1 h 16 min · 10,778 words · 3 October 2010
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A speaker, presenting in a public setting, describes their academic work bringing Western critical social theory into dialogue with Buddhism, centred on the idea of awakening struggle and the ethical-political life. Key themes include the Frankfurt School, power and knowledge, poverty and karma, and anger in social justice activism, with reference to Santideva’s Bodhicaryavatara and Lamrim. Some autobiography is included, and the talk ends with a lunch break.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 16m
UUID: 6a2eca34-a2f9-454b-9e64-a81af47c0748
Date: 2010-10-03
Words: 10,774
I’ve found myself having to write and present occasionally out of my sort of Western discourses and putting together some Buddhist ones. And I know how you sort of understand. Whenever I read Buddhist texts, always start with a homage. So when I go out and do my Buddhism in public, then I tend to try and start with a homage. I just think that’s sort of appropriate anyway.
Sorry for the funny little beginning. Just to begin with a few cartoons to set the scene. Don’t know, Being in Australia, there’s Leunig, isn’t there? Leunig’s sort of interesting. I think Leunig does the sort of secular religious thing quite well, probably drawing fairly heavily on his religiosity, actually, which makes him incredibly I don’t know, he gets ideas that other cartoonists don’t.
So here’s the philosopher at work, which sometimes reminds me of me sitting in my office at home. Here was a cartoon that some friends of mine gave me when I was studying a master’s degree, because they thought that’s what I was starting to sound like. The last diatribe of the Serengeti. So you’d be familiar with this one, Pamela. So you start to investigate sets of ideas, taking them seriously, and you start sounding very complicated, and then your friends can no longer understand you.
Hopefully that’s not going to happen today, but I’m sure that it will. But anyway, do our best. It’s one of the things that happens when you get serious about being a scholar. You tend to be reading yourself away from everybody. All these people that were intimate to begin with.
I guess you’re reading yourself towards others. It’s sort of difficult being a reader or trying to be a scholar. Another Leunig that I quite like seems to have been capturing the mood of the present. We’re heading off towards being quite mad. There’s the odd individual that’s sort of looking for some other.
I’m hoping that I’m sort of on the back of someone looking for something else. But then again, of course, madness is sort of interesting, isn’t it? Perhaps some forms of madness I’m really after myself. But anyway. And so the my presentations on Buddhism education and society.
I think worked out that I worked in a school of education. And in our emailing to changes, he suggested that I do something on Buddhism and education. But education as a sort of field of endeavor doesn’t really make any sense to me anyway unless they put society there. I got back to earlier and said, would you mind if I sort of put society in there? So in my more recent work, I’ve been trying to think through the relationships between education and society, whatever society might be.
Don’t know. Margaret Thatcher said that she didn’t believe in society. So the idea of society is quite it’s difficult. As I say, some people say they don’t But then how could you be the prime minister of a country and not believe in society? Anyway, we won’t go to Margaret Thatcher.
Just sort of a few moves in my presentation. Perhaps just to go back a bit, though. So far I think we’ve been hearing from people who’ve been doing conversations between Buddhism and the sciences, broadly speaking, particularly the physical and the biological sciences. Working in a field of education, it’s out of the humanities or the social sciences. So my presentation is going to shift mode a bit.
I’m really interested in the relationships between Buddhism and the social sciences. And that’s sort of a completely different set of ideas. Just to connect up with some of the previous speakers, I thought Ilya’s presentation actually was more a presentation and drawing on Western sociology to make sense of the present than Buddhism actually. So the first speaker was drawing on Western social science. And then various other speakers during the day, I think yesterday, were also drawing on understandings of society and knowledge that the West has actually developed that I think are quite useful for us.
I really did enjoy Ilya’s Buddhist rendering of Weber. Can you do Mark sometime? I’d really like to Oh, you’ve done Mark. Can you do it again? So I was sort of taking, know, Tenzin’s initial invite around has Buddhism affected me and my work.
My presentation will have some autobiographical stuff, so I’ll be presenting myself. But then shuttling around with some other theoretical ideas as well. So I’ll introduce myself briefly and then spend a bit of time talking about my thesis, which I called Awakening Struggle. The term Awakening Struggle is my attempt to think through how Western critical social theory and Buddhism might be able to be understood as sort of a dialogic space between them. So the word awakening derives from the Buddhist tradition.
And struggle derives out of Western critical theory, I think, struggling for more justice, more social justice. How might we understand a project that’s on about awakening and struggle? That’s what I was trying to think through. And then what’s all that got to do with education? Given that I’m an educator, then obviously I’m needing to think that through.
And then briefly I’ll just talk about some stuff that I’ve been doing in the last five years, some of my recent research. So a short autobiographical statement. I grew up in a little country town about 50 miles from here, Murray Bridge. Know, Okaboy, meat and three veg. Mum took me off to church, sent me to Sunday school.
I stayed at Sunday school until I was 13 because I fell in love with Jenny van Darling. She didn’t know that. I think that by the time I was 13, I realized that what was on offer from the Christian tradition that were in my town, that my mother wanted me to engage with, didn’t really relate to my life at all actually. You went there, you sung some hymns, you did bible study which was really about learning dogma. And there was no way that the dogma connected up with the problems that I was having in grade six.
So I just found it fairly empty experience, empty rituals that really weren’t connecting. I certainly had very few mystical experiences in church apart from my mom used to go to church on Sunday nights. And it’s odd, really, but I used to like standing next to her when she sang. My mother had an amazing voice, and so you’d stand there and your whole body would sort of quiver when mom was singing. So that was the mystical experience of church, but eventually I stopped going to Sunday school or church.
You’re making these decisions when you’re quite young, aren’t you? Even when you’re 13, you can work these things out. Then there was nothing really, apart from learning how to drink alcohol and smoke dope and try and fall in love with girls. Then I went off to university and did a science degree. I majored in biochemistry and organic chemistry.
And my family were relatively poor. It wasn’t possible to go to university then unless you got a scholarship of one kind or another. And around that time, you got a teaching scholarship. So you went off to uni, and you promised that you would teach for three years. And so I did a science degree.
And then I did a one year graduate education qualification. My science education was truly appalling, I have to say. I think I left my science degree being pretty much illiterate. The experience of learning in the universities meant going to 10 lectures a week, in which case you started off every sentence with a dash and then wrote as quickly as you could. So you never actually learn how to write a proper sentence.
Actually, learn how not to. And the exams were either short answer or so you never actually wrote anything. You never got an opportunity to really share your understandings of what you were learning apart from multiple choice exams. Anyway, of course, this is the end of the sort of hippie era, so I really got into that, I have to say. Think I’m still an unreconstructed hippie.
The hair’s a lot shorter, but internally there’s a lot of the values that I learned in that period. So you’re studying science. In the meantime, there’s a lot of social ferment going on outside. So you’re sort of trying to engage with all of that. You’re reading one strand of material outside and being bored shitless inside a science degree, which didn’t seem to sort of connect.
Apart from we had one really fantastic biochemistry lecturer who would run from his laboratory to the first year lecture, present the lecture, which was biochemistry was a field that was just opening up at that period. So you’re doing prokaryotic gene control or eukaryotic gene. Prokaryotes are bacteria and eukaryotes are organisms like us. We’re just learning about gene control in this period. So you sort of come out of some of the lectures going, woah, isn’t that unbelievably amazing?
The sort of complexity of the way that the gene’s working. And you worked out that there was no way that science was ever going to work at all out, actually, the complexity of the biology. And so more recently, one guffaws when you listen to the radio when people are talking about mapping the genome and all of a sudden we’ve unlocked it all. You’re coughing into your muesli. For some reason or another, I was living in a shared house.
And one of the people I shared house with left this book Autobiography of a Yogi in the lounge room. I sort of read that, which completely counter to my previous twenty years. For some reason or another, just had this unbelievable desire to learn how to meditate. I just cannot explain where that sort of came from. I’m the ochre boy.
Really, you can’t believe how ochre I was. And then at that point in Adelaide, anyway, I started to fantasize about going to America because the guy who wrote the book was still alive and it was possible to meet up with him and learn. That became a silly sort of fantasy. There was TM, the Hari’s, and a few other groups. So TM looked like the one that I could go with.
I bought the mantra. When you’re a student, it was only one week. It was one week salary. So my salary was only $35, so I bought my mantra for $35. But I I I think I meditated for fourteen years, 10 times a week, TM.
I really, really had to sit. If I didn’t sit, sort I’m of lockupable. So I convinced all of my friends to learn, to meditate. All went Noah went off. So I can still remember one Friday night, you know, 10 of us sitting in my lounge room, my partner and so on, we’d all sit, and then we’d get stoned.
That’s how all this comes together, doesn’t But can you imagine that? Great advice. So during that period, I went and taught maths and science in high school for fifteen years. During that time, I got really interested in social justice. And I guess the way that presents itself to you in everyday life anyway is there’s the two kids in the class that you just don’t connect with.
And some of them have got troubled lives or whatever. So what does the teacher do about that, about those kids? What do you do? The way that schooling is set up was really, really set up to sort of exclude them actually. The way the assessment works and the way that teaching works, the way the curriculum works, the whole system of schooling, is set up, to to, really, really, not connect with them.
Mostly I think when you first start anyway, you sort of naturalize all of that, So the understand way that what’s going on in your classroom is that those kids are just not up for it. So you can let yourself off the hook. You can blame the kids for not being successful in your class. And the more you teach, the more that you get worried about that sort of rationale. That’s all a bit too easy.
And so then I found myself working in a Western Suburbs high school. So this is starting to remind me of my childhood. I mean, I’ve got the working class childhood. You understand what it means not to have very much resources. And then you remember your own history.
You couldn’t even go off to university because your parents didn’t have enough money. Thank God for Whitlam, who makes You know what I mean? So you start to think more systematically rather than just being in the natural of the everyday. Well, it became apparent to me that I needed to be thinking more about society, systems, a more systemic way of thinking. Trying to understand what’s the classic question.
How did things come to be this way in my class? This is not just arising. Even back then, it’s quite clear that our realities are consequence of causes and conditions. So you can go to sociology for some help about that. So I started to be interested in educational researchers that were thinking about that.
Through all that period, I had three kids and a divorce. So by the time I met Khensur Rinpoche, my kids were just about adolescent. So I met Khensur Rinpoche in about 1991. I went and checked my notebooks the other day, I think I’ve still illegally got some of the tapes from the precious garland teachings he gave in 1991. I think that was the first teaching that I took from Khensur Rinpoche, actually, which was pretty extraordinary, really, if you understand the Buddhist canon.
Around that time, it’s quite clear to me that TM’s not enough. And so I had this very, very traumatic time in which I left my TM practice behind and took up Buddhist meditation. Jampa Gendun was incredibly patient and helpful as I was transitioning from something that I really didn’t need. And without my meditation, I’m in really bad shape across to these other forms of meditation. But obviously, in hindsight, of course, TM’s just provides a form of calm abiding meditation.
You’ve just got one object to hold the mind on. It was a sound, a mantra that there’s multiple variations on that theme, obviously. And then I jumped careers and moved across to the university sector as a consequence of doing some study. I found myself working as a research fellow or research assistant, really, well a glorified research assistant working for a neo Marxist professor at Flinders. And that was incredibly interesting.
So I moved from being a classroom teacher to just doing research full time, which was it’s unbelievable to be able to be paid to read and write and to be researching the world. Is I just can’t believe my luck. And then having the opportunity to be mentored by a professor who had a wonderful international reputation, who was a fantastic reader and writer, and trying to get up really, really close to look at how someone does that, that was quite extraordinary. So I’m in the sort of Western University reading Western texts and then I’m studying with Khensur Rinpoche so you’ve got this sort of weird conversation going on inside of my head. And then I completed a PhD, which took the full eight years part time.
And the PhD was really an opportunity to be able to work out this really weird conversation that I was sort of having in my head between the Western social theory and how Buddhism might sort of come together. And then recently I’ve moved across to the University of South Australia. So that’s me, briefly. Now just sort of going back over some of that just in terms of me the teacher. So I guess my sort of most fundamental research question is what does it mean to be a good teacher?
That’s pretty basic, really. So if you are a practicing teacher, that is the question. What does it mean for me to be a good teacher in this place and these times? But more recently, I’ve tried to think that through in more sophisticated ways. So I’ve now got a question, which is what does an ethical political teacher look like in an unjust world is the one that I’m sort of working with now.
I think being good is really about being ethical and political. I can’t sort of disentangle the two actually. Think it’s the French philosopher Derrida who uses the category ethicopolitical. And I’ll explicate that in a little while. Or another version of that question is how does a teacher respond ethicopolitically to the demands of the present?
That seems to me to be, I guess that’s the question. So just keep that question in mind if you get confused about what I’m on about. That’s really my meditation. So another go at my autobiography. When I was in the classroom and for the first part of my career, I was really interested in classroom action research.
And if you’re a practitioner then it’s possible to be doing research on practice. That’s the methodology in my field is called action research or practitioner inquiry. The phenomena being researched is your practice. And so you attempt to systematically examine aspects of your practice using various sort of methods and collecting data about yourself and so on and so forth. And when I went looking for conceptual resources to help me think about the social justice problems that I was having, the literature I read, the key category is critical pedagogy.
The word critical, I’ll elaborate in a little while, just sort of let that hang for a while. Pedagogy word, that’s sort of quite difficult. Perhaps pedagogy can be understood as the art and science of teaching. A more elaborate definition would be pedagogy has got to do with the relationship between the teacher, the student, and the co construction of knowledge. Or more recently, the relationship between the teacher, the student, the co construction of knowledge and identity of both the teacher and the student.
So it’s not only knowledge that’s been co constructed, but one’s identities, one’s sense of self. You’re working on subjectivity itself in the pedagogical relation. And the sort of categories that this literature had at this particular time, I was interested in class and gender. I was really, really interested in poverty actually. The period that this work came from was the end of the disadvantaged schools program, and that was inaugurated by Whitlam in the early 1970s.
It went for about twenty years. The last ten or fifteen years of that project, the whole field of the social sciences got quite confused about class. The category of class became just so complicated. It sort of fell over and and it was just very, very problematic, especially in Australia that doesn’t even believe that we are a class society, but we won’t open that one up. Rather than talk about education and class, we talked about poverty and the relationship and education.
A lot of us were trying to do a lot of thinking about how poverty impacts on schooling. In the literature, there’s reproduction theory, basically says that one of the functions of schooling is to reproduce the status quo which I think that’s quite clear to me the way that the system of schooling works not schools themselves, teacher but schooling as a structured process reproduces already existing social stratification. So if you’re finding yourself being a teacher in a school with a lot of working class kids, then you’re really, really up against the whole system working against your success. Now, you don’t have that theory, then it’s quite difficult for you to work in those schools actually because you just blame yourself and think that you’re a bad teacher because that’s what the theory says. I mean, common sense.
You can read it in the papers. One of our previous prime ministers said so about public school teachers many times. Then of course you’re also interested in curriculum. Again, if you’re a teacher in a difficult school, one of the things that tends to happen is there’s sort of an overemphasis on student behaviour management. You’ve to manage the behaviour, as opposed to how can I make the learning that’s going on in this room engaging, which is a curriculum problem and not a student behaviour management problem?
So if you’re interested in social justice, then you’re interested in curriculum, not student behavior management. So there’s a whole field of curriculum studies that started in education over about the last ten or twenty years, probably. It’s not very old, actually, as a subfield of education studies. And then there’s theories of social justice and so on. And you’ve got other categories out of Marxist tradition.
Because in this period around the 1980s, the social justice discourses in education were drawing on neo Marxist ideas that were very influenced by emphasis on class. So if you were engaging as a critical education scholar at that period, then that was the dominant. But then, of course, around that period, we’ve got the emergence of feminism. So all of a sudden, gender and gender relations and gender hierarchies are all appearing. And we’re also starting to see anti racist struggle.
Environmentalism is appearing. In the late nineteen or no, the early 1970s, the key text in my whole education in this space was a book called Pedagogy of the Oppressed by a South American guy called Paolo Freire, who’s probably one of the grandfathers of liberation theology. So you’ve got neo Marxism, feminism, environmentalism, liberation theology. Of these sort of debates about the way that oppression works in our society are all starting to take off in serious ways. I guess in the field of education, education’s when you’re thinking about it in terms of knowledge and the way that knowledge is organised in the Western universities, it’s not one of the classic disciplines.
It’s not sociology, history, philosophy. It’s sort of a bastard discipline, really. It sort of draws on everything. So, you know, in my school some of my colleagues, well most of them draw on psychology actually. Educational psychology is just so strong.
Some of us draw on sociology and anthropology. There’s some of us, a smaller number, interested in philosophy. Some are interested in history. There’s a couple of us interested in various forms of theology. Just on social justice, when you’re into social justice and education, then you’re really interested in how schooling outcomes are not equal across a range of different ways.
And there’s huge amounts of data sets that I won’t bore you with, because I think I’ve made my point on all of that. Just perhaps a few quotes though. Here’s a quote from Tony Fitzgerald, who wrote the education part of the Henderson Royal Commission into poverty in the mid-1970s. Yeah. He’s got a bout.
In conclusion, we argue from the evidence contained in this report that people who are poor and disadvantaged are victims of a societal confidence trick. That’s sort of pretty strong language. They’ve been encouraged to believe that a major goal of schooling is to increase the equality, while in reality schools reflect society’s intention to maintain the present unequal distribution of status and power. Because the myth of equal opportunities has been so widely accepted by Australians, the nature of unequal outcomes has been largely ignored. Thus, failure to succeed in the competition is generally viewed as being the fault of the individual rather than the inevitable result of the way our society is structured.
And I think that sort of is a wonderful summary of the logic that sort of drives my work. And there’s more quotes that we can have there. There’s multiple versions of this. This one’s a nice one. This is from Bob Connell.
It was Bob Connell at the time. Class inequalities in education range, measured by a range of outcomes, persist on a massive scale. They’re not an issue of the past. The second conclusion is that inequalities are not a minority problem to do with pockets of poverty in the landscape of affluence. Study after study shows a gradient of inequality that stretches right across the class structure.
And it goes on to say that the minority is, in fact, not the poor, but the privileged, which if you have a look at the data then that sort of shows up. I think the way that we think about the poor in Australia is that there’s a sort of small number of them. We’re all doing very well. But in fact, when you have a look at health outcomes, education outcomes, housing, and so on, this is all much, much more complicated than that. I’m sure people working in different social policy fields will have their own arguments about that.
More recently, here’s a quote. OECD studies indicate that Australia has a low equity education system, understood here to mean that Australian schooling produces a small, highly educated elite and a long tail of educational underachievement. And this now possible on the basis of international testing of various kinds. Sort of an indictment, really, on the way that the schooling system works. Again, just to distinguish school from schooling.
So there’s the everyday reality of school, but schooling’s the sort of system. So, yeah, being interested in critical pedagogy at the time of the 1980s, then the people I was reading were reading the Frankfurt School. So that was really the reason I signed up for a PhD because you couldn’t really take the Frankfurt School on without some sort of serious mentoring. Here’s a few of the people that were in the Frankfurt School. We’ve got Horkheimer who was the inaugural chair, whose opening presentation to the Frankfurt School in the early 1930s I still think is a sort of a fantastic manifesto for the emergence of transdisciplinary studies in the social sciences.
And maybe even inaugurates cultural studies, but that’s sort of another matter. There’s Theodore Adorno and Walter Benjamin and Max Horkheimer and Erich Fromm particularly. And Eric Frome becomes interesting to me later. I’ll get to him hopefully. And then, of course, if trying to read the German Frankfurt School who were sort of a mob of social philosophers, maybe prominent in the nineteen thirties, forties, to the nineteen sixties.
I think Marcuse was the social theorist for the hippies. His work suggested that liberation was possible through sex. I think everyone went for that. The way that I understand, one of the projects of the Frankfurt School anyway was an attempt to think a Freudian Marxism. So, again, theoretically, I think what the Frankfurt School were up to was the social sciences had theories of society.
And we had theories of the individual, you know, psychological, the psyche, and so on. But no one had really tried to put them together. And I I don’t know how you go, but in my life, I need to understand that myself as a psychological psychic individual and the society. And both of those interact very, very powerfully. So we really do need theories that can put both of those things together.
So I think the Frankfurt School sort of inaugurate a really, really important theoretical project that I think that’s how I sort of understand really what’s going on in the social sciences since then. So, of course, you need Marx. They were reading Marx. They were reading Gramsci and Nietzsche, Weber, etcetera. So again, when you’re trying to be scholarly, then the problem you’ve got is how far back do you go.
And if you’re in Australia, you’ve had a paltry philosophical education compared to if you’re in a European country. Know, you’re reading material that’s written by the European educated person who understands all the arguments between Kant, Hegel, and Marx. So there was a lot of catching up to do. I did read a bit of Marx. I refused to read Hegel because I just can’t make Edna or Tale.
I did read some Nietzsche and some Weber and so on. So you’re really, really trying to catch up as a way of being able to engage with the debates in social theory, broadly speaking. And then I moved this is when I moved on to Flinders and working with a professor. We were doing research into the contemporary nature of teachers’ work, studying what’s happening to teachers and their work. So interviewing a lot of teachers.
Done quite a lot of school ethnographies. Must have interviewed hundreds of teachers actually and principals in schools talking about the effects of various policies on their lives. And in the meantime trying to draw on the social theories that I was reading. As well, we did the big study into early school leaving. We interviewed a couple 100 young people about why they left school early.
That was a really incredibly interesting study. And then a whole new lot of categories start to emerge when I’m doing that research, and I won’t rehearse all of those. And so we bump into, in particular anyway, the work of Foucault, the French, I’m not quite sure what discipline one would call it. We could call that a philosopher perhaps. Some people call him an historical sociologist and you know it’s difficult to sort of peg.
But I guess one of the things that I sort of understand by the critical here is people who are interested in trying to understand the social are really grappling in the dark around how does power work? How does power work through the social? How does power work through our own subjectivity? So in my early work, when you’re reading the neo Marxist, you’ve got a Marxist version about power. Probably it’s hierarchical based on conspiracy theories and all sorts of other sort of Machiavellian.
Then Foucault comes along and blows all that out of the water and comes up with a completely different rendering of the way that power works based on his sort of genealogies of varying kinds. And one that I would highly recommend to people to read is Foucault’s Genealogy of the State. I think it’s an alternative thesis to Weber, actually. The thing that was missing from yesterday was an analysis of power. Power was just haunting the whole conversation, but missing.
So What Foucault did was track forms of governmental power. So you’re interested in the history of power and the way that power works, you you start by doing an analysis of the king, sovereign power. And then, of course, we have the English and French revolutions. And and we we chop off the head of the king, don’t we? At least physically.
But then the king’s still there. We we move to sort of parliamentary forms of democracy in which in which around that time what happens is the the government, the idea of government changes from the idea of government that the king was pursuing. And really the king couldn’t give him rats about the population. The king was just interested in his lands and so on and so forth, raising taxes for the army. So sort of maintaining his land.
Now when we move to post the king then all of a sudden we’re interested in governing a population in which case we need knowledge about people and so discipline arises. So knowledge itself becomes a part of the sort of control of nation. So I think I don’t know it’s one of the things that the Frankfurt School, one of their famous texts, the dialectic of the enlightenment. The enlightenment sort of understood as knowledge leading to liberation but of course knowledge leads to oppression as well and certainly that’s the way that knowledge gets used by government. Knowledge gets used to control people as well as provide them with liberation and this is sort of quite complicated.
We could go on and on about Foucault. Let’s keep moving. More recently, I’ve moving across to doing other sorts of ethnographic studies outside of the field of education, actually. Just getting really interested in what’s going on in society in general, particularly I’ve sort of been calling it hope studies. We’ve done some research around reconciliation.
Been doing some research around what’s been happening for refugees in schools. Recently got a big grant to study what’s happening with Ngunna Njeri Nation and its negotiations with the Australian nation. And we’re hoping to win a big grant to research the Tibetan diaspora. So just moving across to my thesis. How am I going time wise?
Right. My thesis, was, you know, the title was Awakening Struggle, I tried to just briefly introduce that just before. The key question was just a more general version of the one that I introduced at the beginning. So rather than just render the question in terms of being a teacher, the question becomes how can we live an ethical political life in an unjust world was the sort of general question. And then how might a conversation between critical social theory and Buddhism sort of help with that with that question.
So I I went to that was the way I constructed my work in that project. And there’s the sort of I just cut a bit of text out of the introduction of my thesis for this life. I think I was in that quote there I’m sort of not just interested in the knowledge or the wisdom that the traditions have but their sensibilities became really, really important for me. Trying to think about Buddhist sensibility and a critical sensibility. That’s where I sort of ended up.
How can I, as a person grappling with this question, nurture those sensibilities? How might both of those sort of come together in my life? I guess that’s what my thesis was about. My thesis ended up becoming a bit of a manifesto for myself that I’m never going to be able I think it’s going to take me three eons. Anyway, just back to ethics and politics, the ethical political.
This is a quote from Richard Bernstein. There’s a few Richard Bernstein’s. This book’s called New Constellations. He talks about a symbiotic relationship between ethics and politics. To read the quote, So ethics concerned with ethos, with those habits, customs and modes of response that shape and define our praxis, which is our life.
Politics is concerned with our public lives and the polis with communal bonds at once unite us and separate us as citizens. The essential link between ethos and polis is the nomos. Although we can distinguish ethics from politics, they’re inseparable. For we cannot understand ethics without thinking through our political commitments and responsibilities. And there’s no understanding of politics that does not bring us back to ethics.
And I don’t think that’s the way that politicians necessarily lead or even people that are trying to be ethical. But I was trying to sort of struggle with both of those together. I don’t know. As a, was sort of a characterisation of the critical social theory tradition and the Buddhist tradition. I think the critical tradition I think is very very strong on the political.
It’s really really rich on trying to understand the nature of the social and the political. That’s quite clear to me. But I think probably weak on the individual and the ethical. I think if you go to social theory and try and read the field in the last ten or fifteen years, there’s a huge emergence in interest in ethics, actually, which I think has confirmed some stuff that was said yesterday. It’s really, really big now in the field, ethics.
If you look at the Buddhist tradition, Buddhism emerges from a guy who lived two thousand five hundred years in a village life in which there’s almost no society other than there’s no social institutions that we would understand. No media. No schooling system. You know what I mean? It’s a village.
So the Buddha’s rendering of what’s going on is coming out of that. And so it is at the level of the everyday. And is very rich around ethics and very weak around politics. So, you know, the lives that we lead, I think we actually need to draw insight from both sort of Western and Eastern traditions because they sort of offer strengths in various ways that the other doesn’t have necessarily. Here’s another take on ethicopolitics.
Just to quickly read this. Again, this is my own view here. It seems sort of impossible to separate thinking about living a good life and being a good citizen. I guess that’s the one way of distinguishing the difference between ethics and politics. There’s an implied personal and social dimension to living an ethical political life.
Political work needs to be in dialogue with our personal struggle to live an ethical life. And our ethical work needs to be in dialogue with our political activism. If we attempt to keep these two separate, somehow we end up in very odd and even dangerous places. But then there’s the dilemma we all that’s the dilemma we all live in, if you sort of get the idea. And I guess one of the things that sort of concerned me mostly, or when I’m thinking about the relationship between ethics and politics, is I just know too many angry feminists and angry labor activists and angry environmentalists and angry peace activists.
So, on the one hand, you know, the western social movements critical theory, I think, the theoretical edge of all of that. Making a lot of arguments about how we need to be doing things to make the society a better place to live, and I don’t have any trouble with that. But then there’s no internal reflection. No emphasis on the sort of personal transformative dimension. The only thing that’s being described mostly out of those traditions is we need to change the outside.
It’s nothing to do with the internal. And I think that really does sort of undercut their project. It sort of undercuts the Western social movements because they’re not able to think the social and the personal together. And then on the side of the Buddhist tradition, it’s often presented, not I I try to recover a socially engaged presentation of Buddhism. Often people outside of Buddhism anyway think that Buddhism is sort of an otherworldly thing you go and hide and that has nothing to do with the social.
And I guess that’s complete nonsense, isn’t it? So how do we think about our lives as having some engagement between the personal and the social? That was my thesis in the end, actually, the impossibility of disentangling those things. Quite banal, really. I spent eight years to come up with that.
Anyway, one sort of of key dilemmas that was haunting me when I was conceiving of my thesis was this. According to Western educational sociology, poverty is socially constructed or constituted out of social conditions. And I believe that. It seems to be quite clear to me. But then I’m sitting in Rinpoche’s classes, according to Buddhism, poverty is lived as a consequence of karma.
It’s a personal result. So on the one hand, it’s socially constituted. On the other, it’s a personal result. Now, I’m not going to rehearse here how I’ve resolved those. But I don’t think those two are contradictory.
I guess that’s one of the things that I had to try and think through in my thesis. Actually had the conversation with Rinpoche about this personally right at the beginning, actually, which was quite useful. In fact, Rinpoche said poverty arises as a consequence of causes and conditions. That was the sort of key between the two. Obviously, there’s karmic causes, but there’s also social conditions.
Whilst we might not be able to do anything about anyone’s personal causes for their poverty, can certainly struggle over the social conditions. I won’t bore you. Anyway, I went and looked for some quotes around karma. Anyway, my thesis was trying to bring two interpretive communities together. So we’ve got critical theory on the one hand, which I understand as a, I don’t know, Jürgen Habermas’s text, Philosophical Discourse on Modernity.
I think that’s a good way of understanding critical theory. Critique of post modernity. It sort of involves an interdisciplinary engagement with the present drawing on a range of knowledges. I’ve just got there a few names. Kant, Hegel, Nietzsche, Marx, Lukacs, the Frankfurt School.
Sorry, I forgot Veblen. More recently, feminism, etcetera, etcetera. So it’s all now sort of quite complicated, what it means to sort of engage in critical theory. Fifteen years ago, if you were reading the journals and books, then critical theory with a big C, big T, that actually referred to the German Frankfurt School, the German school of critical theory. I think they probably inaugurate the term, actually, critical theory.
More recently, the category’s been taken over. And now it’s little c, little t, and it’s sort of more general, more universal. There’s sort of an ongoing rejuvenation inside of that tradition as a consequence of debates of the style that we all sort of enjoy. And then on the other hand, given that I was studying Tibetan Buddhism, then I was trying to bring Tibetan Buddhism into bear there. I don’t know, I was probably like a completely outrageous claim that I could make that I could bring Tibetan Buddhism into conversation with critical theory, but I gave it my best shot.
I don’t know. Apart from someone who hasn’t gone and done the Kopan course, which probably is about as intensive an introduction to Lamrim as you could get, Rinpoche taught Lamrim on Saturday mornings in 1991, ‘ninety two, ‘ninety three. There was Kimball and me, Tenzin and Rinpoche, for two years. Kimball and I would meet and do the Vajrasattva purification practice, and then we would do Lamrim with Rinpoche. Unbelievable to have such a wonderful presentation of Lamrim.
I think he did it two years, so got the whole cycle. I had many talks with Rinpoche during this period. I’m too afraid to go and talk to him now because he knows that my practice is terrible. But he said one story. When I escaped Tibet, I went with 20 or 30 other people I was leading.
I could only take one text. I took Lam Rim. Sometimes you think, oh, it’s only the Lam Rim. You know what I mean? There’s all these other texts.
When Khen Rinpoche Tsultrim came to Adelaide about fifteen years ago, his biography went around. The biography said and maybe this was wrong, but this is what I read. He spent fourteen years in a cave, and for the first seven years he meditated on Lamrim. And then he did tantra. You start to add these things up, don’t you, how significant the Lamrim is.
I had some interviews with Lama Zopa when he came in that period. And Lama Zopa said to me, the best thing that you can do is to go through the whole Lamrim as often as you can. And don’t just concentrate on one bit. Do the whole thing. You start adding up all the reconnaissance about how significant the Lamrim is.
Again, you study the Lamrim. The whole of the Buddha’s teachings in the lamb rim. It’s simplest version, 65 stanzas. You can read it quite quickly. The whole Lamrim.
Around that period, I’m reading Walter Benjamin. And has a category in his writing of the constellation. You’re picking categories from tradition to tradition. I sort of understand the Lamrim as a constellation of ideas. So you put all the ideas in constellation and they’re all shining on each other.
You need the whole constellation to sort of make sense of what it’s about. Renunciation without compassion is terribly dry and so on and so on. So you to sort of familiarise yourself with the whole constellation to work out how those concepts are working. Anyway, sorry about that. I’m telling you about Lamrim.
But then of course, they’re not separate. My thesis was how could I bring them together and study the interface. I think one of the things that I tried to do was to study what was at that interface already, and also to imagine it in a richer way than anyone else had ever done. So just on the interface between what I understand critical theory and just make it Buddhism without Tibetan Buddhism, Heidegger, Nietzsche, Schopenhauer all read Buddhism. As I said before, Erich Fromm, one of the key scholars in the Frankfurt School, he wrote books in which he talked about Buddhist meditation.
He was sort of shunned by the Frankfurt School actually. We all feel this If you sort of come out and explicitly describe how you’re engaging with Buddhist resources even now, then you tend to be shunned. I don’t know, there’s a lot of old hippies in the room. How many of you have got books by Erich Fromm in the library at home? I think a lot of people have.
His books on love, and so on and so on. He wrote in much more accessible ways than Max Horkheimer. I think he actually got Freud right. But anyway, that’s another matter. So what I was trying to do in my thesis was to conceive of a dialogical encounter between critical theory and Buddhism and sort of imagine the space between them.
Which I think this whole two days has been about really. How do we imagine the spaces between the east and the west and the knowledges that they’ve got to offer? But then of course, the space is already inhabited. I was saying to someone yesterday, recently I’ve been reading the writings of Marcus Aurelius, and in there there’s a meditation on death and impermanence that just looks so familiar. And if there weren’t Buddhists in the court of Alexander, then I’ll go here.
And I think someone is doing research on that as well. The sort of Greek and Roman philosophers, think, have already met Buddhist ideas. This is the know, we’re thinking that we’re at the beginning of something, but I think this has been going on for quite some time. Anyway, one of the one of the categories that’s really, really important to me in my teaching is dialogue. How does one engage in dialogue with one’s students?
I went to school and the teacher stood out the front and bored me shitless most of the time and some people in this room have already talked about why school’s a problem. It seemed to me as though good teachers don’t stand out the front and bore the students shitless. They sort of try to engage in some sort of dialogical encounter. For various reasons I went looking for strong versions of dialogue and then just conceiving of my own thesis of dialogue between two traditions was quite useful for me. I don’t know, dialogue with one’s intimate friends is incredibly rare and difficult.
I don’t know how you understand dialogue, but sort of dialogue you actually do hear the other person, your behavior changes on the basis of hearing that, etcetera, etcetera. I can’t say that my behavior changes from listening to my partner very often. You know what I mean? And she’s telling me quite often what she wants. Dialogue’s very difficult.
Dialogue across traditions is very difficult, and hence the struggles that I think we’ve all been talking about in the last of the last day and a half. If you go looking for resources around dialogue, then you can find it being rendered in terms of dialogical space, pedagogical space, space for double consciousness, being able to hold two ideas together for a while and see what happens. Homi Bhabha, a postcolonial scholar, talks about it in terms of third space. Anzaldúa talks about it in terms of a borderland, inhabiting a borderland. I guess that’s what this room is.
We’re making up and inhabiting a borderland between a couple of interpretive communities. At the border is the possibility of being revitalized or disturbing our habitual ways of seeing, thinking, and being in the world of making a new mestiza consciousness. Mestiza is a Spanish word for mixed blood, which is sort of an interesting metaphor really for what’s going on here. Then back to what the word critical means for me. Just a few quotes, because this is quite fundamental for me really.
Think one of the things that I did in my PhD was really trying to work out what that word means. It’s sort of bandied about inside social theory pretty easily. If I was trying to claim that for myself, then I’ve tried to do a lot of work on that. It’s like, what does it mean to be a Buddhist? What does it mean to be critical?
Don’t know, yesterday we were trying to peg what it means to be Buddhist, but it’s obviously quite difficult. It’s not simple, and one has to sort of work on even just the definition. So here’s a few quotes from Foucault, who I’ve really, really started to enjoy immensely in the last five or ten years. He talks about it as sort of a mode of relating to reality, a choice made by certain people, a way of thinking and feeling, of acting and behaving, that it’s one and the same time Marxist relation of belonging and presents itself as a task. You can probably apply that to being Buddhist as well actually.
Thought about in this way being critical informs a form of subjectivity as not only a way of reading the word and the world but also a way of acting on the world. It has to be considered as an attitude and ethos of philosophical life in which critique of what we are is at one and the same time the historical analysis of the limits that are imposed on us and experiment with the possibility of going beyond them. Criticism consists in driving thought out of hiding and trying to change it. I think yesterday Ilya was talking about common sense and the way we sort of naturalize things. I think what Foucault’s talking about here is bringing that out into the light and trying to interrogate the two easy gestures.
That’s the way he puts it. This one’s probably quite can’ty, and this is my favorite really, about what it means to be critical. What is the reason we use? What are its historical effects? What are its limits and what are its dangers?
How can we exist as rational beings, fortunately committed to a rationality that is unfortunately crisscrossed by intrinsic dangers? That seems to me to be quite nice. Maybe we could say, more recently, wanted to put what other reasonings we use. That’s in trying interrogate them. It appears to me as though our present condition comes about on the basis of adopting various reasonings.
That’s why I like Buddhism, actually, because it puts all of our reasonings under interrogation and provides the sort of outlines of virtuous, skilful reasonings as alternatives to ones that are unskilful. As someone who’s trying to jump across the two traditions, I just cannot understand why more critical theorists aren’t reading more Buddhism because of the basic sort of overlap in the key proposition about what it means to be critical. Yeah, we’ve done that one. We’ll just move on. Here’s a good one.
It’s sort of a radical form of skepticism towards common sense. What seems obvious and natural is not necessarily so, but that on the contrary the obvious and the natural are not given but produced in a specific society by the ways in which that society talks and thinks about itself and its experience. I think one of the things that we were talking about yesterday, and obviously the way that a society understands its knowledge fundamental. And yesterday we had some quite good critique of what we all, I think, understand to be misunderstandings and abuses of truth and knowledge that’s rendered as science. I think recently, in my field anyway, there’s what’s called a science war going on inside of the literature.
So there’s a war about history. There’s a war about literacy. There’s a war about science going on. In my field, the science war is being perpetrated by quite conservative forces in America that are trying to claim that the only form of knowledge that’s worthwhile in the social sciences is empiricist. So what constitutes truth is being narrowed.
Funding, of course, goes with the narrowing. So if you want to talk to people and get subjective understandings, that’s not seen as science. So all the research I do is bunk them according to the war that’s going on in America. We heard it yesterday. Certain forms of knowledges are not listened to inside of what constitutes science.
I think that’s part of the problem actually why Buddhism is having trouble. It’s the way that the category of science itself is rendered. That needs to be opened up. Guess the Dalai Lama is doing his own work there, but everyone needs to be onto that. And I mentioned it before, critical is about trying to understand the relationship between power and knowledge.
Back to the Frankfurt School, the myth of the Western Enlightenment is that knowledge leads to emancipation. I think in fact we’re sold a pup over and over and over by the common sense in our society that we have got to this point as a consequence of progress and rationality and the better argument. When in fact a lot my experiences and my realities come about as a consequence of people struggling with power actually. So labor struggle. Workers’ conditions haven’t got to that as a consequence of progress and rationality.
I’m sorry. Women’s lives hasn’t come about as a consequence of men all of a sudden becoming enlightened. And we can go sort of on and on and on. White slave traders didn’t give up slaves as a consequence of progress and rationality. It’s about relationships between power and knowledge that we sort of need to be sort of understanding.
I don’t know, it’s something that I’ve really learned from both Buddhism and Western traditions. They both offer me different things. The basic insight is that all knowledge is interested. It has knowledge interests. Okay?
So this is Jurgen Habermas especially. When reviewing the social sciences, there’s various ways of knowing. There’s empiricism, interpretivism, and critical or post structuralist versions. So the way that this normally gets rendered is that empiricism, which the social sciences borrows or has imposed on it by the other sciences. We need to, you know, the social sciences has to ape that.
Otherwise, it’s not truth. Empiricism has a knowledge interest mostly according to the social sciences I read anyway is about control. Control of nature actually. That’s why we have scientific knowledge at a quite fundamental level. In my field, the sort of empiricist knowledge inside of social sciences is about controlling people.
So the basic skills test is about controlling teachers’ work and controlling students. It’s not about liberation, it’s about control. So we have empiricism. The sort of interpretivist traditions are about getting access to understanding. So we’ve moved away from control.
We’re just trying to understand human subjectivity. Now that’s okay at one level, but what’s missing from that is that all of our own understandings are shot through with power relations. And so one needs to bring some sensitivity to power to understanding our own subjective understandings, which is where we move towards a critical epistemology. More recently, we’ve got the post critical. I guess we’ll have the post post critical and the post post post post.
Anyway, just on that, the sort of post is sort of interesting. I think Buddhists are post or the post is Buddhist. The reading that I’ve been doing anyway, particularly in the philosophers, the key insight that I get from the post structuralists or the post modernists I think that their project is driven by a suspicion of essentialisms, which is very Buddhist. There’s no essence. How Buddhist is that?
So when I go to read Western Social Theory now, you’ve just got these enormous amount of debates going on across a whole range of different fields trying to account for what that means. Which is quite difficult if there’s no essence. Anyway, we move on quickly to socially engaged Buddhism just for one minute if you don’t mind. Yes, I did some work on socially engaged Buddhism as a sort of a I think that’s the space between Western struggles for justice and Buddhism. I went looking for scriptural justifications and they’re in the sutras and the key text for me anyway was Nāgārjuna’s Precious Garland which was instructions to the king about how to live the life of the king.
There’s various commentaries around about that. Then of course there’s various versions of socially engaged Buddhist from the East and studied three especially. The Dalai Lama is quite key. Thich Nhat Hanh, a Vietnamese Zen Buddhist and Sulak Sivaraksa who’s a Thai Buddhist activist who’s been jailed many times. His critiques of Western capitalism are some of the best I’ve read.
Very, very compelling arguments about the negative impacts of Western development models on Thai society. And then more recently there’s sort of some Western reinterpretations including Stephen Bachelor and a mob that I’m not even sure whether they’re still going, but if you Google Think Sangha you’ll get some sort of interesting stuff from them as well. And of course the sort of iconic image of socially engaged Buddhism. I went to Vietnam and went looking for this guy and he’s everywhere. There’s a huge Buddha in, I forget the town, and around the base are monuments to the self immolating monks of that period.
There’s his photo in the monastery just down the road from where the self immolation actually happened. I guess the reason why I became interested in this guy was Thich Nhat Hanh wrote a history of Vietnam called Lotus in a Sea of Fire. In the appendix is his letter to Martin Luther King Junior describing why the self immolation wasn’t suicide was a practice of a bodhisattva. It’s one of the most moving pieces of text I’ve ever read. Very sort of compelling.
Here’s the Dalai Lama on being socially engaged. When there’s something that needs to be done in the world to rectify the wrongs with the motivation of compassion, if one is really concerned with benefit, it’s not enough simply to be compassionate. Is no direct benefit in that. With compassion, one needs to be engaged and involved. I just think that’s such a provocation.
But then, of course, when we’re trying to think through the relationship between personal transformation and social transformation, what comes first? I’ve got just one last slide. I was going to go to where I’m up to now and trying to respond to some of the big things that are happening in our country. But the thing that’s sort of driving me at the moment is this quote out of the Bodhicaryāvatāra. One of the advices that that I’ve taken from my teachers in terms of my engagement with Buddhist practice and Lamrim is you should try and work on your biggest problems.
Only you know that. What’s your biggest delusions? Now with me it’s anger. I’m just really, really not quiet. I’ve got this problem.
In the area of trying to do social justice then you can be angry at the world. It’s terribly compelling. But as I as I tried to as I tried to rehearse before, sort of undermines your project. So dealing with anger as a social justice activist is really important. So here’s Śāntideva.
Whatever wholesome deeds such as venerating the Buddhas and generosity that have been amassed over a thousand eons will be destroyed in one moment of anger. There is no evil like hatred and no fortitude like patience. Thus I should strive in various ways to meditate on patience. So one moment of anger is seen as being just appalling according to Śāntideva. So As a sort of provocation for my thinking anyway I’ve been sort of trying to think through post anger as a social justice activist.
Again you go and read the you go and read the literature and and you and you talk to people and anger’s so central to social justice activists. They just love anger. It’s just really so important to them. So the philosophers, Derridean philosophers like Critchley in pieces just written recently is claiming anger and arguing with Seneca, etcetera, etcetera. So trying to find discourses that are post anger have become really, really important to me.
Then trying to find sites in the world where people are trying to get over their anger in serious, substantial ways. That’s also sort of significant. What can we learn from that? And there are places like that. Which led me to doing some research about national reconciliation projects.
And there’s 25 truth and reconciliation commissions already. There’s at least 45 countries that have national reconciliation projects of one kind or another. And I don’t know how you understand reconciliation, but it does appear to me as though in a lot of countries, most countries are struggling with revenge narratives. Blood feuds and revenge. Ireland, Israel, you could just pick a place, Cyprus, it goes on and on and on and on and on.
It goes on forever in some cases. And you know, how does the country deal with some sort of traumatic event and in some cases they don’t get over it in hundreds of years because they’re still trapped inside of negative emotions. So National Reconciliation Project just seems so bizarre when you think about that, you know, historically how sort of attached we are to revenge. Hollywood movies, don’t you love a revenge narrative? Good beats evil, all that stuff.
I mean I just really get off on revenge narratives, but we’ve got to be able to sort of think through what’s the sort of alternative, not just individually, but sort of socially, be able to talk about the sort of the alternative as a social alternative. That’s where I’ve started to turn to sort of hope studies, And where, you know, where people, real people on the ground are trying to get beyond, you know, the expression of these delusions that Buddha sort of understand relatively well, even though we can personally still be struggling with our anger. And I’ll finish there. Thank you so much Rob. I’m sure that there are many thoughts that have arisen as a result of Rob’s presentation, but given that Tenzin has made a commitment with the restaurant around the road to have the food ready, what I’ll do is ask you to make a note of your questions and then there will be an opportunity if that’s alright Rob on the panel to distil your thoughts succinctly I and beg your pardon?
So otherwise I think if we started with questions now then we would get in, well the food will go cold not that we are attached to that but then it means that we can come back refreshed for the next session and we can continue on so just join with me again in thanking you Rob very much So if you can make your way. There is a toilet down in the restaurant as well And then if we can be back here promptly for a 12:30 start with Jampa Gendun. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.