Mind Training

1 h 38 min · 4,438 words · 5 August 1997 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 98-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche defines bodhichitta—the awakened heart—then teaches tonglen, the practice of taking and giving. Authentic bodhichitta requires two inseparable aspirations: achieving your own enlightenment and liberating all sentient beings. He uses a quicksand analogy to show why you must attain Buddhahood yourself before you can authentically help others reach it. He then guides the tonglen visualization in detail: draw all beings’ suffering through your nostril into your heart, then breathe out your happiness and virtue to establish them in Buddhahood. The practice moves progressively through the realms from hell beings to gods. The talk closes with substantive Q&A on how bodhichitta arises spontaneously, the distinction between desire and attachment, and how self and others’ welfare interrelate.

File metadata (for organising)

File: #14 Bodhichitta and the practice of Tonglen – KR.mp3

UUID: 8a96f97a-0dde-4676-b14c-97f76cfdbe4c

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Mind Training

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,439

We’ll begin with cultivating as our motivation for the listening to this teaching on the Dharma, the precious awakened heart. So, we’re all the same in that we are spontaneously thinking of how we can find happiness, how we can rid ourselves of suffering. Merely thinking that we want happiness does not in fact bring us happiness, and merely thinking that we do not want suffering does not prevent our suffering. Happiness is a result. It’s necessary that it arises in dependence upon a cause in order that it be brought about.

If we create the cause and the necessary conditions for it, for the happiness, for happiness arise, then even if we were to say, I don’t want to be happy, still we would be happy. If in fact we want to be happy, it’s necessary that we create the causes of happiness. Likewise, suffering is a result, and it too arises in dependence upon causes and conditions. If we cease creating the causes of suffering, then suffering will cease of itself. The main means by which we can see suffering and achieve happiness is bodhicitta, the awakened heart.

If we generate the awakened heart, we will bring to an end our suffering. We will achieve happiness. That’s why it is so precious. So, begin by meditating for a few minutes on the awakened heart. As a prerequisite to the actual cultivation of the awakened heart, it’s necessary that we develop love and compassion.

And compassion expressed in the thoughts, It would be wonderful if myself and all sentient beings were free of suffering and the causes of suffering. May they be free of suffering and the causes of suffering and the development of love expressed in the thought, it would be wonderful if myself and all sentient beings had happiness and the causes of happiness. May they have happiness and the causes of happiness. Compassion a prerequisite to the development of the awakened heart? Because love and compassion are the cause and the cause must become before the result.

Before we can actually free all sentient beings from their suffering and to lead them to complete happiness, we, each ourselves, must bring to consummation all our excellent qualities and rid ourselves of our various faults. This aspiration to do just that is the awakened heart. Motivation, the precious awakening heart, as our intention to listen to this essence of the universal vehicle Dharma, that of the means of actually developing the awakening heart. We should have such a motivation in order to listen to this present teaching that determine to, once having listened to it, to reflect upon it, and then to meditate and to put it into practice for the benefit of vast sentient beings. Quoting from the Ornament for Clear Realization by Ārya Maitreya, where he says, the awakened heart, the aspiration to achieve awakening for the sake of all living beings.

The awakened heart in Sanskrit is bodhicitta. In the Tibetan language, it’s jang chub kyi sems. And we’ve explained at length how extremely precious it is. And it’s important to try to get a sense of what is meant by this quality of mind. Not just understanding what are its causes, but if we were to gain an appreciation for it, even that appreciation of it would accumulate a vast collection of creative potential.

So the in Sanskrit, the the awakened heart is bodhicitta. First, understanding what bodhi is. Bodhi in Tibetan is jang chub. It’s made up of two syllables. And chitta is sems, is the aspiration to attain, Jangchub.

So Jangchub normally translated as awakening, chitta as heart. So the aspiration to attain awakening or enlightenment. So, the sense of this term bodhicitta is that one has resolved deeply in one’s heart that I must attain awakening. There is a determination that there is no other way than to achieve awakening for what it is that I want. I must achieve that end.

So, as we said, the the Tibetan term for awakening or enlightenment is which is made up of two syllables, each one having its own meaning. First, the meaning of syllable, it has, it is the ridding of all faults. So there is a category of faults or undesirable factors, dysfunctional qualities that have been completely eliminated, abandoned. So it is the factor which is the elimination of all dysfunctional factors of mind is what is meant by Then the second of these two syllable word, means to realize. Through jang, we have eliminated all dysfunctional factors of mind.

All the faults of the mind have been removed, completely abandoned. Thereby, we are able to come to realize directly the nature of all phenomena. We understand the reality of all phenomena and see them in such a way as if they were there in the palm of our hand. We see them that clearly. So it has the notion of realizing directly the nature of all phenomena.

So this state of Jangchub, that is a bodhi or awakening, enlightenment, is will be achieved by all sentient beings, eventually at some time in the future. Whosoever have the potential to achieve that state, that each of ourselves will within our continuum realize that state. That is to say, we will progressively decrease the various dysfunctional factors within our mind until they are completely abandoned, and we will achieve awakening, bodhi. We each possess the cause of that awakening. We each have the seed of that awakening within us.

How are we going to actually generate this within our continuums of mind? This awakening. We all have a mind. A mind here that What is meant by here, by mind, is a consciousness. And by consciousness, we can simply describe it as discriminating thinking this is this, that is that, that quality of mind.

Moreover, this mind that we all possess does not truly exist. Is empty of inherent existence. But that emptiness of our own minds, the emptiness of inherent existence of our own mind, is obscured from our present understanding. This it is obscured by the various afflictive emotions. As we progressively remove the afflictive emotions by means of applying antidotes, this emptiness of the mind will become more apparent.

This is what is meant by that is to say, the elimination of all obscuring faults. So the the stains, these obscuring mental factors of afflictive emotions which presently obscure the nature of mind are progressively removed until the emptiness of mind becomes apparent. But this removing of the faults of the afflictive emotions from the mind represents the second factor of awakening, the chub, that is to say, this is the realization of its own nature. Its own nature as emptiness and the nature and as being the nature of all phenomena. So, the upon the the complete removal of all obscuring factors from the mind, when that emptiness of mind which becomes apparent, and the mind which is realizing that emptiness represent what is called the truth body.

There are four bodies of the Buddha. There is a nature truth body, a wisdom truth body, a complete enjoyment body, and an emanation body. The emptiness of the mind, having having abandoned all obscurations, is the nature truth body. That which realizes that nature is the wisdom truth body. That truth body represents the consummation of one’s own welfare.

That is to say, the removal of all obstructions from the mind, in which all the various dysfunctional factors have been eliminated constitutes the truth body, and the truth body is the consummation or the bringing to complete fulfillment of one’s own welfare. So, my removal the removal of all the obscurations within my mind, that means I achieve a truth body. Likewise, each of you, through the progressive removal of all the obscurations from your minds, you will achieve a truth body. And you will all be Buddhas. So, the removal of all of one’s various faults represents the achievement of one’s own welfare.

So this is why we call the truth body the truth body which is the consummation of one’s own welfare, because it is achieved through the removal of all the dysfunctional factors of one’s own mind. So it represents the complete fulfillment of one’s own welfare through the achievement of this removal of all obscurations from one’s own mind, which is the truth body. Until we achieve this own welfare truth body, we cannot bring about the complete welfare of others. Until we have achieved this one’s own welfare as embodied within the truth body, we cannot bring about the complete welfare of others. Who has abandoned all afflictive emotions from their mind.

And they can be of tremendous benefit to others. They have unimaginable excellent qualities. And again, the Bodhisattvas, who are on the various grounds, the bhūmis, whether they’re on the first, second, third, all the way up to the tenth bhūmi, They their the deeds are unimaginable. They have they are of tremendous benefit to others. But until either of them actually achieve the Buddhahood, they cannot be of ultimate welfare to others.

With regard to others’ welfare, there are two levels. There is others’ temporal welfare and others’ ultimate welfare. So what do we mean by the temporal welfare of others? A bodhisattva engages in the practice of the six perfections, the perfections of generosity, ethics, tolerance, joyous effort, meditative concentration, and wisdom. These, they involve themselves in.

For example, they involve themselves in the practice of generosity, and they do this with regard to others, that they would benefit others. For example, one form of generosity would be teaching the Dharma to others, for example, their students. They would practice various ways of demonstrating ethics to others as a means to instill ethical conduct in others. All of these various practices of the six perfections of the Bodhisattva at this point are means whereby to bring about the temporal welfare of others. So they are demonstrating the means by which to bring about the temporal welfare of others.

But then further than that, if one self were actually to have achieved awakening, enlightenment, then one could teach the Dharma to disciples and lead them to that same state of awakening. Only once having achieved that state of awakening oneself is one empowered to be able to lead others through the teaching of Dharma to that same state. It is leading them to the state of awakening, which is the ultimate welfare of others. So until we ourselves have achieved Buddhahood, we cannot teach Dharma in such a way to our disciples whereby they can themselves can achieve Buddhahood. Therefore, without ourselves achieving that state of Buddhahood, we cannot bring about their ultimate welfare, which is their achievement of Buddhahood.

So, it is only upon ourselves achieving Buddhahood that we are able to bring about the ultimate welfare of sentient beings. That is to say, that we have the ability to lead them to Buddhahood. It is only upon ourselves achieving ultimate happiness that we are able to lead others to their ultimate welfare of their own ultimate happiness. Until we have achieved that state ourselves, we are not able to lead them to that state. Therefore, only it in such a state that we have the most profound and vast means whereby to lead our students through the teachings to their ultimate welfare.

So, analogy which illustrates what is being gotten at here is the case where two people are trapped in a swamp, in quicksand. Though the other might want to pull the other out of their quicksand, they themselves are up to their neck in quicksand. And therefore, though they may wish to extricate the other person, to draw them out, there’s no way, in fact, they can. But once you yourself are free of the quicksand, then you can use methods whereby to pull the other one out. There’s another term which is used synonymous with the awakened heart.

It is often translated as mind generation, universal vehicle mind generation. But another way that it could be translated is to say the open heart. And this is an extremely vast mind. So this is this open hearted attitude is extremely vast in its conception. It looks upon all sentient beings equal to space.

It takes that vast number, an infinite number of sentient beings as the object of its observation. And moreover, it aspires to eliminate all of their suffering. The suffering of infinite sentient beings is immeasurable, but it is going to eliminate all of that suffering. And moreover, it’s going to lead them all to complete bliss. That’s the vastness of the conception, of its vision.

So the the conception the attitude wishing to free from suffering compassion. The attitude which wishes to bring happiness is love. So the this love and compassion is expressed in the attitude of wishing to free others from suffering and to establish them in a state of bliss. This is the aspiration to bring about the welfare of others. So there is a a coupling of purposes expressed within the awakened heart, the the welfare of both oneself and others.

This evolves from the, first, from the aspiration to bring about the welfare of others in terms of love and compassion, wishing to free all sentient beings from suffering and to lead them to complete happiness, that is to say, the aspiration to bring about welfare of others, then we look to ourselves and say, can I actually do this? Am I able? No, in fact, at present, I’m not. It is only someone who themselves has achieved such a state that has the means to bring this about in fact. Therefore, I must, I myself must attain awakening.

This attainment of one’s own awakening is one’s own welfare. So it is this, the awakened heart represents the aspiration through seeking to bring about the welfare of others, the achievement of one’s own welfare is established, and thereby, the welfare of both oneself and others. So unless there is present both of these aspirations, that is to bring aspirations of purpose, then it is not a fully qualified awakened heart. For example, we may have love and compassion, and here, compassion is the attitude which wishes to free sentient beings from their suffering, and love is the attitude which wishes to lead others to happiness. This is, in fact, the aspiration to bring about the welfare of others.

But merely this is not a fully qualified state of the awakened heart. On the other hand, to have the aspiration to achieve complete awaken. On the other hand, the aspiration whereby one to have the attitude which aspires to attain the state of awakening. It it that alone, again, is not a fully acquired fully qualified awakened heart. The attitude which aspires to which in which one aspires to achieve the state of awakening, that alone is not the fully qualified awakened heart.

So developing from the cause. The causes being love and compassion. Compassion being the attitude of wishing freedom from suffering. Love, the attitude of wishing to lead to happiness. That is to say, leading from arising out of an attitude of aspiring to bring about the welfare of others.

One looks, can I in fact? At present, I can’t. One goes on to to recognize the fact that only by achieving awakening can is one able. Therefore, I, I must achieve complete awakening. But why?

For the sake of bringing about the ultimate welfare of all sentient beings. It is therefore the fully qualified awakened heart has there has to be this combination of these two welfares, One’s own complete attainment of awakening, which brings about one’s own welfare for the sake of the welfare of others, is leading them to that same state of awakening. Very good. So when we meditate the awakened heart, we we should take care that it is we are trying to develop the attitude which is a combination of these two welfares, an attitude which is aspiring to bring about these two welfares. And then if it has these two purposes, then it fully is qualified awakened heart.

It has all the necessary characteristics of what we mean by the awakened heart. So it’s important that we understand when we’re cultivating an awakened heart that it has these two aspirations for these two welfares. If we meditate in such a way, then the skillful action that we create, the creative potential that we accumulate, is equal to space. If it had formed, it would not be able to fit in space. It would be so beneficial.

So it is said by the Buddha, said by Śāntideva, that if we were to try to appreciate the immense benefits of cultivating cultivating the the awakened heart, that it if it had formed, it would not be able to fit in all its space. The the skillful action is almost unimaginable, and therefore we can appreciate the tremendous happiness which is going to be derived from that skillful action. And moreover, the purification of our negativities which consequently takes place, and thereby the elimination of our suffering. It it it would be wonderful to actually develop the awakened heart, but but even to gain a sense of what the awakened heart is, to appreciate its qualities, its characteristics, to get an idea of what that state of mind actually is, accumulates a tremendous creative potential. It imprints latencies, a potency within our mind, whereby we will be able to readily develop it in the future.

So in the future, you know, we in the future that you yourself will become this wonderful being, the bodhisattva, and then gradually, you will progress to the state of a Buddha. So it’s it’s necessary that we practice in order to achieve that state. It’s necessary that we meditate in order to achieve that state. If we neither practice nor meditate as a means to achieve that state, we won’t achieve it. Okay.

So we have been discussing the practice of giving and taking. And in the actual in the actual wording of the text, the word giving or sending is presented first, and taking is second. But in the method of practice, we begin by taking upon ourselves. By way of example, by way of analogy, why it’s necessary to first take as opposed to give. If someone were sick, they wouldn’t be able to appreciate delicious food that we gave them.

So, if someone were sick and in pain, they wouldn’t be able to appreciate even the most delicious food that we might give them. But, if we were first to give them some medicine and to cure their illness, and then subsequent to that, then subsequent to that, to give them some food. Then they would be able to keep the food down, and not only that, they would be able to enjoy it. So, in our our practice of of taking and giving, We first take upon ourselves their troubles, all their difficulties. First take upon their suffering.

Then, subsequent to that, we give over our happiness to them. So, I haven’t previously, in talking about taking and giving, we haven’t really discussed the actual manner of taking and how we are to give. That is, say, meditation, the manner of meditating, taking, the manner of meditating, giving. Let So we first begin with those who are experiencing the greatest suffering. We begin with hell beings.

So, beginning by taking upon those who have the greatest suffering, the hell beings, that we imagine that this is, at this point, purely practiced as visualization. Imagining that you’re drawing all the suffering, their manifest suffering and and all their sources of suffering. Drawing that suffering on, it enters in through your nostril, and down, and dissolves into your heart. Imagine having taken their suffering from them, that have a blissful, healthy body. Progressively moving up to the hungry ghost, again taking upon yourself their manifest suffering and the causes of suffering, and drawing it into the nostril.

It could be the left nostril, and dissolving at your heart. And then the animals. And then breathing out, imagine that you are breathing out. You’re giving over your body, all of your possessions, your roots of skillful actions, your roots of virtue, everything that is fine, bliss and jewels, this, it approaches them, transforms themselves and their circumstances such that they have a complete, healthy, blissful embodiment, that they have all complete material prosperity, that they have the accumulation of all the necessary creative potentials, that they achieve the paths and grounds that you establish them in Buddhahood. And then likewise, with regard to human beings and celestial beings, taking upon yourself their suffering, it enters in, drawing it in through your nostril and down dissolving at your heart, and then giving away to them your body, possessions, and the roots of skillful actions, and thereby establishing them in a state where a complete health and well-being, a blissful embodiment, of complete material prosperity, and all of the creative potential needed to progress along the grounds and paths, and that they achieve Buddhahood, and that you yourself rejoice in in their achievement.

And this, you can then take on the, as the object of cultivate, of your practice, hearers and solitary realizers, bodhisattvas. Though these are highly realized beings, they still possess the obscurations of mind, and that you take upon yourself these their faults. And giving, you give over to them all the means by which they are able to eliminate these faults, that they’re able to progress along the paths and grounds, and that they to achieve Buddhahood, and then rejoicing in their achievement. So initially, the the the text says that we are to mount these two upon the breath. That we are to mount taking and giving upon the breath.

But this should not be done initially. We should first gain familiarity in the practice of simply visualizing the process of taking and giving. Upon gaining familiarity, then we can actually mount it upon the breath. Upon the in breath, we simultaneously take upon ourselves the suffering. Upon the out breath, we simultaneously give away our body, our possessions, virtue.

So, through such a practice, we can accumulate tremendous accumulation of creative potential, purify a tremendous amount of negativity. Therefore, it is a very powerful practice. So we’re gonna stop there, we’ll spend the rest of the evening on questions. Yes. Yes.

So So the ultimate welfare of self and others are achieved simultaneously. Is that what it’s been said? I’m just going back over your question just to parse. The ultimate welfare of both oneself and others are achieved simultaneously. Yeah.

Is that is that your that’s kind of this Well, I’m asking if that is what is happening because No. You said that one’s own welfare is Oh, yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yes.

Yes. So I asked Rinpoche, are the are are self are the ultimate welfare of self and others achieved simultaneously? And he said, yes. So, is a general statement. If we were to take it in regards to each sentient being, then there is these are it would be attained in a serial fashion.

One first would achieve one’s own welfare, and then by teaching the Dharma to disciples, they would be led to that same state, and would that would and achieve their own welfare. In general, welfare of others and one’s own ultimate welfare are achieved simultaneously. But in terms of particular sentient beings, then those attainments are serial. One first attains one’s own welfare, ultimate welfare, and then brings about the ultimate welfare of others. Is that okay?

Yeah. So, one would make use of either of the two traditions for cultivating the awakened heart, either the seven cause and effect instruction, or the, as what has been explained thus far in the present teaching, the equalizing and the exchange of self for others, where where it incorporates the practice of taking and giving. One would achieve a state where it the awakened heart, this aspiration, would arise effortlessly. The word is uncontrived. Uncontrived, that means it is spontaneously, uncontrived.

One doesn’t have to think, even think about it. It’s just there. That is the measure of having achieved the awakened heart, the awakened heart arises in an uncontrived fashion. The seven cause and effect instruction in equalizing and exchanging self with others. Whichever?

In what way is a single sentient being dependent upon all other sentient beings? In what way do you mean dependent there? And so in in what in in saying what you said, how are is that one person depending upon all others? In what way is they dependent? They’re dependent for their existence on all other sentient beings?

Is that what you’re saying? Wrong. This is just as it was. And because they they shot on it. They’ve been shot on it.

This is that that’s the second one. This is. So, this is not the way in which this is not this is not a a way of being dependent. So, this is we could say this is just a generality. It’s not the way in which we mean we are using the word dependence or reliance.

In general, if there were no objects of knowledge, then there would be no sentient being. We can say that in general. For example, the the fingers of the hand are not dependent one upon the other. But if we didn’t have a hand, these fingers wouldn’t exist. So, in the West, desire and attachment are looked upon as identical.

They both, but in fact, they do both have the attitude of wanting. I want this, or I want that. And this is true both of desire and attachment. But in the case of attachment, the wanting is motivated by an afflictive emotion. Most basically ignorance grasping at truly existent self.

Out of this arises an unskillful wanting because it has its source of it. It is couched within the afflictive emotions. On the other hand, desire is a wanting, but it can be a wanting, for example, of wanting to the awakening, enlightenment, Buddhahood, wanting sentient beings to be happy. It can be an extremely kind hearted attitude, free of any afflictive emotion, and therefore, it is a skillful it can it can be a skillful state. Okay.

Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
sambhogakaya enjoyment body; long ku (Tib)
The enjoyment body; the form in which the enlightened mind appears in order to benefit highly realized bodhisattvas. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top