Ornament for Clear Realisations – 51 2004 09 02 OCR

45 min · 3,708 words · 2 September 2004

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations - 51 2004 09 02 OCR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching introduces the fourth chapter of the Abhisamayalamkara, focusing on the principal application of bodhisattvas, which is a practice combining calm abiding and special insight on emptiness. It explains the definition of the application and the difference between sharp-faculty and dull-faculty bodhisattvas. It then goes through the first five aspects of the application, which concern the nature of realising emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2004-09-02

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 88444943-e44c-4cbd-bd4c-8834d5dd706c

Words: 3,704

In order to establish all sentient beings in a state beyond sorrow, then we need to become enlightened. In order for us to become enlightened then we need to establish the causes for becoming enlightened. One of the causes we need to establish in order to become enlightened is to be able to do the practices as described in the fourth chapter of the Abhisamayālamkāra so if we want in order to develop an understanding of these practices in order to be able to put them into practice in order to develop the merit in order to be able to in order to develop the merits, put them into practice, in order to develop understanding of them, then we are listening to these texts, listening to the teachings on these texts. So in this text that we have here, there’s three pages of quotes and quotes from sutras, quotes from shastras, from the commentaries, quotes from commentaries on the shastras, and quotes from commentaries on commentaries. But we’re going to leave all that for this evening and just get to the section which says what these texts mean so basically all that you really need to know the essential point about and the reason that they list all of these texts is to show the authority of teaching to show the where the authority comes from to be able to put things in this way.

So that’s the reason they have to put all these different quotes in, to show that they haven’t made it up themselves. So the the thing that we’re up to today is principal application, topic two of the eleven topics of the fourth chapter. So within that there is said to be twenty different sections And these twenty different sections are divided by the actual nature of these twenty different aspects or twenty different applications that are the actual twenty different sorry, twenty different aspects of the actual application. Okay. So one way of looking at these twenty actual applications is that there are five which relate to the way to develop the applications and fifteen that relate to the nature of the developed application.

So the definition, the first of the general explanation of these twenty different aspects to this application there is four different sections the first is the definition the second is the divisions the third is the order in which these things are developed. And the last is the borders of it. So the first from these then is the definition. The definition of actual principal application is a bodhisattva’s yoga conjoined with a union of calm abiding and special insight observing emptiness that is explicitly indicated in this case so this first section of this definition is a bodhisattvas yoga conjoined with a union of calm abiding and special insight observing emptiness now a bodhisattvas yoga is any practice that’s engaged in by bodhisattvas the union of calm abiding and special insight is the practice engaged in by bodhisattvas to develop their insight into emptiness and to progress along the path to purify negativities and accumulate positive merit however not all bodhisattvas have the ability to do this practice and to have a union of calm abiding and special insight observing emptiness they either need to be a being who is an ārya who’s perceived emptiness directly and is therefore on the path of seeing and the path of meditation or they can be a being on the path of accumulation or the path of preparation that is a being of sharp faculties so beings of sharp faculty before they perceive emptiness directly have an indication of emptiness are able to meditate with a special union of calm abiding and special insight on emptiness before they’ve directly perceived it. Beings with dull faculties are unable to do this so this means that although the border of this may be from Mahāyāna level of preparation all the way through to the continuum of Ascension it doesn’t it doesn’t include everybody in those instances.

So you have instances before you reach the heat level of the path of Mahāyāna, path of preparation, where there is a non-manifest or — no, not manifest. A non-direct. I’m trying to think of Okay. Okay. I know which word it is.

Okay. So if you’ll notice, definition here says the definition of a principally indicated application explicitly indicated in this case right now these two different words of indicator that they have here are actually meaning two different words in Tibetan The last one is indicated in this case means to be shown in this case. I suppose they mean similar things but anyway they’re different. Indicated that is said to be in this case. The first indicated means that they have put it forward.

Right I’ll explain so I’ll use I’ll translate Gesunda’s explanation because I couldn’t do it myself anyway there’s beings right so for example who have gone through the path of the Hīnayāna path and become Hīnayāna arhats and then they develop Bodhicitta and they come back and start at the beginning of the Bodhicitta path, right? So the second moment after they’ve developed Bodhicitta they’re on the path of preparation sorry, path of accumulation of a Bodhicitta, but they’re already arhats. Okay? Now these beings have these realizations, but not in a indicated way not in a way that’s actually shown they don’t show it or they don’t let it it out that they have this developed this it doesn’t it’s not that it doesn’t manifest but they don’t show it. Right?

So this is word to show. Right? Which they’ve translated both here is indicate. But one one case it means to no. Like Revealed.

Revealed. No. Even but it’s to reveal. They haven’t it isn’t revealed. It’s not necessarily them doing it.

Okay. So this word is both places is indicated. In the first instance, it means to have the conditions to come about so it’s manifested. Yeah. And in the second case, the indicated means written down here.

Yes. Indicated in this case and written down here. Alright. So there’s two different ways to show something. You can explicitly indicate something or you can implicitly indicate something.

So they are able to implicitly indicate it but not explicitly indicate it. So it manifests in an implicit way in them, but not in a direct way. Okay. These applications. Right?

This is in beings who are our hearts, but on the path of accumulation. Okay so the thing that it says it says that their definition of a principally indicated because what we’re dealing with here is two different types of beings yeah the beings that we’re talking about in this instance where it says indicated in this case are able to put these things into practice practice. They’re actually able to take them on and to put them into practice. In order to take them on and be able to put them into practice you have to have achieved the heat level of the Mahāyāna path where you achieve the unity of special insight and calm abiding based on the motivation of Bodhicitta. So bodhisattva yoga has this.

Until you reach the heat level of that path the heat level of preparation and have developed a bodhisattvas yoga based on a union of calm abiding and emptiness you can’t use this information you can’t manifest this directly because you can’t put it into practice okay so these beings may have it indirectly or subsumed in their continuum — some of these understandings through being Arhats — but they’re unable to put them into practice until they have that motivation and the level of the joining of calm abiding and insight that comes about on the heat level of the path of preparation. So the beings who are able to the order of realization that we’re going through just actually describe the type of beings that are able to do this practice and these beings don’t necessarily have those conditions that make them able to do this practice so that’s why it was described earlier the difference between those who can put it into practice and those who can’t. And that’s why in the definition it specifically indicates principally indicated, which means they are directly showing. So is there’s this weird thing in this text, right, where it says that the these are this group of aspects to the actual application that we’re about to go through are actually first of all divided into nineteen but then they’re divided into twenty.

So this means that if you have nineteen things, it doesn’t hang on. How do put it? There is nineteen because there is twenty, and perhaps the last two could be subsumed into one, but they’re not here, so it’s twenty. So it says there are nineteen, but here there are twenty. There can be nineteen and there can be twenty, yeah?

But so in some instances yeah? Is it? Yeah. It’s just because I can find it. Okay.

So Geshe-la said this sixth one. Right? Is because it’s a practice that’s usually associated with dull faculty bodhisattvas and therefore it takes a long time to develop an understanding using that then that is actually usually means that it is associated with the path of preparation as well Yeah? So there were some other ones that were also like that it comes into a similar thing to this thing we’re talking about before of the it can come into a similar thing as what we’re talking about before that it’s not a directly manifesting or a directly shown thing but it’s actually in their continuum or they have their ability to use it so if you’re a sharp faculty bodhisattva you don’t need to focus on that practice particularly but it doesn’t mean that you don’t have that capacity or you don’t have that practice in your continuum. It’s just that it’s something that is used he said it’s their application that realizes emptiness over a long period of time and with great difficulty.

So it doesn’t mean that sharp faculty bodhisattvas don’t have it. It’s just not something that they necessarily show or have to have to manifest in order to get along. Yeah? So in this, it says the definition of principally indicated applications explicitly indicated in Okay, so he says see how it says the definition of a principally indicated application explicitly indicated in this case, right? There’s actually nineteen of them.

If on the other hand you said the definition of a indicated application explicitly indicated in this case there would be twenty all right but because the sharp faculty bodhisattvas only practice in nineteen yeah they only have a principally principally work with nineteen, and then straight after this definition, it says there’s nineteen. That’s because it fits with the definition. But there’s actually twenty indicated in this case because it’s not just the principally indicated ones. It’s all of the indicated ones. There’s twenty indicated ones, nineteen principally indicated ones.

Is that okay? Yeah. So the sixth So so this number six, difficult one. Application that realizes emptiness over a long period of time and with great difficulty. That is an indicated application explicitly indicated in this case, but it’s not a principally indicated application explicitly indicated in this case.

So this number six, right, which is called the application that realizes emptiness over a long period of time and with great difficulty. Now the sharp-facultied bodhisattvas need this because they need to have the motivation to stick at it in order to develop realizations and to put in a lot of effort to develop their insights over time and gradually becoming having a subtler and more profound understanding of emptiness and of bodhicitta. But the way that this works for the dull faculty beings is that’s what they rely on the most. In the beginning they focus on this and develop and develop and develop. The other beings need it — the sharp faculty, the bodhisattvas need it — and they need to rely on it, this application, in order to keep going, but they don’t focus on it solely and then graduate to other things later. They have it as a non-primary practice in their continuum, but it doesn’t have to — it’s not their main focus. Okay. So there are twenty applications mentioned in the root text, nineteen of which are primary applications for sharp faculty beings and one of which is a primary application for a non-sharp faculty being.

The first five relate to the nature of the applications. The next eight relate to the person who is the support of applications the four following that relate to the relation to the method of completing the applications and the last three relate to the result and to time. So the first of the five applications that relate to the nature of application is the application of not abiding on forms and so forth. In the hearer it says application of not abiding on everything from forms up to Buddhahood which is another way of saying all phenomena all right so everything from gross forms up to the state of a Buddha — all phenomena and when it says application of not abiding on forms and so forth, it is not apprehending — it means not apprehending all phenomena as being inherently existent Okay. So the next one, application that stops application.

So previous application is the concentration on the emptiness or the lack of inherent existence, the lack of the true existence of all phenomenon, everything from form up to Buddha right now this application it means just it says here application that stops application now this has a we can look at this two different ways but it’s actually doing the same thing So the first thing that this thing is stopping application. So it’s stopping any other the aspect of the mind that stops the mind from focusing on anything else but that the lack of true existence of all these phenomena right so you have a you stop applying applications in any other way so you stop grasping at things as being inherently existent yeah and you stop the mind focusing on anything else now and this so that’s one way of looking at it it’s there’s one thing focusing on in the lack of inherent existence lack of true existence And then there’s another mind, another aspect of the mind stopping the mind from practicing any other applications or applying anything else when that’s happening. The other way to look at that is if you’re doing that, this means that you can’t start to grasp on to the idea of looking at inherent existence as being an inherently existent thing right so you can’t grasp onto the application itself as being inherently existent so by stopping the mind doing anything else but focusing on the lack of inherent existence of something, not only do you stop any other conceptualization, but you also stop your the mind from thinking that looking at the inherent nature of existence is actually an inherently existent thing for that application itself.

Right? Didn’t drop them. Yes. So this is because sorry. I was just checking.

Because there’s a practice in the seven points of mind training where you’re supposed to focus on emptiness, but then also realize that the process of focusing on emptiness is empty in this way you it says you apply an antidote to the antidote yeah and so this is what this is happening in this case you’re applying an antidote to the antidote and Geshe-la said yes and if by applying an antidote to the antidote then you stop the mind being able to go in circles with that alright so this is the antidote empty is the antidote really there Yeah. So if you’re able to do apply that emptiness to the antidote, you stop the mind from recognizing the process as being empty as well. So this is the first thing where it says the mind not abiding on forms and so forth what this is saying is that what not abiding means is recognising the lack of true existence of things they don’t abide they don’t have the ability to stay inherently existent for a moment so that not abidingness is another way of saying the lack of inherent existence but the mind focusing on the lack of inherent existence is something is also something to be taken into the meditation focus so you have a mind meditating on emptiness but then you turn it around and say well that mind isn’t isn’t inherently existent either so the mind meditating on emptiness isn’t inherently existent and the mind the focus of the the mind isn’t inherently existent neither of them are by doing this you stop your mind swapping one focus for another so this is where says application that stops application you stop the mind applying applying the concept of emptiness to everything in a circle.

Like, the mind we’re looking at the mind, looking at emptiness. It stops that. So the next one — sorry. I was just like my head felt like I was going — I was trying to conceive of something that I don’t have the ability to. Okay.

Now the next one is the application of the profound. Now this real what this is referring to is if you’re looking at emptiness, then you can keep looking at emptiness because there is no base there’s no limit to emptiness. So this is what when it says profound guess it says it means deep but literally deep in that you you don’t find a limit to it but if you’re dealing with a non affirming negative there is no limit to it yeah there is a there’s no kind of place where it stops and something else starts so he said for example if you go looking for the bottom of the ocean eventually you find it yeah but when you’re meditating on emptiness you go looking for the bottom of it there is no bottom Right? So this is so this is what is meant by this concept of profound, that it just keeps unfolding and unfolding and unfolding. It’s like you’re you’re looking into the if you even look into the emptiness of the emptiness of the emptiness of emptiness and emptiness, it can just keep going and going forever.

There is no base to it. There’s no there’s no bottom. So the next one of these fits in with that. Application in the difficult to fathom. Now, Miss Profound has this idea of expanse and keeping on going.

I think fathom is an interesting one because the fathom, I think if you took its original meaning, in Tibetan it has these two words the idea of depth and the idea of judging depth. You know how fathom used to mean to not necessarily figure something out but to take the depth of something so this fathom here means to take the depth of something okay so there’s this realisation of the profoundness and the lack of bottom of the base of or the edge. You know what I mean? The bottom of the ocean, proper bottom. Yeah, yeah.

She’s playing while you guys are laughing. So first of you have this idea of it being really profound. And then you have this idea of it the next one is the difficult to fathom that you that there’s the process of looking for the bottom and not being able to find it. Alright? This is what’s coming about in this one.

Okay, so the next one, application in the immeasurable, means the understanding that there is no limit. So the first one is this idea of realizing the profoundness, then looking trying to fathom that profoundness and then recognizing the concept of limitlessness in the last one. So all of these five are interrelated because they’re talking about the nature of the realization of emptiness. So Geshe said that those five are right. They’re all about the nature of the way that the realization of emptiness comes about and what the its nature is.

Okay. So the next one, six number six, the application that realizes emptiness over a long period of time and with great difficulty. Now Okay. So this one, application that realizes emptiness over a long period of time and with great difficulty. Okay.

So I have just asked him three times, and he said he doesn’t think it’s is. So it’s not necessarily a person with dull faculties, right, in which it says in these notes. Geshe-la said that when beings first develop Bodhicitta they need this application very much and beings with dull faculties definitely need this application a lot and they use this when especially on the path of preparation Because when you’re on the path of preparation you haven’t developed the combination of calm abiding and special insight that brings about the realization of emptiness. So this whole idea of application that realizes emptiness over a long period of time and with great difficulty can be applied to all bodhisattvas who are on the path of accumulation. So to say that it’s just for dull faculty people doesn’t make sense unless you can say it’s dull faculty people because you could say all beings who haven’t developed an inferential understanding of emptiness are dull faculty.

And in that essence, you can say they’re Dal Faculty. Dull faculty? And they need this application. Now, in Tibetan it actually says application that realizes emptiness over a long period of time and with great difficulty through listening, through study and so on. But it actually covers all of them.

It means that they need to do a lot of listening, a lot of contemplating, a lot of meditating, a lot of developing merits. All of these things need to be undertaken in order for these beings to develop these kinds of realisations. Once they get to the stage where they develop the union of

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top