Ornament of Clear Realization — 1990-03-22

1 h 38 min · 4,810 words · 22 March 1990 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Ornament of Clear Realization (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament of Clear Realization (Khensur Rinpoche)
Ornament of Clear Realization — 1990-03-22
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 98-minute session, Khensur Rinpoche teaches the branches of the knower of paths—the foundational conditions before a practitioner can directly realize the spiritual paths. He uses a field-preparation analogy: removing the main obstacle (pride), planting Buddha nature, and cultivating it through bodhicitta, the awakening heart. He distinguishes three types of path-knower consciousness: those guiding practitioners along the Hearer vehicle, Solitary Realizer vehicle, and Mahāyāna path. He traces the five paths and how subtle faults are gradually removed across the ten meditation grounds. The final segment emphasizes the five faculties—faith, effort, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom—as essential for progress, and identifies pride as the primary obstacle, with respect as its antidote. For practitioners already studying the Ornament of Clear Realization.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1990-03-22 – T7 – Tape 7. . Branches of Knower of Paths – KR.mp3

UUID: 3d534d36-19a8-4903-8212-56f23bb46ee3

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Ornament of Clear Realization

Date: 1990-03-22

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,792

Holding others as dear as oneself, I must attain enlightenment for their benefit. Through attaining complete perfect Buddhahood, I will be able to establish all sentient beings in complete happiness and eliminate all their suffering. And to that end, in order to achieve Perfect Buddhahood, I’m going to practice the great vehicle perfection of wisdom. And therefore, adjusting one’s motivation with the intention of listening to this teaching will cultivate the awakening heart for five minutes. So we’ve been discussing the eight categories.

And amongst these eight, the initial three being the three exalted knowers. And previously we finished the explanation with respect to the first of the exalted knowers the exalted knower of all aspects of this is the omniscience. And in a very what do we mean by omniscience? It’s simply that an exalted consciousness that has in which all the faults have been eliminated and all the excellent qualities have been developed. That is to say and this is a the excellent the exalted consciousness exalted wisdom of a Buddha.

Exalted knower of a Buddha. This is what we mean by omniscience. And then today we’re going to proceed from there. So in by omniscience, we mean the elimination of all the faults the consummation of all excellent qualities within the exalted knower. And this brings about the welfare of both oneself and others.

What is the actual method whereby we can attain omniscience? And that brings us to the second category that is knower of paths, which is the method to attain omniscience. So in order to carry out a practice whereby we can attain omniscience, we have to understand the meditative practices within that practice. And therefore we must understand the knower paths well. As a means to actually come to an understanding of the path knower, we make you we We come to that understanding by means of the presentation is in terms of 11 topics.

So we come to an understanding of the path knower by means by means of the presentation in terms of 11 topics. So in order to come to an understanding of the path knower we must understand the various topics by the presentation of the various topics by which it is presented. And what are these 11 topics? The first of these is as it states here branches of knower of paths. Branches of knower of paths.

And in coming to this understanding we can think of the exalted, the path knower, the knower of path as the main office. And we’re going to know understand what all the branch offices do. So this is a branch office and trying to understand what their function is. So in general we come to an understanding of the knower of paths by the actual generation of the path within our minds. A knower of paths is a path.

That is to say, it is a consciousness. And it is to be realized within the mind. It’s not something that we can understand like using our eye to see various forms. Looking at different colors and you know red and blue etc. Or a pot.

These types of things. But we actually, in order to come to know it, we have to regenerate it within our mind. So in order to understand the knower path, have to understand it by and what how it is actually generated and the causes for its development. Therefore it’s helpful to understand what are the boundaries of the knower of paths. And speaking of the great vehicle, there are five paths.

There is the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and no more learning. So now we’re talking about the knower of paths. It doesn’t exist on the path of accumulation or preparation. It doesn’t exist. It exists and it is initially generated on the path of seeing.

And within the path of seeing and meditation, there are what is called the 10 grounds. The first ground is at the path of seeing. So it’s at the first ground that the knower of paths is first developed. And therefore the path knower exists on the path of seeing and the path of meditation, but it does not exist on the path of no more learning. So it’s on these two grounds.

Seeing and meditation. On these two paths. Seeing and meditation. So when we talk about the branches of knower of paths, this acts as the preparation for the actual generation of knower of paths. It Before having generated it, one makes use of the branches of knower of paths in order to newly generate or develop the path knower knower path.

So if we explain what we mean by the branches of knower of paths, first by way of an analogy. Just as in the case of cultivating a field. If we have, if the field is not prepared, if it’s bad earth, if it has many boulders, if it has old trees laying around, then we’re not going to get a crop. We have to first clear the field. And these we had is we have to remove all the obstacles to growing the crop.

So if we present the meaning of the meaning, apply the meaning to that analogy, the field, the mind is compared to the field. And in order to develop the qualities, for example, awakening heart, we must the mind must be cleared of obstacles. Just as in the case of clearing the field of stones and trees, fallen trees, etc. The mind must be cleared of obstacles. And here, specifically, the obstacle of pride or arrogance must be cleared away.

And to carry the analogy further, just as in the case of field that is necessary to plant the seed and to germinate the seed likewise, the seed which exists within our mind is the great vehicle lineage or we can say the vehicle nature is the seed. Just as in the case where the sprout arises from the seed, likewise the path will arise from our great vehicle lineage or Buddha lineage or we could say Buddha nature. So just in the case of the field, it’s not enough simply to clear the field and to plant the seed, but we also have to water the field. So we’ve as in the case of the field, that we’ve cleared the field by eliminating arrogance, pride, that we have planted the seed of our Buddha nature, Buddha lineage, and now we apply the water. And in this case the water is analogous to meditating on the awakening heart.

And just as in the case of collecting these conditions together, the clear field, the seed and the water that the sprout arises. Likewise, through having removed the obstacle of pride, implanted the lineage Buddha nature, and watered with the meditation of the awakening heart, what arises, the knower of paths will arise. So collecting all of these main causes together and that we’ve just enumerated the removing the obstacle of pride, planting the seed of lineage, with the water of the awakening heart, but also additionally with other meditations such as meditation on emptiness. From this gathering of these collection of causes arises the actual result which is the path. And this this gathering together causes is what is meant by the branches of path.

If we ask when does the awakening when does this result actually arise? When does the knower path arise? Having cultivated the awakening heart, we combine, create a union of method and wisdom. And we in activating our great vehicle lineage directly without having passed through the lower vehicles of the hearers and solitary realizers. We directly realize emptiness, then we have developed the knower of paths.

So the person who has directly realized emptiness within the great vehicle has attained the path of seeing and simultaneously the first ground. So do you understand the way that we newly developed the knower of paths? So we could explain knower of paths in terms of various categories. It has innumerable qualities to it. But if we were to condense them we could talk of the knower of in terms of three types.

So the knower of paths is a path of bodhisattva superiors. And what is the practice of a bodhisattva superior? What kind of work do they engage in? What do they do? They are seeking to lead sentient beings along their each of their individually desired path.

Now we can talk about these various types of beings in terms of three vehicles: the vehicle of the hearer, the vehicle of the solitary realizer, and the vehicle of the great vehicle. And each so for those who are inclined to the hearer’s vehicle, the bodhisattva superior teaches them in accordance with their desires and shows them the method to achieve the goal of the hearer’s vehicle. For those who are inclined toward the solitary realizer vehicle, the bodhisattva superior teaches them the methods for attaining the goal of the solitary realizer vehicle. And likewise, for those who are inclined toward the great vehicle, methods for leading teaches the methods for leading higher and higher paths in terms of attaining the goal of the great vehicle in order to achieve the welfare of others. So, the bodhisattva is seeking to lead sentient beings to each of their inclined goals according to their various desires of sentient beings.

Therefore if he were, if a practitioner desired to be led along the hearer’s vehicle then it would be necessary for the bodhisattva to know, to understand that vehicle well, to understand all the various practices. Whatever that practitioner desires, he would have to be able to teach it to him or her. And therefore, he would have to or she would have to know it for him or herself. And the method whereby he is able to understand what he is going to teach to that practitioner, in this case the practitioner of the hearer vehicle, that consciousness that understands the method for leading this hearer upon their desired vehicle is this type of path knower which is called a knower of paths that knows hearer’s paths. A knower of paths that knows hearer’s paths.

And likewise, this again applies to the practitioner who is inclined toward the path of the solitary realizer vehicle. In order to lead that individual along the path of the solitary realizer vehicle, the Bodhisattva Superior must understand that path in order to, that he is able to lead him. And therefore, he develops an understanding of that path, a consciousness, and this consciousness is a knower of paths, but specifically a knower of paths that knows solitary realizer’s paths. Again, this applies to the practitioner inclined toward the vehicle or the paths of the great vehicle. In order to lead this particular practitioner along their path of inclination which they desire to follow, then it’s necessary that the bodhisattva Superior understand that path and the consciousness which understands that path is a knower of paths, but specifically a knower of paths which is the Mahāyāna path of seeing.

So there’s a question that came up here because technically we could call this third type of knower of paths the knower of paths that knows the bodhisattva’s paths, the knower of paths which knows bodhisattva’s paths. But here it’s not listed. This is because this knower of paths which is the knower of paths which the which knows bodhisattva paths is going to be divided into many categories. And so they do not separately list this knower of bodhisattva paths but they actually begin with a categorization as it says here the Mahāyāna path of seeing. This would be the first division.

But we could just make this generalization to keep this form This type of knower would be called a knower of paths that knows bodhisattva paths. And then we could carry on these various divisions. So we could ask, well I mean to lead a hearer or a solitary realizer upon their particular desired path we don’t have to have a path knower. But, so we have to but the path knower has three qualities in which it is seeking to in which to lead these all of these various types of practitioners. The first is the quality of motivation and that is the motivation is the awakening heart.

The second is the actual teaching and it teaches the non true existence of phenomena. And finally, the third is the entity and this is to lead the practitioner ultimately finally ultimately to the Buddha ground. And therefore this is the reason that the path knower is necessary to lead each of these practitioners. So, and then in terms of the actual great vehicle, where the path knower is initially generated at the path of seeing, the knower of paths, the knower of paths. Therefore it begins at the path of seeing.

And the definition of the great vehicle path of seeing is as is stated here, a great vehicle clear realizer of truth conjoined with the wisdom directly realizing emptiness in the continuum of a person who possesses it. If you haven’t previously made a note of this definition, then you should definitely make a note of this definition. It’s important. It’s in your handout. Six A1 was it?

Six A1? Yeah, that’s right. Yeah. It’s the great vehicle clear realizer of truth conjoined with the wisdom directly realizing emptiness in the continuum of person who possesses it. So if you don’t have this handout, then there’s some extra copies in the back, I believe.

So, the actual initial development of the knower of paths is the path of seeing. And you know the path of seeing has the various innumerable varieties, qualities, and types. But if we were to subsume three types if we’d subsume those various types into three, we could list three types of paths of seeing. And as it says here, these three divisions: an exalted wisdom, a meditated equipoise, a subsequently obtained wisdom, and a great vehicle path of seeing which is neither of these two. So have we direct insight into emptiness, we attain the exalted wisdom of meditative equipoise.

When we arise from that, we have the subsequently obtained wisdom. And then there is the third type which is neither of these two. So it would be good if we knew how we travel through these various paths within the great vehicle. We begin when practitioner generates, develops a fully qualified awakening heart, bodhicitta. Within their mind they attain the first of the paths.

They’re called the path of accumulation. And during this path they train in developing, for example, calm abiding. And they, as the object of their calm abiding, that is śamatha, they take as their object emptiness. When this meditation develops, they gain a special insight with respect to that emptiness. When they gain this, then they move on to the second path, which is the path of preparation.

So, on the path of preparation, practitioner realizes emptiness by means of this special insight with respect to emptiness. But he is not realizing emptiness directly. During the path of preparation, he is meditating, meditating on emptiness. When he actually gains a direct insight, direct realization into emptiness, he attains the third path, the path of seeing. And what do we mean by seeing?

He directly sees emptiness. The stain, could say, generally there could be a light part, a light stain, and very deep stain. And we cannot immediately remove the the deep stain, but we can gradually get to it, by we wash it, and we we get out the lighter part. The lighter, what do say, layers of the stain. And then using soap, we can scrub it and we get to the deeper part of the stain.

And that way, gradually, we can remove the stain altogether. Likewise, with the various faults, the various obstructions, we cannot initially remove the subtle faults obstructions, but we begin with the coarser ones. That may sound strange. The coarser ones are the light ones and the deep ones are the subtle ones. We gradually work this way.

So our own minds are analogous to these stained clothes For example, a shirt or something has a stain on it just as our minds have stains of various faults such as the afflictive obstructions and the knowledge obstructions. And in India, they have people who do your wash for you. They call them dobies. I don’t Anyway, we have a laundry people here laundry person. So, a laundry person what do do you have a name?

Dry cleaners. Yeah, dry it’s not dry, it’s wet. It has to be wet here. It doesn’t work. The wet cleaner.

Anyway, laundry person if they don’t so they have to do they have to get water, they need soap, and then they have to actually scrub. If they don’t scrub, then it doesn’t work to get out this thing. And so, the water and the soap are the understanding of emptiness is emptiness and the awakening heart. The water and the soap are emptiness and the awakening heart. The scrubbing that we have to do is the meditation or actual practice.

And this is the way we can actually begin to remove the stains from our mind. First, And we begin with the coarser levels of stains, the light stains, and then we can move on to the more subtle levels of stains, the deeper stains. So the the path of seeing is like the dobe. So the path of seeing through the meditation on emptiness, it is at the path of seeing that we’re able to remove the coarse faults from the mind. So, we can remove the coarser faults very quickly.

We can purify these, but the subtle faults are much more difficult and we have to do this in many levels through many levels in a graduated manner just in removing the stains from clothing. And and this is and the subtle levels are removed during the path of meditation in which there are 10 grounds. Over the 10 grounds of the path of meditation, we’re removing the subtle faults from the mind in various degrees. There’s a there’s a there’s a a degree of difficulty in the ability to abandon the various levels of thoughts. And we can only, only upon the tenth ground, the very final ground, can we remove the most subtle of the faults from the mind.

Upon removing this most subtle fault from the mind, the next moment we attain the path of no more learning. Is to say we attain Buddhahood. So, in order to actually understand all of the objects of abandonment at their various points along the path, at the various grounds in order to understand the various qualities of the antidotes, the various divisions, what are the degrees of the power of the antidotes, the great middling and lesser antidotes, it is necessary to study what is called to study the presentation of paths and grounds. Without studying the presentation of paths and grounds, you won’t be able to understand all of these. So, if we would ask, know, throughout these various grounds don’t you have to practice the various perfections?

For example, the perfection of generosity, ethics, patience, effort, etc. And the answer is yes, that in each of the grounds of these 10 grounds, we concentrate on a particular perfection. For example, on the first ground, we concentrate generosity on the second, ethics on the third, patience on the fourth, effort on the fifth, meditation meditative stabilization on the sixth, wisdom on the seventh, method on the eighth, power on the ninth, prayer and on the tenth, exalted wisdom. So, I made a mistake way back at the beginning when there’s three qualities of the path of the knower of paths. Said the first one was the motivation of the awakening heart.

The actual practice is emptiness. And I said, Nature. And it should have been the dedication. Is that one dedicates the positive potential created is dedicated for the benefit of all beings. That’s the third quality.

I made a mistake. So the mistake was that third quality. Should be rather than nature, it should be dedication. And dedication is that the positive potential created by the practice is dedicated to the attainment of Buddhahood. And we could ask, Well, throughout this process of moving through the 10 grounds, don’t we have to have the awakening heart?

And this as was said previously, that the motivation of the practice is the awakening heart. And the practice, the actual practice, is the various practices of, for example, the six perfections with the mind conjoined with the direct realization of emptiness as the actual practice. And then comes the the prayers of of dedication. And these are all of these are conjoined throughout these practices. So we’ll stop there, but if you have some questions, you can ask a question.

At what point is the awakening heart irreversible? Do you mean the sign or just in general? The sign the sign of non non reversibility or just or just irreversibility? No. Mean, So when one has conjoined with the awakening heart, when, so one has generated an awakening heart.

When this is conjoined with having destroyed the intention to bring about one’s own welfare, then irreversibility is achieved on that occasion. One has the awakening heart and conjoined with that one additionally develops the quality of having destroyed the intention to achieve only one’s own welfare, fulfill one’s own purpose, then at that occasion, irreversibility is attained. So is is there a point on like, Rinpoche was just explaining the So, the we can differentiate it into two possibilities just in two ways. The actual sign of it, as I mentioned, the sign of irreversibility is achieved on the path of preparation. But the the but the not the sign but the but the mental quality is achieved on the path of accumulation.

And this for the practitioner the sharp, intelligent practitioner can achieve this the the mental quality at the path of accumulation. But the sign doesn’t appear until the path of preparation. So, main practice should be the development of the awakening heart. This should be our main meditation. What is the discordant?

What stops us? What mainly stops us from developing a awakening heart? What fault? It is the striving for our own welfare alone. This is the discordant side which stops us from developing a awakening heart.

So, this is the mind that we should try to cease. The mind that the intention to strive for our own welfare alone. Completely. So, when there is no occasion in which there arises the intention which strives for oneself alone. Then, this is the occasion when there completely ceases the striving for one’s own welfare alone occurs according to the the practice.

Strength We can’t say it’s going to occur at any of the specific of the five paths. Generally, we can say that most intelligent practitioner, this will occur perhaps on the path of accumulation or preparation. For the middling level of intelligence, it will occur at the path of seeing. And for the dull practitioner, on the seventh ground. But it actually is at this occurs on the occasion this occasion could occur anywhere along these five paths according to the strength of the practice of the individual.

So there’s hope. The reason this the least intelligent is in terms I’m using this word intelligent literally be in lowest faculty, the least faculty, small faculty whatever you want to call it. I call it intelligent. It’s due to little wisdom and little positive potential or merit. This will due And to this then he has an inability to understand the mode of abiding things very clearly.

He doesn’t understand these things clearly. But so when they attain the eighth ground, then there’s no difference. There’s no distinguishment among these three levels of intelligence. I develop I meditate on your awakening heart and emptiness. So, these various practitioners are you know the great the high highest highest they’re very sharp clever fellows and they’re all getting to their destination, they can just get there quicker.

It’s just like know, wanting to get to somewhere someone walking and someone goes in a car or goes by train. Eventually the person walking will get there and so it just takes a little bit longer for those dull intelligence. They have to travel slower. They need a while, a little bit. So, there’s no relationship between the degree of intelligence and the amount of afflictive emotions that a person would have.

There’s many very smart people who do a great deal of negativity. So as I mentioned this word that I’m translating as intelligence can be translated as faculties. So, we can say those of sharp faculties and those of dull faculties. And by faculties, sometimes another word which is the same word in Tibetan are the sense faculties eye, ear, nose, tongue, body these sense faculties. This isn’t what we’re referring to when we talk about these faculties or I call it intelligence.

We mean the five faculties. There are five faculties. These five faculties are faith. So, one’s cleverness, one’s sharpness is dependent upon the degree of the strength of one’s faith. One’s effort, one’s mindfulness that is the ability of the mind to hold an object, one’s meditative concentration, which is the stability of the mind, and wisdom.

So, these are called the five faculties: faith, effort, mindfulness, meditative concentration, and wisdom. So, we’re talking about the degree of strength of each of these. And the reason that these vary in strength is due to habituation, the degree of habituation in past lives. Those who have not cultivated and are not habituated to these, their faculties will be of a lesser strength and we will call them dull. Those who are highly habituated to these five faculties, these faculties will be very strong and We will call them sharp or highest faculty or highly intelligent.

So, then it becomes obvious that there is a method whereby we can increase the level of our faculties, that we can become a person of sharpest most faculties by training. And what we train in are these five faculties. If we cultivate, increase the strength of each of these five faculties, if we increase our faith, increase our effort, increase our meditative concentrations, increase our mindfulness and wisdom, then we have increased our faculties and therefore we are individual of highest intelligence for faculty. So the actual antidote to pride is respect. And we generally hold and by pride we mean that we ourselves high compared to others.

And we can reverse this and act by holding others as higher than ourselves and respecting them. And the factor of pride, a factor of mindfulness, a question of how mindfulness would work in this, it actually doesn’t have a specific it’s not a specific antidote. One could remind oneself, that is to say, not forgetting what a bad the bad quality of pride. One would not forget, I shouldn’t be proud. One would remember that.

And this would be the factor of mindfulness. But the actual antidote would be the development of respect for others. So generating the path the lower path. So with So So, as in this illustration, remember just holding an upside down pot. Though you pour water on it, none of it goes in.

And those who are full of pride are such that the qualities cannot arise. Nothing can enter into them because they’re full of their own pride and therefore great pride is the obstacle to developing great qualities. Nothing else could fit inside. So, as summer approaches, the new grass grows first in the lowlands. So, the grass grows last in the highlands horizon as the summer approaches.

In general, we should hold ourselves we should have humility and we have respect for others. In this way we create a great deal of positive potential for ourselves and allows and through this we develop all the various positive qualities. Those on the other hand hold some others high and look down upon others at creating great negativity for themselves and therefore, this obstructs all the development of excellent qualities. So if we don’t want to remain in this difficult position of being somewhat of dull faculties, we have to make effort to develop these five faculties, increase them. Try to develop your faith, try to develop your effort, mindfulness, meditative concentration, wisdom so that we can eventually become those of highest intelligence or faculties.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
Pratyekabuddhayana rang sang gyä kyi thegpa, rang gyälwäi thegpa (Tib)
The Solitary Realizer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of solitary realizers (pratyekabuddhas), practitioners who attain liberation from cyclic existence autonomously without relying on an external teacher or teachings. LYWA
Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

At what point does the awakening heart become irreversible?

Irreversibility is achieved when one has generated the awakening heart and, conjoined with it, has destroyed the intention to strive for one's own welfare alone. The mental quality can be achieved on the path of accumulation by a sharp practitioner, but its sign does not appear until the path of preparation. The timing cannot be fixed to one of the five paths, since it depends on the strength of the individual's practice. For the sharpest it occurs on the path of accumulation or preparation, for the middling on the path of seeing, and for the dullest on the seventh ground. From the eighth ground there is no difference among them. All reach the destination, some just more slowly.

Scroll to Top