1 h 14 min · 2,566 words · 23 September 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching begins with a morning and evening mind-checking routine to set motivation and review the day with loving kindness. It then contrasts love for loved ones with the more stable love for all beings, and presents two methods for generating renunciation, based on physical and mental suffering, with students asked to reflect and share which suits them. The talk notes that the mental-suffering method is the one usually emphasised in the Mind Training text, which explores the faults of self-cherishing and leads toward bodhicitta.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 15m
UUID: c0f9c134-59fc-454a-8593-f4a3d89cc728
Date: 2012-09-23
Words: 2,562
And some sometime, you may go to the beach. This one. This one. Was that. But I was well, I was injured.
But I went injured. But I went went went but I went Went. Yeah. Last Saturday and last Friday, go to the Glenelg. The Glenelg.
Glen Neuve. Yeah. And another, Henley Beach. Yeah. Awareness.
Awareness. The bus. What? Bus number probably 303 number. This Wednesday is Losar.
This Wednesday Wednesday. This Wednesday, Losar. So this Wednesday, usually every Wednesday at night, Lam Rim, but this Wednesday no teaching. You know? Because because because because I have a lot I have a lot I have a lot Tibetan texts about Kālacakra to study.
Yeah. A little bit difficult. So cancel. This one is the teaching. This one?
Really? Preparing preparing preparing Preparing. This word was probably new words for me. Preparing. Preparing.
I am preparing for 32 as well, prepare. Yeah. Yeah. Preparing. Oh, thank you.
Thank you. Thank you so very much. Very easy. Because So each morning when we wake up in the course of our lives when we wake up each morning, whatever it is that we, whatever it is that we need to do, first we should set about to try and establish our motivation for the for the day. And to to take a moment it only takes a moment to set your motivation for how you wish to be able to project yourself through your day.
So first of all you need to check your own mind to see exactly how is your mind traveling. It is important that you through this investigation aim to calm your thoughts and have some clarity of mind to think clearly as you are setting yourself in preparation for the day. And you can think that in the course of this day I must control my behaviour and my speech, the way that I go into my social world in such a way that somehow I will be of benefit to the people I meet throughout the course of the day. Because as practitioners we have a commitment where we are trying to cultivate a great love for all other living beings. And so before we set ourselves off into our social worlds for the day, if we are able to remind ourselves of this commitment we have for cultivating love for other living beings, it is very important and very beneficial to do.
At the end of the day before we retire just as we are about to go to bed to go to sleep in the evenings. It’s important to once again reflect on the day that you have experienced and use that just the moment before going to sleep to do this reflection and check whether you have been able through the course of the day, through all your interactions to sustain this state of mind that was established in your morning motivation and whether you’ve done beneficial acts, you’ve had a good positive state of mind through the course of your day. So you do some kind of inventory on how you feel your thoughts, your behaviours, your behaviour and the way you’ve spoken have how you have acted out through your course of the day. If you feel on reflection that you have done good things, that you feel you have fulfilled your ambition for the day in terms of generating positive states of mind and behaviours, then it’s important to rejoice in that and congratulate oneself for being able to have sustained such a positive state of mind through the course of your day and to have done meaningful actions that are in some way beneficial for others and rejoice and to commend oneself to repeat such good efforts in the future.
On the other hand, when we go through our inventory of our thoughts through the day of our behaviour through the day, if we feel that there are instances where we have generated some form of negativity or failed to live up to our aspiration, then we should look upon those behaviours with some kind of regret and imagine ourselves being able to overcome such behaviour and act differently in the future. So these are the two ways in the morning and the evening that we’re able to check our minds. So when we think about our capacity for loving kindness and compassion, we some investigation into the benefits that will have on our own well-being. We understand that if we do an investigation into compassion, loving kindness and compassion, can see that it will bring benefits to the way we are able to live our lives and our well-being. And it is important to understand that we, in order to fulfil these states of mind, requires some determination and some courage to be able to take responsibility to carry this mental state throughout the course of our days.
And it is of enormous benefit if we’re able to, understand that whether we go to work, whatever we do throughout the course of the day, to have this courage to take on the responsibility of sustaining this loving kindness and compassion, it will bring about great benefits to our well-being. So when we ask, we think about, loving kindness and compassion that we are trying to cultivate for living beings, we can also, think about the kind of love that we have for our children, for our partners, for the people who we we love the most. And if we analyse and think about the kind of love that we have for them and the kind of loving kindness and compassion we are trying to generate for other living beings, we can see that there is a difference between the two and that if we make an investigation into the nature of how those, positive mental states arise, we can see that there is some difference between the two. So if we when we make this analysis of the difference between the kind of love that we have for our nearest and dearest and the love that we’re able to generate for all living beings, we begin we can see that the love that we have for our nearest and dearest is sometimes not as is in fact not as stable and secure as we might imagine that it could it that we might imagine it is because there are some events or circumstances that can occur that will corrupt the nature of this love.
Whereas the love that we’re trying to cultivate towards all sentient beings, there is actually a far it is a far more stable and reliable love that we’re able to cultivate for all sentient beings because our connection and relationship to sentient beings never changes. We always will remain connected to other living beings. Therefore, if we make this investigation we can see that actually the love that we’re able to cultivate towards all sentient beings is somewhat more reliable and stable than the love that we cultivate towards our nearest and dearest. So now if we direct our attention towards the idea the concept of renunciation, a concept that’s been explored in the recent Lam Rim teachings. When we talk about renunciation, there are two methods that we can, rely on in terms of our understanding and practice of renunciation.
So the first method, the first method for cultivating renunciation comes about on the basis of our experiences of physical suffering. We know that our life at some stage will end, that we will be subject to the laws of cause and effect, and that will shape our future possible experiences. Now this, an understanding of the way that the nature of our body, the law of cause and effect is going to bring about potential states of suffering, what we call in this context physical suffering, we wish to end this process is the first kind of renunciation. So the first renunciation very much focused on the physical suffering that we experience in life and our wish to be separate from it. Physical suffering being our embodiment and the laws of cause and effect and the potential for suffering to ripen upon us in the future.
The second method in striving to gain renunciation is more centred on the mental sufferings that we experience, where we know that no matter what level of prosperity we might enjoy, it will be compromised it can be compromised by various mental states, in particular, the negative mental states such as anger and jealousy, malicious competitiveness, these kinds of negative mental states. So when we understand these the presence of these negative mental states, we look for their origin and we can see within the embodiment that we are experiencing in this life, source from which they arrive is self-cherishing. And this suffering therefore comes about as what we term as the mental suffering. Our wish to be free from this kind of mental suffering is the second type of renunciation. So they are two distinct methods that will result in the same goal.
So now if we can take some time, we’ll take some time now to reflect upon in our own in in the way that our own mind works. If our goal is renunciation and we know both of these methods will produce the same result which is renunciation. We can investigate the two different ways. The one that is based on, the experience of physical suffering and our wish to be separate from it. The other one, the experiences of mental suffering and our wish to be separate from those causes.
Which one do you feel is more do you feel more compatible with as a practice for yourself? So this is something that you from your own side have to decide for yourself. And if we take some time now just to do some reflection and think which one of these two methods you feel more inclined towards. And then after we’ve had some time to think about it, then we will discuss what your points of view are. So now in a very relaxed state of mind, make this investigation within your own mind and we’ll do that.
We’ll concentrate on that now for the next few moments. Just meditate on these two ways and which you feel is more compatible for your own disposition. So few minutes meditation, you know? Good. Good.
So there’s enormous benefit to be had from making investigation into why we should engage in certain, practices or attitudes, taking the time to reflect on which method really is compatible for you is of immense benefit. So now Geshe-la would like to hear your thoughts on what you’ve been considering when you’ve made this investigation, made this reflection. Mark. And with the renunciation, which of these two did you feel? Alright.
Another? This is good. And, Annie, what are you thinking about? What are you thinking about?
Thinking about. What are you thinking about? That one? Very important. From that’s the quote from the prayers of the meditator, isn’t it?
Alright. Good idea. So Geshe-la commends you on your answers and says in terms of these methods, it’s sometimes considered that in terms of the first method where as we go into old age, we become more acutely aware of our physical limitations and our sense of this physical suffering is far stronger because we are more aware of, as we start to begin to, experience more physical conditions as we reach old age. So that often relates, we say, to the first method. The second method of, renunciation based on this mental method usually is we it can be said that it’s thought of more for people as young adults.
When people are young adults, these negative mental states, often really dominate their lives and the way that they go about living. And so that is often a reflection of the second method of the mental basis for generating renunciation. So when we, the text that we are basing these studies on, like Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun, generally it focuses on a renunciation generated through the the second method, the mental method of, cultivating renunciation because it explores so, precisely the faults of self-cherishing. The answers that you’ve given to this, the reflection that you’ve made on these two paths is what is found within the section that we are covering today. Remember we got up to page 81 in the previous week.
And so what the answers that we have discussed can be found in this section. So in order for us to understanding of this sense of, compassion leading up to the great compassion of bodhicitta. We are trying to cultivate a happiness for ourselves that is based on taking responsibility to relieve suffering from others. At this time, if we see around the world, we can clearly understand the amount of suffering that is being experienced by sentient beings. And we if we try to, cultivate within our mind this desire, this drive to take responsibility for this eliminating such sufferings, it is of it it is some that is where our source of mental happiness will arise from.
So we understand through the method of the great path where we are trying to cultivate our ability to bring benefit to others, that it requires a great deal or a great many skills to enable us to fulfil our ambition. And these, such as effort and diligence, and these, the way that we work and the way that we strive to fulfil this aim not only brings about a great benefit to our mind in the way we experience our mind now, but it also bodes well for what will happen in terms of future incarnations. So this is the part of this, in terms of this great path, the great benefit of it and the great aspiration we have in it. So we know that it is true from what we’ve read and discussed and from Śāntideva’s teachings as well that whatever kind of physical suffering we might find ourselves experiencing, the effect that will have on us is dependent upon our minds and the way that we are able to exercise our mind at that time. So what is of most importance is trying to cultivate this mind that is understanding the power of the mind in all circumstances to be responsible for minimising whatever kind of suffering, other kinds of physical suffering we might experience.
So Geshe-la apologizes for the way the time unfolded this morning that we didn’t find a moment to do the prayers that we normally do before the teachings. But Geshe-la was very determined that we should cover fully this exploration into our motivation because it has such enormous impact on the way that you are able to go about your practice. So I’m sorry for not being able to have time for the prayers, but we did have very important things that took precedence this morning. That’s true. That is right.
Here stop and finish for today. Alright. Good. Yeah. Yeah.
I’m sorry, Chris. Chris, because you is No. No. No. No.
No. No. No. You’re you’re the chant master, so he’s deprived you of your chant master moment in the sun.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.