48 min · 2,436 words · 12 October 1989 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche opens this 48-minute session with a striking image: gods are humbled by the Buddha’s radiant light, which awakens their curiosity about the cause of such beauty—bodhicitta (the awakening heart)—and serves as a gateway to understanding the path knower. Continuing his commentary on the Ornament of Clear Realization, he illustrates why the path knower, the method to attain Buddha’s omniscience, comes second in the teaching progression. Rinpoche outlines the 11 topics covering path knower and unpacks the first: the five limbs (obstacle, conducive condition, substantial cause, and others), explaining each through the analogy of preparing a field—removing obstacles, adding conducive conditions, planting the seed. Assumes familiarity with Buddhist terminology.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1989-10-12 – Side 1 – KR.MP3
UUID: c2642612-4e7f-4eb6-881f-48a52f6ed5b4
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Ornament of Clear Realization
Date: 1989-10-12
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,432
Just a motivation to develop the attitude of the awakening heart. Such that we’re going to listen to this profound teaching on the great vehicle in order to practice what is being taught. And that is in order to achieve complete Buddhahood, in order to establish all sentient beings equal to space and complete peace and happiness. To that end we’ll meditate for two minutes adjusting our motivation. Having adjusted motivation, we’re going to listen to this teaching, and the teaching is on the the great vehicle, which is extremely advanced and profound vehicle.
This is supreme vehicle. And having this wonderful opportunity to listen to such a teaching, we should listen to it with a great appreciation. So we’re going to continue our discussion of the ornament of clear realization. The subject of the ornament is presented by me in terms of the eight categories and 70 topics. The eight categories are the three exalted knowers, the exalted knowers of all aspects, the path knower and base knower, the four preparations, the preparation for completing the aspects, the path preparation, the final preparation, the momentary preparation and then the eighth category, And then the eight categories are further divided into the 70 topics, of which we have completed.
The 10 topics concerned with the first of the categories that is exalted knower of all aspects. The 10 topics being mind generation, precepts, the four limbs of discrimination, the nature of the element of qualities which is the basis for achieving, the object of observation, the achievement of the Mahāyāna as a great vehicle doctrine, armor, activities and engagement, collection, defence and working. So having completed the first category, we’re now going to begin the discussion of the second that is path knower. Between exalted knower this is the second and this will be explained in terms of 11 topics. So if we were to ask the reason why is path knower presented second after the first category of exalted knower of all aspects.
The exalted knower of all aspects is the consciousness of a Buddha. That is, a Buddha is a person who has such a type of omniscient consciousness. And then what method do we need to meditate on in order to actually attain such a state of consciousness that is the exalted, knower of all aspects? And this method is the path knower which is the means, the method to attain exalted and knowable aspect. So the path knower is to be understood by means of the 11 topics.
And the first of these 11 topics is the limbs of knowers of path. The limbs of knowers of path is the first of its 11 topics. The the second is the the path knower which is the knower of the hearer’s path, of the hearer’s path, the knower of hearer’s path. The third is the knower of the solitary realizer’s path. Then the fourth is amongst the there are five paths and amongst these is the path of seeing.
And this fourth topic is the great vehicle path of seeing, cultivated on this occasion. The great vehicle path of seeing cultivated on this occasion. The fifth topic is the function of a great vehicle path of meditation. The function of a great vehicle path of meditation. And the sixth is a great vehicle path of meditation of belief.
A great vehicle path of meditation of belief. The the the seventh is the the benefits of belief. The eighth topic is the great vehicle path of meditation and dedication. The great vehicle path of meditation and dedication. The ninth is the great vehicle path of meditation of admiration or rejoicing.
The great vehicle path of meditation of admiration. Then the tenth is the great vehicle path of meditation of achievement. The great vehicle path of meditation of achievement. And then the eleventh is the completely pure great vehicle path of meditation. The completely pure great vehicle path of meditation.
So we’ll begin with the first of these 11, the limbs of the knowers of path. And this will be discussed in terms of the three divisions of definition, division and boundary. There are no synonyms. Definition, division and boundary. So the definition of the the the limbs of path knower.
So I might have to work this out as we go along. It is a is either the cause, either I’ll just give you the words and I’ll work it out. Either of the three results, nature, or cause of a path knower which is included within either of the result, nature or cause of a path knower conjoined with great compassion. A special quality included with either included in either within either of the three, comma, result, nature, a cause of a path knower conjoined with great compassion. A special quality which is included within either of the three, comma, result, nature, or cause of path knower conjoined with great compassion.
So there was a special quality which is included in either of the three results, nature or cause of the path knower conjoined with great compassion. That’s the definition of a limb of the knower of the path. Then the divisions, there are five. So we’re going to explain the meaning meaning of this definition and by means of the first verse in the ornament itself. Now first it talks about in order to make suitable the gods and with the explaining the gods, we talk about the three realms.
There are three realms, The desire realm, form realm, and formless realm. So within the desire realm, there are five types of migrators. There are within the three bad migrations, are the hell beings, hungry ghosts, and animals. And then the upper, the happy migrations, are the the the two types of human and gods. That is to say desire gods.
When when we speak of humans, we’re necessarily talking about a desire being. But in terms of when we talk about God, there’s the three types of Gods. There’s the Gods of desire, the Gods of the form and form of realm. So some examples of various types of desire gods are sun, the moon, the stars, etc.. These are all the the stars in the sky are desired gods, for example.
So the the the god the level of god is attained by the means of very excellent karma. And in this attainment of the God, the level of God, it is associated with a very beautiful body, a body made of light, a very light radiant body. That is why we say that the sun and the moon are desire realm gods, desire level gods. And even beyond this, even within the upper realm gods, such as the gods of the first concentration, the second concentration, etcetera, their light is even more radiant. So the the sun and the moon are the houses of the the are the abode of the of the abode of the gods of the moon, the gods of the sun.
And these these beings which reside within the Sun and Moon are extremely radiant. And just like the current running within a light bulb, to the power of this current in the light bulb it radiates out a very bright light. So due to the beautiful and lustrous light body, they developed a great deal of pride. Because the gods have a great deal of pride with regards to their beautiful and lustrous light body. In order to remove their pride, the Buddha radiate out light from their bodies.
And they radiate out light in such a way that it is the same as if a star which appears at night disappears when in comparison when the sun rises. And so the Buddha’s radiant light compared to the gods radiant light is like the sun compared to the stars. When they see this beautiful radiant light that the Buddha is able to shine out, their pride is completely eliminated. The first two lines of the first which can introduce is path knower. In order to make suitable the gods by the light by producing lustrous skin.
The gods are made in order to make the gods suitable. Parentheses the Buddha radiate out their lustrous light. What this means is out of their compassion, the Buddha’s compassion, the Buddha’s emanates beings who have very beautiful and lustrous bodies. And then when gods see them, they think to themselves, have never seen such a beautiful radiant light body that has never been seen in the world before. It outshines even the sun and the moon and therefore their pride is diminished and they develop great faith in the Buddha.
Not pride, faith in the Buddha. So the the the the gods, when they when they see the beautiful and lustrous bodies, the emanation, they like it very much. Develop great faith. And they go on to ask, how did you develop such a lustrous radiant body? And the emanation’s answer is that such a body arises in dependence upon meditating on the awakening heart.
And therefore this is the cause of attaining such a lustrous radiant body, beautiful body, lustrous beautiful body. And therefore is by this means that the Buddha diminishes the pride of the gods and this acts as a cause for them to meditate on the path knower, which is the cause of this beautiful body. They cannot explain directly the path knower. They explain by means of, telling them what is the cause of such a light body that’s inspiring them to meditate on the awakening heart, which is the cause of attaining the lustrous beautiful body. There are the five limbs of the path knower.
And the first one is the limb of obstacles. And this is that due to pride that these gods cannot generate. They will not meditate the awakening heart and thereby generate the path knower. And it is by means of this beautiful and radiant and lustrous body that this conflicting condition is removed and they become suitable to develop the path knower. So the first of these five is obstacle.
So the second of these five limbs is conducive condition. As we discussed previously with respect to path knower, with the boundaries of path knower, there are five great vehicle paths: accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning. There is no path knower on these first two accumulation and preparation. The path knower begins on the path of seeing, meditation and no more learning. In order to get to the path of seeing we must develop the awakening heart.
Therefore the conducive condition is the generation of the awakening heart. The third limb is substantial cause. Substantial cause. We take the example of when we plant a seed, a sprout grows. The seed is the substantial cause of the sprout.
But we also need the condition, the conducive condition. Conducive condition as was mentioned is the awakening heart. In case of the seed, conducive condition is warmth and water and soil. These are the conducive conditions. The substantial cause of the seed in terms of developing the path knower, the conducive condition as was mentioned is the awakening heart.
The actual substantial cause, that is the main cause, is the activation of the great vehicle lineage. Activation of great vehicle lineage is the substantial cause of the path knower. So if we go back and explain these first three limbs by means of analogy, using the growing a crop in a field, the first thing that we have to do is prepare the field, that we have to remove the various obstacles, the hindrance to the production of the crop, the grain of the crop. And so we remove all the stones and fallen trees, wood from the field, preparing the field. This is the first removal of the limb of obstacles.
This is removing obstacles. So that’s removing the conflicting conditions. Then we have to create the conducive conditions. We add water, we add fertilizer to the field providing conducive conditions. And then finally we need the main cause and the substantial cause is seed, planting the seed itself.
Now applying this analogy to the meaning, in order to develop the path knower. First we have to overcome the obstructions. We have to remove the conflicting condition. Conflicting condition is pride. It’s necessary to remove pride.
Then we need to develop, to provide the conducive condition and this is the awakening heart. Then we need to have the main cause or the substantial cause and this is the activation of the great vehicle lineage. So these we’ve mentioned these three limbs necessary to develop a path knower. That is the removing of the obstruction by removing the pride, providing the conditions by developing a awakening heart and then finally having the substantial cause which is the activation of the great vehicle lineage. In talking about the nature of the limb, in terms of a person, when we say a person does very good actions, say this person is a good natured person.
When a person does that very bad actions, say, oh, this person doesn’t have a very good nature. This is a bad natured person. So we’re going to discuss what the nature of the path knower in trying to determine its quality. In general we can say the general meaning of a path knower is the understanding of the complete path of the three vehicles. The complete understanding of the path of the three vehicles, the vehicles of the hearer, solitary realizer and the bodhisattva.
This understanding is what we mean by path knower. Now it has what is its nature? This is its ideal of its meaning. It has the qualities of not taking attachment as a main abandonment. In general, not taking attachment as a main abandonment.
In general, because attachment is an afflictive emotion, is to be abandoned, but it’s not taken as a main abandonment. Whereas, for example, in the lesser vehicle, attachment is the main abandonment, but it’s not in the path knower. And the main practitioner of path knower is the great vehicle superior. The main practitioner of path knower is the great vehicle superior. And it is by means of path knower that the purposes of the three types of lineages are able to be fulfilled. That is by means of the path knower that the purposes of the three types lineage.
Of I’m able to fulfill this, the lineage of the hearer, the solitary realizer, and the bodhisattva.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.