1 h 40 min · 4,656 words · 26 October 2011 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 100-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche addresses how to study Dharma effectively and what blocks genuine learning. He clarifies the correct motivation: developing bodhicitta, not merely gathering information or pursuing individual liberation. He then covers practical ethics—examining the ten non-virtues through daily reflection, understanding the four forces of purification, and daily confession. Using three vivid metaphors—the upturned, filthy, and pierced vessels—he exposes common obstacles to learning: absent mind, impure motivation, and poor retention. He illustrates these with stories of great practitioners like Geshe Ben Gungyal, a reformed thief who trained his mind through vigilance. A section on the Lamrim outline explains how to structure understanding, and practical Q&A addresses ethics in everyday situations. Best suited to serious practitioners already familiar with Buddhist fundamentals.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2011-10-26 – KR.mp3
UUID: dd691f65-3546-463e-b75c-d6f42eed40ed
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Meditation
Date: 2011-10-26
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,653
So regarding the motivation which has to be generated to listen to these teachings, Generally speaking, these are Mahāyāna teachings and there are three categories of motivations. Yeah. So within these motivations, the first is to listen to teachings merely for the sake of gathering a large amount of information. The second motivation is to attend teachings with the wish to in turn impart teachings to others. These two motivations must be set aside.
And finally, the motivation of attaining for one’s own sake the state of an Arhat and listening with that motivation to these teachings does not open the door to these Mahāyāna teachings. Because these three motivations are when all is said and done motivations for one’s own sake. Now the treatise which we are studying is a Mahāyāna treatise. What is the motivation therefore with which we should listen to this presentation of the meditations of the practice of the beings of the three scopes? Ideally, it is the wish to generate a spontaneous bodhicitta within our mind stream.
But at the very least, it is the motivation to generate an artificial or a contrived, a constructed bodhicitta within our mind stream. So we will reflect on this for two minutes or so. It is really remarkable how well the texts are disposed now. It’s the Tripitaka of the Buddha. These are the collected works of Tsongkhapa and his two disciples, Gyaltsabji and Khedrubji.
It is very difficult for us to get texts like this. The texts are meaningful when we put in practice their teachings. Otherwise just placing them there, there’s not a lot of meaning. Don’t think that folding your arms and looking at the text and saying please bless me is going to be of great help. There’s no benefit in that.
And some however who obtain the Samādhi on supreme Dharma, which is obtained at the highest level of the path of accumulation are able to see the bodies and the manifestations of the teachings of Mañjuśrī Maitreya and so forth. On the great path of accumulation. As the Kadam masters of old said, the crux when one enters into practice is knowing how to protect the vows. So at the beginning, when one starts practicing, what is essential is to understand the vows. Geshe-la would explain how to practice and we will listen.
However, it is up to ourselves whether we practice ourselves on a daily basis or not. For all of us it is essential before engaging in this to have some explanations on what renunciation bodhicitta and the pure view are. It’s the same thing as horse racing. When, hundreds or thousands of horses are raced, initially the jockeys train them on the racing course. Then after the horses are well trained, there is no difficulty or hardship either for the horse or the jockey in racing.
So in this room, there may be some who have a very limited understanding of renunciation, bodhicitta and the pure view as well as the meditations of the beings of this small middling and great scope and some who have a better understanding. However, realistically, the odds of any one of us generating renunciation bodhicitta or the pure view in this life are very small. However, even though our goal may be far removed the practice of Anuttara Yoga tantra for instance and we may not be able at present to generate renunciation bodhicitta or the pure view, nonetheless practicing from the bottom up the practice of the beings of the three capacities we can move upwards quietly. And in this room among us, perhaps nobody here does not have the vows to abstain from the 10 non virtuous Geshe-la suspects that if one examines carefully the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues, this could probably qualify as authentic practice. As Atisha said, I have never broken even the slightest of the Prātimokṣa vows, the vows of individual liberation of a fully ordained Buddhist monk.
From time to time, I broke the bodhisattva vows committing root downfalls or faults which I purified. However, the tantric vows I broke as rain falls on the earth. All of us are disciples of the glorious Atisha who is in the direct lineage from Buddha Śākyamūni. So we should therefore take example on Atisha as our spiritual director. So how should we practice?
In the evening before going to sleep, we should examine our ethics during the day and starting with the virtuous deeds, the 10 non virtuous deeds examine whether we have engaged or not in the three non virtuous deeds of body. So the three non virtues of the body, most of us know, they are killing, stealing and sexual misconduct. So if we take in turn the four non virtuous deeds of speech, which are lying, divisive speech, harsh words, and idle talk, we have to examine whether in a day we have engaged in deeds of speech which are related with lying. Now in the context of Geshe-la’s experience at for instance, the monks would often go to the neighboring village, Kushal Naga, to purchase butter, food, fabric for the monastic vestments and so forth. And in so doing, they would have to make a careful tally of what they had purchased.
Now very often the tradesman would say that what cost 10 rupees actually was worth 20 rupees. This could be considered from the standpoint of Vinaya as a case of lying. Or some traders would say don’t buy your fabric from the trader next door. His goods are spurious and they are expensive. Buy from us, our goods are authentic and not expensive.
This is a case of lying. This amounts to deceiving another person. Instead of this, one must be very clear about one’s prices. This is what something costs and this is how much I charge you with nothing more. It is important for us to be careful about this because if one engages in spurious business deals and one deceives others, then even for oneself very shortly, there will be harmful consequences.
Divisive speech is to turn people who are in harmony within each other into being in a state of disharmony through speech. Harsh words are to utter unpleasant words which hurt another’s feelings. Idle talk or gossip is meaningless talk, talk which has no results, no purpose, mere gossip or chatter. Therefore in the evening before going to sleep we should examine whether we have committed by the body and of the three non virtues of the body or by the speech any of the four non virtues of speech. If we have done so, we should restrain our behavior.
If we have not, we should rejoice. And reflecting on the fact that our behavior in engaging in these three non virtuous deeds of body and form of speech is at odds with the advice imparted from the Buddha’s downwards through the bodhisattvas and their scions, we should then confess and purify these deeds. And we should do this through applying the four forces. The force of the base, the force of repentance, the force of the antidote, and the force of restraint. Regarding the first of these forces, the force of the base, whatever fault we have accumulated, we have accrued with respect to either the Buddha or sentient beings.
And the force of repentance is if we take the case of lying, if we have lied to another person, to have a rejection of this deed which is comparable to that of someone who has ingested poison and realizes it. And the force of restraint is that force which thinks to do this means that I will be reborn in the lower realms. This is something which I do not want at any cost. Therefore, I will abstain from it. Finally, force of the antidote is for instance reciting 21 mantras of Vajrasattva or whatever appropriate antidote one wishes to apply.
As a result of this, the thought will no longer amplify. And this is what is meant by practice. Practice, Geshe-la feels, can be none other than the abandonment of the non-virtues and the realization of the virtues. Geshe-la thinks that probably in this temple, there are none of you who do not know what the 10 non virtuous deeds are, therefore practicing abstaining from them should be relatively easy. To practice the way Atisha did, confessing immediately whatever faults one has performed and purifying them day and night throughout a twenty four hour cycle is very difficult for us.
However, great amounts of merit can be accrued through at the end of the day analyzing our day, confessing our thoughts and purifying them. Do you practice in this way? If we think about it, not many of us do. This very good will improve progressively. However, for us to claim at the beginning that we can attain bodhicitta renunciation or the pure view is a fantasy.
We can only understand the words. And therefore training in this way initially in the practice of the being of small scope, eventually we can generate renunciation and finally bodhicitta within our mind stream. Of yore in Tibet, there was a Kadampa Geshe called Geshe Ben Gungyal who before becoming a monk was a criminal, a robber and a thief. And then he met a good teacher and became a monk. His foremost practice was to sit and to observe his mind and his thoughts.
And he had a collection of white and black stones. Whenever a virtuous thought arose, he took a white stone and put it to the left. And when whenever an evil thought arose, he took a black stone and put it to the right. Initially, the pile of black stones was huge. And systematically applying the antidotes to whatever afflictions arose in his mind, eventually one day the pile of white stones was larger than the pile of black stones.
One day, one of Geshe Ben Gungyal’s sponsors was coming and Geshe Ben Gungyal had to offer a long life puja. And at that point in the kitchen, Geshe Ben Gungyal had arranged or arranged everything which was required. And because of his karmic imprints as a thief, when he saw the pot of melted butter in the kitchen, he couldn’t restrain his hand from going in the pot. And then with the other hand, Geshe Ben Gungyal grabbed his right hand and shouted, a thief is in the butter pot. A thief is in the butter pot.
And when the host said, where is the thief? He said, here it is. Here it is. So we may feel a little bit uncomfortable with the the richness of these stories, but these were true practitioners. And you may have heard of the great Tibetan yogi Jetsün Milarepa.
One can say that the view of Jetsün Milarepa is the opposite of the view of samsaric beings and the view of samsaric beings is the opposite of that of Jetsün Milarepa. Another day, Geshe Ben Gungyal arranged a beautiful arrangement of offerings on his altar in bowls, putting water in the offering bowls and flowers. And his motivation was to impress his sponsor who was coming to visit his hermitage to show the beautiful offerings he made as a monk. Then when he realized this was his motivation, he grabbed handfuls of ashes and filled each of the seven bowls with ashes from the earth. And a great Yogi in Tibet at the period said, There has not been in the universe this day an offering comparable to Geshe Ben Gungyal’s ash.
So this was not done to impress others. This was an authentic deed. So we ourselves have never seen someone behave in this way. So within the four outlines of the present text of Lamrim we are covering, we have finished the first outline, the greatness of the authors. We’re on page six seventy four of your English translation.
The greatness of the authors given to show the teaching has an immaculate source. We have also finished the second outline, the greatness of the Dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instruction with the four greatnesses and the three features. And we are now approaching the third outline on page six seventy four, the how to teach and listen to the Dharma that has these two greatnesses. And the third outline is subdivided itself into three. The first is a way to listen to the Dharma, the second is the way to teach the Dharma, and the final one is what the disciple and teacher should do together at the end.
The first outline on page six seventy four, this is outline three eleven, is contemplating the first subdivision of the first outline is contemplating the benefits of studying the Dharma. The second subdivision is how to show respect for the Dharma and its teacher. The third is the actual way to listen to that Dharma. Now the broad third outline on page six seventy four, how to teach and listen to the Dharma that has these two greatnesses of the authors and of the Dharma is a Dharma which has the two greatnesses of him who utters it. In other words, the teacher and the Dharma which is uttered, which is the practice of the being of the three scopes.
In our case, our teachers are probably His Holiness the Dalai Lama and Khensur Rinpoche, with whom we have a very close connection and whom we view as akin to the Buddha Śākyamūni. Now the elder who also instructs us sometimes must use various means to instruct us. At times also, this elder may either lack the time to instruct us or have other responsibilities. In other words, there are interferences. There is an account of the great Kadampa Geshe, Geshe Potowa, a Kadampa Geshe in the Kadampa’s following scriptures who at one period was struggling with the meaning of a large number of different texts and when a lay person came and asked him for instructions, blew up and said, get out.
Therefore, one must be skillful in asking for one’s teacher when to teach us. In the case of our teacher Khensur Rinpoche, when Khensur Rinpoche was in India, he taught whenever he was asked to teach. Likewise, Rinpoche never set a major appointment for people to meet him. When he had time, he would receive them. The reason for which from our side we should always make an appointment with our teachers and be respectful of their time is because great beings such like these, such as Rinpoche, rise at 03:30 in the morning and, enter in meditation, training their mind in the totality of the path of the being of small, middling and great scope.
When we disturb them with our trivial and unimportant requests, it can disturb their actual meditation. Then as a result of this, we accumulate great waves of non virtue. Likewise for us, and this applies both to us and to Geshe-la himself, when we receive teachings, the last thing we should be focused upon is the appearance of the teacher. He is handsome or he is not handsome. He is bald.
He is ugly. Or his elocution. His language is coarse. He has an accent. Instead, it is on the meaning which we should focus.
So instead of reflecting on the manner in which the teachings are given, we should focus on their relevance to our own mind. And from the teacher’s side, the teacher must only be motivated by the wish to help the students by whatever means are possible. This is how it is explained in Asaṇga’s Bodhisattva Bhumi, the stages of the path of the Bodhisattvas. And the third outline is itself subdivided into three. The first of these is the actual way to listen to the Dharma, which includes abandoning the various types of thoughts.
So these interfering conditions to our listening to the Dharma are critical to our understanding how to practice the Lamrim and all of us unfortunately tend to have them. And therefore, we must understand on the one hand how to abandon what is to be abandoned, the thoughts, and on the other hand, how to practice those favorable conditions. And here what one is focusing focusing upon within the three subdivisions of contemplating the benefits of studying the Dharma, how to show respect for the Dharma and its teacher and the actual way to listen to the Dharma is the actual way to listen to the Dharma. So, taking the first example of the three, the example of a vessel and taking the example of Geshe-la’s bell to illustrate this, if one were to try to pour liquid in the bell with the bell in this position, probably not even a drop would enter the bell. You can see that whether you were to pour water, milk, or nectar not a single drop would enter.
So in our present situation in which Geshe-la is explaining the teachings and we are listening to the teachings, If even though we are physically present in the room, our bodies are there, our minds are someplace else, then we are in exactly the same situation as an overturned vessel or Geshe-la’s bell. So how should we listen? We should listen in the same way as a deer listens to the flute of a hunter. This is an old Asian tradition that hunters would play the flute and the deer would be captivated by the music of the flute and the hunter would approach the deer with a gun or a bow and shoot it while it was hypnotized by the music. So how should we listen?
Wherever we are, we should listen with 100% of our minds and not listen with 50% of our minds of the teaching of the teaching and 50% elsewhere. Therefore, we should listen to the teaching without being like an upturned vase or Geshe-la’s upturned bell. Now the second example of how not to listen is the following. Imagine we take Geshe-la’s bell and we actually turn it the right way and pour whatever, it might be milk, it might be nectar inside, but imagine that the inside of the bell is filthy, it is contaminated with filth or with poison. Then whatever we pour inside gets contaminated as well.
If we listen carefully with the motivation to increase our own understanding for our own sake, if we listen to gather information, if we listen to become arhat, if we listen to compete or criticize others, then in every single case, we will form the category of a filthy vessel for the teachings. And this is the type of listening which should be abandoned. Now, the third metaphor for wrong listening is if we take our cup and it is not upside down, number one. In addition, it is turned upside up and is clean, number two. But even though it is turned the right side and is clean, there is a hole in the bottom.
Then whatever we pour inside, whether it is milk, nectar, or water, cannot stay in the cup, it will flow through the bottom’s hole. And therefore, if we listen well, in other words, we do not fall in the first fault, and we have a good motivation, in other words, we do not fall in the second fault, but our recollection, our memory is poor and whatever the teacher says just goes in one ear and out the other, then we will have succumbed to the third fault of the pierced vessel. So during this one and a half or actually one hour teaching, it may be difficult for us to remember everything which has been said. How should we then proceed? The most important thing is to use the outline, is on page 673 onwards of your English text as the framework within which we fit the teachings.
And therefore, you take the outline of your text on page six seventy three, if we reflect on the meaning of the outlines 2.1, 2.2, two point three and two point four on pages six seventy three, four greatnesses of the teachings. Then we know from the outline 2.1 is the greatness of allowing one to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction. When we read this, we think of everything which was said on this topic. We know that the second outline is the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves as instructions. Then we reflect on everything which was said on this topic.
And the third outline is the greatness of allowing one to easily discover the true thinking of the victorious one. Then we reflect the true thinking of the victorious one is the three principal paths, renunciation, bodhicitta and the pure view. And we reflect on the meaning thereof. Finally, outline 2.4 is the greatness of allowing one to save oneself from the worst misdeed. As Geshe-la explained, the worst misdeed is the abandonment of Dharma.
So we reflect on the meaning of that. And specifically, Pabongka Rinpoche’s advice is to reflect and to discuss what was covered during the Dharma teaching during that hour or two. Therefore, it would be good if we all put in our minds this advice of this instruction of which is written in his experiential guide. Even though it is difficult for us to listen to teachings for one hour, one hour and a half, when we go out from the teachings for tea, it is important that we not talk about trivia and unimportant things, but instead that we try our best to talk about what was covered in the teachings. And for instance, it would be good, don’t take this literally, if you rang up your neighbor at home and ask him what it mean?
Non contradictory nature of the teachings was. So then if I don’t have time, we can talk about it at the center. Yeah. However, remember what Geshe Potowa was saying? However, in reality, if we we talk about what we’ve studied and we discuss about it, then those studies have great impact on our minds.
This advice is not only for Dharma. It applies to all studies. If we undertake university studies or even high school studies, this advice is very valid. So the means for integrating these teachings are as Geshe-la explained, to reflect on their meaning then keeping with instructions to fit the teachings within the outline of the teachings, which is like a framework. And then not to talk about topics unrelated to the teachings when one leaves the temple.
When Geshe-la himself first arrived at the monastery, his first teacher was Khensur Rinpoche. And he was studying the middling collected topics, middling Dura, which is a presentation of Buddhist logic. It was very difficult for them because they had never studied this before and they would doze off. And Rinpoche had a long switch, so he would poke at the class and tap on the shoulder of the students who dozed. However, Geshe-la from his side when he attended Debate, these teachings, was stubborn and persevering and put effort.
We have similar difficulties when we attend teachings, especially for us, we don’t understand what is taught, don’t understand the words, there’s a big risk of dozing off. We have to be careful about this. Geshe-la’s goal is to teach in simple language which is easily accessible to us. So you can only understand, the bell, he hopes. And the Buddha himself says in a sūtra, listen, listen forcefully and retain or grasp with your mind.
What is meant here by listen forcefully? It means to listen intensely, forcefully with 100 of one’s mind to what the teacher is explaining. Listen well or listen excellently refers to listening with the motivation of bodhicitta. Hold or retain with the mind means to retain with the force of memory whatever was explained. Therefore, we must avoid the three faults of the vessel.
The first is the vessels being upturned, the second is the vessel being filthy, and the third is the vessel being pierced. So reflect well on the meaning of these three examples. It is easy to understand. And therefore, we will not go any further in the outline. And as there are fourteen minutes left, if you have questions, Geshe-la will be happy to answer them.
It’s perhaps best to talk with the teacher first to know if he does have time. Yeah. Yes. Are there other questions? Yeah.
Yes. Cover yourself up. Can actually blow in your palm if the mosquito is biting you and reflect on the fact that as a human being you have much greater virtue merit than a mosquito. What is a little bit of blood after all? It’s very good, that’s the way to do it.
You create a good motivation and you think after all what is a little bit of my blood and it feeds this poor mosquito so I will give the blood to him. Then you accumulate through that roots of virtue. That’s very good. Yes? So same thing.
I mean, we try to capture the venomous spider and we put him in an area where he will not be harmed, then we have no certainty that he will harm others or not. There is no guarantee. So the most important thing here is the motivation. The first thing is to check on motivation. Then talk in and of itself does not become idle talk.
It has to be meaningless talk, talk which has no real goal. Then it becomes idle talk or chatter. It is meaningless talk, meaningless chatter. Otherwise, we would be in the very strange situation where whenever we spoke, we would commit non virtues of speech. Yes.
So the reason for this is that within the three categories of vows, vows of Prātimokṣa, Bodhisattva vows and Tantric vows, Prātimokṣa vows are actually quite easy to hold. They are external vows of behavior. It’s quite easy to know when they are broken or not. Bodhisattva vows are more interior. They are harder to keep and they are vaster in their import.
Tantric vows are largely interior. They are very difficult to keep and their scope is very vast. And in addition, there’s a very large number of such vows. We have for instance the 18 root Bodhisattva vows, the 46 branch Bodhisattva vows, the 14 root tantric vows, the eight gross misdemeanors, each one of which is extremely heavy. To give you one example, if one does not meditate accurately on emptiness three times in the morning and three times at night, a root vow has been broken.
This is the situation. Yes. So if we take the case of a Naga or a spirit living in a tree, when we cut the tree down, we do not harm the naga or the spirits directly because they are not material like us. However, we do destroy their dwelling. So one must perform rituals in this case.
For instance, if one builds a house on a plot of land, one must perform a Naga Puja to request the Nagas who live there to leave the land. So Geshe-la would like to qualify that statement. It is not sufficient to recite 21 mantras to prevent a fault from increasing. It can only be prevented from increasing if 21 mantras of Vajrasattva are recited in conjunction with the application of the four forces without which it does not work. The recitation of mantras alone is not sufficient to purify non virtues.
It is only possible to purify the root of the non virtue through meditation on emptiness. Great waves of merit are accumulated through meditating again and again on emptiness.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
- Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- Kadam
- The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Atisha, Dromtönpa and their followers, the "Kadampa geshes"; the forerunner of the Gelug School. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.