46 min · 3,231 words · 9 November 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues an earlier session on the knower of the path, explaining the tenth and eleventh of the eleven divisions: the path of meditation’s accomplishment and the perfectly pure path of meditation. It covers how these uncontaminated paths abandon the afflictive and knowledge obscurations, using the analogy of a doctor treating illness, and concludes that method and wisdom are applied together.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-11-09
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 8a03bb9e-b4a5-4b60-b45c-8e1c11c49fdb
Words: 3,227
We will meditate for about three minutes trying to transform our person motivation into that of bodhicitta, thinking that in order to remove all the sufferings of sentient beings as infinite as the expanse of the infinite space, and in order to place them to excellent happiness, firstly, I must try myself to get rid of all the faults, and I should try to myself be with all the excellent qualities, and for which purpose I will listen I will listen to these teachings and be interested in the studies of it. So meditate for three minutes. In the last teaching, we were talking about or the explanation was about path knower which has eleven divisions. And out of eleven divisions, nine has already been explained. And tonight, the explanation will be from the remaining two, tenth and eleventh.
So the two remaining are basically under the category of the minor part of meditation. So the minor part of meditation is one of the five paths: path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, and then meditation being the fourth. The remaining two tonight, they belong to that Mahāyāna part of meditation. And Mahāyāna part of meditation itself is of two divisions, contaminated mind part of meditation and uncontaminated mind part of meditation. And contaminated mind part of meditation has three divisions: path of meditation’s inclination, path of meditation’s dedication, path of meditation’s rejoicing, and they have all been explained.
And tonight, the two remaining belong to the uncontaminated, minor part of meditation, and those two are part of what are called minor uncontaminated part of meditation’s complete pure minor part of meditation. So that’s the one. So when you explain. So the two belonging to uncontaminated path of meditation are path of meditation’s accomplishment being the first and completely pure path of meditation. And regarding the first one, the what I call path of meditation’s accomplishment, it has three definition, divisions, and ranging borders.
So regarding the definition, the first part of definition goes like being a subsequent thorough realization being sorry. Being uncontaminated subsequent realization of the great vehicle because it belongs to the great vehicle. So to repeat, being uncontaminated subsequent realization of the great vehicle. And one which so the remaining part of definition, one which leaves the, handprint. So that’s literally one which leaves the handprint, handprint of the ultimate, realization.
One which leaves the handprint of ultimate realization. So here in the first part of definition where it says uncontaminated subsequent thorough realization of great vehicle. So why it is called why it called uncontaminated is because it basically belongs within the category of uncontaminated minor part of meditation whereas in the last three we had put in the first part of definition in the last three that would be seven, eight and nine. So in those three the definition starts with contaminated subsequent thorough realization of the great vehicle. So in last teaching, we missed the word subsequent that has been stated with those previous three definitions: contaminated subsequent thorough realization of the great vehicle.
And why there is a difference between contaminated and uncontaminated is because here contamination refers to the mind of conceptuality and uncontaminated refers to mind without conceptuality. So normally, that’s the standard translation for the word poka in Tibetan. Because it is a mind without conception, therefore it is uncontaminated. And because it is a mind with conception, therefore, it is, we call, contaminated. So regarding conception and nonconception, already Rinpoche has explained in the past teachings when his teaching was on the subject of Lorig, mind and mind and awareness.
So in that, it has already been explained clearly that, basically, mind is of two kind. From one angle, basically, mind is of two kind, conceptual mind and nonconception mind. And in the second part of definition here, there is a word called ultimate realization. So here realization is not realization in the sense of the word where sometimes the Tibetan word topa can mean realization, but of same designation, the word togpa sometimes is also a word for conception. So here, the realization being in the second part of the definition, this realization refers to realization of the grounds and path, meaning it is the realization of the actual practice.
And because Buddhist realization is the ultimate way one can go and there is not any point beyond that, therefore this ultimate realization refers to realization which one attains in being a Buddha. And the second part after that in the definition it says, which leaves the handprint. So this is literally translated translated because sometimes I feel it much better not to interpret. So which leaves handprint, it’s a literal translation. It could be better as a word, which leaves potential for which leaves potential of ultimate realization.
That could be an alternate way of translating. Leaves handprint is explained as meaning the means by which one has to attain that ultimate realization. So, this which leaves handprint means the means, and means refer in this context the whole path by which one attains the state of Buddhahood. So why here it says the means, to attain that ultimate realization? And in the definition literally, which leaves the handprint, of the ultimate realization is because this being this tenth one being a part of a knower of the path, and knower of the path being the means to attain what already in the past Rinpoche explained the first of the eight eight topics.
The first one is the omniscient mind or literally called the knower of all aspects. So that knower of all aspects is the result and it has to be attained by the different means of which the second among the eight categories is the knower of the path. And this has five divisions, so that would be second. First thing, definition. And regarding the five, let’s not let’s not talk about them.
And regarding the third one, the ranging border, it ranges from first ground, first Mayana ground to the last continuity. That is the moment before attaining Buddhahood. And regarding the ground, the first ground, it means the first among the ten Mahāyāna grounds. And then the next one in the eleventh series is the perfectly pure path of meditation. And this is, basically same as the previous one, path of meditation’s accomplishment, but because it is a little bit slightly different in functions to the function to the tenth one, therefore it has been categorized as separate.
And this has three parts, definition, divisions, and ranging borders. So regarding definition, the first part is same as the previous one being a uncontaminated or subsequent to realization of the great vehicle. So that part is same as the previous one. And the second part is slightly different. Here we see, ultimate abandonment instead of ultimate realization.
So it goes, the second part here in the definition goes, which leaves the handprint or which leaves the potential of ultimate abandonment. So to be really precise, both the definition we have to say which is to leave the potential of the ultimate realization, and in the second, which is to leave the potential of ultimate abandonment. So, making it as means. And regarding the first meaning of the first part of definition is exactly the same as the previous one, and the meaning of the second part of definition where the word says the abandonment. So this abandonment refers to all the faults, and faults refers to the two kinds of obscuration, obscuration of the pure wisdom and afflictive obscurations, obscurations of delusions.
In other words, obscurations of pure wisdom and obscurations of delusions. And these two, when one completely abandons, that is the ultimate abandonment. And that ultimate abandonment is only in the continuum of Buddha. Therefore, this one, this eleven in the eleven series, this one, the perfectly pure path of meditation, is a means to attain that ultimate abandonment which is within a continuum of Buddha. And regarding Buddhahood, it comprises of four divisions and whether Rinpoche has explained about it or not or whether it’s still in your memories, Rinpoche is not sure.
But when there was explanation about eight categories or eight topics, the last one is called the resultant dharma body, Dharmakāya, and that resultant Dharma body is of four divisions: the entity body and the pure wisdom Dharmakāya, and the emanation body and the enjoyment body. So those four are the possible four maximum aspects of Buddha and they are called the four kayas or four bodies. And those four can be included into two bodies of Buddha and those two bodies are from the point of two aspects. One from the aspect of perfection of one’s interest or one’s perfection of accomplishing one’s welfare, one’s interest. And other is from the point of perfection in accomplishing others’ welfare.
So in short, those four bodies of Buddha can be summarized to two. The body of perfection of one’s interest and body of perfection of other’s interest. And with the Buddha, there is an aspect of mind with his mind which knows everything, and that knowing of everything is called the ultimate realization, and that is for his own interest, meaning that being able to know everything is a perfection of his own interest, of his own welfare. And also with Buddha’s mind, there’s another aspect which is the aspect of being perfected, of having abandoned all the faults of creation, and that aspect is called ultimate abandonment. And both these comprise the self interest perfect both these mix the Buddha’s body, which is perfection of one’s interest.
So with the body of perfection of one’s interest, with this it has two aspects of which one is I call perfection of having ultimate realization. And this, what I call perfection, ultimate realization is the mind knowing everything. And this mind knowing everything is something to be accomplished. And because it is to be accomplished and because this eleven are what are called, tenth in the eleventh series, the, path of meditation’s accomplishment. Because this tenth in the eleventh series is a means to accomplish that ultimate realization.
Therefore, it is named it is called by the name the what are called path of meditation’s accomplishment. And regarding the eleventh one, which is called perfectly pure path of meditation, why it is called perfectly pure path of meditation is because it is the one which is a means to remove all the faults, eliminate all the faults, and what I call completely make oneself purified of all the faults of obscuration. And that’s, how these two from their functions, these two from the different functions, have, their respective different names, the tenth and eleventh. Fundamentally, these tenth and eleventh, the path of meditation’s accomplishment and perfectly pure path of meditation. Fundamentally these two are one, but they are called by different names just because of different functions.
The first one is means to accomplish all the good qualities and the second one is a means to get rid of all the faults. That’s how they got the different names. For example, with the flower on in in on the front on the table, so that flower is called by two different names. It’s impermanent. It’s called by the name impermanence, a noun, and it’s also called a product.
And why it is called impermanence is because it is subject to being disintegrated moment by moment. So it doesn’t stay the next moment. Therefore, is impermanence. And why it is called product is because it is so literally product in Tibetan or normal translation, they tend to use word product. So literally, it is what’s called done deed.
So why it is called product is because it has been done or formed by the combination of causes and conditions. Therefore, it came into being. But in basic or fact, it just refers to the same flower, different name. So you got it clear that those two names are given from point of one being the means to accomplish all the good qualities and another as means to get rid of all the faults. So means to abandon, means to get rid of faults.
So what are those fouls? Which one has to abandon and get rid of? So those faults are principally categorized or being grouped into two: the afflictive obscurations and pure wisdom obscurations. And afflictive obscuration refers to delusions, normally translated as delusions like the mind of attachment, hatred, and ignorance. And pure wisdom obscuration refers to the misconception of everything being truly existent and literally called truth grasping mind.
So that is what is referred by the second obscuration, pure wisdom obscuration. And to go into more detail, the pure wisdom obscuration means the truth grasping mind together with its imprints. Why attachment, hatred, ignorance and other what are called impure thoughts are called by the name afflictive obscuration is because whenever they arise instantly, it brings within the person affliction, suffering, discomfort, uneasiness. Therefore, it’s called afflictive or obscuration, which afflicts, which brings sufferings. And that’s how it has to be understood.
And normally, do not, exist truly. They are not formed truly, but still our ignorant mind grasps things and apprehends to everything as being truly existing. And that mind is called literally truth grasping mind. And that is what is referred by the second obscuration, pure wisdom obscuration, or literally knowledge obscuration. And sometimes they also translate as obscuration to omniscience.
But it’s best knowledge obscuration. And why it is called knowledge obscuration is because whoever has that mind, then this mind obscures the person in seeing the reality nature of the things of knowledge. And therefore, it is called by that name knowledge obscuration. It obscures the person in seeing the reality nature of the things to be known, things of knowledge. Now the reason why we have to abandon the afflictive obscurations is because if we have the afflictive obscurations, then because of them we will have to experience suffering, we will have to continuously wander in the cyclic existence.
And also the reason why we have to abandon the, what I call, knowledge obscuration is because from one point of view, if we have knowledge obscuration, then we will not be able to see the reality nature of things. And also, in order to perfectly accomplish the welfare of others, or in other words, in order to perfectly do the welfare of others, one must know each and every mentality of different sentient beings. And as long as one, what I call, doesn’t have one has this, what I call, knowledge obscuration, one will not be able to see the different mentalities of sentient beings. And because of that, how much ever one may try to satisfy, fulfill other sentient beings’ wishes, they may not be appropriate and may not be successful. And that’s the reason why we have to abandon the second obscuration.
For example, if a patient has to be recovered, firstly, or whichever doctor is treating the patient has to know what sort of sickness the patient has got and the doctor has to know root causes of the sickness and then if he gives medicine then the patient will be recovered. But if he doesn’t perfectly identify the sickness and its causes, and even though he may give medicine, it might become medical poisoning or may not work. So in that case, the doctor has to know the sickness and its causes. Regarding a doctor, even though how much ever, what called expert he may be, he can cure only physical sickness. Regarding mental sickness, the doctor who can really cure at the most perfect level is only a compassionate or enlightened being like a Buddha.
Nobody else. As the bodhisattva who is striving on the path, in this case not of the path on this level, he is striving on the path in order to attain the state of Buddhahood omniscience so that he may be able to understand each and every mentality, different sentient beings, and then to work in accordance to what they need. Therefore, that’s the reason why at this point the bodhisattva on the path has to get rid of all the two kinds of obscurations. In what I call trying to in trying to get rid of all the faults of obscuration, normally, the means by which one has to one one has to get rid of is through the paths and grounds. So part and ground, when we talk about parts, refer to the five minor parts.
And regarding five minor parts, the first two, the path of accumulation and path of preparation, those two cannot be, what I call strong means enough to eliminate all the faults and obscuration. And regarding the last one part of no more learning, it is the resultant, destination. Therefore, it doesn’t have anything to do with the means to eliminate the or abandon the obscuration. Therefore, the real means out of the five paths, five minor parts are the two by which one abandons the obscuration. And regarding the two, they are the path of seeing and path of meditation.
And path of seeing, it can eliminate, so path of seeing and path of meditation, these two are the real by which one has to combat like in a fight between two enemies. So here, these two are the real, what called challenger against all the obscuration. And regarding path of seeing, it can only eliminate just cause, literally cause the cause and all imputed afflictions, and it cannot eliminate and abandon the subtle obscuration. Therefore, a part of meditation, a minor part of meditation, is the only real means by which the practitioner applies in trying to abandon all the obscurations. Regarding the path of meditation, it is of two kinds, contaminated path of meditation and uncontaminated path of meditation.
And contaminated path of meditation is of three: path of meditation’s inclination, path of meditation’s dedication, and path of meditation’s rejoicing. And all those three are conceptions, conceptions in the proper sense of the word, being not, being not, what call, being not handled by the realization of the emptiness. And how their conceptions are examples like bodhicitta, conventional bodhicitta, and great compassion. And those were called contaminated paths of meditation represented by such thoughts of conceptions like bodhicitta, conventional bodhicitta and great compassion, they are not able to combat directly with the obscurations. Therefore, they only have the practitioner indirectly to combat against the obscuration.
Therefore, the practitioner has to apply an uncontaminated means non conceptual means by which he can directly combat the obscuration. Therefore, there are the remaining two of the path of meditation. Path of meditation’s accomplishment and perfectly pure path of meditation which are uncontaminated, what we call, path of meditation. And they are uncontaminated in the sense they are not conceptions, in the sense that they are wisdom directly realizing emptiness. Therefore, practitioner has to apply the indirect means to combat the obscuration along with the direct means of combating the obscuration.
Therefore, one is called method and the other one is called wisdom. Therefore, the practitioner at this point in trying to get rid of obscuration combinedly applies the method and wisdom.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- four kayas catuhkaya (Skt); ku zhi (Tib)
- The classification of a buddha’s body into four: jnanakaya (wisdom body), svabhavikakaya (nature body), sambhogakaya (enjoyment body) and nirmanakaya (emanation body). LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
- The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
- sambhogakaya enjoyment body; long ku (Tib)
- The enjoyment body; the form in which the enlightened mind appears in order to benefit highly realized bodhisattvas. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.