama

Collection: Puja

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,350

And as always, you’re possible. As Tsongkhapa says in his Praise of Dependent Origination, is a praise of Buddha Śākyamūni for having taught Dependent Origination, I praise thee for having taught the way things are. And this refers to a praise of dependent origination in the extensive middling and short perfection of wisdom sutras. In addition, whatever Buddha Śākyamūni taught, he taught to enable one to attain liberation. It was not taught for just whatsoever reason.

Moreover, as Āryadeva says in his 400 verses of Chatuhshataka, for so long as one has not dependent understood dependent origination, for so long will one not have severed ignorance. In other words, for so long one has not gained realization of emptiness, for so long will one not eliminate ignorance. In addition, as Tsongkhapa says in the Praise of Dependent Origination, moreover, whatever teachings you imparted, you imparted to enable one to attain liberation. In other words, whatever Buddha taught was taught to enable us to attain liberation. So, the topic of emptiness is one which is central to grounds and paths.

It is basically what underlies the presentation of the five paths into 10 grounds. The 10 grounds are specific to a Mahāyāna present presentation of grounds and paths. And here, one must gain realization of emptiness at the very least. One must gain an understanding of emptiness which is a wisdom based on hearing. It is even better naturally if one is able to generate a valid cognizer realizing emptiness in dependence on a wisdom arisen from thinking.

But in either case, one must meditate on emptiness. So you have received numerous teachings on emptiness and therefore I’m not quite sure what benefit there is in my presenting the topic again to you. I think it would be much more beneficial if I were to interrogate you on the topic. Generally speaking, regarding emptiness, emptiness is only spoken of within the two higher schools of tenets. In other words, Cittamātra and Mādhyamika, and there is no substantial difference in the presentation of emptiness within the two main schools of Cittamātra, the true and false aspectarians.

There is indeed a difference of presentation between Svatāntrika Mādhyamika and Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, we should not enter into that because it will make us all dizzy. I would like us to focus on the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view irrespective of whether you like this view or not since it is at the end of the day the view one must realize. So, I don’t care what you think or what you want, it’s a matter of focus. So basically what we need in the context of grounds and paths is a Prāsaṇgika view of emptiness and therefore I’d like to ask you, but I’d like short clear answers. What is your understanding of emptiness?

So, give me the mode of assertion of emptiness in and an example. So empty of inherent existence and an example may be the emptiness of a pot. And another. Ratnasambhava Madhyamaka. Mhmm.

And I’m just trying to recall a quote. Whatever is dependently co-arisen, that is explained as emptiness that being a dependent designation is itself the middle way. And what is the last part of the quote you want to give? That being a dependent designation is itself the middle way. It’s a quote, is it?

From where? From Nāgārjuna. His His Holiness suggested there are two two verses to remember. As with everyone else, it’s empty of inherent existence and I’m thinking an example might be that I see myself as being independent. An example of what?

Of as in that the inherent existence is I believe myself to be an an independent sort of entity when I’m not. Emptiness is dependent arising, an example of which An example of which being that the mere merely imputed eye only arises in dependence upon its base. A mere imputation by mind as the assertion and the merely labeled eye as an example. So, who are we? We are beings who are striving for liberation.

What do we therefore need to attain liberation? What is that which must be abandoned or to be precise countered when we strive for liberation? The ignorance which grasps at true existence. Now, are numerous different true existences that ignorance can grasp at. The true existence of the table, the vase, the temple.

But these are broadly speaking irrelevant to us. What matters is the true existence of the I or the self, and to eliminate the ignorance which grasps the true existence of the I or the self, we need a powerful antidote which opposes it. So we need to eliminate that root of anger, of envy, and of jealousy. And the root of these is ignorance grasping at a self, at an I. Now, when we eliminate the ignorance grasping at the existence of the table and so forth, whether that affects desire, jealousy and envy or so forth, honestly, I don’t know.

So the reason for which we refer to the lack of true existence of the table, of the cup, and so forth is just in terms of examples. What we need is to eliminate the ignorance grasping at the inherent existence or true existence of the I. And for this, we need the direct antidote to this that which is directly contradictory to it. What is that? The wisdom which realizes the absence of inherent existence of the I.

So if you try to realize emptiness on the basis of a table and so forth, it will be rather difficult. The ancient pundits of India always ascertained emptiness on the basis of the eye of the self since it is the eye of the self which we experience, which walks, which functions in daily life. So, therefore, when we try to understand the mode of existence of the eye, as you said, it is the eye being empty of inherent existence. This emptiness of inherent existence of the eye is the emptiness of the eye and that is the antidote to the ignorance grasping at the inherent existence of the I. So when one endeavors to ascertain selflessness in the two higher schools of tenets, one ascertains initially the selflessness of persons, and specifically the subtle selflessness of persons.

And in Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, this is just the I being empty of being inherently established. And therefore, when one is asked what the emptiness of a person is in Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, one should give a pure and clear answer. It is the person’s not being established from its own side. This is the most beneficial. Or the person not being inherently established, not being established by its own characteristics.

And therefore, ascertaining that the I is not established from its own side or is not truly established is what is truly beneficial in eliminating this ignorance which grasps at a self. There is no obvious benefit in eliminating this ignorance when one ascertains that the table for instance is not established from its own side. There are numerous different presentations of the I, both in non-Buddhist and Buddhist schools of tenets. These presentations are subtle and difficult, and for this reason there is great benefit and great importance in presenting the mode of existence of the I. So is that clear now?

The nonexistence of the eye from its own side? So once one has understood this non establishment of the I from its own side, then it is very important to understand the manner in which this realization of the non existence of the eye from its own side acts as an antidote to the ignorance grasping at the inherent existence of the I. How does this operate? Now this one should understand in keeping with the great treatises. So how does the realization of the non existence of the eye from its own side act as an antidote to the ignorance grasping at an I?

That’s the question I ask. So when one reflects on the view, this is how one should proceed. So I am in no way claiming I have any experience of this, but this is how the holy beings have proceeded, and this is how one should proceed. Actually, think if one does not proceed in this way, one does not gain results, but if one does proceed in this way, one definitely does gain results. Okay.

So the wisdom which realizes that the I is not established from its own side acts how or in which way as an antidote to the ignorance grasping at the self. Like hot and cold water. So if you have cold water and you put hot water in, it changes the temperature of the water so that there’s only hot water left. So you’re saying that when I pour cold water in hot water, it doesn’t turn cold too? Just an example, but the meaning isn’t there.

So Sorry, Helio. Could you repeat the question? So Geshe-la’s question is, how does the wisdom which realizes the non existence of the eye from its own side act as an antidote to the ignorance grasping at an I? I’m just thinking that as the wisdom increases, the ignorance decreases. There is no self grasping, therefore there is no karma that can be produced.

You’re giving examples. What’s the meaning? Give the meaning. Give the meaning. Yeah.

Please. So what you have to understand is that the ignorance grasping at the self and the wisdom which realizes the non existence from its own side of the self are focused on exactly the same object, the self or the I. The object is the same. But the mode of apprehension, or if you wish, the mode of thinking are exactly contradictory. As a result, they are contradictory.

This is what you have to understand. I would suggest that you repeat it verbally. So these two modes of apprehension are directly opposite. They are contradictory. Therefore, the ignorance which apprehends the self and the wisdom which realizes non existence of the self from its own side are said to be incompatible which cannot dwell or exist simultaneously.

What that means is that when the one increases, the other decreases and reciprocally. It is akin this is an example. It is not the meaning of light in this temple. When the light is on, then there is no obscurity, no darkness to be seen. So at present, due to very powerful habituation, the most powerful force within our mind stream is ignorance grasping at a self or at an eye.

And apart from a verbal statement of the eyes not existing from its own side, we have no understanding or realization of this. So here, the ignorance which grasps at a self is therefore the ignorance which apprehends the self as being established from its own side. The wisdom which realizes that the self is not established from its own side is its direct opposite. Now, this ignorance which apprehends the self as being established from its own side is not supported by a valid cognizer. In other words, it actually does not exist.

That object, the self being established from its own side does not exist. On the other hand, the self not being established from its own side is supported by a valid cognizer. In other words, it exists. And therefore, the more we reflect on the fact that the eye is not established from its own side, that the eye is not established from the side of the aggregates, the more it becomes clear that the I is not established from the side of the aggregates, but that it is a mere mental imputation on the basis of the aggregates. Now, these schools of tenets from Svatāntrika Mādhyamika downwards all assert that the I is established from its own side.

In other words, that the I exists within the aggregates or if you prefer that when one searches for the I within the aggregates, the I is findable. Now Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika asserts that the I is not findable under analytical investigation in the aggregates. Asserts that the eye is unfindable within the aggregates. It is unfindable under analysis with the aggregates. It is unfindable because it is a mere imputation on the basis of the aggregates.

Now let’s take an example. Let’s take the example of 100 Australian dollars. 100 Australian dollars are not findable under analysis when it investigates. Yet, that in no way precludes 100 Australian dollars from being able to perform their function as money. These two coexist with each other.

So, $100 are therefore not established from their own side. They are a mere conceptual imputation. Now, if they were established from their own side, what would this mean? This would mean that the rectangle, the rectangular $100 bill is actually established from the beginning as a rectangular $100 bill, which it is obviously not. It rises in dependence on numerous conditions.

How is it? So it is difficult to understand the view, but this is how one has to proceed through personal analysis. And then once one gains understanding by means of a valid cognizer, then one’s outlook changes completely. That’s here. Exactly.

Then if we take a true $100 bill and a fake bill, they are both mere imputations. So what’s the difference? Both the true and the counterfeit $100 bill are mere nominal imputations. The true $100 bill can perform the function of a $100 bill. The fake or the counterfeit $100 bill does not have precisely the design of a true $100 bill and cannot perform the function of a $100 bill.

Now, even though phenomena do appear to be established from their own side, nonetheless, they do not exist or dwell as being established from their own side. And it is similar in another sense to the example I gave of counterfeit money. Counterfeit money seems to be real money. Often very good counterfeit bills seems to be exactly as real money, but they cannot perform the function of real money. Your weakness is that you rely exclusively on examples.

You should first rely on the meaning, understand the meaning, and then use the example to illustrate the meaning. And not instead rely on an example without understanding the meaning. So once you have understood the meaning, you use the example to illustrate the meaning. So after ascertaining the selflessness of persons on the basis of the I, we then are led to understanding emptiness on the basis of the mind. In as much as if there were no person, there would be no mind or no consciousness, and if there were no consciousness, there would be no person.

Mind or consciousness and person are of one nature, but of different isolates. And therefore, an understanding of the selflessness of persons leads one to an understanding of the emptiness of the mind. So if you try to assert that the I and consciousness are one, then there are numerous refutations of this in Buddhist scriptures. On the other hand, they are closely related and it is very helpful to see them as being of one nature and of different isolates. Now you do understand what the eye is.

The eye is what performs the various activities. The eye is not the body naturally. So setting ourselves from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the lowest schools of tenets, means from Svatāntrika Mādhyamika downwards, all consider the I to be the mental consciousness. This is a viewpoint which is completely rejected in Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika for which the I and the mental consciousness are of one nature, but different isolates in the sort of same way as when we speak in Cittamātra of the emptiness of form and the valid cognizer apprehending form being of different being different substances, actually form and the valid cognizer apprehending form are of one nature, but different isolates. So, it is on the basis of the realization of the emptiness of the I or the person that one gains a realization of the emptiness of mind.

And this is critically important since actually the emptiness of mind is the Buddha lineage, which is called in some traditions the Buddha nature. There is no other Buddha lineage apart from this. Now, would be very odd if one initially gained a realization of the emptiness of the person and then subsequently gained a realization of the emptiness of mind. Instead, the emptiness of the person and that of mind are of one nature but different isolates. So, I would like to point out here that if one understands this relationship between the selflessness of persons of the I and the selflessness of consciousness, then one finds within one’s own self that which is able to lead to liberation or to the truth of cessation, which is the ngang tshul in Tibetan.

So it is critical to identify this. In other words, the lineage, the nature lineage. So if one proceeds in this way, then one’s understanding of emptiness will become stable. So the initial realization by means of a valid cognizer of emptiness will necessarily be a realization by means of an inferential valid cognizer. Can such a mind act as an antidote to the ignorance grasping at the self?

No. Because such a mind is a mind of the desire realm. And the mind of the desire realm is unstable. All of us are similar in this respect. Our minds of the desire realm are unstable.

But what do we need as an antidote to the ignorance grasping at a self? We need a stable mind. So how and where does one generate this stable mind? Ultimately, it is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight which arises at the level of the path of preparation. But for this, one must have initially attained a calm abiding focused on emptiness and an insight focused on emptiness.

So to eliminate the ignorance grasping at a self, we therefore need a stable mind which acts as an antidote against that ignorance, not a mind which is occasionally present and occasionally not present. In other words, a mind grounded in calm abiding at the very least. As Tsongkhapa says in his Three Principal Aspects of the Path, once definite emergence arises day and night without effort at that point, it will have been well generated. So here, there is an important point which must be a food for thought for us. There is a distinction between the disciples of sharp and of dull acumen at the point of the first generation of an inseparable union of calm abiding and emptiness focus of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness.

A disciple of sharp acumen at that point will cause the grasping at the true existence of the self to become non manifest. And all of the afflictions will be eliminated. However, a disciple of dull acumen will only be able to eliminate all afflictions at the level of the eighth ground. So let us now meditate during a couple minutes on the I and its emptiness. There’s no particular benefit in meditating on the emptiness of this table, the temple, and so forth.

And here, the way to proceed is to be aware first that the I exists, and secondly, that under investigation it is unfindable. Mhmm. Over to puja book, page one. We recite one, two, three, four, and page five. Number six, mandala offering.

Verse one and three. Within our mind stream, we therefore have that which becomes the noble noble truth of cessation. This is none other than what is called the Buddha lineage or the Buddha nature in other traditions. It is the vastness or the emptiness of mind. Now, once one meditates on the emptiness of the self, then this emptiness of the self or the realization of this emptiness of the self gives rise to the realization of the emptiness of mind.

And this is a case because the bases are the same. And if you have questions, ask your questions. Please concise questions. Geshe la referred to being able to perform a function before the the real $100 bill. What’s the importance of being able to perform a function?

So $100 bills are mere imputations. Does the fact that the $100 bill is a mere imputation suffice to make it a $100 bill? No. Because there are $100,100 dollar bills which are also mere in mental imputations. So an example to be similar would be yourself, Jampa Chöpel.

Jampa Chöpel is a mere nominal imputation on the basis of the aggregates of Jampa Chöpel. Is that sufficient to define Jampa Chöpel? No. Jampa Chöpel must be able to perform the function of Jampa Chöpel. Mhmm.

A counterfeit $100 bill is an example of is an example of a phenomenon which is established by its own characteristics. Even though it seems to be established by its own characteristics, it is actually not established by its own characteristics. So a counterfeit $100 bill looks like a real $100 bill. Is it able to perform the function of a real $100 bill? It can’t, even though it seems that it should.

Okay. Another questions. Questions from previous weeks. I’ve read the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali and I wanted to understand the distinction or boundary between Samādhi and śamatha. So all calm abidings are samadhis.

All samadhis are not calm abidings. For instance, when you realize calm abiding by means of the nine mental abidings, each one of those mental abidings is a samadhi, but none of them is calm abiding. The mode of realization of calm abiding of the non-Buddhist Indian yogis and that of the Buddhist Indian yogis is exactly identical. There is no difference. Not one iota of difference.

Mhmm. Went. Can Geshe-la please explain again Buddha what Buddha nature is? Is it the liberated mind? So in Buddhist scriptures, there are two aspects of Buddha lineage or Buddha nature.

Since one is an impermanent aspect, is mind, and the other is the emptiness of mind, and that is permanent. I think rough. No. There is a big difference between being established from its own side and what you refer to, which is basically the meaning of reflexive consciousness. They’re two completely different things.

When one speaks of phenomena being established from their own side, one has to distinguish between Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika and all the lower schools of tenets. So for all the lower schools of tenets, phenomena are established from their own side. And what is meant by this is that when one seeks for phenomenon such as the I, they are findable under analysis. Whereas for Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, phenomena are said not to be established from their own side because when they are sought, they are unfindable. So in Svatāntrika Mādhyamika, before the object is apprehended by the mind, cannot say that it is established by its own characteristics or from its own side.

You cannot say. Yes. You’re saying that such a mind is a reflexive consciousness because it understands itself. That’s the understanding of reflexive consciousness in the lower schools of tenets. And?

Geshe la, from the Prāsaṇgika point of view, must every valid base necessarily be for any objects, must the valid base of that object necessarily perform the function of that object? What what’s a valid base? So so you have valid base and invalid base. So we’re talking about the the counterfeit. You’re speaking of the base of designation?

Yes. Could you repeat your question then using the term base of designation? So must every valid base of designation necessarily perform the object perform the function of that object? Yes. The designation of valid and invalid bases exists then a valid base is a base on which it is appropriate to designate a person.

From previous weeks, what is the distinction between the mind basis of all, fundamental mind and clear light mind and are any of these equivalent to Turiya in the Hindu tradition? Turiya. In Sanskrit, Turia. Yeah. The fourth state.

So there’s waking, sleeping, dreaming and then Turia which is meant to be the fourth state, pure consciousness. What is the third state? First state waking, second state dream? So there is a reference in Buddhist scriptures to four states of mind and the fourth state of mind is the mind of clear light. So in Cittamātra, the Alaya Vijñāna is referred to as a mind.

This term is not used as far as the mind of clear light is concerned. One final very short question. Earlier you were referring to person, mind, consciousness being of the same nature but different isolates. When you say of the same nature, do you mean being in the nature of not being established from their own side? Not being established from their own side.

Yeah. So being of one nature in different isolates is totally unrelated to being established on its own side. The nature you’re referring to when you say of one nature. The meaning here is that apart from the mind, there is no consciousness. Apart from the consciousness, there is no mind.

Excuse me. Apart from the I, there is no consciousness. Apart from the consciousness, there is no I. Then we shall stop you for today. We send email but it looks like some people got it, some people don’t.

So if you haven’t received it, it’s a bit funny because we just attach and subject is wow, wonderful news and it looks like a scam. So many people maybe not open. Please open the attachment and it explains everything. The news that we share is we receive confirmation from his holiness represent and that he’s going to come to Adelaide, what a lucky occasion after twenty five years. This is his third time.

And so we are very honored and to hosting, you know, the he’s visiting here in South Australia. So please make sure share that other look at the email. Thank you. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is the distinction or boundary between samadhi and shamatha (calm abiding), for someone who has read Patanjali's Yoga Sutras?

All calm abidings are samadhis, but not all samadhis are calm abidings. For instance, when calm abiding is realized by means of the nine mental abidings, each of those mental abidings is a samadhi, but none of them is calm abiding. The mode of realizing calm abiding is exactly the same for non-Buddhist Indian yogis and Buddhist Indian yogis. There is no difference, "not one iota of difference."

Scroll to Top