1 h 32 min · 4,823 words · 24 June 1997
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Teaches the six-stage method for developing the awakened heart (bodhicitta) through mind training. It begins with equanimity, seeing that all beings equally want happiness and not suffering, then builds love, compassion, and resolve. Reasoning drawn from karma, impermanence and dependent arising is used to support equanimity, and the talk ends with a brief question session.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 33m
UUID: 2e720e31-190f-4cb7-9534-4187fb4fd96e
Date: 1997-06-24
Words: 4,819
We’ll begin by meditating for a few minutes, cultivating as our motivation the awakened heart. Just as we ourselves wish happiness and not to suffer, likewise all sentient beings wish happiness and not to suffer. So we begin by cultivating love for all sentient beings expressed in the following thoughts. It would be wonderful if all sentient beings had happiness in the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings have happiness in the causes of happiness.
I myself will lead them to a state where they have happiness in the causes of happiness. So, it’s necessary to generate our minds into the entity of love, not just leave it with the words. And likewise with regard to compassion, that what is expressed in thoughts is to be used to generate the mind into the entity of compassion. Beginning with the thoughts, It would be wonderful if myself and all living beings were free of suffering and the causes of suffering. May myself and all living beings be free of suffering and the cause of suffering.
I myself will lead myself and all living beings to a state where they are free of suffering and all the causes of suffering. We go on to cultivate an intense resolve that I myself alone, without depending upon others, shall lead all sentient beings to that state of complete happiness, shall lead them to a state of freedom from suffering. So it’s necessary to generate our minds into the entity of that result. But when we look into the actuality of our ability, we see that we cannot achieve even though we have this end, that we have a tremendous resolve to achieve it. Then we have to ask, well who could, who could possibly has such an ability?
It is only a Buddha who can eliminate the sufferings of others and in fact establish them in complete happiness. So therefore seeing that there’s only a Buddha and wishing to achieve this end, determining that I will achieve the state of a Buddha, that is to say I will eliminate all my various faults and bring to consummation all of my excellent qualities. If I do that, then I will be empowered whereby to actually bring all sentient beings to a state where they have complete freedom from suffering, where they have complete happiness. Therefore, for the sake of all sentient beings, in order to eliminate their suffering, in order to bring them to complete happiness, I will achieve the state of the Buddha. When you commit yourself to that end, then you have developed the awakened heart.
But if we were to question, well, can I actually achieve the state of a Buddha? In fact, we have that potential just as a seed has the potential to produce a sprout, likewise we have the potential to achieve Buddhahood because each of us has Buddha nature whereby we can achieve that end. And just as the potential of a seed can be actualized in producing a sprout, it is by the conditions of listening, reflecting, and meditating, and finally putting the teachings into practice that our potential of attaining Buddhahood is actualized. So, as a means to actualize our potential that of Buddha nature, determining to listen to this present teaching on the essence of the universal vehicle Dharma, having listened to it, to reflect upon it, having reflected, to meditate upon it, and to practice it well. And this process is like watering the seed whereby we can actualize the result.
We’re presently discussing the means of developing the awakened heart and the method that we’re employing in its development is equalizing and exchanging self for others. This initially begins with the development of equanimity or a sense of equality in terms of others in that all sentient beings are equal in wanting to be happy and not wanting to suffer. They’re all the same in that. And developing that sense of equality and being able to place one’s mind single pointedly upon that understanding. Subsequently, developing, looking at the faults of self centeredness and the excellent qualities of other centeredness.
Going on from that, the development of love and compassion, observing their object and in that context practicing taking and giving. Then generating an intense resolve which culminates in the awakened heart. So there are, I’ve just described the stages in the development of the awakened heart And these are set out in different ways of categorizing. Sometimes the numbers are expanded, sometimes they’re condensed. But I think this method that I’ve outlined into six is an excellent way to look at the practice.
So, I think it would be excellent if you can to be able to hold these six stages in the cultivation of the awakened heart in your mind if you can remember them. If you can’t, then by all means make some notes. Write them in a book so that in the future you can refer to them and you’ll know how to the method is arranged in the development of the awakened heart. So, it’s important that we proceed in the cultivation of the awakened heart in a methodical manner. If we leave out a step, if we cultivate them in a haphazard way, then we may not achieve the desired result.
So, these are set out in a very systematic fashion, in an unerring and ordered fashion, and this is the way that we should implement them in our practice. That we should meditate upon them in this order and whereby the first five of this six part method acts as a cause and then we achieve the sixth result, that is the say, the awakened heart. If we proceed in this fashion, then step by step, we can achieve the result. This mind training method of awakening our hearts is really something wonderful and it’s really the outstanding feature of the practice of mind training and to meditate on is really a wonderful way to spend one’s life in this fashion. Out of it one becomes a bodhisattva.
Again and again taking this method to mind and putting it into practice and meditate upon it. It’s like training in school. We familiarize ourselves with these subjects and we become very skilled at them. Even if we weren’t to achieve the awakened heart in this life, if we were to cultivate it and gain a familiarity over the course of this life, in the future the result will definitely arise. It will arise almost automatically at some life in the future.
So that is the order of cultivation. So, these teachings have presented in within the context of a lineage coming, having a source in Atisha. It is his practice that we are following in the cultivation of the awakened heart. He had two main teachers whose method he was following, that of Serlingpa and Chekawa Yeshe Dorje. According to the tradition of Serlingpa, there was no preliminary meditation of equanimity.
It was the exchange of self for others. And it was Chekawa who taught the preliminary method of equanimity. And if you use this as a preliminary, the practice of equanimity, then the rest of the meditation will go well. So, looking at equanimity and it is important in terms of the order of cultivation of the awakened heart. It is the initial method that we are to implement.
And Rinpoche is quoting from an Indian master from a text called The Stages of Meditation. This bodhisattva is saying equanimity presents an analogy as to the importance of equanimity in its order of meditation and cultivating the awakened heart. He analogizes it to the preparation of a field for planting. If the field were not prepared in any way, if it had, on the contrary, if it was full of rocks and stumps, tree stumps, etc, then even if we were to plant, the land would not be able to be cultivated well, that the crop would not grow well. But if we were to clear away all that was hindrance to the growing of the crop, if we were to clear away all the rocks and the logs, etc, to prepare the land well where it was flat and level and even.
Then upon planting the crop, upon planting, the crop would grow well. And then the author goes on to continue with this analogy that having once prepared the field, that in itself would not be sufficient. It’s necessary if the earth was dry, then it needs to be irrigated. We need to supply moisture in some way and we need to fertilize the field. So, secondly, supplying moisture necessary for growth in fertilizer.
And then thirdly, finally, actually planting a seed, ensuring that the seed must be a proper seed, having a potency. So, planting a healthy seed. Having prepared the earth, supplied water, fertilizer and in combination with the sun, then a healthy sprout will grow, won’t it? The author says we can see this with our eye, can’t we? So, in explaining this analogy in the cultivation of the awakened heart, preparing the field and supplying the necessary conditions, and then finally planting the seeds.
The seed will grow and it will grow into a crop. And this crop, the harvest, is the harvest of the awakened heart. And the seed that we are planting is like the foundation and that is compassion. So compassion is the seed and the harvest is the awakened heart. If the land is dry, then it’s necessary that we supply moisture and the moisture and the fertilizer is analogized to love.
And the actual preparation of the field where we remove stones and stumps, clearing the land, leveling it, is analogous to the cultivation of equanimity. So therefore, we can see from this analogy that as a preliminary, it’s necessary that we cultivate equanimity. So, with regard to the means of meditating equanimity, there are two methods. There is the conventional and ultimate method for the cultivation of equanimity. So, first the conventional method of cultivating, the conventional method of meditating and cultivating the equanimity, there are two.
There is the conventional method from the point of view of oneself and conventional method from the point of view of other, and by other we mean all other sentient beings. So, from the point of view of oneself, cultivation from the point of view of oneself, and from the point of view of other. So, and then with regard to the method of cultivation in terms of other, there are three parts. The first is that all sentient beings, whosoever, are the same in wanting happiness and not wanting to suffer. There is no difference.
Isn’t it the case that all sentient beings wish happiness? Isn’t it the case that all sentient beings do not wish to suffer? Aren’t they the same in that regard? Secondly, Though, in fact, all sentient beings want happiness, they’re all the same in not having that happiness. That is, and here we don’t mean any sort of of happiness, but here an uncontaminated happiness, the happiness of liberation where there is no suffering whatsoever.
So, all sentient beings are the same in that though they want happiness, they do not have that happiness that they possess. They do not possess the happiness that they want. So, it is from that point of view that our aversion and attachment are unjustified. If we take by way of analogy, you know, in Australia there aren’t beggars, but in India there are many beggars. And they’re all exactly the same in that they don’t have enough food.
They’re all the same in needing food. So, from that point of view, holding some close and others distant from the point of view that they’re all the same and not having the food is there’s no justification for it. Since they’re all the same and not having the food that they want, there’s no justification in being holding some close and others at a distant. And then thirdly, though all sentient beings do not wish to suffer, still they are troubled by many sufferings. They are all the same in that regard.
In that context, taking the fact that though wanting not to suffer, still they suffer and being the same in that, then we cannot be justified in our being pleased with some and holding them close and displeased with others and therefore holding them at a distance since they are all the same and not having experiencing suffering which they do not want. By way of analogy, everyone in a hospital is suffering in some manner and moreover, none of them want to be experiencing the suffering that they’re going through. They’re all the same in that And therefore, our being pleased with some holding them close and displeased with others and holding them at a distance is unjustified from that point of view. There’s no justification for taking that position since they’re all the same. So, from the point of view of others, there are these three parts in the cultivation of equanimity.
Now, from our own point of view in the cultivation of equanimity, this again has three parts. And the first of these are that our attachment and aversion for others cannot be justified toward others because from the point of view that they are all equal in having benefited us in the past, they are equal in their benefiting us at present, and they are equal in how they will benefit us in the future. Therefore, since they are all the same in terms of the benefit, past, present, and future, our attachment and aversion is not justified. But there might be some stubborn people amongst you who don’t quite buy all this. They might say, Well, okay, everyone has been the same in the past in terms of how they benefited me, how they have benefited me in the past.
Maybe in the future they will all be the same in how they will benefit me. But that doesn’t do away with the fact that at present there are some people who are benefiting me, but on the contrary there are some who are actually harming me. How am I supposed to say they’re all the same in that? So, it is because we see individuals at present not only not benefiting ourselves, but on the contrary, there are some who don’t matter to ourselves, are more or less neutral, but further there are those who actually seem to be harming ourselves. Therefore, we can’t meditate equanimity with regard to those.
It’s not possible since they’re not equal in how they’re benefiting me. If we reflect upon this, we begin with there are those who do benefit us at present, so there’s no debate. There’s no arguing about that. But how about those who don’t seem to be benefiting us? Well, first beginning with those who we have a sense that they are neutral, that they are neither benefiting nor harming ourselves and looking at them.
Now, just the very fact that we are gathering here this evening and listening to the teaching that we’re out of the rain, we’re out of the elements, that we’re in a comfortable physical situation is out of the kindness of these neutral people or these strangers who we don’t even know. The fact that we’re able to enjoy in gathering here together and in the comfort that we presently experience is directly due to these strangers benefiting ourselves. So, with this, we could go on. The clothes that we wear, the food that we eat is all dependent upon the difficulties incurred by others in producing. Though we haven’t seen them produce these directly with their eyes, we can understand indirectly that in fact they did work and this work, they did in fact, are in fact benefiting ourselves, neutral strangers.
Well, okay, might go along with what has just been said, okay, though that they aren’t directly benefiting me, that they are in But I’m still not going to go along with this enemy. There’s no way I can see them equal to others since they in fact not only not benefiting me, but in fact they’re harming me. But in fact, enemy definitely does benefit ourselves, though may not presently be able to appreciate that fact. Rinpoche quoted a verse by Śāntideva which points out that how very much the person who is actually of our greatest benefit in our practice of Dharma. Now why is that?
In the practice of the universal vehicle, the Mahāyāna, we are to cultivate the perfections. For example, the perfections of generosity, ethics, and tolerance. And it is an in dependence upon those who harm us, those who get angry at us and hurt us, that are we able to bring to perfection our practice of tolerance. There’s no other person who we can practice tolerance towards than just these people who harm us, who get angry at us. Moreover, these people are extremely rare and that they are tremendously kind to us for giving us the opportunity to perfect our practice of tolerance and thereby to achieve the greatest benefit of all, that of Buddhahood.
So, it is our enemies who are in fact of greatest kindness, who show the greatest kindness to ourselves. Without these people who harm us, we could not achieve Buddhahood because we could not practice tolerance. Therefore, it is these individuals who are so very kind to ourselves and moreover, even setting aside the ultimate attainment of Buddhahood, that by means of our practice of tolerance and dependence upon these people, that in the future lives we will achieve higher status, that we will achieve a human life, and moreover, that as a human we will have a beautiful body, we will have harmonious companions. And all of this benefit comes about through the great kindness of those who harm us, who are angry at us. There are no other individuals toward whom we can practice tolerance than them and therefore, and that these individuals are extremely rare and what is rare is thought of as to be very precious.
There are many beggars in the world, so there are many opportunities to practice generosity, but there aren’t that many people who harm us and are angry at us and therefore these are to be held as most precious. So, this is the method of cultivation from one’s own point of view, the second part. So, the third part is we are to look at the equality from the point of view of that ourselves and others are under the control of karma and afflictive emotions, and that we are undergoing the process of impermanence. That we ourselves are other powered, that is to say, under the control of karma or actions and their afflictive emotions, and we are moreover momentarily undergoing the process of disintegration. And likewise, others are exactly the same, that they are under the control of karma and afflictive emotions and undergoing the process of momentary disintegration.
Therefore, since we are both the same in this, how can we have a liking for some and a disliking for others? So, this is the means of cultivating equality from one’s own side, which is an equanimity devoid of attachment and aversion. So, then we can look at the equality of self and others from the ultimate point of view. Generally, might regard someone who, we would say, I didn’t do anything. You know, this person is harming me completely from their own side.
That their harming me has had nothing to do whatsoever with me. That it’s coming completely from their own side. It’s not relying upon anything that I’ve done, and that their harm is coming from their own side independent of ourselves. That’s the way things appear to us. But if they existed in that way, the way they appeared, then in fact that harming would not rely upon cause and the condition.
Harming coming from their own side, independently existing, would have to be truly existent and nothing truly exists. So, is often the case, isn’t it? We generally regard that when somebody harms us, well, I didn’t do anything to him or her. They’re harming me completely from their own side. But, is a But, Kadampa Geshe answers and replies, Well, if you didn’t set yourself up as a target, the arrow would not find a place to hit.
But, I’m not setting myself up as a target, but in fact you are. That in a previous life, you have harmed others under the control of afflictive emotion, for example that of anger, and through that action having accumulated that negative karma, that accumulation of negative karma sets you up as a target, and now the arrow of the result is returning to you. We do not just have only this life. In fact, we have had beginningless previous lives. You know, if we had only this life, then it would make sense to say, I haven’t done anything to deserve this person doing that to me.
But in fact, we have had many, many previous lives, and over the course of these previous lives, through anger, through attachment, the various afflictive emotions, have involved ourselves in negative actions. Have killed, we have beaten, we have caused suffering in various ways to others. And that now as a result, this bill of negativity is returning to ourselves. That if we hadn’t created the cause for our present suffering, then we would experience the result of a cause which we hadn’t created, which is not the case. So, considered properly,
If we were to appropriately become angry, if our anger was to be justified, it would not be directed toward the other person who is harming us. On the contrary, that person is not in control. They are under the control of their afflictive emotions. Therefore, if we were to become angry and justify anger, our anger would be justified if it were directed toward that person’s afflictive emotions, not the person themselves. By way of analogy, if someone were to hit us with a stick, we don’t get angry at the stick, do we?
You know, the stick is not in control of itself. The stick is controlled by the person, therefore we get angry at the person. So, first of these, this first part is the fact that there is nothing which is not reliant upon something other than itself, that everything is under the control of other, that nothing is truly existent. So the second part is that nothing is truly existent, that everything is undergoing change. If things were truly existent, then they would be as it were fixed, frozen.
Whatever they were in the first instance, that is what they would always necessarily have to be. But in the case of, for example, an enemy, an enemy undergoes change. Sometimes an enemy becomes someone dear to us and when someone dear to us becomes an enemy. So, this shows that they’re not truly existent, that because they are undergoing change, that which is truly existent would necessarily not undergo change. So, then thirdly, that one who is held dear and an enemy do not truly exist.
That even a slight change in condition can alter our perception of them. For example, someone who benefits us, we derive a liking for them from that and we hold them dear. Someone who harms us, we derive a dislike for them and we hold them an enemy. But even if they were to, that even a slight, a minor change in the way they treat us would cause us to perceive them in a different fashion. The person that we like, if they were to, through a small change of a condition in that they harmed us in some way, we no longer hold them as dear.
And then the person who is harming ourselves, a small change in condition where they benefited us, we develop a liking for them, we no longer hold them as an enemy, but in fact hold them as dear. So a slight change in condition demonstrates, bringing about this transformation in our perception, that those we hold dear and enemy are not truly existent. So, that which is dependent upon conditions does not truly exist. Which I quote from Root Wisdom, a text called Root Wisdom, which says that because of dependent on conditions, because things depend upon conditions, they are dependent arisings. Being dependent arisings, they are empty of true existence.
So, it is by means of these three, that is to say, from the equality of self and others from one’s own side, from one’s own point of view, from the point of view of others conventionally, and then from the ultimate point of view, each having three parts making a total of nine. If we meditate on this well, we will be able to look upon all sentient beings with a lack of attachment and aversion. That we will appreciate that all sentient beings are exactly the same in wanting happiness and not wanting to suffer and developing an even mindedness toward them which is free of holding some close and others at a distance. And this sets the context in which we can go on to develop love. If we do not have this sense of equality, then there’s no way that we can develop love.
So, in dependence upon the development of equanimity, we can cultivate, we can develop love. And love in terms of not seeing a, first not seeing a, on the basis of not seeing a difference between the three categories of individuals, that is to say those held dear, strangers and enemies, as a basis that they all equally want to be happy, that they all equally do not want to suffer. And then in terms of love, developing the attitudes of mind which would be wonderful if, directing this attitude toward all three, if they had happiness and the causes of happiness. May they have happiness and the causes of happiness that I myself will lead them to a state where they have happiness and the causes of happiness. So, then we can go on to cultivate great compassion.
With great compassion, just as we did in cultivating the understandings of the being of small capacity, that is to say, first recognizing the sufferings of cyclic existence in terms of ourselves, and then going on to develop the understanding of being a middling capacity who develops a longing to be liberated from cyclic existence, a longing to be free of suffering, and taking that understanding and extending it to, again, to all others equally and that they are just like ourselves and developing in wanting to not suffer and developing these attitudes of great compassion extended toward all living beings. So, it’s necessary in the cultivation of great compassion that we first understand come the nature of our own suffering and develop a longing to be free from our own suffering. Then we can extend that understanding and develop a longing that others be free of their suffering without having first come to understand suffering in terms of ourselves and developing a longing to that we ourselves be free of suffering, we cannot develop great compassion which longs that others be free of suffering. So, it is initially that we have to develop an attitude which seeks to bring about our own welfare, a longing to free ourselves from suffering.
This longing to free ourselves from suffering is what we usually term renunciation or the will to awaken. Without having previously developed this, there’s no way that we can go on to cultivate compassion toward others. We must develop the understanding of the being of middling capacity in terms of developing this will to awaken or renunciation to free ourselves, a longing to be free from our own suffering if we are to develop the understanding of the being of great capacity which is compassion, wishing that, a longing that others be free of suffering. Yeah. I’m thinking of that. So, we’ll stop there.
We’ll take a few minutes for questions. Yes. What was the last part of your question? The six parts? So firstly, is equanimity, an understanding of the equality that all sentient beings want happiness and do not want to suffer and thereby bringing about an even mindedness which does not hold some beings close and others at a distance.
Then, the faults of self centeredness. The benefits or the excellent quality of other centeredness. Then within the context of love and compassion, the practice of taking and giving. Then, intense resolve. And then finally, the awakened heart.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.