Ornament for Clear Realisations – 56 2004 09 23 OCR

45 min · 3,751 words · 23 September 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 56 2004 09 23 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk surveys Buddhist critiques of mistaken views about the self and the continuum of mind, including permanence-based views and the materialist Lokayata school. It then explains the logical structure of Tibetan debate, definitions and syllogisms, and the four conditions of a moment of mind: continuum, object, governing and preceding moment. It ends with a description of how monks debate in pairs and groups.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-09-23

Duration: 46 min

UUID: fceeca6d-a237-43bb-9816-9d0241700c68

Words: 3,747

So if you Okay. So there’s others that had a different kind of clairvoyance. Of course, they’re looking at other people. They have the eye of the gods, not the clairvoyance of future lives. Right.

So in dependence on the clairvoyance that is the eye of the gods as opposed to the clairvoyance, which is the clairvoyance where you can see past and future lives of your of your own continuum. And they were able to there was other beings that were able to perceive that their beings may go from higher realms to lower realms and lower realms to higher realms, but they continued on in these realms, and because of this, because there was a continuation of one being through these different states, and then they used that as a as a basis for asserting a self and saying that that self was permanent. Because they said, look, this person may go from this life to that life and this life to that life and backwards and forwards, but they don’t stop. And there is a continuum here, and this that means that they are because they are permanent, that they are going from one place to another and they don’t end, that that means that they have a self and that self is permanent. So they use this to determine this view for them.

Yeah. So there’s some other people who, in dependence on their clairvoyance, came up with the idea that some things were permanent and other things weren’t permanent. And so they said that Brahmin and Brahmin’s retinue were said to have been born as humans and then through their abilities, be reborn in god realms. So and they could see they having developed the ability to be reborn in the retinue of Brahma, they they had the ability to perceive that Brahma was someone who didn’t die, but then they could see that other beings around them died. So there was others who, based on their clairvoyance, decided that there was Brahma and his retinue and that the gods of those realms were permanent and lived forever, but all other beings weren’t, yeah, because they died and moved on.

So they said that Brahma was permanent and everybody else wasn’t. No. All Brahma and his retinue were permanent and nobody else was is what I should say. So in this way that they said there was another sorry. There was another There was another group that said that that which was permanent was the mind, and the mind was the self, the mind moved from one lifetime to another to another.

But all of the other parts of the being and the world that they lived in wasn’t permanent. And it wasn’t permanent, it wasn’t self. So in this way, they said that the thing that was permanent was the mind, and the permanent end was the self, was the mind, and the things that weren’t permanent was the other phenomena. Okay. So there’s some other weird dude who were the opposite because they had turned into gods that were I said, that’s really strange.

He guessed it. Yeah. No. No. It is really strange.

Anyway, so that’s why I could say that they’re weird dudes. They they had reached the level of being what’s called peak gods or gods who existed on the peak of the desire realm. And then they had this experience of their comrades or their companions dying. So they thought, well, we’re not permanent, obviously, because we can see people dying. But all other beings must be permanent because they go from lifetime to lifetime to lifetime to lifetime.

So they so they posited themselves as being impermanent and gave these teachings to people and then said everyone else was permanent. Because they went from lifetime to lifetime, but god didn’t. Yeah. Yeah. That’s exactly.

It is weird, isn’t Yeah. So because the the reason that’s given for this is that these gods could see some of their companions dying and then being reborn as humans. They thought that couldn’t possibly be the case, and therefore there must be an impermanence for them, for other beings going from one place to another as they tended to be they they seem to be permanent. Okay. So then we’re up to the third type of people that had wrong views.

It is one that needed to be refuted by the perception of their lack of self and this is those that didn’t think that there was any kind of continuum. They proposed there was two different types of groups that proposed a lack of continuum between lifetimes And now the first of those groups was the followers of a person who had been existed in the formless realm, and after dying from the formless realm was reborn as a long life god. And because through the clairvoyance that came with these states of being, he was able not able to see any continuity, between these two different states. He couldn’t see how, his previous life had led to the life of being a desire realm god. Then he posited or he he or the god he or she posited the idea that there was no continuum between lifetimes, that there was just advantageous conditions that brought into being a situation based on meditative stabilization or samadhi.

So these two existences that he experienced, he or she, this god, said there was no link between these two states that he experienced. So he could clairvoyantly see the two states, couldn’t see a link between those two. So he posited that we experience different existences, but there’s no link between the different existences we experience. Okay. So the second type of people that were putting forward ideas that weren’t about continued were were anti the idea of a continuum at the time of the Buddha were those who said that the self came into about came into being based on a combination of air and the parts of the body, combination of air and fire and so on.

And therefore, were their self was the result of this coming together of elements in much the same way that a flower is a result of a plant’s wishing to to germinate. So there was no real significance to that situation. So we can stop there. Well, my head’s going. Okay.

Because in order the the definition of a, knower of basis is a mind which gets rid of incorrect minds and things that cause, suffering, and it’s going through all the incorrect ways of thinking that need to be gotten rid of. In the definition understanding what? In the definition of a knower of basis that that’s defined as the knowledge characteristics of a knower of basis, it says that they are and that which gets rid of the mistaken bases of wrong views. So this is going through the wrong views. Okay, so a characteristic and a definition is the same thing in Tibetan.

Okay, so a whole bunch of characteristics give you a definition. So one of the characteristics that makes up the definition of a knower of basis is that it is the application which gets rid of wrong views. And in order for us to understand this application, need to understand the wrong views is getting rid of. Does that make sense? Yeah.

Yeah. That’s Christianity? And souls aren’t permanent? Sorry. And souls aren’t permanent?

Geshe-la said that the reason that they posited this idea was that they that Brahma and his retinue lived for such a long time that in order to have the clairvoyance and to perceive the death of Brahma, you have to have incredibly powerful clairvoyance. And so they were unable to perceive the death of Brahma, and so therefore they thought that Brahma didn’t die. Alright? Because it was such that Brahma lives Brahma and his retinue lived for such a long time. And he said, but the he as far as he understands it, in Christianity, they say that Jesus’ Jesus’ body died and then came back to life.

So that has to be has to say that that’s not impermanent either. Sorry. That’s not permanent either. But so he said that they in Christianity, they say they seem to posit the the mind or the the the self of of god and Jesus as being permanent, but not necessarily the physical form. Mhmm.

Sure. So a flower oh, yeah. Okay. Again, I’m just pointing out that you you do seem very interested in this stuff, you guys. Okay.

I’ve lost my place. Now he’s laughing at me because I lost my place. Okay. So what that means is that sometimes it’s there, sometimes it’s not. And I said, Geshe-la, is that the Lokayatas?

Do you remember those guys from the tenants? The ones that they’re they’re they’re often called the hedonists, but that that’s not a very good translation. Yeah. They’re basically materialists. Yeah.

Mean, life is advantageous. Yeah. Life is advantageous. The same way that a flower comes about, and it’s there when it’s there, and it’s not when it’s not. Yeah.

Yeah. So they say that yeah. The materialists. He said, yeah. So they’re supposed to have clear points too, but he doesn’t know he doesn’t think they’re clear point they’re very good at clear points, if that was the view that they came up with.

At least the other guys had a bit more of a clue. So, yeah, this is it. Yeah. And it’s like the Kerry Packer clairvoyance. I was just telling them about what happened to Kerry Packer.

Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Sure. Yeah.

I said, yeah. We’re talking about people with very amazing qualities. Tradition is that they don’t have the three higher trainings. They don’t have the trainings of ethics, the training of wisdom, and the training of meditation altogether. So if you don’t have things with the three higher trainings attached to them, then your view doesn’t become focused on others as much.

Yeah. And so you don’t have renunciation properly. So he said if they could just develop renunciation, imagine how amazing they’d be. I’m not having a good night. As if it wasn’t difficult enough to try and translate.

I’m trying to how do I translate big bang? Yeah? As as if it wasn’t hard enough trying to figure out ways to translate the He’s like, so what was this big explosion? Did you have, like No. No.

But Geshe-la wants to know now because I had to try and explain. Yeah. But what exploded? He wants to know. Energy and matter are the same words.

Oh, it’s guess like, is that kind of fits with Buddhism? Because from the potential of karma, we exist. So it’s like the energy of karma, we come into Oh, this. This is so it’s like come explodes. You know?

Heard him from come exploding. So guess I said so you can’t this this is where it comes on stock because you’re looking for an answer in form, and the answer is not in form or answers in the using the idea of karma and the idea of beings creating karma. So if you limit what you’re looking for, then you’re not going to find any answers. So they have to think outside what they’re looking for in order to find that. So so it all has to come down to the potentiality, and the potentiality can only come about through action.

Okay. So just for people who don’t know, the basis of a Tibetan Buddhist debate starts with an object. Alright? And we say are taking, for example, the cup. Okay?

So you say, take, for example, a cup. Alright? Or the object of the debate is the cup. You can translate it either way. Yeah?

Then you say either it is impermanent because it is an object. Yeah? Or it is what was? Okay. So it is blue.

Therefore, it it has a color. Alright? So you can activate things. So you start off take this for example. It is such and such because of something else.

So that’s the, like, the pattern of the syllogisms. So that’s the basis of a definite a that’s the base. Yeah. It doesn’t work. This is this is the basis of a what’s called a syllogism.

But then you also it’s the same way for syllogism as they use for definition. Alright? So you’re developing a syllogism like an idea. This is this because it is this. It’s the same way of saying the definition of something is this, this, this, and this.

Alright? And so the same process is happening. You’re establishing that something is something because of valid reasons. Alright? But that can be called some is sometimes what’s translated as a definition, sometimes what’s translated as a syllogism, sometimes what’s translated as a debate, and sometimes what’s translated as a whole school of logical thinking.

But they all blend into one in one word into it. So should you I I know I’m probably getting this word wrong, but you have this idea of a definition and a definindum. Right? A definition describes something, so it’s explaining the characteristics of something. And a definindum is the instance of that thing that you’re describing.

So every moment of a mind stream is a definiendum, is something that needs a definition in order to describe it. Alright? So we’re dealing with all of the different aspects of the bodhisattva’s mind stream, the definitums that exist within the bodhisattva’s mind stream, and this is describing the is giving the definitions for those definitums. That or definitum meaning that which is being defined. He goes, yes.

Well, if you don’t think it is an object because it is an impermanent thing, And just think it is an entity because it is defined by its characteristics that may make it easier for you. He goes this, and then I went, well, actually, the question was this. And I went, oh, wait a minute. You just answered that before I actually got that. Okay.

So when you’re talking about the conditions is like you know one of those nights when you think, oh, was getting somewhere, and now my brain has been so stretched, I feel like I know nothing? Alright. You have four different conditions with that condition every moment of consciousness. First of these is what’s called the condition of the continuum, and that is that you have a similar moment of mind as a continuation of similar moments of a similar type. That is that they are all mind.

They all have this thing in common that they’re mind. Yeah? So that’s what’s called the a continuum condition. That’s just the fact that one mind creates another mind. It doesn’t create matter or it doesn’t create a a non associated or factor.

A moment of mind precedes a moment of mind. So it doesn’t turn into matter. Mind doesn’t turn into matter. A mind doesn’t turn into a non-associated compositional factor. Alright?

So it’s like the continuum condition. Every moment of mind. So an object condition is that the mind takes different objects. So they can be completely different depending on what the object is. And it doesn’t have to be a sequence behind those.

Alright? And the third type of condition. Okay. Now the next condition is so we have two conditions. Right?

First of have the condition of a continuum happening. Second one we have is the condition of an object, which can flutter from one thing to another. The third condition is what’s called the empowering condition or the governing condition, and this is the presence of mind. Alright? So the the ability to to for mind to be present in it in itself.

This is actually a synonym of the first one, the continuum of mind. If you have a continuum it goes from one thing to another. One moment of mind creates another moment of mind, this is a that’s the continuum, but the fact that that a governing condition is the preceding moment of mind. So if you have a preceding moment of mind, you can have a moment of mind after that. You can’t have something that isn’t mind.

Yeah? And you can’t create mind from something that isn’t mind. Okay. So the governing condition and the continuum condition are the same. And there’s also something that’s called the preceding moment the condition of the preceding moment.

And this is a synonym when you’re dealing with mind is the same as well. So the fact that you had a preceding moment of mind means that you have to have a subsequent moment of mind because of the concept of time. Well, something proceeding has to have something after it. So when you’re dealing with mind, the preceding moment, the condition of the preceding moment, the condition of the governing condition and the continuing condition are all the same thing, but the object’s condition isn’t. And this is why our mind can flutter from one thing to another, but still stays as mind.

Yeah. The the condition of the preceding moment. I’m sure there’s a bit of translation for that that I can’t remember. Like, something that sounds a lot smarter. Uh-uh.

Yes. I said, yeah. Sometimes they would. Sometimes they they wouldn’t. It depends on what they chose to do for that day.

So for example, if they gotten up to this stage in this text, then some people may decide to take then and you you’d have, like, a a lot of people debating on this this section of the text. And some may people may decide to take on the the role of a a negative view, in order to understand why it was wrong, and other people would choose to do something totally different. It depends on what they chose to do in that in that day. So you don’t so you wouldn’t necessarily do one thing every day all the time because you just do it so much that you do it in in all different ways and approach it from any different way. And so on any given day, you may have a number of people doing it one way and another people doing it another way, But you wouldn’t wanna do it the same way every day because you wouldn’t learn anything.

So he said that sometimes you do it so usually, you do it like one on one. So every day, you’d be having a different debate partner, and you go around in a circle debating one person and the next person and the next person and the next person. And so you get a different you you may use the same argument for a while until you’ve gotten the answers that you want. But then you have other situations where you have big groups of people debating together. So then you’d apply different techniques when you’re you’re debating in big groups.

He said, now do you wanna go and do it? No. And it’s so much fun to watch. It’s like if you get them doing it in groups, you know, you’ve seen it doing it in groups. It’s like the little ones have no chance.

The big ones chuck them out of the road. You guys just say, yeah. Yeah. If you’re a bigger monkey, get more chance of winning in debate because you you know, you get chucked out of the road. I’ve seen it.

I picked my It’s a good show. Yeah. Yes. Said it’s great because it gets stuff into your head that you’ve been learning. So it’s not just going around in your head.

It actually sticks there because you you have to use it. And it’s good exercise because you’re always fighting and, like, jumping up around and down and stuff. And it’s it’s fun. It makes everyone happy because they’re, like, they’re laughing their heads off while they do it, and, you know, they don’t take it that seriously. So they they have fun.

They get exercise, and things get into their brain. Example, if they’re going through a text, then they could start the debate with about six people focusing on one person, and they’re all doing the same studies. So the six people would say to this one person, we want you to explain this this quote from a text. Right? And if that person so they had to explain that text, what they quote.

You know? They had to explain what it meant to them and explain what he was referring to. Now if they said it really well, it would be harder for the people that were arguing with them to find fault in it, but they could still do it. Alright? But if there was one tiny thing wrong in what they said, they’d have six people jumping on them.

Like, you said this, and you can’t say that because of this. So in this way, even none of them would ever be able to say it perfectly right so that people would wouldn’t be able to find a fault in it. But even if it was the smallest fault, they could make a big argument out of that. So it would mean that you had to know the texts incredibly well and know what they mean very well. Uh-huh.

It is. Yeah. Very fast. He says you have to think very fast because you get things thrown at you all the time, and you instantly have to have a response. And so you have your brain has to get very fast.

He goes, do think I do up here every time? Oh, you said, yeah. Because you guys haven’t had the same experiences studying as I have, so, of course, I’m gonna win, but it’s the same thing. He said if if you guys are all monks who’ve been studying dialectics for many years, it’d be I would be very embarrassed to say anything. Yeah.

He said every time I said I’d say something, they go, no. No. No. They do. He said they do.

You open your mouth and say anything wrong. They’re like, no. No. No. So yes.

Yeah. He said you’d have to you have to be very, very careful what say. Yeah. Definitely.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top